Hixson v. Raynes et al

Filing 15

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 1/23/2019. (jv)

CLERK' OF CE U. .DI COURT
S FI
S ST.
AT RG NOKE,
VA
FI
LED

UN I
TED STATE S D I RICT CO U RT
ST
W EST ERN D ISTRICT O F VI GI IA
R N
H ARRI N BU RG D I SION
SO
W

J 23 2 1
Ay
29
JU
sv,

C.
DUDLEY LERK

%j
(
e

..
x

C AREY H I
XSO N ,
lldttfy
a l lif

M.

Ci lActon N o. 5: CVvi
i
: 17- 032
5: CV18- 001

BRYAN H U TCH ESO N ,eta1,
.

By:

M i haelF.U r
c
bansl
dy

Chi fU. Diti t udge
e S. s rc J
D ef
çndant .
s

M EM O M N D U M O PI I
N ON

Plidf Cae Hi onrflx on), ni ll de nd n da dc alg sh wa
an f ry xs lis ' a nsln- pe e t ibe , l e e s
i
e
de e i fl whi i rc rtda t Hars bur- l g m Re i l alf L ',
nid nspn l nc eae the tion gRocdn ha gonali(C RJ'
i
e
HI )
gi ng rs t avi a
vi ie o ol don ofli Ei h Am e
ls ght
ndm e rght a a sa e lw cni ofgr s
nt i s nd t t -a l m
os

n gke c . x o sS c ndAme e Co antfrMo tr Da g sECF No. 2 ,
e l n e His n' e o
nd d mpli o neay ma e,
15
rie t s cnmsa nns Dee a DrMiha l rn (Dr Mo a ),hedo tra HRR
as s hee li g i t fnd nt . c e Mo a < . rn' t co t J
f
dltng H i on' i a c r don.Thi m a trc esbe or t c uton D z M ot n' M odon
pi
xs s nc r e a
s te om
f e he ot
. a s

f S l r ud me . No. 8 Fo t er a o gve beo t c ur GRANTS
or lmmayl g nt ECF 1 9. r h e s ns i n lw,he o t
t m odon.
he
I.
1

H i on w a ft tdignos d wih t 2 di be e i Apdl2015 dltng a hos t lz don
xs
s ts a
e t ype a t s n
li
piaia

a Ro kng a Me ra Hos ia (lMH' ECF No 1 - , t49 Dlrngt s me
t c i h m mo il p tl <t ).
<
. 99 5 a . zi he a
hos t ls a hewasas dignos wih m e hamphe a i -nduce ps hoss
pia ty,
lo a
ed t
t
t m ne i
d yc i,
1 efcso tic s aesx z e b lw a , o itn wi tesa r jd me sa d r, r ve di te
Th at f ls ae r lmmai d eo nd c nsse t t h '
z
h
mmay u g nt tn ad ae iwe t h
z
l ht s fv rbet His n S eWak r . du-fatHo sI 7 5F.d2 2 2 5n1(t Ci. 0 4 ( ng
i mot a oa l o x o . e le v Mo - lrf me.ZC, 7 3 0 , 0 . 4h r2 1) dd
g
F Cv Calo , 2 F.d1 9 1 3(t Cr2 1 ).
DI . sl n 7 0 3 6 , 7 4h i. 0 3)
i

pol ubsa e a e a a c
ys t nc bus , nd l ohola e. d. c ula
bus I A ons tdon not by aphyscan on Aprl26,
e
ii
i

2015 r c de t tH i on ha alit yofi e m it ntbl r vii a pa eshesasoft
e or d ha xs
d lsor
nt r te
ur y son nd t t i
he

ha a f e .JL
nd nd e t I
-.

Dt M o a wa t em e ia d t tf i t sa HIRJdlig Hi on'
. tn s l d c l oco ot nmae t L l n xs s
a
t
i r r
nca ce adon.
ECF N o.199- a 5.H ewa e pl d by Rocki m Count t pr vi
3, t
s m oye
ngha
y o o de

me ia c r t t i mae .. a 6 His n e tz dHRRJo Au s 23 2 6 a d wa
d c l ae o he n ts J t . x o n e e
Z
n gu t , 01 n s
r la e onl n r 29 20 7 ECF No 1 92, t3 . n e ty I is n wa se b a
ee s d a ua y , 1 .
. 9 - a 1 Upo n r , 'x o s e n y
I
nonpa t i a nur e ECF N o.199- a 7-8.H ei or ed he t heha t 1,nsli
r y nt ke s .
3, t
nf m
r hat
d ype i llndepe ntdibet s butt i a nur ew a una et congf t dignoss de pie f vi
nde a e ,
he nt ke s s bl o
' he a
m
i, s t a ng
ar c d r s t Hi on' m e c lpt de .I Dr. or n t dfed t tt m e ca t a
e ot eque t o xs s dia ovi r d. M a es i ha he di l e m

a HRRJwa u b et o an His n' me ia hso ybe a ef n D x o )sg d h s
t
s na l o bti x o s d c l it r c us f
whe
s n ine i
r e e f m ,hewr edo notr e e m e a he lh i or a
elas or
ot
elas
nt l at nf m éon,'a H i on' dignossof
' nd xs s a
i

dibe e wa m a durng li sa i t ps hit uni ofRM H .ECF N o.199- a 8.
a t s s de i ls ty n he yc a dc t
2, t
Polc dit t d t tanur e r pea t r d t s i aheat pt de f ied t r s
iy c a e ha
s e t he ecor eque t f
lh ovi r al o e pond
wihi 24 holr .
tn
z s ECF N o.199- a 10.I t pr de s ldi notr s
4, t
f he ovi r dl d
e pond wihi 24 hout
tn
s
oft s ond t s , iy t quie t tt nut ecalt physca f or r a
he ec
eque t polc e r d ha he s l he
i in or de s nd
docl entt tno t or we ee rr eve 1 W hiet odgm a r cor r ques t
lm
ha
ec ds r ve ec i d. d. l he
' le d e
to

Hi on' pr de wasm ade,no e de ha be n eiie s
xs s ovi r
vi nce s e lct d howi ar pe tr ques w a
ng e a e t s

m a ort tD r M or n wascont c ed r ga di t e f iur t s cut r c ds L.
de ha . a
a t e r ng l al e o e e e or . I
a
L
D r M or n r vi we t i or a t ke by t i a nlr eand plce H i on on
. a e e d he nf m éon a n he nt ke zs
a d xs
a dibe k dit ECF N o.199- a 8. ea s or r d H i on' bl s rlve sbe t sed
a t e.
2, t H lo de e
xs s ood uga e l
et

e r da J aFort fr tf m ont ofli i ar e a i Hi on' bl s zr afi
ve y y. - . he ls our
d
hs ls nc c t ton, xs s ood uga e lngs
2

we evai bl,wih s e nor ala s e ee t d s ot . Se ECF N o.113- 2,a 18-22.
t ta e t om
m nd om lva e c esz e
1 t

Hi on' Se t mbe r al gsr n d fom alw of9 mg/ on S ptmbe 2 , 01 t a
xs s p e r e cn a ge r
i
o
4 x
e e r 42 6o
hih of1 7mg L o S ptmbe 22 2 1 L a k wie i Oc o r l slw r a i wa
g
5 /d n e e t , 0 6. d Lie s ,t t be ,l o e dng s
l
i
1 8mg dL on Ocobe 3 2 6a li hg r a n wa 1 mg/ on Ocobe 5 20 6
1 /
t r , 01 nd t ih e dig s 69 K
s
t r , 1.

