Cashion v. Lee et al

Filing 48

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 11/8/17. (kld)

cv RK' OFFI U.S.DI T COURT
s
CE
S,
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

N2V 23 2
I THE UN I
N
TED STATE S D I RI CO U RT
ST CT
FO R TH E W E STE RN D I RI O F W RGI I
ST CT
N A
H A RRI N BU RG D I SION
SO
W

JU
BY

.

:

t
.

M M ON CASH ION ,
Pl ntf,
ai if

Cas N o.5: CVe
17- 00004

J
ACK LEE,e a .
t 1,

By: M i ha lF. ba l
c e Ur nsd
ChifUnie St t Diti tJ
e
t d a es src udge

D ee
f ndant .
s
M EM O R AN D U M O PI ION
N

Tli matrc me beor t ec r o dee da Mi l lie Re i na l i
ls te o s f e h ou t n f n nt dd e tv t go l al
Aut rt' I< GJ 'M o n t Dir isf rFalr B S aeaCli ECF No. , c
ho iys T
MI A7 éo o sn s o i e t t nm,
I
u
30 whih
s e sc s nsa ofCou IIofpli ifAl o Ca honsrca hin' Fis Ame e
e k l n is l
i
nt I
antf vin s i ' ç s o ) tt nd d
Co antf rMon tr Da g sa Eq ia eReif(h T
mpli o
e ay ma e nd u tbl le t e f
FAC), No 26 MRRJ
ECF . .
A
a pz st Cl i 1 1 t onl c nm pld a i ti,i tm eba r or i t at r éve
r e hat nm 1 , he y l i e gans t s i
r ed , n he le na ,

MRR A i e ie t s ve eg i
J s ntt d o o r in mmuni . MRRJ Ssa ueofl ttonsdee e
l
t As
y
A' tt t i ai
mi
f ns
r q ie a j l a n ofCo tI oft eFAC,n wh c Ca l o a kst c r t de lr
e uz s ducc do
i
un V h
i ih sl n s he ou t o ca e
i
t tVign aCo j8012 . viltst Eq l otci Clus oft Fo re n h
ha r ii de . - 432 o ae he ua Pr e t
on a e he u te t
Am e
ndm e oft U . Cons i ton,t c ztw11as de i Count1 . t r s
nt he S.
tm i he otr 1 lo c de
V For he ea ons

d srb dbeo t ec ut GRANTSMRRJ Smo t dil s, S I ES Co t 11
e ci e l w, h o t
A' éon o snis DI M SS
un s 1
a d I oft eF W I PM J I a D EN I ASM OOT M RRJ SM oto t
n V h AC TH
UD CE, nd
ES
A' in o
SubnltSuppl m e a Aut iy ECF N o.47.
i
e nt l hort ,

,

ct q
alx

RK

1.

Backgr
ound
)

Cahi ' i ta Comp an f rM o tr Da g sth T mpli ' ECF No. ,
s ons ni l
i
li t o nea y ma e t e f
co ant),
1
s g tda g sa ans d fnd nt MRRJ J c Le (T e',n li i ii a c pa iya
ou h ma e g i t e e a s
A, a k e f ' i zs ndvdu l a ct s
Le )

s pei e nto MRR A, ndDr MossQuho srolio s),nhiidiiua
u rntnde f J a
. ie i ne f l ne' i s n vd l
i
c pa iya ad c o a MRRJ ICa lon alg dt tLe unlwf l i tt t dapoiyof
a ct s o t z t
A. sa l e ha e a ul nsiu e
i e
y
l
c
de ynga ps c otcpr s rpto me ia n t i mae . ! 1 Quho salg dl
n i né y h i e ci in dc éo o n t s FAC 3. i ne l e y
e
kne t tCas on ha a s ve em e a i ne sand be n pr c i d c r an a i yc i
w ha
hi
d e r
ntl l s
l
e es rbe e t i ntps hotc

m e iain. c us ofLe ' poiy ho ve, s on cam st tQthone ne r
dc to Be a e
es l , we r Cahi li ha z s ve
c
i
pt s rbed t m e c ton ore ur t tCaslon woul be e l e by a he quaii d
e ci
hat dia i
ns ed ha
li
d
vauat d
not r lfe

me ia p of si na. ! 3 , .
dc l r e so lFAC ! 3 38
No a l, s i wa i a c rt da MRRJ fo a oxmaeyOc o r1 , 01
tby Ca hon s nc z eae t
A r m ppr i tl t be 7 2 5
t ou h De e r1 , 1 . !28 Ca h o fldli Compli onl nuay3 , 01
hr g c mbe 1 20 5 FAC . s i n l ts
e
ant a r 1 2 7.
M RR A ie aM ot t Dir is ECF No. 9 c t ndn t tCa lon' cqmsa ans
J id
l
i o sns ,
on
1 , on e ig ha sl s li g i t
i

MRRJ we etmeba z dbyVignaCod j80 - 4 2 whc pr s rbe ao -e tsa e
A r i re
ti i e .1 2 3., ih e ci s ne y a tmt
ofl tto f rcnmsf eai t t ec i o ofg p io rs c nfne n . Va Cod
i ai ns o li r lt o h ondt ns a rs ne 7j o i me t' . e
mi
r ng
i
'
j801 2 32Be a eCa hin fld szto a uay31 20 7 mo et n on y a atr
. - 4 . c us s o l t nl n r , 1 , r ha e e r fe
e i

