Hegedus et al v. Nationstar Mortgage LLC et al

Filing 81

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 2/27/2020. (Opinion mailed to Pro Se Parties via US Mail)(jv)

clERK' oFFl t, .DI CG J C
- s
cE Js ST. RAT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

FEB 2 ï 22
22
'N T H E U N I
1
TED STATE S D I RICT CO U RT
ST
FO R TH E W ESTE RN D ISTRI O F W R GI I
CT
N A
H ARRISO N BU RG D I I O N
V SI

U
)L1 C.DUDLEY, LERK

s

é

R

J ESA.
AM
HEGEDUS e .a.
, t 1y
Pl i if
a ntfy

CaseN o.5: cv17- 000053

N AT I N STAR M O RT GA GE LLC,eta1,
O
.
By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l
D ef ndant
e

Cli fU . Di t c J ge
le S. s t t ud
i
M BM O R AN D U M O PI ION
N

Thi matri beo et c u tpus ntt p nn if J me A. ge usa Vigna
s te s f r he o r t ua o litfs a s He d nd ri i
E. g du ' rt He e u e ' mo i t r o n t c s (Mo i ' hld (nJ n r 1 ,
He e ss fhe g d s s' ton o e pe he a e < ton' e ) a ua y 5
)
<
)
2020.Pr Se M ot t Rensat Pt ee ngs ECF N o.77.Pli if a gue t t t c ts
o
. o i t e oc di ,
antfs r
ha he our'

De e e 1 , 01 o d rr e e rOr r)dimisn t c s wihprj c , ndal l
c mb r 1 2 8 r e r c mbe de' s sig he ae t eudie a
uy
2 ,2 1 o d rd n igrl fun tFe R. v. 5 ()r l Or r)aevodbe a eof
9 0 9 r e e yn ei de d. Ci P. 9e quy de7 i i c us
e
t a om ai sa a s i t d wih t ba
he ut tc t y s oc a e t he nknl c petton t y fl d i N ove be ,2018.
pt y ii he ie n
m r
1
M e .t Reque tt Re ns a e Pr ee ngs ECF N o.78. D ef ndantN atons a M orga
m o
s o i t t oc di ,
e
i tr
t ge

LLC ( a nsa ' t s nde , r uigt He e us sfie t c ryt i bur e un rRul
( do t*' e po d ag n he g d e ald o a r her d n de e
W
r)

6 $. s i Oppn t P1.Re uett RensaePr e dng ,
0q Rep.n ' o s' q s o i tt oc e i s ECF No.7 . lw d s
9 The a oe
notr nde t cour' proror r voi be us oft H e dus s ba upt y flng. ss
e r he
ts i de s d ca e he ge e ' nkr c li A uch,
t i m oton t r
het
i o eope m us beD EN I .
n
t
ED

1Pr sp bl , t H e e e 'lo s e r leff om t co tsSe e be 17, 9 O r rde i tt He dus 'mot
e lmq y he g dus sa s e k ei z he uc' pt m r 201 de nyng le ge es
bn

frrc ns ea o . fe tmb rOze'. No 7 . ec mt lc n ie temo o a a pyn t alhe
o e o i rd n rs pe e d t' ECF . 6 Th o wi o sd r h d n s p lig o ltre
d
)
l
o de s
r t.

1.

Tli ca ea i e fom am orga a ee e be wee t H ege e a Fis H orz
zs s rs s r
t ge gr m nt t n he
dus s nd t t i on
Hom eLoa Cop or ton c
n
a i once / ng t lesa e l a e i D e a a e.Compl, ECF N o.1 a
r
ea t t oc t d n lw r
.
,t

2.Them otga w a s r ed by N a i t. a l era sgne t Ba ofN e Yot M el
t ge s e dc
tonsar nd at s i d o nk
w
k lon

