RLI Insurance Company v. Nexus Services, Inc.

Filing 59

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 7/2/18. (kld)

I TH E UN I
N
TED STATESDI
STRI COURT
CT

CL RKSOF I jq D1TGOUR
E ' FCE u u S . T
A RJ .è' V
T f>r)E,A
'7
t

HA RRI ON BURG DI SI
S
VI ON

J g2 2 1
UL
28

FO R TH E W EST ERN D I RI O F VIRGI I
ST CT
N A
1.. I SU M N CE CO M PAN Y,
11N
1

F1E!
t3
.

3 L C.
W
'

', u
Y ck M
.

.

.

EM

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

Ci lActon N o.5: 8- 00066
vi
i
1 CVV.

N EXU S SERVI
CES,I C.
N ,
By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l
D ef
endant
,

Chi fUnie St t sDiti tJ
e
t d a e src udge

V.

J
UAN VALOY, a .
et l,
Inter
venots.

M EM O R AN D U M O PI IO N
N

Thi matri be o et c u to amo in f rp ei nayi jnci fldb
s te s f r he o r n
to o r lni r nu t i y
t
on e
pli if11, l t a c Co n (RI1'. No. . s e sa ot re o cn
antf 1 1 nsz n e mpa y < ,7 ECF
t
t )
4 RLI e k n de nf ri g
pr vii nsofaCo e ca S eyGe rlI e t Ag e me (h K nd mnt
o so
mm ril urt nea nd mniy r e nt t e < e iy
l

Ag e me t' e e e i owih dee d n Ne u S r e , n . < x s> o J n r 2 ,
r e n ' ntr d nt t f n a t x s e dc s I c (f u ' n a uay 0
)
Ne )
2016,s ii ly oblga i N e t pr de RLIa es t N e 'books r or and
pecfcal i tng xus o ovi
cc s o xus
, ec ds
ac
count .
s Them ate ha be n f l bref d,and t c thed a e denta y he rng on
t r s e ul i e
y
he our l n vi ir a i
Aprl27,201 Pe t pa te ' eques,t c thed isor ri a y
i
8. r he ri s t
t he our l t de n be ancet ough M a 1
hr
y 7

t alw f s tlm e ds usins Fol V n c ur- r e e me ito on M a 30a J ne
o l or ete nt ic so . l g o to d r d d ain
o
o
y nd u
1 t c r hedas c e d n ir he rn t s ta a pr p it bondonl ne7 Fo t
, he ou t l e ond vie ta y ai g o e n p o rae
u . r he

r a onssae beo t c r fn t t ()t lw a d f csce ry fvo lllsposto
e s tt d lw,he ou t i ds ha: 1 he a n a t la l a r t a' iin,
and Rl, i lkel t s ee on t m e i sof s e por i ofi sbr c ofcont a a ton;
1 s i y o ucc d
he rt
om
ton t ea h
r ct c i

j
i
e

()RT1i l eyt s frirpaa eh r i t a e eofaprlri rrnu t ()t
2 , s i l o ufc re rbl am n he bsnc
k
eit .ijnci 3 he
r na !
on;
baa c oft e ui e s p t aprlni t i u to a ()ap ei nayij to i
ln e he q t s u pots ei na' njncin; nd 4 r lni r nunci n s
i
t y
t

i t p l i ee t Ac o dngy Rllsmo i f rpr lnia yi u toni GRAN TED
n he ubi ntr s. c r i l, w' ton o ei n r njnci s
c
r
i pa ta d DENI i pa t a Ne u i PRELI I
n r n
ED n r, nd x s s
M NARI ENJ NED fo
LY
OI
rm
t src i Rllsac s t t books r or and a count s ii be ow a i t
e ti tng v' ce s o hc
, ec ds
c
s pecfed l nd n he
ac pa i or .
com nyng der
1.

Thi i a br a ofc r c diput arsng fom an i
s s e ch
onta t s e ii r
ndem niy a ee e be wee
t gr m nt t n

t o c r ai s r ii gi nir t n bon . a uay2 , 01 , , n Il i
v o por t e vcn mt g ai
v
ons
o
ds Onl n r 0 2 6 RLl a lno s
i
c or ton,ent z d i o t I m niy Ag e e a t s et wih N e ,aVig ni
om a i
e e nt he nde t r em nt s he ur y t
xus
ri a
c por i Se Com m e c a Sur y G e r ll
or aton. e
r i l et ne a ndemniyAgê m e ,Ex. t Com pl,ECF
t
ee nt
A o
.
N o.1 TheI m niyAg ee e s r d asc î r ton f RIIsa e m e t is
-2.
nde t r m nt e ve
onsde ai or ,' gr e nt o s ue
i t gr ton bonds whih i ude bondsc
m ni a i
, c ncl d
ondii d upon del r ofa ain,
tone
i y
ve
n le bonds
c
ondii d upon vol a ydepa t e ofai a or rofs t son bondslPur uantt
tone
unt r
r ur
len, nd de
upevii
.
s
o