J N o mb tsz a i sc e pt u bu z mane ve a l,fo a1w of1 7mg/ L o
. ve e ' e dng t e d p, t e i d
Z
be r m o
3
d n
N o e r25 2 1 t ahih of2 9mg dt o No mbe 3 2 6 L De e rs
v mbe , 0 6 o g
3 / a n ve r , 01 . da c mbe '

r a i swhi hkhe,sill tae fo 1 8mg dL o De e r2 2 1 t 2 7
e dng, l
e
r tlfucu td r m 1 / n c mbe 4, 0 6 o 7
m g d a D e e r7 2 1 .. His ' b o s g rv l e r ti d t svaibit i
/ t on c mbe , 0 6 J x ons l od u a au s eane hi ta l y n
Z
i

J nu t 20 7 i a t r ed y t a mon h, a a y21 2 , nd 2 , x o sB iedal
a ay 1 . d On h e a s h t t J nu r , 4 a 8 Hi s n' v c i
y
r ci we em or t n 100poi sa r.J
ealngs t
e ha
nt pa t A
Hi on as be occ i ly t f i t s
vs lo gan asonal e usng e dng,cli i a ehenson i i e ac i
l m ng ppt
i n nt r tng
wih N ur eK a he i Ra nesafe aconfont
t
s
t rde y
tr
r adon wih he overiw 1i 3ECF N o.1 - a
t r
t 1n.
99 2, t

34. r M or t viwed t bl s rr di on aw e l ba i ,a i ca e by li
D . an e e
he ood uga ea ngs
edy ss s ndi t d ls
i dasi Hi on' m edi lr or ECF N o.199- a 13.l r s
ni l n xs s
ca ec d.
4, t
n e pons t t hi rt di ,
e o he ghe ea ngs

Dr Morn o de e t a t bl s g tt ssbepe f r dt c dal i a a y20 7 b
. a r r d h t he ood u a e t
ro me wie i nl nu r 1 , ut
y
a no poi ci D z M or n pr c i Hi on any t ofor ldi be e m eciadon ori ni
t
nt ld . a es rbe xs
ype
a a t s lc
t lt
w n

i e d . No. 9 -, t23 W hl His n cnmsherpe tdyak dnu sngsaff
njc onsECF 1 92 a . ie x o li .e ae l s e ri tf or
i uln,not ng i tn r or i c t t tH i on r por e any s pt sofee t d
ns i
hi n le ec d ndia es ha xs e t d
ym om
lva e
bl s rt e t ra nur eorD r M or n.I e H i on w a s e byD r M ot n on
ood uga o ihe
s
.
a nde d, xs
s en
.
a

2Ofiil oiya HRW stanoma fsigbo dsg rrn eo 6 -1 mg d zECFNo 1 21 , t .I eAmeia
f apl t
c
c
e r l at lo u a a g f 01 0 / t.
n
. 1 -2 a 6 'h
'
rcn
Dib t s s ca o s g e t atr e r n eo 8 - 3 mg d aAmeia Dibee Aso it n Ch cr Yo rBl o
a ee Aso id n u g ss ag t a g 'f 0 1 0 / t. zc n a ts s cai , e ln u o d
o
i
Glc s,ls e i dOc. , 0 8, :/ b tsog n gGi- b ts tea e ta d-ae bo dgu oe
u o e ( t dt t9 2 1)ho / ia ee.r/ e - ia ee/ a n-n cr/ lo -lc sa e
c nûo/ h c l gy u - lodgu o ehml
o lc e kn - o rbo - lc s .t .
'
3Nuz e Ra ne va ey r m e be st c r adon butdoe notr m e be i H i on r q t d i l i ECF N o. s y s gu l e m r he onfont
s
e m r f xs e uese nsx n.
l
199
4,a 1 .
t5

3

Se e be 29,2016 a di notz l t any s pt sofordicus di e . CF N o.199pt m r
nd d
eae
ym om
s s abet s E
2,
a 35. ozdi Ilxs Sl an ofk ilgre nc orcom pli a ki f i uln oza ot
t N
d -i on e
i a iva e
ant s ng or ns i
ny her

f m ofdibee teame .A
or
a ts r t ntJ
H i on fl hi org nallw s ton M a c 31,201 a i tDr M or n a va
xs led s ii a ui
th
7 gans .
a nd dous

ot rde e
he f ndant who ha sncebe din is 4ECF N o.1.Hi on algest f l ng
s
ve i
en s as ed.
xs le he olowi

c u e ofa do a ans DrMorn:()DtMornvoae His n' fih t befe fo
a s s c n g i t . a 1 . a iltd x o s fg t o r e r m
z
dei r ei f e encet li known s rousm e c lnee f ci be m e ca
lbe at ndif r
o ns
ei
dia
d or la éc di don

(z srpt o ohewie t te tlskn wn, dcl dig sdc nddono da tsJ
p eci i r t r s) o ta a o me ial a no e o i f ibee,
on
i
y
'
ECF No 1 , t3 ; nd ()Dr Mo a c mmi dme ia map a dc , sa elw cnm
. 25 a 8 a 2 . r n o le d c l lr c e a t t a li
wlih hasbee dinns e t t e e i s
lc
n s is d o he xt nt t oundsi ne i nc z t rt n gr sne i nc
n glge e, a he ha os gl
ge e.

ECF N o.1 a 38;ECF N o.16 H i on as s kspuri dam a a a t ne 'f es
25, t
7. xs lo ee
léve
ges nd tor ys e ,

prmie o t el bit un r4 U. C. 1 8 a ans Dr Mo a ECF No 1 , t4
e s d n h i l y de 2 S. j 9 3 g i t . r n.
a i
. 25 a 5.
I
I.

Pu sa tt Fe ea RueofCiiPr e t 56a,hec ur mus f rn smmay
ru n o d rl l
vl ocdu e ()t o t tf a t u r
g
jd me ti t mo n s wst tteei n g nlneds ea t a maeila ta
u g n f he va t ho ha h z s o e l iput s o ny tra fc nd
i
t mo a i e ldt jd me a amatroflm'Fe R. v. 5 a; ltxCo .
he v nts ndte o u g nt s te a ' d. Ci P. 6()Ceoe
v.
Cart, 7 U.. 7 3 2(9 69 nnv.
tet4 7 S 31 , 2 1 8 ) Gl
EDO Co .7 0F.d2 , 1 (t Ci. 1 )
, 1 3 09 2 3 4h r20 3.
W he m a ng t sde e m i don,t c ts d c i tt lepl di ,de i ,
n ki hi t r na
he our houl onsde f l ea ngs posdons
t

a we st i e r g t de , n a nison on fl,og t e wih..a )a ida t' f d b
ns r o ntro ao s a d dr si s i t eh r t .gny f vis? ze y
e
4Hi snsoiia c mpan b o g tcnmsa anst To nDo 'n te. No. . a u t 3 2 1 , xo
xo ' rgn l o lit r u h li g i t wo q h e' u ssECF 1 Onln ay , 0 8 Hisn
fe Hisnv. ne, :8c -0 - ? whc b o g tclmsa an t y sa dln l S e fr, n te nus a
t d xo Ra s51 -v 0 1MF
l
U, ih ru h li gis Rane n a el ekod a oh r t e t
e
HRRJAstl sc n ad nbru htd n cl li a ansRan sa S e fr a wee&s b o g taans t Do
. ls eo d c o o g ie d a cnms g i t y e nd eko d s r t ru h g i the e
i
nur e a alge t s m e f t al ge i Hi o sodgta c
s s nd le d he a ac s l d n xs n' izl ompl i , twa cla f om t f c oft Ra ne
e
ant i s e z r he a e he
s
c
ompl i t tRa ne a S kf r az ,i f c ,t D oenur e na e i F o sozgna c
ant ha y s nd ee o d e n a t he
s s m d n sxs n' i i l ompl i .ECF N o. a 6.
ant
94, t
'he c 't c olda e t t ca es ECF No. O n N o m be 19, 8, y sand Se kf r we e cimi s d
I out hus ons i t d he wo s .
t
95.
ve r 201 Ra ne
e o d r ls s e
a de e nt .
s f nda s ECF N o. .
198

