RLI Insurance Company v. Nexus Services, Inc.

Filing 108

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 10/30/2018. (jv)

CLERKSOFFI U.
CE
S. ST
ATROANOK DI . COUR7
E
,VA
FIED
L

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STRICT COU RT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D ISTRICT O F W RGI I
N A
H ARRISO N BU RG D I I ON
V SI

OC'J a j
r
g
J

v

BK

'

U

KLII SU RAN CE CO M PAN Y,
N
Pl ntf y
ai i f

Ci lActon N o.5: - 00066
vi
i
18 CVV.

N EXUS SERW CES,I C.
N ,
By:
D ef ndant
e
,

Mi
chaelF.U t
bansl
d

Chi fUlie St t sDititJ
e at d a e src udge

V.

J
UAN VALOY, ta.
e 1
y
l er
nt venor
s.

M EM O RAN DU M O PI I N
N O

Th sm atri be o et c ut on amod t i tr e fld b ua Vao , g r
i te s f r he o t
on o n e v ne le yl n ly Ed a

Alrd Ra sRa , rei Ra rzsa he , srAug soGrmao a Ges
fe o mo - mos Mac l
no mie - nc z Cea
u t a j, nd ron
Ca to Se da ECF N o.8. m a t rhasbee f l bref The c tdipens wih or l
s r ge .
The te
n uly i ed.
our s es t a
ar e be a e t l ga cont ndonsa e a qua ey pr e e i t m a e l be or t
gum nt c us he e l
e
t de t l es nt d n he t das f e he
cour a a gu e woul nota d t de ii lpr es .Fott f l ng t as ,t
t nd r m nt
d
i he c sona oc s
he olowi e ons he
m odon t i e e i D EN I .
o nt rv ne s
ED

RIII urnc Compa y (RI1) a Ne usS r ie , nc tf x ' e ee i o a
, ns a e
n < , nd x e vc s I . f us' ntt d nt n
T '
Ne l
i de t a r e n onl nuay2 , 01 rfn mni Ag e me ' a c nsde a n f
n mni g e me t a r 0 2 6 l de t r e nt) s o i r éo ot
y
y
RT,' a e m entt is i i a
Is gr e
o s ue mm gr éon bonds A sde al i t cour' opi on on t
.
t ied n he
ts ni
he

xC /K
R
E x

e tns l l ae p ei nayi u do R1Ialg st tNe usbra he t I mnt
xe i y i td tl t njnc n, , l e ha x e c d he nde iy
ve dg
mi
e
Agr m e f avai yofr a ons i l ng f itr t pr de a es t N e '
ee nt or zet
e s , ncudi alze o ovi cc s o xus books
,

rc r sa ac u s ECFNo 5 . c ur g a tdRIIap ei n r i nc t t
e o d nd c o nt.
. 9 The o t tne , rl ay t don ha
mi
ju
r r d N exust gi a ce st a s lcéon ofisbooks r cor a a ount .ECF N o.60.
equie
o ve c s o ee
t
, e ds nd cc
s

Durngt c reofb ifn a dagu ntfrt p ei nayi u don,u n
i he ou s reig n r me o he rl r njnc l a
mi
Vao , a AlrdoRa - mosMacl Rn tzs nc z Cea Au soGrmao
ly Edg r fe
mosRa , rei mie- a he , sr gut a j,
no
a Ges nCatoSe e (heT nev no s)mo dt i e v n a dee da si t s
nd ro sr g da t d tr e r' ve o ntr e e s fn nt n hi
l
a
cdon.
ECF N o.8.
The l e e scnm t y ha arghtt i e ve unde Fe r lRul
nt w nor li he ve i o nt r ne
t de a
e

ofCiiPr e ur 2 a be a e()t yha alg l pr e t di e e ta sa e t i
vl oc d e 4() c us 1 he ve e al otce ntr s t tk - het
y
s nstve a confde i lpe s li or a i l a ed i doc e shed by N e a
e ii nd
i nta r ona nf m ton oc t n
um nt l
xus nd

rq etdb RI1 ()t i i eeti i ie o et pes a i o- t i dicosd
e u se y .;2 herntrs smpatd nc he ron lnft bn s sl e ;
ma
a ()net rRTIno Ne usa q tl t pr s nt t i i tr ssbe a eoft pn e '
nd 3 ihe , r x de uaey e e e s he. n e e t c us he e s
t
hna ili e e t i c plancewih t bond t t s ECF N o.8,a 3-10.TheI e ve s
nca nt r s s n om i
t he
e- .
m
t
nt r not

as agu t tt c ur c udga tpe is itr e inu rRue2 be a et y
lo r e ha he o t o l rn M si nev nto nde l 4$) cus he
ve
i e t die ty oppos t r ifs
nt nd o r c l
e he ele oughtby RT, and t i de e ess r t s m e
1
he r f ns ha e he a
ques
éonsof1w a f cta is i tlsa éon.ECF N o.8,a 1
a nd a t s ue n li c
t 0-12.Addii ly,t
tonal he
I eve snot t tt y ha sa lng be aus dicos e oft i pe s li or adon i
ntz nor
e ha he ve tnci
c e s l ur
he r r ona nf m
s

a i ydrc l c us dbyRI1sr q s, ihwotd ber d e s d b afvo a ed cson
nt
jur ie t a e
y
,' e ue t whc
z
l e r se y a rbl e ii
by t scour .ECF N o.8,a 1 3.
hi
t
t 2-1

