In re: Subpoena of Angela George

Filing 1

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 4/10/2017. (jat)

cLElK' OFFI U.s. ST.
k s
CE
DI COURT
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STM CT OF VI GI I
R NA
H A RR I
SON BUR G D I I ON
V SI

AF 19 2 1
2
27
J
BY

DU L

:.

,

LERK

cu
nax

M i c la usA c i N o.5: M C00002
s e l neo
ton
17

I r Subpoe ofAnge aGe ge
n e:
na
l or
M EM O R AN DU M O PIN IO N

By:Hon.Gl n E.Co a
e
m'd
ChifUnie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
Unie St t Pr bai n Ofi r Ange a Geo ge ha bee s ve wih a s
t d aes o to
fce
l
r
s n er d t
ubpoe t
na o
t siy a t sae c i na ti lofCly M a s l Curi. Curi i be ng tid f mtr ri t
e tf t he t t rmi l ra
a
rhal ts
ts s i re or lde n he
Cic tCour f t Coun y' W a r n. Att tme oft mtr r Curi was o s l s d
r ui
t or he
t of re
he i
he lde , ts
n upewie
r las i t s ditit f a f r l fr n m ofe e. The c t ha be n a s t t t
ee e n hi src or ede a ie r
f ns
our s e dvied ha he

Co n at itn s t eii tsi ny fo tç p o ain o fc r r g r i' c ran
mmo we lh n e d o l t etmo r m h r b to fie e adn e ti
c
j
i or ton s r c ve f o Curi whiehewa unde he s pe v so .*
nf ma i he e ei d r m
ts l
s
r r u r ii n
I i w e l e t bls d t tt r c ds and r pors pr pa e a m a nt i by t U nie
t s l s a ihe ha he e or
e t e r d nd i a ned
he t d

St t Pr ba i Ofi e a e hi y c i ntal a t tt r i a sr pr sl i agans
aes o ton fc r ghl onfde i , nd ha he e s tong e lmpton i t
dic osng s h r co dst t r pa te . SeeUnie St t sDe .ofJ tc v.J i n,486 U. 1
s l i uc e r o hid ri s
t d a e pt
usi e ula
S. ,

1 ( 9 7 (ç 1 b t cv la d ci n lc s st e c u t h veb e v r r lca tt gv t id
2 1 8 ) ç1n oh ii n rmia a e h o rs a e n ey eu tn o ie hr
(
pa te ac es t t pr e e e i si to r por pr pa ed f s
ri s c s o he es nt nc nve tgai n e t e r or ome ot r i vi l or
he ndi dua

idv d as' (olci gc s s.W hl mo tc s sivovngt ea piaino t i p eu to
n ii u l.) c l tn a e ) ie s a e n li h p lc to f h s r s mpin
' e

*

I ac danc wih polc die i is d byt Admi sr tve Ofie oft Unied Stt sCours
n cor e t
iy r ctves s ue
he
nita i
fc
he t
ae
t,

tematrh sb e rfre t t u desgn dc e dsrc j d ef rc sd rto rg r n a a prprae
h te a e n ee rd o he n ri e hif itit u g o on ie ain e adig n p o it
rs on et tes bp e a Se Gud t J iir Pol y Voume2 ,Cha tr8 j8 0 b ()( oigt tt
e p s o h u o n . e ie o udcay i , l
c
0 p e , 4 ( )3 n tn ha he
c ifp o ai o fc r s o d f o utwi t c e j g o t c r s r e b t patc a ofc
he r b ton fie h ul f ns l t he hif ud e f he ou t ev d y he riulr fie
c
h
rgadn t ep o e rs o et ar q e t drce t a e o e o t tofc )
e r ig h r p r e p ns o e u s' ie td o n mply e f ha fie.
'

i ve r que t f rpr s ntnc r pors c t ha r ogni d t tP he polc r as be nd
nvol e s s o e e e e e t, ours ve ec ze ha t
iy e ons hi
pr eci c nfde ilt a y a a1sa soft pr e ngsbewe n t de e nta t
ot tng o
nta iy ppl t 1 t ge
he oce di
t e he f nda nd he

pr ton ofie.' l r Se No.2: - C- 1 U. Dit LEXI 1 40,a *5( Vt J n.
obai fc ' n e m,
96M 3, 996 S. s.
S 6 t D. . a

