O'Sullivan Films, Inc. v. Neaves

Filing 83

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 10/18/2018. (jv)

CL
ERK: OFFI U,S. ST
CE
AT ROANO DS . COURT
KE,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES D ISTRI CO U RT
CT
FO R TH E W E STE RN D I M CT O F W RGI I
ST
N A
H ARRI N BU RG D I SION
SO
W
O'
SULLI
VD

0CT 19 2 1
22
J
UL
BK

FI S, I C.
LM
N

Pl ntfy
ai if

.

D L&rGLERX

e

DE W CL '
PU
EQ<
Cas N o.5:7- 00031
e.
1 cv-

V.

DAW D N E AVE S,

By:

V c
haelF.U r
bansd
l

Cli fUit d St t sDiti tJ
ze
e a e stc udge
D ef
endant
.

M EM O RAN D U M O PI IO N
N

W he D e e ntD a d N e ve s a t d hi e pl m e wih Pl ndf O ' lva
n f nda
vi a s t re s m oy nt t ai f Suli n

Fi ,nc (f s lv n' h a re t al tdnon o t are nt(h
l I .T ul a ' e g ed o i e
ms
o' i l
mi
c mpee ge me te
T nc
f ompee' wih O'ul n. a e c c de t a h ha wilul v o ae t tr sof
No
t' t S lva Ne v s on e s h t e s lf l i ltd he e m
)
i
y
t N oncom pet buti it t t N oncom pe ei i ld unde Vig ni l w.O ' xl n
he
e,
nss s hat he
t s nvai
r ti a a
Slli
va
dia e a as t c tt e or t N onc
s gz es nd ks he our o nf ce he
ompet
e.
Thi m a t rc e bef et cour s ve a m odons O ' lva hasf e aM ot
s te om s or he
t e rl
. Suli n
ld
bn

f S mma yl d me thef s lv n Mod l ECF No. 0 Ne ve ha fldaMo n
or u r u g nt t f ul a
o' i
on',
5. a s sl
e
do

f Sl r u me Re adngteEnftebit oft No compee(hef a s
or l
mmayl dg nt g r i h
oc a ly he ni
t t f ve
Ne
Enf r e bit M o ' ECF No 5 a aModo f zSz r u me Re a dng
o c a l y éon),
i
. 4, nd
no l
mma yl dg nt g r i

Da g sth T a sDn g sModo ', No 5 . rt raonsd sdbe beo
ma e te f ve ma e
Ne
n) ECF . 5 Fo he e s ec d lw,
t O ' l n M ot wilbe GRAN TED i parta D EN I
he Suli
va
bn l
n
nd
ED i par ,t N ea
n
t he
ves
Enf c a lt M odon wilbe D EN I ,a t N e vesD a a M oéon wilbe
or e biiy
l
ED nd he a
m ges
l
GM N TED i par a D EN I D i pat .
n
t nd
E n
t

S
umm ayJ gm e Stndads
r ud nt a r
Pu s ntt Rul 5 () t c 'mu tf rntsp r j g nti t mo a
rua o e 6a,he out s f a l
t
g
mmay ud me f he v nt
s
howst tt r i no genui ciput a t a m a e ilf tand t m ova i e l d t
ha he e s
ne ls e s o ny t ra ac
he
nt s ndte o

j g n a amatroflm 'Fe R. v P. 6() CeotxCo . .Cart 47 U.. 7
ud me t s te a ' d. Ci. 5 a; l e
v teq 7 S 31 ,
3 2(9 6;G1n v.
2 1 8)
n EDO Co .71 F. 2 9 21 (t Ci. 01 )W h nma igti
r , 0 3d 0 , 3 4h r2 3. e kn hs
det m i éon,t colr s d consdq ft placi ,de i ,a we st
et na
he zt houl
i r <he e lngs posdons ns t o

i trog t re , nd a misonson fl,t ehe wih . .(n jafd vt'fldb t pn-e .
n e r ao is a d si
t og t r t . a y f a is' t y he tis
e
e
r
Ce ot x,477 U. a 322. he he a f cti m a e i lde ndson t r lva s t ndvelw .
l e
S. t
W t r a s t za pe
he ee nt ubsa
a

Andes v. bet Lo y l .4 7U.. 4 , 48(9 6.f ydsutso rfcsta
ron Li ry bb , nc, 7 S 2 2 2 1 8 ) f
onl ip e ve a t h t
rlghtafe t out om e oft s tunde t gove ni 1w wilpr ry pr cudet e t
ri
f ct he c
he ui
r he
t ng a
l ope l e l
he nty

ofs mmayj g ntFat a dsutst taeirlva o u c saywi n be
u r ud me . cu l ip e ha r ree nt r nne esr l ot
l
c ntd. L a(ia n o te )Themo i pat ber t i da bur nofd mo ta g
ou e ' d ctéo mitd .
'
vng ty as he ni l de
e nsrdn
t a e e ofagenui is ofm a e i f t Ce ot x,477 U. a 323.I t bur n ha
he bs nc
ne s ue
t ral ac . l e
S. t
f hat de s
be n m et t non- ovi pa t m us t n c e f war a esa ih t s i m a e l
e
, he
m ng zy
t he om or d nd tbls he pechc t da

fc si diput t s t i s mmayj g n . tu ht Elc I us Co. Ze ih Ra o
a t n s e o u vve u r ud me t Mas s a e . nd . v. nt di
CI P. 4 5U.. 7 ,5 6 7 ( 9 6 .
-.. 7 S 5 4 8 -8 1 8 )
J ,
I
.

I de et i ng whe he age pnei s ofm a e ilf c exit ,t cot viw st
n t m ni
t t nli s ue
t ta a t s s he ut e he
f t a cr w sa l ea ona ei e ence i t lghtm os f vor bl t t non- ovi
ac s nd la l r s bl nf r
s n he i
t a a e o he
m ng

pat . 1qn 71 F. a 21 (i gBo v. a iq 6 F.d 3 9, 8 (t Ci. 1 ).
zy . p , 0 3d t 3 cdn nds Le v t 29 3 6 3 0 4 h r 20 1)
G
I de d fiti a fx o t ti tln o amo n f rs mma yj g nt t ee i e c of
n e ,fj s n a i m ha n ql g n
g
i
do o u r ud me a h v d n e
t no va i t bebeive a alus ib ei e e e aet bedrwni hi fvo '
he nmo nt s o
l d, nd l j éfa l nfr nc s r o
e
a n s a n'
'

Mc dads I . Ki r -cl. Co .75 F.d 3 7 31 ( h Ci. 01 )( ena
Ai i nc v. mbel ak
r
, 6 3 0 , 0 4t r 2 4 i r l
nt

2

attdonomitd (i gToa v. ton 1 4S. . 8 1 1 6 (01 )@e c iml.
lea
te ) cdn ln Cot , 3 Ct1 6 , 8 3 2 4 r ura )
M o e ve ,f jel lt d tr na ns t eweg i oft e i nc , n t drwi g of
r o r Tcr cbi y ee mi do , h ihng he v de e a d he a n
l i i

lgtmaei ee e fom t fcsaejr fnc ns no t eo aj g . Andes n, 77
e i t nfrnc s r he a t r u y u do , t hos f ud e'
i
'
ro 4
U . a 255.
S. t
The non- ovi pa t m us,howe r f e f t s i f t t go be
m ng ty
t
ve , f t orh pechc ac s hat
s
yond

t T r e itnc ofasi iao ei nc .' l 7 0F.da 2 3(uod An ro
he mee xse e
cntl f vde e' G1 m, 1 3 t 1 q ng des n,
l
'
4 U.. t25 ) I ta t eno mo i gpa t mus s w t tThe ei s hce te de e
77 S a 2 . nse d, h n- v n ry t ho ha f t s uf in vi nc
t

fvo i gt non vngpat f rajr t r tr aveditf t tpa t ' s Ba hae
a rn he mo i ry o u y o e u n r c or ha rp'Re . nks r s