! 3c oft el e t Ag e me :
() h nd mniy r e nt
U ntlSur ! ha bee f nihed wih concusve e de e ofis
i
etr s n ur s
t
l i vi nc
t
dic r wihout l s fom a Bonds a untl Sur y ha
s ha ge t
os r
ny
, nd
i
et s
bee ot r s f l i m nii ashe eunde pr de Sur t
n he wie ul nde fed
y
r
r ovi d, e y
s l ha t r htofac s t t books r cor and a ount
hal ve he i
ce s o he
e ds
cc
s
.

oft I e t rs f rt pu pos ofe t nn a c yn
he nd mnio t) o he r e xaniig nd op i g
t m . The I e nt rs h r b a t rz t id p ris
he
nd m io t) e e y u ho ie hr a te ,
i udi but not lr t d t depost i of f
ncl ng
inie o
iores
unds of t
he

1 g r fe oRa - a sMacl oRa rzsn h z Cea Au ut Grmao,n Ges nCatoS g d h v
Ed a Alrd mosl mo , rei mie-a c e, sr g so a j a d ro sr e e a a e
k
n
ak dt itze a dee d n s(ltweo s'i ti at n 'h cu t se c t e ftteltre o st a rs
se o nev ne s fn a t çne n r' n hs ci . 'e o r ak d omslo h nevn r o ddes
<
)
o T
whe hera c lc e it d gve c
t
onfi t x se i n ouns lspot nta r l tons i w11 N e us I a e m alt t c t c
e ' e il e a i h p t1 x . n n - i o he our, ouns lf t
.
e or he
I e v nor sat d t tt I e ve si e d t s e a dona cou e a woul c a t c t o s ahe tng
nt r e s t e ha he nt z nor nt nde o e k ddi l ns l nd
d ont ct he our t et ai

o temoint itre .ne nosddn t p era t p ei n r i u t nh aig o Api2 , 0 8o l n
n h to o nevnel twe r i o a p a the rl aynjnci ern s n r 7 2 1 r u e
mi
o
l
7 2 1 . u e e ee a a pern eo b hl o t I e e osatrteh a n o u 7 ECFNo. 7
, 0 8 Co nsl ntrd n p aa c n e af fhe ntnrn r fe h ed g nl ne .
4.

l mn t t) t fr s t S r t a y i o mai r q e t d
nde iors, o u nih o u ey n nf r t e u se
on
by Str t i connec i wih a ta a ton. Sur t m a
ze y n
ton t ny r ns c i
ey
y
f nih a i or a i whi i now ha or m a her fe
ur s ny nf m ton, ch t
s
y
ea t t

a q iec nc r n t I e t rs, o o he pe s ns fr so
c ur o enig he nd mnio t) t t r r o , lm t
enttes f t pur e of pr urng c s e ys p or
ii
or he
pos
oc i
o- ur t hi
r i ur nc or ofa sng s pe s ,ir s or e ii a i
ens a e
dvii uch r ons im , nttes s t
m a dee a opra e.
y m ppr it

ECF No 12, t3 (mphai a de ) lh i 1w g v r t I e t Ag e me t S eis
.- a e
ss d d . lnos a o e ns he nd mniy r e n . e d ,
at3.R1, al ge is ng m or t n 2, bondsi r lanc upon t l m niyAgr m ent
1 le s s ui
e ha 400
n ei e
he nde t
ee
,

wih a las 2, bondst m ati i f c a t tm eoft Aprl27,2018 he rng.
t t e t 197
e ilng n or e t he i
he i
ai
Appr m atl oneye ra t rsgni t l m niyAgr em e ,RI1as d N e f
oxi ey
a fe i ng he nde t
e nt , ke
xus or

ac es t isr or f t ft ttm e Thr
c s o t ec ds or he ts i . ough m uli el t r a e m al,11, r quesc
tpl ete s nd - is 1 1 e t d
m ee i t r viw N e 'r cor ofi m i a i bondsand e es e c e nsa
tngs o e e
xus e ds m gr ton
xpr s d onc r bout

no ie fo De rme toft eTr aur tvr a u f' a u pa td i o c sf rt
tc s r m pat n h e s y < e s r l bo t s ue nv ie o he
bonds O n M a c 1 2017,afe r evi no r s
.
r h 3,
t r ec i ng
e pons t isr or r viw r
e o t ec d e e eques,11,
t11