RI1o e t t t i e v ndo a aNe usc e td sr tg t ft taeRTIs
, bjc s o he ntr e n s x -r ae tae y o rz r t .'
s
e or e e ofiscontac a rght .ECF N o.71,at2. Ia gue t tt I e e s
nf c m nt t
r m li s
RT, r s ha he nt w nor

ha notc ri d t i but n ofde onsr i t i zghtt i e vendon ort t
ve
a re he r de
m
tatng her i o ntr
ha

2

ctu tnc ssppo tpe- si i ev ndo ECFNo. , t 4. ,cnms ()t
ic msa e u r t sve ntr e n.
mi
71 a 4-1 RTI li :1 he
alge ha m oft ei o ma n' f u eus i s c ld ;()t I e v no sa Ne us
le d r
h nf r do s ut r e s pe ua ve 2 he ntr e r nd x
ha nea l i
ve ry dendca i e essi opposng e or m e oft l m niyAgr m e f
l nt r t n
i nf ce nt he nde t
ee nt or

p i c pu pos s a wela d fns sa r l fs ug t ()o de si t spr c e n pr cud
rva y t e , s l s e e e nd ei o h ; 3 r r n hi o e dig e l e
e

RTIfo dsl igt si omaint mos fidpate;4 t l ev no sh venot
, r m icosn hi nfr to o t hr ris () he ntr e r a
s wn a v riyofi e e t c l i n, rno e s n e a d ()t el e v no sha n pe
ho d e st ntr s, ol o o nf a a c ; n 5 h ntr e r ve ot ld
us
f c sc
a t onnec t m t t I m niyAgr e e ort i m i a bonds i l ng f
dng he o he nde t
e m nt he m gr don
, ncudi or

pu e ofsandi L.M or
rpos s t ng. da eovet 1Llc e t ti e v
,1 ontnds ha ntr enéon c dope t
oul
n he

fo g tst t 24 0ohe bo prncpas terfmie, ndfinds a dc udprj ie
lod ae o he ,0 t r nd i i l,h i a l s a re , n o l eudc
i
RLIbe us t I e v
ca e he nt r enor m a wot wih N exust f sr t R'lsenf ce ente f s
s y
k t
o m t a e L ' or m
fort

t ou hdlt ylkai tc c . No. 1 a 1 1 .
hr g i or i t a d sECF
a
t on
7 , t 4- 7
l z pons t l e v
n es
e, he nt r enor de e RI,' a us tonst tt i pr
s nid Is cc a i ha het opos d
e
i e e
nt w ndon wa a ldgaton t dcbenehdng N e .ECF N o.75,a 2.N e ,f ispa'
s i i ac
xus
t
xus or t t,
t
a ee wih t I e ve s m oéon a not st tc
gr d t he nt r nor '
.
nd e ha ouns lf t I ew e spos es e
e or he nt nor
s ss

knowldgea
e
bouti m i aton pr e ngsa N e 'cint .ECF N o.78.
m gz i
oc edi
nd xus le s
I
I.

Rul 2 a()g vensitr e nb r ta p o ie a flo ,
e 4()2 o r ne vnéo y kh, nd t vd s s olws
O n tm ey m oton,t cout m us pe i a
i l
i
he
'
t
t = t nyone t i e ve
o nt r ne
who ...c sm sa i er tr ldng t t pr ry or t ns don
l i n nt es ea
o he ope t
za ac

t a i t s jc oft a t a i s st ae t a d s i
h t s he ube t he ci nd s o iu td h t iposng
on,
of t a ton m a a a pr céca m ate i par or i
he c i
y s
a l tr m i
mpede t
he
m ova ' a lt t pr e is i e e t unl s e s
nts biiy o ot ct t nt r sa e s xiéng pn te
ris
a qua ey r es ntt ti e es.
de t l ept e ha nt r t

Fe R. v. 2 ()2 . ,n a déon t de tai tmei s oft moéo a
d. Ci P. 4 a() Thus i d i o monsr t i l s he
ng
ne
n, n
a pl a mu ts w:()i tt s i t s bjc matro t a don;2 t tt pr e é
p i nt s ho 1 n e e t n he u e t te f he c () ha he otc on
c

ofti i eet ul bei ie b cus oft a éo a ()ta t a l a ' i eet
hsntts wo d mpatd e a e he c n; nd 3 h the ppi nt ntts
c s
i notade t l r es nt d by exie g pn-ist t ldga
s
qua ey epr e e
s
t e o he i don.SeeTea ev.Ba r 931
t
kke ,

F. 25 , 6 -6 ( h Ci. 9 ) <( dstc c uti fntte t t f lr n ofr a on bl
2d 9 2 0 1 4t r 1 91.f itit ot s e ild o he ul a ge e s a e
A)

dice n'od t= iewh te t rq e nsofi ev nd a amatro r tha e
sréo t ee n eh r he e e me t ntr e on s te f kh v
be m e .? be t M ut FieI .Co.v.
en t' Li ry
. z ns
Lum be Li dat s I ,314 F. D .180,18
r qui oz , nc'
R.
3

( D. . 0 6 (uoigCo of . W ed h eElc Co .5 2F.d21 , 6(t
E. Va 2 1 ) q tn m. Va v. s n ous e .
, 4 2 4 21 4h
Ci. 9 ).
t 1 76)

Rul 2 p o ie frpemisvei ev ndo ofpnqe. e24 $() sae ta
e 4$) r vd s o t si ntr e n
tisRul q 17) tts h t
on tm ey m odon,t c tm a pe nnta
i l
he our y r i nyone t i e ve who f acn m ordef e
o nt r ne
f
has li
ens
t ts r wih t m an ac
ha ha es t he i éon a c m on ques of1w orf c . Fe R.Ci P.
.
om
éon a
a t' d.
?
v.