Co . StPa Mec I .Co.4 F.d6 , 35( hCi. 0 5 (uod And ron, 7
v. . ul r
ns , 07 3 31 6 4t r2 0 ) q ng es 4 7
U. a 2 )fn ohe wor ,t g a tsn r jd me t glur mus d tt net t
S. t 49.f t r ds o rn l
l
mmay u g nthe co t t eemi ha
noraona l j y c l fndfrteno vn pat o t e i nc beo ei. Mos v.
e s be ut oud i o h nmo ig ry n he vde e ft t' s
'
Pak Co .9 F.d 7 6 7 ( t Ci.1 3 (uod g Pei iCo . Pe i Consr I c,
rs
, 85 2 3 , 38 4h t 99 ) q n rn
v. rni t. n .
91 F.d 1 ,1 4 ( t Ci.1 9 ).
5 2 21 2 4 h r 9 0)
I
I. B ackgr
ound

The f c si t sc e a eundiput Pl i fO ' lva Fim s I i a m a a tle
a t n hi as r
s ed. andf Suli n l , nc. s
nuf c l t
t
ofar killat r wli i s l t t a om otve i ty,a ong ot cint .
df a e he , lch t els o he ut
i ndusr m
her le s

De ltdo ofRihadJ Ti (C lDel), No. 0Ex A, 1 O'ulva slso t$ 7
caa n
c r . l f l c. ECF 6 . ! . S l n el ve 1
l Ti
'
i
m ilon i n ffc a l t tpz
li n riii l ea he oduct a
s nnual a is:na iliw e % e i m a hi r
l nd t
y,
nca t s nt n c ne y,

e ui n , nd ta s c esi g e ttt n $ 0mii . a ! 5 O'll a sa omo l
q pme t a rde e r t s r ae ha 2 lon.. ! -6. Sli n' ut bi
l J
d
lv
e
busne si t t ed t m a a ut r i t U nied St t s M e co,and Canada. eposdon
i s s a get o nuf ct e s n he
t
a e , xi
D
i
ofSc tl ue r ECF N o.60 Ex. ,at10:-9,11:
ot c ge ,
B.
2
20.

De e a tD a d Ne ve wa hie b O'ul n i un 2 3a wor e O o h
fnd n vi a s s r d y S lva nl e 01 nd k d ug
i
D e m be 2016.N e vesft twor a aN e Pr
ce r
a
ts
ked s
w oduc D e l e Che s i Ar i l
t veopm nt mi t n dhca

3

Le te, ndt nwa pr motdt Ar kil ahe Fi R&D Ma a rTZ Del! 2 .
ah r a he s o e o df a Le t r l
m
n ge.
c. ! -3
Asar qut me ofhi e o me twih O'ulv n onl ne1 , 01 , a e e ee i o
e ie nt s mply n t S l a , u 7 2 3 Ne v s ntr d nt
i
aConfd n il nf r éon I ve n, nd No soiiain Ag e me t(hef r e n '
i e ta I o ma , n ndo a
n- l t t
c o r e n t f e me t),
Ag
ECF N o.60 Ex.C,wih O ' lva TheAgr e ent i l ng t N oncom pe e i
t Suli n.
e m , ncudi he
t, s

g ven dbyVignalw. z e nt!1 .
o ze
tii a Age me 9
Pa a a 8 oft Agt m entcont i t N onc pe e
r gr ph
he ee
ans he
om t :
For one ye a t r my em pl m e wih O' l n e ,et rvol n i or
at fe
oy nt t Suli
va nds ihe
unt tl
y

frcus,Ia re ta lwi not()sl atmptt sl o ass otesi
o a e ge h t l
l
a el te
,
o el r sit h t n
,
s li orpr vi ng pr
e lng
o di
oduct or s r i s i c pe bn wih t Busne s of
s
e vce n om dt
t he i s

O'ul n a t Re t td Co a t;o ()h l,fna il orot r s, n
S lva t he sdce ntcs t b ep i ncal
i
y
hewie a y
pe s or endt t c pet wih t Busnes of O ' lva by usng or
r on
y o om e t he
i s
Suli n
i
c a i t Re t t Cont t .
ont ctng he s dc ed
ac s

I ! 8 fk stce Co a t'i deme a :
d. .f e ti td ntc s's f d s
l
acaa a
tzl nd pot nda c t e s a s diti or , ve
e l usom z , gent , s rbut s
ndor , busne s
s
i s
pn' r , a pe s
tne s nd r ons or e
t
ndde t t dutng t t o yea s be or m y
s hao i he v
r
f e
e oy e wih O ' lva ends I ha d r t cont ctwih or t t I ha
mpl m nt t
Suli n
,
d iec
a
t
ha
d
i i e cont ct wih, i l ng i r t c a by s
nd r ct
a
t ncudi ndiec ont ct
uppot
dng or beng
i
rs
e ponsbl f t ac tes of ot r O ' zlvan empl
i e or he dvii
he Sll1
'
oyees who ha die
d t ct
cont ctwih t Resdc e A c
a
t he t t d count .
s

J Addii l t fBusnes ofO' l n'i def d a ft de l e ,
da
tonal he f i s
y,
Suli 's me s fhe veopm nt
va
m anuf cnli m a ke
a tng, r dng,a s l ofpl dc e i r d fl sc pounds s rdce r a e
nd ae
as ngnee e i
m om
,e
s elt d

t t sma ke,and ot busne st O' xlva enga i dltngmyempl e . J.
o hi r t
het i s hat Slli n
ges n ni
oym nt' .
'I
L

!2.
(
Furhe ,N e ve
t r a s

a k wldg gj a a r ed t tt e i or don i l ig t ie dt a
c no e ed nd g e gj ha h nf ma , ncudn he d n y nd
sze ofand t c a i otnadon att s Re ti t d Cont ct a sm ia
i
he ont ct nf v
he e sr c e
a s nd i lr
i or a
nf m don t t O ' nlva has obt i about ot r a t l a pot néa
ha
S'li n
nned
he c ua nd
e l

c t me s a nt,dsdbu o s v n r,b i e s pat r Li! a a y tme
uso z , ge s it t r , e do s usn s rne s sc t n i
c dt esO ' xlva sConhde lI ot don.
ons ut
Sll n'
i
nda nf vna

L a J . eAg e me dei sf
d ! 8 Th r e nt fne f
conhd néa I o ma 'a :
e l nf r don' s
4

a ki ofi or
ny nd nf madon t ti notknown by t ge t lpublc I i l
ha s
he ne a
i. t ncudesal
l
docz e sorie st tr lctwha Iha done wih,ort
lm nt
t m ha efe
t ve
t
houghta
bout t
, he
Conûde l I or adon ....Confde l I ot
nda nf m
i nda nf madon i l ,buti not
ncudes
s

l td t tc nia i f ma on (u h a f r z s ta s ce s i n i ,
i e o, e h c l n ot d s c s o mtl , r de e r t, t tons
mi
a
we
a dein) f nca i ov do (u h a p ojc ,ftc ss bu ges
nd sg s; i il nftna n sc s t edons o e at, d t,
na
a pa ) a b i s a ma ufc tn i o ma n (u h a plns
nd lns; nd usne s nd n a nlig nf r do s c s a ,
sz t gi , pz es es c pe
ta e es oc s , om déve a l es a lss a i o= a
nays , nd it nd nf
don a
bout

c t r, po e l c t me s ve o s a e o e s.AI Confd néa
usome s tnda uso r, nd r , nd mply e) I
ie l
l ot a i i r e e b t sA e m entr a dls ofhow i i l a ned b
nf - ton s ot ct d
m
hi
e
e r es
t s er
m e ordic os t m e
s l ed o .