4

t pa de .Ce otx,477 U . a 322.W het ra f cti m a e i depe on t r lva
he z s l e
S. t
he a s t ral
nds
he e e nt

s bsa elw. ronv. bet Lo y I .47 U. 24 , 4 (9 6.f z ds uts
u tndv a Andes Li ry bb ,nc, 7 S. 2 2 8 1 8 ) f l ip e
ozy
ove f ct t tnzghta f c t out e oft sltunde t gove ni 1w wilpr zy
r a s ha i f e t he com
he ti
r he
r ng a l ope l

p el etee c o s
rcud h nt f ummayjdg ntFa ta dipue t taeirlva to unn c say
r u me . c' l s ts ha r ree n r e esr
u

wil otb c ntd. J. (ia nomitd . mo n pat be r t i da bt e of
ln e ou e ' - ctéo
'I
L
te )The vig ry as he ni l ud n
de ons r dng t abs eofa ge neis ofm a e i lf ta m a pr va lby s
m
ta
he enc
nui sue
t ra ac nd y e i
howi
ng
Ta a e e ofe de e t s
fn bs nc
vi nc o uppot' a e s nta eem e oft nonm ovi pa t sc e.
t' n s e il l nt he
ng zy' as
Ceot x, U . a 323.I t bur n ha bee m e ,t nonm ovi pa t m us t n com e
l e 477 S. t
f hat de s n t he
ng ry
t he
f
orwa d wih s c f m a e lf ct t tpt t r i age inediput f ti l M a s hia
r t pe ik t da a s ha ove he e s nli s e or ra. tus t

Elc I u . v. nihRa oCo .4 U.. 7 5 68 (98 )
e. nd s Co. Ze t di r , 75 S 5 4, 8 -7 1 6.
I de er i ng whe he age lneis ofm a e i lf te ss t cour viwst
n t m ni
t r
nli s ue
t ra ac xit , he
t e he

f t a dt wsalr s bl i e e esi t lghtm os f vot bl t t nonm ovi pa t
ac s nd a l ea ona e nf r nc n he i
t a a e o he
ng r p

cll 71 F.da 2 3(ii Bo v. a iq6 9F. 36 , 8 (t Ci. 1 ). t u h
zym, 0 3 t 1 ctng nds Le vt 2 3d 9 3 0 4h r20 1)Alho g
-

.

fhee ie c oft no va i t bebeive , n alus bl i ee e aet be
f vd n e he nmo nts o
t
l d a d lj dha e nftnc s t o
e
dr wn i li fvor' M cAili I .v.I m be l - a k Co . N o.13a n ns a ,'
'
tads nc ii r clr
,
2044,201 W L
4

28 1 9 , t 1(t Ci. 0 4 ( tr a atrdo omitd (ingTolnvs to 1 4S. .
7 4 2 a * 4h r 2 1 ) i en l lea n te ) ct
n
i
a - tn, 3 Ct
co
1 6 ,1 6 ( 1 )( rcliml,fthemeee itn eofasi iaofe i nc i sppo to
8 1 8 3 20 4 pe lr/ lfg
j
r xse c
cntl vde e n u r f
l
t g nmo nt )p iin wil i ufiint t o r o s mmayj g ntAndes n,
he no va ' osto lbe ns fce ' o ve c me u r ud me . r o
s
'
477 U . at252.Rat r age xnei s ofm a e ilf c exit onl T ft r i s f ent
S.
he , nli s ue
t ta a t s s y f he e s ufki
i

e de efvo gt n mo i pat frajr t yt naveditfrta pat ' s
vi nc a dn he on vng ry o u y o eur
r c o h t tp'Re.
Ba s rsCo . S. ul t I . , 7F.d6 ,6 5(t Ci. 00 )(u ng
nkhae
v. tPa Mec ns Co.40 3 31 3 4h r2 5 q od
An ron, 7U.. t 9 .fn ot rwo ds t g a sx t j g ntt gl ur mus
de s 47 S a 24 ) f he t , o r nt lmmay ud me he co t t
l
5

d tr i t tn raon bl jr c ll S f:t non vi pat o t e ie c
ee ne ha o e s a e t y ozd nd o he mo ng ry n he vd n e
z
beo ei. Mos v. rsCo .9 5F.d7 6 7 8(t Ci. 9 3 (i Pei Co .
fr t' s Pak
'
, 8 2 3 , 3 4h r 1 9 ) cdng tni
v.
PeiiCo t I .91 F.d1 1 1 4(t Ci. 9 0)
rn ns , nc, 5 2 2 , 2 4h r 1 9 ).
1 1.
1

CountIale savi a ofH i on' Ei h Am e
lge
ol éon
xs s ght
ndm e m ght put ua t 42
nt
s s nt o

U. C. 1 8 . saeacmm un rj1 8 , pli fmus alg t v o a n ofadg t
S. j 9 3 To tt li de 9 3 a andf t l e he i ldo
e
h
s cut d by t Cons uton orlw soft U nied St esa m us s
e e
he
ét i
a
he t
at nd
t how t tt de i i
ha he prvaton
oft trghtwasc m izd by ape s a dng unde col ofsa e lw.Cr b v.Ci of
ha i
om t
r on c
r or t t a
os

Gatni, 3 F.d6 4, 3 (t Ci. 01 )(ingW et At ns48 U.. 2 48(9 8)
so a 6 5 3 3 6 9 4h r2 1 cd
s v. ki , 7 S 4 , 1 8 ).
To pr a Ei h Am encm e vi a
ove n ght
l nt ol don,Hi on mus s
xs
t how t he s f t d a s f e l
hat ufe e ufki nty

s tousde i
ei
prvadon a t tD r M or n a ed wih Tdei t t i fe e e' t hi he lh or
nd ha . a ct
t f lbe a e ndif r nc ' o s at

sft. t rv. e a ,5 1U. 8 , 3 (9 4 (ia o ate )Thsi at p on
aey Fame Brnn n 1 S. 25 8 4 1 9 ) ctdons nitd . i s wo r g
ts, t t f tT e d 'p o rqltn ade srdonoftesdo nesoft
etwih he us,f c ve' r ng e liig mon ta
obj
h e us s he

d prva na t sc nd f u e d 'p o rqltn as wigo t d fnda ts
e i do nd he e o ,f bjc ve' r ng e l ig ho n f he ee n'
s
i
Ts hc e l czpa e'sa e ofmi Fn- e ,511U . a 834.
fuf i nty tl bl' t t
nd. t r
m
S. t
A.

Asasatn p ntHi onmu tme tt o e t pr g oft Fa me ts b
trig oi , xs
s e he bjc i on he t r e t y
ve

rii ag n i q e éo ofmaeilfc t tfhed prva nalg d g s, bjc vey
asng e une u s n
tra at ha ç e i do le e wa)o e d l,
t
fufiin l s rou .' fn r 5 1U. a 8 4 (uo gW is v. etr 5 U.. 4 2 8
s fce ty e i s' Fnv e, 1 S. t 3 q dn lon S ie , 01 S 29 , 9 ,
'
( 9 1) Ulma ey t d prvai n mus bef xte ' me nigi mus po eT s rousor
1 9 ). t tl, he e i to
i
t f r me7 a n t t s f ei
e
a

sg i n ph sclo e ina i u yrs ligfom t c alng dc di ns'o <
ini t yia r moto lnjr eutn r he h le e on éo , r <
ka
' a
s t néa ds ofs h s rousha m r ul f om . .xpos e t t c lenged
ubsa l k
uc e i
r es dng r .e
ur o he hal

6

c ndd . DeLo av. eone 3 0F.d6 0 6 4(t Ci. 0 3 ( ena q a on
o ions' ' nt An l , 3 3 3 , 3 4. t 2 0 ) i r l uotd
'
h
nt
m ak a ctéonon itd . nm e c ln e c s s l et ec s a ha t eFa me ts
r s nd ia
ate ) I dia e ds a e ,i h a e t nd, h r r e t
k
r qliespl ndfsde onsr eofii l'dei r t i fe e e t a fs rous'm edialne d
e lr ai f m
tat fc as lbe a e ndif r nc o fe i '
c
e

t hase t r'be n dignos d by aphysc a a m a
hat
ihe f e a
e
ii n s ndadng te e or..ss obvi
r au nt .i o
ous
t te n a ly pe s woul e iyz cogni t ne s iy f a doc ozsa t ndon.'l v.
ha ve a z on
d asl e
ze he ce st ot
t ' te
' ko

S e , 3 F.d2 5 2 1(t Ci. 0 )
hrve 5 5 3 2 , 4 4h r20 8.
Hi onwa da nosdwihtpe2da tsprort hi ic rea na HIRJ ECF
xs
s ig e t y
ibee i o s n acréo t L .
N o.199- a 48
5, t -50. tt ttm e hewaspr c i d M e f m i Lanm s a H um al t
A ha i ,
es rbe
tot n,
, nd
og o

ma g t c nd é L.a 5 . on l sa rva a HIRJo Au s 23 2 6 Hi on
na e he o i on. d t 8 Up ' ri l t L n gu t , 01 , xs
a
t
i
i or e t i a nur e t thewa dibetcand had bee pr s dbed t e m e ca
nf m d he nt ke s ha
s a i
n ec
hes di dons
.

