Utley v. Utley

Filing 4

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/11/2018. (jv)

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D ISTRI CO U RT
CT
FO R TH E W E STERN D I
STRI O F VI GI I
CT
R N A
H ARRI
SON BU RG D I
VISION
(Lt. s
7:;,
.

)ï.:. t sj v eotxv
:/(; k op
,mxàs , sw i
t
$
aj)g(
. yy
, )
f
,

,
.

D AN I L F . UT LEY ,
E

.

yk7)jg 2 j
t4 N
.y
jg

Cas èê 5:18-cv-00064
e o.5: cv00021
18

Pl ntf,
ai if

J.- tv . DU
t!.
//
.

iY'
,.

'
'

,

C1
Fr

x

By: M i
chaelF.U r
bans
ki

Chi fUnie S a e Di ti t udge
e t d t t s s rc J

J N Y FE UTLEY,
EN
D ef
endant
.

M E M O M N D U M O PI I N
N O

Pr c el g p o s , antf Da ilF. ly(< . ly' fld t ei tntComp an
o e cn r e pli if ne Ute < Ut ' i h nsa
i
Mr e l e
li t

(hc< mpli 'o t
t f
co ant: r <
Comp.)ECF No. l teac mpa igo d re trdwihti
l',
'
2.n h c o nyn r e nce t ls
l
m e or ndum opi on,t c twilgt ntM r Ute la t pr e i f m a a ersdue
m a
ni he our l a
. ly e ve o oce d n or
u i
t hi i gence Afe r viwi t Com pl i ,t cour c l
o s ndi
. t r e e ng he
ant he
t oncudest tt ac i m us be
ha he ton
t

d s se f lc ofurs it pu s ntt 28U.. j 1 3 a 1 1 ()2 ( ( -()
imisd or a k j idc i
on, rua o
SC. j 3 2 nd 9 5e ()B)i i .
) i
Undc 28U. C. 1 5 dititc rsha ead yt s r e i iilfl g a ds ns
r
S. j 91 , src ou t v ut o c e n nta ii s nd inis
n
ac
ompli fl i f m a a e i (a any tm e i t cour det m i st ...t
ant ied n or
u rs tt
i f he
t er ne hat
he

a t . .sfi l o.m aii s. .( jfist saeacam onwl c r l fm a be
c i . i rvoous r l ou . ol al o tt li
on
c
a h ei y
i
e

g a td. 2 U. C. 1 1 ()2 ( ( -() s eas Erl eCo. . v. o s , 4 F.d 6 8
r n e ' 8 S. j 9 5e ()B)i i ; e lo in
'
) i
i
SA. - hn on 4 0 3 4 ,
l
6 6 ( h Ci. 0 6 ( e na q tto orit d rt e t )1 1 p rnisd src c urst
5 4t r 2 0 ) i r l uo ains n te ) g ci 9 5 e t t itit o t o
nt
s on
i pe nty as es t m e isofi f m a a e i c pli s a t e l szt t t
nde nde l s s he rt
n ot
u rs om ant, nd o xcude lis ha

h veno ag bl bai i lw o fc .
a
r ua e ss n a r a t).
'
The c tc tues r s c pli slbe al,i posng çls srnge sa r
our onsr
o e om a nt i r ly m
i Ke s ti nt tnda ds

t n f z lpe d n sd atd b lwy z . Erc s n v Pa d ,5 1U.. ,9 ( 0 7
ha o ma la i g r fe y a e s' ik o . r us 5 S 89 4 2 0 )
'

(uo ig Esel v. mbl, 9U.. 7, 0 05(97 ). ehee s < c mpli mu t
q tn tl Ga e 42 S 9 1 4- 1 6) Non t ls,< o ant s
e
a
cont i s fce f ct lm ate ,a e ed a tue,t ft t a cam oft left ti plusbl
an ufii nt a ua
tt cc pt s r o s ae li
ei ha s a i e

onisfc .' hc o tv. ba,5 6U.. 6 , 7 (0 9 (uo igBel l Co .
t a e' As r f 1 l 5 S 6 2 6 8 2 0 ) q tn lAt.
'
v.
Two , 5 U. 5 4 5 0 (0 7 .
mbl 5 0 S. 4 , 7 2 0 )
Ft t c rs e ,i a
om he ove he t t ppea st M r Ute a guest tt cour c exe cs
r hat . l y r
ha he
t an r ie

dve st j rs cin, sde e da l nn FeUte (t . lf) i pu po tdyact e o
i riy u idito a fn nt e y
ly ( Ut s r re l ii n f
Ms e
z
t Phii ne .Ci lCove Shee ,ECF N o.2- Butfdititcour ss l notha orgi l
he lppi s vi
r
t
1.
f s rc
t hal
ve i na

gie stjjrs ito . . a a tonbea e n ct e ofaS aea ct e ofaf r in
dv ri u id cin . of n ci tv e ii ns
y
z
tt nd ii ns
z
o eg
sa ewho a e lwf l a nit f pe m a ntr sdencei t Unie St t a e not
tt
r a uly dr ted or r ne e i
n he
t d aes r

do ncldi t esm cStt. 28U. C. 1 3 a() M r Ut ycamst t1 hhea d M r.
t iie n h a
ae'
;
S. j 3 2()2 . . l li ha 3
e
0t
n s
U te lve i W oods oc Vigi a. vi Cove She ,ECF N o. 1. ss h,t c tca
ly i n
t k, t ni Ci l
r et
2- A uc he our n

e r iedve st j idc in o yi M r. lyi n alg lp r ne r sde oft e
xe cs i riy urs ito nl f s Ute s ot e a e ma nt e i nt h
U nie St t . r Ute doe notpla t s whi i f a t hi cam .
t d a es M . ly s
e d hi, ch s atl o s li

Furhe,t c r ma onye e cs dve st jrs it i t a nti
t r he ou t y l x t ie i riy u idci f he mou n
on
c nto ryi gr ae t n $ 50 0 2 U. C. 1 3 a. r Ut ya a st se t er t r
o r ve s s e tr ha 7 ,0 . 8 S. j 3 2() M . l ppe r o e k h e u n
e
ofhi c l en, a he t n m onetr r lef Se Compl at5.
s hidr r t r ha
a y ei . e
.
The c tc nnotafot M r
our a
f d .
Ute t r ifhe s e .A sM r Ute fist pl d t r quiie a ounti c t r y,
ly he ele
e ks
. ly al o ea he e st m
n ont ove s

a an, h c u tc n e e cs dve st jrsl to o rt eCo ant
g i t e o r a not x r ie i riy u iccin ve h mpli .
i

Acor n l,hec r wi csls Mr Ute 'c mpant t ut eu iep tua
c digy t ou t l lris . lys o li wiho prjdc u s nt
li a
t 28U. C. j1 3 a d 1 5e ()B) f rlc ofjrs ito
o
S. j 3 2 n 91 ()2 ( $) o a k u idci n.
The Cl k i diec e t s nd c esoft sM e or ndum Opi on a t
er s r t d o e opi
hi m a
ni nd he

a com pa i O t rt pli if
c
nyng de o a ntf.

Ent ed: Aprl11 2018
er
i ,

5 M ichaelF.Urbanski .
f - r,
' 4
V
ClifUnie S ae 't c l g
le td tts l t ud e
i

3