RLI Insurance Company v. Nexus Services, Inc.

Filing 388

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 2/10/2020. (jv)

E U S D S CX RT
X

cec vckux,
um soyc kk
'w
R
Al
uEo

FEB 1 1 2 2
20
I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STRICT CO U RT J
UL
FO R/ E W E STERN D ISTW CT O F W R GI I V)
TH
N Aa
H ARRI
SON BU R G D I SI N
W O

DUDL CLERK
EK

E

RLII SU RAN CE CO M PAN Y,
N
Pl nt f y
ai i f

Ci lActon N o.5:8- vvi
i
1 c 66
V.

N EM J SE RW CE S,I C.et a1y
S
N
. .
D ef
endant
.

By: M i haelF.U r
c
bansd
l

Chi fUnie S a e Diti t udge
e
t d t t s src J

M EM O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O

Thi mattc me beo et c u ton Plitf RT1l u a eCompa ysrRTI'
s te o s fz he o r
anif , ns tnc
n ' f ,'
)
obetons ECF No.3 6 t Ultd Sae Ma itaeJ g J lC.Ho ' No e r1
jci ,
3 ,o
e tts gsrt ud e oe
ppes v mbe 3
dic veyode rric veyo de' ECFNo. 1 , swel sDee da sNe usS r ie,n .
so r t t dso r r r),
3 7 a la fn nt x evc sI c,
Lir by Ne us I c,a Ho sb Ne us l . tNe us' o e to ,ECF No 3 5
be
x , n . nd me y x , nc' f x ' bjcins
sf
l
. 3,
br
oughtpt ua t Rul 72 oft Fe r lRul ofCi lPr edur Thi dicove y diput
us nt o
e
he de a
es
vi oc
e. s s
r s e
ats fom va i dicover m otons fl by I I and N e
i es r
tous s
y
i
led
Uw
xus t com pe pr
o
l oduc i of
ton

d l nt a r s ns st i trog t re . l wi g aNo e e 1 ,2 9 he rng J g
ocl s nd e po e o n e r ao is Fol n
me
o
v mb r 7 01 ai , ud e
H oppe e e e t dicove y or raddt s i t e m otons t wlih RT, a N e now
nt r d he s r de
e sng hes
i , o lc
I nd xus

z ie t i o e do . Ne us r ie t e obq do : () Budd US, LLC' (%udI'
as he. bjc ns x as s ht e jc ns 1
r
i
S < c'
il
pt d donoft fa t t 'o GPSi o mai ofe c o RT1sbo dprncpas ()t
o uc
he f s pi ' r
l w
nf r ton, a h f , nde i i l;2 he
'
pr d don ofaprv lg l g a ()t pr uci ofals ofalprvaea d pu i o n
o uc
iie e o ; nd 3 he od ton
it l i t n bl pe
c
i skai nsori qxte ofNe u f v oai oflwsorr gua inssnc 2 6 a wel s
t t to
we
t liis
a
x s ot i ltons a
e lto i e 01 , s la

com m uni donswih t e i s i i a i s a a publc or non- i flmgs RT.
ca
t hos nve tgatng genc e nd ny
i
publc ii . I
z que t a m odi aton oft dicove y or t z quie N e t ha ove ali or aton
e ss
fc i
he s r der o e r xus o nd r l nf m i

fo t Ca s ed tb s a o e t t ( n r l t t udp e ldeo u ul dea RJ1
r m he p ul aa ae nd bjcs o f y ui ha wo l rcu r nd y ly ,
a
ng
f om obt i ng Ca ul da a e i ot a i z ga di alofRI,' bond plncpas a al
t
ani
ps e tbas nf m ton e r ng l
Is
i i l nd l
l a i i or a
oc ton nf m don f al RT, bonde prncpas s h as t t a ki i or a i
or l
I
d i i l, uc
he t c ng nf m ton

manti d b Bud ' (mp ssr mo d . No 3 a 3.
i ane y di e ha i e ve ) ECF . 36 t
'
The c tdipe e wih oz la gu e be aus t f c s and l ga c e
our s ns s t a t m nt c e he a t
e l ont ndons ar
e
adequat l pr e ed i t m a e l be or t c t and a gu ent woul not ai t
ey es nt n he t da s f e he ouz
r m
d
d he
decsona pr es .
ii l oc s