Ca h o wa ls alg dyde id a tps c i me iai n, J a g e t tl scnms
s i n s a t l e l n e n i y hotc dc to MRR A r u d ha ' li
e
l
i
a i ti we euntm ey.
gans t r
i l
Ra hert n a rt ta dif r sa tt oflmiai a i t li cai s Ca hi
t ha ve ha
f e ent t tze i t tons pples o ns l m , s on

c t n t tVigni Co j 80124 . ofe st Eq l o e éo Clus o t e
on e ds ha t i a de . - 32 fnd he ua Pr t c n a e f h
Fouree h A m e
t nt
ndm e .Ca hi fl d t FAC,whih a
nt s on le he
c dded Count1 a cnm s ki
V, li ee ng
1M fc sheenaetke fom t FAC.On amoton t ds s,hec ttfe a tuealalga . eCoo e v.
a t ri r a n r he
i o imis t our a s s r l le dons Se
r

Pae 3 8U.. 4 , 4 (9 4 (e c z m)
t, 7 S 5 6 5 6 1 6 ) p r ui ,
a

d caaor jd me t a Vigni Cod j801 2 32i u o ttz a a a op it
e lr t y u g nt h t t i a e . - 4 . s nc nsit l nd ppr rae
éon
i j c ver l f
nun d ei .
e
Ca li as fld anotc unde Fede a Rul ofCi lPr edur 5. whih notfed
snon lo le
ie
r
zl e
vi oc
e 1, c
ii
t Com m onweat ofVig ni ofhi c lnge t t consiutona iy ofVigi i Code
he
1h
zi a
s hale
o he
tt i lt
r la
n

j80 - 4 ..
.1 2 32 MRRJ r ne dismo t cin is a Vigri i tr e d t d fnd t
A e we t don o ls as , nd t il n e v ne o e e he
a
c si inaiyo Vig naCod j80 - 4 ..
on tmto l f r i i
t
e .1 2 32
I
I.

St
andar ofR e ew
d
vi

MRRJ mo st dsns Co IIu e Fe ea RueofCiiPr e u e1 $()
A ve o inis unt 1 nd r d rl l
vl oc d r 29 6
f fizet saeacnm.Rul 1 $()pemisadsnsa whe apli iffi To saea
or alr o tt 1i 2 e 2( 6 t t irisl n antf al f tt
t
st
cnm u nwhc rl fc nbega td. Fe . Ci P.1 $()Tos ri aRue1 $()
li po ih ei a
e
rne ' d R. v. 29 6. u vve l 29 6
'
mot t dimis ac mpli mus c nti s fce f a t t sa eacam t r l fi a i
i o s s, o ant t o an uf int f cs o tt li o ei h t s
on
f
e

p a il onisf c . Bel lCo . Two
lusb e t a e' lAt. r v. mbl 5 0U.. 4 5 0 (0 7 . c mpli '
;
5 S 5 4, 7 2 0 ) The o ants
fg a t a alg do mus bee u h t tiearg tt r l fa vet es e ua velve. 1 .
ff c- l l a ns t no g o as i h o ei bo h p c lé e l' d
l u e
e
'
at555.

A c u tmus c nsr fc l le ainsi t n mo i pat fvora dwil
o r t o tue a ma alg to n he on vng zfs a n l
te tt e a tue bu i r ts bo ndwih r s c t ( c lits lg lc cuso .
ra h m s r , ts ç o u
no
t epe t o a ompan 'j e a on l i ns'
:
D it 28 Unied M i W oz r ofAm . l v. el or Coa Co . 609 F. 1083,1085
s.
t
ne
ke s
nc. W l e
m
l
,
2d

(t Ci.1 79. nd e ac u t l a c ptn ihe fe a c cu insd a fo t fcs'
4. t 9 ) I e d, o t wi c e et r f j l on lso z wn r m he a t'
h
l
l
norfunwa r nt d i e e es unr as bl c l i ,ora gu e s7 E.Shor M kt .l .
f
r a e nf r nc , e ona e oncusons
r m nt .'
e
s, nc

v. . Aso s Lt P'hi 2 3F.d 1 ,1 0 (t Ci. 0 0 . rhe ,fl e d r r ctl
JD. s c . d. s p, 1 3 75 8 4. r 2 0 ) Fu t r Tghz a ba e e ias
h
t
oft e e e sofaca e ofa i s
he l m nt
us
cton, uppoz e by m e e c l or sa e ent,do not
td
r onc us y t t m s
2 J as mo e t ds s Co n 1Ifrakof u jc matrjr dc n, o tn igta ii potce fo
MRR A lo v s o imis u t 1 o lc sbe t t ui ido c ne dn h tts r e td rm
e s
stto Col t1 Iby q lEe i lniy. ca e t co tf dst tCa hi scqm sa etm e ba r d, tnee notr a h
ti n m I
ua i d mm l t Be us he ur m ha s on' l i r i
re i d
ec
a de ii n on qua i ed i m u zt
c so
ll m zip
i

s fc . As r tv I ba,5 6U..6 2 6 8 (0 9 . y atraclm i sae a q tl
ufie' hcof . q l 5 S 6 , 7 2 0 ) Onl fe li s ttd de uaey
'
m a i t n fbe s
y t he f uppored by s
t
howi a s off ct conssentwih t alga i i t
ng ny et a s
it
t he le tons n he
com pl i .'Tw om bl,550 U . a 563.
ant'
S. t
A sam t oflm ia i def e T us be r s by t de e ntt ough a
t e i t tons ens f t aied
m
he f nda hr
n
afim a i def ns ,a t bur n ofe t bls ng t a fr a i . e er t on t
fr tve e e nd he de
s a ihi he fim tve def ns es s
he

