Hegedus et al v. Nationstar Mortgage LLC et al

Filing 66

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/11/2018. (jv)

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STRICT COU RT
FO R TH E W E STERN D I
STRICT O F W RGI I
N A
HA RR I
SON BU R G D I SI N
W O

CLERKS OFFI t
CE J
,
S. ST
ATROANOKEDS . O URT
F
ZVA
I
LED

DE jj j
r
j
JUL

BK

J ESA. EGEDU S e a y
AM
H
,t1

/

R C RK
Rà
(

Pl ntfs
ai if ,

Ci lActon N o. 5: 7cv53
vi
i
: 1

V.

N ATI N STAR M O RT GAGE LLC,
O
By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansl
d
D ef
endant
.

Chi fUG t d St t sDit tJ
e
e a e sdc udge
M EM O RAN DU M O PI I N
N O

Pli f Jme a VignaHe e sr nnéfs' rfh He e e' a e tng
anéfs a s nd rii g du Tli f'o f e g duss), pp ai
t
p- . , r u tt sa ton a ans De e n Na onsa Mo ta LLC O e e nt or
-q K b o gh hi ci g i t fnda t d tz rg ge
r
fnda '
'
t to tr), l gngO s on c r ltd t Na trssr i ofamo ta ea t
f insa ' al i
Na
e
c du t eae o éonsa ' e dcng
rg g nd he
s e ntf e l ur on at sde pr vi l owne by Pl i f i Sus ex Count ,
ubs que or c os e
e i nce e ousy
d
nndf s n s
y

D ea r N a
lwa e. éonsa fl t pz s ntM odon t Di nls f Fal e t St ea Cli on
tr led he e e
o s is or iuz o at
qm

Api4 20 8 Pu s ntt 28U. C. 6 6q 17) t c ur rfre bo. mo nst
rl , 1 . zua o
S. j 3 $() ,he o t eerd t éo o
h
Urie Sae Ma itaeJ g J e C. ppefrarpo ta rc mme a . tr
l d tts gsrt ud e o l Ho o e r nd e o nd don Afe
t
he rn o a agu ntfo t pade o une2 , 1 ,hema itaejd erc mme e
aig rl r me r m he r s nl 6 20 8 t
gsrt u g e o nd d
g a ngNa nsa' moéo i 61. He e ussfldobeéonst t rpo ta
rné
do trs
n n 1 The g d e l
1
e jc
o he e r nd
r om m endaton on O c obez29,2018.
ec
i
t

Fo t er a o sae beo t c u t l OVERRULE t He e us s o e do ,
r h e s ns ttd lw, he o r wi
l
he g d e ' bjc ns
AD O PT t r por a r com m e don t t e entconssentwih tasopi on,a
he e t nd e
nda
o he xt
it
t li ni nd
G

T Na
éons a ' m odon t dir s .
t rs
o snis

Rue7 $)oft Fe rl lsofCi l ocd epe- t apat t f ev a fe
l 2
he dea Rue
viPr e ur t s ry o f r' nd l
mi
s e
l
s cfc wrte obetons'oama itaejd ' p o e f n a rc
pe i , itn jci 't
gsrt u ges r posd mdigs nd e omme a
nd dons
wihi f ure n d y ofben s r e wih ac pyo t r po t S eas 28U.. j
t n o te a s
ig e v d t o f he e r. e lo
SC.

6 6q 1. Fo t Cicz ha hedt ta o jc pat mus d s f t s fkint
3 $()The urh zkt s l ha n beéng ry t o o f h ul e
.
i
wi

s cûct s a rao bl t aett cititc u toft t l gou ftteo e do '
pei iy o s e s na y o lr he l tc o r he te ' nd o h bjc n.
s
n r
'
UntdSae v. d et, 78F.d6 6 6 2(t Ci. 0 ) cr de id, 2 S. . 0 2
ie tts Mi te 4 3 1 , 2 4. r20 7, et ne 1 7 Ct3 3
h
(00 )
2 7.
To c l ot r s woul deea t put e ofr qlii
oncude hewie
d / t he pos
e ltng

ob e éons W ewozd bepev it apa t t a pe la is e
jc .
ll
tnti
ng ry o p a ny su
t twa be o e t e ma itae jd e rgad e s oft naut
ha s f r h gsrt u g , e r ls
he t e
a d sopeo o e éo ma et t ma itaejd ' rp t
n c
f bjc ns d o he gsrt u ges e or.
Eihe t diti t c twoul t ha t r viw e r is
t r he s rc our
d hen ve o e e ve y s ue

i t ma itae jdg ' pr sd f n s a
n he
gsrt u es opo e mdig
nd
r com m enda i or c 's of a
e
tons
out
t
ppeas w oul be r r d t
l
d
equie o
r viw is s t tt ditit c t ne r c i r d.l et r
e e s ue ha he s rc our ve onsde e n ihe

c s ,j iil e o r e wo d bewa td a t dsrc c r'
a e udca r s u c s ul
se nd he itit ou ts
e f ci ne s ba e o hep fo ma itae jd s wo d be
fe t s sd n l r m gsrt u ge ul
ve
unde m i
r ned.