Bohpnf saktl c t t o runpo to of u eHo 'dic veyo d tRul
t ri s li out o vet r rins l dg ppes so r r e. e
e
s
7 () o t e Fe rlRuls o Cii Pr c d e pev is a pa t t s atob e tons t a
2 a f h dea e f vl o e ut fnt
ty o ubn i jci o

ma itaej g 'rzigo no dipostvematr,s ha dic veyor es Fe R. v.
gsrt ud es t n n n- s ii tes uc s so r d r. d. Ci P.
l

7 a;se2 U.. j6 $)1( . anondipostv matr t rve ofamaitae
2() e 8 SC. 36 ()A) As
- s iie te, he e iw
gsrt
'

1 ' dic r or i gove ned by t Tcea l e z ous'or fc r r t lw' s a r
udges s ove y der s
r
he fl ty r one ' font a y o a ' t nda d

ofrve I Onyi ama itaejd esd cso i f lal er ou orc ntayt lw'
e iw. d. l f gsrt u g ' eiin s f e r rone s o tr o a '
c y
ma aditit ontud emodf o staiea ypo do oft deii L. c ut'Tt ig
y szc c ltj g
'
iy r e sd n r n he cson.d A o tsfndn
f
i Tlatye r ous whe at
s ce l r one ' n lhough t r i e dencet s
he e s vi
o uppor i, her viwi c zton t
t t t e e ng olr
he
e ie e de e i l t wih t de t a 61 c
ntr vi nc s ef t he fnie nd . onvi ton t t a mi t ke has be n
.
m
c i ha
sa
e

c
ommitd. Unie S ae v.Unie S ae G s' Co.3 U..3 4 3 ( 9 ) s e as
te ' td tt s
'
td tts
t
t
m , 33 S 6 , 95 1 489 e lo
Hl ma v. v n 7 2F. 1 5 , 5 (t Ci. 9 5 .f e tonsoflw, n t ot e ha ,
r n Le i , 7 2d 1 0 11 2 4 h r 1 8 ) f si
ou
a o he h r nd
ar r vi we unde t c r t t lw sanda d,whih i e s ntal s
e e e d
t he ont ap o-a t r
c s s e i l ynony ous wih de
y
m
t

n vorvim 'Hars v.S n h n 2 9WL 2 6 4a * ( D. . y2 ,2 9.fn
o e e ' rion ha a a , 01
21 47 t 4 E. Va Ma 2 01) ç
l
l toft b oa dsrtongv n t amaitaej g ilt r slto ofnon s ii
i
gh he r d icei ie o
gsrt ud e r he eouin
dipost
ve
dic eydiputs t c r s l onyo rueama itaejdg ' d tr n t i t s
sov r s e, he ou t houd l ver l
gsrt u es eemiai f hi
on
diceini a usd'S o v. t, 01 W L 5 6 56 ,* ( D. . . c 6 201)(iig
sr to s b e . ho
'
Hot2 0
0 7 7 2 N. W Va De. , 0 ctn
Dee do S s I c v. t v Co .9 F. D. 5 1 4( D. Y.1 8 :. ftz c ur f
tc n . n . Pih a
, 6 R. 1 2, 5 W. N. 9 2 I ls o ti
i
nds
t tJ g Ho ' ml n swee cezy e r o o c nta yt lw,i wils ta i t e
ha ud e ppes l g r lal rone us r o rr o a t l e sde hos
i

txng .ns d tr nig t c utwi a rs ec o e to i tln.
nl sl o eemi n ,he o ' l dd es a h bjcin n l
i
t l
r
I
I.