ECF No.199- a 9 Assaeda ,t swa ne tc
3, t -11. tt bove hi s ve onf= ed.1 Dr M or n rviwe
i. . a e e d
t si onna i plce H i on on adibe (i t a or r dal t tng ofli bl
hi nf
ton, a d xs
a dc Ie , nd de ed i es i
y
ls ood
s rlvel,butdi notpr c i i uln ora ot rt ofm edi ton us t tea
uga e s
d
es rbe ns i
ny he ype
ca i
ed o r t

dibee .L Dt M or sw Hi oni pe s onl oncedurngli i r r don--on
a ts da . an a xs n r on y
i ns ncace a
Se em be 29,2016,when Hi on r quese a physcan vii f te e ofbac pan a
pt
r
xs e
td
ii
st or r a% nt
k i nd

hi bl pr s e ECF N o.199 2,a 48. i on di notc pl i ofa s m pt s
gh ood es ut .
- t H xs
d
om an
ny y om
z a e t dibet ,nordi he m e i hi (i est D r M or n durtg t a nt e .
elt d o a es
d
nton s Iabet o . a
iz he ppoi m nt

Onl n r 1 , 1 , fe His n' boods g tlvesbe a t rs , . r n o dee
a uay 9 20 7 atr x o s l u a e l g n o ie Dz Mo a t r d
Hi on' bl s
xs s ood ugarbe t sed t c ada butsilpr s tbe li no m e c ton.
e t wie
y,
tl e c i d lm
dia i ECF N o.
199- a 23.
3, t

W h n aj1 3 c/m f zi d q a eme ia te % e i vov sac mpl a e he l
e
98 li o na e u t dc lz a nt n le o i td at
c
h

c ndi e pettsi yi rq ie t s w pr ofc u a o ijr Ed t sv.
o don, x r etmon s e utd o ho oof a sdon f nu p wad

Grha Ct. alNo. :6CW 31 - , 01 W. 58 44 6 a * ( . N. No . ,
a m yJ i
, 11 5FDW 2 7 L 9 9 , t 6 W D. C. v 29
20 7 . xs n alg shes fr d pan, ic o ta fa whi i a c r tda d s v t
1 ) Hi o l e ufe e i d somf r nd e r l nc t e ae n e e e
e
e
i pnt e ofli f ll f dons'asar ul oft m ont s ntwihoutm ediadon.
m i- nt zs f i unc
m
boc y
'
es t he
hs pe
t
c
ECF N o.125,a 18.H er le upon Dr Car Rupe a hi e z wine sa as e t t the
t
eis
. ol
s s xpe t t s nd s r s ha r
t fm ony s she s f r s fcenty s zoushs' .
esi
how
uf e ed ufi i l e i
t
m
D r Rupe t s i d t at 2 dibeécwilt c ly r r ee t d bl s
.
e the hat ype a
l ypi al equie lva e ood ugar
lvesf 1 20 yea sbef e s t i ng da a t i e na or ,r tnopa hy,or
e l or 5r
or us ani
m ge o nt r l gans e i t
ne opa hy.ECF N o.1 5,a 53-54.I i undiput t tH i on s ntonl fve m ont
ur t
99- t
ts
s ed ha xs pe
yi
hs

i HIRJund rDr M oz nsc t . n a i , her c r i u la a t ho l g Hi on
t L
'
l
e . a ' a e I ddéon t e o d s nce r s o w on xs
ha s f r d fom dibe e bef e hi of ildignossort whate e li s pt s
d ufe e r
a t s or s hca a
i
o
xt nt ls ym om

p e t l i a c r ton M or o e ? .
r dae és nc r e ai . e v r Dr Rupet sze t ts c l dnot c ran t a
e t d ha he oz
l
be e ti h t

His nha s frdorwi s fta yd ma eo i u ybea s oft dmes nta HIRJ
x o s ufee
l ufe n a g r njr c u e he
l
pe t L
wihoutm ediadon.l a 47,a 52-54.
t
c
d. t
t
Ator la gtm e aH i on conc
a r z nt xs
eded t tt ew a i ufi i e de e ofl t r
ha her s ns fcent vi nc
ong-e m

pema ntnu ybutc me hes frds r-e srousi yi t ft of
r ne ijr
bi d ufee hott= ei t n he o'
jut
m
dic mf ra i a f a. n hsde i n, x o saç t a whi i a c r td a HRRJ
s o o tpan, nd e r I i posdo His n ytd h t l nc t e ae t
e
,
he had T l d'vii ne opat a dnglng a pan illi f et ECF N o.199- a 14,
d oude ? son, ur hy, nd
c
i nd i r ns e ,
2, t

at ou h t r i no e i e et thev ie t s s mpt t me ia sa fa HRRJ
lh g he e s v d nc ha o c d he e y oms o d c l t f t
.
Cozt h vef u t t r ne p sc lmpltne ti un c say t s w a ij y
lrs a o nd ha pe ma nt hy ia i i n s ne e s t o ho n nur
x
s hcentt c dtze s dousha m unde t Ei h Am e
uf i o ons at e
r
r he ght
ndm ent Se Ease v.Powel
. e tr
l,

46 F. 4 9 46 65(t Ci. 0 6 rEv ni g pli f fie t saea Eiht
7 3d 5 , 4- 5h r 2 0 ) f e f t andfl ald o tt n g h
he
Am e me vildo wi r g r t t dea i me c lte t n ..h lce r sae a
nd nt o a n t e a d o he ly n dia r ame t .ge la l ttd n
h
y

EihhAme me voltonwiazg r t t sveec s panhes frd..'( lig
gt
nd nt i ai t e ad o he e r he t i ufee .' hodn
l
)
t tpan s fr d wliewatng f tea e i s hc e t s a e a Ei h Am e
ha i ufe e ll i
i ot t % nt s uf i nt o t t n ght
ndm e
nt

v oa on .
i ld )
A sD r M or n poi sout s e oft s m pt sdes rbe by H i on a D r Rupe
. a
nt , om
he y om
ci d
xs nd .

p e t His n' H i jia t weenot a e b t cnme fi et me iae
zdae x o s me n al nd hus z c usd y he li d al o dc t
ur
whl a HRRJ ECF No. 9 - , t5 . s no e rh i His n' sx- nt d lyi
i t
e
.
1 9 5 a 0 Alo two ty s x o s i mo h ea n
s e i gme ia c t atrliJ nu r 29 2 1 r la e ECF No.1 9 5 a 1 -11 Ru e56
e k n dc l a e fe as a a y , 0 7 ee s .
9 - , t 09 . l ,
howe r doesnotr r t tt non- ova ' ca ebewihoutfa ordoubt I r quie
ve ,
equie ha he
m
nts s
t
lw
.t e rs

onl t tt f c s w he viwed i t lghtm os f vor bl t t non- ovi pa t z ie a
y ha he a t , n e
n he i
t a a e o he
m ng ry, a s
ge lne ques ofm a e i lf c .W hie t f c sadduc l vem a que donsuna we e
nli
éon
t ra a t
l he a t
ed ea
ny s
ns r d,

t colr fndst H i on pr e se
he zt i
hat xs
es nt nough e de e s
vi nc uppot i hi posdon t pe- ta
tng s i
o t
mi

rao bl j yt fn hes frdasro ,abets o tl d hn'
es na e ur o id ufee eius l i h r-i , t
ve
m.
B.

