Hegedus et al v. Nationstar Mortgage LLC et al

Filing 41

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/23/2018. (jv)

r F/e: OFFI U.S.Dl c0bR3
2
CE
sT.
'
AT ROANOKE, V
A
FI
LED

MA2 2 2 1
22
BKU
J

I TH E U N I D STATES D ISTRI CO U RT
N
TE
CT

FO R TH E W ES
TERN DI TRJ O F W RGI I
S CT
N A
HARRI BURQ DI SI
SON
W ON

q

,

UTY c

J FSA. EGED US e a .
AM
H
, t 1,
Pl i if y
a ntfs

Ci lActon N o.5:7- 00053
vi
i
1 cvV.

N ATION STAA M O RT GA GE,
LLC,etal
.
'

By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l

Chi fUnie S a e Di ti t udge
e
t d t t s s rc J

D ef
endant .
s

M EM ORAN D U M O PI IO N
N
Pr K p andfs a sa Vi i aHe e us(Tlit f' algedee a s
o
li fJ me nd r ni g d
g
ani s' l
f l e fnd nt
.

Nai trMo ta , rNainsa )a Da e T.Co wa (con y'voae
tonsa rg geLLC f to tF' nd nil
n y < wa ' iltd
f
)
va i lwsdurng t s r i a f ecos e ofam orga on ar sde e t tt y
rous a
i he e dcng nd or l uê
t ge
e i nc ha he
-

-

'
'

,

ow ned i D elw a e. si t s ond a i Pli f ha br
n
a r Thi s he ec
cton anéfs ve oughta ns N a i t rf
gai t tonsa or

s r i a i tesr l tng t t sD elw a er i nc Pli if alge conve son,br a of
e dcng ctvii e ai o hi
a r esde e. antfs le
ri
e ch
c r i t dousi e f r nce f lik a
ontac , or
nt r e e , asi don ofbusnes r or ,a i endonal nfiion of
i s ec ds nd nt
i lc
e otona dites a i tN adonsa ;Pbi if cli de a aton a pt es i l
m i l sr s gans
tr
ntfs nm f m i nd of sona
miconduc a ns Conwa Thecom pli as i udesc m sofede a e a eof
s
t gai t
y.
ant lo ncl
bi
l r bus , bus
'

!

pr s , aii pr e uton,a f anuf c rng ad,e aztladi t a il ga f ecos e
oce s m lcous os c i nd f
m
am i
f tl e ng o n le l or l ur
a don.'R& R,ECF N o.30,a 8
c
'
t -10;s e r l Com pl,ECF N o.1.80t def nda s
ee ne al
.
h e nt
i t s
.o s s
m oved t dil s t c pl i f f iur t sa e ac nm .S e N atons ar' M ot t D i m i s
o snis he om ant or al e o t t l i r
.

-

f Fal e t St t a Cli ,ECF N o.69Conwa sM ot t D imi sf Fal et St t a
or iur o a e
nm
y'
. o s s or iur o a e

s

Cli ECFNo 1 Thi matrwa r fte t UntdSttsMaitaeJ ge oe C.
am,
. 0. s te s eerd o ie ae gsrt ud J l

Hop frrpo ta rc mme éo p sa t 2 U.. j6 6q 17) .
pe o e r nd e o nda n, uru nt o 8 SC. 3 $() .
I azpo ta zc mme a is e onFe r ay1 20 8 t ma itaejd
n e r pd e o nd éoq su d
b u r , 1 ,he gsrt u ge
r com m e
e
nded gr i Conwa sm oéon t dimi sa gr ndng i pa tN a
antng
y'
o s s nd a
n r donsa '
t rs

m odon t dim is R&R,ECF N o.30,a 25.Spe ik t N a
o s s.
t
c f o dons a ' m odon,t m a st t
t rs
he gita e

jd erc
u g e omme e d n igt modo a t Plidfsc n ri cnm, rnt t
nd d e yn he
n s o an f' o veson li g a i he
ng
mo t dimist bra ho c ta tc m wiho p eudc bu wihla t a nd
éon o s s he ec f onrc bi t ut rj ie t t eve o me ,
a g a tngt emoto t ds s al he camswih p eudc .
nd r n i h
i n o imis l ot r li t r j ie R&R, No. 0 a 25
ECF 3 , t .
The r tga notcet t pa éest tt y had f zt e da wihi wlih t fl a
epor ve i o he r ha he
olre n ys t n lc o ie ny

o e to . Fe uay5 20 8 Plièif fldamoé fze e i o t t zs nd
bjcins On br r , 1 , ar fs l
t e
on o xtnson f i o epo
me
t t r por a r om m enda
o he e t nd ec
éon.P1. M ot f Ext nson ofTi e,ECF N o.32.
s' . or e i
m
The

ma itaej g e tnde t H f ro e do unt Fe u r 2 , 01 . de Grnd i
gsrt ud e xe d he me o bjc ns i br ay 2 2 8 Or r a ng n
l
Pa ta D e ng i Pa tM ot f Ext nson ofTi e ECF N o.29. andf st r afe
r nd nyi n r
. or e i
m ,
Pli f he e t r

t l fldo e do t terp tECFNo 3 ,a dNai sa r s nde o Fe r ay22
i y i bjc ns o h e or,
me e
. 6 n ton tr epo d n b ur ,
2018,ECF N o.40.