2 $() . c ur e o ss bsa ldsrdo o ralwi o rjc ngmoinst
49 17)The o t njy u tnéa ice n ve l ng r ee d
o
to o
itr e und rRue2 $. e S t v. n n o 35 F.d8 4 8 2 ( h Ci. 0 39 l
nev ne e l 44 S e mih Pe nigtn, 2 3 8 , 9 4t r2 0 )Hi
l
v. etr Elc Co.6 2F.d3 , 5 6(t Ci. 9 2.
W sen e . , 7 2 81 38 -8 4h r 1 8 )
1 1.
1

Thel e vno sagu t tt yaee ie t i ev n a amatrofr u e
ntr e t r e ha he t ntt d o ntre e s te kht nd r
l
Fe e a RueofCii Pr c du e2 a, ratr d l, h tt c r s l pe mi t e t
d rl l
v l o e r 4() o le na vey t a he ou t houd r t h m o

i ev n u e Rul 2 $. c ut hndst tteI tr e t fit d monstt t i
ntre e nd r e 49 The o t
ha h nev no s alo e tae hez
ne dt i e vneu e ete Rue2 a or()
e o ntr e nd r ih r l 4() b.
A.

Unde Rul 2 a ,heI e v no sc nn e tbl h e c ee n t q e f r
r e 4() t ntr e r a ot sa i a h lme t e e d o
s
i e e ng a a m a t rofrght The I eve sdo s és yt tm ei s r quie e .
nt w ni s
te
i .
nt t nor
a f he i lne s e r m nt The

l e e sm ove t i e ve wihi t wee ofRLIflng iscom pli a t m odon
nt w not
d o nt r ne t n wo
ks
li t
ant nd he

4

frprl n r ij cin. ec s i sl i ise rysa swihonyt i éa pla igs
o ei ay nun to Th ae s tln t al tge, t l he ni l e dn
mi
l
flda d dic ve yr c nt c mme igpe t J i Dic veyPln.Se Un d S ae v.
le n so r e e l o ncn r he ont s o r a l e ke tts
y

Vkgni, 2F. D. 0 , 05( D. . 01 )rW heeac s ha no pr ge sdbe o t
i a 28 R. 4 3 4 E. Va 2 2 t r ae s t o rse y nd he
i éa pla n sa e amoéo t i tr e i t l ). we e , heI t r e sfi t
ni l e dig tg ,
n o n e v ne s i p' Ho v r t n e v nor al o
me

de taeta t yha a itr s i tes etmattoft a don t tti a do
monsrt h the ve n neetn h ubjc te he c ,ha hs c n
woul i part pr ec i oft tal ge i e es,ort tt i i e e ti nota qua ey
d m i he ot ton ha le d nt r t
ha he. nt r s s
t
de t l

r pr e ed by t exitng pa dest t léga i Se Tea
e es nt
he si
r o he i ton. e gue,931 F. at260-61.
2d

TheI e v n sfit e p e h w t e ha a i e e ti t s bjc matroft s
ntr e or al o x l o h y ve n ntr s n he u e t te hi
a éon, hi i t alged br c d oft I m niyAgr m e .To de ons r t
c
w ch s he le
ea he
he nde t
ee nt
m
ta e

i e ve
nt r ndon by rght t I e ve sne d t s
i , he nt r not e o how T sgni ntypr ec a ei e e t' as
f i hca l ot t bl nt r s,'
a

( ge rlneeti tes bjc matro pe diglkain d e no c ns at a
< nea itr s n h u e t te f n n i to o s t o ét e
a
t
z
pr tca l i e e twih nt me n n ofRul 2 a()'D ' MadD ' l . . ie
o e tbe ntr s t i he a i g
e 4()2 .
'
i
nc v Untd
S ae , 4 F. D. 0 ,1 1( D. . 9 3 (uo gi pa tDo l o v. ie S ae , 0
tts 1 7 R. 1 9 1 E. Va 1 9 ) q e n r nads n Un td tt s 40
U.. 7 5 (9 ). i e e t spr t ca l i a i tr e rsclm o d fns f a l a
S 51 , 42 1 71) An ntr s i o e tb e f n n e v no ' li r e e e f rs
be j
cos r ltonsùp t t diput be wee t e s ldga sa t r or m us bediec ,
l e ea i l o he s e t n he xiéng i nt nd he ef e
t
r t
r he t n r m ot orcontngent' I H e e t I evenor m a concus y as e dons
at t ha e e
i
.' d. r , he nt t
s ke
l or s r

a
boutt i i er ti t sa don. t
he. nt es n hi c
t
Alhough t l e ve sunde a y ha a i e e ti
he ntt nor
nibl ve n nt r s n

t ii o ma dsl e i t sa to ta ao d sno etbihar tof
hernfz éon icosd n hi cin,h t lne oe t sa ls kh
i e vendon.Thetprva y i e es doe notbe a cos r a i li t whet rRT. or
ntr
i i c nt r t s
ar l e eltonslp o
he
I
N e br a
xus e ched t l
he ndem niyAgz e e dudng t c s oft i busne sr l
t
e m nt
he our e he r i s eadonsùp.
l

Tli i boltr by t f c t tt I e venor do notcnm t be t r pa t benehca i s
ls s se ed he a t ha he ntr
s
li o
hid- ry
ite
1 c t n tsta dsl t s v b e rlae p rt p ei nayij do , uth yh v bens bett a
The out oe h t icos hae e n eesd e he rl r nl n b te a e e u jc o
ue
mi
mc
pr e dveoz r
ot c
de .

t t I m niyAgt m e a ha nota gue t tt y pos e sa s cik lgal
o he nde t
ee nt nd ve
t d ha he
s s pe f e l
y

pr e tbl tg ti t si or to Cf Unie S ae v. t ' ', 8 F. D. 3 4 ( D.
otca e ih n hi nf mai n. . td tt s Vi a 2 2 R. 40 , 05 E.

