Hixon v. Hutcheson et al
Filing
94
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 2/8/2018. (jv)
PJFRK' OFFI U. . ST COURT
S
CE S DI .
AT RM NOKE,
VA
I TII UN I D STATES o l rl c' co u R'
N -E
TE
s- u r
r
FL D
IE
FORTI E U S
I
TERN ol - uc' OFVI NI
srl r
RGI A
FEë 29 2 1
22
H xu l so N su Rs o rw sloN
u
-, , D.CEK
(
U
,LRo
z
---
CARY H I SO N ,
X
Pl ntfy
ai if
Ci lActon N o.5:7- 00032
vi
i
1 cv-
By:H on.M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l
BRYAN H U TCH ESO N ,etal
.
dhifUnie Sa e Ditit udge
e
td tt s src J
D ef
endant
s.
M EM O RAN D U M O PI ION
N
Pli ifCa' Hi on,a i uln- pe ntdibei,algeshek deni i uln
antf t xs n ns i de nde a tc le
y
'was ed ns i
y
)
r
.
.
.
,
whi i acrtda Hars nbugRoc i ha Re i al i(f t '. xs sFis
l ncreae t rio r- kng m gon lalf RJ? Hi on' rt
e
H1 )
Ame de Compli f Monea yDq g s(h < ', No. 4 r ie vai cnms
n d
ant or
tr ma e t e < ) ECF
FAC'
3 , as s rous li
a tDee a sBz nHuc s , e nS nelDzMihal rn (ol c veywih
gzns fnd nt ya theon Stve ho l . c e Mo a c l d l t
,
e
Hu c s n a S relt eT JDe e a s) So he nHe lh Pa t r , nc (%HP'
the o nd ho tl h <
, HRR. fnd nt', ut r at rne s J . K )>
a hnDoe#1a #2(Doe, a dc l ci l wiht HIRJDee a t a SHP,
ndlo
nd f s? n ol t y t he L
<
?
e ve .
fnd ns nd
ç fnd nt' l
f e a sl.
De
Tli matrc me beor t ec t to t HRRJDe e a s a S SM o nst
zs te o s f e h oz n he
r
fnd nt' nd HP' do o
D ir s .ECF N os 37 & 53.Fozt r a onsdic s d beow,t cour wilGRAN T i
snis
.
he e s
s us e l
he
t l
n
par a D EN Y i par t M otonst D imi s The c twilas s s ont
t nd
n
t he
i
o s s.
our l lo ua
e
CO N SO LI ATE t sa i wih H i on v.Ra ne ,5: c 00001 M FU .
D
hi cton t xs
s 18- v-
1 hie Hi s doesnoti ndf D oe i t FAC,H i on' c
W l x on
de y
s n he
xs s ompl i i Hi on v.Ra ne ,5: - v- 01- FU,
ant n xs
s 18 c 000 M
ie t sDo sa Kah rn Ran sa dl n l S e fr . i tec u t u so t c n oi ts51 -v0 0 1wi
d ni
se e s teie y e n a el ek od Whl h o r s a ne o s l e :8c -0 0 t
e
e
da
h
t sa éon,i t sopi on,t c tm 'lc ntnue t r e t t t SHP nur e a D oe .
hi c
n hi ni he our l o i o ef r o he wo
ss s s
1.
Alegatons
l i
Pli ifCa y Hi on i a 53- a - d m a who wa ,a a l e e ntHm e ,dignos
antf r xs s
ye r o1 n
s t l r lva
s a
ed
v'hi ul - pe e tda ts2FACj 3, 2 6 His nwa i acrtda HR-Jfrsx
i ns i de nd n ibee.
t
n
! 3 , 8. x o s ncreae t R o i
mo hs ltj3. x on d snot e d t ee a td t sdmi wl c hewa i a c l e
nt . t. His oe pla l x c ae ng a'
.
n
ih
s nc reutd.
Hi on i notcut e l i a c r t d.l
xs s
r nty nc r e a e d.