(C N. M eln' Pl. Am. e d n ,
T Y. l ). s' Pla i g ECF N o. 3 a 2 TheHe e us sf e sve a cqms
B.
o
4 ,t .
g d e l d e t l li
l
il t s cour i l ng c
t hi
t ncudi
onve son, br ac of c r c , a t tous i e f r nc wih a
ri
e h
ont a t nd ozi
nt r e e e t

conta t a ong ot r ,a ii outofwhatt y alged we eN a i t rspr dat y l ng
z c, m
he s rsng
he le
r
tons a ' e or endi
pt tc .
aci es ECF N o. N ai t rm ove t dir s t s cam son t g oundst tapr vi
1. tonsa
d o snis he e li
he r
ha
e ous

c s, n ofNe Yo kMelnv. e usNo CV S 5 1 0 3 20 7W L 6 1 2 O e.
ae Ba k
w r lo He d , .
1 L-2-5 , 1
45 1 3 l
S e . . c 1 , 01 ) a fdb He e u v. n ofNe Yo kM el 1 0A.d9 O e.
up r Ct De . 8 2 7 , f' y
d s Ba k
w r l 9 3 98 l
on,
2 8, e r l ntd ne fuy2 , 0 8 , e lde t He e s s camsi t smatr ECF
01 ) ra l
me e id l 5 2 1 ) pr cu d he g du e ' li n hi te .
N o.44.

Thec s wa t fre t Unie S ae Ma itaeJ d o lC. ppepurua t 28
a e s e er d o td tt s gsrt u gel e Ho
s nt o

U. C.
S.

6 64 17) J g Ho c duce a hetng a is d a Re or &
3 $() . ud e ppe on td
ai nd sue
p t

Re om m e ton r om m e ng t tN a i t ts m oton be gr nt i f 1 ECF N o.61.
c
nda i ec
ndi ha
tons a '
i
a ed n u1.

Afe ob e ton we e f e ,t c r is d ame r nd m opio g a ig Na nsa '
tr jci s r i d he ou t sue
mo a u
i n r ntn do trs

moint dsasj uigt tt He e u e' li wa prcu dbyaj g nti Dea r
to o inisr l ha he g d ss cnm s e lde
n
ud me n lwae
s a e c t be> ee t pa te conc r ng t pr zy. M em .O p. ECF N o.66.The
t t our
n he r is
e ni he ope t
H e dus sdi nota a dir s a oft i c s
ge e d
ppe l snis l he r a e.
I t d,t H e
nsea he gedus st c a ked t c tt r onsdetis z i wli h t c ut
e wi e s
he our o ec i t ulng, nc he ov

a r se i t l l a S ptmbe Oz e s ECF Nos 6 a 76 I t l l Or e ,hec r
dd e s d n he uy nd e e r d r.
. 9 nd . n he uy d r t ou t

a es ed t s
ddr s he ubmi son by t H e
si
he gedus ofcn m e ne e de c itng ofan e al
es li d w vi nce onss i
m i
bet n B. . M e l a N atons a c udi t tç hee al snotc nget c zts
wee N Y. lon nd i t q oncl ng ha f m i doe
t
ha
he ou '

rzn ' ul Or e , No 69 a 3 No n ieo a pe l sfld
tip'J y d r ECF . , t . otc f p a wa t .
l
e
Agan, t H ege r s
i he
dus s ought z c i r i whi h t c t addr s ed i t
e onsde aton, c he our
e s n he
Se e rO r z ECF N o. Tha or ra es ed t a gu e st i e by t H e
pt mbe de .
76. t de ddt s he r m nt a s d he gedus
es

t a t eJ l Or zr s o tu d t i ag nta ofe e a dtona ne e i nc ,t s
h t h uy de nic nsr e her r ume nd ft d d ii l w v de e hi
tm e r ltng t B. . M el s f it t fl a pr ofcli i t H e dus s W e t n
i
ea i o N Y. lon' alue o le
oof
l m n he ge e ' ser

Di ti tofVig' l ba rt c pr e ng.A fe addr s i t cnm ed ne e de ,t
src
r taa nk z y oc edi
t'
pt
tr
e sng he li
w vi nce he
cour concude t tt H e dus s f ie t m ee t r r m e sofRuls 59 and 6 a
t
l d ha he ge e ald o
t he equie nt
e
0, nd

deci d t f e sti s supon whih ha ale rzed.' Or r ECF N o. at7. gan,t
lne o T vii s ue
r
c s r ady tl ' de ,
76, A i he
H e dus di notfl anotceofa a.
ge es d
te
i
ppe l

OnJ nu r 1 ,20 0 p an if f e t i pe dig Rue 6 r qu s t r i tt t er
a a y 5 2 , litfs f d her n n l 0 e e t o ensae h i
lws t t stm e c m i t tt cour' pror or r we evoi be a e t y we e e e ed
a ui, bi i
bi ng ha he
ts i
de s r
d c us he
r nt r

i conta nton of t a om a i s a a s i e wih t i N ove be ,2018 ba upt
n
r ve i
he ut tc t y s ocat d t he t
m r
nkr cy
Pe l
tton.
I
I.