I. 1
d! .

Fi l , tga 1 o teAg eme tprvi sf rbot i u d zl fa fe
nal Paa tph 2 f h re n o de o h njnc ve ei nd e
y
e
s f s d N ea vi at a pa toft A g e m e :
hidng houl
ves ol e ny r
he t e nt

la ret a t rme e a i bl a lw frbrah ofmy o l do un t
ge h t he e dis val e t a o ec
a
bka ns de
t s Agr m e m a be i de t a t O ' lva wilne d i m edit
hi
ee nt y
na qua e nd hat Suli n l e m
ae
r ift pr e isrght unde t sAgr m ent Ia e t t i addi t a
ele o ot ct t i s
r hi
ee
. gz e ha , n
don o ny
rght and r m e e a ia e t O ' lva a lw or i e t ,t m poz r a
i s
e di s va lbl o Suli n t a
n quiy e
a y nd

pema e ti un d rl fma be g a e i a y pr e cng b ou htt
r n n nj c ve ei
e y
tntd n n oc el r g o
i
e ot m y oblgaéons unde t s Agr e e ,wihout t ne t pt
nf ce
i
r hi
e m nt t
he ed o ove
a ua da a .I a e t tI wilbe r ponsbl f ala t ne 'f s cos s
ct l m ge gr e ha
l
es
i e ot l tor ys ee , t,
a e
nd xpens i ut ed by O ' xl n by r as of a ac
es nc r
Slli
va
e on
ny don r ldng t tls
ea
o li
Agr m e ,and t O ' l n wilbe e ld t s h a éona r left ta
ee nt
hat Suli
va l
néte o uc ddi l ei ha
cout dee sa opra e.
' m ppr i t
t
'

I. 1
d ! 2.
I N e ves va i postons her ed O ' pl n' n-l a l t r D eposdon of
n a ' rous ii , eO
Slli s tiki l ea he .
va
r
i

Da i Neve rNeve De ', No 6 Ex. 5 :4- 7. a e as ha
vd a s f a s p.)ECF . 0 D, 01 1 Nev s lo d
'
ma g me r s nsblt o rmo ej i n-f a lahe r s a c a d veop n
na e nt e po i i y ve r unor ti le t r e e r h nd e l me t
i
rki
e pl s 1 68: 4-65: Acc di t O ' lva a notdiput by N e ve :
m oyee . d. 1
7. or ng o Suli n, nd
s ed
a s
N e ve ha ac es t t c m i lf m ulsus by O ' l n f isa dhca
a s d c s o he he ca or a ed
Suli
va or t t il
lat r consanty r i d O ' xl n' a dfc a l t
e he ,
t l efne
Sll1 s r ii l ea her pr
'
va
oduc s a
t , nd
pe f m e hi ow n t s i a s r ed t dng ofO ' llva s pr
r or d s
e tng nd upe ds es
Sll1 n' oduc s t
'
t o

i o pe f = a e Ne v s De 2 : -1 . He ma a us e s t
mpr ve ro nc . a e p. 811 4
de dj % nt o
f v za
otntldonsf cze s N e ve D ep.34: -35: and dr t i t cdonsa
or nt , a s
20 4,
afed nsru
nd
t e g plnsf li s
es
a or ls uborlna es N ea D e 39:
ci t . ves p. 8-11.

5

O'ul a MS Br 9
S lv n J . .
i
N e vesa it t tt a om odve c pani hew or d a c
a
dm ted ha he ut
om
es
ke nd omm unia e wih
c td t

wh l a O'u l ni lde Te l,Ge rlMo o s(GM' a Ch y lr Ne ve De
ie t S lva ncu d sa nea t r f ) nd r se . a s p.
i
<
59:-5.I pa dcaa ,N e ve ha prm a y r ponsbiiy f O ' lva sa tm ptt wi a
1
n r llr a s d i r es
i lt or Suli n' te
o n

GM p oe tna dPI
z jc me NKAD.t 1 921 1 :. dion l , a st o hO'llva ,
L. 0 : -1 03 Ad t al Neve,htug Sll n
l
a
i y
i
wor a as onta orf For on c rti a t ill t rpr t. da79: Unde
ked s ubc 'tct or d
e an rfca eahe oducs L
5-7.
r
Pa a r ph 8 oft Agr m ent Tesa GM ,Chr lr a For a e fkesrc ed Cont c s't
rga
he ee
, l,
yse , nd d r f tit
l
a t' o
whih t N onc pet a i .
c he
om e pples

OnDe e r1 , 01 , a stsg dhiposd a O'ulva O'ul nMS
c mbe 2 2 6 Neve eine s ion t S l n. S lva J
i
i
Br 1 H ei or e O ' l n t the had a ce e aposton asD ie orofRes r a
. 2. nf m d Suli
va ha
c pt d
ii
t ct
ea ch nd

De l pme wil no ryUnio a Glba En i e i , nc tun t a'. d Unr y l
veo nt tl npa t r y l o l gne rng I . f ioy ll L a io a
f
'
as m anuf ct esa tfc a l t rf t a om odvei
lo
a ur riii l ea he or he ut
ndusr a ass h, sa diec
ty, nd, uc i
r t

c
ompett ofO' lva L D e i O ' zl n Fim sBya Tht
ior
Suli n. i; posdon Stli
va l
nd ough IsDe i ed
t sgnat

Re r sna eS otI u g rrf s lv n 3 q 6 De ', No. 0Ex. a 1 :5 2
p ee tdv c t c e e o'ul a 0 $() p.)ECF 6
i
'
B, t 61 -2 9
Unioya 2017 1 1 Annua Re t ECF N o.60 Ex.K.1 par tl ,Unioya' t lr t
r l
0-<
l por,
1 dczar
r ls wo a ges
ci sa eFot and G M .LitofGl lOEM SSe ve U nioya G l lEng ne r
lent r
d
s
oba
r d, r l oba
i e ed

Pr du ty a uay2 7 ECF No. 0Ex J a 1 .
o csl n r 01 ,
6 . , t -2

Neve ha be nhevl ivov di tePI
a s s e ai n le n h NKAD p ojc frUnioyl t sme
y
r e t o r a- he a
pr jc f wb c hehedprma yr s nsbl ya O'llva D e. Ans r P1s
oe t or ih
l i t e po i it t Sxi n. f' we s .
i
l
s
'
I e r . ECF N o.60 Ex.L,a N o.7.M or ove ,a e als st twhie a Unioya,
nt r ogs,
t
e r n m i how ha
l t r l

N e ve hasha c a wih Chrs H cks ii c ac wih GM a O ' va Em a lfom
a s
d ont ct t
idna
, ls ont t t
t Suzi n.
i r

6

D .N ea st C.JIc dat Se e be 27,2017,ECF N o.60 Ex.N .N e ve as pe f m s
ve o
' ks ed pt m r
i
a s lo r or
s e wor a Unioya f For O ' lva M ot Br 1
om
k t r l or d. Suli n
. . 3.
11 .
1

Enf ceabiiy oft N oncom pet
or
lt
he
e

Thepa de ha sl d duei m odonson t enf c a lt oft N oncom pe e. s
r s ve e
lng
he ot e biiy he
t A

dicus e bel t cout f dst tt N onc pet com por swih Vig ni 1w a i
s s d ow, he
t m ha he
om e
t t t i a a nd s
f l e or a e.
ul nf ce bl
y
A.