S rf Br a Huthe o wa t es r i g o t t zofHRR ,d ! 4 wh l
he if y n c s n s h upe dsn pe ao
J ix , ie
Sh tlwa t op r t of J L . 7 Dz Mo a wa ame c l oco e o e b
orel s he e aoz HRR ,d $ . . z n s dia d t r mply d y
=
HRRJ J !1 9 Addéon l , . a wa T r igo be loft c unt a wa
.A 0 . i al DrMorn s t kn n haf he o f' nd s
y
wo
e o e b Rocdng a Co yfg o a la tAu us 1 2 6t t ug a ua y29
mply d y l h m unt ijt m t e s g t , 01 h o hl n r ,
2 1 . 1 . ! 1 9 1 1 1 4 S i arg o l at c t p o i rt a e l y a
0 7: d ! 0 , 1 , 1 . HP s e i na he lh a e r vde h t mp o s nd
:
c ta t wih me ia c r pr f si ast p o i c r t i tsa HRR 1 ! 1 . s
on r cs f dc l a e o e son l o r v de a e o nmae t J. d, 0 Doe
.
#1a #2 (Doe ? we enus se o e b S t p o i eme ia c r a HIRJ L
nd ( s' r t e mply d y HP o r v d d c l a e t L . da
T
)
!1 .
1
S wa un rc r c t p o i eme ia sr ie a HERJ I ! 4 . i tt
HP s de onta t o r v d d c l e vc s t R . d. ( 9 Pro o
ViS n' i c r eai n a I RRJ Kuthe on S rela S d veo dap iyt a
x O S n ac r to t ' , c s , ho tl nd HP e lpe ' ol h t
I
,
c
p ohb td al tf,ncudn me c lsa f a HRRJfom p o i i me c t i cudng
r iie lsaf i l ig dia t f, t
r r v dng diai n l i
on,
i ui t da dc h us da HRRJ J . ! 2 - , 4 Huthe on, ho tn a Dr Mo a
ns l o ibe s o e t
n,
. . ! 8 29 6 . c s S re , nd . r n
1
a pr ve S Spoiyofno pr v dngdibei mel ain.. ! 6 -6 . s po iis
p o d HP' l
c
t o i i a tc cc to J ! 6 7 The e lce
i
Z
ha 1d nn eou i tsa HRRJt bede id te t n .A 1 3 -31
ve e ' r s nmae t
m
o
n e ra me t J I 0 .
!
Upo i c r e ain a HRRJ Doe , be l ofS pe f r d ame c lsz e g
n n a c r to t
, s on haf HP, ro me
dia c e in
ofHi s L x ! 6 , 5 Uponi ur ,Hi oni or dDoe t thewa da no e < t
x on. d ! 8 7 .
nq iy xs nf me
s ha
s ig s d h
2A1 f c she e n a e tke fom t e FA C,t algado ofwhi h att s sa e t c 'm us tke a t u .Se Coo e v.
1 a t ri r a n r l
z
he le ns
c
hi t g he ouz
t t a s re e
r
Pae 3 8U.. 4 , 4 (9 4 @e c r m)
t, 7 S 5 6 5 6 1 6) r ui .
a
2
dibet a ne
a es nd eded t t ke m e c ton,i l ngi uln,t c t ii dibet s 1 D oes
o a
di a i ncudi ns i o ont ol ts a e . d.
r viwe Hi on' m edi lfl a conft ed he nee d m e c ton,i udi i uln,as
e e d xs s
ca ies nd
im
de
di a i ncl ng ns i
wel sada ei de ,o te th sdib t s I T 6 , 7 Dr Morn t ve dHis n'
la ib tc it t t a i a ee . d. T 8 7 . . a e iwe x o s
me c lflsa kzw t a His r qur d te t ntf l sdib ts J ! 1 7 Ea h
dia ie nd t h t x on e ie r ame or a a ee .. 1 . c
e
i
Z
de e ntwasa e on t fr tda ofI i on' i aê m ton t H i on wasdibetc.L
f nda
war
he ls y - xs s nc ce i hat xs
l
a i i
.
!1 8
4.
