DIRECTV v. Coley et al

Filing 19

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/9/2018. (jv)

CL RK'PFJ Uqu'
E S -A S r
FC

FORTHEWES S DITRIS OFVI NI A FFEK
I THE UNI TERN S DITRI COURT TKXOY
N
TED TATES CT CT RGI A
lD
HARRI
SONBURG DI SI
VI ON

AP 1p DF
R
J
ULZ C
3Y;

;
CL EI

D I CTV ,LLC,
M

Ci lActon N o.5:7- cvi
i
1 m 00004

Pl nt f y
ai i f

By:H on.M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l

M N D Y CO LEY,etal
.

Chi fUn t d S a e D iti t udge
e ie t t s src J

D ef
endant
s.

M em or
andum O pi on
ni
Thi m ate com esbef et cour on pe ii rI m be l Coly' M oton t
s tr
or he
t
ttone ii ri e s
i o

Re o i e Mavh 2 , 01 Or r(heK l in t Re onsde 'o K o . c nsd7 ECF
c nsd r l 9 2 8 de t t ot o c i r' r < t Re o i .
s o
xf
),
No. 8 Thec u tsM a c 2 2 8Or r(he< de7 s sane r s nd n DI
1.
o r' r h 9, 01 de t f r' u ti d e po e t RECXV
or )

LLC' I< RECT ' Obe to t Ma itaeJ d 'J n pr , 01 Or rGr nt
SC
DI
V I jcins o gsrt u ges a ua 3 2 8 de a i
ng
I
Gmbe l Coe ' M o i t Qua h (h t jcins' ECF N o 1 , n de e i
ry lys ton o s t e f e to ',
ob
)
. 5 a d nid n
s sa il r Coe ' M o in t Qu s ECF No. .Ast c u tfndst M o i t
ub tnta pat lys to o a h,
11 he o r i he ton o
Re
consde lga l ba ees ,i wilbe D EN I .
i r e ly s l s t l
ED
Col f ist a tc a et lga sa r unde w hih he M oton t Rec i r
ey al o riul t he e l tnda d
r c r
i o
onsde

s oud bea j iae o d t r s me in ( c ls a lz )t ep o e url o nst
h l
dudc td r f hewie nto mu h e s nay e h r c d a pr pe iy
o
ofge lmoto 'W oo e v. r ii,1 F. u 31 9 8 3( . Va 2 6 . c u t
h r i n.
' t n Vi l a 68 S pp. :8 0, 9 W D. . 01 ) The o r
a
wil sumet tColyha fe he mo i un rFe r l l ofCiiPt e t 5 $. e
la s
ha e s i d t ton de de a Rue
l
vl oc du e 47 Se
M c e v Boc a, o 31 c 6 6 2 2W L 2 0 2 3 a * ( D. . u e2 , 01 )
Afe . z r N . :1 v 4 , 01
5 5 6 , t 2 E. Va J n 8 2 2
1 ec u t tn e t s o in t Qu s o l a t Pa a rp 1 o t eS b e a
Th o r g a td he l t o ah ny s o rg a h 4 f h u po n .
o

'

(nay igarc i tto mot rltdt amoto t q ahu e Rul 5 $) Co t
a lzn e onsdeain i eae o
on
in o u s nd r e 49 . urs
i t i cr ui h vei epr td Rue5 $)t r qur t ep rys e igr c nsde ai n t
n hs ic t a ntr e e l 4 o e ie h a t e kn e o i r to o
s o ( 1 a i e v n n c n ei t lw,()ne e ie c t twa no ptv o l
h w:ç ) n ntr e i g ha g n he a 2 w vd n e ha s t e i usy
(
a ia l, r()c r ci oface êer roflw o t prve ma fs ij t e'Wootn
valbe o 3 ore t
on
la ro a r o e nt ni t nusi .
e
c '
e,
1 F.Supp.3d a 8 I pora l,r onsde a i i nota ia ewhe e apa t i smpl
68
t 93. m t nty ec i r ton s
valbl
r
ry s i y
di s ts i w ih t c tsr i a s ksa s cond bieatt a e. e i
s a ifed t he our' ulng nd ee
e
t
he ppl Se d.