Va 2 1 )(< 't tn e t Pe éonesha asg ika , r e tbl i eeti tcii
. 0 2 f hev ot,he é t ve inf ntp otca e ntr s n e evng
Fur
t a op it c t oft i c iea p oe dn t i tg t und rt ADA. ..lhe
he ppt rae ae het hoc nd z tc g her ih s e he
. rl
Com pli c ai ave ybr d r ques f r left tdie tyi plc t t tght a
ant ont ns r oa e t or ei ha t c l m i a es he i s nd

i tt ssoft Pei e s'
n e e t he tdon r .
).
M o e v r dg h Fo t Cic th sh l t ta i ee tc pdng nto t ou c
r o e ,ft e urh rui a ed ha n ntr s o
j
e n he tome

o ohe pe iglkai qu lfe a Tiniia typ otca e' Li ousv Am. tr a e
f t r ndn i ton ai s s sg fc nl r e tbl.' nk . Alen dv
t
'
I . .No. : 1 CV- 7 , 0 K 48 4 3 , t 2 ( . Va Oc.1 2 11 (iig
ns Co , 7 1 - 2 8 2 11
9 2 3 a * W D. . t 3, 0 ) ctn
Te u , 31F. a2 1 ; e as Tia Ata M f . nc v. ik No. :1 0 2, 0 4W L
a e 9 2d t 6 ) s e lo tn ls
I . Ss , 11 CV0 01 2 1

8 7 4 , t 3 ( . Va Ma. , 1 )( e yngi e v n n byrg whe et i e nig
3 2 7 a * W D. . r 4 20 4 d n i ntr e do
iht t he ntwe n
i m niorfa gu t tisdiput wih Tia i N e Yor a Sout Ca olnaa e
nde t Tr es ha t s es t t n n w
k nd
h r i r
i l nc byTian' diput wih PM R i t sc t'a fal ist ti i notpat oft t
nfue ed
t s s e t
n hi our' nd fcm t ha t s
' ha
t

d s t' He e ho ve, heI e v n s i e e ti no c dn e to t ou c oft s
ipu e). r , we r t ntr e or'ntr s s t on g n n he tome hi
M ga i a t y ha nots n t tt y ha a sgnikantypr ec a ei e e t
ton, nd he ve
how ha he ve i f
l ot t bl nt r s .

The I e ve sas have notde ons r t d t tzsa
nt z nor lo
m
ta e hat li céon m a pr céc ly i paroê
y a al m i
i pe t i ale d i e es i tlsi ot aéon.
m de her lge nt r t n li nf m
The c thasi plm e e ptva y
our
m e nt d i c
pr e éonsf t dicos esm a t dat i tlsac
ot c
or he s l ur
de o e n li éon.
Thecolr f t rnot st
zt uthe
e hat
N e ' r nta f m e ci s whih m a i l t I e ve s ha waved t i
xus cur e nd or r lent , c
y ncude he nt r nor , ve i
he.
r
prva y rght t atlas s eoft i or aton hel i N e 'books r or a
i c i s o e t om
he nf m i
d n xus
, ec ds nd

ac ount . e m pl t G PS Addendum t t Conta f I m i a
c
s For xa e, he
o he
r ct or m gr don Bond

Se k éz ton a I m niyAgt e ent s a es <Iunde sand t ti ot a pt ded t
cui a i nd nde t
e m z tt :T
tt
ha nf m éon ovi o
Li eby N exusi lke s pr de t t lc ns d s et who posst bond i t
br
s i wie ovi d o he i e e ur y
t he
n he
rs
e ponde ' c e. ECF N o.13- a 22.
nts as '
:
2, t
Addi
donal a not d a
l s e bove t I e ve s i ez t w oul notbei par
y,
, he nt r nor ' nt ess
d
m ied

be us t y ha t oppot uniy t ldga ewhe he t i pzvac i e e t a tvi a e i
ca e he ve he
t t oi t
t r he r i y nt z s s r olt d n
a he a
not r céon. s pa a e a
A e t t céon r ar ng t eprvac i e e t i f tm or a opda e
eg di hes i y nt t s s s a
e ppr
t
t n def ndi a i tabr c ofconta a ton i wlih t I e ve sa enet ra
ha
e ng gans
ea h
r ct c i n zc he nt r nor r ihe
sgnat y t t c r c noral d t bei br a h ofs i conta . li a ey,t
i or o he ont a t
lege o
n ec
ad
r ct U tm t l he
I e enor ofe no m or t n c l or ale éonsast ho t ri e e tw oul be
ntw
s fr
e ha oncus y lga
o w hei nt r s
d

i ie b t sbrahofc nta tadon. e Li o , 0 W L 4 9 2 , t* rf and f
mpatd y hi e c
o rc c S e nk us 2 11
8 4 33 a 2 pli f
woul notc ngeasar s toftlsca e W hie i ha s le consde a ei des tbi is
d
ha
e ul li s . l t s pild
i r bl nk c i ng t
i e e t St t Fa m hasnotm a a sngl nonnt r s, a e t
de i e
concus y a gum e a t why t i e e t
l or t
nt s o
hat nt r s

woud bei ie ori e e wiho ti e v n ' f s n r : o a tVitm As es
l mpar d mp d d t u ntr e don. s I e Holc us c i s t
); f