A sor r by Dr M or n,D oe t H i on' bl s tlvesdal at a of150
de ed
.
a
s ook xs s ood uga e l i otl
y
H s ec o whihwa rc r do a SHP f ' 1 . !7 ,8 , 2 . hl abl d-u a
me , a h f c s e o de n n
ot d ! 9 2 1 0 W i oo sg r
m.
e
lve beo 1 0 mg/ L i c i e e no a,Hi on' blod-u rlve t a ls t n 1 0
e l lw 1
d s onsd r d = l xs s o s ga e l e d e s ha 1
mg dwony3ou o 1 0tme , ve 1 0mg dL 41H e , nd a hg a 4 7 mg d 3 .a
/! l
t f 5 i so r 8 /
m s a s ih s 0 / L.J
d
! 8 -8 . s t t s lihlves a dept ha n t a t rt t d s Do sr fsd
! 4 6 Depie hee ag e l, nd s ie vig he uhoiy o o o, e eu e
t prvieHis nwih o o d ri ul o ohe n c saydibe me iai .- ! 8 -9 .
o o d x o t z r e ns i r t r e e sr a dc dcton J. ! 9 2
n
I
L
Doe ddti dept k wi tersst His . d. 9 - .
s i hs sie no ng h ik o x on I ! 4 96
Hi on z gulry c pl i a
xs e a l om aned boutt pan hewasi due t notr evi i uln,
he i
n
o
ec i ng ns i
a Huth s n, ho tl a Morn die t r c ie t s c mpli s J ! 4 - , 2 .
nd c e o S rel nd a r cl e ev d ho e o ant.A ! 2 43 1 5
,
y
Hi onas c mpli dt Do sa utt p i hewa i L a !1 2 4.nse do tetn
xs lo o ane o e bo he an
sn. d !J 0 -0 I ta f raig
Hhs , we z Do st e tne HL s n wih s ltr c fne n , n a k dHRRJ
on ho ve , e hr ae d x o t oia y on me t a d s e
de
puéest putH i on i s ia c
o
xs n olt v onfne ent be us he c
m , ca e
onénued t com pli a
o
an boutnot
r c i n pr rte t ntf rh sdibee . d ! 3 ,1 7
e evig ope ta ne o i a ts I . ! 3 0 .
Si ia l,D r M or n r vi we H i on' m edi lr c dsa kne he ne de i uln.
m lry .
a e e d xs s
ca e or nd w
e d ns i
L ! 1 7, 1 . hl Dr Mo a i t zt dt sa ft s r eHi on adibe me l nd
i I 1 1 9 W i . t n nst ce he tf o e v xs
!
e
a
a dc a a
3f / L'i a a b eid nfrmiirms rd cle. e Sit v Sa b r , 4 F3 2 9 2 7(t Ci. 0 6.
f d 's n b rva o o lg a pe eitrS e cno . tnse 8 1 .d 1 , 2 4h r2 1)
mg
l
i
pe s iyr viw e H i on' elvat bl s rlve s her f ed t pr deH i on wih
r ona e e d xs s e ed ood-uga e l, e us o ovi
xs
t
i uln orot rdibe e m edi ton.L sr 1 8 4 DrMornrf e te t n dept
ns i
he a t s
ca i d l( 1 -2 . . a eusd rame t s ie
1
.
k V n t ezs o fin t pr v d His n 4 t i ui 1 .j 1 7 29
no g h iks f al g o o i e x o 4. ns l d j 2 - .
i
1
4
n.
Be a eh wa not r ae a HIRJ Hi s s fe e s v r , r l g d p i
c us e s te td t L , x on u fr d e e e p oon e an
t oughoutli f t ha a l gs s f r d fom bl z d yii a rng ng i li e r f
hr
zs ee , nd, nd e , ufe e r
ur e son nd i i n as a s oz
hi e iesa a HRRJ a n w s fe sfo or a da g a s te d l ee pe tnc .
s ntr ty t
, nd o u fr r m g n ma e nd ho tne i x ca y
f
l
I !4 .
d. 6
Hi on fld s ta i tD e enda s TheFA C cont i ni c
xs te ui gans f nt .