Therme yprvd dbyRul 6 i T xro dnaya i onyt beiv e u na
e d o ie
e 0$) s < ta r i t nd s l o n ok d po
e
s
howi ofe eptonalc t um sa es' Com t v.Alon S. Co. I 608 F. 96,1
ng
xc i
ic t nc .
'
on
t
S.
nc.
2d
02

(t Ci.1 7 ) fti awelstldprncpl oflw t taRul 6 mo n sedn rl f
4h t 9 9. f s l ete i i e a ha
l
e 0$) do e l g ei
e
fo afn lud me i no as bsiu ef zatmeya p o ra pe l' wel S aeFn'
r m i a j g nt s t u tt t o i l nd r pe p a. Do lv. tt t
'
m
Fie& Ca . o. ns Co.9 3 F.d 4 ,4 (t Ci.1 9 ) A pa t mo i f rr l fun r
r
s Aut I . , 9 2 6 8 4. r 9 3 . ry vng o ei de
h
e

Rue6 $)mu ts w tmeie s ameioiusdee s,a alc ofu arprj iet t
l 0
s ho i l s, rtro fn e nd ak nfi eudc o he
n

o osn pat.W ene v.Cab 7 F.d 2 4 2 6 7 h Ci.1 8 Th s t ehod
pp ig ry ê r
r o. 31 2 0 , 0 -0 /t t 9 $. ee hrs l
t q ie nt a ei e e t g i ac r i b lncn t e d t ofz sj l aawih t
e ur me s r ntnd d o ude ou t n aa i g h ocdne e ucc t t he
i
deiet tus ebed i l ht a1 hefc s Com t v. t n SS Co.6 8F.d 9 , 0
sr ha j dc
one n i of 1t a t.
g
on Alo .. , 0 2 6 1 2
(t Ci. 9 9 . et mo ig pat ha ma s h as o n , o s mu ts tsyo
4 h z 1 7 ) Onc he vn ry s de uc h wi g he t he s aif ne

oft sxg o ndsfrtl ffom j g ntoul di Rue6 .J Th pat mo igf
he i r u o ei z ud me ti n l 0$)2Z. e ty vn or
e
ne
rl fu e Rul 6 mus ceryetbl ht gou dsf zle tot stsA to o te
ei nd r e 0$) t lal sa i he t n or eif f he aifcin f h
e
s
t
citi t c t a s
lsrc our , nd uch g ounds m us be c e ry s t nta e by adequat pz 'I r
r
t
l a l ubs a i t d
e oof' n e

Bur l 9 8 F.d 1 3 ( h Ci. 1 9 ) ( e n lctto o ate ) As t He d e
n e 8 2 , 4t r 9 2 i r a iains n itd . he ge us s
nt
pz e pr s t i pl a ngs ar e il t lbe a c tuc i Se e.s Ercks v.
oce d o e, het e di
e ntted o i r l onst ton. e, g , i on

Padu , 1U.. 9 9 (00 )
r s 55 S 8 , 4 2 7 .
The H e dus s m oton s eksr lef fom t pror or r unde t t y t tt
ge e '
i e
ei r
he i
de s
r he heor ha he

j g nt weevod u e Rue6 $/)o t c thalprviin ofRul 6 $() Th i
ud me s r i nd r l 0q
r he ac l o so
e 0q 6. er
voi s a gu ents e s fom t f tt tt H e dus fld a ba upt y pe ii i t
dne s r m
tm r
he ac ha he ge es ie
nkt c tton n he

U nie St t sBa
t d a e nkmp c Cour f t W e t t D it tofVigi a on N ove be 18 2018,
pt y
t or he s e n sdc
r ni
m r ,
af w we be or t D ec m be Or rwase e ed dinns i tasac i a
e
eks f e he
e r de
nt r
s i sng li ton gzns N a i t t
t tons a .