Lt .22 F.d 1 ,1 9(dCi. 00 )( hodn csrc c u tsd rilofitr e do a o
-V , 5 3 91 9 2 r2 0 up lig l tit o z' el
i
a ne v n n s f
dghte n whe epz edi e ve sf d fcema sgni ntobsaces'wihout
ve
r opos ntr nor ç
woul a
ny i fqa
tl' t

i e v néo )
ntr e n .
Pe ha m os i
r ps
t mpor a l,t I e ve sha nots
t nty he ntl nor ve
hown t tN e m a
ha xus y
i
nadequa ey r pr entt i i e e t .
t l e es her nt r s s The I e ve sf ed nots
nt r nor f
ne
how t tt
ha he
r pr s nt
e e e adon by e s i par swilde t l bei
xitng de l fniey
nadequat,'s I I v.
e' ee LS. nc. Pub.Se .
rv

Comm' o W . ri i, 21F. x2 6 28 ( h Ci. 0 ) a t eb d n ofs wi g
n f Vi n a 3
App' 8 , 9 4t r 2 09, nd h ur e
ho n
i dequac oft pr e a i i nnni a.SeeTr c v.U nie M i W or r ofAm .40
na
y e es nt ton s i m l
bovi h
t d ne
ke s
, 4
2'hepa te di notr fr nc ti f i t bresng, t co ttke nodceofi a N e fldt f m a a
F ' ris d
ee e e l s o= n he i
z
but he ur a s
t s xus te he or s n

ehbtt is moa dl o 1w i o p sd nt t mo o frp ei n r i u c n
x ii o tme rn l fa n p o io o he d n o rl ay t n do .
m
mi j

U..5 , 3 n.0(9 2. we e,heI ev no sha n s wnt a t rprsna
S 28 5 8 1 1 7 ) Ho v rt ntr e r ve ot ho h t he e ee tdon
hasbe i qua ei a wa t dat a t i c
en nade t n ny y o e, nd her once nsa
r bouti de t t pr ent
na qua e e es adon

m ovi f wa d ar s uldve.N e and t l e ve ss e t s m er le of
ng or t e pec a
xus
he nt r nor e k he a ei f
pr vendng t dicos eoft ci nt'i ot a
e
he s l ut
he le s nf m don i N e 'books r or and a ount,
n xus
, ec ds
cc
s

a a ncene l i ntc la ft a i def ns . h t I e e sa N e wa t
nd dva
ary de ia fi- tve e es Bot he nt w nor nd xus nt o
m
pr ve t dis nadon oft l e e s pe s li ot aton dudng a afe t s
e nt he s emi
he nt rv nor ' r ona nf m i
nd t z hi

lws i. e s r tesmeo e d rg r igdsl ur ofi o mai i t sado
a utTh y hae h a bjc ve e adn icos e nft ton n hi c n.
f he tepat se ngi ev n h st smeutmaeobe dv a apat t
f n h ry eki ntr e don a he a li t jc e s ry o
W
t s t apr um pton a iest tisi e essa eadequa el r pr ent a i twhi t
he ui, es
i rs ha t ntr t r
t y e es ed, gn ns
ch he
pe
ddone mus dem ons t t a r iyofi e e t c l i ornonf a a e.'Com .ofVa.
r
t
ta e dve st
nt r s , ol on,
us
e s nc '
v.

W ed ho eElc Co .5 2F.d2 4 21 (t Ci. 9 6 (in Or na eContie
s n us e . r , 4 2 1 , 6 4h r 1 7 ) cl g d nc
i
an r
Co . S e Ra Co .47 F.d 8 4 (t Ci. 9 3) Alho g Ne u ' nd t e
v. r nd
, 8 2 4 5h r 1 7 ). t u h x s a h
I e ve s i e essa enotpr iey ai d,ajN e hasfnanc a i e essa t
nt r nor ' nt t t t
ecs l lgne
xus
i i l nt r t nd he

I e v n r ha p i c i ee t, heI e v no sh venotp e e e e i e eofa ve st
ntr e o s ve rva y ntr ss t ntr e r a
r s ntd v d nc
d tiy
ofi e e t c l i otnonf s nc N e ha a es i l de ende t prva rght of
nt r s , oluson,
ea a e. xus s ggr svey f
d he i cy i s
isf v rand c r cint i t sa don. r pr ent éve ofN e i f ctt s i d t tis
t otne
urent le s n hi c
A e es a
xus n a e dfe ha t

c m i entt m nnt i ng t i cint ' i c i es e i lt t i busne sm ode.See
om r
o i nni het le s prva y s s nta o he. i s
r
l ,

qg.Prl l . g Tr ECF No. , t1 0 ( r 2 ,2 1 )(e po i t t eq s n of
. , e. njHt . .
23 a 1 Ap . 7 0 8 r s ndng o h ue do

.

how N e 'busne sm ode woul beafe e by a s e y s rng i or a
xus i s
l
d
f ct d
ur t hm i nf m don f t
or he

pum os ofdetndon,N e 'vi pr i ntofrs m a ge e s aed:f tw oul a ol ey
e
e
xus ce esde
ik na m nt t t f
l
d bs ut l
dest ourbusne sm ode bec us no one pe e c e t usbe a eweunde s a a
t oy
i s
l a e
- opl om o
c us
r t nd nd