ans ne ount .Count1 pl
s
, ed
a i tD z M oz n a D oesi t i i vi lca cde ,alge Sec i 1983 c m sba ed
gans . a nd
n her ndi dua pa i s le s ton
bi
s
on avi a
ol donsofHi on' Ei h Am e
xs s ght
ndm entrght .CountI ,pl d a i tH ut on a
i s
I e gans
ches nd
Shor eli t i i vi lc pa ii ,algess r i or la lt arsng outoft s m e
t l n he t ndi dua a c tes le
upe v s y ibiiy ii
he a
S c n 1 8 cnm i Co nt1 Cou 11 pe a i tt HIR.De e a si t erofkil
e do 9 3 li n u . nt 1 , ld gans he L J fnd nt n h i i a
c p cée , l g savolton o t ADA. i lry Co ntI as pld a ans t HRRJ
a a i s al e i ai f he
e
Smial, u V, lo e g i t he
D ef nda si t i of i c pa ii s algesavi a
e nt n he r ûcal a c te , le
oléon oft Re biia
he ha lt don A c .CountV,
t
pld a i tH ut on a Shoteli t i i vi lc pa i ,a lge sa e lw gr s
e gans
ches nd
t l n het ndi dua a cdes le s t t -a os
ne i nc CountVI pl d a ns D r M oz SH P,a D oes al ss a e lw m edi l
gl
ge e.
, e gai t . an,
nd
, lege t t -a
ca
m apr ctce.CountVI ,pld a i tSHP,al ge sat -a r s
l a i
I e gans
le s t e lw e ponde s rorlabiiy.
at upe i i lt
.
CountV1 I pld a i talD ef ndant ,s kspuri da a . nal CountI s eks
I , e gans l
e
s ee
ldve m ges Fi l
y,
X e
a t ne 'f esa i tuns c fe pa te .
tor ys e gans
pe ii d r is
I.
I
Consoldaton
i i
W he da tonsbef et cout i ve acom m on que don of1w orf ct' Fede a
n fc i
or he
t nvol
s
a
a ,'
rl
Rul ofCi lPt e e 42 alowst cour t fc oldat t ac
e
vi oc dur
l
he
t o 'ons i e he dons'Fe R.Ci P.
.' d.
v.
4
42a()Co ol ai i aT na eil vc 'ta f k sposil t sr/ ie
()2. ns i t s f g ra de ie'h tf e sbe he te ml d
d on
ma
ma
n
pr s i ofgr
oce sng
oupsofc es ofe obvi dng t ne f m ul elws t a ti l.'8
as , t n
a
he ed or dpl a uis nd ras'
M o r ' Fe rl a tc j4 .0g)a. c z ha wi ed sr don t c ns l t a do .
o es dea Prc ie 21 1 (j The ou t s d ic e o o oi e c ns
da
A/ 1Lu wi Mo nc lsRe rv. de trConsr Co.55 F.d9 8 9 ( hCi.
S . d g wi ke dei Ti wae
t. , 9 2 2 , 33 4t r
1 7 ) Th tdice in e t n t c ns l dn a éo s s on e 8M oo esFe r l
9 7 . a s r to x e ds o o oi g c ns ua
da
t.
r ' de a
Pr c iej4 1 2 (j b ; e as Be c Ma t I . L & L W i s l .Nos 2;1 CV- 4 F
at
c 2.0(ja-() s e lo a h r nc v.
n nc, . 1 - 4 & 2:4 CV- 2 F, 01 W L 46 5 5 ,a * ( D. C. pt 1 , 01 )(o oi én c s ss a
1- 5- 2 4
3 4 0 t 1 E. N. Se . 5 2 4 c ns l g a e u
da
s on e .