dem a
nded f lbond dichar e orc lt a put ua t Pa a a 3. oft I m niy
ul
s g
ola et l s nt o t gr ph d he nde t
Agt em e . e s equenty a e t pt dea es t isdocum e sf r viw dutng
e nt N xus ubs
l gr ed o ovi cc s o t
nt ot e e
i
am e tngwih 1 1on M a 26,2017. hieN e pr de s er or ,notalr c ds
ei
t V
y
W l xus ovi d om ec ds
l e ot
w e e pr ded a 1 1cli st ti l c s i inti or a i t cl eiscor es
t ovi
nd V
am ha t a ked ufk e nf m ton o os t
r pondi
ng
bond fl s Thepa tesa i m e on D ec m be 1 2017,a N e i or ed 111t ti
ie .
ti gan t
e r 2,
nd xus nf m
1 . ha t

woul onl pr de a ce st t cot pur ua t a c i ntaiya e m e . ihout
d y ovi c s o e ds s nt o onfde ilt gr e nt W t
wavi isrght,RT, a ee t ne it aconfdentaiyagt e e wih N e . a e
i ng t i s 1 gt d o gota e
i ilt
e m nt t
xus Bec us
t pa tes c d nota e t a s oft r s N e contnue t de ac s .
he r i oul
gr e o et e m , xus
i d o ny ce s
D urng t e ne i i ,t bus nes r l tons p w ot ened.1 1, cl m sN exus
i hes gotatons he i s e a i hi
s
1 -1 ai
.

f ie t cont m por ne l i or t m ofde lngswih D e r m e ofH om elnd
al d o
e
a ousy nf m he
ai
t
pa t nt
a

S c rt (< ' pr v d c ncusv e ie c ofdic r ewih tl sfom bo s o
e u iy i
DHS', o i e o l ie vd n e sha g t ou os r
)
nd , r
c pl v7t1s c fcr que t f i or a i The Tr asm rnotfe 11, ofpa tdue
om y 1. pe ii e s s or nf m ton.
1
e t
ii d 1 1
s

pa m ent a m a m one a y de a wih i e es on out t ndi bonds Alhough t
y
s nd de
t r m nds t nt r t
sa ng
. t
he

patesdiput whehe 1.. s d ha ma t pa ment,RI,pad $83, 14f
ri s e t r 1 1 houl ve de he y
1
s I i
874. or
uns ts id bond cam sbe us N e al ge y f ied t dem onst t t ti ha pad t
a ife
li
ca e xus le dl al o
ta e ha t d i he
cam s 11 1sa est tt s notce ha bee i r a i i fe nc A sar ul oft e
li .1 . t t ha he e i s ve n nc e sng n r que y.
es t hes

Tr as y notc a l e pa ent ,RTIf r t tisr l tons p wih t gove nm e ha
e ur
ies nd at ym s , ea s ha t e a i hi t he
r nt s
bee unde r ne Spe ii al 11 1wor ist tsnzlrde a f pa tduepa m ent wil
n
rni d. c fc ly,1 .
re ha i ia m nds or s
y
s l
c i bas on t hi he -ha e ct d num be ofbondsr ani out t ng,a is
ontnue ed
he g r t n- xpe e
r
em i ng sandi nd t
r put ton wilbe ha m ed be us contnue dei
e ai
l
r
ca e
i d lnquenciscoul ber pored t t
e
d
e t o he

Tr a u yo utmaeyt De rme tof usiesc le to d pa t n . ,i nota r
e s r r li tl he pa t n J t ' olcin e rme t RT1 s wae
c
ofany r r sonsfom t Tr s t da e H owe r Rl, cam st tisc
epe cus i
r
he ea upr o t .
ve , I li ha t once nsa e
r r
bolt r d by t m uli e i si tonsi o N exusby sat a t ne ge r l a by N e '
se e
he
tpl nve tga i nt
t e tor ys ne a, nd
xus

r pa ments
e y
chedul f a he s ey' bondst tr r pa me sof$30, t $35,
e or not r ur t s
ha equie y nt
000 o
000
pe da by c rii d c k.N ex a ke 1 . i i wa i e e t d i e
t y
c tfe hec
us s d 111 f t s ntr s e n ngag ng i a sr lr
i n inia
t pa m entpln,whi h c us R1, t quesi t num be ofisbondsi br c a
e y
a
c a ed 1 o
ton he
r t
n ea h nd
N e 's venc
xus ol y.

N e ,f ispa t c am st ti i wilng t com pl wih t l m niyAgr em e ,
xus or t r, li ha t s li o
y t he nde t
e nt
butne dst pr e t prva y ofisi t g a i ci s N e alo cli st i i
e o otct he i c
t m nir ton lent . xus s am hat t s
fna ily vibl a t tRIIs d notbeconc r
i ncal a e nd ha , houl
e ned,sa i t tisfna a
t tng ha t i ncil
a r ngem e sw ih ot sz e i s a e s a r busnes pr ctc l w , i N e ' e ,ha
ra
nt t her tr te r t nda d
i s a i e. U I n xus vi w
s

be n unr as
e
e onabl i isde andst r viw books r cor a ac
en t m
o e e
, e ds nd count a f c lt r l
s nd or ola e a.