J dg Hop ' ds o r o d rr q ii gBu di o pt uc f li or to a utt e
u e pes ic ve y t e e u tn d t od e f lnf mai n bo h
a
ope a i oft bond pr r m wih N e orLi e a w elast Ta tpi ofea h ofRT,'
r ton he
og a
t
xus
br s l he l s ng'
c
Is

bonde prncpas i l lng t l s z cor tm e dat ,a l aton,' snotconta y t lw .
d i i l,ncuci he a t e ded i , e nd oc i ' i
rr o a
ECF N o.335 at2.N e a gu t t r quesed l aton dat T snet rt lva t RT,'
xus t es hat he e
t oc i
a f ihe ee nt o Is
i

cnm snori por a t z s vi t is i t c s y't ef enotdic r bl ECF N o.
li
m
t nt o e ol ng he s ues n he a e' her or
s ove a e.

3 5 a 4 Fe rlRueofCi. Pr e u e26 ()pe isdic veyoff n no rvlg d
3 t . dea l
vi oc d t $)1 = t so r f y np iie e
l
a
matrta i rlva t a ypat csm ord fns a pr po éo lt t ne dso t
te h t s ee nt o n rfs li
ee e nd o r na o he e f he

c s. Fe .R.Ci P.2 9 1.dfheo etn pat crist b de ofprvngta t
ae' d
'
v. 6 $() f' bjcig ry are he ur n
e
o i h t he
chal nged dic r pr
le
s ove y oducton s d notbe pe mit ' Ca ia O ne Ba N . .v.H e s
i houl
r ted.'
tl
nk A
s

Ke e Chatrd LLC,No.30 c 4 ,2 8U..DitLEXI 7 38 ,a * 5 ( D.Va
nn d
ree
:8 v1 7 00 S s.
S 6 5 t 4- E.
.

S p . 0 2 0 ) Ne usagt st ttelc ofrlva c u zRul 26 $()ma e l ai
e t 3 , 0 8. x r z ha h ak ee n e nde e 9 1 k s octon
e
i or a i undic r bl asaque ton oflw,t ber viwed denovo.
nf m ton
s ove a e
si
a o
e e
N e cont ndst t physca l ton ofbonde prncpa si notr lva t t
xus
e
hat he
i l oca i
d i i l s
ee nt o he
r s udon ofax ea h ofconta cli .N e as tas c xtt lm i t s fndi a t
e ol
br c
r ct l m
xus ks li olt o i t hi i ng nd he

s
copeoft dic r ot rt l aton i or aton t doesnoti l abonde prncpa'
he s ove y de o oc i nf m i hat
nc ude
d i i ls
c r l aton,e ai ng t d oc ton i ot a i ca m e n s ve a dif r nt t ngs'
urent oc i
xpl ni hat ç a i nf m ton n a e r l fe e bi .'
l

ECF N o.335 a 5.I
t ndee a t N ove be he i N e s a e t ti ca z er t a
d, t he
m z nrng, xus t t d ha t n ef . o n
i vi lsaddr s whi h i i t Ca ul da abas oz i ca m ea G PS c di t s f
ndi dua '
es , c s n he ps e t e, t n
n
oor na e or
whe e a i vi l was on a pa tc a dat a tm e.ECF N o.318, Hrg Tr 47: 9.
t n ndi dua
t iulr e nd i
' . 5-

S cfcl ,Ne u obe t t RTIsrg tt obnn mos c rntl ai d t,o telts
peiial x s jcs o - ih o ti
y
'
t ure octon aa r h aet
G PS coorlnaess i by t r a -i tac ng s t m us d by Budci ECF N o.335 a 5ci t ubnnt he e ltme r ki yse
e
l.
t 6.

Fis,N e s s s t t RT, does not ne t know cur e l ton of bonde
r t xus ugge t ha
I
ed o
r nt oca i
d

plncpast a s swhet rNe ha br c d t contac. daa 4.Se ond,Nexusagtes
i i l o ses
he xus s ea he he
r tL t
c
rz
t tt t e entt tRT, ne t c
ha o he xt ha I eds o onduc a ds as es m e ofisexpos e i or a i
t
k s s nt t
ur , nf m ton

obti d unde t dicovey or rfom t Ca ul daa e s d s fce J a 5.Thi
ane
r he s r de r he ps e tbas houl ufi . . t
i
s
dat woul i l t org na addr s of a bonde ptncpa, a a es c nges a
a
d ncude he ii l
es
d i i l ny ddz s ha , nd

