Cash v. Berryhill

Filing 28

ORDER ADOPTING 27 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS ; granting 14 Motion for Summary Judgment ; denying 21 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 1/15/19. (kld)

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATESDISTRICT COU RT
FO R T H E W EST EKN D ISTRICT O F W RGI G
N
H ARRT
SON BU R G D I SI N
W O
D ani lC.
e ,
lldltf,
3l zif

Cas N o.5:7- ve
1 c 00074

V.

NANCY A.
BERR#H I
LL,
Actng Com m i s onerofSoci
i
si
al
Securt
ip

By: M i
chaelF.Ut
bansd
l

Cli fUnie S a e Di t t ud
le
t d t t s s dc J ge
D ef
enda .
nt

O RD ER

Tli ma ttwa mfre t t Hono a l J e C. ppe Unt dSttsMa itae
ls te s er d o he
t b e o l Ho , ie a e gsr t

J g , us n t 2 U.. j6 6q 1 7) frp o e fn ng o fc a a
ud e pt ua t o 8 SC. 3 $() ,o r posd idi s f a t nd
t c mme de diposdon. maitaej g fldarpo ta r c mme a on
e o n d s i The gsrt ud e l
e e r nd e o nd dons
De e r28 2 8 rc mme digt tt pli fsmo n frsn r j g n be
c mbe , 01 , e o n n ha he andf
do o l
mmay ud me t
g a e t Co si e' mo frsl r j g n bed ne , n t c s be
rntd,he mmison rs don o l
mmay ud me t e id a d he ae
rma de f frhe c iea nb t Admiita eLa ud e Noobedon t t
e n d or ut r onsd rdo y he
nstdv wl g .
jc s o he
r por a r om m e
e t nd ec
ndadon ha bee fl a t c ti oft opi on t tt r por
ve n ied, nd he our s he ni ha he e t
a r com m enda
nd e
dons s d be a
houl
dopt d i isentt y.
e n t iet
A ss h, ti he eby O RD E RED t t
uc i s t
ha :

1 Ther po ta r c mme do a a nd d ( No. )i ADOPTED i
.
e r nd e o nda n s me e ECF 27 s
n
i sentr y;
t
i et

2 Pli fsmoéo fzsmmayj g n ( No. 4 i GRANTED;
. andf'
n o u r ud me t ECF
1)s
3 Dee a ' mod frsn r j g nt( No 21 i DEN I
. fnd nts on o l
mmay ud me ECF . ) s
ED;

Tli c ei REM AN D ED t t Com m i sone put ua t s nt nce f of
ls as s
o he
si r s nt o e e
our

42U. C. 40 @)f rflt rc ieainc itntwihterpo t nd
S. j 5 o lrhe onsd rto onsse t h e r a
r om m e don;a
ec
nda
nd
Tli m ate i D ISM ISSE D a STRICKR N fom t ac doc oft
ls tr s
nd
r
he dve ket he
Cotrt
I .
'

re
E t à o (- t zo f
ne : '
r9
*

#

!.''
1.
.t' ' s
%.J
ja.
,

& ..

.

.

.:, k
s. l
:

M - ha lF.
i e
c

a

.

js. .
- u ay
' t

'

ChtfU .dSttsDltlt ud
e
e ae dtc l ge

2