Bright v. Berryhill

Filing 16

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/9/2018. (jv)

I TH E UN I D STATE 9D ISTRI CO U RT
N
TE
CT
FO R TH E W ESTE RN D I
STRI O F VIRG I I
CT
N A
H A RRI N BU RG D I SIO N
SO
VI

.:J S. ST,
(. DI COUR'
F
) ANOKE,
(
7
VA
,.gr
y .l
.

,

.
.

.

1t 2 1
) 2s

JOHN HARVEY BRI
GHT,

.

ë Dk (
. .
l

cjsax
-

Cas N o.5:7c
e
1 v00025

Pl ntf ,
ai if

N AN CY A.BERRYH I
LL,
Actng Com m i i
i
ss onerofSoci Securt
al
iy,

By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l

Ch e Un t d S a e Di ti t udge
i f ie t t s s rc J
D ef
endant
.
M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O

PlitfJ hn Ha v yBrg tfe t ss ils c rt a e l da o tieoft
an if o
r e ih i d hi oca e u iy pp a one y u sd he
l
s a ut ofl niatonsperod.Ac di y,t Com mi sone m ovest dinns t c eas
tt e i t i
r
i
cor ngl he
si r
o s i s he as

tm e ba r d.Pl ntf c
i - r e ai if once t li c pli wa fld one da afe t de dlne due t
des hat zs om ant s le
y t r he a i
o
couns lsove sght buthe a gue e t bl t lng prncpl s d be e e
e'
ri ,
r s quia e oli
i i es houl
xt nded i t sc s
n hi a e
and e
xcus t lt flng.
e he a e ii

Th smatrwa r fre t t eHo r bl J e C. pp , ie S ae Ma itae
i te s ee r d o h no a e o l Ho e Un td tts gst t

J g , ru ntt 2 U. C. 6 6 $() ,frpr posdfndng offc a a
ud e pu s a o 8 S. j 3 9 11) o o e i i s a t nd
rc
e omme e ds osto Th ma itaejd fe arpor r c e ig t ec r g a
nd d ip ii n. e g sr t u ge i d e t e omm ndn h ou t r nt
l

t eComn isone ' moto t d snist sa to a u i l. cma itaej g
h
asi rs in o ir s hi c in s ntmey Th gsr t ud e
r s d t t K r n va i y'e
ea one hat he t de ret ' xcus bl ne ectby couns ldoe notc tt e t t pe
ga
a e gl
e
s
onsiut he y

ofe ta d nayct u tnc st twoud war n e utbl r l f Btg to e t t t e
x ror i r ic msa e ha l ra t q ia e ei ih bjc s o h
e
m a ita ej g ' r p ta gzn t ma itaejd eer d b no f l wi t erzngi
g sr t ud es e or, r lig he gsrt u g re y t ol ng h ti n
o
l
S a l v. tu , 20 c 0 2 , 0 1W L 6 0 6 ( D . . . c 1 2 1, nd
tne Asr e No. :9 v 08 1 2 1
0 99 7 S. W Va De . , 01 ) a
a yng ejzt bl t lng.
ppli ctia e oli

Thi ca ei unlke St nl ,howe r Thepli ifi St nl fld hi cvi a i t
s s s i
a e
ve .
antf n a e ie s i l cton '
wo
da a t rt s a ut oflt t i ha t duet aperonnelis i vi apat l a
ys fe he t t e iniatons d un
o
s
s ue nvol ng
aeg l
who w a r ponsbl f flng t aci i f de alc t 2011W L 6009967, *1 The
s es
i e or ii he ton n e r our.
at .
c tde e r ned t tpli ifha m e hi bur n unde l wi v.D e a t entofVe e a
our t rni
ha antf d t s de
rr n
rm
t r ns

