Savas v. District Court of Commonwealth of Virginia Augusta County et al
Filing
3
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/19/17. (mka)
o w soF l us Dlm * u
ae
Fce
s
r
A RF D iv
T oV K,A
A
v
DE2 1S 2 1
û?
I TH E U N I D STATE S D ISTRICT CO U RT
N
TE
x
.
D ,
FO R TH E W ESTE RN D ISTRI O F VIRGI I B J
CT
N A
H ARRI N BU RG D I
SO
VISION
DE
P
L
D AV I SAVA S,
D
Pettoner
ii
,
)
)
)
)
)
DI TRI COURT OF
S CT
)
COM M ONW EALTH OF W RGI A,
NI )
AUGUS COUNTY, 4Ak,
TA
4
)
Re ponde s
s
nt .
)
CaseN o.5:7c
1 v001 5
1
By:H on.M i haelY.U r
c
bans d
l
Chi fUnie S a e Di ti t udge
e
t d t t s s rc J
M E M O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O
Pe ii rD a d Sa s pr eci pr K ,fld t spe don f T rtofEz orttone
vi va , oce lng o
le hi t
or ' i
W
z
.
Or rt Re cndOr e -Vo dl g m e , c aln i a u p cfe o d ris d b
de o si
dr
i ud e nt' h le gng n ns e iid r e sue y
'
J d Ru n R. ha oft Ge e a Dit tCo tofAu saCo t . t g h as
u . pe S h he n r l sdc ur
ge
gu t un y Al h e lo
hou
n m e Ator yl Ho , 1, n Da c D. rya d fnd nt,ti u la wha
a s t ne ohn oe 11 a d r i Obe l s e e a s i s nce r t
cnm s i a Sa salgesa i tt m . vass ksla t pr ee L f ' a a ei.
li ,f ny, va le gans he Sa ee e ve o oc d q ot
m
u rs
Be a ehe a r i gent t cour wilGR AN T Sa s m odon t pr ee L f m a
c us
ppea s ndi , he
t l
va '
o oc d q or
a e i.H owe r afe z vi wi t c pli ,t cour wilD I ISS t sa ton
u rs
ve , t r e e ng he om ant he
t l SM
hi c i
p rua t 28U. C. 1 1 ()2 7)
u s nt o
S. j 9 5e() .
Un r2 U.. j1 1 ()2 ( , src c rsha ad t t sr e i i a fl g
de 8 SC. 9 5 e()B) ditit ou t ve u y o c e n n é l tn s
i
a dinas a c pli fl d t f m a a e i a a tm ei t cour de e nlne t t
nd s is om a nt le q or
u rs t ny i f he
t t r i s hat he
a to fi i fiol o maii s $)fi t saeacqm o whc r l fma beg a td;
cin <) s rv ous r lcou ; al o tt li n ih ei y r n e
(
s
e
orti s e smo tr r l fa i tad fnd n whoi i
i) e k nea y ei gans e e a t
i
e
s mmunefo s h rle ' t s
z m uc eif'I i
unce rf om t f c oft com pl i whate cty Sa i a s r i i t sa i buti
la r
he a e he
ant
xa l vas s s e tng n hi cton,
t
a pe r hetk sis wiha o d tis d b J d eS h, c o d rheb l ve s ud b
p a s a e sue t n r e sue y u g ha whih r e
ei s ho l e
e
t ci d.
es nde The c ti n i u ofisoblga i t c tuept . q f ngslbe al Etc on
out s nndf l t i ton o onst
o â ûi i t l iks
y.
