Barb v. Crites et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/16/2018. (jv)

Download PDF
( f xoplzuç D= d v t od d . I œ a u i u qv T- K e R A Fl x I TH E UN I N TED STATES DISTRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTE RN D ISTRICT O F W RGI I N A H AARI N BU RG D I I SO V SION J l!6 2 . rl 01 : ' J wc. bL g Y' ' ,. u D TE RRY W .BARB, Pl nt f , ai i f Ci lActon N o.5:8cv00059 vi i 1 By: SHAW NA M .CRI TES, ta . e 1, H on.M i chaelF.u r ' bansd l Chi fUnie St t sDiti t udge e t d a e src J D ef endant s. M EM O RAN D U M O PI ION N Pr e ng pm . ,pl ntf Te r W .Ba b,fl d t i t ntc oce di K ai if r y r le he nsa ompl nta ns H a dy ai gai t r - Cou yMa itaeS wn M. ie a d Ha d Cou yPr e u igAto ne Lu a J. e nt gsr t ha a Crts n r y nt osc tn tr y c s Se , s e ngl vet pr edL f ' a a ei.Fort r s s tf t bel Bat s e ki ea o oce q ot m u rs he ea ons e orh ow, b' a i a i t pt ee L f pplc ton o oc d q onna a e i * 1beG RAN TED a li c pl i wilbe u rs nd ls om ant l DI I ED wihou pr j iept u ntt 28U.. j1 1 ()2 ( . SM SS t t eud c us a o SC. 9 5e ()B) 1 . Bab' c antaie o o a2 7 ci na a to a jdiae i t Ma itae r s ompli rs s ut f 01 rmi l cin du c td n he g stt Cou to Had Couny W etVi/ni.nAu us 201 , rmia c li sweeSld r f ry t, s r a I g t 7 ci n l ompant r e a i tBar f alga i ofdom e écba t r dom esi as a t a obsruc i Aspa tof gans b or le tons s te y, tc s ul, nd t ton. r aplaa r e n , r p e n c nts t a sul a obst to c r e . ud me te tr d e g e me t Ba b ld o o e t o sa t nd tucin hag sJ g n n e e o De e r7 20 7 S eCrmi l Or e frVi a o 6 -209 $, No. - a n cmbe , 1 . e i nal. d r o oldon f 10 - q ECF 2 A t 1 Crmi l . d rf rVi ain of6 - 5 1 a, ; i na l Or e o olto 1 0 - 7() ECF No. -5 a 1 Bab r c i d t 2 , t 4. r e eve i me s rv . s pende s nt nc a uns r ed pr don w1. c e edya us d e e e, nd upe ds oba t4 ondii , ncudi 1 tons i l ng r quii li Tt atend a rm a ge entcouns zng untlt couns li s fed t the e rng lm fo t nge na m e i he e s adsi ha 1 a e s d t i s s' Se e i O r r U ns r ed Pr ton,ECF N o.2 at10. ddr s e he s ue .' nt ncng de ; upe ds oba i -5, Afe c ei ga o iea e ma g me tc k s i a ua y2 8 Bab alge t a t tr ompltn n nl ng r na e n oz e nl n r 01 , r le s h t he n r pr e i a cour f os cuton nd t ound t c s t bei de t . lte t t m a s r t cout he our e o na qua e A e t r o he gita e ' t e anst pr ec xpli he os udon' posdon t tBa b s d padcpa eilange m a ge e s i ha r houl l i t t r na m nt c ouns lng a t Ce e f M a ra a Fam i Couns lng.Se Le tr fom K e hi Anne ei t he nt r or ri ge nd l y ei e te r s a C. Tenoro t M a i ta e Sha i o g sr t wna Crt ,ECF N o.2-5,a 1 Ba b a hi couns lwer ies t 7. r nd s e e s he e t a a i c tr ga di t ecas eson A prl9,2018.SeeLete fom c duld o ppe r n our e r ng hes l s i tr r D e rc W . he z t Te r Ba b, a . 