Fitzgerald et al v. Alcorn et al

Filing 71

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 2/5/2018. (jv)

CLERKS OFFI t. . DI COURT
CE J3 ST.
AT ROANOKE, A
V

I TH E UN I D STATE S D ISTRICT CO U RT
N
TE

FL D
IE

FO R T H E W ESTERN D I
STM CT O F W RGI I
N A
H A RRI N BU RG D I SION
SO
W

FEi û5 2 1
28
J A C. DLE CL
U
D
X ERK
BK '

AN N E T .FI
TZGE R AI. ,eta1,
D
.
Pl i if
a ntfs,

DE
P

L .

CaseN o.5: c 1
17- v- 6

By:

J ESB.
AM
ALCORN,e a .
t 1y

Mi
chaelF.U t
bansd
l

ChifUnie S a e Diti t udge
e td t t s src l

D ef
endant
s.

M EM O RAN DU M O PI ION
N

Thi m a tri bef et c ton D e enda s M oton f Sty Pe ngA ppe .
s te s or he our
f nt' i oz a ndi
al
;

ECF N o.62.80t pa te ha ild m e or ndaof1w i s
h r is ve èe
m a
a n uppor oft i r pec i
t her es tve
postons The cour cipe eswih or la gum e bec us t f ct a lga c entonsa e
ii .
t ls ns
t a r
nt a e he a s nd e l ont i
r

a qua ey pr e ed i t m a e i l bef e t cour a â gum e woul notad t
de t l es nt n he t ras or he
t nd r
nt
d
i he
de ii lpr s .Fort r as sa e beow ,t c twilG RAN T D e endant '
c sona oce s
he e ons t t d l he our l
f
s

mot f asa oft ij ci p n n a pe l
i or ty he nun ton e dig p a.
on
OnJ n r 1 , 1 , h c u td ca e Vigni' I ç mbe Pz tc n Ac, .
a uay 9 20 8 t e o r e lr d t i as n u nt o e éo t Va

Cod An j2 2 5 9 ,fcal u o tmton lb cus t Ac'o rve steFis
e n. 4.- 0 7) a il nc nsi i a e a e he tc nta ne h rt
y
Ame me trg t ofpo i a paée a d t i c mmite . umm. . de,
nd n i h s
l l t s n her o te s S
dc
J Or r ECF No. 7
5.
Thec u te o ne t Vigri De rme tofElci a me r oft Vign a
o r nji d he rit pat n
a
e t nd mbe s he r ii
ons
Boa d ofEl tonsfom e or i t I
r
ec i
r
nf cng he ncum be Pr e i A c i a or re e ed on t
nt ot cton t n n de nt r
he

s meda . r ne I .Or e , No 5 . fnd n s Vigri ee d n ofkil, w
a
y Pe ma nt nj d r ECF . 8 De e a t, ril lc o f as no
a
a kt c ur f asa pe dig t i a a und rFe e a Rul o Cii Pr c du e6 c,
s he o t or ty n n her ppe l e d r l e f v l o e r 2()

cont ndi t a sa i nec s t t a d dit
e ng hat t y s es ay o voi supdon ofVigti' adm i st i oft
t ila s
nitaton he
2018 e e tons M ot f St yPe ng Appea,ECF N o.
lci .
. or a ndi
l
62.

A pat rq sigasa mus de tae<1 ta h wi lk l p e alo t
ry e uetn ty t monsrt T ) h t e l iey rv i n he
(
l
meisoftea a,()t thew1 s ftitpaa ei u yi t sa i de id ()t t
tt h ppel 2 ha
1 ufe te tbl njr f he ty s ne , 3 ha
1

ot tpade wi notb s bsa il hame b t sa , nd()t ttep i i eet l
he t s l
l e u tntal r d y he ty a 4 ha h ubl ntrs wi
y
c
l
bes r e b g a i t sa . Lo v. b ns , 2 F.d 9 7 9 ( t Ci. 9 0 ; e
e v d y r nt he ty' n Ro i on 43 2 7 , 79 4h t 1 7 ) s e
ng
'
as Nk n v. de,5 6U. 41 , 3 (0 ) f i et eta é lsa f co s
lo e Hol r 5 S. 8 4 3 2 09. f nc h rdiona ty a t r.
s
c ntmplt i ii uaie j g n si e c c s ,hef r ac nn ber du e t as t
o e ae ndv d lz d ud me t n a h a e t o mul a ot e c d o e

ofrgdr e. Hionv. a ll, 1U. 77 , 7 (98 )
ii uls' l
' t Brunsdl48 S. 0 7 7 1 7.
I weghi t baa e oft ef t s t c tfndsis l m uch ilt s m e
n i ng he lnc
hes ac or , he our
tef
t he a