1 1 9 )(olci c s s ;s eas Untd Sae v Hars n No 9 - 4 - ,20 3 U..Dit
2, 9 6 c l t a e ) e lo ie tts . rio , . 2 5 3 1 0 S s.
e ng
LEXI 7 3 ,*12 ( D.Pa M a 7 2 0 )(b e vn t a ( ie Sae p o ain tlsa e
S 7 3 - E.
. y , 0 3 o s r i g h t t td tts r b to ie r
un
co i nta cou tr co dsc
nfde i l r e r ompie i t cotr eoff lilng c tor r d r s i ltes' a
ld n he ls
ufli our- de e e ponsbiii ,' nd

t rf r c n o b ds l sdt atidpat wi u p ira t rz to fo tec u t.
heeo e n n t e ico e o hr ry t t ro uho iain r m h o r)
ho

l od rt o ro tejeu to a ans dsls r,atidpat mus d mo srt
n r e o vec me h rs mpin g i t ico ue hr ry t e ntae
t a (lfig c n e tai i rq ie t me tt ee dso j sie' ie S ae v. a zki
h t t it o sd nilt s e ur d o e h n f u tc .'Untd tts Fiu s ,
G n
y
'
5 F.d 3 9 3 1( t Ci.1 7 )( u tn Ha c c Br t rp n . J ne , 9 F. u p.1 2 ,
45 2 8 , 9 4h r 9 6 q o ig n o k ohes I c v. o s 2 3 S p 2 9
1 3 ( D. l 1 6 ); e as Uni dS ae v. r rI uss n .71 F.d 1 6 ,1 7 ( d
2 3 N. Ca. 9 8 ) s e lo t tts Chnme nd .I c, 1 2 1 4 1 3 2
e
Ci.1 ($ ea eewih t rtonal ofHanc k Br t r a wih isc uson t tt
r 983) ç gr t he ai e
W
oc ohes nd t t oncl i ha he
ditit c ts d not a horz dicl ur of a pr e e r por t a t r peron i t
src our houl
ut i e s os e
es nt nce e t o hid s n he
a e e ofa c
bs nc
ompe lng de onsr ton t tdic os e oft r po ti r r d t mee t e
li
m tai ha s l ur
he e r s equie o
t he nds

o j sie' Th c u th saEarme s r o d sr to ' i d tr nig wheh rt i sa d r
f u tc .
). e o r a s i a u e f ic ein' n eemi n
f
te hs tn ad
ha bee m e . Cha me ,711F. a 11
s n t
r r
2d t 77. I exe cii is dic e i t co tm us c i r
n r sng t s r ton, he ur
t onsde

wh t e t ei omaina is ei o ti befo oh rs u c s Se jlCW c n rlee n i
eh r h nfr to t su s bana l r m t e o re . e .
t
:
a
e ta lme t n
t s wi r quied ofat r pe s n s e ng dicl ur i t deg eet whi t i br ton
he ho ng e r
hid r o e ki
s os e s he r o ch he nt ma i

i t (rbai n fljc n o b o tie fo oh rs u c s' s e as Gudet J dca y
n he p o to ie a n t e b an d r m t e o re . e lo i o u iir
);
Polc Vol 8,Cha e 6,56 ( pli ngt c i ntaiyma belfe Sift fde a
iy, ume
ptr
30 ex ani hat onfde ilt y itd l q he e r l
g
c tc l st tdicl lr oft s
our oncude ha s osze he ubpoe e i onnai i nec s a y t G tt e of
na d nf
ton s e s r o mee he nds

j sie' a t tG ico t e s o l bed n e wh n te rq e td if r to i a ia l b
u tc ,' nd ha t s l sl h u d e id e h e u se n o main s valbe y
'
d
r
a ohe me nssn et eçnd o j tc ' ono icu eme ec n ninc ' .
n t r a ic h e s f usie d t n l d r o ve e e'
)
2

The s me co i r tonsha be n hel t a y whe pr ton r or a e s htf r
n
nsde a i
ve e
d o ppl
n oba i ec ds r oug o

u ei saej d ca pr c e ig , t ci n la d cvl S e ec,Unie S ae v. v , .
s n tt u iil o e dn s boh rmia n i i. e . .. td tts Do e No
3:
08CR31, 2008