2018,ECF N o.2-5,a 1 r ik W t el o r y r M r 28, t 9. Ba b fl d tasac i a ns M a i ta eSha r le li ton gai t g sr t wnaM .Crt oft M a s r t Cour of ies he gita e t HadyCo t, e tVigni a d Luc s . e , o e u i Ato ne f rHa d Cou yi r un y W s t i a n a J S e Pt s c tng t r y o r y nt n z pons t hi c i i ac i Ba b' algatonsi ude: nf m a i s a hi bit dat es e o s rm nal ton. z s le i ncl i or ton, uch s s th e a drve ' lce e s a s we e s a e i r ty d'tng hi c i i lpr e ngs hewa nd i rs i ns t m , r t t d ncor ec l li s rm na oce di ; s c r f ley ofs xual a s uli r nor ;t m a s r t a pr e utng a t ne ha ged as l e l s a tng ni s he gita e nd os c i tor y y t e t ned t a r thi i he ci notatend a he a rm a ge entcolr e a Chid hr a e o t es m f ld t not r nge na m zs ; nd l Pr e i Se v c s f Vig ni a W es Vig ni a us hi ofi de t s r i of ot ctve r i e or t i a nd t t i a cc ed m na qua e upe dson li da zs ught r .I hi cvi c rs et Ba b des rbest na ut ofhi s tasf li unde e s n s i l ove he , r c i he t e s ui alng r t Fa s Cli sAct SeeCi lCove Shee ,ECF N o.2 By wa ofr m e Ba b s kst he le am . vi r t -1. y e dy, r ee o / . ha hi r or cea ed oft e c r a alofli fnesa cour cossdir s e ve s ec d l r hes ha ges nd l ls i nd t t snis d. 1I. Bab mo st p oc e t f r a a ei, rua t 28U. C. 1 1 ()1. e r ve o r e d q o m u rs pu s nt o S. j 9 5 a() S e ECF N o.1. cour W I gt ntBa b' m oéon t pr ee L f a a e i. H owe r The t I a r s o oc d q om a u rs ve , a t rr vi wi t com pl nt t c tc ude t tt sa fe e e ng he ai , he our oncl s ha hi cdon m us be dinns ed t s is 2 pu s ntt 28U. C. 1 1 e()B) de 28U. C. 1 1 ()2 ( , ititc ursha rua o S. j 9 5()2 ( .Un r S. j 9 5e()B) dsrc o t ve adut t s r ni ta flngsa dinas ac y o cee niil ii nd s is ompli fldL f m apa rsa a tmei ant ie q or upei t ny i f t ec ur deemie ta t aton<ii fi lusormaiius @ fist saeacam on h o t tr n s h the ci <) s rvoo ( l o ; al o tt li c ' whihrle ma beg a e o tise mon tr rle a ans ad fnda whoi i c eif y rntd; r i) e ks eay eif g i t ee nt i smmun e fom s h r i . z uc elef' ' Ba b a s rsno b ssf rfde a jrs c o e t sma tr Se Kok o n v. r s et a i o e r lt ididon v r hi te . e k ne z Gu r a LieI . o Am.5 1U.. 75 3 7(9 4 rTe rl ou t aec isbf adin f nsCo. f , 1 S 3 , 7 1 9 ) dea c rs r ou t l td jrs iton. e pose sonl t t we a t rz dbyConsi in a saat, i e u idci Th y s s y ha po t u ho ie mi tmto nd tt e z whc i no t bee pa de b j iild ce . ( tr l ia onso te l;e as Fe . ih s t o x n d y udca e re' i ena cté 'n mitd) se lo d R. Ci P.8a ( pla i mus c nti as r apli sae ntoft g o ndsfrtec r' v. () a e dng t o an ho t an ttme he r u o h outs j idci ) Thefc oft c mpli alg snoc nsi i l i ain