Bright v. Berryhill
Filing
16
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/9/2018. (jv)
I TH E UN I D STATE 9D ISTRI CO U RT
N
TE
CT
FO R TH E W ESTE RN D I
STRI O F VIRG I I
CT
N A
H A RRI N BU RG D I SIO N
SO
VI
.:J S. ST,
(. DI COUR'
F
) ANOKE,
(
7
VA
,.gr
y .l
.
,
.
.
.
1t 2 1
) 2s
JOHN HARVEY BRI
GHT,
.
ë Dk (
. .
l
cjsax
-
Cas N o.5:7c
e
1 v00025
Pl ntf ,
ai if
N AN CY A.BERRYH I
LL,
Actng Com m i i
i
ss onerofSoci Securt
al
iy,
By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l
Ch e Un t d S a e Di ti t udge
i f ie t t s s rc J
D ef
endant
.
M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O
PlitfJ hn Ha v yBrg tfe t ss ils c rt a e l da o tieoft
an if o
r e ih i d hi oca e u iy pp a one y u sd he
l
s a ut ofl niatonsperod.Ac di y,t Com mi sone m ovest dinns t c eas
tt e i t i
r
i
cor ngl he
si r
o s i s he as
tm e ba r d.Pl ntf c
i - r e ai if once t li c pli wa fld one da afe t de dlne due t
des hat zs om ant s le
y t r he a i
o
couns lsove sght buthe a gue e t bl t lng prncpl s d be e e
e'
ri ,
r s quia e oli
i i es houl
xt nded i t sc s
n hi a e
and e
xcus t lt flng.
e he a e ii
Th smatrwa r fre t t eHo r bl J e C. pp , ie S ae Ma itae
i te s ee r d o h no a e o l Ho e Un td tts gst t
J g , ru ntt 2 U. C. 6 6 $() ,frpr posdfndng offc a a
ud e pu s a o 8 S. j 3 9 11) o o e i i s a t nd
rc
e omme e ds osto Th ma itaejd fe arpor r c e ig t ec r g a
nd d ip ii n. e g sr t u ge i d e t e omm ndn h ou t r nt
l
t eComn isone ' moto t d snist sa to a u i l. cma itaej g
h
asi rs in o ir s hi c in s ntmey Th gsr t ud e
r s d t t K r n va i y'e
ea one hat he t de ret ' xcus bl ne ectby couns ldoe notc tt e t t pe
ga
a e gl
e
s
onsiut he y
ofe ta d nayct u tnc st twoud war n e utbl r l f Btg to e t t t e
x ror i r ic msa e ha l ra t q ia e ei ih bjc s o h
e
m a ita ej g ' r p ta gzn t ma itaejd eer d b no f l wi t erzngi
g sr t ud es e or, r lig he gsrt u g re y t ol ng h ti n
o
l
S a l v. tu , 20 c 0 2 , 0 1W L 6 0 6 ( D . . . c 1 2 1, nd
tne Asr e No. :9 v 08 1 2 1
0 99 7 S. W Va De . , 01 ) a
a yng ejzt bl t lng.
ppli ctia e oli
Thi ca ei unlke St nl ,howe r Thepli ifi St nl fld hi cvi a i t
s s s i
a e
ve .
antf n a e ie s i l cton '
wo
da a t rt s a ut oflt t i ha t duet aperonnelis i vi apat l a
ys fe he t t e iniatons d un
o
s
s ue nvol ng
aeg l
who w a r ponsbl f flng t aci i f de alc t 2011W L 6009967, *1 The
s es
i e or ii he ton n e r our.
at .
c tde e r ned t tpli ifha m e hi bur n unde l wi v.D e a t entofVe e a
our t rni
ha antf d t s de
rr n
rm
t r ns
Afar, 8U..8 , 6( 9 0 , nde tbl he t a h h dpu s e h srg sdl e l a d
fis 49 S 9 9 1 9 ) a sa i d h t e a ru d i iht ig nt n
s
i y
exta di r cr s a ess ood i hi w a 2011W L 6009967,at* 3.Spe f l t
r or na y icum t nc t
n s y.
2cikal he
y,
cour r as
t e oned:
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?