Garris v. 933387 ONTARIO LTD. et al

Filing 108

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 11/27/2018. (jv)

cLERl OFFI U.s.DI .Coor
fs
CE
sT

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I RICT COU RT
ST
FO R TH E W E STERN D I
STRICT O F W RGI M
N

A ROA E V
T NOK , A
yl
uEo

u auul suas ol sl
sow
w ow

Nw 28 2 1
28
L .
A D

KAREN J.
GARRI
S,

:

Pl i if
a ntfy

I
CLERK

CEK
LR

Cas N o.5: 7- 39
e
1 cv-

V.

93338 O N TARTO LTD . etaly
7
,
.
By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l
D ef
endant
s.

Chif t d S a e Dit t udge
e Unie t ts sdc l
M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N
N O

Thi m a trcom esbe or t c ton Pl ntf' m oéon i lmi Sld on
s te
f e he our
ai ifs
n i ne, e
N ove be 9,2018 r ques t ts be al d t fl a s e e a i e r t y
m r
, e éng ha he
lowe o te upplm ntl nt r oga or
r pons t m a t r iw ol ng he l f a e, i kne a rghts de .Spe ikal
es
e o te s t vi
r e t nkl tght e, nd i houl r
c f ly,

Plitf rq se pemiso t ts yTotep o i t c u eis srg r i t i s
anif e uetd t sin o eéf f h r xmae a s sue e adng he t
t
jude
t h ra ke rg k e , nd rg s tle . ECF No. 2 On No mbe 1 , andf Sld a
o e n l, iht n e a iht ho z r'
d '
9.
ve r 2 Pli ) e
f
s e e a m e oz ndum i s
uppl m nt l m a
n uppor oft m odon,cdng Slm ne v.Sr t 220 Va 226
t he
i
l r
nih,
.

(9 9 a ispr g nyt sppo th rrg t ts ya t cusdo ECFNo. 6. zt
1 7 ) nd t o e o u r e iht o edf s o a a n.
9 Fo he
r s e ane beow,Pli ifsm odon i G RAN TED i pat a D E N I i par.
ea ons xpli d l
antf
s
n t nd
ED n
t
St e hed t m e c lt s i ony T snotapr r st t t ovey ' a t tf he
mm r l hat dia e tm
f
i
e equiie o ec z ' nd ha f
t

tsi yoft pnn fao ..p e e td aj. is ea t c us l o c '2 0Va a
et
mon he li éf lne . r s n e ut su s o a a c nne don. 2 . t
y
'
226.Sum ne ,howe r wasdecded by t Vig ni Supr eCour ,a t isptnci es
r
ve ,
i
he r i a
em
t nd hus t i pl
gove n sat lw.Thi c ti af r ldit tcolt wlih,when sti i di t iy,a
r t ea
s out s ede a sdc xt lc
itng n ve st ppies

saes bsa d lw a fde a p oc du a lw. i R. v. m l 30 U. 6 ( 9 8 .
tt u tn ve a nd e ê l r e rl a Ere R. To dns 4 S. 4 1 3 )
S eSt ho ke v. ne a Mot r Co .58 F.d 1 1 1 4 (t Ci.9 ) TheFe rl
e one c r Ge r l o s
7 2 5 , 5 4 h r1 78 .
dea

Rul ofEvi nc a efbe ond at m e ' pr edut la t c r unl sa sa e
es
de e t f y
gu nt' oc
a nd hus ontol es t t

e de ir rze e t rfe bodi ori cos y ted t as a e s t ndve polc ' H otl v.
vi nta y t ihe fm
l
es s l el i o t t ubs a
i y.
' te

Be c AicatCo .4 F.d1 6 1 9- 1 (t Ci. 9 5.
e h rrf
, 7 3 0 , 0 0 4h r 1 9 )
The ei no contoli aut iy c
r s
t lng hort once ni whe he Slm ne ' polc m e t t s
z ng
t r l rs iy e s hi

c ie .The c tne nota e st sque don.Slm ne r t sonl t tapli fbe
tt da
out ed
ddr s hi
s
z t equie
y ha
andf
pe= it d t t éf f m al ast whatt tpl i fe re e 220 Va.a 226. tdoesnot
te o es y ac ly o
ha andf xpe i nè d.
t
I
per tt tm ony ofa e r , e c lna ur fom aly pl i f a Rul 701oft
mi esi
n xpe t m dia t e r
a andf, nd e
he
Fede a RulsofEvi
rl e
dence dial a e de e fom aly wines bas on fs i ndhc
s lows ny vi nc r
a t s ed
fc e
,
t c c l orot rs ilze knowldge' Fed.R.Evi 701.
e hnia,
he pecai d
e .'
d.

Pli fK a e G a dsm a t df t t Aprl22,201 c lson, ts
andf r n r
y es y o he i
5 olii wha he
e re e durng a a t rtnscolii he physca s a ebef et colii a t
xpe i nc d i nd fe li lson, t
i l tt
or he lson, nd he
pni s e rence afe .Shem a s y t ts had no pa n bef et c lson a
n he xpe i d tr
y a ha he
i
or he olii nd
e de e pan f l ngi.Shem a notofera t s ony ate pdng t s
xpe nc d i olowi t
y
f ny e dm
tm
o how m edi l
ca
c us don.
a a

An a opzat or rwilbe e e ed t sda
ppr i e de l
ntz bi y.

Ent r d: ovembe 27,2018
ee N
r
*

*
.
.
'

'

!
t

*
.
K y gk . . .
,'..
.l

M 'ha l 'Uz a
l e . bc

'

. j
-- , ..

Chif n td Sa e Ditit ud e
e ie tts stc l g

2

- ,--. .
. ... -,