orv oai of urs it . on a e he o ant l e e o tmt volto ona i lt on fd rlsa tet t u dgv rs t fd r lq e t j id cin un r2 U.. j1 3 . e e a ttz ha wo l ie ie o e e a u si urs ito de 8 SC. 3 1 t on Bar ss l c b' e e don oft Fas Cli sAc on hi cvi c rs eti uns he le nm t s i l ove he s uppor e by hi td s com pli ;br y s ki t Fa s Cli sA c i pos la lt on pe s who ant oadl pea ng, he le um tm es i biiy r ons k wi l s bt torc us t s mi flecamst t go r me . e 3 U.. j 3 29 no ngy u ni a e o ub t as li o he ve n nt S e 1 SC. j 7 3 3 Th th snotbe n alg d hee Bab as c msdv riyjts it o hi cvl o r 7 3. a a e le e r . z lo bi ie st u idci n s iic ve on s e t bu hedoe no alg d ma e e c e ig $ ,0 a r q ie b 28U. C. 1 3 S e h e, t s t le e a g s x e dn 750 0 s e u rd y S. j 3 2. e CiiCo rS e, No 2-9 mpl ECFNo. ,a 7(e u sigdsnsa ofc r vl ve hetECF . 1 Co . , 2 t r q e t inisl ou t n c t a d f s; i n l . d rf rVi ldon of6 - 2 09 $, No. - a 1 oss n i ) Crmia l Or e o oa ne 1 0 - 9 ECF 2 4, t (se sn c ssa fe i t a o tof$ 2 259 i nal. d rf rVi lton of6 a s sig o t nd e s n he m un 2 0. ) Crmi l Or e o oai 1 0 - 7() ECF No. -5 a 1 (se sngafn of$ 5 .0 a d c t a fe of$1 .5 . 5 1 a, 2 , t 4 a s si i e 3 00 n oss nd e s 852 ) I any e ,Bar ha notal ge acli upon whih r lefc be g a e The n vent b s le d am c ei an r nt d. Ma itaeCou to Had Co te tzdci naj g nt a i tBaba pat6fapla gsrt r f ry un nee rmi lud me s gans t s r e delS eCrmial Or e f Vi ain of6 -209 $, No. - a 1 Ctmi l . a. e i n l . d r or olto 10 - q ECF 2 4, t 9 i nal Or e f rVi ai of6105 1 () ECF No. -5 a 1 . eRoo rFedma d t d r o olton - - 7 a, 2 , t 4 Th ke- l n ocdne ge z lypr zbisl rf de a coursfom r e ng sat c ztdecsons The Fouzh ne al oli t owe e r l t r eviwi t e otr ii . t Ciczte pli dtec t'l tdj idci u e tzsd ti i Fre ma sl . . rti x ane h ou tsi e urs it nd r i ocrne n id n',nc v mi on i Du a 29 F.d 1 , 9 (t Ci. 00 ) nlp, 0 3 91 1 6 4. r2 2 : h U nde t Rooke -Fedm a doc rne l t f de a cour sm a r he z l n ti , owe e r l t y notc i r et rdis a aal pr e ed t a decde by onsde ihe fsues ctz ly es nt o nd i d a sa e colt7 or f tt zt' r tt éona cli s t t a e i xti a y consiu l nm ha r ne rc bl i e t ne wih q sinsr ld upo b a sae c t. Tllr ntrwi d t ue to u e n y t t ou t' y e ' v.Moo e 1 F.d 7 ,73 n. (t Ci. 1 9 ) ( e n l r , 29 3 28 1 6 4 h r 9 71 i r a nt q otto ma k o nte ) Fe rl c urs a e dve td of u ain r s r itd . dea o t r i se j icci n T z e tranng t f d r lcam s ud be t ursl to f e n e tii he e e a li ho l i whe he equi lnt of a a la e r viw of t sa e cour oz r' vae n ppe lt e e he t t t de . : J z a g. moc ai Pa t ofVa) 1 2 F.d (9 , a 20 (t o d hl v De r tc ry . 