J.Th dititc tr mus d tr ne7qno a ypo do oft ma itaejd 'rpo t
-a e src ozt t eemi . vo n r n he gsrt u ges e r
d
a rc
nd eomme to t whihap o ro e to ha benma e f dstc c ur ma
ndain o c r pe bjcin s e d .The itit o t y
a c ptr jc, rmod f t r c
c e , ee t o
iy he e omme d ds séo r c i f the e de e o r tr
nde ipo i n; e eve l t r vi nc ; r eu n
l

tematrt t ma itaejd wihi tu do . Fe R. v P. 29 3; c o d2
h te o he gsrt u ge t nsrc ns' d. Ci. 7 $() a c r 8
'
U.. j6 69 1.f nea obe to t tmeeyrieaeagu n sprsntdt t
SC. 3 $()t zl jcins ha rl etrt r me t e e e o he
Ge
ma itaej g lc t s cfct r q ie und rRu e7 a ha et s meef c a a
gsr t ud e a k he pe iiiy e ur d e l 2, nd v he a fe t s
ft et obe t o a awave ofs c ob e ton. Moonv.
al o jc, r s i r u h jci '
'
ur
'
BWX Te hs, nc, 4 F. u
c .I .7 2 S pp.
2 8 7 8 ( D. . 0 0 (ii Ve v. tu ,5 F. up 2 8 , 4 ( . Va
d 2 , 29 W. Va 2 1 ) ctng ne Asr e 39 S p. d 41 8 5 W D. .

20 8)af 4 8F. x2 (t Ci. 0 2; e as Tho sv Ar 4 4U.. 4 , 5
0 ), f' 9 App' 68 4h t 2 1 ) se lo ma . n, 7 S 1 0 1 4
d,

(9 54) rtRhesaut do snot e let j g t zviw a is e.<no i no
1 8 3) r tt e e rq'r he ud e o e e n su d vo f
i
obe éo a efld.
jc ns r t >
e ).

Futh r obe ù st tonyrp a agu nt rie beor tema itaejd eae
t e, jc on ha l e e t r me s asd f e h gsrt u g r
c nsd r d g nea obe éo t t ee ieyoft er po ta r c mme a on. e Ve ,
o i e e e r l jc ns o h ntrt h e r nd e o nd d S e ne
539F.Supp. at845. t c tnotdi y.lt
2d
As he out e n . ky:
t

Alo n al ka t obnn 2:n vo rve ofh re iec s
lwig i nt o ti
t
o e iw
e nt ae
t
b meeytfr tiga e tirbre a a o e éo f kgs
y rl eo matn n al if s n bjc n f ej
e
ma
t i éalr f r nce t t m a itat us es .The f nc
he ni e e e
o he g sr e el s
u dons of
t ditit c zt a e e f dvey duplc t as 10t t
he s rc otr r fec l
ia ed
3 h he
m a s r t a t diti c t peror i néc l t s .Tli
gita e nd he srct our
f m de a a ks ls

d pl a n oft a ef r watsj iilrs u c srt r
u i do
c
i nd fo t se udca eo re ahe
me
t
han s vi t , a r
a ng hem nd uns conta y t t pur e of t
t r o he
pos s
he

Ma itae Ac . Ho t ( S c o He 1 & Ht na S r s ,
gsr t s t' wa d v. e ' f at
'
h
u n ev j
9 2 F.d (05, 0 g t Ci. 9 1j
3 2 5 1 5 9 ( h z 1 9 ).
6
5 F.Supp.2d a 8 A pli ifwho r ie a e hi pr vi l r ie a gum e swilnotbe
39
t 46. antf
et r t s s e ousy as d r
nt l

gv n fhes c d bt a t a e( h s e . I . nse d hi r -t d bre wil te td
ie f e on ie t he ppl j e e ks' d I ta , s e fl if l be ra e
t
'
e

a ag nea o e éo whihha t smeefc a afi et obe tl
s e rl bjc n, c s he a fe t s al o jc. d.
ur
II.

N ai trsBrefi Suppor ofisM odon t Dinns Pli if 'Am ende Pladi
tonsa ' i n
t t
o s i s antf s
d e ng

agu st tt Dea r Cou t r l gpr èud st He e us s csmso 10 hr sj iaa
r e ha he lwa e r' ui e l e he g d e ' li n 3 t e udc t
s n

(li prcuso a c ltrl sop l(su p el in go sl He e uss
clm e l in) nd ol ea et pe is e rcuso ) t und .The g d e '
a
a e d c pli a
m nde om ant Eege t N a
s hat donsa br ac d isc t t a a good f ih
tr e he t ontac u l nd
at
oblga i by f ii t a y t i pa m e st t l n i e es a prncpalpur uantt
i tons alng o ppl her y nt o he oa nt r t nd i i
s
o
t t r soft a e m entzThetorg na c pl i i l
he e m
he gr e
.
i i i l om ant ncuded a cam f conve son,
li or
ri

