Madsen v United States Post Office

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 1/26/18. (kld)

CLERK' OFFt S. 11 :
C:
1.
AT RO .JS.7 . 1 COURI
'
' ') ,V,
Af(KE #
1
.
FE QD
L

I TH E U N I D STATE S D ISTRICT CO U RT
N
TE
FO R T H E W EST ERN D ISTRICT O F W RGI I
N A
H ARRISON BU RG D I SI
W ON

J 2s 2 1
AN
28
J I DUDL , C ERK
FY
BN LA C.
:

DEPU- ' EFK
D CL ?

AN TH O N Y M AD SEN ,
Pl ntf y
ai if

Ci lActon N o.5:8cv00023
vi
i
1
By:

UNI
TED S
TATES POS OFFI
T
CE,

H on.M i
chaelF.U t
bansd
l

Cli fUnie S a e DititJ
ze
t d t t s s rc udge

D ef
endant
.

M EM O RAN D U M O PI IO N
N
Pr edi prn K ,pl i ifAnt
oce ng
antf
honyM ads n,fl t i t ntc pli a ns t
e led he ns a om ant gai t he
- .

Unie St t Pos O f e,s ecng la t pr ee L f m a a e i . Fort r s s
t d a es t hc e li e ve o oc d q or
u rs
he ea ons et

f t beow,M a e sa i ton t pr e jzf ma a ei wilbeGRAN TED and li
orh l
ds n' pplcai o oc ed z or
u rs l
ls

c mpant lbeDI I ED wiho p eudc pu s nto28U.. j1 5e()B)
o li wi
l
SM SS
t ut rj ie tua t
SC. 91 ()2 ( .
1.

Ma e sc mpli c nsssofao pa elte dae a a y22 2 8 ECF No 2
ds n' o ant o it
ne g etr tdl nu r , 01 .
.-

1 Thelte alg st tt Uni dSttsPosa S rie(I ' l ta is rdpak g
. etr le e ha he t ae tl evc <
e
USPS' os n n u e c a e
)
s ntby M a e vi G l lExpr s d G uar nt ed Se dceon A ugus 5,2016. Thepa ge
e
ds n a oba
es e
a e
r
t
cka

i l
ncudedaparofa i a o bumpesvaue a $2, 00.
i ntque ut
r l d t 000. USPS ri
embure M a e f
s d dsh ot

tes i igc t, utha no ri ure Ma e frt v l oftea kuea o
h hppn oss b s t emb sd dsn o he aue h nt ut
blm pe s M a e alge t ha r pe t y c ac e USPS, hos ope at sha r pored
p r . ds n le s o ve e a edl ont t d
w
e r or ve e t
t f e'ewordng on i.'M a e m al awa ni ofi m i ntlga a
hat Y r
l
t' ds n ied
r ng m ne e l cdon t U SPS on
o

D ec m be 6,2017 a hasnotr eve ar pons I addi t t l tvaueoft
e r
nd
ec i d es
e. n
don o he os l
he
a
ndquea o bum pe s M a e c m st li Pa pa.om ac ountha be n c os d a a
ut
r , ds n bi hat ns y lc
c
s e l e s

r s tofU SPS' f lzet r ol li cbi .I li cvi c rs t M a e des rbe t
e ul
S ai r o es ve 's m n ls i l ove hee , ds n c i s he
t
l
na ur ofhi s tasa i ur nc c t cta don a a t tac i vi ot tpe s l
t e
s ui
n ns a e onta c
nd or don nvol ng he r ona

pr tyd ma e a ctst 28U.. j26 0f rt ec u eofa d ECF No. - .
opet a g , nd ie o
SC. 8 o h a s c on.
22
M ads n de nds$ 000i da a s
e ma
2, n m ge .
I
I.

Ma snmo st p oc e ilfr a ei, uru ntt 2 U. C. 1 1 a()
d e ve o r e d ! o ma u rs p s a o 8 S. j 9 5()1.
ECF No.1. cour wilgr ntM a en' moton t pr edL f ma a ei. Howe ,
The
t l a
ds s i o oce q or
u rs
ver
afe r vi wi t c pl nt t cour c l
t r e e ng he om ai , he
t oncudest tt sac
ha hi don m us be dir s e
t
snis d

pu s ntt 2 U. C. 1 1 e()B)
rua o 8 S. j 9 5()2( .Und r2 U. C. 1 1 ()2( , src c rsh ve
e 8 S. j 9 5e()B)ditit ou t a
ad yt s r e i da fl sa ds ns ac li f e L f ma a e a a yémei
ut o c e n ni l ing nd inis omp nnti d q or
i
l
u ds t n
f

t c ur deemie tg tea t Tii fiolusp maiius $)fi t saeac?m on
he o t tr n s h t h ci <) s rv o r l o ; al o tt li
on (
c
s
'
wlihrl fma b ga e o @)se smo tr rl fa zns adee a whoi i ne
lc ei y e rntd; r e k neay ei g t fnd nt
e
e
s mmu
fom s r lef'
r
uch ei .'