.
v. z us 55 U. 8 , 4( 0 7 . vet ls, h sl z l o tu t t ql e ntdo s
Pa d , 1 S. 9 9 2 0 ) Ne rhee s t i i a c nsr ci e lt me e
be
on i
notm e n ta cot ca i e aclatfiuz t alge f ct s t f t acog z bl cqm .
a le ut n gnot
e al e o le a s e éng or h
nia e li
S eWelrv De 'ofS . .' 9 1F.d3 7 39 (t C..1 0 (Therpeilu ca
e l . t oc Sev, 0 2 8 , 1 4h i 99 ) < s ca jdiil
e
r.
r
<
s iiu 'wih whih a dit tc ts d vi w s h p q . c pl nt doesnot
olct de t
c
sdc our houl e uc z & om ai s
q
-
ta f m t c ti o a ad a e.O nl t equesi whi h a es r y pr ent t a
r ns or he ouz nt n voc t
y hos
tons c r qua el es ed o
c l ma bepz rya dts e ' < c mpli mus c ti s fkintfct l te,
oyt y
opel d e s d. T o ant t on an u f e a tz matr
). A
a
'a ce e a tue,t Ct t acbi ofr left ti plusbl on isf e.' s r tv.I ba ,556
c pt d s r o sa e
m
ei ha s a i e t ac ' A hc of
J
l
U.. 6 ,6 (0 9 (uo gBel lCo . Two ,5 0U..5 4, 7 (0 7)se
S 6 2 78 2 0 ) q én lAt.
v. mbl 5 S 4 5 0 2 0 ); e
e rl ixa 6 4 8 (ul n pla i rq ie nt u e Rul 8ofteFe ea Rue of
neal . t 8 -7 o ti g e dng e urme s nd r e
d
ni
h d rl ls
Cii Pr c du ef zT l cvla to 7
v l o e r o f l ii cins).
a
S va a srsn bai f t sfde a c u tsj idci o rt smatrlS e
a s se t o ss or hi e r l o r' urs iton ve hi te . e
Kok on nv. a d a LieI . ofAm.5 U. 3 5 3 7 ( 9 4 (f dea c rsa e
k e Gu r in f ns Co.
, 11 S. < , 7 1 9 ) d r l ou t r
7
Fe
c ursofl tdjrs it Th yposesonyta po ra t rz db Co ttto a
o t i e uidci
mi
on. e s s l h t we uhoie y nsi in nd
v
u
sa e whc i nott bee pa e b j iild c e . (n e n lctéonsomitd ) s eas
t mt, ih s o x nd d y ud ca e r e' i tr a ia
?
te l; e lo
Fe R. v. 8()( pla i t a saeacam f rr le ni tc nti as r apli
d. Ci P. a a e dng h t t t li o eif us o an ho t nn
sae nto t g o sf t c u tsjrs ci ) Thefc oft ec mpli alg sn
ttme f he r und ot he o z' u iditon . a e h o ant l e o
e
c tt
ons iuùona vi a i orvi a i off de a sa u e t woul gvers t f r lquesi
l olton
ol ton
e r l t t t hat
d i i e o ede a
ton
j rs ito u r2 U. C. 1 3 . ra et fw fc salg d s g e t ofa yot e
u id ci n nde 8 S. j 3 1 No r he e a t l e u g si
e
ve n h r
v a eczm f r l f t t e tntdvest jrs id ma bei er dund rj1 3 .
ibl li or ei , o he x e i riy u idc on y nfre
e
e 32
1 ecvl o e s eth t co q isS v sc mpln ctsteb ssfrjrsit na T S Go en n, lni.
Th ifc v r h e ta ac mp ne a a'o lit ie l ai o uidci s < . v rme tplitf'
'
z
o
U.
f'
ECF N o.2 1. t U. G o m m e doe nota a t be a pa t t t sc s .
- But he S. ve
nt s
ppe r o
ry o hi a e
2
I a e ,Sa ha notalge a c m upon whi t lefca be gt ed.The
n ny vent vas s
le d bi
ch ei n
ant
cour hasf w de al oft sa e c tot rwih wli h Sa t sis a i ha no
t
e
t is he t t our de t lc vas ake s ue, nd t s
i i wha s ve i o natle oft unde l ng s a ecout a
nsght t oe r nt
nr
he
ryi t t
t céon i whi t tor rwas
n
ch ha de
e e e How q ,ta Rooke - ll a doc tne ge t ly pr kbisl rf de a cours
nt t d.
vet le
t Fecm n
ti
ne a l oli t owe e r l
t
fo r ve ngsaec ur de ii . id n' I . . nl , 9 F.d 1 ,1 6( . Ci.
r m e iwi tt o t csons Fre ma s nc v Du a 2 0 3 91 9 4t r
h
20)
0 2.