1Be a e t c ta ee wih t s gr unds t r i no ne t a r s N a trsa t m a a gu e s
c us he our gr s t he e o , he e s
.
ed o dd e s dons a ' le dve r m nt.
2Pli f 'org' a c p anti l d a va i y ofcnm sa ii f om smia f ct.O ft e c m s a l r dimis d
a néfs im l om l i ncude
ret
li rsng r i lz a s
hes bi , l we e s s e
s ve one c m f c eri howe r Pbi if we egi n la t a e t i br a h ofco z c c m .Or r
a
bi or onv son;
ve , ntfs r ve e ve o m nd her e c
nta t bi
de
Adoptng R.& R.ECF N o. 1.
i
,
42,

a ii fom sm ia f c s whi s vi N adonsa ' ft tm oton t dimi s N atonsa
rsng r
i l r a t , ch ut ved
t rs ss
i o s s . i tr

big t pe l moé t dirisbot camsu e Rul 1 4 6.
rn s he ncng on o sns h li nd r e 21 )
i
$(
A.

Rue1 $()oft Fe rl lsofCiiPr e r pe isap ryt mo fr
l 29 6 he dea Rue
vl ocdu e v t at o ve o
dinas a ofa c pl ntf f iur t sa ea cni upon wli h t le c n begr e To
s is l
om ai or al e o t t l m
lc ei f a
ant d.

s vi amoé t dsns und rRue1 $() tepan fmu tpeds hce fcsfo
ut ve
on o inis e l 29 6,h lidf s la uf int a t f
t
r iea rghtt r i a
as i o elef bovet s c a lve' and fsat acli t t i t ti plusbl
he pe uléve e l?
ft e nm o elef ha s a i e

o isfc . Bel lCo . Two ,5 0U.. 4 ,5 5 5 0(00 )A pli f
n t a e' lAt.
'
v. mbl 5 S 5 4 5 , 7 2 7. sndf
l
etbihe fail lusblt b pla igKatzl one tt talwst c r t drw te
sa l s f ca pa iii y e dn f ct c tn ha l he ou to a h
s f
f'
f a
o
r s bl i e enc t tt def nda i la e f t mi c
ea ona e nf r e ha he e nt s ibl or he s onductalged.' s r tv.
le 'A hc of

L b l5 6U. 6 2, 7 (0 )l tlngona1 $()moéo tec r mus a cptal
q a, 5 S. 6 6 8 2 09. n nl
i
29 6
n,h ou t t c e l
w elpl a d alga i i t com pli a t e a dr w alr ona e f t li e e si
l- e de le tons n he
ant s ru nd a l eas bl ac ua nf z nce n

tel htmos fvo a et t pli ifI rav. tdSae, 2 F.d47 , 7 (t Ci.
h i
g
t a rbl o he antf.bar Uni tts 1 0 3 2 4 4 4h r
e
1 9 ) Ho ve,fth e d r r ctl oft ee nt o ac us ofa t s po td b
9 7 . we r ç l r a ba e e ias he lme s f a e c i up re y
g
on,
m e econcus y sat e s do nots f ' I l 556 U. a 6789s eW a M or D o s
r
l or t em nt,
ufi ' qba,
ce.
S. t
e
e

LLC v. z r, 0F.d3 9 3 (t Ci. 0 2 Soli t c ur f e dno a c p lga
Co at68 3 5 , 65 4h r 2 1 ) dng he o tf e t ce te l
n
concusonscouc d a f t orunw a r ed i e e es unr a ona e c l i ,or
l i
he s ac s
r ant nf r nc , e s bl oncusons

agt nt' (n e na q tdonmakson itd .
r z s' i tr l uo a
me )
r ate )
he
ts i
o
d he r
I r c don ofPli if ' q . st t and t Cour ' oblgadon t hol t i
n e ogni
antfs pz K a us
-

pla ngst Kes srnge sanda dst n f m a pladi dz t d by lwy r ,'t Colt
e di o < s ti nt t r ha or l e ngs afe
l
a e s' he xt
wilas c i rf c spr e e i Pl néfs opposton bre sa a t c d r e
l lo onsde a t es nt d n ai f '
ii
i f nd ta he elvant

do u nt. ik o v. z us 5 1U.. 9 9 (0 7 ( rc im)(ttn t tadoc me
c me s Erc s n Pad , 5 S 8 , 4 2 0 ) pe uta sai g ha
u nt

fl p - a mus bel e al c nsr e ) S omov. l l .20 5W L 7 76 , t*
led z q t i rl o tu d ; h
q
b y
A e nc, 1
7 20 a 2
.