pos tr ast Ea t r Diti tofVig ri i a e rireec i 1w c s i whih a sa ofa
tze he s e n src
t ila n n a le l ton a a e n
c
ty
n

i u to pe i a awa s u htl Pr jc Vot votn f Ameia l c v. ng
njncin ndng ppe l s o g .n oe t e/ ig or rc . n . Lo ,
2 F. D. 7 , 4( D. . 1 ) teEatr Dititnoe
75 R. 4 3 47 E. Va 20 1,h sen src td:
The c ti notpe s de t t c ty a ndon isnli a fnd
our s
t ua d o a il ba
t lng nd i
t tt def ndant a e lkey t s ee on a a.H owe r as
ha he e
s r i l o ucc d
ppe l
ve ,
t ca e i one of ft t i pr s i t t
he s s
ls m e son hat ouches on m a tr of
te s
s t lna i li por a e t r i c t anl a fs t nta
ubsanda tona m
t nc , he e s e t i y fubsa il

c s on t me is' g lo j 48 U..a 7 8 Ac o dn l,i
a e he rt. Hit n , 1 S t 7 . c r igy f
'
t ot rkct smiiaei fvorofa sa t cour ma is
he he a or ltt n a
ty, he
t y sue
one Se i ;s as M ilrv.Br
. e d. ee lo le
own,465 F.Supp.2c 584,596
1

( D. . 0 ) a f 5 3F.d 3 0 (t Ci. 0 7 .
E. Va 20 6 , f' 0 3 6 4h t 2 0 )
d,
Smial,n M ie v. o , hec ur e pli d Tg hl t eCou tc nno s yt a
i lry i l r Br wn t o t x ane ,f ie h
l
wl
r a ta ht
D ef nda sa e lkel t pr vali t i a a,t Cour doesr cog z t tt sc e r i e
e nt r i y o t i n he. ppe l he
r
t
e nie ha hi as a s s
a is off ti pr son.'465 F.Supp.2d a 596.
n s ue us m esi '
t

I t i a t ,t c r' de ii a dr se c mplxis e ofjsiib ly a
n l s c i he ou ts cson d e s d o e su j u t a ii , nd
z on
c t
i lda e as a tt g di poltca pa tes pr es esf nom i dng c ndi t si t
nvai t d t tze ui ng ii l ri ' oc s or
na
a da e n he
2

Comm onweay The sam t ati s i uni i ournaton,a gi i
lh.
t e s ue s que n
i
nd ves ncum be si
nt n
Vigi a s t ilpow e overhow t i poltc pa de choos c dat f publc
r ni ubsanta
r
he r iial l s
e andi es or
i

ofie Thec nsit naiyo t ssa eha be nt s jc ofmuc de t a p r
fc .
o tt do l f hi tmt s e he ube t
z
t
h bae nd do

lt ai Se 2 tS n t ilDitRe u ia Co v. c r 8 0F.d6 4(t Ci.
ii ton. e 4h e aora s. bl n mm. Alo n, 2 3 2 4h r
g
c
J

20 6; l rv. ntn h m, 2F.d9 (t Ci. 0 7 ( l s , .cse ngfo
1 )Mie Cu l a 51 3 8 4h r2 0 ) Widn on ),l sné t m
l
i
l
i
'
h

de a ofr he rng ç ba ) At e s a t t eis ofj t ibit , h a e l r s nt J
nil e a i - nc. la t s o h sue usi a l y t e pp a p e e s ç
q
c i
a
.

s t ntalc e on t m e is' H it 481U . a 778.W hie t c tr m ni
ubs a i as
he rt .' lon,
S. t
l he our e ns

unconvi e oft lkei
nc d he i lhood ofD e enda s s es on a
f nt' ucc s
ppea,a sa c d beappr i t
l t y oul
opra e

i t rm ari f t sn iiaei fvorofmanti ngt sa' quo.Se i
f he e ilng acor altt n a
i ani he tt
us
e da

Ea hpa t cnmsij yi isposto on t sa i u e e . fnd n sagu t t
c ry li nur f t iin he ty s nhe d d De e a t t e ha
t i u to wil e k h vo be a epa t ofiil mus b gn t ma 2 8ee to
he njncin lwr a a c c us ry fcas t e i o ke 01 lcin
de ii i t ne f w da ,welbef et Fourh Cic tCour ofAppe l coul r e on
c sons n he xt e
ys l oz he
t z ui
t
as
d ul