lit ialGPS coot nae .J. The c ux ofis agu e i t tRT, ca c
lsotc
di ts -a
t
l
t
t t m nt s ha I n onductisds
t k
as es m e wihout l r ng t m os r ce l ton of bonde ptncpas Thid,N e
s s nt t
ea ni he
t e nt oca i
d i i l. r
xus
dr ws a t nton t t conc r t tequi d wih t m os r e l a
a te i o he
e n ha
ppe t he
t ec nt oc don da a ofbonde
t
d
i m i ant ,RT, wils ek t natga e is la lt by t ni ove t ti or a
m gt s
I l e o ii t t ibiiy
ut ng
r ha nf m don t D H S
o
r t rt n rs l s I a 4.
a he ha ik os . d. t
H owe r N e e r i confa i r l va unde Rul 26wih i or a i s nstviy
ve , xus r s n
ltng e e nce
r e
t nf m ton e ii t

warndn ap o eév o d r Rul 2 $)1 i b o dya lcbl,a mo tzc n lc to
ta g r tc e r e. e 6 () s r a l ppia e nd s e e t o ain
i ot a i f i m i ant f lswili is n bi.I is O c obe 2,2019 hea i t cout
nf m ton ot m gr s al tzn t m t n t
t r
rng, he
'
t

hel t t fali ot a i r l t d t t bond pHncpa s i l ng l ton i or a i i
d ha fl nf m ton e a e o he
i l, ncudi ocaj nf m ton, s

rlva ,sdic v rbl,s jc t apr tci o d z'ECFNo. 8 ,HtgTr 8 : 7J g
ee nti so ea e ubet o oe t r e.
ve
:
2 8 ' . 02-.ud e
'
4

H oppei
ndepende l hed t s m e att N ove be 6 he i <1t nk t z nee t be
nty l he a , he
m r
atng; r hi he e ds o
s e da a 1t nk i' dicove a e t ha s e dat a
om
t . bi ts s r bl o ve om
a boutwhe e t e pdncpas a e,not
r hes
i l r

j taph c lt a e o e o s tigsyn i tlspes n s wig u f wo k'
us
one al o n mply r r omehn aig s li ro ho n p ot r .
'
ECF N o.318,Ii g Tr 83:- RTIa gue t tbot t fls pi 'f bonded prncpa sa
r' . 1 4. - r s ha
h he Ta t ng' or
i i l s
w elast l ton i or a i fom Ca ul i r lva t t i rs a s s ent ba e on
l he oca i nf m ton r
ps e s ee nt o her ik s es m , s d

t i rv e o t i iils mpl g o d t d byJ g Hop , c us Ne usfsno ta kn
het e iw f he nta n i r e e
n
ud e pe be a e x f t rc ig
i
a oxi at l hfy pe ce ofbonded prncpa s butr t rm aki unia e a de e i tons
ppr m ey t r nt
i i l,
a he
ng lt r l t - na i
t no l zm otiorbonde prncpas duet i tra .,sa ed T l a t i n' pos s'ECF
o onge
lt
d i i l,
o ne na t t htm niata pur e .'

No. 36a 3. e lma y t si r a e RTIsts e pos e J g Ho a c ran dt ti
3 t Pr sn bl,hi nce s s ,' ik x ur . ud e ppe s e tie ha t
i r lvantt RTIsrs e
s ee
o ,' ik xposue t a ce t n whe he bonde prncpas a e beng ta d,
t o s rai
t r
d i i l t i r cke
and i t y at beng tac d,whe e t y a e a i t y a e i com pha e wih t t r sof
f he e i t ke
t he r nd f he r n
nc t he e m

t i bo , i nt lkhr t ofb e c dbo . c ur a re .
het nd gve he z ae ra he ndsThe o t g e s
Fi ly,whie t c ztr m ans c
nal
l he olr e i once ne a
t d boutunne s arl e i t bonde
ce s iy xposng he
d
prncpas t t unwa r nt d rs of de t don, t s nstviy of i or a i i
i i l o he
r a e ik
pora
he e ii t
nf m ton s
appr i t l addr s e by a pr ec or t ECF N o.288,H-' Tr 80: 7.
opra ey
esd
ot dve de .
tg . 2- The pr e dve
ot c

or rpr vent RTI fom s tng t l a i da ar ga di t bonde prncpgswih ot z
de e s , r
hn i he oc ton t e r ng he
d i i l t he
pa te ,obvitng t sconc n t t e e pos i e.ECF N o.328.
r is
a i hi
et o he xt nt sbl