( D. . b 2 , 5 (onsdei f ot t ec li a t ef ct alg d i
W. Va Fe . 4 201 ) c i rng f h h ompant nd h a tml l a ons n
b
e
S omo' r s e ..i deet nigwhehe hscnm sc n s r ds sa7. e
h s epons . n trni n
t r i li a u dve imisl) Se

W it nv. d.ns Co.1 4F. x3 5 3 6(t Ci. 0 )@e c im)(x bi t
thoh Fe I . , 6 App' 9 , 9 4h r2 06 r ura e p nig
n
t ta c tm a wihoutconve éng am oton t cir s i o a m oton f s m a y
ha our y, t
r
i o lsnis nt
i or um r

j g nt K onsde . . oc nt c nta t pli fscnm . . ol a t a le éct
ud me ,f i r . d ume s e tl o andf li . s ong s he ut n iy
c
a
oft e edo ume si no d s td7 Fu t t r ,f he t pli fatc so
h s c nt s t ipu e ). rhe mo e Tg n he anéf ta he r
wj
i op or esadocum e upon whih hi c m i bas orwhe t com pli ot r s
nc
at
nt
c s bi s ed,
n he
ant he wie

s o t tt epli iha a ptd t c e soft do l nt't eCou t i c e i t e
h ws ha h anéf s do e he ontnt he cl , h
me :
t w. r dt h
l
l
cont soft doc entove c t di or al donsi t c pl nt G oi sv.Val
ent
he um
r onta ct y lega
n he om ai . ne
le

Cmt S r s Bd.8 2F.d 1 9 1 7 (t Ci. 01 )
p ev. , 2 3 5 , 6 4h r2 6 .
B.

The H e dus ' es ntc m sa ie fom a m orga a e m e f pr r yt y
ge es pr e bi rs r
t ge gr e nt or ope t he

owne i Sus e Count D ea r .Bot pa tesa r t tt H e
d n sx
y, lwa e
h ri g ee ha he gedus e e ed i o a
es ntt nt
m or ga contac * t:Fis H orzon H om eLoa Com ot ton on t Sus e Count
t ge
r t . rt
1
i
n
ai
he s x
y

pr t i 2006.Com pl,ECF N o.1 2 - 3.N a
opery n
.
,
donsare e e a s e i a e m e
t nt r d ubs rdcng gr e nt

wihFis Ho ion o J 21 20 1 tkn o e f rMe f Ba , h p e i ussr ie .
t rt rz n une , 1 , a ig v r o Gie nk t e r v o e vc r
Am .Com pl, CF N o.43,2. antf swe enodhe oft c ngeon A ugus 25,2011 a
.E
Pl i if r
d he ha
t
nd

be s ndi t i m ont y m orga pa m e st N a
gan e ng her
hl
t ge y nt o éonsa .tt J
da
The tr soft m or ga a r m e r r d t tN atons a appl m orga
em
he
t ge g ee nt equie ha
i tr
y
t ge
pa e sfz tt i e e t t t prncpa,a fnal t ot rr s el ne c r ,
ym nt ls o nt r s ,hen o i i l nd i ly o he nic la ous ha ges
i l ng es z ie s Am .Com pl,ECF N o.43,2.I da l N a
ncuHi
c ow t m .
.
ni ly, dons a a Pl ndfsha
t r nd ai f d

a e c ow wave ,buta trc uson r ga ci t x pa m ent t t c
n sê
i r
fe onf i e rlng a y
s o he ount ,t H e
y he gedus
es
alge t N adonsa i pz ryr voked t wave ,s tup a e c ow a ount a plce a
le hat
t r m ope l e
he i r e
n s z cc
, nd a d
por
éon oft i m ont ypa m e si o t a count t pr vendng t pa m ent f om
he r
hl y nt nt he c
, hus e
he y
sr

beng a i t i e es a prncpa a c usng a e nt lde a ti 201 1
i ppled o ntr t nd i i l nd a i n ve ua f ul n 3. d.
For cos e pr di we e t n i ta e i t Supe i Cot ofD ea t .See
e l ur ocee ngs r he nii t d n he
ror ut
lwa e

Ba kofN. Mel v. e , A. 5 5 1 -5 O e. u r CtDe . 8 2 7.
n
Y. l
on He dusC. No. 1 L-20 3 lS pe. . c 1 , 01 )
Pli f c esed t f e l tr t D ea r c s Ba ofN e Y or M el v.
anéfs ont t he or cosze; he lwa e a e nk
w
k lon

He e us( N. Mel )f l we .. i s Dea r Cou tf un t tt mo t g
d B. Y. l ol d 5= d The lwae r o d ha he tga e
on o
.
a r em e bev ee Fis H orzon a t H e
g e nt t n t t i
nd he gedus di i tal i udean e c ow w ave ,
es d niily ncl
sr
i r
butt ,f n M a ch 8,2013, a i trs ntal l rtte T
hat t
o
r
N tonsa e
ete ild URG EN T' t t H e
' o he gedus '
'
es

i ot ngt m t t$140.7 off sx Count txes whih ha bee dueon Se e r
nf mi he ha
1
d e
sus
ya , c d n
ptmbe
30,2012,..ha notbe n pad, t tt dei
. d
e i ' ha he lnquentpa m e c tt e a def ul unde t
'
y nt onsi d
m
a t
r he
t r soft m ozga a ee ent a t tN atonsa nlghtfom t r on r quie t
em
he
t ge gr m , nd ha
i tr i r
he e
e r he