R1Ibou htsl a ans Ne usonAprl1 20 8 sed ij ci rl fs cfc
, r g tt g i t x
i
i 2, 1 ,e lng nun t ei ,peii
ve e
pe f m a e,a br c ofi m niy a e e .ECF N o.1 On t s m e da R11m ove
ê or nc nd ea h nde t gz cm nt
.
he a
y, ,
d

f raprlni r i jnc in on t g ou t tNe u dea td u e t eI de t
o ei na y nu to
t
he r nds ha x s ful nd ê h n mniy
e
Agr m entbyr usng t c pl w'h RT,' r
ee
ef i o om y i
t
Is eques st i pe N e 'booksa r or
t o ns ct xus
nd ec ds

frmo ct nay a.
o r ha er ECF No. . ,camsirpaa l ijr t o g t de il is
4-1 RTI li rc rbe nu y hr u h he na oft
ba gane f c r ct lrghtt i pec docum e s whi pr ve si fom as e sng and
r i d-or onta ua i o ns t
nt, ch e nt t r
s si
pr ec i is fa i tt outt ndi bond la lt ,a t l sofgoodwilt tf l s
ot tng tel gans he sa ng
ibiiy nd he os
l ha olow
f om N e 'c i d f iur t m a tm ey bond pa e s RLInow s ksac es t
r
xus ontnue al e o ke i l
ym nt.
ee
c so
Ne '
xus books r cor a a ount ,a t e ofisr a e e ii ,wihi s ve da .
, e ds nd cc
s nd hos
t elt d nttes t n e n ys RLl
r que t an e e i as orm e ofdoc ent , ncl ng alr cor t a e t t
e ss
xt nsve s t nt
um s i udi l e ds elt d o he
i r gr i bonds fna ilr cor ,t x notc , sorca da aa
m ni aton
, i nca e ds a
ies hit i l t boutbonds a
, nd
i or a i a
nf m ton boutt bonde ai .
he
d lens

Thec r h l ah ai o t moto f rp ei nayij to onAprl , 0 8
ou t ed e rng n he i n o r lni r nunci n
t
i27 2 1 .
Bot pa te pr ent wines esfom t i r pe tve c
h ri s es ed t s r her es c i ompa es 11, Vi ePr i
ni :1 1 c csdentof
Cl i sI aSus m an and N e Vi ePr i
am r
s
xus c esdentofm s M a ge e Erc Sc i r
k na m nt i hnede .
Alhough t pa tesdiput d t na ur ofm os oft i busnes r l tons p,N c
t
he ri s e he t e
t het i s e a i hi
xus
a e d att hea i t tRI1ha a rghtofa ce st a l s s e ofis fna il
gr e
he rng ha , d i
c s o t ea t om
t i nca
doc ent pe t I
um s r he ndem niyAgr e ent Thecour t t m oton unde a s e f
t
em .
t ook he
i
r dviem nt or

t n da t al t pa test ne it t t m sofa e sng N e 'r cor .ECF N o.15.
e ys o low he ri o gota e he er
cc s i
xus e ds

On M a 9 2 8 t pate ji l mo d t c u tt hod ispr lni r i jnci o d r
y , 01 ,he ris ont ve he o r o l t ei nay nu ton r e
y
r
i a ya epe f t rne itons ECF N o. Thecour gr nt d t t
n be nc r urhe gota i .
28.
t a e he eques t ough
t hr
M a 17,2018.E CF N o.29.O n t ni ofM a 1 t pa tesnotfe t c tt tno
y
he ght
y 7, he r i
ii d he our ha

a r cm e ha bee r c d.ECF N os 3
g e nt d n ea he
. 0-31 RLIc am e t tN cxuspr ded no
.
l i d ha
ovi
fnancilr cor a of4: p. .on M a 1 a s ey pr de doc c s t tN e
i
a e ds s
00 m
y 7, nd oll ovi d um nt ha xus
pr vi l e eve fom RT, ozisbond pr
e ousy ec i d r
1 t
oduc r Se Le t f om Vi a Ka s nt s M a
e . e ter r
vi n t a oni, y

17 201 ECF N o.3O. exusê ponded t ti ha pr ded m or t 9, docum e s
, 8,
N
es
ha t d ovi
e han 000
nt;
ne ry 7, pa sofi nzgr i r oz we e pê
a l 000 ge
m i aton ec ds r oduce on M a 14,2018 a m or t n
d
y
nd
e ha
2, pa we epr
000 ges r oduc afe 4: p. .on M a 1 i l ng as e lss r cept,i ce ,
ed t r 00 m
y 7, ncudi
s t it , e i s nvoi s
gener lldge s pa r la counta s lr i or a i pr i a l sdoc e s ve
a e r , y ol c
nd a a y nf m ton, oft nd os
um nt, ndoz
baa e det i,a is2016 f r lt x r t n.Se Lete f om D a eG .M ule M a 1 2018,
lnc
al nd t
ede a a eur
e tr r
l
l n, y 7,
ECF N o.31 Upon r vi wi t l t r fom t pa tes t cour or r t pa test
.
e e ng he ete s t
he ri , he
t de ed he ri o

e a ei me it wih t eU. Ma itaeJ d e ECF No. 2. pate we eu bl t
ng g n dai t h S. g srt u g .
on
3 The ris r na e o
Com e t t
o eêm s.