2 3 1 21 t 2 4. , h Ci.1 9 1 (l r ton a i ena q téon ma k onitd . r 9 7 at ai s nd ntr l uo a e r s r te ) Rooke -Fedm an apples whe t f r l ac i Tes e i l r l i n he ede a ton f s ntal y a un st no higm o et n a atmptt s e rv e ofg mo t o t n r ha n te o e k e iw t he saec u ts de ii b al we fde a c ur. J1-. 1 9 F.d tt o r' cson y o r e r l o t' 1yg: 2 3 ) ' .11 , a 733.Thus f hen a pa t s s i f de a diti t c t t t ,f w ry ue n e r l src our o ' r a jciae t e sme is s d cd d i t e sae c r e du l t h a c sue e ie n h t t ou t pr ee tngs t ta i i i es e an a t m ptt obt n d r ct oc ci , ha cton s n s nce te o ai i e r viw of t sa e cour de ii . . i c z ve i of e e he t t t c son n onta nton Ro e-Fed n' Br wn & Ro l l . Br c e i e,21 ok r lma . o ' ot, nc v. e k ntdg ) 1 F.d (9 , a 2 g4 h Ci.2 00j The lbe a c d t t 3 1 4) t 01 (t r 0 ). a l la he o he f de a cour a don wilr r l i e r be i por a , snc a e rl t c l a ey, f ve , m t nt i e pat t ti s e ig i fd z lc u tt r a u c t a is ry ha s e kn n e e a o r o e djdiae n sue de i i s a e c ti unlkey t s y s c ded n t t our s i l o a o. 1 Fe e a c rsma note t ran ac mpli wheefhel ig p ryi saec ut g ls d. d t l ou t y n eti o ant r ' osn a t n tt o t f ej t l s t n fde a c ur a trt saepr c e igse e , o anigofa i jr c us dbyt uii e r l o t fe he t t o e dn nd d c mpli n n nu y a e he sae c r jd me g'Ex onMoblCo v. a i scI dus Com.5 4 U.. 8 , 91 t t-ou t u g nt.' x l i m. S ud Ba i n . ,4 S202 (0 5. 2 0) Al ug Bab do sno e pl il s e t ov r nhi sa ec ur jdg e s he t h r e t x i t e k o e mr s tt o t u m nt, ho cy 4 rq e t rl fta efcieynulfe t s j g nt bye p gn hi rc da srkn e u ss ei h t fetv l l is he e ud me s x un ig s e or nd tiig e i fne ,c t,and f s Tli a ount t not ng m or t a c lenge t t vai t oft i s os s ee . ls m s o hi e han hal o he ldiy he saec u tjdg ntBab' cnmsa i tMa itaeCrt sa Pr e u o Se aieou of t t o t u me . r s li gans gst t ie nd os c t r e rs t li dia e e wih t sat c tpr e ngs Undert Rooke - l a docti ,t s ns s gr em nt t he t e our oce di . he r Fe dm n rne hi c z lc t jrs c t rviw Bab'c ms ou taks he uidiéon o e e r s bi . M or ove ,Ba b ha fie t a s r avi bl cai f da a a i tet r e r r s a ld o s e t a e l m oz m ges gans ihe M aitaeCrtso Pr eutrS ebe a s t yaee tte t a olt jdiila gsrt ie r osc o e c u e he r nild o bs ue u ca nd p os c ora i riy r s ciey l g sha i ni fo satf f csc r e ut ilmmu l , epe tv l. ud e ve mmu t r m li or f t ommit d t y a te wihi terj iiluidci 'Pironv. , 8 U. 5 7 5 3 4(96 ) seas t n h i udca jrs iton. es Ra 3 6 S. 4 , 5 -5 1 7; e lo ? Miee v. ao, 0 U.. ,1 (9 )Soli ta idiiua j g saei rls W c 5 2 S 9 1 1 91 dng h t n vd lud e r mmunefo rm l b l y%rd ma sf a tonstk ni t i jdiilc pa iy . a itaeCrtse ee i ii a t a ge or ci a e n her u ca a ct) M g sr t ie ntr d j g nta ans Bab, ndalg