Dit L S 8 9 ,a * ( D.Va No 5 2 08 ( e yn te
s. EXI 9 65 t 5 E.
. v. , 0 ) d n ig h

pe ii rsm oto t a e st pr s nt nc r por ofa c c e f r lofe ri ntfed a a
ttone '
i n o cc s he e e e e e t
onvit d ede a f nde de ii s
wines i a pe ng sa e pr e uto on t bass t t t peii rs Cge r lze a
t s n
ndi t t os c i n
he
i ha he ttone ' ç ne a i d nd

uns ppore ase tonofne d figdjt s tsyt heg e d sa df t r pa t ac es t
u td s ri
e ale o aif he ihtne tndar or hid- ry c s o

p e e tn er p rs); nr Se 1 9 U. Dit LEXI 1 4 , t* ( e yigar q s t o ti
rs n e c e o t' I e m, 9 6 S. s.
S 6 0 a 2 d n n e uet o b an
de ii t si ony f o a f de alpr bai n ofi e f us i a f miy c tpr ee ng snc
poston e tm
r m e r o to tc r or e n n l our oc di i e

t pe ii ne f l t de
he tto r aied o monsr t q lc ofat m a i s ur e f obt i ng t i or i a
ta e a k
le tve o c s or ani he nf maton t

is ) I r Ap lc to o Ho so d 6 9 F.S p 4 3 4 5 ( D. Y.1 8 (o ldngt a
sue; n e p iain f rf r , 9
u p. 6 , 6 S. N. 98 ) c ncu i h t
t a s re ne d f dicos e of a f de a ofende ' pr e e a pr bai s r ii n
he s e td e or s l ur
e r l f rs es nt nce nd o ton upe v so

r co ds f us i a sae c i na pr e i was ç s fc e l co pe lng t ba a e t
e r or e n tt rmi l oc ed ng
t ufi i nty m li o l nc he
not

d sr bl yo c n iu dc n i e tai o Eu hrc r s'
e ia it f o tn e o fd n il y f s c e o d q).
i
t
l t s c s ,t c tha r e ve a l te f om t Com m onw e lh' A tor y ou lni
n hi a e he our s ec i d e t r r
he
a t s t ne ti ng

t t si o t t t Comm o a1h it nds t e ii fom t pr bai n ofke a t
he e tm ny ha he
nwe t n e
o lct r
he o to
t r nd he
s g sc nc o t pr pos d t si o Theco thasas r e ve asl a y oft pr ton
i ni a e f he o e e tm ny.
m'
lo ec i d tmm r
he oba i
ofi e ' c
fc rs omm uni to wih t f de a ofe r whi h co i' t Comm o
cai ns t he e r l f nde ,
c
nfl
ms he
nweat s
lh'

Ator y' f e as oft ev de e. Bas on t i onza i pr de t t c t a i lght
t ne s or c t he i nc
ed
he nf a ton ovi d p he our, nd n i
oft s ro naur o t c i e c r
he e i us t e f he rm ha ged,t c tc ude t tt Comm onwe 1h ha m e
he our oncl s ha he
at s t

isb r e o d mo srtn t a tep o o e tsi n i n c sayt me ttee d o j sie
t u d n f e n taig h t h r p s d etmo y s e e s r o e h n s f u tc .
The co thasbe n a s t tt t si on pe ti t m a tr t t a e uni y wili t
ur
e dvied ha he e tm y rans o te s ha r
quel tln he
knowl
edge of t pr ba i ofi r t t t i or ai n c nno be obt i fom a ot r
he o ton fce , ha he nf m to a t
aned r
ny he
s c , a t t i i c ii alt t pr e ton of t c i i c e. On ba a e,t c t
our es nd ha t s rtc o he os cu i
he rm nal as
l nc he our

be ives t t t Com monwe lh' i e e t i obt ni t pr to ofkers t si
le
ha he
a t s nt r s n
ai ng he obai n f ' e tmony
out i hst i e e ti m ant i ngt c i nta iy oft i or a i s r c i d fom he
we g he nt r s n i ani he onfde ilt
he nf m ton he e e ve '
r
r
s l s d r e s . Acc di y,t c twila horz t pr bai n ofi e t c
upewie ela ee
or ngl he our l ut i e he o to fc r o ompl wih
y t

t e s b o na a d o fr tsi n ' lv n t te is e i e tfe b te Co n at s
h u p e n l fe etmo y r e a t o h su s d niid y h mmo we l
e
h'
Ato ne The c te
tr y.
our mphasze ,howe r t tis de i i i lmie t t pa tc a f c s of
i s
ve , ha t c son s i t d o he riul r a t
t sc s
hi a e.
'

DATED: i 1 1: d yo Api, (1y
Ths 0 a f rj p ),
,

Chif nie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

4