Fo t r a o sae beo t c r wilOVERRULE Pli f ' jc i ,
r he e s ns ttd l w,he ou t l
anùfs ob e tons
AD O PT t r ta r c m e i i ise ie y GRAN T Conwa sm odon t
he epor nd e om ndaton n t ntr t ,
y'
o
dit s ,GRAN T i par and D EN Y i par N a
snis
n
t
n
t éonsa ' m odon t dinns ,D I I
t rs
o s is SM SS

wihoutpr j i Pli f' r a h ofc c cnm a p o i eLEAVE TO AM EN D,
t
eud ce andfs b e c
onca t li nd r v d
a D I M I Swih pr j c al h rcamse c ptf rPli if' o e so cnm.
nd S S t eudi e lot e li x e o antfs c nv ri n li

2

1.

Rue7 oft Fe rl lsofCiiPz e t pemisap ryt f ev a dfl
l 2$) he dea Rue
vl oc due r t at o f r e n t
s
e
s cf wrte obe t 't ama itaejd 'pr posdfn n sa drc
peik, itn jci 'o gszt u ges o e idig n e omme a ns
ons
nd éo
wihi f ure n d y ofben sr e wih ac p o t r po t S eas 2 U..
t n o te a s
ig e v d t o y f ie e r. e lo 8 SC.

j6 6 $()TheFou t Cic th shedt ta obe tn pat mus dos f t s hce t
3 9 1.
th rui a l ha n jcig ry t o f h uf in
wi
s cfct s a ra o bl t aettedsrc c ut oft tueg o d frt o e do '
pe i iy o s e s na y o lz h itit o t he t r un o he bjc n.
i
'
Uni dSae v Nfd et, 78F.d6 6 6 2(t Ci. 0 ) cr d ne ,1 S Ct3 3
t tts . i te 4 3 1 , 2 4h r20 7, et e id 27 . . 0 2
e
(0 7.
2 0)
To c ude ot r s woul def at t pum os of t ltng
oncl
he wie
d e he
e
eqlii

o e éo . ewoud bepemién apat t a a a yis
bjc ns W
l
t t g ry o ppel n sue
ta wa beo e t maitaej g ,rg z ls oft n tr
h t s fr he gsrt ud e e ades he aue
a so ofo jc onsma et t ma itaej g ' rpo t
nd c pe be d
d o he gsrt ud es e r.
Eihe t diti tc tw oul t n ha t r viw e r is
t r he sz c our
d he ve o e e ve y s ue

i t ma itae j g ' p o e ûncn
n he
gstt ud es r posd
l gs a
i
nd
r om m e
ec
ndadons or couz s of a a s woul be r quied t
t
ppe l
d
e r o
r viw is t t diti tcour ne r consder I e t r
e e s ues hat he stc
t ve
i ed. n ihe

c s,jdiilrs t c swo l bewatda d tecsdc c ut'
a e u ca eol e ud
r
se n h l t t o ts
i
efci nesbae on hep fo maitaej g swo l be
fe t s sd
ve
l r m gstt ud e ud
unde m i d.
r ne

.
,

J.Thedititc u tmus deer neA no oa yp tono t maitaej g 'tpo t
-a
d
src o t t trni
v n ori f he gsrt ud es e r
a rc nz n d n t whihap op robe d h sb e ma e t dititc r ma
nd e o me da o o c r e jc on a e n d .The s c ou t y
a cptrjc, mo f t r c mme de diposdon rci flt re ie e o rnln
c e ,ee tor diy he e o n d s i ; e eve l he vd nc ; r e r
t

tematrt t maitaej g wihi tu éo . Fe R. v. 7 $()a c r 2
h te o he gsrt ud e t nsr c ns' d. Ci P. 29 39 c o d 8
'
U.. j6 6 $() f n rlo e i t tme eyrieaeagu nt pt s ntd t t
SC. 3 q 1 .T e a bjc ons ha r l etr t r me s e e e o he
Ge

ma itaej g lc tes cfct rq ie u e Rue7 a ha etesmeefc a a
gsrt ud e ak h peiiiy e urd nd z l 2, nd v h a fet s
fi r t obe to a awav rofs c o jcin. M o nv. X Te hs,nc,7 2F. up
al e o jc, r s ie u h be to ' o BW
u
'
c .l . 4 S p.
2 8 7 8 ( D. . 01 )(i ngVe v. tu ,5 F. up 2 8 , 4 ( D. .
d 2 , 29 W. Va 2 0 cd
ne Asr e 39 S p. d 41 8 5 W. Va
3