t)
W he e c sng isdic e
n xer ii t s r éon t c olda e,t c tm us c i t
o ons i t he our
t onsde :
whehe t e s cfcrs sofp eudc a d posi ec f so we eo r r
t t h pe ii ik
r j ie n
sbl on u i n r vebo ne
b t rs o ic nsse ta j ia nsofc n n fc la d lg lis e,
y he ik f n o itn dudc do
ormo a ma n e a su s
te'ur n o pat s winess a d a albe j iilr s re posd b
h b de n ri , t se n v i l udca eou c s e y
e
a
m uli e lw s t ,t l ngt of tm e z quied t concude m ul e s t as
tpl a uis he e h
i
e r o
l
dpl uis
a i ta sngl one a t r l i e
gans i e
, nd he eatve xpens t alc
e o l once ne oft snglr d
he i e
til m tli e ti lat r tve .
ta, ztpl-ra le nai s
At dv. Ai Lie ,I .6 1F.d 1 6 1 3 (t Ci. 9 2 9 e as Ant i ev. nc
nol E. r n s nc, 8 2 8 , 9 4 h t 1 8 ) s e lo o n Anik
Fams LLC, vNo . , 62 4 & ELH- 629 8 2 7W L 6 6 6 a * 4( Md.a
r .
Ci s E11 -4 4
+1
1 - 3 , 01
8 4 , t 1 D. l n.
6 20 7 (o oi tn aéon atrc nsd rn f u ia onofcso r a dfta
, 1 ) c ns l ig c s fe o ieig f pl d
da
d c
l c vef' n f il
i
t
tsi ny'f onsr gton lf jdiil eouc s . . e ucé jg le pe e as cae
etmo y t e vai l oj u ca r s te, . rd gon of x nss so itd
'c
wih til'a d t eTnc nv ne c t win se f r10t sde '
t ra, n h f o e in e o t e s s o 3 h i s).
'
i
Onl nuay3 2 8 Hïs n f e Hi onv. ne ,51 -v- 0 1 MFU,n t i
a r , 01 , o i d xs Ra s :8 c 00 0 l
i hs
c ur. ec an i Ra ne (h fk y sCo nnt' rdk y sCo .) Co ant
o tTh omplit n y s t e f a ne mpli 'o f a ne mpl7 mpli ,
l
l
',
51 -v- 0 01MFU, No. , rn scnmsa ans Kahei Ra n sa a l
:8 c 0 0 ECF
1 b i g li g i t t rne y e ndl nel
e
Se kf r ,' nu s se l y dbyS t p o i me ia c r t i tsa HRRJ Ra n s
e od t
wo re mp o e
HP o z v de dc l a e o nmae t
. ye
Co l1 7, 0 Th alg d i t Ra ne Co antmir rt alg donsi t eFAC.
mp .5 1 . e l a ons n he y s mpli to he l a
e
e
nh
M or ove ,t c/i sa i tRa ne a Se or aSec i 1983 c nm ,a sa e lw
e r he l m gans y s nd ekf dton
li
t t -a
tve m ge nd tor y ' ee - ppe o
m e ca m apr tc cn m ,a r que t f punii dl a sa a t ne s f s ha n t
di l l ac ie li nd e s s or
.
bet s mecnmsbr
he a li
oughtagins Doesi t FAC.Com a eLL a 20-21 wihFAC 38t
n he
r ( t
, t
39, -45. ti ce r fom t f ceoft Ra
44
I s la r
he a
he ynesCom pli t Ra nesand See or a e, n
ant hat y
kf d r i
f ct t D oe na e i t FA C.I tad ofa e ng t FAC t i ntf D oes howe r
a , he
s m d n he
nse
m ndi he
o de iy
,
ve ,
Flxs hasfl as pa ae c pl i .
i on
zed e r t om ant
The c tnow hasbef ei t a tonst i ve t s m euli a e s t off c s
our
or t wo c i hat nvol he n
tm t e s a t ,
lw,a wines es D ico r a ti t s ony i t t a éonswilam os a s edl be
a nd t s . s ve y nd ral e ém
n he wo c
t l t s ut y
duplca i ,as atba e bot t FA C a t Ra
i tve ,
s , h he
nd he ynesCom pli i vet s m e unde l ng
ant nvol he a
ryi
f t a t a lr e ent c esofac i N otonl do t t ac
ac s nd, o a ge xt , aus
ton.