Afar, 8U..8 , 6( 9 0 , nde tbl he t a h h dpu s e h srg sdl e l a d
fis 49 S 9 9 1 9 ) a sa i d h t e a ru d i iht ig nt n
s
i y
exta di r cr s a ess ood i hi w a 2011W L 6009967,at* 3.Spe f l t
r or na y icum t nc t
n s y.
2cikal he
y,

cour r as
t e oned:<t tPli ipsc
<ha a ntf ouns lc it nty ilsi a tm ey m a rs
e onsse l ie n i l nne howst t
hat he
e ss r
vent ut oundi t sflng,t pa a e la pe s
ng hi ii he r l ga nd r onneltoubl oft Pli ifsc
r e he antf ' ouns l
e,
wer i f c exta di r cr um sa es' l a * TheSt nl c ta i eqtia e
e n a t t or na y ic tnc . d. t 3.
'
a e our ppled zt bl
t lng a de e t Comnas i rsm oton t din ist c pli a untm ey.I
oli nd ni d he
isone '
i o s as he om ant s i l d.
N o s h K r onne is ' e ssi Brghtsc s Rat r t lt flng i a ti a e
uc ç s
pe
l s ue? xit n i ' a e. hc , he a e ii s tlbut bl

t a ove sghton t pa' ofl lc
o n
ri
he t
t oca ouns l Ther i no diput t tt flng dea i f
e.
es
s c ha he ii
dlne ot

Brghtsf z lcom pli w a M a c 20,
i ' ede a
ant s r h 2017.N o.i t r a diput t tBrghtdi not
r s he e ny s e ha i
d
r ques a e e i fom t Appe l Counclbef e t tdea i expie
e
t n xt nson r
he
as
i or ha
dlne
r d.

Brg ' c m pant ssg e byl hn Os r eGos, me e o t ba oft i
ihts o li wa in d o
bo n
s a mb r f he r hs
cour ,a da ed M a c 1 20171- ti wa notfl i f de a c tuntlM a ch 21,201
t nd t
t h 4,
-ye t s
ied n e r l out - r
i
7,
t da a t rt s a- e ofl ia i ha r I awrte sa e entfl i conne ton
he y fe he t t
ut
i t tons d un. n
m
it n t t m
ied n
ci
wih t Com nasi rsm oton t dir s ,M r Gos a ist tt O lns La G r
t he
isone p
i o snis . s dnlt ha he i ky w oup,
a it pr ha vie i t sca e,s ntt c pli doc ent t hi on M a ch 14,2017,
dnlted o c c n hi s e he om ant um s o m
t
t dat t docum e sw e e s g d;how e r '
he e he
nt r i ne
ve , T t ove sght' he di notfl t
due o
ri y
?
d
ie he

c pli untlM a c 21 2017.
om a nt i r h ,

lThe c pli i daed M a c 1 2 , c i pli ya e r .
om a nt s t
r h 4, 016 whi h s anl n t or

2

Two da afe M r G os fl t com pli ,Br d M y e ,outofs ae couns lwho
ys t r . s ied he
ant a
lt - -tt
e
r pr ent Brghta t a i sr tvehe rng,r
e es ed i
t he dnnnita i
a i equesed a one da e e i f om t
t
- y xt nson r
he
Appe l Councl e ani t tBrghtsc e ha be n r f r e t a he fr f t
as
i, xpli ng ha i ' as d e e e r d o not r lm ot he
a ala c
ppe nd ouns lha fl t c
e d ied he ompli one da lt a ar s tofa c l tng e r .
ant
y a e s e ul
aenda i r or

TheAppe l Counc lde e M ylrst
as
i ni d
e ' eques,fndi no good ca e f e e ng at s e
t i ng
us or xt ndi
nis d
de i .
adlne

Fe r lc t a y e t bl t lng s rngl I wi v. e ' ofVe e a A far ,
de a our s ppl quia e oli pa i y. r n D t
t r ns fi s

49 U. 8 , 6 (9 0 . t a iain G tber s r e f t err i sa e wh r
8 S. 9 9 1 9 ) 1s ppl to <
c
mus e e v d or hos a e n tnc s e e
due t ct sancese e na t t pa t sown c
o icum t
xt r l o he ry'
onduc -- tw oul beunc cona e t
t i
d
ons i bl o

e o c t l ltto pei d a i tt epat a g os i u tc woudr s l. Harsv.
nf r e he i iai n ro gans h ry nd r s njsie l e u t' ri
n
'