I Vig ni f esrcdve cove sa edifvor r s r i son ta y'and a s t
n r i a, f ti
r
nant r s a ed e tnnt
t de'
s uch, he
vai t ofanonc pe ei at es d quesi See Om ni 1x W ord Se vs Co . U.
ldiy
om t s hr hol
ton.
e
l r .
v. S.

I ve ; a Se .I .2 0Va 2 6 2 ,6 8S. 2d3 , 4 (0 ) W h t e a
n s dons ws nc, 7 . 4 , 49 1 E. 40 3 2 2 05. e h r
de e ntbt a
f nda
e ched anoncom pe e be om esm ooti t nonc pe ei iw ai a
t c
f he
om t s t ld nd
une or a e.Se H om ePar m ountPe tContolCos v.Sha f r 28 Va 41 420,718
nf ce bl e
a
s
r
.
f e , 2 . 2,

S. 2d7 2 7 6(01 )(f cus weha f ndtectutc u tddnoteri nxigt
E. 6 , 6 2 1 f a e
Be
ve ou h ic i o r i
r n l he
n
Pr son une or a e H om ePa a ountse denceofShafe ' ac' br ac wasnot
ovii
nf ce bl,
tm
' vi
f ts t
ual e h

rlv n ).
ee a t'
The Supr m e CourtofVigi aha i % ct courst e or e nonc pe e
e
r ni s ns
ed
t o nf c
om t

a e m e sonl fft c r c i na r y dt wn t pz e tt e pl rsl g tm at
gr e nt y f he onta t s r owl a o ot c he m oye ' e ii e
i
busne si e es,i notundul bur ns e on t e pl e' a lt t e r a l ng,a i
i s ntr t s
y de om
he m oye s biiy o a n i
vi
nd s

no a ans pu i pol p'Omni1xW o l S r s, 7 Va a 2 9 61 SE.d a 3 .flhe
t g i t bl i '
c c
e rd e v .2 0 . t 4 , 8 . 2 t 42 frl
e pl rbe st bur n ofpr a a a bi ii i t c t twilbecons m ed i
m oye ar he de
oof nd ny m gutes n he ontac l
t
n
fvoroft e pl .'I
a
he m oyee' d.

7

No t ls, c r cnno a j iaet e orebit ofano o t i a
nehee sa ou t a t dudc t he nf ca ly
i
nc mpee n
f ct lva ulm . s ut nceD at l v. a e c 286 Va 1 144,747 S. 2d 804,8
a ua c l A s a
a nc. M l va ,
. 37,
E.
08

( 1 ) A c zts oud f onsde t efu don g o rphi s o , nddu a n' lme sof
20 3 . ot h l f i t h f nc , e g a c c pe a
r
c
r do ee nt
t r ti don.'H om ePa am ountPe tContol 28 V a a 415 6,718 S. 2d a 76
he esrc
'
r
s
r , 2 . t -1
E. t 4

( odn Smmo v. l r 2 Va 5 ,5 1 5 SE. 66 , 7 (0 ).vh s ee nt
qu g i ns Mie, 61 . 61 8 , 44 . 2d 6 6 8 2 01) T ee lme s
l
aefonsdee tg t r rt rta <stle sp rt a ds tis e .' d.q dng
r c i rd o ehe'ahe h n a lre e aae nd idnc su s' I (uo
'
Smmons 26 Va a 5 1 5 4 SE.d a 6 ) Ass h, sngefco t tma beo he wie
i
, 1 . t 8 , 4 . 2 t 78. uc a i l a t r ha y t r s
unr s bl c d be fr s bl a c t d i lghtoft ot r > 0. Ca ol I v.
ea ona e oul
fea ona e s onsrue n i
he he
' nt , nc.
:

Mc ne, 2:6 6 2 06W. 1 39 2 a * ( D. . t 2 , 0
Da ilNo. 0 CV8 , 0
L 21 9 , t 4 E. Va Ap . 8 20 $.
Th fmc n ee nte pi swhe h rt eno ompeef e t ts c mpe n b
e t do lme xa ne
t e h nc
t f sdc g) o ddo y
r
de e milng whet rt pr bie a t i oft s m e t ast tac ual e ge i by
t r ri
he he ohi t d cdviy s he a ype ha t ly nga d n
t f m e e pl r' H om ePa a ountPe tCont ol 28 V a a 416 718 S. 2d a 764.
he or r m oye .'
rm
s
r , 2 .t ,
E. t

dyj l pr vsonspr hbi (ne l y efo e a i gi a t te t a a t al o
f ai o ii
d
o i t a mp o e r m ng gn n ci is h t c u l r
vi
y
pot ntal c pe ewih t e pl ' f - re pl r' 1 a 417,718 S. 2d a 765
e ily om t t he m oyees ot
me m oye .' d. t
'
E. t

(uo g Omn lx, 7 Va a 2 9 6 8SE. a 3 ) W he anon o t f e kst
q én
i e 2 0 . t 4 , 1 . 2d t 42 . n
c mpee f e o
s
p olb tg)f r e e o e fo wot i f rg f r re o e ')c mpe t si a
r z i a o m r mply eq r m
i
kng o t o me mply rs o d or n ny
he

c p ct,ghef me e l y r mus p o algtmaeb i s i ee tf rdongs . I a
a a iy t ot r mp o eq t r ve e ii t usne s ntr s o i o' d. t
'
41
7-18,718 S. 2d at765.
E.

frl eg o rphcs o ofac ve n nott c mpe emus ber a o bl l t d'
fl h e g a
c pe
o na t o o t
t e s na y i e .
mi '
Spe i lyM a kedng,I v.La e e, o.CL09000928- 8 V a Ci.
c at
r
nc.
wr nc N
00, 0 . r 214,201 W L
0

7 75 1 , t* ( . r Ct Ma . 1 2 0 . e h ls ,hea e c o ag o rpli
3 6 6 a 3 Va Ci. . r 1 , 01 ) Non t ee s t bs n e f e g a lc
lm ia
i t éon i notf t l Se Pr f r ed S s Sol.I .v.GP Conszén LLC,284V a 382,39
s
a a. e e e t
. s nc
tl
.
4,

8

73 SE. 6 , 8 (01 )(Thelc ofas cûcg oga cl ttoni n ftlt t
2 . 2d 76 6 2 2 2 f a k
f
pei e rphi i ai s ot aa o he
mi
c ve n be a et no ompeeca ei s n ro ydtwnt t spntcz rp oe ta
o na t cus he nc
t lus s o arwl a o hi titl r jc nd
a
t ha u ofc mpa e i d r c c mpe n wihPS ' ; anwa e l . Ma n, 0
he ndf l o nis n ie t o ddo t S.) Bri r , nc v. ha 8 8
'

F. u 2 8 0 8 ( D. . 01 )rf t u htea e eofag o tp c li tdo
S pp. d 2 , 27 E. Va 2 1 Alho g h bsnc
e g a hia l a n
mi
m us be consde e i e l
t
i z d n va uadng whe he anon- om pe e pr son i e oz a e t l c
t z
c
t ovii s nf ce bl, he a k

o s h al td do sn ,nisl, e de t n - omp t pz vii n un nf c a e'
f uc i a on e oti tef r n r he on c e e o so e or e bl.
mi
l;
fi M a ch I 'Co . Anae Co .No.(1r nTe ntl
.
v. lx
,
2,2008- 45,75Va Ci.35 2009W L
58
. r 4,