dee nt'
fnda . Good nv. a ar I c, 4F.d 4 8 4 4 ( t Ci. 0 7 ( ena ctto
'
ma Pr x i, n .49 3 5 , 6 4h r 2 0 ) i t l iains
nt
onitd . he f a t s fce tt r l on a af ai dee ea ealg di t
r te ) W n f cs ufiin o ue n fgm t
f
ve f ns r le e n he

c mpli ,hed fns ma bera h db amoéo t dsls u rRul 1 9 6.o antt ee e y ec e y
n o inis nde e 2 $()J.
l
L
The efcs ho ve, tf la l a a gon t fc oft c mpli . m c nd,
s a t, we r mus f e ry ppe r
c
he a e he o ant ' hmo
'

Fr deik but & Pot ma R. Co. Fo s, F.d2 , 5 (t Ci. 9 3 .
e rc s
o c R. v. rt 4 3 44 2 0 4. t 1 9 )
h
1 1 Vi#ni Codej 8.12 3.
1. r a
0 -4 2

MRRJ c tndsa dCahi doe n c nts,ha Vigni Cod j80 -4 .
A one , n s on s ot o ett t ri a e .12 32
g vçnst a lc bl lriai nspe i f rCo 1 1 Vigni Co j80 - 4 . pr v de :
o r he pp ia e ir tto rod o unt 1. r i a de .1 2 32 o i s
l
N o pe s confne i a sa e orl lc r c
r on
i d n tt
oca oz e dona f clt s l brng or ha
l a iiy hal i
ve
br
ought on l s be l a pe s l a ton z l i t t c
n
i ha f ny r ona c i eatng o he ondii of hi
tons
s
c i m ent untlal a l bl a i st tve r m e e a e e use Such
onfne
i l vaia e dnanit a i e di s r xha t d.
a ton s l be br
c i hal
oughtby or on beha fofs pe s wihi one yea a t r
l
uch z on t n
r fe
c us of a ton a c es orwihi sx m ont a t r aladr rit a r m eci
a e
c i c ru
t n i
hs fe 1 nilsz éve e les
a e e use whihe rocc sl t r
r xha t d, c ve
ur a e .

Va Cod .
. e Ann. 80 - 4 .
j .1 2 . 2.
3
Th S pr meCo tofVigni ha hed t a Vig naCod j80 - 4 2 a ist
eu e
ur
t i a s l h t ti i
e .1 2 3. ppl o
e

a a to wh r : 1 apli if sfc nfne ' tt tmet ec us ofa ton a c u d'a
ny cin e e () antf wa f o i d a he i h a e ci c r e y nd
f
'
()Tlec us ofa t . . eaes t g)pantf' Toncto ofc nfne n .' n v.
2 f' a e ci . r lt gj o a li if c l ins o i me t' Bi
tl
on
s
i
'

Ha ood 2 3Va 3 1 3 , 22S. 2d2 4, 4 (0 2 (ii Va Code An j80 , 8 . 8 , 85 7 E. 4 2 6 2 1 ) ctng . . n. .1
2 .) M o e ve , ri i Cod j80 - 4 .: l tt pei a l se n i af litf
432 . r o r Vigna e .1 2 32s i ai
mi ons rod ppi ve f f an if
e
p
4

i no l ri a c r ed a t tm es fl he ac i r ldng t c
s
onge nc r e at t he i he les r ton ea
o ondii ofhe
tons
r

c i me t'Luc sv. ood , 7Va 35 3 1 7 6S. 2 4 7 45 ( 1 )
onf
ne n . a W
?
28 . 4, 6 , 5 E.d 4 , 0 20 4 .
TheFA C pladst Cas on w a c i a t tm et c us ofac i
e
hat hi
s onined t he i he a e
ton- t ti,
ha s

t alg d r f a of J a dissa ft pr vdea tps c tcme ia i - a c d
he l e eusl MRR A n t t f o o i n i y ho i dc t
e
on c me ,
a t ca e ofa ton r l t t hi condii ofconfne e .The c zthnds and
nd he us
c i e aes o s
tons
i m nt
otr
,

Ca lin d snotc t s, ha VignaCod j80 - 4 2pr s rbe ao - e rsam eo
szo oe
on e t t t ri i
e .1 2 3. e ci s ney a tt f
l tt f rCou 11 Fr t fc oft eFAC,Ca honwa r la e fo M RRJ o
i ai o
mi ons
nt 1 . om he a e h
si
s ee s d r m
A n
D e m be 11 2015,t l tda e t alge i de t tea m e a f iur t pr de
ce r ,
he as t he le d na qua e t t nt nd al e o ovi

me ii a MMRJ c l ha oc u r d. !28 Und rVigni Codej8012 3.,
d cne t
A oud ve c re FAC J . e ri a
. -4 2
Ca hi had untlD e m be 11,201 t fl a c pli r l t d t t c tonsofhi
s on
i ce r
6 o le ny om ant e a e o he ondii
s

c i me . i t a d le ,fi t sa to onl nu r 3 , 01 - a tzt l ltt
onf
ne ntHe nse d al d ing hi cin a a y 1 2 7 fe he i iai
i l
n ons
pei ha e p r d. r i aCo j8012 . t r f ep o i e t tCo tIIi tme
rod d x ie Vigni de . - 432 he eor r v d s ha un I s i
ba r
r ed.