Undert Rooke -Fedm an doczne l e f de a c t m a
he
r l
ti , ow r e r l our s y
notc i re t r T s ue ac u ly pr s nt d t a de i by
onsde ihe f s s t a l e e e o nd c ded
i
a s a e c t' or fc tt i l c m s t ar i xti bl
t t our'
fons iutona bi
hat e ne tca y
i e t n d wih q e t r ld u b asae c ur. Fllr
ntrwi e t u si ue pon y tt o t' ye
ons
'
v Mo e 1 9 F.d 7 8 7 n. ( t Ci. 1 9 ) ( e na
. or , 2 3 2 , 31 6 4h t 9 71 i r l
nt
q tton ma k o ni e ) Fe e a c zt a e di se of
uo ai
r s r t d . d r l ot s r ve td
t
r
jrs ci K r e e ti n t fde a c m s l be t
u iditon f e ntranig he e rl bi houd he
whe
e va e of a a la e r viw of t sat c t or r'
qui l nt
n ppelt e e
he t e our de .'
I r h g De o r tcPa ofVaj 1 F.d ( 9 )a 2 2 (t
o da l v. m c ai t
. 22 3 1 2, t 0 4 h
,
Ci.1 9 1 (le ains a d i tr a q otto maks o nte )
r 9 7 atr to n n e n l u ai n r r itd .
Rooker l a a is whe t f de a a ton f s
-Fedm n pple
n he e r l c i ç endal
es
ly
a nt t n ln mo et a a atmp t s e r ve o g
mou s o ot ig z h n n te t o e k e iw f t
a
he
saec ur')d cso byalwe fdea c u t' 11 ,1 F.d
tt o ts e iin
o r e rl o r. 2. = 29 3
' .
p.
a 733.Thus f n a pa t s i f de al diti c t t
t
,c
whe
ry ues n e z
s rct our o
r a j iae t s me is e d cd d i t e sae c ur
e dud c t he a
su s e i e n h tt o t
pr e lngs t ta ton i i e s nc a a t m ptt obt i diec
oc eci , ha c i s n s e e n te
o an t t
r vi w of t sat c t dec son . . . i conta nton of
e e
he t e our
ii
n
tve i
Roo r l ma ' Br wn & Ro l I .v.Bz c n i g l 2 ,
ke-Fed n. o
'
ot, nc
e ke rd e, 11
F.d (9 , a 20 ( t Ci.2 0 ).The lb latc d t t e
3 1 4j t 1 ( h r 0 02
4
a e ta he o h
f de a c t a i ' il r r l i e r be i pora , snc a
e r l our cton w l a ey, f ve ,
m t nt i e
pat t ti s e i i f d r lc r t r a j iae a is
ry ha s e kng n e e a ou t o e dud c t n sue
de i d i sat cotr i unlkey t s y s
cde n t e zt s i l o a o.
I Ad ii nal, l h na sT t ne J hn Hooe117 nd Da c D . ry a
d. d to l whi e me f or y o
y
e
At
17a
r i Obe l s
def nda s Sa ssa esno cam f r lefa i tt s i lvi l ore n m e i t m
e nt , va tt
li or ei ga ns he e nci dua s ve
ntons he
by na ei t body ofli c pl i .
m n he
ns om ant
3
A c di y,t cour fndsno gz
cor ngl he
ti
ound upon wlih i cotl gr ntSa 'pe i a
lc t zd a
vas tdon nd,
t r or ,dinls e tnsa ton.An a opra e Oz rwilbeent r d.
he ef e s is s li c i
ppr i t de l
ee
Ete: 1- / /no,
ned J/ q . =
r
M i ha lF.Ur nsd
c e
ba l
ChifUnt dStt sDitit ud e
e ie ae src l g
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?