6 5 9 7 a * ( Ci. .uy1 , 0 )( ngta fhelc o ag o rplia l tdo
7 9 6 , t 2 Vk. t CtJ l 8 20 8 noé h tf ak f e ga lcli a n
t
mi
i noti is l f t l' butiw aldadng t nonc pe ebec us i Tc a nsno lm ia
s
n te f a a ,
'
t i
he
om t
a e t font i
i t dons'at
'

a1; s eSr t ' Re I . Ne n, 10 CV9 2 GCC) 2 0 WL 3 4 9 ,a *
l but e tae c s nc v. vi No. :5 9
)
,05
1 3 41 t 3
( D. . v. 3 2 5 ( epr f re S se S ut c s f l g t tano omp t
E. Va No 2 , 00 ) pr - e er d tms ol i a e i i ha
ons
nc n
nc e e
t tdi noth veag o r pùcl té wa pe s u e s na e. nse d c utsf t
ha d
a
e g a l i a on s r e nr a o bl) I ta , o ' f
mi
t mus
c i t t rt i e d f i oft a e m enta isdlr don a w elaswhe he
onsder oge he he nt nde uncton
he gr e
nd t za
s l
t r
i c ansageogt pli lm ia
t ont i
a ac i t don.'M a ke * es l ',I v.KM D M e a LLC,72 V a
' t t Acc s ntl nc.
di,
.

Ci. 5 2 0 R 3 75 35 a * ( Ci. . c 1 2 0 )
r 35 , 0 6
7 9 , t 3 Vk. t Ct De . 4, 0 6 .
B.

N e ve a guest tt N oncom pet f ist oft t e ee e si t r quied
a sr
ha he
e a l wo
he hr e lm nt n he e r
nonc
ompet a l i:fm c
e nayss t éona l ia
l i t donsa t geogr pli s ope.
m
nd he
a lc c l

1N e ve doe nott kei s wih t N onc pe e sone y ard a nordoe t c tpe c i a l ga is swil
a s s
a s ue t he
om t ' - e uz don,
s he om r eve ny e l s ue tz

t d rd n S ePrfre S sS l.2 4Va a 3 4 7 2SE.da 6 1(odn ta ao ey a no o eewa
he u a o . e eerd . os, 8 .t 9 , 3 . 2 t 8 h lig h t n e r nc mp t s
f arwl da '; a etf& Co v. 'cNo. 81 1, 7Va Ci. 7 2 0 WL 8 0 0 0 a * (k Ci. .
f ro y rwn' Trd saf . No e, CL0 -5 2 7 . z7 , 0 8
n
)
2 1 5 ,t 3 7 . rCt
S p. , 0 8 tvi ii c urswi tpcl e oc c v n nso u t t y as. .'; v e v. si G .Lt.
e t4 2 0 ) f r na o t l y ial nfre o e a t f p o wo er . . Den w Ra h
r g
l
y
'
)
d,
No CH0 - 1 3 7 Va Ci. 3 , 0 6WL 6 4 7 2 a * ( . rCtDe. 9 2 0 )t dn at -e re
. 53 7 , 5 . r4 6 2 0
3 5 3 , t 7 Va Ci. . c 2 , 0 6 Xllg woy a t=
'
zao a l)Moe v ras re dua o cnifr t rao be e s teg o rp i so a d6lc o
e sn be. ro e, ho tr t d n a nom he esna ln s ofh e ga hc c pe n n d n
c
ompone sofanonc t.Se Ad nc dM a.Ent s. nc v.
nt
ompee e va e r er.I . PRC.nc,25 Va 106 119 5 S. 2 1 1
I . 6 . , , 01 E.d 4% 55-56

(9 8.
19)
9

FunctonalLi iatons
i
m t i

N e ve c endst tt f
a s ont
ha he uncdona lm ia
l i t donsi t N oncom pet a e ove br
n he
et
r oad.I
n
pn tc a ,N ea a gue t whie he wor d onl a ache s f O ' l n,t
riul r
ves r s hat l
ke
y s
mi t or Suli
va he

N oncom pe e f ol t a m uch br rr nge ofa tes he s l notTel a tm ptt s l,
t f ùbis
pr
oade a
cdvii : hal
s l, te
o el

orasitot r i s li otpr vi ng pr
ss he s n elng
o di
oduc s otf p,hnancal orot r s ,any pe s
t ' hel
il
y
he wie
r on

o e iyt c
r ntt o ompee wih O'ul n. De'. e La S pp. o . u J Re r n
t' t S lva ' fs M m. w u M t S mm. . gadig
i '

Enf c a iiyNo compeerNeve Enfre blyMotBr? ECF No. 3 a 7(uo g
orebl
t nt f a s o ca it
i
. .
),
6 , t q dn
Ag eme !8)
te nt ..
N e ve m anl t is wih t l
a s i y akes s ue t he angua hepor r ysa t s cond ca eoft
ge
ta s he e
lus
he

No o t :fep,fn n il o o he wie a ype s o e yt c e e'L a a e
nc mpee f l i a cal r t r s, n ron r ndt o omp t. d Ne v s
h
y
'
c m st tt s cond ca e f d c ra m anne ofT p' s e pi t foor ,
bi ha hç e
lus f
coul ove ny
r hel v w e ng he l s

wor ng i t a oundng de r m e ,m ant ni t pl ntf cH es pr vi ng l l
ki n he cc
pa t nt i ai ng he a a i , o di ega
s r i e ,s ocl t e pl e kic n,i a éon t beng achenls . I
e v c s t dng he m oye t he n ddi
o i
it' d.
'

Neve woudh vet sc r a pl teta trts7 T faca ei s br a a t
a s l a hi ou t p y h j nio et' f lus s o o d s o
:l
pr bi w or iw ol ng e pti tas f acom pe ior s l a t y di notwor asa
ohi t k t vi m y ng z h or
tt - o ong s he d
k

jzio a t ipro jb- t nt ca s i u nfre bea voda amatroflm 'I .
altr t her ir o he he lu e s ne o ca l nd i s te a ' d

a 8(iigRot- eCo. Le sr 8 9F. u 1 5 1 20( . Va 1 9 .
t ctn o Di v. se, 9 S pp. 51 , 5 W D. . 9 $)
N ot y,howe ,N e vesr adsoutquaiyng l ngua i t N onc pet ,whi h
abl
ver a
e
lfi a
ge n he
om e
c
lngua r dsi 6:1
a
ge ea n 1:

I wilnot ()s l a tmpt t s l o a ss ot r i s lng or p o il g
l
a el te
,
o el r sit he s n el
,
i
r vci
n
pr
oduc s or s rdce i c pe
t
e
s n om ddon wih t Busnes of O ' alva a t
t he
i s
Sll1 n t he
'

Retitd Cona t; $)hep,f ncal o ohewie a pe sn ore dt
stce
tcs or
l ma il r t r s, ny ro
y
n y
t c pe e wih t Busne s of O ' lva by usng or c a dng t
o om t
t he
i s
Suli n
i
ont c
he
Resdct d Cont ct .
t e
a s

1
0

Ag e me !8.
t e nt

Theo yra o bewa t ra pat()i s ta t pl s f usn o c ntcig
nl e s na l y o e d r b s o h the uae %y ig r o atn
t Re t t d Cont c s'm odi fhe p,fna i l orot wi e'Thephz s f usng or
he s dc e
a t'
hes f l i nc al
y
her s .'
ae f
by i
c a dng t Resrc e Cont t ' doe notm a s ei i m odi sfa pe s orenét
ont c
he ti t d
ac s' s
ke ens f t
he fny t on
y

t c pe ewih t Busnes ofO ' l n.'Cons que l t onl wa t N e ve coul
o om t t he i s
Suli '
va
e nty, he y y hat a s
d

volt p t ()i byusn o c a én t Re titd Co a t t hep a he e y
i ae a t b s
ig r ontc g he stce ntcs o l not r ndt
c pe ewih t Busnes ofO ' xlva
om t t he i s
Slli n.