M ads n' c pl ntf ist sa e a cqm on wli h r lefm a begr ed and s e
e s om ai al o t t li
nc ei
y
ant
e ks
m one a yr lefa i tade enda w ho i i m une fom s h r lef Rul 8 oft Ci l
t r ei gans
f
nt
sm
r
uc ei . e
he vi
Rul ofCi lPr dr e r lr a pl alng t ts a e acli f r le t c an:
es
vi oce
eq'ies e ci ha t t s nm or ei f o ont i

()as or a dpansae ntoft gou sfrt c r'
1 h t n li ttme
he t nd o he ou ts
j idci n;
urs ito
()as or a dpansae ntoft c m s wigt tt
2 h t n li ttme
he bi ho n ha he
pl deri entte t r le ;and
ea s ild o ei f

()ad ma f rt r l fs u htwhih ma i l erle i
3 e nd o hç ei o g , c y ncud eif n
e
t at r tve ordif r ntt sofr Eef
he le na i
fe e ype
e .

M a e sonepa lte f l t al gehow hi gre nc wih USPS r ga ci al tpac ge
ds n'
ge e t r ais o le
s iva e t
e rlng os
ka

e lshm t r l f Byr fr ncng2 U.. j2 8 i t cv l o e s e, hec u t
ndt i o ei . ee e i 8 SC. 6 0 n he ii c v r he t t o r
e
e
c t esM ads n' c pl i asm a ng a cam unde t Fede a Tor Cli sA c
ons nz
e s om ant
ki
li
r he
r l t nm
t

CT ' 7.
FTCA' ECF 21 Ho ve, a e doe no ma a yalg donssppo tn a
I
-. we rM dsn s t ke n l a
e
u rig n
a ia ef m oft lefunde t FTCA.
va lbl or
ei
r he
TheFTCA pr desa lm ie w ave oft Unie St t 's r i i m uniy i '
ovi
i t d i r he t d a es ove e gn m
t n

l g d S eUnie Sae v. la , 25U..8 , 1 (9 6. nmse e e fo t
i a on. e td tts Ore ns4
d
S 07 8 3 1 7 )Cli x mptd r m he
FTCA' wave ofs r i i m uniy c
S i r ove e gn m
t annotbe m ant i a i tt U nied St e .Se
i aned gans he t
at s e

Ore ns4 U. a 8 4rsnc teUnie Sae c nbes donyt tee tntt ttha
la , 25 S. t 1 fi e h
td tts a
ue l o h xe ha i s
wave isl
i d t mmuni , uer g t mus begve t t ee c pdo ..o s hwave . Hu he
t d e a d t i n o h x e ns .t uc i r'
y
l;
s
v. ulva ,5 4F. u 6 7 6 ( D. .1 0 , f' s b no Hu he v. td S ae ,
S l n 1 S pp. 6 , 68 E. Va 98 ) a fd u m.
i
s Unie tt s

6 2F.d21 (t Ci.1 1 (x ani t thea pl a it ofa e e inun rj2 8 i
6 2 9 4h r 98 ) e pli ng ha t p i bly n xcpto de 6 0 s
c i

atrs l q s nt tc nbedee i db t c ur a amattoflw) S c n26 0$)
h ehod uedo ha a
t= ne y he o t s te a . e do 8
s cfc l l t fgl yc/m a ii gouto t l s mic rig ,o ne l e tta miso of
pe iial i s f n li rsn
ys a
f he os, s ara e r gi n t ns si n
g
l ter orposa m a t r'a a e e
et s
t l te ' s n xc péon t t FTCA.
o he
TheU nied St t ,i l ng U SPS,hasnotw ave s r i i m uniy undert
t
a es ncudi
i d ove egn m
t
he
FTCA f t t ofcbi t tM a en brngsi t sac bn.SeeD oln v. . Posa Se ,
' or he ype
m ha ds
i n hi t
a U S. tl m