Ne ussobetonst RTIrciig c re lc to i oma n fo Bu iae
x ' jci o - e evn urnt o ain nfr éo r m dd r
OVE RRULED .
1 1.
1

J dg Ho ' cic ve yo de r q ii g bo. RLIa Ne ust p od c ap iie e
u e ppes l o r r r e u tn t
s
h
nd x o r u e rv lg
1 aongsde alt i or a
og l i l he nf m don and docn e swihi t i c r ,c t
lm nt t n he r a e usody,a c r t
nd ont ol hat

t c utha f
he ot
s ound t be dic r bl i notcontat t lw .
o
s ove a e s
r y o a ECF N o.31 at4. e a gues
7
N xus r

t tRul 2 d sn rq r af ocl ntbyd l nt piie elgt a sr pi lg ;
ha e 6$) oe ot e uie f l - - ocl ' rvlg o o set rvi e
d me
me '
e
howe r a c tm a s ilm a t i i i fndsone ê r d ba e on t t ofpzvie
ve , our y tl nda e t f t
equie s d
he ype
i lge

asre Fe R.Ci P.26 $() To fcltt isd tt nai ofptvlg ,ac t ma
se td. d.
v.
q 1. a i ae t ee- ton
i
mi
iie e out y
r q t f n a q tl d tie prvlg lgi c njnci wihe i n ir s bmisonst f l
e uie f de uaey e ald iie e o n o u ton t v de ta y u si o i
a
l

i a yfc l a . U. v. tucinPz ucsReerh-nc, 3F.d46 ( dCi. 9 6
n n a ma g ps' S. Cùnst to od t sac I .7 3 4 2n r1 9 )
'
( uo ig BowneofNe Yo k Ciy l c v.AmBa e Cor ,1 0 F. D.4 5 4 4 (. N.
q tn
w r t, n .
s p. 5 R. 6 , 7 SD. Y.
1 9 ). p iie lgs ll fd ntf e c do ume a t ei ii uaswhowe epate
9 3) The rvlge o hozd d e iy a h c nt nd h ndv d l
i
r ris

t tec mmu c do ,p o ii s f e d ti t pe i ajd me a t whehe te
o h o nia ns r vdng ufkint eal o = t u g nt s o t r h
docn e i a l s pot ntal pr e t d f om dicos e.'Bowne 150 F. D . a 474
lm nt s t ea t e ily ot c e r
s l ut '
,
R. t

(ia
ctdonso te ) J g Hop d tr ne apiie elgwa n c say a t sc ut
mitd. ud e pe eemi d rvlg o s e e sr, nd hi o t
a e s es c al gi n RI.' c
gz e , pe i ly ve
Is once ns a
r boutove - e c
rr da don ofpr
oduc doc e s ECF
ed
um nt .
N o.336 a 2.
t

Re r e s t cour fndspe s i N e ' ar m entt tac egorc lprvie l
ga dl s , he
ti
ruasve xuss gu
ha at i a i lge og
woul s r t pum os of a s ri prvie a e ai ng r da tonswihouti posng
d e ve he
e
s e tng i lge nd xpl ni e c i
t
m i
undue bur on t po-is gi n t nlm be ofdocx ent pr
den
he t e , ve he x r
f
lm s oduce a dicove a e i
d nd s r bl n

t sc s.
hi ae ECF No 3 ,a 7rf x ha p o c d o e 1 , 0pa e ofdo u nt wih
. 35 t Ne us s r du e v r 0000 g s
c me s t
rdaton rq rdbytl Cou t p e ius uy2 2 8 Or rECF No. 0'.
e ci s e uie
li r' rvo J l , 01 , de,
s
s
67
)
Ne ussobedonta l d Ho 'o de i c ntay t 1w i OVERRULED,
x ' jc h t u ge ppes r r s o rt o a s
but
N exuss r
' eques t m odiy t dic r or r t al f a ca e ialptvie l i
t o
f he s ove y de o low ot
t gotc
i l ge og s
GR AN TED .