Tli i e ea n dee t Ne ve ' ppe l o ajrt zt s. c ut h i d f z
ls ntmz tdo f as a s a a t az o e t The o t nds t if l
i
klt

t i gnea yse ai i whc ajnio wo dbec ntc gt Re t tdContcsa
o ma i n c n ro n ih a tr ul o a én he sdce
at nd
tyi t c pe ewih O ' lva unl s asO ' lva a l sa es fs e pl e w e e
t ng o om t t Suli n es ,
Suli n pty t t , fuch m oym nt t
a s m efor t obs ediec com pe
ha
f t o cur t t
ddon, li t ca ew otl pr ve .' .sM e .
w lch he lus
zd e nt' P1' m

Opp. fsMot S1 J Re a cngEnf c a l yNo co e e ECF No. 7 a 1 .
De .
' .1
mm. . g rl
i
or e bit n- mp t,
i
6 ,t 0
I t d,t c thol t tt N onc pet i na r y t l e s t tN e vesi onl
nsea he our ds ha he
om e s t owl aior d o ha a
s y

prcud dfo e a igi e o me wh r h ()wor i afedt tsdrcl
el e r m ng gn n mply nt ee e 1 ksn il ha i iety
c mpe dv wih O'ulv n a d () f test te o me b e pli gli tléo lp
o d e t S l a , n 2 urh t ha mply nt y x oe ls ea nsl
i
i
wih O ' llva scEe s
t Slli n' nt .

Smi ry Neve tk sis wihteT sidn ohes'a g a eofpat()Liewih.
i l l, a s a e sue t h f ss g t r'ln u g
a
a
r a. k t .
lsagu nta utpat()oft Nonc mpee Neve cnmsta pa ta p ohbt hm
a r me bo z b he
i
o t, a s li h t r () z iis i
fom w or ng i t a tfc a l t rc
r
ki n he r iii l eahe apact e n i i e l N e ve Enf c a lt M ot
iy ve nd r cty. a s
or e biiy
.

Br 8 (uo g Ho Paa nt 2 2Va a 41 , 8S. 2da 7 5 . ta nn, a sr a s
. q dn me rmou , 8 . t 8 71 E. t 6 ) Bu g i Ne ve e d
outt quaiyng lngua f t t Busnes ofO ' l n a t Resrc e Cont c s'
he lf i a
ge f h he i s
wi
Suli
va t he ti t d
a t.
'

No higi pat()o t No o t p e e t Ne ve fo wo kngi t ea dfca
t n n r a f he nc mpee r v n s a s r m t i n h r iil

11

l t ri ty - ven i r l
eahe ndusr --e
n eadon t t a om obiei
o he ut
l ndus r - a l asli wor i not
ty s ong ls
ks

r a e t t Resrct d Cont ct,whih t e dences
elt d o he ti e
a s
c he vi
howsi lm ie t as l tgt of
s i t d o eec oup
a om obie m a a t r t .
ut
l nuf c u e s
I s ,t cout hol t tt f dona lmiaéonsi t N onc pe e ded as
n um he
t ds ha he unc
li t
n he
om t ,

t y a e t t Restct Cont ct,ar narowl t iot d t pz ec t lgii at busnes
he r o he ti ed
a s e r y al e o ot t he e tm e i s
i e es sofO ' l n.
nt r t
Suli
va

2.

Geogr
apM c Scope

N ea alo com pli a
ves s
a ns boutt lck ofgeogr pli s
he a
a nc copei t N onc pe e
n he
om t .

Ne v s a g me tditl do t on s ntnc :r ' lc ofa yg og a cs o i (h
a e ' t u n sis wn o e e e e f he a k n e rphi c pe n t e
l
l
Nonc mpe e, c e tnd t p a e aou t wordwhe eO'e v n ha no lgtmae
o tj whih x e s o lc s r nd he l
r S a s e ii t
busne spur e i s
i s
pos n uppr s i com petdon,r nder i ove br d a une or ea e.
e sng
i
e s t r oa nd nf c bl '
'
N ea Enf ce biiyM ot Br 6.
ves oz a lt
. .

O fcour e t a e ofgeogt phi s
s , he bs nce
a c copei t N onc pe ei notdiposdve.
n he
om t s
s i
Se Br i a e,808F.Supp.2d a 8279 ef r e Sys Sol. 284 Va.a 394,732 S. 2d a
e nnw r
t
Pr e r d . s,
t
E. t

682.Br nwa e,I v.M a n i i t tve.I Br nwa e t cour f
ai r nc.
ha s nsruc i n ai r , he
t ound anoncom pe e
t
t tci notc ai age z pli l iadon wassilvai Br i r wasa s alcom pa i
ha ld
ont n
og a lc i t
m
tl ld. anwa e
m l
ny n
anihem a ketwih agl lz a The c pe busne sa w li t f m e e pl
c
z
t
oba e ch.
om dng i s t ach he or r m oyee

wo ke wa a ot rmao ply ri t ts l nihemak tThen o t' fnc ona
z d s n he jr a e n ha mal c
,
re.
onc mpees u d l
l iadonswe e na r y t or d.
i t
m
r r owl o e

A sdic s d i t ba gr
s us e n he ck ound s don,O ' l n i i m uc t s m eposdon a
ec
Suli s n
va
h he a
i
s
wasBr i e.O ' lvan com pet i ali 'y s ilze nihem a ket n fca lat r
anwar
Suli
es n zgll pecai d c
z
z : e iil e he .
Though t m ar ti s al O ' lvan hasagl lr ac U nioya com pe eswih
he
ke s m l, Suli
oba e h. r l
t
t

12

O'ulv nt wi t smecint frt smep ojcsAn t c ur ha ara yh l t t
S l a o n he a l s o he a r et. d he o t s led ed ha
i
e
t N onc pe esf
he
om t ' uncdona l iat a e narowl dr wn t pr ec O ' ll n a i t
l i t bns r
m
r y a o ot t Slli
va gans
N ea diec l c pe i wih O ' lva a t Restct d Cont ct . kei Br i e t
ves r ty om tng t Suli n t he ti e
a s Li n anFar , he
c thol t t lck ofgeogr phi s
our ds hat he a
a c copei notf t lgi n t cr um s rbe s ope of
s
a a ve he ic c i d c
t f dona lm ia a t z s bl one ye rdt don.
he unc
l i t don nd he ea ona e - a ua
The fve c esN e ve ct do notdit t adif r ntout om e.Fhes c esa e et r
i as
a s ies
c a e fe e
c
' e as r ihe
ditngu s bl orabr ed byPr f r ed S s e sSol
si iha e
ogat
ee r
tm
udons i whih t Vigila S e e
,n
c he t ti upr m

Cour hed t t flc ofa s c hcge a lc lm ia
t l hat he fa k
pe i
ogr pli i tdon'wasnotf al he e a
'
at w r

n c mpeewa f ar wl drwnt ()pad ua p oeta dteha f ofc mpa e i
on o t s f ro y a o a r c lr r jc n h ndul o nis n
n
diec com pe
r t
ddon wih' t e pl r 284 Va.a 394,732 S. 2d a 68 SeeA lt
t ' he m oye .
t
E. t 2.
son