ECF N o.78.The H e dus s cont nd t t t ba upt y s hedul s pz pa ed by t i
ge e
e ha he nkr c c
e e r
he r
ba m p c c m s lf ied t a knowl
nl pt y ot e al o c
edget pende y oft sac i c usng t ba pt y
he
nc
hi ton, a i he nknl c
petton t fy unde t cour ' r da when t s c e was din is a f w we l t r i
ii o l
r he
ts a r
hi as
s as ed e
eks a e n
D e m be , 2018.H a t ca e be n sa d,t H e
ce r
d he s
e t ye he gedus ar t t t y woul ha
es gue ha he
d ve

2Theeg o ndsncu :1 mitkei d re e s ieo e c a l ne lc;2 ne ydsov rde ie c ;
s r u i lde () sa ,na vetnc ,umrs r x us be ge t () wl ic e e vd n e
()fa ,mirpfsntto ormic nd tb a o igpat;()t j g nti vod ()t j g nt
3 rud se ee ain
so uc y n pposn ry 4 he ud me s i; 5 he ud me
ha be ns t fe , ee s do dic r d;tsbae o a e rirj g ntt tha ben rv re orv c td
s e ai id r lae r shage ii s d n n ale ud me ha s e e e sd a ae ;
s
o apligip oped l i nolngre uial; r()a yote rao t tusie rl f Fe . Ci.P.
r p yn t r s c vey s o e q tbe o 6 n h r esn ha j tf s ei . d R. v
i e
6 $.
0q
4

pr vi
o ded ne e denc t t f
w vi e ha f d ha sg hca l i l nc t out om e of tls
woul
ve ini nty nfue ed he
c
li
ltga i ' I a 3.
ii ton.' d. t

I zs
n e pons N a i t zc e t tt H e
e, tonsa ont nds ha he gedus c
es annotm a a s f e s
ke ufki nt howi
ng

und rRue6 $, ndt tt imo ina unst f oti mo et na uni l c laea
e l 09 a ha her to mo t o f lng r ha n fmey oltrl
n n
a t c on t Coar' ozgi lOr t cim i sng t ca e' Res i O pp' r M ot t Reope
ta k
he
ts i na de ts s i he s .' p.n
n e
.o
n
Cas ECF N o.79 a 4.N a
e,
t
donsa not s t a e ofa ne e de t twoul ha
t t e he bs nce
ny w vi nce ha
d ve
i pa t t out e oft ca e ore ptona cr um s a eswa r ntngr lef ECF N o.
m c ed he com
he s
xce i l ic t nc
r a i ei .
79
a 3t 4.
1 1.
1

Pli if' tont ti tt terc s do sno stsyt r ql e nt ofRue6 $.
nntfsmoi o ensae h i ae e t aif he e ltme s
i
l 0q
Fis,pli if f i t m a t t es d s
rt antfs al o ke he hr hol howi t t a i t tr lefwilnoti t e
ng hat T ntng ha ei l
gr
n he nd

ha ebe n af tl g st , y s wi t a F yh ve am eiorou de e eo cnm. Bo d
v e ' ie e tue b ho ng h t he a ) rt i s fns r li ' y
u
'

v. ll, 05F.d7 4 76 (t Ci. 9 0.nt ul a S ptmbe Or r,hec u tfu
Buaa 9 2 6 , 9 4h r1 9 )I hel y nd e e r dest o r o nd
i ufi intt ne e dence ofe ed by pl i if .ECF N os 69 a 76.Furhe ,t s c e
ns fce he w vi
fr
antf s
.
nd
t r hi as
pr s nt no exc ptona cr um sa esa t ba npt y flng doe notr
ee s
e i l ic t nc s he nktl c ii
s
ende dt c ts
rvoi he our'
prorr i .I addii t z hasbee no s
i ulngs n
ton, he e
n
howi t t s i r quie e s ofRuls
ng hat he pechc e r m nt
e