Huthi o 2 9 F.d 3 5 3 0 (t Ci. 0 0 . utb et li p i i e f o no e e d t
c ns n, 0 3 2 , 3 4 h r 2 0 ) Eq ia l ol rncpls < t xtn o
ng
d
wha i a bes aga de vai yca m ofe us e negec ,'l wi 498 U . a 96 a t t
t s t t r n tet li
xc abl
l t' r n,
S. t
nd ha
i pt iey whatwe ha he e Pli ifatrbut li lt flng onl t an ç r i ' on t
s ecs l
ve r . antf ti es ls a e ii
yo
f sght' he
ove
pa tofl lc
r
oca ouns l Butc
e.
ouns ' m it ke i flng t c pl ntone da a t rt dea i
els sa n ii he om ai
y fe he dlne
ex r Ki
pied f
doesnotpt entt e r di r cr s a be
es he xtaor na y icum t nce yond t pa t ' c r whe e
he r ys ont ol r

e ut s ul se i 't c r c un e' er r Ro ev Le , 3 F.d 2 8 2 ( h Ci.
q iy ho d tp n' o u e o s l ro . us . e 3 9 3 3 , 48 4t r
:
s
2 0 )(uo i Ha rs 20 F.d 3 5 ; e t a t2 - 9 (olcigc s st a h vehed
0 3 q tng ri, 9 3 2 ) s e d a 484 c l tn a e h t a l
e
r sa b apat ' c unsl ni e ei asau eoflniai do sno j tf e ut be
nitke y rys o e i ntmr t
ng tt t i ttons e t usiy q ia l
t
t l g.
oln )
i
Pli ifa g hi ç ef r e 'c
antf r ues s f e r d' ouns ,t O l k La G r
pr
el he i y w oup, a t r d t
ns
w s equie o
a s it wih l a c
s oca e t oc l ouns t i ta et s pr ee ngsi f de a c t and t ss ehow
el o niit he e oc di n e r l our,
hi om

a nt t a e ta dnaycr u tn ej tfi ge utbl t lig To b s r , to n y
mou s o n x ror i r ic msa c usiyn q ia e o l . e u e at r e s
n

hkc M r O lns who a e notquaiid a lce ed t pr c ie undert lwsofVigi a
. i ky
r
lfe nd i ns o a tc
he a
r ni
m a a a onl i a s i ton wih am em be oft baroft sc t W . . G e R.
y ppc r y n s oc a i
t
r he
hi our. D Vk. n.

6() Not t tn i gpli ifsf e e e e 'a t c unsl Brg thie M r Gof t f e
d . wihsa d n antf' r fr nc s: s o o e, ih r d . f o i
pr
l
hi c
s ompli i t scas M r G of aci i doi s oneda afe t flng de i
ant n hi e. . fs tons n ng o
y t r he ii
adtne

e r a e a ti a et pli ifunde sa r a nc prncpl .Rous 339 F. a 249.
xpied r tzbut bl o a ntf
r tnda d ge y i i es
e,
3d t
The e i not ng exta di r a
r s hi
r ot na y boutt e cr um sa es
hes ic t nc .
Pli ifbea st bur n ofesa ihi exc ptona cr um sance t wa r nt
antf
t he de
t bls ng e i l ic t s hat r a

e ia et l g Gi v. r a t No 2:4 0 6 20 5W L 2 3 05 a + ( . Va
qutbl oln , bbs Banh r, . 0 CV0 05 , 0
i
8 2 , t 2 W D. .

Fe 7 2 05 qon s C.., ndheha fie t me tt tbu d n i t i c s . c s lw
b. , 0 ) e , J) a
s ald o e ha r e n l s a e The a e a
a
m a cea t te t bl t lng prncplsdo notext t c
kes l r ha quia e oli
i ie
end o ouns lsf iur t fl wihi
e ' al e o ie t n
t sat or lr ttonspe i duet ove sght Ac or ngl t c tm us dir s
he t ut y inia i
rod
o
r i . c di y, he our
t sni s

Brghtscom pli a untm ey.
i '
ant s i l
An a oprat or rwilbe e e e
ppt i e de l
nt r d.

ute: o t a ç / '- /F
ne d
r
/
zo
.

4/

-d mr'
r
'

.

* -'
Z-

M i ha lF.Ur ns '
c e
ba

Che Untd
if ie

t sDitit u r
e src l dg