He
gedus t manti a esz a countf f ur txesa i ur .L.at1- 2,9.
es o i an n c ow c
or ut e a nd ns ance ds
N a i t ra i notfed t H e
tonsa gan ii he gedus oft de i nc fvew e ksl tz and w a ne t
es he lnque y i
e ae,
t d hat
i t y di notpr depr ofpa entwihi 1 da ,N atonsarwoul a nc pa m e
f he d
ovi
oof
ym
t n 5 ys
i t
d dva e y nt
and fe t bls a ir voc bl e c ow ac ount't pr ve f t e def uls D ef' M e . n
fs a ih n r e a e s r
c
' o e nt utz
r
a t . .s m i

S p. . ECF No. 5 3 O e. . ) 2 - 3
up Ex B,
4 - l Ct Op. 9 0.
,
TheH e
gedus ci notr s
es ld
e pond t N a
o donsa ,butdi s nd pa m e t Sus ex
tr
d e
y nt o s

Count .D el Ct O p.4 - 5.TheH e
y
. .
gedus ci notpr deN a
es ld
ovi
donsa w1. a pr oft
t r t: ny oof he
1

tx p y nt a s Nai sa as s n pa me oft tx st t ec un y( a r t t
a a me , nd o ton tr lo e t y nt he a e o h o t un wa e ha
t etx sha aza ybe n pad a rvok d t e c o wav r J. S s e Cou yr t r d
h a e d le d e i) nd e e he s r w ie .- u s x nt eu ne
l
L

t duplc t pa ntt Na tr L TheHe dus sas r i
he
iae yme o donsa. da
ge e lo emburedNadonsa ;t s
s
tr hi
m one wasplce i t ne esr ac ountJd
y
a d n he w c ow c .-x

Be i ln ul 1 , 01 , ttm e t sntt t He e us sr fe td ane a i e c o
gnrigl y 6 2 3 sae n s e o he g d e elce
g t sr w
ve
ba a ,butt H e
l nce
he gedus c
es onénued t s nd pa m e sr fec t pz - cr m ont y
o e
y nt e l dng he e es ow
hl

bila ount D e .Ct O p. - 5.Di a t em e sa cont néon conénue ast H e dus s
l m
. l . 4
s g e nt nd
e
d, he ge e
c i
ontnued t pa m ont y pa e st we ei uf i ntt c r10t t es r
o y
hl ym nt hat r ns hce o ove 7 h he c ow

p y nt a mo hl i tr s a p i cpa. d Byl y 2 1 , heHe e us sweet
a me s nd nt y n e e t nd rn i lL . ul 0 4 t
a
g d e t wo
mont beandi morga pa nt.- a 5- 6.Na trs aNodc ofI e t
hs li n
t ge yme s J. t
I
L
donsa ent
e ntnt o
f ecos i t y di notbrngt a
or l e f he d
i he mountc r .J TheHege e di notdo s a
urent ds
dus s d
o, nd
B. Y.M el fld f f e l tr .I.
N.
lon le or or cosze .
I
L
TheD e a r Cour concuded t tB. . M el t ough N adonsa ,ha a t d
lwa e
t
l
ha N Y. lon, hr
tr d ce
wihi t rght ac ded by t m orga a r m e ,whih pe it t r voc
t n he i s cot
he
t ge g ee nt
c = ted he e adon of

t es r wave T a tm e's l aspr rnotc wasgi whie t H e dus s
he c ow i r f ny i ' o ong
at
ope
ie
ven, l he ge e
ha br a
d e ched t a e e by r usng t pa t es r a ount D e .Ct O p.8 - 9.
he gr em nt ef i o y he c ow m
. l .

J g ntwa a c r i l e e e f rB. . M eln. d TheHe e e a pe ld t
ud me
s c o dngy ntr d o N Y. l L a
o
g dus s p ae ; he

Dea r S p e Co r aft dt tilc ur' j g ntHe e usv. nkofNe Yo k
lwae u rme u t fime he ta o tsud me . d Ba
w r
Meln, 9 A.d9 8( l20 8, et l n de idguy2 , 01 )
lo 1 0 3 9 De. 1 )ra l t ne l 5 2 8.
me
Pro t t Dea r j g nt o Ma 3 , 01 t He e us sfld t sa d
i r o he lwae ud me , n y 0 2 7,he g d e t hi c on
e
a ns N a
gai t dons a i tasc t Com pl,ECF N o.1.O n Aprl18,2018, a
t r n li our.
.
i
N donsa br ht
tr oug

amo i t dsas u r1 $()agangteDea r d cso ptcu st He e uss
ton o inis nde 29 6, r i h lwae e iin e lde he g d e'
cli si t sc e.D ef M e . n Supp.ECF N o. 1.
qm n hi as
. m i
,
48,
C.