8

we s
uppor t m a w ak wih t m .I t y t
t he nd l t he f he houg t ti t y ca et ust r woul be
ht ha f he m o he e
d

as r a ntoft a te wo dj tbet-ean d, on wo dus ou srie'
ho t mou
i nd l y ul us ed tie no e ul e t evc .
me
a
l.
An c nc r t a Ne usma c a g c urei e l s czai a t sj c u e
y o en h t x
y h n e o s s neey pe t t thi un tr .
l ve
Se W e én ho eElc Co .5 2F. a 21 ( igpr pos di e v no ' c c r a ut
e s
us e .
, 4 2d t 6 hndn o e ntr e rs on en bo
s tlm entne
e te
goéa
donsbeng c
i onduc ed i a m a rad r et isi e essasrunf
t n
nne ve s o t nt r t f ounded'
'

wih tt i r ucin ofpr s orig t c c r ) .iVi 'i Ur n l I .
t ou he ntod to
oof upp tn he on en ; - t ra a b m nc v.
ç
l

Mc if, 4:5CV-0 31 2 5WL 61 31 , t* ( D. . t1 , 01 )(The
Aul e No. 1 - 0 0 , 01
f
4 05 a 3 W. Xa Oc. 9 2 5 f
s r pr umpdon a iest tD ef nda sa qua eyr pr s ntt ba i a s i
tong es
rs ha
e nt de t l e e e he sn s ocadons
'
i e e t.Bot ar uli a ey c e ned t tt Cout hol t tt AEA doesnotpr mpt
nt t s s h e tm t l onc r
ha he
t d ha he
ee

Va Cod An j4 .-28 .) Theeas ha n be n a ys g s n ofc l i n bewe n
. e n. 51 3: . r lo s ot e n u ge do
'
ol o t e
us
RT- a N e ,ase dence by t e ensve M ga
I nd xus
vi
d
he xt i
don t da e ornonf as nceby N e .
o t,
e a
xus3
Ba ed on t a gum e and i or a
s
he r
nt
nf m don pr ded by t I e v
ovi
he nt r enot ,N exusca a quat l
s
n de ey

r pr entt i i e ess
e es he. nt r t .
r
The I e ve sf ied t s
nt r nor al o how t t y ha asgnii a l pr e a e i e es i
hat he ve i fc nty ot ctbl ntr t n

t es jc ma troft a do t tt p otci oft si tr s wo d b i ie
h ub e t te he c n, ha he r e ton hi n e e t ul e mpat d
bec us oft ac
a e he don,ort tt t i i e e ti nota qua ey r e e e by N e .Se
ha he hez nt r s s
de t l epr s nt d
xus e

Te e 931 F. a 260-61.The ha notc ri d t i bur n f pur esof
a ,
2d t
y ve
a re he. de or pos
r
de ons r éng t i tghtt i e e i t sa éon.
m
ta
he r i o nt w ne n hi c

3A d donal a t h nota e s by t pa e ,t I e v nor do notal g t tN e wilprortz t i prva y
di l lhoug
y,
ddr s ed he rd s he nt r e s
le e ha xus l i iie her i c
i e essls tz n ot rci s i o m a
nt r t e s la he l ' nf r don,nordoe t r or s e ts h ac m .Cf Unie G ua . i nta
ent
s he ec d ugg s uc once
. td
r Resde il

I sCo. Iwav. hld lhaSv. n S c, 1 F.d4 3 4 6(t Ci. 9 - (tdn ttteddn ta e u tl
n . ofo
P i e i a Fu d o .8 9 2 7 , 7 41 r1 88 fzig rse i o d q aey
a
1
t
z
r pr e pr e i e ve ' i e e t be a eft Ba he eha a br de i e e ti pr e tng a loft c ri t
e es nt opos d nt z nors nt r s s c us f
he nk r s oa r nt r s n ot c i l he e tfcae

h lesta d e Phld lhasn ro rteetnp oet giso mo ta ecziiae'.
od r h n o s i ep i' arwe itrsi r tci t wn rgg etf ts)
a
z
n
c
9

B.

Un rRue2 $) t c ut ma pemii eve onTlj tmeymodo ' ya y
de l 4 ,he o t y t tntt nd f n i l
o
n'b n one
who f a cqm otde ens t ts t wil t m an a i a c
f
has li
f e ha ha es ta he i cton omm on ques oflw ot
don a

fc. Fe R. v. 2 q 11)I d tv i n wheh rt pe ii ev ndo t c u t
a t' d. Ci P. 4 $() .n ee nig te o = tntr e n,he o r
'
mus f on ie wheh tt i ev ndo wi u ul dea orprjdiet a udcto of
tf sd t te he ntr e n t nd y ly eu c he dj iain
c
l
t o iia p r s rg s'Fe Ci P. 49 3. , eemo nt se pemiso t
he rgn l ade'iht. d. v. 2 $()Thuswh r va s e k r sin o
'
i e v n und tRue2 ,he mus etbl he c o t flo n ee n s ()ta t i
ntr e e e l 4@ t y t sa i a h f he olwig lme t:1 h t her
s
moto i H l;()t tt i cnmso dee e ha eaq e éon oflw o f c i c mmo
i n s mey 2 ha her li r f ns s v u s
a r atn o n
wih t man a do a ()t ti eve nwi n t s t nund dea orpr j iet
t he i c n; nd 3 ha ntt néo l ot e uli ue ly
l
eudc o
t e si pa e .SeeW r htv.its I em eD ou hnut l . 231 F. D .475,
he xitng o s
i
I i e
s nc,
R.
479