Thec ur t e e fe h l a e d n irr ai onl ne7 20 8f pu p e of
o t h t atr ed n vie tajhe rng u , 1 or r os s
t ki e de e r a e t a a opra ebond a ount ECF N o.43.'' pa tesdi not
a ng vi nc elt d o n ppr i t
m
.
The ri d
pr e e dence f a a oprat bond a ount butpr de ftt ra gum e .11,
es nt vi
or n ppr i e
m
,
ovi d trhe r
nt 1 1
i t
ntoduce ne e de e r ga di N e 's ve y t ough t t si ony ofPet Fa ca a
d w vi nc e r ng xus ol nc hr
he e tm
er s i,

f ensc a count ntatM a s D rs l& D anio LLP.Fa c at tfed t he ha
or i c
a
ton, icol
lc
s i esii hat
d
difc t as esi N e 'fna ilsa ebas d on t i or a i pr de t da e
fiuly s sng xus i nca t t
e
he nf m ton ovi d o t ,

expli nghow t ne ry$44nlli i t a i omef t 201 c l rye rwa
ani
he al
ilon n otl nc
or he 7 aenda a s
ac ountd f t ough acy i not ton of$ rlloni K
c e or hr
rptc ai
42 ri i n <
l
combi cinti ome.'I
ned le nc 7 n
addii t t s e de e a
ton o hi vi nc bout s ve y,1 - e es e c
ol nc 111 xpt s d once n t tN e m a m a pul e
,
r ha
xus y ni at

isbooks r cor and a ount.Bas d on r pr ent tonsby N e '
t
, e ds
cc
s
e
e es a i
xus couns lt tta yw e e
e ha le
r
silpr pa i r or f pr
tl e rng ec ds or oducton,11, bele t N e colec i l m anti t i
i 4 1 ived hat xus l tvey i a ned her

r or vr h t r c dsofN e -elt d e ii ,s asLi eby N e .N e c
ec ds i he e or
t
xusr a e nttes uch
br
xus xus ount r
e ed
t tt ordsa e beng pr s r d,a t a tona i or a i i sm pl be ng adde i o
ha ec
r i
e e ve nd hat ddii l nf m ton s i y i
d nt

N e us Quik k i r a tme Ne sc tnde t ta c s t isr c d aon c l be
x ' c boo s n e l i . xu on e d ha c e s o t e or s l e oud
pr de t ough a s pa ae l
ovi d hr
e r t ogon. fe he rng a gum e ,t cour ga t pa te notce
A tr a i r
nt hc
t ve he r is i
ofpot ntal a ntng as ca m a trt r ol t i diput et rvr h oïvz houta
e ily ppoi i
pc il se o es ve hc. s e, ihe i
r
t
i
t

p eilnayij n to Bot pa t sc ns ntdt t es ca ma tr b dd s on v ri g
r l i r n u c in. h ri o e e o h pe il se, ut i o
n
e
ayn
condii lt r s ECF N os 48
tona e m .
. -49.I iscons nt N ex notie t cour ofa a tona
nt
e , us ii d he
t n ddii l

10 3 p g sofd u nt pr u e t RTlo un 1 , 01 .
,4 a e
oc me s od c d o , nl e 1 2 8 ECF No. , t2
48 a .
I.
I

< p eiana yi u c in i a e ta r i c r me yn ve a r d a ofrg .
< r l i r njn to s n x r o d na e d e r wade s iht'
A
n
'

Wi e v. t r l s De . un i, nc, 5 U. 7 24( 0 8 ; a Tr t Abou Oba ,
ntr Nau a Re . f Co cl I .5 5 S. , 2 0 ) Re l u h
t ma
l . Fe . e t Co ' 5 F.d3 2, 4 ( t Ci. 0 9 , c td o ot r r und ,
nc v. d Elci
on mm n, 75 3 4 3 5 4h r 2 0 ) va ae n he o s

1 0S Ct2 71(0 0,ensae i rlva t at6 7F.d35 (t Ci. 01 )l i a
3 . . 3 2 1 ) ri ttd n ee n r, 0 3 5 4h r2 0.t s
r m e t ti ff a e onl s rngy a i lm ie cr s a es''M i r r e
e dy ha s f nt d y pa i l nd n i t d icum t nc .' c ostat
gr

I v.
nc.