l . E qualPr ecton Cl us
V
ot i
a e

Re o n zngt i, slonc ntndst tVigr aCodej80 - 432 ofe t
c g ii h s Ca li o e ha til
i
.1 2 . fnds he
Equa Pr e i Clus oft Foure h Am e
l ot cton a e he
t ent
ndm e .
nt TheEqualPr ec i Clus
ot ton a e

pr v d s f S aes l . . n t a ype s wili isj idc n t e u lp o e to
o i e :< tt hal . de y o n ron t ! t urs iéo he q a r t cin
No
na
oft lws'U.. t a e . V,j1 f hee ua pz e ton r ql e ntdo snottk
he a . S Cons. m nd XI
'
.f q l otci e lr me e
l'
i
ae
fom t St e alpowe ofcls ii a i butke psgover e a de ii a r fom
r
he at s l
r
a sfc ton,
e
nm nt l c sonm ke s r
tea dif r nty pe s who a ei alr lva r s c sai 7V e v.W c ,293 F.
r éng fe e l r ons
r n l ee nt e pe t lke.' ne
he
3d
9

7 , 3 (t Ci. 0 2 ( ena q otto a ctto o te )
26 7 0 4. r 2 0 ) i r l u ai ns nd iains mitd .
h
nt

5

Theeem e sofa s es f e lpr ec
l nt
ucc s ul qua ot don csi a ewels ted.Ca hi f us
l m r l etl
s on f t
m
fr tde ons r e t he lasbe n tea e difze l f
ls m
tat hat a
e r t d fe nty rom ot r Mdf whom hei sm ia
he s .
h
s i lHy

sm at a t tt une ltea e w a t r tl ofi e
i ed nd ha he qua r r nt s he eszt nt ndona orpum os ul
l
ef

dstmi éon'Kobev. a 8 F.d1 4 1 6(t Ci. 1 )(nba )(uoig
ici na . l Ho n, 49 3 1 , 4 4h r20 7 e nc q tn
'
M ors v. ra h , 3 F.d6 8 6 4(t Ci. 0 ).fCahonma e t ss owig
rion Gar
2 9 3 4 , 5 4h r20 1)l s i
k s hi h n ,

fhec t p oc e t deez n whehe t ds rt i te t n cpbej tf dund r
f out z e ds o trnie t r he ipaiy n zame t a usii
t
e
e
t rqust lve ofsr tn ' ors nv Garg y 2 F.d6 8 65 (t Ci. 0 ) At
he e iie e l cuip'M rio . ra ht, 39 3 4 , 4 4h t 2 01.
t sse < c t ge rl prs st ttesauei vai a wileett c l ng f
hi tp,< ou' neal eume ha h ttt s ld nd lrjc he hal e i
a t
y
e f
t casii a
he l sfc don dt w n by ta satzei r donal r lt d t a lg tm a e sat i e es. '
a
le t tt s a
ly ea e o e ii t t e ntr t'
'

Kobe 8 9 F.da 1 6 (uot Ci o Clbu nev. e ur Lii Ct.I .47 U.. 3
l ,4 3 t 4 q i
ng
f e r Clb ne v n r nc, 3 S 4 2,
44 (98 ).< saea e ua pt t cin cnm, Ca h o T tp e d s f intfc st
0 1 5) < tt n q l o e to li 7 s i n f
To
7
mus la u hce a t o
s ésy ea h r qlie ent'V e ,293 F. a 731.I Casùon f l a et rs e t c t
a f c e lr m .' ne
3d t
f l
ais t ihe t p, he our

mus fnd t tVigni Co j8012 . d sno v oaet eEq a Pr tci n Clus
t i ha t i a de . - 432 oe t i lt h u l o e to a e
1.

Si iqry Siuat
m l l t ed

Fis,Cas on m us de onst et thei sm ia l st t d t non- one swih
t t hi
t m tat ha
s i lry iua e o
pds r t
r pe t sa t oflm ia
es ct o t m es i t dons He f is fT'e Ti ia l st t d's a r z qliesa
.
al. f h sm lry iua e t nda d e lr
pl i ft i ndf pe s m a e i lyi nic lt hi orhe w ho ha r ceved dif r nt
anéf o de y r ons t ral de a o m
r
se i
fe e

te tne t'Kobev. a 81 F.d 1 0 1 5 (t Ci. 1 ) va ae o ot r r un ,
ra n . l Ho n, 3 3 6 , 8 4 h r 20 6 , c td n he o ds
'
8 9F.d 1 4 ( h Ci. 01 )(nba ) A pli fmus p od ee i nc t a T ho s a
4 3 1 4t r 2 7 e nc. anéf t r uc vde e h t f wg) n
s
e te l lg d g e ofsmi rt 'A ( od Wi i v. wn ofMa s l N. , 5F.
x rmey a h e r e i l ip'J qu ng ls To
i
a
l
rhal C.27
,
Ap x 2 7 23 ( . Ci. 0 )
p' 2 , 3 4t t 2 08 .
h

6

A ppl ng t ssrnge sa r i a e ha f
yi hi ti nt tnda d, nm t s ve ound i difc tt de onsr t t t
t fiul o m
ta e ha
t y a e sm ia l stz t d e t ot ri a es See e .Bea a v. e u Di.N o.7:2he r i lry i a e ven o he nm t .
a
., m n D
r,
1

c 0 6 , 1 W L 4 6 4 , t* ( D. . y2 , 01 )(ndigidiûc lt beive
v-01 3 20 2
4 0 36 a 3 W. Va Ma 9 2 2 h n t f ut o le
t timae aee rsmi ryst ae t ot e i tsv sàv spa o ede ii ) Sa ev.
ha n ts r ve i l l iu td o h r nmae i-- i r l csons; ld
a