Ha i ma eas wigs hce tt me tteRue56sa ada t t obed
vng d ho n uf in o e h l tnd r s o he jc ve
s rous soft de i don s f ed,H i on m us now m ake as
e i nes
he ptva
ufet
xs
t
howi t tD t M or n'
ng ha .
a s

s bjci me tlsaewa ta ofd l rt idifrnc . l rt i ifrnc rq,rs<
u et
ve na tt s h t ei ae n fee e Dei ae ndfee e e le <
be
be
i a
li rde eeofciz ga d t n m e e negi
lghe gt
ls e r ha
r
lgence' Fnt e ,511 U . a 837. prs ofkil
.' - r
m
S. t
A ion f a
f us 10t bea a e oft f t fom w hi t i e encecoul be dr wn t ta s t nda
f t3 h
m
w t
he ac s r
ch he nf t
d
a ha ubsa l
rs ofhn' e ss a hem us dr w t i e e .'Brcev. t ' ' Be ch Cor ec
ik
l xit , nd
m
t a hat nf t nce' i
Vi a a
r dona
l

Ce e , F.d 1 1 1 5 (t Ci. 9 5 . i s wig r q ie f r t n m ee
ntr 58 3 0 , 0 4 h r 1 9 ) Th s ho n e ur s f e ha r
mo
n gie e't o h fe st a a t o o si gone f rt veypt os ofc usn
e l nc y h ug d s h n cs r misons d ) o he r z e a i g
g
'
l
m
hsr orwih knowl
m
t
edge t tha m V I r ul. Fs m e ,511U . a 835.
ha r
I es t' t r
'
S. t
The sanda d fles
t r Ti

s me r bewe nne l nc a dpupos o k wld e na l, e kes e soft
o whee t e gke e n r e r no e g : mey rc lsn s he
s be d etpeusdi ci n la 'Bdc v. . ahCo r Ct.58F.d1 ,1 (t
u jc v y e n rmia lm ' e Va Be c ê. r, 3 01 05 4h
Ci.1 9 )
r 9 5.
D r M or n a gue t not ng i t r or s shew a dei a ey i fe entt
. a r s hat hi n he ec d how
s lber t l ndif r o

Hi onssro me ia c di n. sdsyt s jc vep on o t Fnme ts,
xs ' eius dcl on do To a f he ube d z g f he t r et
H i on woul ha t s
xs
d ve o how t tD r M or n kne Hi on' bl s tr adi
ha . a
w xs s ood uga e ngs
r pr s nt as tnda rs ofha m whieH i on wasunde hi c r ,a yett no
e e e ed ubsa l i k
r
l xs
r s a e nd
ook
a
céon.Se Fa m e ,511 U . a 837. r M or n a gue H i on c
e r r
S. t
D .
a r s xs annots
how t s a not ng
hi, s hi
i t r or i c eset rs h a sa e ofm i ors i ion.The c 'a e .
n he ec d ndiat ihe uc
tt
nd
uch nac
out gr es
t

W hie Dr M or n di notpr s rbei 'ln orany ot rt ofm e c
l . a d
e c i nspi
he ype
diadon f
or
H i on,hes a e r dona m edi lr s f notdoi s Dr M or n sa e t t bec us
xs
ttd a
l
ca ea ons ot
ng o. . a t t d ha , a e
H i on' bl s rr a lngsva d,a i uln pr s rpdon coul ha 1 t hypogl e a
xs s ood uga e ci
de n ns i e c i
d ve ed o
yc mi
i t ke whie lvesw e e l . nsr s ng,com bi d w1. t dibe ditand dal
fa n
l e l r ow Tli ea oni
ne t1 he a dc e
1
iy
bl t s
ood e dng,i s hce t s
s uf int o how t tD r M oz n wasnotdelbe at y i fe e t
ha .
a
i r el ndif r nt o

Hi o sc l n. ePees nv. vs 5 1F. up 1 7 1 6( Md. 98 )rghemee
xsn' oncdo Se tro Da i, 5 S p. 3 , 4 D. 1 2 fj
i
t
t
f iuz t te alm edi lpt e s .e n i t tf iur a ount t m e c lm apr c ,i
al e o t at l
ca oblm . .ve f ha al e m
s o dia l a dce s

i s hce t s po tacsm u e j1 8 ' .
n uf int o up r li nd r 9 3:
)
Dr M ot n' e r wine s D : Ros Sua va opi d t tt decson nott
. a s xpe t t s , . e a , ne ha he ii
o
a i s e i lln w a r s bl,gi n t va i bl na ut ofH i on' bl s
Hm nit r nszi s ea ona e ve he ra e t e
xs s ood ugart aci
e lngs

a weghtdurng li i ar et don.ECF N o.190- at3.H i on' expe q D r Rupe
nd i
i ls nc c a
9,
xs s
r
.
,
c
ount z t tD r M or s w Hi on' zsng bl s rr a ngsa t no a
e s ha . an a
xs s ii
ood uga e di
nd ook
cdon.She
c m st ti t a ed t tng i notteam entand t tHh s sbl s tlvel c led f
bi ha nc e s esi s
r t
ha
on' ood uga e s al or

t us ofi uln.
he e ns i ECF N o.199- at76.I he opi on,D r M or n s d ha pr c i d
5,
n t ni
. a houl ve es rbe

i uln f Hi on be i ngi D e mbe 2016.J a 10 Cl ry,Dr Rupe,Dr M or n,
ns i or xs
gnni n ce r
. t 2. eal .
da
. a
a D z Sua vadia e a t wha wast pr rwa t handl Hi on' rsng bl
nd . a
s gt e s o
t
he ope y o
e xs s ii
ood
s r D e i r t i fe e e,how e r z r st t te m e gi n d s gt sy
uga . lbe a e ndif r nc
ve , equie hat he r at nt ve f o os l
be

i
ncom pe e oi qua e,oze e sveast s
t nt nade t
xc s i
o hock t cons i nceoz. . i ol z bl t
he
ce
.be nt e a e o

fnd me a fines'Mi tv. o n, 9 F. 8 , 5 (t Ci. 9 0. g g nc ,
u a ntl at s. l
' de Be r 8 6 2d 48 8 1 4h t 1 9 ) Ne E e e
m apr c ,ori r c dignossdo notaone gvers t avi a
l a dce
ncor e t a
i
l
i ie o oldon oft Ei h
he ght

Amendme . daTha aprs di notr evet tea e desr d doesnotc dtze
ntL. t ioner d
ec i he t % nt ie
ons tt

dei z t i fe e e notdoe dia e m e bet n t medi lpr e sonas 1 .Se
lbe ae ndifr nc ,
s sgr e nt wee '
wo
ca ofsi l. d e

Ic s nv. g sy 7 5F. 1 ,1 8(t Ci. 01 )(ttn t tapds ndoco '
a k o Lihte, 7 3d 70 7 4h r2 4 saig ha
o
trs
te t e de ii c d be Tgr vel 'm it ke a dia e w1. a f m e di gnossa
r a m nt c sons oul
f a y' s a n nd s gt e :' ot r a
1
1
i nd

pr s rbed tea ntpl n by a outi s ils wihoutrm ni a ouloft Ei h
e ci
r tne
a
n sde pecait t
t ng f
he ght