Coly onl c pli t tt c tm adea cea eroroflw by c ltng t
e
y om ans ha he our
l r r
a
onfa i he
Fourh Cic tsopi on i Sk Ca e LLC v.D I
t r ui' ni n
bl
RECT' I ,--F. --,2018W L
V nc. - 3d --

1 4 3( hCi. a . 8 2 8 , ih a tr d t i c u t nise ie y wih t Fou t
51 41 4t r M r 2 , 01 )whc f me hs o r i t ntr t, t he rh
i
Cic i' f rhc nz ma dae whc ta se sj rs ito b c t t i c u t 4 h Ci. 41
rut o t o i
s
ng n t, ih r n fr u id ci n a k o hs o r, t r R. .
S eM ot Re o i !4
e
. c nsd. .

Colyi wr ng Thec r i c g z n t a i ge e al lc j idci t a ndt
e s o .
ou t s o nia t h t t n rl a ks urs it o me he
y
on
jdg nt i i i si un ra pe l f r t Fo rh Cic i, ihi whyt c ur d d
u me whl t s tl de p a beo e he u t r u twh c s
e
l
he o t i
notlf iss a oft O r rI plm entng Appoi e ofRe i r Sk Ca e LLC v.
it t t y he de m e
i
n% nt
ceve ,
bl

cpty 51 -v- ( . Va Au .1 , 01 ) ECF No. 0 . nse d ofa p r re
-e , :1 c 48 WD. . g 2 2 6,
3 9 I ta
ny u po t d

.

nls once i ornas pplca i oft lw,t c tba e t O r ron S ln sv. 1
ic
pton
ia i ton
he a he our s d he de
i
A1

Fi nca l .whc pr vde t ttec ur d oe rti j idci t e o c te
na il nc, ih o i s ha h o tf s ean urs it o nfte h
d
on
jd n 'd i a a a.6 7F. p' 1 ,1 1( h Ci. 1 )( otn Ci of
u pne t' urng n ppe l 5 Ap x 48 5 4t r 20 6 qu i g
Co e i ev. e Cu ra d Elc M e rhi Co .48 F.d 3 0 3 4 ( t Ci.
ok vl U r mbe ln e . mbe s
l
r , 4 3 8 , 9 6h r
20 7 TheS bp nameey se st e o c t u ryn jdg ntwh c t ec u t
0 :.
u oe
r l e k o nf r e he ndeli g u me , ih h o r
un q ioc l r ti jrs ito t d S ei .
e uv al eans u id cin o o. e d
y

Fort f s t , e ag st a Sp i si i ppia e S eMotRe o i ! 1 .
he i t i Coly r ue h t rng s na l bl. e
r me
c
. c nsd. 2
Bu DI
t RECTV' Objci nsctd S rn sf t smep o ii t c ur a ptd i is
s e to ie i or he a r poston he o t do e n t

Or t seObe to 6 a Colyssx en- g Repo et DI
de,e jcins , nd e' ite pa e s ns o RECI SObjcinst
V' e to o
M a itaeJ d 'J n t 3, 0 8Or r ECF No.1 ,fie t me tonSp i s Coly n w
gsr t u ges a uay 2 1 de ,
6 ald o n i rng . e o
want dt c nc t c a tne ori pr
s the ha e o r f w
m oved lga postons' butt tm et a tcult her
e l ii ,'
he i o ri a e
lga postonshasl pa s d. oot 168 F.Supp.3d at893.
e l ii
ong s e W
en,
A c di y,Coly' M oton f Re
cor ngl
c s
i or consde a i v'lbe D EN I D .
i r ton i
l
E

I i SO O RD ERED .
ts

Enee, ôq- &q- got
trd
Z

/
w/

2
m

/ .

M i ha lF.Ur
c e
ba

'

ChifUnt tt sDitit u ge
e ie ae src l d

'