( . N. 20 5 .
M D. C. 0 )
Ase ane pr vi l t I e v ss ds yt tm elnes r r e .H owe ,
xpl i d e ousy, he nt r enot a f he i i s equiem nt
ver
ba e on t pa r pr s nt d,t l e ve sdo notha acli ordef ns t ts e a
sd
he pe s e e e he nt r nor
ve om
e e ha har s
ques
don oflw orf ctwi. t sac
a
a
t hi don.The l e v
h
nt r enor ac
s knowldge t tt y do not
e
ha he

a v n ene cam s butfntnd t d rc l op eg Lls r q ssf rr l f . . ECF No.
d a c w li , f e o ie t pos l 'l e ue t o ei . .'
i
y
h
e
'
8,a 11.The e def ns i udechale ng t e or a lt and i e pr t don oft
t
s
e es ncl
l ngi he nf ce biiy
nt r e a
he

I m niyAgr m ent and r li on t e t bl def ns sofunc e n ha , ave ,a
nde t
ee
,
ey ng
he quia e e e
l a nds w i r nd
esoppe .
t
l ECF N o.8,a 11 2.
t -1 The l e ve sdo notcnm t be t t pa t be hc a i
nt r nor
li o
hid- ry ne i tes
oft I m riyAgr e e a do notpr s nta ce at e ast how a t t pa t
he nde lt
e m nt nd
ee
lar gam nt o
hid- ry
coul c le a prva e c r t M or ove ,aloft s def ns a e onesa
d halnge i t ontac .
e r l he e e es z
dvance by
d
N e and a e nots c f t t I e e s I i uncla how t I er enor s t
xus
r
pe ik o he nt rv nor . t s
er
he nt v
s ubsandvey
l
c d a t t c egi n t a nc m e oft s m e def ns sa N e 'ac and
oul dd o he as ve he dva e nt he a
e e nd xus dve

1
0

ze l pur ui ofs e r ng isbooks r or a a ount i t sa
aous s t af gua di t
, ec ds nd cc
s n hi cdon.Cf
.

W e % ho eElc Co .5 F.d a 21 (xhetilc r,d l e wih a déona b if
s
us e . r , 42 2 t 7 f ' ra ou t eug d t d i l ze s
f
a pl di ,
nd ea ngs woul bept ded wih no ne viwpoi sa ltl i any ibl i don t t
d
ovi
t
w e
nt nd ite f
l m na
o he

o ii l s ng ous c rcsdiputs'
rgna We d h e onta t s e .
).

Thel tr e o sma ha ea e uia l ptv c i eetnt hkhl pes na
ne v n r y v n q tbe ia y ntrs i he y ro l
i oma ns e tt t l e t Ag eme . we t assi wh te cutnta
nfr do ubjc o he nd mniy te ntHo ve, se sng eh t t e nd
f m e c int ofN e m a ha s e e t bl prvac i e e ti t i or a
or r le s
xus y ve om quia e i y nt r s n he nf m don he d by
l
N e i at m a ka y dif t nti r t n whet rN e orI LIbr c t I m niy
xus s e r bl fe e nquiy ha
he
xus t
ea hed he nde t

Ar ee e .I f t de ng i e ve
m nt n ac , nyi nt r ndon i unlkey t l a t i
s i l o e d o nconss e r i a i i
i t nt ulngs s t s
conc i bl t tt sc tcoul fnd t I m niyAgr e e e or a ewhieanot
eva e ha hi out
d i he nde t
e m nt nf ce bl
l
her
cout consde st l e ve s i e es i N e 'books r or and a ount wihout
'
t
i r he nt r nor ' nt r t n xus
, ec ds
cc
s t
e n addt s i t valdiy oft a ee e .Cf U . e r l M iesoneTa ant
ve
e sng he i t
he gr m nt . S. x e. l t
r ,

Lt /l i a O r m entlI on W or .l .v. d.I .Co. 815 F.Supp. 36,39
f d ghlnd na
a r
ks nc Fe ns ,
2d

( D. 20 1 rf o n Ve u ei mor E eyt bepr j ie i tlsCo t s talw
D. C. 1 ) Thel i t nt t s e k l o
eudc d f l ur doen' l
i
o
M a ta t i e ve t ha t c lc
nha t n o nt r ne o ve he onfidng c m ss t d outbe a e s tng t m out
bi or e
c us or i he

o a atmec ul la t c l tn t l gsa d wozd c ranl tk mu hmo etme'
ne t i o d' d o onfi ig ' i n t e ti y a e c r i .
e
c un
l
).
The I e ve sm a s r a i e e ti t dicos d i or adon,butt do nots r a
nt r nor
y ha e n nt t s n he s l e nf m
hey
ha e
c m on que don of1w orf ctwih t br ac ofc r c att hea toft sa
om
s
a
a
t he e h
ont a t he t
hi cdon.
The I e ve s lc ofcea def e a nonpa te t t l m niyAg ee ent
nt r nor ' a k
l r ens s s
r is o he nde t t m

as rs sund l dea i t sa ton a prj ii gRT, Th I tr e r ' r pos d
lo ik uy lyng hi ci nd eud cn I e n e v no s p o e
.
def ns sove lp wih N e ,butt y ha no cea sa i t I m niyAgr m e a
e e
ra t
xus
he ve
l r t ke n he nde t
ee nt nd
t t I ev
hus he nt r enor 'a oa h i r l dif r f om N e .Cf Unie St t sv.St e, o.
s ppr c nhe enty f e s r
xus . t d a e
at N

11

11 CV4 5 2 1 W L 3 2 3 6, t* ( D. C.u 2 , 01 )(%e a et pt e
:6 2 , 0 6
6 6 8 a 3 M. N. J ne 9 2 6 f cus he oposd
i e ve s de e esa count r bi sl gey ove lp w11 t l ga a f c a i s st
nt r not ' f ns nd
e c m ar l
ra t1 he e l nd a m l s ue hat
.