2 08)g.., 8F. ' 26 (t Ci. 01 ) seas Tho sv. n 47 U. 1 0 1 4
0 ),, 4 49 Appx 8 4h r2 2; e lo ma At, 4 S. 4 , 5
f.
f:
1
(9 () rrl esaued sno rqlr t j g t rve a is dqnovo i no
1 853) rlh ttt oe t e lie he ub e o e iw n sue .
f
.

obe ton aefld.)
jci s r le '.
'
Fut r o e éo ta o yrpetagu nt rie beo et ma itaej geae
rhe, bjc ns h t nl e a r me s asd f r he gsrt ud r

c nsd rdg n rl jc t t e ieyofterp ta rc
o iee e ea obedons o he ntrt h e or nd e omme do Se Ve ,
nda n. e ne
5 F.Supp.2d a 8 A st c tnot i y-qc :
39
t 45. he our ed n .
q
Alowi a ldga t obt i d. novo r viw ofhe e ie ca e
l ng i nt o
an t
e e
r ntt s
.

bymeeyr fr t ga erirbifa a o e d f kgs
rl eo maén n al re s n bjc on f ej
e
ma
t i ta r e e e t t m a st t us l s .The f tons of
he niil ef r nc o he gita e e e s
unc i
t diti t c t a e efe i y duplc t d a l0t t
he stc our r
f ctvel
i a e s n h he
m a st t a t diti t c t pe f m i néc l t s .Tli
git a e nd he s tc our r or de a a ks as

du iai oftmea efr watsj ca rs ure rt r
pl t
c on i nd fo t se udiil eo cs ahe
t n s vi t m , a nm s c r y t t pum os of t
ha a ng he
nd
ontar o he
es
he

Ma itae Ac. Ho r ( Se ' ofHe lh & Ht n S r sj
g sr ts t' wad v. c
'
at
l
ma e v .,
9 F. (0 j 5 9 g t Ci. 9 1j
32 2d 5 5, 0 ( h r 1 9 ).
6
539 F.Supp. a 846. pl i ifw ho r ie a eshi pr vi l r ied a pl ent wilnotbe
2d t
A antf
e t r t s e ousy a s r m s l

gve fhes c b t a t ea l ghes e . I I ta h sr - ldbre wi bete t d
i n f e ond ie t h ppe ) e ks' d. nse d, i e û e if l r ae
t
'
l

a ag n tlo e do whc ha t smeefc a afi r t o e tl
s e ea bjc n, ih s he a fet s al e o bjc.d.
u
I.
I

'' s r eamoto t ds s u de Fe ea RueofCiiPr e le1 ()a
Io u dv
in o imis n r d rl l
vl ocdt 2$)6,
r
c mpli mus c nti s fkintfc l atrwhc , fa c ptd a tu ,T tt llac m
o ant t o an u f e a ma m te ih i c e e s r e f aes bi
s

t rle t ti plusbl o isfc . As cofv. b l5 6U.. 6 ,6 ( 0 )(u g
o eif ha s a i e n t a e' h r t I a, 5 S 6 2 78 20 9 q odn
'
'

Bel l C9 . TFo ,5 OU. 5 4, 7 (0 7) Th c r mu tf c e t welp e
lAt.
v. ! mbl 5 S. 4 5 0 2 0 ). e ou t s f c pt he l ld
a
a lga
le donsoft com pli a t ' a fc t'e t f t a r as bl i e e es
he
ant s rue? nd fonst he ac s nd e ona e nf r nc
u
de i d t r r i t l m os f vor bl t t pli f1 I r v.Unie St t s 120
rve he efom n he i
ght
t a a e o he an:f 7 bara
td ae ,

F.d 4 2 4 4 (t Ci. 9 7 . es mei n tu f rlg l o l i .f e d r
3 7 , 7 4 h r 1 9 ) Th a s ot r e o e a c ncusons T a bae
Thz
4

r ct l oft elm ent ofa c us ofa
e ia s he e
s
a e cdon,s
uppored by m e e c l or sa e e s do
t
z oncus y t t m nt,

nots fc 'Iqba,556 U . a 6789s a s W a M oy D o s LLC v.Coza' 680 F. 359,
ufi e.' l
S. t
ee lo
e
t
t
3d

3 ( h Ci. 01 )
65 4t r 2 2 .
A pli fpr ee ng pt.. i hed t T e sstnge s a r ' t couns l d
andf oc di
t t s l o t s ti nt t nda ds' han
lq
l
ee
.

-

pl if ,a t c tm us cons r li orhe cli slbe al SeeErc on v.Pa dus 551
intfs nd he our
t
tue ns
r am i t ly.
iks
r ,

U. 8 , 4( 0 )Ho v r t c r n e no ino eace rfi r t algefcst tst
S. 9 9 20 7. we e,he ou t e d tg t la al e o l a t ha e
u
e
f t a c za ecli .SeeW elrv. e ' ofSoc.Se v c f Ci ofBali or ,901F.
orh ogni bl nm
le D t
r i es or
fm e
2d

38 , 91(t Ci. 9 0.nl of andfs sa'sa gt K,h c urw11fon i rlot
7 3 4h r 1 9 ) I kht Pli f' tt s q te o t 1f sde n h
u
c
t c mpli a t fc u l l g éo i Tlidfs r s s t t modo t d snisi
he o ant nd he a t a al a ns n an fq e pon e o he
e
n o ir s n
dee mi i wh t e gh hjcnm sc n s vv d s ns a. S omov. l I .N o
tr nng e h r t e li a ur ie inis l' h
'
A e nc, .