Ha o Roa - e 'l t 3 3F. u 2 7 9 7 2( D. . 0 4 ( t a ingtil
mptn dsl gl al 0 S pp. d 7 , 8 E. Va 2 0 ) i e wat ra
k
,
nma
i
n smi rystztdt c n ce i t s; a esv. s, 0 F. up 2d8 2, 1 ( D.
ot i l l it e o o vitd nmae) W tr Ba s 3 4 S p. 0 8 0 E.
a
a
Va 2 0 )(tt i ma e no smi ryst ae t f d r lnmae) I f lo ,t n, ha
. 0 4 sae n ts t i l l iu td o e e a i t s. t olws he t t
a
fp rs e sa eno smi ry st ae t no prs ne s'Rolrv. n,1 7 F.d 2 7 2 4
f jion r r t i l l iu td o n- io r . l Gun 0 3 2 , 3
r
a
' e
( h Ci. 9 7 .
4t r 1 9 )
M o e v r Tg h us ofd fee tsa te o l tt f rdifr ntofe e do s
r o e ,rq e e ifr n ttz s f i ai o fe e fns s e
t
t
mi ons
notc ea ean i di cas iiaton orbkr n a f
r t
nvi ous l sfc i
zde
unda e alrght' Unied St esv.H a ,
m nt i .' t
at
m

No . 9 4 2 9 - 7 3, 0 WL 3 6 3 , t 1 (t Ci. 00 )( rc im) s eas Cha e
s 9 - 77 , 9 4 7 20 0
4 9 5 a * 4 h r 2 0 pe ura ; e lo s

S c Cor . Don ls , 25U. 3 4, 1 (9 5 rf laue ofl tt g t matr of
e.
v. ad on 3
S. 0 3 4 1 4 ) g ttts i ai o o tes
s
mi on
r me y no t d sr ton off nd m e a rg s' I ta fst t tsofl tto
e d , t o e tuci
u a ntl iht. nse d,f ja u e i ai ns
).
g
mi

fe ee apu i poiya utt prvlg t l gae a Ci t ij tfc to i
rprsnt bl lc bo he iie e o i t' nd fnd her usiiain n
c
d
nee st a dc n ninc .. g o d rt)s r t c zsfom li éo ofsaecqms'
c siy n o ve e e .i r e o pae he ou t r iga n tl li .
n
t
:
D a & Buse ',I v. hieFlntM al LLLP, 61 F. p' 55 ,5 7 (t Ci. 01 )q s
ve
trs nc. W t i
l,
6 Ap x 2 5 4h r2 5 at
.

t oatzto i oii l ( ot ChaeS c, 5U. a 3 4.
v leains n rgna) qu i
v
ng s e .32 S. t 1 )
W ih tlsi nnnd,t cotr ha ltl toubl conc udi t tCaslon,whos c m
t li n i he zt s ite r e
l ng ha
li
e bi

a ans MRRJ r ltst t c diinsofh sc i me , snotsnl al stztd t
gi t
A eae o he on to
i onf
ne nti
i i ty i a e o
l
a
no rs r wihpe s n i u ycqms whos cnmsa eg v r d b Vigri Cod j80 np iones t r o njr li , e li r o e ne y r i a e .1
t
2 3' t - e rsa u eofl téon . isfc , t i aCo j8012 . o ya pl st
4 s wo y a tt t i a s On t a e Vigni de . - 432 nl p i o
mi
e

camsT eaig t t c ndtonsof. . onf me . Va Co Ann. 80 - 4 2Be a e
li f ltn o he o ii
r
. c i nt: . de
ne
'
j .1 2 3. c us
fp rs r a enotsmial smae t non prs e s'Rolr 1 7 F.d a 2 4,tf l ws
r jiones t
g
i lty i td o - ion r , le, 0 3 t 3 i ol
'
o
t ti vi l who a s r c m st nec s rl a i ef om i prs e a enotsm ia l
ha ndi dua s
s e t bi hat es a iy rs z m ionm nt r
i lry
stz e t i vi l who a s r c nm st do nota e fom i pzs
it d o ndi dua s
at
s e t l i hat
ds t m ionm e .
nt

I a ate ptt ciéngtih Role ,Cas on c nm st t r lva c pa ion i
n n t m o ls zs
lr
hi l i hat he ee nt om rs s

no bevenp io r a n prs es b i ta ftecéz nswhoaeijze whi
t t e rs nes nd on ion r, utnse d ' e i e
f
r nt d l
r
e
te aenotc e a dfl s t i no c i d' n rrecéz nswhoweeij e
hy r
onfn d n ie uiwhl t onfne 'a d f e i e
e
f
r nurd
wbl c i e a d f es iwhl no c nfne 7P1' Rep.
ie onfn d n l ut i t o i d. . s Opp. fMRR A' Mo .
l
e
' s
De . J S t