To as e sN a
s s éons a ' pz l i a gu ent t cout m us de e n i t a ia e
t rs ecuson r m , he
t t t t ane he pplc bl
s c oflw . AI f de alc 'sm us gi STIf ih a c e tt vai sat colr
our e a 3 I e r out
t
t ve I at nd r di o ld t e zt

jd me s a rq ie b fdea sa e I r Ge e sDaaTe hs l .2 4F.d1 4 1 7
u g nt, s e utd y e rl tmt.n e n s t c . nc, 0 3 2 , 2
( t Ci. 0 0 . npr vi n s c f l fiha d c e t28U.. j1 8d rc sfdea c urs
4h r 2 0 ) l o dig u h ul at n r di
,
SC. 73 ie t e rl o t

t r frt tep el i 1w o t saewheeajd me wa zndee - i ti
o ee o h rcuson a f he tt t u g nt s e td n hs
ct um sa e D ea r lw a is SeeL Stt pr cuson1w a isunl sa e e
ic tnc , lwa e a pple . Q ae e l i a pple es n xc péon

t j1 8g v r . e M ar s v. . a . Orh a di S e ns 4 0U.. 7 , 8
o 73 o e ns S e re e Am Ac d of t o e c ur o , 7 S 3 3 3 0

(9 5.
1 8)
Fe e a c ursa l at -tp pr e st deemi whehe j1 3 s u da y 1.
d r l o t ppy ' se oc s o tr ne t r 7 8 ho l ppl. 1
wo
1
r Ge
e nes sD at Tec .20 F. a 1 A f de a c tm us fr ta k i sat lw w oul
a hs, 4 3d t 28. e r l our
t ls s f t e a
d

gveasaec ur jd me pr cusvee f c. x , h c t mu ta ki Con r s c e td a
i tt o t u g nt e l i fe t Ne t t e ou' s s f g e s r ae n
t
a lc bl e p e so i le e c pto t j1 38
pp ia e x r s r mp id x e i n o 7 .
Unde D elw a elw:
r a r a

apat cnmi t tt edo ti eof(li pr cuson ba sas bs q nta do mus
ry li ng ha h c rn c/m e l i ) r u e ue c n t
de nszt t prsnc o ûv ee nt: () t c ur ma ng te proz
mo tae he e e e f e lme s 1 he o t ki h i
a jdia n ha j idito ()t paée i t p ee a to aeet rt sme
du cdo d urs cin, 2 he r s n he t snt cin r ihe he a
paée o i prvt wih t p risfo t pro a jccton ()te cus of
r s r n iiy t he ate r m he ir dut ai , 3 h a e
.
i
ac
éon m us be t s m ei bot c e ort is s de i d i t prorac
t he a
n . as s he s ue c de n he i
h
éon m us
t

bet s mea t os r ie i t p e e c s ,()t is e i t p i ra do mus
he a s h e as d n he r snt a e 4 he su s n he ro c n t
bed cd da v r eyt t ep nn f c t n
e i e d e s l o h liéf' on e donsi t i sa c s , nd ()t p i r
s
n he n tnt a e a 5 he zo
a jdia onmus befna.
du c é
t il
Balyv. t ofW i n t 7 6A. 4 7, 8 O e. 0 )( rc im) Folwi gt
ie Ci
y
l g on, 6 2d 7 4 1 l2 01 pe ura . l n he
mi
o
he rn o t emod t dsnisa d i t i ob e éo t J g Ho ' Re r a
a ig n h
on o ir s n n het jc ns o ud e ppes po t nd
Re omme a Pli if o e td t t a pl a n ofcsm p e lsonbyc t s g t
c
nd éon, qntfs bjce o he p i éo
c
li t cu i
on e én he
3Cli p elso o dn tl cn o bersle o Rue1 9 6 mo o , u tec u t ya rs t sd fns
lm zcuin riaiy a n t eov d n l 2 $() é nsb th o r ma ddeshi ee e
be a ealne s a y f ct a a et ron t f c oft pl ri ori t s a e c 'doc m e s ofwhih t c t
c us l ce s r a s ppe r ihe
he a e he ealngs n he t t oul u nt ,
t
c he ou '
t

ma tk jdca n d e S eAnde v Da 2 1F.d5 1 5 4n1(tCi. 0 0.
y a eu iil o c. e
rws . w, 0 3 2 , 2 . 4h z 2 0 )

s c ndee nt(h i e tt a d/ prv t bewe n t pa d si t f ta do a t
e o lme t e d n iy n or iiy t e he r e n he rs c n nd he

c rn a to ) tet t ee n th smi tt oft cus ofa do a is si tet
ure t cin ,h hid lme t te i l iy he a e c n nd sue n h wo
a
c ss, n t hfhee nt(hefn lyoft prorj g nt oftea lss Eah
ae)a d he t lme t iai he i ud me ) h nayi. c
.
t
o e do wil a drse i tr
bjc n lbe d esd n un.
Fis, nn f o jc t t a lc é n of el ind t t i ntyofte
rtPliéfs bet o he ppia o pzcuso ue o he de i h
t
pa des B. . . elon and N a i t ra e pl nl nott s m e pa t .The e or t c '
r . NY M l
tonsa r ai y
he a
ry
r f e, he out
t
m us de e m i i t y a ei prviy f i t i al ga de evn naéon f t ti lcout wih
t t r ne f he r n i t . Trviy s e l t t i
or he ta
t t

r ga d t whe he t r a
e r o
t r he eldonskp be we n t pa tesi s f e l cos t s
li t e he ri s ufki nty l e o uppor
t

pr cuson. Se 1 1 i v. al,9 1A. 1 , 3 O e. upe. . 0 )( u ig 1
e l i ' e - ns W l 0 2d 22 1 8 lS r Ct20 5 q otn 8
' 1
s