y
he wo éonsfpr s nta
f ee
c
ommonqu s nofete lw orfc, Fe R. v. 42a, lornetyal uedo of
eéo
ih r a
a t' d. Ci P. () al al lq s ns
'
1w orf c a es r bet e t t o a i .
a
a t r ha ed we n he ' ctons
w
O n t one ha be us f heca e cons ut m ir i a sofonea he ,'t
he
nd, ca e f
t
ss
ét e ror m ge
not r' he
c u tfnd ta t r i nors ofp eudc orc uinit cs saec ol ae .
o r i s h thee s ik r j ie onfso f he ae r ons i td
d
Ce t i I e esed U nde wrt sSubs rbi t Polc N o.81 2P2001
ran nt z t
r ier
ci n o i
26
7013 v. .Rea
Am
l
Ad io s Nos5:6CV-40FL & 51 - 7 - 2 7W L 1 3 2 , t* ( D. C. .
vsr, . 1 - 9 :7CV-4FL, 01
3 1 45 a 2 E. N. Apr
11 20 7. t ot e ha , ft ec r d sno c ns l t t c s s t r wil x s a
, 1 ) On he h r nd i h ou t oe t o oi e he a e , he e le it
da
sg fc n rs t tt p r swi b s bjc t i onitnta j iainoft smeis s
iniia t ik ha he aée l e u et o nc sse dudc to
l
he a sue,
d pl a vedic vey (ndc t i u r d i d so r ) a awa t o t j ca s se s
u i é s o l a oss nc re n ic ve y, nd se f he udiil y tm'
c
r our s Se i Thecolr t r or fndst tHi onv.Ra ne ,5: -ves ce . e da
zt he ef e i ha xs
s 18c 00001M FU,
s d be c oldat d wih t saci f alpur es Se W CC Cabl l v.G 4S Tec
houl
ons i e t hi ton or l pos . e
e, nc.
h.
6
LLC, 51 - 0 0 2 2 7W L 6 0 4 a * ( D. . c 1 , 01 )(o oi dn
No. :7 CV- 0 5 , 01
5 31 2, t 4 W. Va De . 5 2 7 c ns l g
da
at )
ci .
ons
1 . M otonst D i m i s
11
i
o s s
Th HIV De e nt a d S mo et din isc ran c nt i teFAC u e
e L
fnda s n HP v o s zs e ti ou s n l
z
nd r
Fe rl eo CiiPr c due1 $() TheHRRJDee a smo t ds s Co s
dea Rul f vl o e r 2( 6.
fnd nt ve o imis unt
11 I V1 a VI1a a ans t HRRJDe e a s S mo st din isCo nt V1 I
1, V, , nd 1 s g i t he
fnd nt. HP ve o s as u s I
a I a a i tSHP.
nd X s gans
A.
Le St
gal andar
d
Rul 1 $()per t adinisl napli ff sTosaeac m upo whc
e 29 6 rnis snsa whe anéf zl f tt bi
t
n ih
rl fc nbeg a e . Fe R. v. 1 4 6. s ri aRul 1 4)moin t dsas,
ei a
e
rntd' d. Ci P. 2 $()To u vve
'
e 2$)6 to o inis
acom pli i tc an s fce e 41 n 5 lg a <
l
mg' r cle
i
r L' f .ult whe lsboodsg zwa beae n 1 a d2O mg/ L, nds on. Lxa
d ) our zis n n l u a s tv e 51 n 0 d a o ' d t
,
i
'
2 . cnt r q se s plm e a i u i be a ehi bl d s a wa 2 0 /d JJ 80 h
27 S i o e ue td up e ntlns l c us s oo ug r s 0 mg L. . t
n
I
.
Scnt a def ndant a e d t Scnt wasa y scnt cnm i i wa fa las i pa t
i o nd e
s gr e hat i o
ngr - i o li ng t s dt e t n t
bec us hi bl s rwashi ' and t doc orclm i t Scnt e ged i
a e s ood uga
gh,'
he t li ng hat i o nga
n
f hr a eni be vi .'I a 227-28.l wasundiput d t tt doc orft r i t
f e t ng ha oz' d. t
t
t
s e ha he t
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?