a eale pr s nii t m an a i t a don oft s pa de i notlkey t
r r ady e e n he i cton, he ddi
he e r s s
i l o
sgnika l com plc et pr eelngsorundul e nd t s
i f nty
iat he oc ci
y xpa he cope ofa dic r iltzs
ny s ove y t li

c s . Dee i n wh t tt l tr e r ha sa i t puru t s dee e a d t e
a e' t= nig ehe he n e v no s ve tndng o s e he e f ns s n h
).
ne e s tl d fee tma e i wlc t yp s t s dee e (st ydi notsg t
c sni ifr n nn r n l h he urue he e f ns s a he d
y
i
in he
c ta t wi sg f n l c mpiaet pr c eln s Theel eywo dne d t be
on r c) l ini ty o l t he o e cig . r i l ul e o
l ka
c
k
dic r t detrni whe he t I e enor ha sandi i t sa don a t what
s ove y o e r ne
t r he nt w
s ve t ng n hi c
nd o
de e t y ha a i e es i t e or a lt oft l m niyAgr e e . t r or ,
gt e he ve n ntr t n he nf ce biiy he nde t
e m nt Furhe m e

t pr
he opos d ans e doe notsa e t l e e s z sdenc sa us l vi t c ut
e
w r s
t t he nt w nor ' e i y t t , ea ng he ot

un bl t d t = i wheh rt i a l n wo d d sr yj idc n.
a e o ee ne t e her dcéo ul e to uts ido
i
Uli tl,ntr e nwo l p eudc RTIb r qx igi t d fndtlsa don o
t ey i e v néo u d r j ie , y e li n t o e e li c
ma
t
n
m t pl f ont and undoubt y de a and com plc t t sa
o er s
edl ly
ia e hi cdon t ough e nded
ht
xpa

d s o e ya a i a p era mo . c ur w.l talw t tt h ppe Thi c s
ic v r né dddon l r til dons The o t i no l ha o a n. s a e
l
o
at a hasbe r m a ka y c plx w1. a numbe ofhe rngsf t pr lm i r
le dy
en e r bl om e t1
1
r
ai
or he ei na y

ijncin,h a i e ofas ca matr a no amod frasc ndprl n r
nu to te ppon% nt
peil se, nd w
on o e o ei ay
mi
i éo I t el tr e r wa t c aln et erprv c i e e t i t i o ma n
t
junc n. f h n e v no s nt o h le g h i ia y ntt ss n he nf r do
cove e by t l m riyAgr e e ,t y m a s pa a ey pur uea c e a i tRLIor
rd
he nde lt
e m nt he
y e r tl
s
as gans
N e . lsa
xus Tli cdon r m ansadiput be ee t t pa te t sgne t I m niy
e i
s e > n he wo ri s hat i d he nde t

A g e e a wilbelm ied t abr a h ofc r ta i
r em nt nd l i t o
ec
ontac cton.
Thecot r c ze t tfl r li e ve
ut e ogni s ha fi a nt r néon i de ia e t dipos ofa m uc ofa
be
s sr bl o s e s
h
contove s i vi a m a a r nty c e ne pe s asi c pa ewih e hc e y
r ry nvol ng s ny ppa e l onc t d r ons s om dbl t f i nc

12

a dd pr e s'Felrv. oc 8 2F.d7 2, 29(t Ci.1 8 )( en lq tdo
n ue oc s. le Br k, 0 2 2 7 4h r 9 6 i r a uoa n
;
nt
ma k o te ) Ho ve, r t itr e
r s mit d . we r pemi n e v ndoni t i a éo o ywoud tc o a i ay
dng
n l s c n nl l a k n ncl t
a
l
is a ii fom N e 'busne spr céce i r l don t t I m niy Agr m e .
s ues rsng r
xus i s a s n e a
o he nde t
ee nt
l e vendon i notc pai ewih ef inc a duepr es i t sa
ntr
s
om tbl t fce y nd
oc s n hi cdon. c di y;
A cor ngl
t cour wilal nott I e e st pe mi sveyi e ve i t sa don unde Fe r l
he
t l low
he ntw nor o r s i l nt r ne n hi c
r de a

Rul o Ci l o e ue2 $. t I e n r' t t i ev newi bed ne ,her
e f viPr c dt 44 As he ntwe o s mo bn o ntr e l e id t i
l
m oéon f D alsS. pir et a a pr hacvi on t i be l i t sa
or la Le e r o ppe r o
ce
he r haf n hi cdon i now
s
m oot ECF N o.10.
.
I .
V
Fort s r as ,t c twilD EN Y t l e ve s m oton t i e ve a
he e e ons he our l
he nt r nor ' i o nt r ne s

d fn nt ( No. )a dmod frDalsS Le er t a pe tpr ha vie( No.
ee da s ECF
8 n
on o la . pire o p a o c c ECF
1)
0.
An a opdat O z rwilbee e ed.
ppr
e de l
nt r

&i

Enee: /
trd

.f
Ja

f

@

:

)-$
.t
.#
ï'
1
$

'

'

.,
kf
$

-

z* .'..z ,
f ''' ,
' t
'

,

.. .
; ,

ysj!jj. . . ..
. ; ys, ç . .
.
s
,

' '
'

-

.
.
J

M - . e1F. r a ki
i a
c
cs
.

C ,e Unie S ae Dit t u e
f td tt s sdc l dg

1
3

t

:'
-