7:4c 0 20 5W L 7 7 20 a * ( D. . b. 4 2 5 ;seas Ch it sv. Ar of
1 v4 , 1
7 6 , t 2 W. Va Fe 2 , 01 ) e lo rsma The c

t Pid ntI .No 3:2 0 0 8 2 2R 2 05 8 , t* ( D. . uy1 , 01 )
he e mo -nc, . 1 > 0 0 , 01
9 5 4 a 2 W. VaJ l 6 2 2 .
1 1.
1

Thec t ha rve dPli f' bjci t t ma itaejdg ' rpota d
ou' s e iwe andfs o ç t o he gstt u es e r n
t
ons
rc mme to a dlnd t i obe d t bee ieywiho mei. andfspi rl
e o ndain n i s her jc ons o nt l t ut rtPli f rt i
r
m y

a v n et o e to l()t a pl a nofrsj iaat ti a donwa i er , n
d a c wo bjcins:1 he p i éo e udct o hs c
c
sn rora d
()t tz usi efrnc cnm s oudno beds se . ho t s o e do rieae
2 he o ùo ntree e li h l t imisd Bot f hee bjc ns etr t
ag me sp e i l ma t temaitaej g . e - ..Pl.M e i Opp.oDe.
r u nt rvousy de o h gsrt ud e S e eg, s' m.n
t f
Na onsa ' M o . o Dimis ECF No. 5 q 2 (r an fi r t i néf sme
d trs t t s s,
1 , t -5 a g ig al e o de y a
u
ta a i ors re ofta a i and a ia lt ofne è de e f om def ul s c aits
r ns cton
e i s r ns ctons
valbiiy
w vi nc r
a t pe i ls'

1Theeobjcbnsael tdt t ma itaej 'r c
s e t t i e o he gstt udges e omme donrgacigNai trs
mi
nda e rln tonsa'
mo in. e ECF No 3 , t4(l tematro Da il n y tePlidfsa c p l d eHo pes
t Se
o
. 6 a < n h te f n e Co wa ,h an f c e t u g p '
f
rc
e omme donl
nda
5

ts mon i Dea r S peirCou t;d a 9 1(r i i efrnc wihi u a e
e é y n lwae u êo
r)L. t -1 agung ntree e t ns ênc
.
a
p iy. eeo e éo fit i ndf s cf er r i t rpo ta rc mme t
ol )Th s bjc ns al o de y pei to sn he e r nd e o ndabn,
c
k
a aepr ryc nst da g n rl edonst tdonot ra tdeno rve &ç
nd r opel o tue s e ea objc
ha
warn
yo e iw. .
q
.
V ePC ,539 F.Supp. a 844
2d t -46.H owe r asPli f ar r s a r evet be ht
ve ,
andfs e o e nd ec i he ne

--

.

.

ofp o e dn u e ls srng ntsa dad ,hec r wi a d est s obedons
r c e ig nd r es ti e tn r s t ou t l d rs hee jc .
l
A.

Pl i f appea t c le t a i biiy ofb0t cnm pr cuson a is
andf s
r o halnge he pplca lt
h li e l i nd s ue
pr c uson t t i c pli . ga di c m pz cuson, anéfsc end ft tat
e l i o he r om ant Re r ng bi e l i Pli f ont fha lhough
t i cli sm ee m os oft z quie e sofpr l i t y c nnotc ét ea sngl
he r am
t
t he e r m nt
ecuson, he a
ons ut i e

cam. ECF No. 6 a 1 W h l i i u la wha Pli dfss cf l o e tt i t
li '
?
3 , t -2. ie t s nce r t an f pe ikal bjc o n he
y

rpor a r c mme ai t o e é i u e e sr be a et ma itaej g rze
e t nd e o nd ton,he bjc on s nn c say c us he gstt ud e t d
l
i t i fvo rgadigcnm prcuso Themaitaejdg rc mme de t tclm
n he. a r e r n li e l in.
r
gsrt u e e o n d ha li
pr cl i nota y be a et fr ta don wasnotc l i l r ol i ise ie y.
e uson
ppl c us he ls c
oncusvey es ved n t ntr t

R&R, No. 0 a 1 . ma itaej g e pli d,d andfsa epr s l a s a
ECF 3 , t 8 The gstt ud e x ane f i f r o e i nt, nd
pl
ég

teCou tnHe e usIddno e p esyp o iefroutihtds sa wihprjdieoft
h
ri gd
i t x rsl r vd o rg imisl t eu c he
e ie a
ntr céon i Pli if f ied t t ke flt ra don ors e t fl a a e
f a ntfs al o a irhe c
e k o ie n m nded c pli .'
om ant'

I . c uz f no mei t Pli f' bjc i a y t t ema itaej ges
d The o t i
nds
rt o anéfs o e éon,f n , o h gsrt ud '
z om m e
ec
ndadon r ga di cli pr l i
e r ng nm ecuson.