S i I . Ll dV. e s& Aso s, 2F.d2 9 28 (t Ci. 9 4 (r- eerb
mdos nc v. o
Grs
s c.49 2 7 , 3 4h r 1 7 ) p epr fre
S sem sSol
t
udonsca e fndi nonc pet i ld bec us offislm ils ge a lc
s i ng
om e nvai
a e ft i te s ogr pli

a pl ai n, nd t br a e ompa s ntofa d i si whih g e o e jwa n
p i to a oo- o d nc
c
sme
c v ée n c t mply e s ot
he
e g ge ' Powe Dit uto l c v. e e c Po rEn ' I . 5 9F. up 5 5
n a d);
r sdb in n . Em r n
we
nc, 6 S p. 4, 8

( D. . 9 3 (r - eerdS se S u sc s û i lc pfg o rp cl tto
E. Va 1 8 ) p eprfre tms oldon ae ndng a k e ga hi i ain
mi

pe s unra o be; i
r e e s na l) Smmonsv. l r26 Va 5 , 8 , 4 S. 2 6 6 6 ( 1 )@tMie, 1 . 61 5 /' 4 E.d 6 , 78 20 1 e
l
5
Pr e z d S se sSol i ca e f di noncom pe ei ld be us ofTtz lngt
ef ê e
tm
utons s m ng
t nva i ca e fle e h
dut éon oft r ti
a
he estcéon,t e nson ofr s tc ed f
he xpa i
e ti t uncdons a t l c ofge a ca
, nd he a k
ogt phi l

l tdon'; w lie M e i G
i a ) Ne tv r da
mi

I . 1 1ht n, 45Va 3 7 37 , 2 SE.d 2 , 6
nc v.*1 o 2
.6, 049 . 2 52

(99 )( ho dngno ompeewih g og a i s opel td t a e ss r e b f me
1 3 up l i nc
t t e r ph c c i e o r a e v d y or r
mi
e l y r; ueRi eAne t sa& Ctd a Caev. dik 2 Va 3 9 38 SE. 4 7
mp o e) Bl d
shei
i c l t Gi c , 39 . 6 , 9 . 2d 6

( 9 0 (a )
1 9 ) sme.

13

I . D am ages
V
N e ves D a a M oton s kst dimi sCount1 oft Am e d Com pl i ,
a ' m ges
i ee o s s
1 he
nde
ant

whihs e sd ma e a ij t rle f rNeve' ec oft No o t. a e
c e k a g s nd nunci eif o a sbta h he nc mpee Nev s
ve
cnm st tCount1 m us becim i s d f O ' llvan' f iur t esabls a t lda a .
li ha
1
t ls s e or Slli s al e o t ih c'
ua m ges

I pe tne pa t Count1 oft Am e
n r i nt t ,
1 he
nded Com pli pr des
ent ovi :
48.

Purua t Pa a r ph 1 of t A g e m e , O ' zl n s ks
s nt o
rga
0
he
r e nt
Sll1
'
va ee

i un d r l fprve tngNe ve fo wo l g f rUnio a f ra o - e r
nj c ve ei e n i
e
a s r m rdn o
r y l o ney a
pe i fom t dat ofe r ofa fna O t ri t sca e I a don,N e ve
rod t
he e
nty
i l de n hi s . n ddi
a s

c du tgijh spr xmaey c u e O'ul a da g si a a ntt t
on c sc a o i tl a s d S lv n ma e n n mou ha
i
e e $75,
xce ds 000.
49. Purua t Pa a a 12 oft s Agr e e O ' lva as s e t
s nt o t gr ph
hi
e m nt Suli n lo e ks o
r cove is c t a f s t e or e is rght l de tls Agr m e a
e r t os s nd ee o nf c t i s m r li
ee nt

a ii e t exc d $100,
ntcpatd o ee
000.

Am. mpl! 4 - .
Co . ! 8 49
N e vesc endst r cor de onsr t t tO ' 'l n ha n' i nt e a
a
ont
he e d m
ta es ha S'li
va s t nde o d ny
da a a i f om N e ve 'br ac l pa dc a N e ve poi st O ' xl n' Rul
m ges dsng r
a s e h. n r ulq a s nt o Slli s e
va

3 q 6 de sdo
0 $() poi n:
Q:

Asfra l sofb i e s ha O'ul a l ta mone a az s l o
a s os
usn s, s S lv n os ny
i
y s eut f
M r N ea ?
. ves

A:

A sls d pr vi l 1ca tt l you t t
ai e ousy, n' el
ha .

Q:

Ha O'llva l ta ya c nt t Unioy la ar s tofM. Ne ve ?
s Sxl n os n c ou s o t a s e ul
'
:
r a s
.
N o.

O'ul n 3 4 6 De 3 1 -1 .
S lva 0 $() p. 9:0 7
i
A sar ll oftzst s i ony,N ea a gt t tO ' lva sfda a sar
eszt li e tm
ves t z ha Suli n' f m ge e
es

s ul dvea lm ie t t c t i ured i purli t i t nta don. D ef' M e .
pec a
nd i t d o he oss nc r n snng he nsa c
'
? .s m

La S pp. . u J Re t ngDa g sr a g sM o. .) ECFNo. 2 a 4.
w u MotS mm.. gadi ma e o ma e tBr7,
'
6 ,t

14

Cons
equenty, e ve a kst colt t dimisCount1 f l k ofda a s Seei
l N a s s he 't o s s
1 or ac
m ge . da

Notby ho v r Ne v sino e O'llv n' r qu s f ri u d r l f n Co I.
a l, we e , a e g r s S zia s e e t o njnc ve ei i unt I
l
e
O ' lva doesnotdeny t ti i note l t m one a y da a ,ot tt n
Suli n
ha t s
ndted o
t r m ges he ha

atr e ' fe.nse d iagu st tii e dte t a i ncinp e nt gNeve fo
to n ys e s I ta ,t r e ha ts n ld o n t to rve i a s r m
ju
n
w ozdng f U nioya f oneyea bec us i tha s f t d iz prabl hl. a hasa
l
oz z l or
t a e t f s ufe e z e
e t nd
m
n
i
nadequat r m e a lw' s h asf n m onet y da a sa edifcztt a c rti or
e e dy t a ' uc
f
whe
ar m ge r fill o s e an

aei d q aet c mpe ae( S11 n frt ijr cusdbyl evelb e c ofa
r na e u t o o nst O'11va ) o he nu y a e
i
a s t ah
r sdc vec ve nt' . Me Op De . M o . u J Re a d n Dn g s ECF No
e t é o na . Pl' m. p. f' t S mm. . g t i g ma e ,
' s
s
.
71,a 1.
t

Th f tee ntts apli fmus sdsybeo eapema e ti ncini is d
e ou -lme et nndf t a f fr
t n n t to s sue
ju
i wele t bls A pli fm us s
s l s a ihed. andf
t how:

()t ti ha s frda irpaa l ijr ;()t trme e a albea lw,
1 ha t s ufee n re rbe nu y 2 ha e dis v i l t a
a
s h a mo tr d ma e,ae ia e u t t c mp nst fr t tijr;
uc s neay a g s r n d q ae o o e ae o ha nu y
()t t c i rn te baa c of h r hps bewe n t pli f a
3 ha, onsdeig h ln e
adsi
t e he andf nd
d fnd n ,a t me y i e ui i wa zntd;a ()t t t e pu i i ee t
e e a t e d t q t s ra e nd 4 ha h bl ntr s
l
y
c
wo l not dsev db apema n i nc
ud be isr e y r ne tt don.
ju
e I . Me c c n e L. C.5 U.. 8 , 1( 0 $.
Ba nc v. r Ex ha
L. , 47 S 3 8 39 2 0
O'ul n e tb ihe ee n s()a ()v aPaa r ph 1 oft eAg e me . e
S lva sa ls s lme t 1 nd 2 i rg a 2 h r e nt Und t
i
Vigi al w, ti f els tld t par st acontac m a s iy t e nt orpr r ni a i s ç l- e te hat de o
w
r t y pecf he ve s
e
c
ondi
donst wilti rapa t srghtt r ove f t ot tpa t sbt a oft i
hat l rgge
ry' i o ec z or he he ry' e ch
he.
t

a r e n . Ul v. P, nc, 71Va 7 , 9 6 4 SE.d 4 , ( 0 ) Tl si l e
g e me t' l QS I .2
' oa
. 2 7 , 2 . 2 3 48 20 6 . l ncud s
i
m o tr da ge , sfgl sa ueo pu i po iyi i piae . . ha wo d c untr al
nea y ma s a f o tt t r bl lc s m l td . t t ul o e v i
n
c
c
t par 'f e
he ées r edom t ei i t da a sasar r d ee entofabr c ofcontac
o lm na e m ge
equie lm
ea h
r t

a don. 1 ;s eas W . ns ld L. v. oo e 3 6F. x 2 , 9 (t Ci. 0 9 .
c ' d. e lo I ua on, P. M r , 1 App' 91 2 7 4 h r 2 0 )
'

1
5

I Par gr 12,t pa desa e t tO ' lvan woul notne t pr a t l
n a aph
he r
gt e ha Suli
d
ed o ove c ua

d ma si abr a h oft Ag e me ,ncudngt eNon o t. r e nt 1
a ge n e c he r e nti l i h
c mpee Ag e me ! 2

(l wigab e c ofc nta ta to t p o e df t tt ne dt p o ata
al n r ah o tc cin o r c e f hou he e o r ve cu l
o
wi
d ma s). epade as a teta Ke r r a pe a n i u dverl f i
a gç' Th r s lo g e h tf mpo ay nd = ne tnjnc ei ' s
t
e'
a opza e f a br ac Unde Vigi alw,t s pt vii oft Agr m entar
ppt it oz e h.
r r ni a he e o sons he ee
e

e o c a ea dstsyee nt ()a d() S eUl , 1Va a 79 6 4S. 2 a 4 .
nfre bl n aif lme s 1 n 2 . e l 27 . t , 2 E.d t 8
oa
Elm e () t baa c ofe t de , i h i fvo ofO'll n. t Ea tr
e nt 3, he ln e ql s weg s n a r
i
Sni As he se n
lva

DititofVignt ha rc nt noe i t p ei nayi unc nc ntx,flt ug ii
stc
tl ' s e e l td n he tl r nj éo o e tfg lho h ts
'a
y
mi
a

und ubtdytu t ts bjc gg f r re ly e t t r sdc vec ve nt yi i
o e l r e ha u e % a ome mpo e) o he et d o na ma mpar
hsa l yt e r al n ,lhee o ejh sa itr s i p otc gisc t m esfo
i bit o an i g t mply r a n n e e t n t e dn t uso t r m
i
vi
di son pe ng t s udon oft ca e' U dae I v.Sa iow,311 F.Supp.3d 784,796
veri
ndi e ol
he s .'
t nc.
ml

( D. . 01 ) Ne v sd sn s g s o he wie Fi al, t1 e p c t ee nt()
E. Va 2 8 . a e oe ot ug e t t r s . n l w11 r s e t o lme 4 ,
y .
,
p lcpoiyweg i fvo ofO'll n. r i a1w c rnnyf nc urg lqt
ubi l
c ihs n a r
Sxi Vigni a e til f o a es he
lva
e
e or me ofvaldnonnf ce nt
i
compeea e menty'd,a t c thasar dyhed t t
t gr e
s'Lx nd he our
lea
l hat he
N onc pe ei va a e or ea eunde Vig ri lw .
om t s id nd nf c bl
r r ila a
l s ,t c thol t tt N onc pet i e or a e N e vesha br a d
n um he out ds ha he
om e s nf ce bl, a
s e che
t N oncom pe e,a unde t t r softz N oncom pe e,O ' van i endte t a
he
t nd
r he e m
le
t
Se
s
ld o n

i éo p e nd Nev sfom c nén dvoa nso t No o t.
t
junc n rve ng a e r o ue ildo f he nc mpee
Thec u shod n sdonot h we r a t ma al e ti e j i n Ne ve fo
o u' li g
, o ve , u o dc l n al n onig a s r m
y
w ordng f Unioya i g yposto CfAm.
l
or t l n s
iin. . Compl!48tf s 1 a s e si j d
.
f ulv n e k nunc ve
o' i
-

r ifpr ventng N e ve f om wor ng f U nioya f aone- rpe i fom t dat of
ele e i
a sr
ki or t l or
yea rod r he e

e r ofaf lOr ri t i c s .) Pr s by t r a eot e posdonsa Unr y l ha
nty
i
na de n l s ae' . e uma l, hee r h r i
a
'
t io a t t

1
6

do notc pe ewih t Busne sofO ' ll n by usng t Resdc e Cont t .
om t t he i s
Slli
va
i he t t d
ac s

Ac o dngy t c ur wi o de tep rist c e a sbmiaji p o e
c r i l,he o t l r r h ate o onfr nd u t ont r posd
l
pema nt nun d noltrt a f ure n da satre r oft a c mpa i gor r
r ne i j c on ae h n o te y fe nty he c o nyn de .
M or
eove ,N ea doe notcont s t O ' llva c n t ove a t neys f sunde
r
ves s
e t hat Slli n a ec r tor ' ee
r

Paa rp 1 sfes f gpr vson. e Da g sM o. . r%tmos,( S11 n')
rg a h 2' e-hidn o ii S e ma e tBr4
t O'11va s
i
dn g saes cza vea l td t t ec t i ure i puri g giqt ei tnt
ma e r pe tld nd i e o h oss nc r d n sn sc h nsa
mi

a éo ' Thec utfndst tO'llva i e ld t r c ve isr a o bl at r y ' e s
c n.
).
ot i ha Sll n s ndt o e o r t e s na e to ne s fe
i
e
and cos si t sa
t n hi cdon.O ' al n m a s i am odon f a t ne 'f esa coss
Sll1
'
va
y ubm t
or tor ys e nd t .
V.

Concl i
us on

Be a et N onc pe e' t m por ls
c us he
om t s e
a cope f dona lm ia
, unc
l i t dons and ge a lc
,
ogr pli
s
cope a e na r w l t ior d t N e ves f m e post a O ' 'l n,t cout hol t tt
r r o y a l e o a ' or r ibn t Slli
va he
' ds ha he
t

N onc pet i vai unde Vigml lw.M or ove ,N e ve doesnotc es he i vi a
om e s ld
r r '' a
a
e r a s
ont t s ol dng
t N onc pe e. one hees ,O ' l n ha f ied t pr a t a da a ,a t
he
om t N
t l s Suli
va s al o ove c u l m ges nd he

i c verl fs u tb O'll a i not to yti r dt t tr oft
t d ei o gh y Sli n s narwl al e o he ems he
jun
e
lv
o
N onc pe e. or ngl t O ' lvan M oton wilbe GRAN TED i partand
om t Acc di y, he Suli
i
l
n

DENI i patt Neve Enfr ebW Modo wil DENI a teNeve
ED n r,he a s o c a i
n lbe
ED, nd h a s
D a a M odon wilbe GRAN TED i par a D EN I D i par .
m ges
l
n t nd
E n t

Ete:/o l- 1
nr hp z.2
ed
/
./

z mr . A # -(j:-- .
u 4
A -è-'à.
z' '
-

M i ha lF.Ur rsd
c e
bà fl

'

-

ChifUrie S a s src l g
e zd t
t
tit ud e

'
'
,

'
. ,