J me W m. or e a.M o r 'Fe rl a dc j1 2.4(j (de 2 0 . a ss
a s
Mo e t 1 o es dea Prc e 3 0 1% 3 d. 0 $)To ses
,
whe he t o pa te a e fs ûce l cos ' D ea ecoursl t t pa tes i e e t a
t rv
r is r fuf inty l e ' lwar
t ook o he r i ' nt r s s nd
a ki t y a e i ndca orcl ey ai d Ts h t tt y we eac l a a qua ey
s f he r de
l
os l lgne fuc ha he
t dvey nd de t l

r pr s n e i t f s s t' e aI . Ca alei23A. 1 7 1 0 @ e. 20 0 .
e e e t d n he l t ui. Av t nc v. v l r, 3d 5 , 8
r
'
i
lCh. 1 )
Pli if a guet r i no ptviy be wee N a
antfs r
he e s
i t t n éonsa a B. . . elon bec us t
t r nd N Y M l
a e he

t a enoti ntc l a f t a gue t N a i t tha ff ied t pt de a
wo r
de ia, nd urhet r
hat tonsa s fal o ovi ny
s t ntai ofprviy. The orgi lm orga a i s ,howe r wasbe we t
ubsa i ton
it'
'
i na
t ge t s ue
ve ,
t en he
H e dus a Fis H orzon,a N a
ge es nd r t
i
nd éonsa s r ed t sl n f Fi s H orzon.B. .
tz e dc hi oa or r t
i
N Y.
M el a quied t m orga by a sgnm ent wih N a i t zsils rdc ng.TheH e dus '
lon c t he
t ge
si
, t
tonsa tl e i
ge es
cni sa i tN atonsa a eba e on t i c e
l m gans
i tr r s d
het ont ndon t tt es r a ountwas
ha he c ow cc
ilgii a e a t N a i trdef
le tm t , nd hus tonsa
endsis fby clm i a hort ,asB. . M elon'
tel
li ng ut iy
N Y. l s
m orgages r e ,t es a ih t a ount I t D ea r c e, N . M el a gu is
t
e dc r o t bls he cc
. n he lwa e as B. Y. lon r ed t

rghtt pur ue f e l tr a i tt H e
i o s or cosze gans he gedus be us ofpa tdue pa ent r l t t a
es ca e
sym s e aed o

lgii a ey esa ihe es r a ount D e .Ct O p.2.N a i t rsi e e t we et
e fm t l t bls d c ow cc
. l .
tonsa ' nt r s s r hus
c os l ai
l ey lgned wih B. . M el si e e t.
t N Y. lon' nt r ss

TheH e
gedus fut rcli t t Re ta Re om m e ton e r f
es t he nm hat he por nd c
nda i r ed T
by

c a gn t wor ç ve t r..o t eBa ofM el n gij' nd t ag t a f a nsa
h n ig he d i so '.t h nk
n
lo sc'a hus r ue h t f do tr
N

wa g )i p i t wih Mel giqa t tmeoft e tb hme ofa e c o a c un .
s not n zviy t l sc t he i
on
he sa is nt n sz w c o t'
?
P1.Obj. oR. R.ECF No. 4, , . t sa r s ndst tc ngn t lbe
s' s t & ,
6 5 9 Nai tr e po ha ha ig he a l
on
fnvesor't t na e<B. . M el 'doe nota trt lga a l i . atonsa i
f
i t ' o he m C N Y. lon'
s
le he e l nayss N i t r s

cor e - ass rvce f B. . . e l t i s ori t H ege e 'l n, a i tra e
r ct
e i r or N Y M lon, he nve t n he
dus s oa N tonsa ct d

onbe loft ba . smi rt ofteis sag d ( éo trsrg t etbls te
haf he nk The i l iy h sue rue Na nsa' iht o sa ih h
a
e c o a c unta d t ba ' rg t t r atrf r cos f re co d fce is la t
s r w c o n he nks iht o hee fe o e l e o s r w e iince) e d o
t c l i t N a i t rsi e essw e e a i l and a qua ey r pr e e i t
he oncuson hat tons a ' ntr t r ctvey
de t l e es nt d n he
fz ts t The t pa tesa e i prviy,s ds yng t seem e oft pr l i anayss
ls ui.
wo ri z n i t a fi hi l nt he ecuson l i.
N e , antfsa gue t tt t cas 'c us ofac
xt Pli if z
ha he wo es a es
don ar nots f e l sm ia
e
ufki nty i lr

t wa r ntpr cusveefec .I de e n i ng tns D ea r c t f l atans c
o ta
e l i f t n t r nni li, lwa e our s olow r a dona
l
a oac i whih c nm pr l i m a Tbei
ppr h n c l i ecuson y t nvoke t ba ltgai .i t cli si t
d o r ii ton. .f he nm n he
l t rltgaton a os f om t s m e ta ac
a e ii i r e r
he a
r ns éon t f m e t ba i oft pror
hat ot d he ss he i

a j iain. RBC Ca ia Mks LLC v. u . nTr 1 8 A.d6 2 6 @ e. 01
dudc to '
'
tl t.
Ed c Loa .V, 7 3 3 , 45 l2 $.
Al i s sw hih r ghtha bee z ied and de i d i t fr ts ta epr l
l s ue
c ni
ve n a s
cde n he ts ui r ecuded,notonl
y

t eis st tw e e de i d. A TheH e
hos s ue ha r cde J
gedus a gu t t D ea e c e c r
es r e hat he lwar as once ned
pa e ofam ozga w hie < heVigt ' s ta es est s r ii dehce i sof
ym nt
t ge, l f
t
t ' a ui ddr s he e vc ng
m
inc e