Pli if obe tdmo es cfc l t tema itaej g ' a pl a nofis
antfs jce r pei al o h gsrt ud es p i do sue
y
c
pr cuson.Pli if cont nd t tis pr cuson s d nota y bec us t t Hm ony
el i
a ntf s
e ha s ue e l i houl
ppl
a e he es

ofEle Br ndt adef ul s ils f N adonsa M orga i t f ecosue a don i
ln a ,
a t pecait or
tr
t ge, n he or l t c
n

Dea r pr s nt ne e i e c r lva tt t i a to Se P1.Re p. oMa itael dg
lwa e e e s w v d n e ee n o h s cin. e s' s t gsrt u e
6

J e C. pesR&R, No. 6 a 2 . ema itaej g o ya pl dis
o l Hop '
ECF 3 , t -3 Th gsrt ud e nl p i sue
e
pr cuson t t is sr va t t i c m ofi e i li lc
e l i o he s ue de nt o be r bi
nt ntona nfiéon ofe odona dite s
m
l sr s .

S eR&R, No. 0 a 1 -2 I He e s1 tec ztac ptdtema itaej g '
e
ECF 3 , t 8 0.n
du ,h ot c e e h gsrt ud es
r
r om m e don t Pli f had notalged a s :c e lve ofouta
ec
nda
hat anéfs
le
uf i nt e l
r geous si
nes n

Na
éons a ' c
t rs onduc ozt tt y s f r d a spafc nty s ve e de z e ofem oéonaldites .
t ha he ufe e i ii a l e r g e
sr s
SeeH e edusv. a
N dons a M or . LLC,N o.5: CVtr
t,
16- 00001,
2016 W L 5
477579,at*
6

( D. .un 1 , 1 ) r pr a r c rme a a o td No. :6CV- 0 , 0 6W L
W. VaJ e 5 20 6,e t nd e on pd éon d e , 51 - 0 1 2 1
5 6 23 ( D. . p . 9 2 6 .
6 0 9 W. Va Se t 2 , 01 )
I or rf ris ep e l i n t a pl,fj is si t pro lé a i mus be
n de o s u r cuso o p y tthe sue n he i r ig t
g
on t

i nt a t t eis ss ug tt begr cud d . Po kv. nt o
de i l o h sue o h o p e l e l' l Mo me C .78 F.d 1 9 ,
c
?
, 2 2 16

1 01(t Ci. 9 6. pat ma se t a i is p e lsono t g o ndso n w
2 4h r 1 8 )A zy y e k o vod sue r cu i n he r u
fe
e ie e S eR ev. S Ste Mi Co.8 6F. up 2 4, 7 - ( D. .1 9 )
vd nc . e
U.. e l n. , 5 S p. 7 2 8 79 E. Va 9 4
(l ra a gs c ohe cru tnc sg d tt ln t a pl a it ofsue
fmpo tnt mon u h t r ic msa e i ee- n g he p i bly is
f
n
mii
c i
p e lson i . . w e d n eha be omea ia l t a c ul l eyla t adfee t
r cu i j s . ne vie c s c
valbe h t o d i l e d o ifr n
k

rs t( otn Rettme (e o )o J dg nt j2 ,c mme t()Ho ve,fthe
eul.qu ig sae nt S c nd f u me s 9 o n j . we r fj
)
l
a ia i ofc lt r lesoppe doe notde nd on w het rne e de e ha be n
pplc ton
ola e a t
l s
pe
he w vi nc s e
unc r d orwhe he t pli fha i ntfe adif r ntc us ofac
ove e
t r he anéf s de ii d fe e a e
éon;i t d,
nsea
c lt r lesoppe de
ola e a t
l pendson thei nét oft is st tw e e ltga e i t e rir
t de y he s ue ha r ii t d' n he a le

s t'S eS rzv. aa, 1 7 8 LM BTCB, 1 W L 3 1 1 , t* ( D . . .
ui. e wa t M tl No. 1 CV4 2
'
20 7
61 7 5 a 3 E. Va Aug

2 , 01 )( ena ctdo omitd ; i I elct l nt e ILLC v. ia OneFi
2 2 7 i r l ia ns te ) . ntl tz Ve urs
nt
q
e a
Ca tl
n.
Ct p , 8 F. u 3 6 1 71 ( Md. 01 )(ppyn c l trle t ppe i pae a d
-z . 2 0 S pp. d 9 , 9 D. 2 7 a li g ol ea so ln tnt c on
)
a

.