W .

Ne usobe t t u eHo 'dic veyo d r aganga c tayt 1w un rRul
x jcs ol dg ppes so r ê e, r i s onrr o a de e
26 $() u eHo ' o de ta t ydsl e
9 1 J dg ppes r r h t he icos:
falprva e a publc ope i tga i ori lre ofN e
tl i t nd
i
n nvesi tons nqlii s
xus
by a r gult y or 1 w e or eme a nc f a vi a i o
ny e a or
a nf c nt ge y or
olton f
f r l sae,o l a lws o r gultons snc 201 Ne s l
ede a , t t r oc l a
r e ai
i e 6. xus hal
f t r pr de c
urhe ovi ommunia i t a fom t i si tng
c tons o nd '
r
he nve tgai
a nc a N e a a publc ornon- i flngs f r t e
ge y nd xus nd ny
i
publc ii
o hos
i si to . The ls of no publc hwesi to a an
nve tgai ns
it
n- i
tgai ns nd y

d cl n s d s ls d ae s b e t t t atme ' e e - ny
o l t ico e r u j c o he to ys y so l
me
pr vii of t f t
o son
he orhcomi pr t c i or r wih t e pton
ng o e tve de , t he xce i

t a RIIma d sg t u t t re ( )c po aer p e e ttv s
h t , y e inae p o h e 3 o rt e rs n ai e ,
wh as wi be s b e tt t e n n ds l s r p o iiùso te
o lo l u j c o h o - ico u e r vso f h
l
f rhc i pr eci or r t r vi w t doc nt . xuss l
o t om ng ot tve de , o e e he ume s Ne
ha l
s i t t Cou t f i c r r vi a c r s
ubm t o he
r or n nme a e ew ny ore ponde
nce
be we n N e a a a nc r ga d ng a i uiy ori tga i
t e
xus nd n ge y e r i n nq r
nvesi ton
i Ne i t ur whehe t i tga i r mai ope ori a
f xus s ms e
t r he nvesi ton e ns n s n

iv siain o a voain o t e 1w a d tus s b e t t
n e tg to f ilto f h a n h u j c o
dic os e.
s l ur '
'

ECF N o. 31 a 57 t 6.Spe ika N e
c f iy, xus clm s t t or r t dicl e non- i
li
hat he de o s os
publc
i e dga
t s dons i pr ry baa es f ee nc , pr
w
m ope l lnc f lva e opori lt , a ot r f t s of Rul
r
tona iy nd he ac or
e

2 $()'Fe .R.Ci P.2 $() I ag e t tf o a e c c n s tdo Ne uswiho
64 1. d
'
v. 69 1. t tu s ha f g n y a hu wn x t ut
n
ma ig a i ska pu i. ECF No.31 ,Hrg Tr 1 01 -2.Theeo e Ne us
kn n t t don bl '
we
c:
8 ' . 6 :1 1
rfr, x
cont ndst ti RT, i usng t si or a i f ds a s s m e pur es t a ce s t
e
ha f I s i hi nf m ton or k- s e s nt pos , hen c s o

pu i ivet to aon s l s hc .ECF No. 8 HrgTt 1 61 -3. we rl g
bl n skains l e houd uf e
c
31 , ' . 5 :2 1 Ho veyud e
H oppe' sa e e sa t N ovem be 1 2019he rng cla l i ca ehi i enton t i l
s t t m nt t he
r 3,
a i e ry ndi t s nt i o ncude