Nai sa. S ePl' j t R. R.ECF6 , - 5 Th smec nta tu risb h
ton tt' e s Obs o &. ,
'
4 4 . e a o tc ndel ot
e
c e ,howe r a 10t ca e de lwih N a i t rsa hort t esa ih a e c ow
as s
ve , nd 3 h s s a t
. tons a ' ut iy o t bls n s r

a ount Theis r ied i t sca e c d c roi y ha bee r ied a ar d i t
cc .
s ues a s n hi s oul e t nl ve n a s nd gue n he
D ea r ca e i d,m a we e Tli ee e i s ds
lwa e s - ndee
ny r . ks lm nt s a ûed.
Fi ly Pli f a guet tt D e a r Cour' decson i notye fna a t y f r
nal, andfs r
ha he lwa e
ts ii s
t i l s he f e
a

si p s n tevaain'oftejdg ntPl' j t R. R.ECF 6 2 TheS prme
tl utuig h c to ' h u me . s Obs o &. ,
l
4, .
u e

Cou'o Dea z hod ta fiftelng a eoftej g n e de e t j g '
l f lwae ls h tfj h a u g h ud me t vi nc s he ud es
t
g
i e éonta t j g n befn lt nt j g ntsfna. Plmme v. T. n r i
ntn
h t he ud me t ia,he he ud me i i l' l z R. Va debl
' z
t
Co, 9A.d1 6 ,1 6 ( l2 2. te t j g ntsSna f pe on( t r
.4 3 1 3 1 7 De. 01 )Wheh r he ud me i lf nds whehe
de
t j g ha orh snotce ryde lr d h si e n i t i r s c i hi o n o ' I
he ud e s a
lal ca e i ntnéo n h s epe t n s pii n.' d.
'
TheDea t Cou tg a e j g ntn fvo ofB. Y. lo e e e j g n
lwa e r z ntd ud me i a r N. Mel n, ntr d ud me t
a i tt H e
gans he gedus ,and a r d da a st B. . M el Se D e .Ct Op.8- 9.
es
wa de m ge o N Y. lon. e l .

Pl i f di a
anéfs d ppea t D elw a e Cour' de ii butt t ki ofan a ala tz l
l he a r
ts c son,
he a ng
ppe caal
y

s ppo t afncngt a t jd me ti Ena. a txFa l Pr ds I . S . u S 1
u rs l h t he u g n s lPl e mi o . nc v. tPa l us
i

Li sI s Co.5 4A.d6 1 68 n. O e. u r Ct1 8 )rrl Cou t o t ssaeha
ne n . , 6 2 8 , 4 2 lS pe. . 9 9 flhe rs fhi tt ve
ii c t d. . ha j g nt o a a aefn lf èr cuso qp
r ae . t t ud me s n ppe l t i a or e l i n umos s Tl si ce rys ,
di
e . n s lal o
i
es t i entve woul be f t l i pa t ..t sm ulaneousy a a a fl s ti
le he nc i
d
or he osng ry . o i t
l ppe l nd te ui n

a t rj icc n, pigfra i on itnt r it'( tr l iai o te l.
nohe utsl éo ho n o n nc sse vedc. i ena ctton mi d)The
i
'n
t
Dea r Co r jd me twa fn l e t Dea r S prmeCo ta c pe Pli f'
lwae u tu g n s ia wh n he lwae u e
ut ce td andfs
a e lAd do l ,hep bl d ke rfe t t tt tilc ur' j g ntwa af me
pp a. di nal t u i oc t elcs ha he ta o t ud me s fs d
y
c
s
r
o J y 2 , 01 . e Ba k ofN. M el n, A. o. 1 L-1 - 5 Fi aiyi e tbihe
n ul 5 2 8 S e n
Y. lo C. N S 5 2 0 3. n l s sa ls d.
t
1 1.
1

Theca eatha i pr c ude The ef e,t c truesnow t OVE RRU LE t
s
nd s e l d. r or he our l
o
he

He e ussobe d ,
g d e' jc onsADOPT t rpo ta rc mme do t tee e tc nsse
he e r nd e o nda n o h xtn o itpt
wih t sopi on,a GRAN T D ef ntsm odon t dir s .
t hi ni nd
enda '
o snis
An a opra e or rwilbe e e ed t sda
ppr it de l
ntr hi y.
Ent r d: e e be 11 2018
ee D cm r ,

/
+f

w , .
' J
-

M iha l . r ns
c e
ba ki

Cli ni dSttsDit t ud e
ae t ae sdc l g
e

12