Din isCo . Op ? ECF No. 5 a 2 (mp ssomitd.
sls mplrT p.
),
3 , t 4 e hai te )
Cas on M s t t st r lva com pa ion.
hi
s a e he ee nt
rs The i ta i 'ye n i t t of
niil nqut xa nnes he ype
r
c nm a t l aton oft pli ifwhen t cam a r s W hiei i t t Bi v.
l i nd he oc i
he antf
he li cc ue . l t s rue hat n
H a ood hed t tt l a i whe e apl ntf i l at a t tm e a a i a m e i
l ha he oc ton
r
ai if s oc ed t he i
n cton cc d s

a ee n o Vigni Cod j8012 .,tas hedt tf t tsa et a y t clm
n lme t f r i a e . - 432 i lo l ha or ha tmt o ppl, he li

mus f eaet g)pant fsfo ii ofc nfne nt' 2 3Va a 3 , 2 S. 2 a 24 .
t ç lt o a li i ' c ndtons o i me .' 8 . t 85 7 2 E.d t 6
r
f
'
The Com m onweat ofVigi a m a pr s rbe acif r ntsatzeofl iatonsf cni s
lh
r ni y e c i
lfe e t tt
i ti
m
or l m

rltdt c iinsofc nfne ntta i d sf i uiss frdeswhee3S eHa
eae o ondto
o i me h n t oe ornjre ufee le r. e m,
20 0WL 3 69 5 a * .nded,th sd s hee Und r>
0
4 3 , t 1 I e i a one o r . e

a dHa apli f
n m, anéf

p os c tn acnm go e ne b VigraCod j80 - 4 2i o ysmi ryst a e t ot e
r e u ig li v r d y rit
i
e .1 2 3. s nl i l l iu td o h r
a

3By wa ofe m pl , s s t ta i i d lbr a hesawrte c -a tt whih a i a ei apa t a t i a e
y xa e uppo e ha n ndvi ua e c
it n ont c o c n nm t s rs nd he nm t
r
i ot r s a e t pr t ee e s f ra br a h ofc r c c am .Furhe ,s
s he wi e bl o ove he lm nt o
ec
ont a t l i
t r uppos t tnet rt br a h nort
e ha ihe he e c
he
c r c inplc est i a e' i a c r
onta t i iat he nm t s nc r e adon, tt i a e s whiei a c r t d.Ihe c tbei ve t tVigml
ye he nm t ues l nc r e a e '' our le s ha z ' '
a

Co ej80 -4 ()sf eya l td n p l dfrc nrc ato wo l a py no Vig ' Co ej80 -4 .. n
d .12 62' i -eri a o s ei o o ta t cins ud p l, t rml d .12 32 Eve
v
mi
o
'a
t
hough t i a ewasi a ce a e whe t ca m a c ue t ' a e ofac i a os fom a e e usc r c ,not
he nm t
nc r r t d
n he li c r d, hec us
ton r e r n xog no onta t
t c donsoft i a esc me e .
he ondi
he nm t ' onf m nt

panif who eaton ()a cu dwhl i acrtd, nd()rlt t tec iinsof
litfs s ci s 1 c r e ie ncreae a 2 eae o h ondto
t i confne e .
he.
r
l m nt
W ih t ti nnnd,i i cea t tCas on,whos Cli l I c pli s ey oft
t ha n i t s l r ha
hi
e nm I om ans ol l
he

c tonsofhi c i m e ,i notsm iary st ed t ot rpli f who com pli of
ondii
s onfne nt s
i l l iuat o he andfs
an

i lre s frdwhi n c i d.nse d Cahoni smi ryst ae onyt ohe
nj is ufee l ot onfne I ta , s i s i l l iu td l o t r
l
e
a
p an f who c mpan o i u e ba e ont c dionso t i c nfne n . r i a
lidfs
o li f t i s s d he on é
jt
f her o i me t Vigni

Codej80 -4 2tet e r pan falgn ti tpeofnu yie éc i AsCahin h s
.12 3. ras vey liéf l ig hs y
e
ijr d n ay.
so a
no de tae t thei smi ry sma e t pli if a s rigpe s a ij ycnms
t monst td ha s i l l i td o antfs s etn ron lnur li
a
g vene b Vigni Cod j801 2 3 h se ua p otcin c m fi .
o r d y r i a e . - 4 , i q l r e to bi al
s
2.

R at onalB as s R e e
i
i
vi w

Eve i Ca hi w e e a e t esa ih t thei sm ia l stz ed t nonprs r
n f s on r bl o t bls ha
s i lry itat o
ione s

wihr g r t saae of i iai ns Vigni Co j 801 2 32e sl wi tnd r t l
t e a d o ttzs l tto , r i a de . - 4 . ai t a s a i
m
y hs
ona
bassr vi w. he fs ilore
i e e W n foca
cononac lgiléon i ati s t Equa Pr ec i Cl us
i e sa
s s ue, he
l ot ton a e

a l t St t wi l i de a t Consitton pr s e t te n i pr dent
lows he a es de atm , nd he
ttzi
e um s ha ve m ovi

decsonswile ual bez ctfe by t de oc atcpr es es' Ciy ofClbtr v.
ii
l vent ly
e ii d
he m r i oc s .' t
e zne