Mot ol- n .2 5F.d 3 5 3 9 (t Ci. 0 )(u i Die lr e Lt . . e k h ou h
or a I c, 4 3 3 , 3 4 h r 2 01 q ot
ng r x sa l d v Bt a t r
Me Co .9 2F.d 8 2 8 6( h Ci. 9 )( tr l uo ai maksor itd ) The
d. r , 5 2 0 , 1 4t r 1 91 i ena q t t
n
on r nte l.
Cout i W i e e ane t ti ea ca e, out sdm us balnc t c
t n ntr xpli d ha n ch s c t t t a e he ompeéng cai sof
lm

i ur a d mus c nsd rt e fc o e c pat oft g a igotwihh dngoft e
nj y n
t o i e he fe t n a h ty he tntn
t oli
h
rqu se t l f'
e e t d ei . Amoc Pr d. v. mb l 4 0U.. 3 , 4 (9 7 .fn e ecsng
e'
o o Co. Ga el 8 S 5 1 5 2 1 8 ) f x rii
,
l
t is
het ound dic c i coursofe at s d pa pa tc a r ga d f t publc
s r ton,
t
qliy houl y riult e t ot he
i

c ns q nc si e o i gt e r o dna yr me yofij ci ' W en r e v.
o e ue e n mplyn he xta r i r e d nun t ' ibe r
on.
Rome o Bac l 45 U. 3 5 3 2 (9 2 ; e as Ralo dCo n of x v. l n
r - reo, 6 S. 0 , 1 1 8 ) s e lo i a mm' Te . Pul
r
ma

Co.31 U.. 6 5 0(9 )Th r f e u e Witr fa pantf se i aprl lnay
, 2 S 49 , 0 1 41. eeor, nd t ne,fj li if e kng ei i r
g
n
i u t mus e tbl h t thei l eyt s c e d o t emeis t a h i l eyt s fr
njnci
on t sa i ha s i l o u c e n h rt, h t e s i l o ufe
s
k
k
ir r bl ha m i t a e ofpt ln i r r lef t tt ba a ofeqtii tpsi hi
r epa a e r n he bs nce
e iana y ei , ha he l nce
ztes i n s

fvo ,a d t ta i u to i i t ep bl i tr s. 5 5U.. t2 s eas Re l u h
a r n ha n njncin s n h u i n e e t' 5 S a 0; e lo a Tr t
c
'
Abou Oba , 7 F.da 3 (otn t tpos- ntr apli ifmus ma eaf la
t ma 5 5 3 t 47 n i g ha, tWi e , antf t k f e r
c
s
howi 't the i lkel t s ce d on t m e isa i lkey t beir r bl ha m ed
ng' ha
s i y o uc e
he rt nd s i l o
repa a y r

a e p ei nayr l f; n lyv W . r i i Re l al Co r Fa it Aut , 71F.d
bs nt r lni r ei ) Ca te . Vigr a g'l i& r. cl y h.7 3
r
e
l
i
2 , 7 (t Ci. 01 )
01 20 4 h r 2 4 .

TheW it ree nt fc ah ihtne i jnciesa r f rma t prr t r
n e lme s a e eg e d nu tv tndad o ndao , ahe
t n p o bt y p ei na ij n t . e Pr co e t LLC v. s No. :2 CV- 7 ,
ha r hiior , r lni prn u ci S e o- nc s
t
ons
Re h, 21 - 5 3
2 3 WL 5 41 42 a * ( D. . t 2 ,2 1 )(Thede ndngsa dad go
01
7 5 , t 4 E. Va Oc. 2 0 3 <
<
ma i tn r f r
prl ln r i u tons be ome e n mo ee a tn wh naplitf s e ap ei nay
ei i a y njnci l c s ve r x cig c
n
an if e ks r l r
mi

i u to ta ma d t t'b2a c nta td wiht etp c lf r ofp ei nayi j ci n
njncin h t n ae A/ / s o r se t h y ia o m
s /,
r l r nun to
mi
t a m eeypt s r e t esausq o pe i tit' (mphai i otgna) s eas Ga cav.
h t t l e e v s h t t u ndng ra.l e
'
ss n ii l; e lo r i

Goo l I .78 F.d 7 3 7 0 (t Ci. 01 )( tn t tapr i io yi j ci
e nc, 6 3 3 , 4 9h r 2 5 no ig ha oh bt r nun ton
p e e v st esau q pe igeilwhi ama aot i u to ma ae a to b
r s r e h tt s uo ndn a, l
e nd t . njncî n nd t s cin y
y
K r e g lar s onsbl pa t t tk a to ) ( ena ctt omitd .f a aor
d d ri
o
ng e p i e ty o a e c in' i r l iai
nt
ons te ) f nd t y
M

p ei nayi uncinsge e aljdo n p e e v t esausq o a n mal s oud b
r lni r nj to g n r l
r
y
ot r s r e h t t u nd or l h l e
y
g a e onl i t e c r um sa eswhe t e ge i oft st ton de and s h
r nt d y n hos ic t nc
n he xi nces he iua i
m
uc

rl f'W ez l Ed r , 3 l.d 2 3 2 6 (t Ci. 9 0 . a aor p einnay
ei . te v. wads 6 5 R2 8 , 8 4 h r 1 8 ) M nd t y r l i r
e '
r

i u tonsmus s w t tt (a a fcscer f vrgs poston no smpyt tg)i
njnci
t ho ha he T w nd a t I y a o i l ii , t i l ha i s
l
al
t
t
lke y t s ee ' G a c a,786 F. a 740.
i l o ucc d. r i
'
3d t