t j tca it ofti ds ut. wa t c s i M ie v. o ( fn nt aec ret
he usiibly ls ip eAs s he ae n l r Br wn,T e da s t o rc
i
n
l
De
t tt i u ton d sc e t a la ts mec u i n a unc ran yi t eno nna n
ha he njnci oe r ae t e s o onf so nd e tit n h r i do
pr s a m a e nm al r quiea lgiltve c nge. 465 F.Supp.2d at596.O n t
oce s nd y ve ly e t e sa i ha '
'
he
ot rha Pli if a gue t tD ef ndant ,s ae eec
he nd, antfs r
ha
e
s t t l don ofii l,c nnotbe ha m ed by t
fcas a
r
he

is a c ofa i u ton p e e tnge o c me ofa u ons ui a lw. e Giva i
su n e n njnci r v n i nf r e nt n nc dt ton l a S e o n
Ca a doa Lt v. s n, 03F.d 5 7 5 ( . Ci. 0 2 . c oft s a g me t ha
z n l, d. Ba o 3 3 0 , 21 4t t 2 0 ) Ea h he e r u n s s
h
i nt es,
m e i,t rng t ' ouz t g egh t e publc i er t whi i t det - ni f c ori
rt equii he c t o r i h
w
ch s he et ng a t n
mi

t sc e. M ilrv. own,465F.Supp.2d a 596.
hi as ' le Br
'
t

3

O n ba a ,t c ztfndsas a t beappr it he e. ty c ipe s m a
l nce he olr i
ty o
opra e r Pa t har r ons y
be n t r tt i m e hodsf s l dng c ndi t sf t 2018 elc i i t dayslA s
gi o epor her t
or eec
a da e or he
e ton n wo
.
s h,a sa pe lng a
uc
t y nci ppea wilnndga et lkei
l l i t he i lhood ofconf i dutng t nomi ton
uson i he
na i

pr s . sa a s wila vi t any c e nsast w he he pa t c ipe s r eve
oce s A t y lo l ne a e
onc r
o
t r ry har r ons ec i d

n eofa un rtndteefc oft c ur'i unc n. e Re nod v. i , 7 U..
odc nd desa h fe t he o ts nj do S e
ls Sms3 7 S
5 3 5 5(9 4 (fna rl go wihhodngi caerl fac ur i e éte t a
3 , 8 1 6 ) T waci r t li mmel t ei , o t s n ld o nd
l
n
i
e
t d c i rt pr m iy ofa f t onlng eec i a t m e
houl onsde he oxi t
orhc i l ton nd he chani a com plxi
cs nd
e ées

o saeee to lws a s l a ta r l upo g ne a e uia l prncpls7
f tt lcin a , nd houd c nd ey n e rl q tb e i i e .
).
Ast Ease n D iti ofVig ni not d i M il rv. own,
he t r
srct
r i a e n le Br

( j sa pe i g a de ii fom t e Fo t Cic twilgve
A ty nd n
cson r h uth tui l i
Vigi as G e r lAs e bl tm e t c e plt a r m edil
r ni' ne a s m y i o ont m a e ny e
a
l g sai i beives t be a oprat and ens e is
e il ton t le
o
ppr i e
ur t
c or iy wih . . .t Fis A m e
onf nat t
he r t
ndm e . . .wihout t
nt
t
he
pr pe tofm odii a i l t rby ahi
os c
fc ton a e
gherc tde ii A s a
our c son. ty
wila s gve t St e Boa d of Elctons tm e t i plm e
l lo i he at
r
e i
i
o m e nt
ne pr dur t tm a ber quie a t c m uniat t e
w oce es ha y
e t d nd o om
c e hos
pr dur t t sa
oce es o he t kehol r i Vig ni ' poltc lpr es .
de s n r i as iia oc s
465 F.Supp.2d a 597.G i t ee
t
ven he lcéon de ii t tne d t be m a a e ry ast s
c sons ha e o
de s a l
hi
W edne da f t 2018 eeci c l t c tfndst tt publci e es i a di
s y or he
l ton yce, he our i
ha he
i nt r t n voi ng
c uson i t i penci nonana i pr es weghsi f vorofgr ndng a sa pe ng
onf i n he m
lng
i tng oc s i n a
a
ty ndi
a
ppea.
l
Fort s r as ,t cour wilGR AN T D ef nda s M oton f St y Pe ng
he e e ons he
t l
e nt ' i ot a ndi

Appea.
l
An a opza e Or rwilbe e e ed.
ppr i t de l
ntr

1l c ntatt ec siti aiyoft I u e Pr e to Ac h sbe n t s bjc o de t i
n o rs, h on tt t l
z on t he nc mb nt otcin t a e he u e t f bae n
Vigml' f r lcour sf t pas t yea s
r ' ' s ede a
a
t or he t en r .

4

Enee: a as= o r - o. /8
ttd
o

4 /- 4 2 /.W &-' '
*
*M iha F. ba ki
c el Ur ns

Che Unie S ae Ditit ud e '
if td tts src l g