Am e me ) I ta His n mu ts o t a Dr M o a fie t pr vdec r hehi ef
nd nt. nse d, x o s h w h t . z n ald o o i a e
ms l

fl t bene esr.d.r.. do trsfizet p o i cr t thehi efd e
eto
c say 1 f.a co ' alr o r vde ae ha
t
msl e ms
ne s a y t tea a i a ess rousm e c lc don m a c dtze de i r t
ce s r o t t n nm t ' e i
di a ondi
y ons at lbe a e

i dif rnc . .
n fe e e'
)
Thez ot gvesno e de e t tt socc r D r M oi n r vi we H ls sbl
ec d i
vi nc ha hi
uted. .
a e e d
on' ood
s rr ci a f
uga ealngs nd ound t
hem t vara e t pr c i i uln. r Rupe l
oo ibl o es rbe ns i D .
ooksa t e
t hes
s m e num be sa c e t adif r ntopi on.A Endi ofdei r ei fe e e doe
a
r nd om s o
fe e
ni
ng
lbe at ndif r nc
s
notf l fom a dia t m e be we n m edialpr e sonas The c ta s not t tt
olow r
s g ee nt t e
c
of s i l.
out lo es ha he

r or pr desno e de e D r M ot wasa e Hi on wass f dng a s m pt sof
ec d ovi
vi nc
. an
war xs
ufe
ny y om
ii bl s r H i on r por she s fr cl
lgh ood uga . xs e t
uf e ed ouded vii a pnn a dnglng i li
son nd i nd
i n ns

e r mi s buthe ne rcom pli d ofa s h s pt st Dr. ot whe hem etwih
xt e de ,
ve
ane
ny uc ym om o
M an
n
t
hi . hieH i on s a eshe a ke nur e f i lln,t r i no e i
m W l xs t t
s d s s or nsli he e s
v denc t the
e ha

com pl i t t m ofs
aned o he
ympt sw a r
om
randng m e c don.I
di a
ndee N m s Ra
d,
e ynest s z e i
et d n
he de i t s be ived H i on t beas
r posdon hat he le
xs o
ympt a i f t e iet ofli
om tc or he ntt y ls

i a c r don.ECF N o.199- a 49.Flrhe ,gve t va i lt ofH xs sbl s z
nc z e a
4, t
lf t i n he tabiiy
on' ood uga
r adi ,D r M ot n wasconce ne a
e ngs . a
r d bouta i uln ove dos Them edia saf' beift t
n ns i
r e.
c l t fs le ha
Hi on wa s f rng no s pt sofhi bl s ta t unpt lca lt ofH i on'
xs
s uf e i
ym om
gh ood uga nd he
eci tbiiy
xs s

bl ds g tlvesftl u tane a i ee eoft ne esr s bjc veme tlsae
oo u a e l aal ndeni s ny nfrnc he c say u e d
y
na tt.
80t pade ha r fzncdS i ov. tns r , 41F.d21 (t Ci. 01 )i
h t s ve eee e cnt Sa be 8 3 9 4h r2 6,n
t i bde s H i on ar
her f . vs
guest Scnt f c sa eon poi whieD r M or n dr wsditnc
he i o a t r
nt l . a a
si dons
be wq n t t stz dons I Scnt a f m e f r lpds rbt
t e he wo iaa
. n i o, or r ede a
one oughts ta i ts ve a
ui r ns e r l
f de a prs ofki l alg ng t ta prs doct vi at li Ei ht Am e
e r l i on f as le i ha
ion
or ol ed ls g h
ndm e rght by
nt i s
de i hi i uln t tea hi t 1 i lln- pende dibet s 1 a 225.Upon hi e r
ny ng m ns i o r t s ype , nsli de
nt a e . d. t
s nty
i o prs pbi ifw a indal pr c i d i uln ac or lng t a si ng s ae ofbl
nt i on, ntf s ti ly es rbe ns i c ci o ldi c l
ood

s rr ali .J W hen t spr c i
uga e ngs .
i
hi esrpdon pt di ufiintt c t pl ntf' bl
ove ns fce o ontol ni ifs ood

s a, rq se as plme tlne do fo t pio doco .d. t2 . cus
ug rhe e uetd up e na ijc n r m he rs n tz l a 27 Be a e
pl ndf wasT ngz 'a t Hm e oft sr s,t doc ort i ed pl ndf ' vii a
ai f
f y' t he
a
hi eque t he t e= nat ai fs st nd

deci d t pr dehi wih i uln, nsea lm ii hi pr c i
lne o ovi m t ns i i t d i tng s es rpdon sgni a l JLAfe
i hc nty. 1 tz
-.

sve a mor smi ri i e s pli ipshe g o i A1 lvesr efo 7 ( t n t e
e r l e i l ncd nt, nntf mo l b n C e l os r m wihi h
a
n ma r ng f rda tc)t 98(nunh at ys o e . dz t2 . ndf as s ft d
ot l a e o ibeis o . a
e lh c r ) L .a 28 Pbi f lo ufe e
da a t li ki ys e sght ne v s t m ,and ps hol c w el i L =The c t
m ge o ls dne , ye i , r ous yse
yc ogial lbeng. d
our
.

r ed t tpbi fhad adduce e
ul ha
ndf
d nough f c ss wi dei r t i fe e e t s vve
a t ho ng lbe a e ndif r nc o ur i

dee da 'modo f tsp t jdg ntL aa 2 0.
fn nts
no l
mmay u me .d t 3
Hi on at est tt Scnt de ii c pesde a ofDr. or sm odon.Scnt
xs
gu ha he i o c son om l nil
M an'
i o,
how e r wasdecde on ver dif r ntf c s Fis,t prs doc ori Sc nt wasw el
ve ,
i d
y fe e a t . t t he ion
t n i o
l

a a e ofpl ndf ' s tousm e c lc don a ha pz c i d a i uln z gl en unde
w r
ai fs e i
dia ondi
nd d es tbe n ns i e '
m
r

wlihpli if st t cies plme a i c swhe libl s g rrahe acran
l antfwa o e ev up e ntlt don
c
je
n ls ood u a ec d eti
lve. d. t2 9. zt r r , li fsTe gtypds me ia r c r ss wgd t a hs
e l1 a 2 Fl he mo e p nndf' f n h
r
l
on dc l e o d ho e ) h t i
da t sda nosswa f ng tndn pe v sve weld tne t d gnd e pt sl no e b
ibee ig i s l sa ig, r ai , l ocu n e , a ) x e sy t d y
o
-

pio ofiilyi l igb g piondo tt lmsl. 1 (u igPars e rlLe v.
rs n fcas'ncudn y t rs
he
coj n ef'd.q otn rih x e. e
i '
Clvea ,3 2F.d 2 4 30 ( t Ci. 00 ). n e b t Fo t Cic i i Scn o, h
e lnd 7 3 9 , 3 4 h r 2 4) As otd y he urh r ut n i t t e
p on d t rt t T iz g r e jli o p e ci
ds oco he e < se a dgd ls wn r s zpdon d sg d t ma g gliéf'q
d
e ine o na e p an fs
c ton,' daat229,be us he wa fa a r and hosiepa .'l
ondii 'i
ca e
s fn ng y
tl dent' d.
H e e i c r s,tzsc ebolsdown t a dia e m enta t te
r , n onta t li as '
l
o
s gr e
s o r atnentbe wee
t n
H i on a Dz M ot n.W hie H i on algeshe s zd ha r ceved m e c don,D r
xs nd .
a
l xs le
hotl ve e i
di a
.
M oz n c e t m oniorhi bl s ra te thi va i bl r a ngswih dit D r M or n
a hos o
t
s ood uga nd r a s ra e e di
t e. .
a

ts d a
e dûe boutt Hs ofpr ci i lln t apadentwih s h vata e bl s
he ks
ovilng nsli o
t uc
ibl ood ugar
r di . he H i on' r di r e,D r M or or r t c da' t si a i
ea ngs W n xs s ea ngs os
. an de ed wie ly e tng, gnn
l
r c zi sgnika vai biiyilt dal r adi .Unde t cr um s a es D r M or n'
e ogni ng i f nt ra lt t he i e ngs
y
r he ic t nc , .
a s
c e ofHi on a hi de ii t m oniorhi di be e a te thi wil di r t rt n
ar
xs nd s c son o
t
s a t s nd r a m ta et a he ha

m ediaéon c nnotc ém t dei t ei fe e e D r M or n' dal m oniorng of
c
a
ons e lbe at ndif r nc . .
a s iy
t i
H i on' bl s
xs s ood ugatt a ngss st hew a notdei r ey i fe e t Hi on'
e di
how hat
s
lbe at l ndif z nt o xs s

mel a c i n. s fcsc n s w et rs jc vea tne so asg i n ds
cc l onddo Thee at a not ho ihe ube d wae s f inf t k
i
ka

oradei r t i lfe e e t t tts 5The c tt r f e GR AN T S t m odon f
lbe a e ncif r nc o ha ik.
our he e or
he
or

s
ummayjdg nta DI M I SESCou 1
r u me nd S S
nt .
I
V.