8

A ptl an r ijnci cnn beis e u esalot ofteeee nt aeme.
ei iay nu t a ot su d nls lf z h s lme s r t
n
on
r
SeeW i vz 555 U. at20;s e as Lca ue ofW om e Vot r ofN .Ca olnav. . r i
nt ,
S.
e lo
n
es
r i
N Ca olna,

76 F.d 2 4, 6 (t Ci. 01 ) c r. e id 1 S. . 7 5 (01 )
9 3 2 23 4 h r 2 4 , et d ne , 35 Ct 1 3 2 5 .
111-

l ismo i f rp ei nayij ci 111s e a c s t Ne us boo , e o ds
n t ton o r l r nun t 1 , e ks c e s o x ' ks r c r
mi
on,
a ac
nd c ount ,a t e ofisr lt d e iis wihi s ven da .D iti c t i Vigni
s nd hos
t ea e ntte , t n e
ys srct ours n r i a

ha va i d i t i de er i tonsofwhet rr rng apa t t peror isconta ua
ve re n her t m na i
he equii
ry o f m t
r ct l
obl tonsi m a
i i s ndat yorpr lbior i nat e.Com ar Pr conce t LLC v.Re h,N o.
ga
or
oli t y n ur
e os
s

Re h' b e c ofli e o me a r e nts po t ap ei nayi j ci r q ii h m
s s r a h l mply nt g e me up rs r lni r nun t e urng i
s
l
on
t r ur Pr
o et n o-conce s l ik Ra r s t r i m e a ey Bas on t f ctt ts
pt ' ts da ofwa e m di t l. ed
he a ha uch

i u tonma ae a ton (e, her t n oft es fwae, heCo twi a pl t emo e
njnci
nd t s ci i .t eur h o t r) t
.
ut l p y h r
l
e a t sa a dt Cou V17 wihW . n s- .LLC v. sad, 11 CV1 7
x ci tnd r o nt . t I du . ng
),
N
Le s r No. :2 7

J TRJ 2 2WL 9 02 , t* ( D. . t21 2 2 ( ihti prncpl i mid,
CC/ , 01
66 8 a 2 E. Va Ma. , 01 ) f t hs i i e n n
v
t Cour wile nlne t zkei
he
t l xa i he lhood ofs es on t m ert 10t ast Pl i ifs
ucc s
he
is 3 h o antf '

c n ri cam, àc i t bai f rt ma ao yi unc ves g , swel sis
o ve son li wlih s he ss o he nd t t nj û ou ht a la t
b e c ofc nta tcam , c i t b ssf rt pt hiii ij t t l fs u ht).
r a h o r c li whih s he a i o he o b t nunci ei o g .
ve
ve e
7
Alhough 111a gued t tiss
t
1. r
ha t oughtr lefwaspr bior ,Rl, hasne ra ce s N e '
ei
ohi t y 1
ve c s ed xus
books r or a a ount.A gz ofbr d a c st N c 'r c dswoul a trt
, ec ds nd cc
s
ant
oa c es o xus e or
d le he
f ualst us quo bet een t par i and t i m andat ' H ow e , t c tfnds t
act
at
v
he tes
hus s
ot
y.
vet he our i
he

dsi ton b t e n t esa dadsf rma aor a pr iio yij to ir lv n i
it i ea e h tn r o nd t y nd ohb t r nuncins ree a t n
nc
v

t scas 11, ha m e isbur n unde e t rsa r bec us RLIde onsr e t tt
hi e.1 1 s t t
de
r ihe tnda d a e
m tatd ha he
lw a f t cea l f vorisposton unde t W i e t s .
a nd ac s l ry a
t
ii
r he nt r e tz
A.