7

ddes t t ne f c u al ga
f pie he w a t al le donsbef em e t al ge t e ntm a ke hasnotc nged
or
, he le d elva
t t
ha

i amaeil f).
n
tra wa
Pl ntfsdo note an how M s Br ' al ge ne t si ony i r lva t t
ai if
xpli
. andts le d w e fm
s ee nt o he
is s r
s ues uroundi i e
ng nt ndonali lc
niidon ofem otona dites .Alhough M s Br '
i l st s t
. andts
t tm onyi ne t t M ga
es i
s w o he
éon a awhol i i unce rhow t se de e c zd bepa tof
s
e, t s la
hi vi nc otl
r
.

t is c i r wih t i e odona dites cnm . s Br ndtst s i ony doe not
he s ues onsde ed t he r m
.
l s r s li M . a ' e tm
s
a a t a f tany oft eem e sofa i entona i lci ofe otona dites c lm ,
ppe r o fec
he l nt
n nt i l nfi ton
m i l sr s li

no doPli if e pli i t e.c mpli ,o jc on, ra yot e fl g ho t t s
r
antfs x an n h i o ant b e é o n h r l n s w he e dmon
t
i
y
c nge t r lva is sbe wee t fr tand s c
ha s he ee nt s ue t n he ls
e ond a éons Theis szr lng
c
.
s ues lrounci
t s aEe tonst r f e a ei ntca be we n t t a tons M s Bt ndtst fm ony
he e ga i he e or r de i l t e he wo c i . . a ' esi
doesnotpr bi t a i a i ofis pt cl i t t c tspr vi fndi
ohi t he pplc ton s ue e uson o he our' e ous i ngs

rg r n i e to lnfc nofe do ldsrs. ma itaejd a opitl
e adig ntnina i l éo
i
mo na ites The gsrt u ge ppr raey
apple is pr cuson.
id s ue e l i
Even i t c tw e e t fnd t tt i s s r
f he our r o i ha he s ues ur oundi i e i li lc
ng nt ntona nfi don of

em oéona dites we e notpr cl
l sr s r
e uded,Pl i f ha notde onsr t d ho M s Br ndts
andfs ve
m
ta e w
. a '
t tm ony s st tN a
esi
how ha
donsa ' a tonswe e out a ousoti olt bl Cf Rus o v.
trs c i
r
r ge
nt e a e. . s

Wlie 4 0S. 2 1 0 1 2 3( .1 9 )( slbn t bg t ehodt saeacam fz
nt, 0 E.d 6 , 6 -6 Va 9 1 deci ig he ih hrs l o tt li o
i e i na i lc ofe ina cite s. rt si nyas h sn be rn o whehe
ntnto lnfiéon moto l l r s) He e tmo lo a o ai g n t r
s
Pli f s f r d s ve e e odona dite s whih t cour f
anéfs ufe e e y m
l sr s , c he
t ound wasnota qua ey pld
de t l e
i t l tac i SeeH e edusv.N a i t rM or . LLC,N o.5: CVn he as ton.
tons a
t,
16- 00001,201 W L
6

5 7 7 , t* ( . Va J e1 , 01 ) r o ta r c
47 5 9 a 6 W D. . un 5 2 6, e r nd e omme do a o td, 51 nda n d e No. :6

CV- 0 , 01 W L 5 6 2 9( D. . e . 9 20 6 rTlitfs Co antst frhno
012 6
6 0 3 W. Va S pt2 , 1 ) anif' mpli es o t
8

f ct s
a s howi t N a
ng hat dohsarac e i awa t wasout a ousori olr bl,ort tt
t, t d n
y hat
r ge
nt e a e
ha hey
s f r sveee
uf e ed e r modo ldsz s be a s o t sc uc. Li et f s c mp an i t e
na ite s c u e f hi ond t). k he t t o lit n h
'
r
.

ir ta i Pli f 'com pli i tùsa
- s cton, anéfs
l
ant n l cdon doe notalge s ve eem odona dites .
s
le e r
l sr s
Pl ndfsha f ie t s a e ac qm f i e i li lcdon ofe otona dite s
ai f ve al d o t t l i oz nt ntona nfi
m i l sr s .

Plitfs obedont t ma itaej g 'rpo ta rc mme a rg r ig
anif' jc o he gsrt ud es e r nd e o nd don e adn
pr cl i i wihoutm ert
e uson s t
i.
B.

Pliéfsne tc a n t ma itaejd 'rc mme daint dsas t i
an f x h Ee ge he gsrt u ges e o n to o inis hez
tr usitree ecam frfi et saeacnm.nt i o jcin, antfsagu t t
o éo nefrnc li o al o tt li I het be to Pli if r e ha
ur
Na
donsa çf c - ac d i tr nceon t hom e
t r ror e pl e nsza
he
owne si ur nc polc 'a f e r c Ey
r ns a e iy''nd d ctonia
el
c led Pl ntf s pad- polc a r plce i wih t i own.7Se P1. Re p.t
ancel ai if' i up iy nd e a d t t her
7 e s' s o