6 6 4 a 6 9 6 h vebe hme.
0 $() nd 0 $() a e t
Rue 6 $/) alws a c u tt rle a pat fo a fna j g n,or r o
l 09
l
o
o r o eive
ry z m i l ud me t de r
pr c e ig wh n K h j g nti vod. Fe .R.Ci P.6 $() < o d ri fo d f r
o e dn e f e ud me s i ' d
t
;
v. 09 4 . < r e s v i ' o
An
pu po e ofRul 6 $)4 o y i t e c ur r nd rn t e d cso lc e pe s a o s jc
r ss
e 0 () nl f h o t e ei g h e ii n a k d ron l r ube t
mattj id ci n o a t d i a ma ti o itn wih d p oc s oflw. W e tv.
te uts ito z c e n
nne nc nsse t t ue t e s a ' nd
'
Le r ,4 F.d 41 ,41 (t Ci.2 05 .As t Fout Cic te pli d i W e t
onad 31 3 0 2 4 h r 0 )
he t . rui x ane n nd ,
h

fd e pt ti s e nn l b o d sae n , na r wl c tnet c e ofat i o de
f q s ie l s e ni gy r a ttme t we ro y onst' he onc pt vod' r z
g
n

und rRue6 $/)p e ieybe a eoftet e tt fnaiyofj g nsa ters t t
e l 09
t csl c us h hra o i l
t ud me t nd h ik ha
lia t . . lus Rue6 4 t cru nt na a p oc s te eetdno t f l m '
ig ns .wi e l 0 $/) o ic mve a ppel r e s h y lce t o ol '
t
l
o

J.Aszg r sRul 6 $/) t He e s sc tndt tt De e ra J yOr r ae
-a e ad e 09 ,he g du e one ha he c mbe nd ul des r
d
v i b cus t yweema i voai oft a omai sa u e 1 U. C. 3 2oft
od e a e he r de n ilt
on he ut tc ty nd z 1 S. j 6
he
Ba tz c Co .The j 3 2 a oma sa tk s ef c u fl g f r ba knp c a
nknpty de
6 ut éc ty a e fe t pon tn o n tlty nd
i
Tope a esa as a ,a i bl t alentte ,of...t com m e m e oz c i ton ...
f z t s t y pplca e o l iis
he
nce nt ontnua i
of

aj iilal nsrtve orot ra to o p oc e i a qns t td btrta wa o c ul
udca, c itai , he cin r r e dng g i t ha e o h t s t o d
mi
ha be c m e ed bef e t c m e e e oft ca eunde t stteort r cove a
ve en om nc
or he om nc m nt he s
r hi il
o e
r
cnm a ns t de ort ta os bef et com m e m e oft c eundertlstte.711
li gai t he bt ha r e or he
nce nt he as
li .l 7
i

U.. j 3 2()1 . p r e o t a o tcsa ,i a lt t pr e t t e rlt
SC. 6 a() The u pos f he ut mai ty n dc i o otci h ea i
i on
ng
ve
poston ofcr dior ,i t s ed t de or fom fnanc a pz s ur durng t pe
ii
e t s s o hil he bt r
i i l e s e i he ndenc of
y
t ba m a c pr ee ng. i e sB & Thr h M c a v.Geor eM as Ba 94F.
he nl pt y oc di W nt r
ou
M hon
on nk,
3d

1 0 1 3(t Ci.1 96.f' a o tcsa i br di sopea iso rto i a o t
3 , 3 4h r 9 )T he utmai ty s oa n c nd t peain s utmai
T
c
u n t fi oft peii . l r W e t ro d 41 B. 2 3 28 ( n t D.. 2 09 .
po he lng he tton' n e ahe f r , 3 R. 7 , 3 Ba k . SC. 0 )
l
'
H owe r t pr e tons a f ded by t a om a i s a a e noti e
ve , he ot c i
foz
he ut tc ty r
nt nded t r c
o ea h
cni sbr
lm
oughtby de or s h a t H e dus s ' heFourh Cic thasnotr e d r cty
bt s uc s he ge e . T
t r ui
uld ie l

on wheh r sc in 3 2()1 sa f th rpr e d n si c ne to wih a c ntr li a
t e e to 6 a () tys i t e oc e i g n on c in t ou ecnm
l
de orfl pr - tton buthasi c e i a unpubûs d opi on t ta a ton itta e
bt led e pe ii
ndiat d n n
he
ni ha n c i rii t d

by ade ort s e r enanai oftxdef e i owedt t l ena Re nueSe dc
bt o e k edetr i ton a kinces
o he ntz l ve
r e
wa nots a by a ba upt y pe ii bec us t a ton w a not Tgans t de or but
s
tyed
nkr c tton
a e he c i
s
a i t he bt '

i iit d b t e de t . I r Ge ,5 0B. 5 0 5 2 ma k .D.. 2 4 (iig Red v
ntae y h b oz' n e c 1 R. 1 , 2
'
n t SC. 01 ) ctn i .
6