dye p e sddistsa to w11Bab' slce a e ud me g i t r a l e l x r se saifcin : r s eetd ng r e 3 m a gem e c s -a r r d t r ofli uns r i e pr éon.Thes a t oc t d na ht our e equie e m ls upe v s d oba e c s cur e durng t pe i he ndenc ofBa b' c i i la ton and pr i wlih c e ry a ewihi y r s rnana c i obaton, lc l a l r t n Ma itaeCrt s j iilurs iton. k wie Pr e utrSe i e i e t i niyfo gsrt ie 'udca j idci Lie s , os c o e s ntt d o mmu t r m l la lt f da a s f hi ofk espr ec i ofBa b' c i i la ton a i ve e i ibiiy or m ge or s i ' os uton r s rm na c i nd nvol m nt n hspr ton Se Buc l v. tsmmons5 U.. 9 2 3(9 3 (g csund za e b i obai . e ke Fizi , 09 S 25 , 7 1 9 ) 'Al' etk n y f t apz e ut ...wlih oc i t cour e ofl sr e a a a os c or zc cur n he s a ol s n dvoc t f t St e,a e i a e ot he at r e ld t t pr e to ofa out i riy.7. t sc lit onisfc , tts néte o he otc ins bs l e mmu t g7 Bab' omp an , t a e sae t j) cam st ta e fi ousa i tpa te who a e i m une f om s h s t .Cf Cht v.G rf h, li ha r rvol gans r is r m t uc uis . i ift 7 1 F.d79 8 (t Ci. 9 5 .Thee o e M a itaeCrt sa Pt e ut Se aee ild 7 2 , 1 4h r 1 8 ) r f z , gstt ie nd os c or e r ntt e t i m uriy a t cq m sf m onetr da a sa i tt om lt nd he li or a y m ge gans hem s d bedinns e houl s is d. 5 Thecour consnz pt.K c pl i slbe al i posng fls s dnge sa r t t es t z om ant i r l m y, i <e s t nt t nda ds - l t a f ma pla i sd atd b lwy t . Erc s v Pa d , 51U. 8 , 4 ( 0 ) h n or l e dng r fe y a e s' ik on . r us 5 S. 9 9 20 7 ? ( u g Esel v. mbl, 2 U. 9 , 0 0 ( 9 6) Ho ve,f c litmus q oén tl Ga e 4 9 S. 7 1 4- 5 1 7 ). we r f ompan e a t c ai s fcentf ct lm ate ,ac e e astte t ft e a cnm ofr le t ti plusbl ont n ufi i a ua tr c pt d rz, o sat li e if ha s a i e onisfc .' hcotv. ba, 5 U. 6 2 6 8(0 )(uot Bel lCo . t ae' As r f I l5 6 S. 6 , 7 2 09 q i lAt. ' ng v. Twombl,5 0U. 5 4 5 0 (00 ). rt era o s tf rh a v , t sc litfis 5 S. 4 , 7 2 7) Fo h e s ns e o t bo e Bab' ompan al t sat al ga cli upon wli r lefm a begr ed. Thus li c pl i m us be o t e e l am lch ei y ant ,as om nnt t ds se p sa t 28U. C. 1 5e()B) a ( imisd uru nto S. j 91 ()2( $) nd 1 $. 1 1. 1 Acc di l Ba b' applcai t pr e t f m a a e i wilbeG RAN TED or ngy, r s i ton o oce d q or u rs l a t smatrwil DI M I ED wih tpz j iea d S CKEN fo t a t nd hi te l be S SS t ou eud c n TRI r m he ci ve docke oft c ut t he ot . An a opra e Or rwilbe e e ed.The c e k i diec e t s ac oft s ppr i t de l ntr l r s r t d o end opy hi K antf. M em or ndum O piaon t alcouns lofz cor a t pa . pli if a li o l e e d nd he . - E te: o y- /# . u t ne d z - g f /. 4 .J /. + m A M i ha lF.Ur ns ' c e ba ChifUntd S ae Ditit ud e e ie tt s stc l g '

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?