5 U.. 1 4 5(0 )rffheUntdSttsma b l bl i po tl mply e c mmi
46 S 48 , 8 2 06 rl
ie ae y e i e f sa e o e s o t
a
t rsun rl c la bu notf zcamsd f d b t se c pdo ( t eITCA a
o t de o a lw, t o li ei y hi x e n of h R
ne
t
j26 0 bj? Ast Unie S ae ha no wave s v r in i niy no mon tr r le i
8 ( ).
). he td tt s s t i d o e eg mmu t,
e ay eif s
a ia e t M a e t ough t c t slSeeK okoésv.U. Posa Se m,223 F. 275,
valbl o ds n hr
he ou t .
S. t l r
3d

1M ads m ay fl a i m niy cl t wih U SPS. I M ads l t
en
le n nde t qi' t
n
f
en ended t r s a caus ofacdon ot r
o aie
e
he
t undeit FTCA ,r i re ai una iabl beca e M ads hasnotale exhaus of
han
he
elef m ns val e
us
en
lged
don
.

.

)

al nsrd er me is S e e .L v U.. sa S r .7 5F. u p 2 9 1 - 3O . C. 0 1
r lta v e de . e . , . S Po tl ev, 7 S p . d , 11 D. 2 1 )
ml
(inisn a d ns e igr c v r frclp o e l s i itr a o a malo fizet e h u t
dsasig c o ekn e o e y o el h n s o tn n en d n l i ft alr o x a s
t
a miita v rme is; n w v U.. sa S r'7 8F. u p 2 1 2 1 7 0 ( Me 2 1 )
d nsrd e e de) S o . S Po tl ev, 7 S p . d 0 , 0 -9 D. . 0 1
.
(imis ga d nivovn cnded k d ma e i d med mal o fi t e h u t; c mit
ds si c o n lig a ls c s a g d n o s c if z al o x a s) S h d
n
me
v.U. Posa S r No. V. .0 85 A, 2W L 32 045 a *1( D. . 2, 2 , f'
S. tl e m, CI A 2- 7- 200
595 , t . Va Aug. 200 ) afd,
E.
5 F. px1 3(t Ci. 0 3 (imisn f zfiu et e h u ta miita v tme is.
6 Ap ' 7 4h r2 0 ) cs sig o clr o x a s d nsrd e e de)
l

2 -7 (t Ci. 0 0 rfo ri i
78 9 4h r 2 0 ) s veegn mmunt c nbewave o yb t s veegn t
iy a
i d nl y he o ri ;he
cz um sa esofiswai rmus be s m pul l obs r ed and note nde by t
ic t nc
t ve
t c
ousy e v
xpa d
he

C u t. .
O TS3
1
Thecour consruesgt î c pl i slbe al i posng f e ssdngentsa ds
t
t
q - om ant i r l m i f s t
q
y,
l
t ndar
.

ta f= a pla i sd atdb lwy r. iks v. t us 5 1U. 8 , 4(00 )
h n o l e dng tfe y a es' c on Pad , 5 S. 9 9 2 7
'Er
(uo gEsel v. mbl, 9U.. 7 1 405(9 6) we e < c mpli mus
q dn tl Ga e 42 S 9 , 0 - 1 7 ).Ho v r T o nnt t
e
a
cont n s i e f c ua m ate ,a e ed ast ue,t ft t a c m ofr left ti plusbl
ai ufki nt a t l tr cc pt
t o s a e bi
ei ha s a i e

onisfc .'As r t I b l5 6U. 6 2 6 8(00 )(uot Bel lCo .
t a e' hcofv. a, 5 S. 6 , 7 2 9 q i lAt.
'
ng
v.
Two , 5 U. 5 4 5 0( 0 ).Fo t rao stf t a ve Ma sn' c lit
mbl 5 0 S. 4 , 7 20 7) r he es ns e orh bo , d e s ompnn
f ist s a ea lgalcnm upon whi h z le m a begz nt a t Uried St t i i m une
a l o t t e li
c e if y'
a ed nd he lt
a es s m

fo s t Th , sc mpli mus becimisdpu s ntt 28U.. j1 5e()B)
r m ui. ushi o ant t l se rua o
s
SC. 91 ()2 ( @
a (
nd 1
$.
1 1.
1

A c di y,pli fsa i éon t pr ed L f m a paupe i wilbe GRAN T ED
cor ngl andf' pplca
o oce q or
rs l

a t smatrwil DI M I S wiho tpzj c a dS CKEN fo t adv
nd hi te lbe S S ED t u eudie n TRI
r m he c e
-

/

docke oft cotr.
t he zt
An a opra eO r rwilbe'nt r
ppr i t de l e e ed.

En e e : a uay2 , 01
trdl n r 6 2 8
,

/

ri '. .
1.% .
VXm x
,
r
M i lF.
chae U

a ki
ns

Cle Uni d S ae Ditit u e'
l f t tt s stc l dg
i

Y