Clb n Li n Ct.I .4 3U.. 3 , 4 ( 9 5 ( e n lctéonsomitd .filnls a
e uz e vi r nè, 7 S 4 2 4 0 1 8 ) i r a ia
nt
te ) f e s
l
sa t a f c sa f m e alrghtors e pr ec e cas ,cotr sge r l a cor t
t m e f e t unda nt i
om
ot t d l s zt ne al c d he
y

lgsai afto pr s mpt of l t b a lig aê do lb sssa a dofz ve '
e ilt
on sr ng e u i vai f y ppyn a na a i tnd r e im '
on
di
W id v. dd , 3 F.d 3 4, 4 (t Ci. 01 )(uot Helrv. o , 0 U.. 2
l ns Ga 7 4 3 4 3 7 4 h t 2 3 q i
l
ng l D e 5 9 S 31 ,
e
3 9 (9 3)
1 1 9 ).
H eght ne s r i onl a
i e d c utny y ppze whe a g oup ofi l dua si a s pec orquass
n r
nci
vi l s us t
i
s pec cas oraf nda e a rghti i ved.Cl bur ,473 U . a 439- A g oup i
us t l s
' m nt l i s nvol
u
e ne
S. t
40. t
s

onl as pec or quas- us ctca swhe Ttpos es esi m ut e c r c e i t ,f ce
y us t
is pe ls
n f
i s s m
abl ha a t rsj a s
cs

l so i o on oig cs rmia on, ri s jc t abirr bt nso s meba i be ond
a t rc r g n l c i n é o s ub e t o r ta y ude n o
i
i
ss y
isa l yt c nto . Wikns 7 4F.d a 3 (ii Clb ne 47 U. a 4 9 43 .
t bit o o r l' li , 3 3 t 48 ct
i
'
ng e ur , 3 S. t 3 - )
K a ebr aki t 1w i akol a y a a m a prs r w11e ntzly ber las
f us e ng he a s
Bec
unt r ct nd ny ione s 1 ve ta l
ee ed,
t Tt t ofi r er i i net ran i m ut e c r c e i éc ..., an i di bass
he sa us nca c aton s ihe
m
abl ha a t rs
nor nvi ous i

ofca sfc to ' I (l rtoni o ii l (uo gM o sv. a k 88 F.d 6 6 6 0 (t
lsiiai n.' d.at ai n rgna) q én s- Clr 6 2 8 , 9 4 h
'
e
Ci. 9 9) Thu , zs ne saeno as pe tca s 1
r 1 8 ). s p io r r t us c ls. d.

AsCa honi n patofas s c ca sa , sdealda ve Vig naCod j8 1
s i s ot r
u pe t ls nd a ti bo , ri i e 0 e
243. doe noti plc t a Smda ent lrght r i lba i r viw a i . nde r i l
2
s
m ia e
m a i , atona ss e e pples U
r atona

bai rviw, r i aCo j 8 - 4 . fsa c r e asr ngp e u
ss e e Vigni de 01 2 32 f c o d d to r s mpdo ofvaiif'a
i
n
l t nd
d
Tspr s me c ns t i l' l rv Doe 5 U.. 2 31 -2 ( 9 3 . s ieCa hin'
f e u d o d ut . Hel . , O9 S 31 , 9 0 1 9 ) De p t s o s
i
ona ' e
c enton t tf hebur n i on t gover e t de onsr t a r i lba i , Opp.24
ont i ha ç
t
de s
he
nm nt o m
t a e atona ss'
'

(iigEn us v Or De 'of rc, 3U.. 91 6 2 3( 0 ),ti Caho wh ber
ctn
it . . t A i.55 S 5 , 0 -0 20 8)i s s in o as
t buz n fço ne i e r conc i bl ba i whih r ghts
he de ft gatve ve y
eva e ss c ni uppor iywhet rornott
t t'
he
he

ba i ha af nd to i t er c r , Helr 5 9U. a 3 0 21 (uo igLe a e v.
ss s ou ai n n h e o d' l , 0 S. t 2 - q tn hnh us n
' e
La eS r Aut Pa t Co.41 U. 35 , 6 (9 3) Th c ur i f ompeld u r
k ho e o rs , 0 S. 6 3 4 1 7 ). e o t s ç
c
l nde
e
r éonalbassr viw t ac epta lgilt esge r i atonse n whe t t i a i pe f c
a
- i e e o c
e sa ur ' ne alz i
ve
n he e s n m r e t
ftbe we n m ea a ends' I a 321
i t e
ns nd
. d. t .
:
TheCor onweataofVigi a wli h i e ve d t def nd t c dt i lt of
nm
ll
r ni, lc nt r ne o e he ons utonaiy

Vign aCod j8 .4 - , ist z er a o wh t ed fe e l iainspei f r
r ii
e 012 3 2 post h e e s ns y h ifr nti tto
m
rod o

c e ntr ltdi u i si waz ntd:ç )p e nt i a c r t dpe s fom fl g
onfn me -eae njze s ra e ç1 r ve i nc t e ae rons r ln
(
ng
i
fi l us sae orfa u e lws t;()p e e vn t S aesf nc s a ()p o i ig
rvo o , tl, r ud lnt a uis 2 r sr ig he tt ' i e ; nd 3 r v dn
na
1
0

s t rl iatonspe i t cam st ta er a l known t t c nm a when t ale d
hor e i t i
m
rods o li ha t e di
y
o he l i nt
he lge

i jr o czs'Br Co n at Va l e v no De e eVa Co . 801 2 32 ECF
hu y c k . . mmo we 1h . ntr e r fns . de j . - 4 .,
r'
N o. a 7.
39, t
Anyoft s r i l s sandi aone i m or t s fc e t s f t c zt
he e atona e , t ng l , s
e han ufii nt o ads y he otr

ta atd a bai e it fzVignaCod j8 12 32 Wihrs c t p e nt
h t a on l ss xss o rii e 0 .4 .. t epet o rve i
ng
fi ouslw s t,t Fouth Cicui ha not t tf ione ltga
rvol a uis he
t t t s ed ha f s r ii éon hasa s e
pr
s um d

s mel n oft n tr ofaTe r ai a a t t .' lr 1 7F.d a 2 4 (ii Ga l
o ti g he a u e
n
r c e ton l ci y' Rol , 0 3 t 3 ctng be v.
vi ' e