alpublca non- i iw es i snc 2016,i l lng dor a i tga i , a e
l
i nd
publc t dgatons i e
ncuci
m nt nvesi tons bec us
t ewoul ber l va t RT,' a lt t unde sand wha t i rs e
hes
d
e e nt o Is biiy o
rt
t her i k xpos e hasbee snc
ur
n i e
201 w hen tlsc e wasorg nal br
6,
li as
ii l ought ECF N o.318,H rg Tr 167- .H e sa e f t
y
.
' .
72.
t t d: f
l

srke m e as hi y r e nt i N e i beng i dga e t t RT, w oul ne t t
ti s
ghl elva , f xus s i nves t d, ha
l
d ed ha
i or a i t as es is rs ' ECF N o. 318 Ht Tr . 177: 178: The f t t t a
nf m ton o s s t ik.
'
, . s
24- 7.
ac ha n

i s ton hasnotye bee m a publcdoesnoti a w a s ges t tise se e doe
nve dga i
t n de
i
n ny y ug t ha t xit nc
s
nothep RT,i ot t i rs as es m e ofla lt e
l I nf m he r ik s s nt ibiiy xpos e. ndee t f c ofa ongoi
ur I
d, he a t n
ng

ivet ton cn s g s c ensa utNe ussbotm l orcs l hton s pcou o
n skai a ug et oncz bo
x ' to i
ne at i
g
usii s r
rst be a iza lats l e t jsiyt e itn eofa on i ivet to
il h vo te s ufkint o u tf he xse c n gong n skain.
y
I s ppo to t i o e to Ne usctst as c rde c s wh r t c ur hed t a
n u r f he. bjcin, x ie o e u i s ae e e he o t l h t
t

ac mpa y h d f g neaie d f't dsls no p lciv si to .ECF No.3 5
o n a f e rl d ut o ico e n-ubi n e t ins
no
z
ga
3
(iig I r LinsGaeEnt tCo .S c Lii. 1 5 F.S p 3 1 1 -1 ( . N. 20 6 .
ctn n e o
t m'
e. t , 6
u p. d , 2 3 SD. Y. 1 )
Thi e
s xampl i unpe s i f t r as . r t t ca es i l a es e t quesi
es
r uasve or wo e ons Fis , he s pechcal ddr s s he
y
ton
of w he he a c pa i oblga e t dicl e t s t der pr vi
t r
om ny s
i t d o s os o ha ehol s e ous non- i
publc

ivetg to c nd tdb t Seurte a dEx h ng Commiso (EQ u rtefd rl
n siains o uce y he c iis n c a e
sin S
nde h e ea
s uttes lw.I a 1 H e e,w e a e addt s i a quesi of dicove a e i o= a i a
ec ii a d. t 2. r
t
e sng
ton
s
t bl nf
ton s

dcae byRue2 a ac ur o d r no t e itn eofaT neaie duyt dsl e'
ittd
l 6$) nd o t r e, t he xse c
f rl d t o icos'
ge z
unde a ot rbody oflw.Sec
t ny he
a
ond,n Li G a e t dicos econc r d whe he anoni ons t , he s l ur
e ne
t t

pu i ivet to s ul bema ep lcHeet c ur h l ta tei o mai rg r ng
bl n skain ho d
c
d ubi. t,he o t ed h th nfr ton e adi
n - bl iv siai i iso rbl,fu e tt t atz y 'y so yprviinoft
onpu i n e t tons s c vea e f bjc o he tone s ee -nl o so
c
g
s
he
frh o ng p oe t o d r wih t e e i t tRTIma d sg t up t t e ()
o tc mi r tci r e, t he xcpton ha , y einae o hre 3
ve
c m o aer pr s n ai s who as wilbe s bjc t t n d sl u epz v so o t
o rt e ee tt ,
ve
lo l u e t o he on- icos r o iins f he
f t
or hcom i pr e tveor r t r viw doc ent . ' pt ec i or rr m ansi e f t
ng ot c i
de , o e e
um s' rhe ot tve de e i n fec .
'
ECF N o.328.