TheVigraS rmeCo r h sd : dg o sne l nc a ad e reofn gie c '
riz up e
i
u t a e ne r s gke e s f g e
d
e l n e'
g
whihs wsfu hi fee e' st T o d teg a ute dirg r of t nc
c ho f c ndifrnc'a o f ns tz ) n tr se ad prz e
s
c
t
de
a u gt t c mplt n getoft sft o a h rFe s v. r s , 2Va
mo ndn o he o ee e lc he aef' f note. r on Fe on 21 .
8 , 2 1 S. 2 6 8 6 3(9 1. zsde zeofne l e emus bes ha wo ds k
6 9 , 81 E.d 4 , 5 1 7 )Tli ge
gi nc
g
t uc s ul hoc
f i- i
arm nded peopl,t
e hough i nee notc dtzewiIUIr kl s s .K ofm a 574 S. 2d
t d
ons tt If ec es ne s
f n,
E.

a 6 . o sne l e c rqpe a o e û i t'y t d fnd n' be vo mus be
t 0 Gt s gi n e e pi s n bjc ve nqur;he ee a ts hair t
g
t
com pa e t t tofa sm iary sm a e hy hedca K ea ona e'pe s Co a ev.
z d o ha
i l l i t d, pot
l f s bl' r on.
r

Ma 9 6F. u 1 2 ,1 49( D. .1 9 )W heh rbe vi c nsi e g o s
nn, 0 S pp. 0 5 0 E. Va 9 5. te ha or o tt s r s
m
ne l e ei us l aq s noffc,etfrtejr t a we.Ge dc v. ifxCo
gi nc s ual uedo
g
y
atlf o h u y o ns r d h Fara un
De t of mi S r s, 2F. u p. 4 , 5( D. . 00 )
. Fa l ev .28 S p 2d 39 47 E. Va 2 3.
Though t sanda dsofdei r t i f e e and g os ne
he t z
lbe a e ndif r nce
t s ghge ar cos y
nce e l el
r l t d,c zt do dr w diO céons Gt sne ge ei asi l l r sa r l l t
e a e otts
a s
. os gh nc s lghty owe t nda d, acdng he

s jc v c mp ntofdei rt i cif rnc . pa q 9 6F. u a 1 49 Unl e
ub e é e o one
l ae n l e e e Cop g , 0 S pp t 0 . i
be
f
k
del t t i fe e e,g os ne i
i a e ndif t nc r s glgencedoesnotz t a fnci t a def nda kne of
be
equie i lng hat
e nt w

asbsa a rs . d I i e ug t tt d fnd nts oubha ebena r ofta ds I
u tné l ik I . ts no h ha he ee a h l v e wae h t k.d.

5I as e e a pladngf lwiz t he dng,Hi onas t c tt f
n upplm ntl e i olo tg he a
xs
ks he our o ocuson c rat de i t tm ony ECF
e tiz posdon esi
.

No 2 5Thstsi n d e no $v rs t ag nx eiseo maeil at sod l eaeidfee c. i Hts n
. 1 . i er y o s t e ie o e 'n su f tz fc a t ei rt t ifrn e Whl ' o
mo
i
a
b
z
e x
d sr sepein igbu r vso a p i i lsfe whl i HRR , No. 9 -, t 4 h d e no c m t hae
eci x re cn lry iin nd at n z et i n J ECF 1 92 a 1 , e o s t bi o v
be
z i
e
r td t st antreorD r M orn.Sm i ry Dr Rupedeszbe Hi on' blur vii i he de i a
epore hi o ts
. a i l l, .
a
c i d xs s t y son n r posdon nd
i ndEed t sasa s
de
hi
ympt m ofee t d bl s rl ves ECF N o. - a 50, butofe e no t tm on
o
lva e ood uga e l,
199 5, t 99,
f r d esi y

etbihn t t n me e o teme ia safa HRR wa a r o t s smptmsTh s fcsd no rieay
sa l ig ha a y mb r fh dcl tf t J s wae fhee y o . ee at o tas n
s
i e e t tDr M o a wasa z ofa s rousds t H i o she lh.
nf z nce ha . r n
wa e
ei
k o xs n' a t

Asdsuse a ve d ighi i a eHis t dt n s a HIRJt t wa a
ic sd bo , urn s ntk x on ol he ure t L ha he s
t 1, nsli de ndentdibe D r M or n sat d he decde nott m ediat pa éal
ype i lln- pe
a éc. . a t e
i d
o
c e r ly
bec us ft i or adon gi n by a i at i s a tcal pr
a e fhe nf m
ve
n nm e s t dsi l oven t s e i esbenot
y
o om tm
t al c r t' ECF N o.199- a 10.D r M or t r f er r sa c im a
ot ly or ec .'
3, t
. an he e or equie onft don t ough
hr

m e c lt coz ofaprs rsdignossbe oz pr s zbi m e c don.I Dz M oz n w e
dia e ds
i one ' a i f e e c i ng di a
d. . a
nt
On t s y:
o a

And had I ha a om a al pl ed M r Hi on on t
ve ut dc ly ac
. xs
he
m e c tons he s i he was on,i w e l a hi bl
dia i
ad
f
ook t s ood s t
uga s

d ig h sftyfw da sa t e ji It i k we wozd be sti
urn i ls e y t h al h n
,
t
l
i ng
l
he e ha ng a dif t de i whe Iove dos d M r H i on
r vi
f e ent posdon
n
r e
. xs
on i uln t t li body di t ne
ns i ha ns
dn' ed. So, no, I ci not
ld

a t éc l p a e hi o me c don j tbe a e h s i he
u oma al lc m n dia us c us e ad
y
w a on i bec us Im r s
s
t a e ' e ponsbl f t m bot f te tng
i e or he
. or r a i
h
diea et y ha and f notc usng a da age.
s s he ve
or
a i ny m

I. Dr M or t r f eplce Hi on on adibei di a or r d dai che ksofhi
.. . an he eor a d xs
I
J
a tc et nd de e l c
y
s
bl s rlve .I
ood uga e l d.

I D e m be 2016,H i on' bl s tlvesr e D z Rupe t lfed t thi
n ce r
xs s ood uga e l os ; .
esi
ha s

r al gswe ef 6nieyo ac itnt sswel bo t 1 0ma k'wl c i a v t e
e cn
i
r f tl n onsse ba i la ve he 3 t ' l h s bo e h
de
i
Am e a D ibe e A s oca
dc n a t s s idon gai lne r om m ende f dng bl s rr adi .ECF
dei s ec
d as
ood uga e ngs

N o.199- a 102.D r M or sr s
5, t
. an' e pons wa t i r as H i on' bl s .r a ngsf om
e s o nc e e xs s ood ugar e di r
onc dai t t cedal A scic s d a
e l o wi
y
iy. ls us e bove D r Rupeopi t tt sw a i
, .
nes ha hi s nadequat She
e.

ag e ta a t spontHi ons oudha be nzcii i llni ci , ndta t
ru s h t thi i , xs h l ve e e evng nslt t tonsa h t he
i je
fiur t do s c us d pema ntda ge. dxDr M ot n' e t,Dr Sua va,dia ee a
al e o
o a e r ne
ma L
. a s xpe t . a
sgr s nd
sa esi he r pot t tt de ii nott a i s e i llt w a r s bl gi t
t t n r e t ha he c son
o dm nitr nsxi s ea ona e, ven he
n
va ibl na at ofHi on' bl s rr di a weghtdurng hi i r t don.
ta e t e
xs s ood uga ea ngs nd i
i
s nca ce a
ECF
N o.190- a 3.
9, t