Ma itael d J e C. pesR&R, No. 6 a 3 Pli f a a t a va et
gstt u ge o l Hop '
ECF 3 , t . andfs ppe r o d nc wo

g nea sb-bjcinst tedsnisl t ttiusi eftnc cnm.
e rl u o e to o h ir sa of he o to ntree e li
Fis, antfsagt a ans tea lcblt oftsj iaat t t do
rtPli if r z g i t h ppia ii
e
y e udct o he or us
i e f rnc cnm. e Pl.Rep.oM a itaeJ g oe C. ppesR&R, No. 6 a
ntre e e li S e s' s t gsr t ud el l Ho '
ECF 3 , t

3 4 (o aigdfee e i alg di efrnc b t e ftta sc a do )The
- c mp rn ifrncs n l e ntree e eve n ts nd e ond c ns.
e
ma itaejd edi nota pl t sj iaat tetr ou i efrn ecamsf st e
gsrt u g d
p y e udc t o h o é s ntre e c li ç hos
a
pe t i t a st tpc ur e a t rt fr taci wa dir s e ' R&R,ECF N o.30,a 16.
ran o ct ha c t d fe he ls ton s snis d.
;
t

Th r f r , h sobjc ni wiho a yba i.
e e o e t i e éo s t ut n ss
S c nd, anéfso e tt t a lc bl yofsaelw t t ett r usi e fr nc
e o Pli f bjc o he ppia ii t t a o h i o do ntre e e
t
c m . c eSt e Fa m I ur nc i ana:onwi com pa Pl i f cont nd t t i
bi Be aus at r ns a e s
de
ny, anéf s
e hat her

clm f l flund rfd rllrs ito whe t r i i eftn ewihabuie s
li f d al e e ea jlidcin n hee s ntree c t
wou
sn s
9

r léons p' and t t y fs d bepe r ted t a e st sunde f de a lm ' Pl.
ea
hi '
hat he çhoul
rnit o ddr s hi
r e r l a ' s'

Re p. o Ma itaeJ g oe C. ppesR&R, No. 6 a 3 4.Thec ur ha
s t gsr t ud el l Ho '
ECF
3 ,t o t s

jrs it o rPli if'oéousi efrn ecom pu sa tt di riyjrs c n. e
u idci ve antfs tr
on
ntree c li ru n o vest l idido Se
a
28U. C. j1 3 9Co .ECF No. , t21(e kn $ 75 0i c mpe ao yda g s
S. A. 3 2 mpl
,
1 a se ig 5 ,0 n o nstr ma e
a d $ ,0 ,, i purd d ma e , a algngcnmsa ans di r epa de) W hl
n 20 00 0 n l ve a g sz nd l i li g i t ve s r s. ie
0
i
e
Pli f 'cnm sa ebr
anéfs li z oughti f r lcotr ,t t dousi er e encecli i s lgove ne
n ede a zt he or
nt f r
nm s dl
r d

bysaelw. e Cha sv.o on, 0Va 1 2, 3 S. 2d9 (9 5 (e o nii
tt a S e ve J hns 23 . 1 3 5 E. 7 1 8 )z c g zng
c r mo lw t r oft r usi tre e ew11 c r c rg si Vigna . efc t a Sa e
o n n a o t o éo n e fr nc t1 onta t iht n ri il Th a t h t tt
.
'
Fa m l ur nceha ofi e na i
r ns a
s fc s tonwi doesnotc nge t a i a e1w t t sc m .
de
ha
he pplc bl a o hi bi

I Vigi a Pli if sa e aprm a f ce ca ef t dousi e f r nc bypl di
n r ni, a ntfs t t
i a i s or or
ntr e e e
ea ng:

f 1 t e se c ofavai c nta ma rldo hp orbusne se pe tnc ;()k wld e
ç ) he xit n e
(
l o z c l ea ns i
d
i s x c a y 2 no e g
oft zlto hp o e ca yo t pa to t i tze o ; 3 i t n a i tre e e
he eai ns i r xpe tnc n he r f he n e fr r () n e don l n e ft nc
i i orca i abr a ort t na oft t l i hi ore ct y;and
nducng
usng
e ch e- don he eatons p
mi
xpe anc

()r sla tda g t t pat wh erlt l o e pe tn yha be ndst td.
4 eutn ma e o he ry os eai ùp r x ca c s e irz e '
ons
p '
Duaa v. % a Trns nsi S s LLC, 5 SE.d31 , 8( . 01 )Co t ig
tl Cot n a nison .
7 4 . 2 3 31 Va 2 4. nsnzn
Pli if' ompanta isot rfl g l rl ,t c u ta ze wihtema itaejd es
antfs c li nd t he ln s i al he o r g e s t h gszt u g '
i be y
r om m enda i t tPl i if ha fie t alge da a f om t t tousi erer .
ec
ton ha antfs ve a ld o le
m ge r
he ori nt f ence

R&K ECF No.30,a 21 Thei ut wasr i tt and algatonst tt i
t -22.
ns ance
ensaed
le i ha her
2Thec ttnot t ajzidc la unti c ryes r q rme f a otbeme meeyby
otr es hat trs idona mo n onto ry e uie ntf mz
c
t rl
pr y ng f e or t ntpunii da a e whih ce ry a e nota hodz d by t sa ut a
a i or x bia
tve m g s c l a l t
ut
e
he t t e nd
wli ilt
ach t hese cr sancesw oul begr sy e svei a e nt' H uf sete v.D avi ,309 F.
icum t
d
os l xces i n ny ve .' t t lr
es
.. .