Co ro I en l ve e 8 8F.d1 3 , 9 9W L7 6 ,t* (t (9.9 9 ( rc ra
mm' f ntr a Re nu , 7 , 2 4 0 1 8
48 7 a 1 4h 2 1 8 ) pe uim)
( u ig 1 U.. j3 2()1). Fol' Cic i h sas hed t ta a o tcsa d s
q otn 1 SC. 6 a ()) The lt r ut a lo l ha n ut mai ty oe
th
noti pac apl dge a z m e vol a iy e e e i o byt de or ass a aci w oul
m t e
g ee nt unt zl nt r d nt
he bt , uch n ton
d
notbe a i tt de orfa i t notwihi t pt
gans he bt <nd s hus
t n he apos oft a om a i sa ' W i e s
e he ut tc t y. ntr
'

B & Thr hM c ho v. o eMao Ba ,9 F.d1 0 1 3( h Ci. 9 )
ou
Ma n Ge r
s n nk 4 3 3 , 3 4t r1 96.
W hie t Fourh Cic t hasnotdiec l ru e on t a ia lt oft a om a i
l he
t r ui
r ty l d
he pplc biiy
he ut tc
s a on c nm s br htby t debt ,sser cr t ha he d t tcli s orcount r li s
ty
li
oug
he
oz it icuis ve l ha am
e clm

br
oughtby a de ora e notba r d by t a om a i s a Se Pa ke v.Bqn,68 F. 1131
bt r
re
he ut tc t y. e r r
i
3d
,

1 38 ( t 6 1 9 ) ( li a cnm o ii l b o h b ape s wh s bs q nt fld
1 9 h 1.9 5 hocng li rgnal r ug t y ton o u e ue l l
l
y
y e
ba r ptyun rc a e 1 wa nots b e tt t a o tc sa ) Calo v. r n (q
nk u c de h ptr 1 s
u jc o he ut mai ty ; rs n No ma 1

r Du a ) 98 F.d 4 0 4 1n. (t ( 1 9 )(otn ati pat atoni t ae by
e nc n, 7 2 9 , 9 2 8h 1.9 3 n ig ht ry ci nsi td
dg
t d bo sa ans at r pat wa nots jc t t a o tc sa) Ma.Elc Co v.
wo e tr g i t hid ry s
ubet o he utmai ty; t e . .
Uitdl re Ba , 5 F.d1 9 , 2 4 05(dCi. 9 )rh' ga e a o ninvaae
e esy nk 9 9 2 1 4 1 0 - 3 r1 91,e g rntd nd pi o c td
ga 1 , 9 2, pii ri ttdonrh' ( r2 1 9 )rMulil cnm a mulpl pat
n. 0 1 9 ) o non ensae
e g Ma. 4, 9 2 f tpe li nd t e ry
i
ltga i m us bedia e t s t tpa tc a cnm s c
ii ton
t
s ggr ga ed o ha riul r li , ount t l i s c os c lm sa t r
e c qm , r s l i nd hidpa t cli sa et e t i pe
ry nm r r a ed nde ndentywhen det m i ngwhih oft i r s c i pr eelngs
l
er ni
c
he r e pe tve oc ci

aes bjc t t ba tl c sa .Thu ,wi n o c s,atonsa ans ade o wilb
r u e t o he nkapty ty
s t ne ae ci g i t btr l e
hi
s pe d e e t u h cos l r ltd c msa s re b t de o ma c ntn . .. .
us nde v n ho g l ey eae bi se td y he bt z y o iue' Ca 1
); ...
.c
:
Ca ia Gr u v. r ma sFu l .Co.88 F.d 1 2 ,1 2 @ . Ci.9 9 ( rc m)
tl o
Fie n' nd ns , 9 2 1 6 1 7 C. r1 8 ) pe uda

Sodn scin 3 2()1 T yistr o ysa spr c e n sa an tted btr a d s
lig e to 6 a() f t ems nl ty o edig g is h e o , nd oe
b
nota es a tonsbr
ddz s c i
oughtbyt de orwlih woul i et t be ftoft ba m a c
he bt
lc
d nut o he ne i
he nl pt y

e tt'(iai sa i e na q ttonmak o itd ; ri- i o v. m i nFe rl
sae' ctton nd ntr l uo ai
r s nl e ) Ma tn Tr na Cha o dea
t