A sw11 del r e i f e e ,dia e m e sbet en m e c lpr e sonasdo not
t4 i at ndif t nce s gr e nt we
.
be
dia of s i l

s fiet s w gos ne l e eJ t cus on me clp ofsina cnmsteote
u fc o ho r s gi nc .us be a e e dia r eso l li h h r
g
s udha ed emo eta h dddo snotgvers t alve ofne l nc f nc s ws
ho l v on r h n e i e
i ie o e l gke e f ih ho
wl
i fe e e t ot r ,dir ga di pr ncet t lve t s f y ofot r i c pl t l
ndif r nc o he s s e r ng ude
o he e l hat a et
he s s om e ey

ne lce 'Wi v. se, 65Va 4 7 4 , 7 S. 2 79 , 01(00 )W eet scnm
ge td. l Go tl2
' b
. 3 , 45 5 8 E.d 6 8 2 3. t hi li
s
oundi i ot na y ne i nc Hi on m a ha be a e t a guet tD r M or n s oul
ng n di r glge e, xs
y ve en bl o r
ha .
a h d
.

ha t ke m or aflve a n
e ft
madve s e t m a ge hi dibe e .D r M oz n,how e r ha ar a
t ps o na
s a ts . a
ve , s le dy
s
hown hei enéte t s r i i m uniy whi h sle dsli f om m edi lm al a dce
s
ld o ove egn m
t , c lil nm r
ca
pr c

sissundn il dnayne l nc . No. 6 . x o i no rq rdt s w g os
ut o ig tor i r gke e ECF
1 6 His n s w e uie o ho r s
ne i nce am uc hi tsa
glge ,
h ghe t ndar t the c nnotm ee .
d ha
a
t

Thet cor claty s st tD r M ot n t se t m oniorH i on' condi
e d e l how ha . a ook t ps o
t
xs s
don.

Vigni lw ma e ce rt ti d fn nt ha tk n f ve t sih e t to c r g ,
r i a a k s la ha f ee da s ve a e f n he l t s bi f a e )
e
g
r gar es ofhow i ufii ori f cdvei m a ha be n,'t t r hasbee no
e dl s
ns fcent nefe
t y ve e ' hen he e
n

s o ngofgos n gie c . l tv. e, 9 Va 6 8 6 , 9 S. 2 73 , 31( 1 )
h wi
r s e l n e Elo Cm r 2 2 . 1 , 21 7 1 E.d 0 7 20 6.
g
i
A c di y,t c ztGR AN T S t m oion and D I I
cor ngl he otr
he
SM SSE S CountI .
I
V.

Dr M o a as agu st thei e te t q a e i riyon b l t ej1 8
. r n lo r e ha s nd ld o u v d mmuzt
0tz h 9 3
c m a t sa e m e c lm apr cdc c m .Thedocti ofqualfe i m uniy a f de a
bi nd he t t dia l a e bi
rne
ii d m
t, e r l

c mmonlw pr c pta ia ei j1 8 c s s sl l sof il fn nt fom mon tr
o
a e e ppl bl n 9 3 a e, led hca dee da s r
c
i
e ay
la lt s l ast ofi a' c
ibiiy o ong he fcils onduc di notvi a e fce l e t bls 's aat yor
t d
olt flary s a ihed' t tzor

cons M tona tght ofwlih ar as bl pe s i t def nda ' poséon woul ha
t i li s
lc e ona e r on n he e nts i
d ve

k wn. th lv. r t 4 2U..5 1 5 6 (9 5 9 elrv. ' ofS . r s f Ci
no Mic el Fo s . 7 S 1 , 2 1 8 ) W l De t oc Se v . or
h
e

ofBat, 01F. 38 , 9 (t Ci. 9 0. ep i il ofq lhe i ni rfe t t
l.9 2d 7 3 8 4h r 1 9 )Th rncpe uai d mmu t elcs he
y
c e n t tt a r ofcvld ma e a ans p bl of il f re r j iil onc r ha he wa d ii a g s g i t u i hcas o vey udcal
c
y
de e m i vi a
t r ned oldon ofrght woul dic a i vi sfom s e ng publc
i s
d s our ge ndi dual r
e ki
i
e pl m ent pr de e e i t t tea ut a i patgove nm e a de ii
m oy
, ove l t rous o he r s y, nd m i
r nt l c son

m aki W elr 901 F. at398.Thedocti ofquai i m uniy,t z or ,m a t s
ng. le ,
2d
rne
lûed m
t he ef e nda e
t tof i sf l notla e f ba gue s si gr y a e s' buti t d a e onl Tla ef
ha hcal f :
ae
ibl or d s e n a r a ,'
nsea r
y fibl ot

ta ge sn bihtl s'M aire ov. l r 9 3F.d2 , 8(t Ci. 9 2.
rnse sig tg i . caiE Sx , 7 2 95 29 4h r 1 9 )
ne '
mne
I det t ni i a def ndanti e l d t quai d i m uniy t cour m us ft t
n e- ng f
mi
e
s ndte o lhe m
t , he
t
t ls
det mi whe her t ken i t lghtm os fvor bl t a pli if t f ct aie d al a
ez ne
t ,a
n he i
ta a e o
a ntf, he a s lge low

hndi t tt de enda ' conduc vi a ed t pbi ifscons i dona rght .I t
ng ha he f nts
t olt he ntf'
tm
l i s f he
a we t t si yes t n t cout m us consde whet tt spariul dghtwa fcea l
ns t o hi s , he he
t t
i r
he hi tc ar
s fl ty

etbihe 'a t tmeoft voa n. a irv Kaz 5 3U. 1 4 2 (00 )Ast s
sa ls d' t he i
he iléo S uce . t, 3 S. 9 , 01 2 1. hi
c 'hasr ed t D r M or n di nots
out
t
ul hat . a d
how de i r t i fe e e t H i on,t & s s e
lbe a e ndif r nc o xs
he t t p

oft a
he bovea l i m us be a wer d i t ne éve. r or ,t t e entt
nayss
t ns e n he ga
The ef e o he xt he

d tt na n i rlv n , . a i e dte t q l di niyo Hi onsj1 8
ee mi do s ee a t Dr Mot n s n ld o uai mmu t n xs ' 9 3
he
c nm .
li 6
W .

Fort a
he bove z s ,H i on' cli sa i tD r M oz n a e D I I
ea ons xs s nm gans . a t
SM SSED .
W ihoutt e s t
t
hes ubsandve underyng c nm s H- on' c nm sf puri da a a
li l i , i
xs s l i oz zdve m ges nd

6T q aie i li cluu i ia pial t tesae1w clm o gos n gie c .o nDo #1v. bnsn,
' u l d mm' t ac lssn p l be o h tt a li f r s e l n el h e
he E
ny
c
g
Ro i o
No CI A. :7 4 2 0 W. 4 5 9 , t 4( D. . b 2 , 0 9 (in Cob v Bod n, 4 Va 1 5 1 9 4 0
. V. 40 CV8 , 0 9 L 3 0 7 a * E. Va Fe . 0 2 0 ) ct g l . re 2 1 . 2 , 2 , 0
i
SE.d1 4 1 6(9 1)
. 2 8 , 8 1 9 ).

a t ne 'f sa egr
toz ys ee r oundls a D I ISSE D .D ef nda ' M odon f Slm m a y
e s nd SM
e nts
or l
r

J d me i GRANTED.
u g nt s
An a oprat O t rwilbee e e t sda
ppr i e de l
nt r d hi y.

Ent r Tu s
e ed:

/
+/

4

03dy ofanuary,2018
26a l
#

.

M i hae F. t ns
c l
ba ki

Chif
e

18

tdSae Dit t ud e
e tts sdcl g

'