S p 1 7 , 3 4( D. . 9 0 (iigFe n v. ie Sae Fd l & Gu rn Co, 4
u p. 3 2 1 7 N. Ga 1 7 ) ct lmi Untd tts iei
n
aa
.1 6
F.d1 8(t Ci. 9 4 Ast ed fn a sh v n t as dti is ,h c u t su st e
2 2 5. r 1 4 :. l ee d nt a e o rie ls sue t e o r a s me h
h
a
a
a u to c nt v ryi u h l n e a e ecsscv ri jts id n S eRo ro v. l,
mo n f o to es s nc al g d nd x rie l est uidc o . e bes n Dae
e
i y
4 4F. u p. 8 , 8 ( . N. 1 7 )(x liiga t o c nto es i o dn rl a cptda
6 S p 6 0 6 3 M D. C. 9 9 e pqnn momt f o t v ry s r iai c e e t
y
f val butf
ace uey
orum sat s r esr gar ng m eas e ofdam a and ava l lt ofs ala
t e' ul e di
m
ges
iabiiy peci nd
puni dam agesat t be r vi
dve
eo
e ewed i t def
f he endantchal
lengest epli f sae nt.
h andf' ttme )
s
,

1
0

r l i li wih t i l la nti fs r i d' a ha fbe om e a f om f t bl '
eatonszp t her oca ge s ftane ' nd s < c
n unc or a e
a r nge e ' a ei ufki ntt cons t da a Se Com pl.ECF N o.1,a 12,19.
r a m nt' r ns i e o
dm e m ge. e
.
t

Nohigi Pli if' bjc onss a st da g si fc,h obe donsa i n et t
t n n antfs o e d pe k o ma e;n a tte jc
r n ot ha
tei u a epoiywa ri ttd Se Pl.Rep.oM aitael d lo lC. pes
h nsrnc l
c s ensae . e s' s t gsrt u ge e Hop '
R&R,ECF N o.36,at3 Bas on t f ct ale i a1oft pl di , anéfsha
-4. ed
he a s lged n 1 he ea ngs Pli f ve
f ie t s a ea cni f t dousi e f r nc
al d o t t l m or or
nt r e e e.

Plitfsobetont t ma itaejd 'rpor a rc mme a nrg ti
anif' jci o he gsrt u ges e t nd e o nd do e adng
ist tousi e f r
t ori nt r e ence cnm alo i wihoutm e i.
li s s t
rt
I
V.

Fort r as sat a ve,t c tm a st f l ng fndi :
he e ons t ed bo he our ke he olowi i ngs

1 Thec tr ADOPTStetpo ta rc mme ain ( No. 0 i ise ttt.
.
ozt
h e r nd e o nd t ECF
o
3 ) n t niey
2. Thec ut OVERRULESPli f' bjci ( No. 6 t t rpo ta
o t
andfs o e t ECF
ons
3 ) o he e r nd
r com m e don.
e
nda

Thec ur GRANTSCo wa ' mod t dimis( No.1 )a dDI M I ES
o t
n ys on o s s ECF
0 n S SS
a1cnmsa ans li wih pr j i e
1 li g i t nm t eud c .
Thecolr G RAN TS i partand D EN I S i par N a
zt
n
E n
t éons a ' m odon t dimi s
t rs
o s s

( No. ) Thec ur DENI Nainsa' moi wihrs c t Pli f'
ECF 6.
o t
ES to trs ton t epe t o andfs
c
onve son cnm .
r i li The c tGR AN T S i par N atonsatsm oton wih r i tt
our
n t i t '
i
t e pec o

Pli if' e c ofc nta tc m, I M I SI G t csm wiho pr j c a d
antfs br a h o r c bi D S S N he li t ut eudi e n
p o i ig LEAVE TO AM EN D t cam wihn hfe n (5 d y oft e tyof
r v dn
he li t i te 1 ) a s he n r
t s or r AI ofPli f ' e ari c m s i udi c lm sf t dous
hi de . I
andfs z m izng bi , ncl ng l i or or
i e f r nce f lii a
nt r e e , a sfc don ofbusne sr coz ,i e
i s e ds nt néona i lc i ofe odona
l nfiton
m
l

dites ,el a e,a e ofpr s ,a m ai i pr ec i a e D I I
st s der bus bus
oce s nd lcous os uton, r SM SSED

wih pr j c .
t eudi e
An a oprat O r rw ilbeent r dst sda
ppr i e de l
r e hi y.

Entrd & J- 2 1- z- t
ee :
- - 0 &

4 / M4haelF.$/. '- V-C '
r Urbans
$M
Zi
c
'
.
Urie S ae Ditlt udg
l d tts stc l e
t

12