8

Theeor, x sso e do t J dg Ho ' o de t tt ytr o e alp iae
rf e Ne u ' bjc ns o u e ppes r r ha he un v r l rv t
a non- i i s i tons snc 201 flngs r lt t s i iw e tga i , a
nd
publc nve tga i
i e
6, ti
ea ed o a d t s i tons nd
c m unia i wih t r l vantr gult y bodi si he e O VERRU LE D .
om
c tons t he e e
e a or
e s r by
V.

RTIobet t tedic veyot r cqmi i un rt d t dso eyo de a a
, jcs o h so r de, li ng t desoo he ic v r r r s
pt lm i r tli t tt c tw otl r vii a a lt rda e a t rILIhad t oppo= niy t
ei na y nlng ha he our
zd e st t a e t fe L
he
t o
r vi w t friils m pûng' ofCa ul da a econt ntt tN e wasor r t pr
e e he f lta a
i
'
ps e t bas
e ha xus
de ed o oducel
.

RTIc msi fasta f e u ' Objci sma ece tt tNe usi d t= i d t ino e
, bi t e r h t W x ss e ton k la ha x s ee ne o g r
t sCour' e es rli ' nd s t a dunduedea i dicove y, hecour s
hi
ts xpr s l ng'a o, o voi
l
lys n s r t
t houl m odiy
d
f

t dicove y ot rt r quie N e t pr
he s r de o e r xus o oducea lTca ul da a s i or a i r ga di
l f ps e t ba e nf m ton e z ng
alofRT,' bond prncpa sa all aton i ot ton f a lRT, bonded prnc pal,s
l
Is
i i l nd l oc i nf vna i or l l
i i s uch
ast tac ng i or aton m nnt ned by Budx ' ECF N o.336,a 3.I s
he r ki nf m i
i ai
'
t n uppor ,i a gu
t t r es
t tf e wilflt rdelyispr
ha f xus l lthe a t oduc i ofe t i ta s m plngofCa ul doclm e s
N
ton ven he niil n i
ps e
l nt
t tt Cour ha or t d i t pr
ha he
t s de e t o oduce' I a 3.H owe t i t s e bdefi as s a e
.' d. t
ve , n he am
t lo t t s

t ti T sha a op tz t t r ve l td(l i o êyr d c e )docl n ai fo
ha t f
ha d n poraniy o e iw i e abet vel e a td l tton r m
mi
me
t Ca ul daa s ,rgarlng81ofisbondprncpas'i a 2.Gi t ti s e sNe
he ps e tba e e ci
t
i i ly' d. t
ven ha t e m
xus
haspr de t f nii ls m pM g' puz ua t t dic r or r tasc z ts e no r s
ovi d he f ta a
i
' s nt o he s ove y de , li olr e s
ea on
t s dt si al e nd t s
o o a tc ly xpa
he cope of dic r bl i ot don. The ef e t s cot
s ove a e nf ma
r or , hi
ut

OVERRULESasmoott obe éo t ud eHo esdic veyor e a DEN I Rtls
he jc n ol g pp ' s o r d r nd
ES a'

1J
udgeHo or r dNe t pr
ppe de e xus o oduceCa ul daaba ei onna i f 8lbo dprncpasa a (i tal
ps e t s nf ton or
nde i i l s n Enii
s mplng, ECFNo.31 a 5, c et si onnai hadbee p i y dicos d ar y i t c s ofa he
a i '
'
7, t be aus hi nf ton
n ublcl s l e lead n he oure not r
ltgai ECF N o.336,a 2.
ii ton,
t

r s t m odiyt dic r oz ta tûspoi . pn teswilbe a et r vii t sis
eque t o
f he s ove y de t l
nt The ti l
bl o e st hi s ue

a t i ne the tngi fon of u eHo , e ehewilc i e t e p o rinaiyof
t het x ai n z t J dg ppe wh r
l onsd z h r po to l
t
flt rpt
lrhe oduc i ofCa ul docl e s
ton
ps e lm nt .
An a opra e O RD E R wilbeent r d.
ppz it
l
ee
Ent t d,
ee

/
w/ 4

& 9- # Q &p- #-o

A. F'92
-

v c e . a ki
ha
Ur ns

.

U ' dS ae Ditit ud e
e tt s szc l g