S v.a Lo n Asocai 8 2 F. 5 5 5 7 ( h Ci.1 9 rffhe a o tc sa i
a nd a s iton, 9 2d 7 , 7 7t r 98 ) rj utmai ty s
i p ia l t s t b t ba ml gl.
na pl be o uis he nk ptj)
c
A ba rtpt y cour i t sc r ui hasf l
nk z c
t n hi ic t
olowed s t deci ng t a y t a om a i
ui, lni o ppl he ut tc

sa t cnm so c ntr li bt ug b t d bt r I r Ge , 0B. 5 0 5 2 ( n .
ty o li r ou e cams o ht y he e o . n e c 51 R. 1 , 2 Ba kr

D. C.20 4.The ds ost ueto wa whehe ap o e cngwa f rgnal b o h
S. 1 )
ip ii
veq sin s t z z c el
i
s < ii l z ug t
o
y
a i tt de or'L xAddii ly,t a om ai sa doesnotba t defnda ' a lt t
gans he bt .' d
tonal he ut tc ty
t he e nts biiy o
a s r def ns s s h a m otonst dim is T li i t e n i t de enda ' s es f l
s e t e e , uc s
i
o s s . T as s rue, ve f he f
nts ucc s u
def ns wilr ul i t l s of a algedl vaua e cnm as e t d by t de or' I r
e e l es t n he os
n le y l bl li
sre
he bt . n e
'

PamdaeHil Pr e LLC, 5 F.d 86 , 7 ( t Ci.01 ) I r Mose , 0B. 5 0
l l l o r
s
6 4 3 8 8 5 9h t2 1; n e l 26 R. 9 ,

5 5 ( nt.SD.Ga 2 0 )( ac ptr1 c s wh r tede o i ap rypanif t t
9 Ba l .
r
. 0 0 i ha e 3 ae ee h btz s at litf, ha
n
d bt z ma c nt e s t. dsrc c uti tzscrti ha smi r de id a lig t e
e o y o i ui A itit ot n l iclt s i l l n e ppyn h
nu
)
i
ay
a om a i sa t a sztbr
ut tc ty o ti oughtby ba uuptpl ntf sw he no c
nl - ai if
n
ount t %qm swe e br
ec i
l
r ought

b dee n s Ho v Caol aFis Ba , 9 F. u 2 6 1 61 ( D. C. 01 )
y fnda t. ue . r i rt nk 8 0 S pp. d 1 , 7 W. N. 2 2 .
n
l t i t nt c e t cli s we e br
n he ns a as , he nm
r ought by t H ege es not a i t t m .
he
dus ,
gans he

N a i t rfld no c
tons a le
ount z nm .Thea om a i s a pr son oft Ba pt y Code does
e cli
ut tc ty ovii
he nkmz c
nota y t voi t cot ' or r i t s tbr
ppl o d he uts de s n he ui oughtby t H e dus s Ac di l Rul
he ge e . cor ngy, e

6 $/)prvde n a nu of eiffo t c utspirrzig f plitfs
09
o i s o ve e rle r m he ot ' ro t n s or anif.
l
Thesmei tuewih Rue6 $() T t ug Rue6 $()i ac thalp o ii
n s t t l 09 6.f ho h l 09 6 s ac l r vson
.
Al
whi al sac tt gt ntr le f a r as ca elw lm ist r s f wli h acour
ch low
our o a e if or ny e on, s a i t he ea ons or lc
t

ma ga rle u rRul 6 $():Do l 9 3F. a 48 Pz e dngu e Rue6 9 6
y rnt eif nde e 09 6. wel 9 2d t . oc e i nd r l 0 $()
7
,
r t e r oz na ycic s a s whi a e notpr enthe e
equies xta di r t um t nce , ch r
es
r.

Acc di y,t H ege e 'M oton t Rensa e Pr e ngs ECF N o.77,wilbe
or ngl he
dus s
i o i t t oc edi ,
l

D E N I .An a opra e Or rwilbee e e
ED
ppr i t de l
nt r d.

Entrd: D >.- 7. - l f V J
ee
-?
z

4 /- 4 2 /. F.4 '
lA
,
'

a lF.Ur nsd
e
ba l

ChifUr td S ae Ditit ud e
e z e tts stc l g
i