Caesar v. Trump et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/13/2018. (jv)

CLERK' OFFI U.S.DI COURT
S
CE
ST.
AT I ANOKE,
O
VA
FI
LED

MA2 13 2 1
23
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATE S D I
STRICT COU RT
FO R TH E W E STE RN D I RICT O F W RG I I
ST
N A J C. EY CLERK
UL DUDL
sv,
H ARM SON BU RG D I SI N
W O

A, C E ka
DPUW .
E

SO LOM ON CAE S ,
AR
Pl ntf,
ai if

Cas N o.5: v00051
e
18c
By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l

PRES DEN T D ONALD J TRUM P, p
I
.
qt ky

Chi fUnie S a e Diti t udge
e
t d t t s stc J

D ee
f ndant
s.
M E M O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O
/
'

Pr ee ngprq K , nnéf Sol on Ca a fl t i t com pl ,s edng la
oc di
pl i f om
es z ied he nsant
znt e l e ve
- -

t p oc e i f r a ei pu s ntt 28U.. j1 5a () Ca s rsc mp zn ,
o z e d ! o ma u rs rua o
z
SC. 91 ()1 . e a' o l t
br
oughtpurua t Bi nsv.Si Unknown N a edA ge sofFe r Bt a ofN a c
s nt o ve
x
m
nt
de al ue u
r odcs
,
:

40 U. 38 (9 1, me cjang v r ntofiil,ncu n t Prsd nta Vie
3 S. 8 1 7 ) nn s eti o enme fcas i ldig he eie nd c
y
'

Pr i ntoft U nie St t s a welast Re ia a D e oc a Pa des a t
esde
he t d a e , s l he publc n nd m r dc r , nd he
Unied St e At ,asdef nda s A fe r viwi t c pl nt t colt concudest t
t
at s vny
e nt . t r e e ng he om ni , he xt
'
l
ha

t sa do mus bedinisdp s a tt 2 U. C. 1 1 ()2 7)
hi c n t sase uru n o 8 S. j 9 5e() .
Un r28U. C. 1 1 ()2 7) dsrc c ursh vead yt sre i d lfl gs
de
S. j 9 5e() , itit o t a
ut o ce n nia in
i
a dimisac
nd s s ompli f L f ' a ei a a tmei t cout det= i st tt
ant ied q ot
ma u rs t ny i f he
t e ne ha he

a ton fi i fi luso ma i us @ fi t saeacnm o wh c r l fma beg a t d
ci <) s rvoo r hco ; al o tt li n ih ei y r n e ;
(
s
e
o ti s e smon tt r l fa is . d fnd nt i i nefom s c t l f'Ca srs
r i) e k
i
eay ei gan ta e e a who s mmu r u h ei . e a '
e
e'
c pli i nons i l Shec nm sdef nda sha c pie a ns he <t ot rt
om ant s
ensca.
li
e nt ve ons r d gni t r '' de o
il

o r s g r bod a r i f rt ero pr ft a e e ti nt'S s e $ 0
pp e s he) y nd nnd o h i wn o is nd ntranme . he e ks 30
'

tiin i d ma e f aho tof nt e s h a t ei bl yt p o c e do , na e
tlo n a g s or s i j s uc s h na it o r du e mo ns ma g
l
ui
i

he o n t
r w hought a m e ores a gr he ha r 'hi flng i f ousa f l t s a e
s nd m i , nd ow r i.T s ii s dvol
nd ais o t t
a cnm f whi h t le c n begr nt d.
li or c ei f a
a e

Ac or ngl pli fsa i don t pr e L f ma a ei wilbeGRAN TED
c di y, anéf' pplca
o oce d q ot
u rs l
a t sm a trwilbeD I ISSE D a STRICK EN fom t a
nd hi te l
SM
nd
r
he céve doc toft c t
ke
he our .

A n a opra e Or wilbe e e e
ppr i t der l
nt r d.

Enee : o %- /'- y. d
trd
ö'

5f

* AV .
'
V

V -1' *
' $E .
.

.

*
.. .
.

,
.

'

.

.

M ihae F.
c l Ur nsd
l

Che Uni S àe Diti t u ge
if t tts slc l d

2

.

.