Barb v. Crites et al
Filing
3
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/16/2018. (jv)
( f xoplzuç D= d v
t od d . I œ
a u i u qv
T- K e R A
Fl
x
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DISTRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTE RN D ISTRICT O F W RGI I
N A
H AARI N BU RG D I I
SO
V SION
J l!6 2 .
rl
01
:
'
J wc.
bL
g
Y'
' ,.
u
D
TE RRY W .BARB,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
Ci lActon N o.5:8cv00059
vi
i
1
By:
SHAW NA M .CRI
TES, ta .
e 1,
H on.M i
chaelF.u r
' bansd
l
Chi fUnie St t sDiti t udge
e
t d a e src J
D ef
endant
s.
M EM O RAN D U M O PI ION
N
Pr e ng pm . ,pl ntf Te r W .Ba b,fl d t i t ntc
oce di
K ai if r y
r le he nsa ompl nta ns H a dy
ai gai t r
-
Cou yMa itaeS wn M. ie a d Ha d Cou yPr e u igAto ne Lu a J. e
nt gsr t ha a Crts n r y nt osc tn tr y c s Se ,
s e ngl vet pr edL f ' a a ei.Fort r s s tf t bel Bat s
e ki ea o oce q ot
m u rs
he ea ons e orh ow, b'
a i a i t pt ee L f
pplc ton o oc d q onna a e i * 1beG RAN TED a li c pl i wilbe
u rs
nd ls om ant l
DI I ED wihou pr j iept u ntt 28U.. j1 1 ()2 ( .
SM SS
t t eud c us a o
SC. 9 5e ()B)
1
.
Bab' c antaie o o a2 7 ci na a to a jdiae i t Ma itae
r s ompli rs s ut f 01 rmi l cin du c td n he g stt
Cou to Had Couny W etVi/ni.nAu us 201 , rmia c li sweeSld
r f ry
t, s r a I g t 7 ci n l ompant r e
a i tBar f alga i ofdom e écba t r dom esi as a t a obsruc i Aspa tof
gans
b or le tons
s
te y,
tc s ul, nd t ton.
r
aplaa r e n , r p e n c nts t a sul a obst to c r e . ud me te tr d
e g e me t Ba b ld o o e t o sa t nd tucin hag sJ g n n e e
o De e r7 20 7 S eCrmi l Or e frVi a o 6 -209 $, No. - a
n cmbe , 1 . e i nal. d r o oldon f 10 - q ECF 2 A t
1 Crmi l . d rf rVi ain of6 - 5 1 a,
; i na l Or e o olto
1 0 - 7() ECF No. -5 a 1 Bab r c i d t
2 , t 4. r e eve i
me
s rv . s pende s nt nc a uns r ed pr don w1. c
e edya us
d e e e, nd upe ds
oba
t4 ondii , ncudi
1
tons i l ng
r quii li Tt atend a rm a ge entcouns zng untlt couns li s fed t the
e rng lm fo t
nge
na m
e
i he
e s adsi ha
1
a e s d t i s s' Se e i O r r U ns r ed Pr ton,ECF N o.2 at10.
ddr s e he s ue .' nt ncng de ; upe ds
oba i
-5,
Afe c ei ga o iea e ma g me tc k s i a ua y2 8 Bab alge t a t
tr ompltn n nl ng r na e n oz e nl n r 01 , r le s h t he
n
r
pr e i a cour f
os cuton nd
t ound t c s t bei de t . lte t t m a s r t cout
he our e o
na qua e A e t r o he gita e
'
t
e anst pr ec
xpli he os udon' posdon t tBa b s d padcpa eilange m a ge e
s i
ha r houl l i t t
r na m nt
c
ouns lng a t Ce e f M a ra a Fam i Couns lng.Se Le tr fom K e hi Anne
ei t he nt r or ri ge nd
l
y
ei
e te r
s a
C.
Tenoro t M a i ta e Sha
i o g sr t
wna Crt ,ECF N o.2-5,a 1 Ba b a hi couns lwer
ies
t 7. r nd s
e
e
s he e t a a i c tr ga di t ecas eson A prl9,2018.SeeLete fom
c duld o ppe r n our e r ng hes l s
i
tr r
D e rc W . he z t Te r Ba b, a . 2018,ECF N o.2-5,a 1
r ik W t el o r y r M r 28,
t 9.
Ba b fl d tasac i a ns M a i ta eSha
r le li ton gai t g sr t
wnaM .Crt oft M a s r t Cour of
ies he gita e
t
HadyCo t, e tVigni a d Luc s . e , o e u i Ato ne f rHa d Cou yi
r
un y W s t i a n
a J S e Pt s c tng t r y o r y nt n
z pons t hi c i i ac i Ba b' algatonsi ude: nf m a i s a hi bit dat
es
e o s rm nal ton. z s le i
ncl i or ton, uch s s th e
a drve ' lce e s a s we e s a e i r ty d'tng hi c i i lpr e ngs hewa
nd i rs i ns t m , r t t d ncor ec l li
s rm na oce di ;
s
c r f ley ofs xual a s uli r nor ;t m a s r t a pr e utng a t ne
ha ged as l
e l s a tng ni s he gita e nd os c i tor y
y
t e t ned t a r thi i he ci notatend a he a rm a ge entcolr e a Chid
hr a e
o t es m f ld
t
not r nge
na m
zs ; nd l
Pr e i Se v c s f Vig ni a W es Vig ni a us hi ofi de t s r i of
ot ctve r i e or t i a nd
t t i a cc ed m
na qua e upe dson
li da
zs ught r .I hi cvi c rs et Ba b des rbest na ut ofhi s tasf li unde
e s n s i l ove he , r
c i he t e
s ui
alng
r
t Fa s Cli sAct SeeCi lCove Shee ,ECF N o.2 By wa ofr m e Ba b s kst
he le am
.
vi
r
t
-1.
y
e dy, r ee o
/
.
ha hi r or cea ed oft e c r a alofli fnesa cour cossdir s e
ve s ec d l r
hes ha ges nd l ls i
nd
t t snis d.
1I.
Bab mo st p oc e t f r a a ei, rua t 28U. C. 1 1 ()1. e
r ve o r e d q o m u rs pu s nt o
S. j 9 5 a() S e
ECF N o.1. cour W I gt ntBa b' m oéon t pr ee L f a a e i. H owe r
The
t I a
r s
o oc d q om a u rs
ve ,
a t rr vi wi t com pl nt t c tc ude t tt sa
fe e e ng he
ai , he our oncl s ha hi cdon m us be dinns ed
t
s is
2
pu s ntt 28U. C. 1 1 e()B) de 28U. C. 1 1 ()2 ( , ititc ursha
rua o
S. j 9 5()2 ( .Un r
S. j 9 5e()B) dsrc o t ve
adut t s r ni ta flngsa dinas ac
y o cee niil ii nd s is ompli fldL f m apa rsa a tmei
ant ie q or
upei t ny i f
t ec ur deemie ta t aton
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?