L n u h 8 5F.d1 4 1 n. (t Ci. 9 8)Th Cor nwelhc ul ha ert l
a , 3 2 2 , 25 1 5h r 1 8 ). e nmo at o d v ai l
onay
d trni d t a s re n t l tt pei f zp po tdi j iss fr d d t
e et ne h t ho tnig he i ai
mi ons rod o ut re nure ufe e ue o
c i m e woul hep c b a esf
onfne nt
d l ur bus ound i prs rH ga i
n ione
ton.
W i. r pe t pr e dng t Cor onwe lh' fna ,i i cla t a ç i ous
t es ct o es r
h
he nm
a t s i nces t s e r hat ztgi
pl i fpr s i a fi ousc nm ,t
andf e sng rvol
l i hough r r l s ce ng on t m e is c be e r m ey
a ey uc edi
he tt , an
xte l

c sl t t edee da . Ha rlonv. td S ae , 1 F.d 1 4 11 (t Ci. 9 0 9 e
o t o h f n nt' res Uni tts 6 3 2 1 , 6 5h r 1 8 ) s e
y
'
e

as I si Prmc 1,
lo oisv. a o 1 LLC, 10 c 1 4( J , 0 9W . 8 3 8 , t* ( D.
No. :8 v1 7 GBL/FA) 2 0 L 6 78 3 a 3 E.
Va Ma. , 0 )( ot Harlo ) TheCo
. r 4 2 09 qu i
ng res n .
mmon at c ul h vetto l d tr ne
we l o d a ainal eemi d
h
y
t t ri aCod j8 .4 - m a sa eof fi l usl iain a d hep pr sr et
ha Vigni
e 012 3 2 y tv f rvo o i g to n l e e v he
t
Com m onwe lh' hs .
at s c

Fi ly, t r pe t pr di s trlm ia i pe i f cli slnown t t
nal wih es ct o ovi ng hoze i t tons zods oz nm c
.
o he

cnma a t et et alg d i u yoc ure ,t S ptmeCo t ha no e t a S cin
li nt t h i he l e njr c r d he u e
m
e
u t s td h t e to
1 lw s t pr c e on prs c ltonsr lr a fs c fc de i i ofa sngl
983 a uis ediat d
ion oncii
eqlie fpe ii prvaton
i e

hu n ne d'W i onv. et r 5 U.. 9 , 5( 9 1 . Co
ma e . l
' s
S ie , 01 S 2 4 30 1 9 ) The mmon at c ul ha e
we lh o d v
r tonal det mi d t t s t rlm iai pe i f ope l a ount f t f ctt t
a i ly er ne hat he hor e i t tons rod '
pz ry cc
s or he a ha
11

c dto - -o me tcamsd nottk a lngt sufc a ot tpes a-nur
on iinsofc nûne n li o
a e s o o k a e s he ton lij y
c am st ta i eouti oft prs cont xt'Br Com m onw eat Va.l e ve D e e e
li ha rs
sde he ion
e . .
?
lh
nt r noz f ns

Va Co e j80 - 4 2 ECF No. 9 a 1 .
. d . .1 2 3.,
3,t 2
W i. t e sat d z i lsi nnnd,<t e lpr ec i c nm i notac os one'
t hes t e atonae n i fhe qua ot ton l i s
h
l e .'
Role ,107 F. a 234.
lr
3d t
The c tfndst t lg sa tr sdetr i ton i entr l
our i
hat he e il tze' e nnna i s iey

r t a. c u eVigni Cod j80 - 4 . ha ar do l ss do sno vi aea
ai lBe a s r i a e .1 2 32 s a na' i, e t olt
on
ba

f da ntl iht a d sno s bjc as pe tca st ds r t te t nt t ec ur
un me a rg , nd oe t u e t us c ls o ipaae r ame , h o t
ho d t a Vigni Co j801 2 32d snotofe t Eq l otci Clus .
l s h t z i a de . - 4 . oe
fnd he ua Pz e ton a e
Acc di y,Cas on' c nm sa e tm eba r d.
or ngl
hi s l i r i
re
V.

Concl i
us on

Vigt aCod j80 - 4 2pa s sc nsiu l tr Be a eCa hin c nc de
ri i
a
e .1 2 3. se o ttéona muse . c us s o o e s

t tVignaCod j80 - 432: l tto pei dgo r hi cqms t e aet bar d.
ha ti i e .1 2 . s i ains ro ve ns s li , h y t i re
mi
me
Acc di y,t M oéon t Dinns f Fal e t Stt a Chi ,ECF N o. wilbe
or ngl he
o s i s or iur o a e
m
30, l

GM NTED. nt I1a I a eDI M I ED W I PM J CE. J S
Cou s I nd V r S SS
TH
UDI MRR A'
M oton t SubnltSupplm ent lAut iy,
i o
i
e
a
hort ECF N o.47, sD EN I A S M O OT .
i
ED

Enee : lI- o&- L< ?
trd
-)
'
e

/
+/

m

J zve .
r g .

M i hae F. ba ki
c l Ur ns

,' *
.

'

Che Unie S sDitit u e
if td t
src l dg

'.
*

.

12

.