Th frtht dl t t t mus ov r o i o d rt o an ap ei n r i u ton
c is z e ha ILI t e c me n r e o bti r l a y njnci
r
mi
i dc ons r tng alkc i
s m
ta i
i lhood ofs e son t m e isofisas e t cam s Sc D e
ucc s
he rt
t s red l i . e whur tv.
s

Ce t Alna m Co.6 9F. 2 7 29 ( h Ci. 1 ) f ng ne a, r mutp e
nu u i
nu
, 4 3d 8 , 0 4t r 20 1. f e r lwhee lil
l
ca esofa ton a e alged,apli ifne onl s
us
c i r le
antf ed y how lkei
i lhood ofs cs on one cam t
ucc s
li o

j tf i unci r l f'W e tr l us- rh LLC v. sad, .11 v1 7 2 2W L
usiy nj t ei . se n nd .No t ,
ve e '
Le s r No :2c 7 , 01
9 6 2 , t* ( D. . r 21 2 2 (iigMC i
6 0 8 a 2 E. Va Ma . , 01 ) ct
n NeI
-PPC v. a tc l .91 F. u
Gr nu e , nc, 9 S pp.
1 8 2 ( D. . 1 9 ). ,fn c s swhe et er q e tf p ei nayr l f
9 , 01 E. N C.9 5) But f ae
i
r h e u s or r l r ei
mi
e

e o a s sbot a i jnci t manti t sau q a d t p o i ma dao yr l f
nc mp se h n nu t o i an he tt s uo n o r vde n t r ei ,
on
e
ashe e t t o r ques sm us beviwed s pa ael,wih t r que tf m a t y r if
r , he w- e
t
t
e
e r t y t he e s oê nda or ele

2Bohpat srl do Fo rhCicz c s 1w i sp oro temao'yofh iprl nayijn do ag me t,
t ri ei n ut ttt ae a n u p t f h jtt tet ei t nu c n ru ns
e e
i
i
mi
prm a iy r li on llnoi l w f rt fr tW i erpr r ga di br a h oft I m niyAg e m e ,a r li g o
i rl ey ng l s a o he is nt ong e r ng e c
i
he nde t r e nt nd ey n n
ami ofIl s Vigi a a Fourh Cicu tlw f t ir pa a l ha m a l i.The I m niy Agr mentha a
x li , r ni , nd
noi
t r i a or he r e r b e r nayss
nde t
ee
s

c ieo lw p o iin fn e io t c nsn a a ret th lwso teSaeo Il oss la pyt ti
hoc fa r vso :f d mntrs o e t nd ge ha te a fh tt f ln i hal p l o hs
l
)
i
Agr m e . Ex. t Co pl,ECF No.1 ,a 3. I m niyAgr e e doe nota e swhet 1 co e s
ee nt ' A o m .
'
-2 t The nde t
e m nt s
ddr s
her kLl ns nt
a a e t Il i a t c c oflw .
nd gr es o li s s he hoi e a
no

Th curn tsta teei aq et no wh te saeo fd tla a pist p ei n r ijn l nsndv riy
e o t o e h th r s u si f eh t tt z eea lw p l o rl ay nu ci i iest
o
e
mi
o
at n . e . ..Pu rolioHo . u l Ic v Bo tnS iCo .4 6F.d5 3 5 6(s Ci. 0 5 (Be a s
ci s S eeg, et tc s S
o
n . . so c. , 2 3 0 , 0 1t r2 0 ) f cue
pr lm i r r i i i e d t dea wil tm por r c tons t diti ' c tdc ii t a y t f de a lw
ei na y el s nt nde o l ta e
ef
.
a y ondii , he srcts our c son o ppl he e r l a
sa r gi n t a bi z c ce oflw pr son, sa r s bl one. dititc tt ( d note ti
t nda d, ve he m gtous hoi - -a ovii wa ea ona e
The src our hus I
i
r n

a pyn fd rla '. lato efd rl o r i Vignaha a pidF u t Cicl lw i stn tesa d r fr
p lig e ea lw.)Ate s n e ea c u tn rii s p l o rh rtta n eé g h tn ad o
'
e
i
pei n c ij t n a a pidtesaelw of c nrc' c oc o lw po iini assigtel eioo o
rl a nt i s nd p l h tt a a o ta t h ie fa rvso n sesn h i l d f
mi
mc o
e
s
k h
sc esa irpaa l h r S eAt. vn S l Ic v MossNo 21 CV3 0 2 1 N L3 8 3 3 a * 1( .
u cs nd re rbe am. e lDii u - n . . e, . :4 8 , 0 4 V. 7 3 4 , t 1 .D.
E
VaJ l 3 , 0 4. ep rish v no a desdwhehe liosVigna o fd rla a pist tepei n r
.uy 1 2 1 )Th ate a e t d rse
t r ln i, rii, r e ea lw p l o h rl ay
l
e
mi
ijn t naayia i sb at, at ual tel eio do scesa dirp rbeh r a aye. . a Wi A
nu ci n lss nd t u p rsp ri lry h i l o f u c s n re aa l am n lss CfP ws t
o
s
c
k h
h
Ca s.n . . t lr7 F.d3 8(t Ci. 9 6 (r n e Vignas h ieo - w rlsVi i alw g v rs
u el c v Crmpe, 3 3 5 4h r 19 ) <ujd r rii'c oc-fl ue, r ni a o en
z
t
a
g
pr e ea r
oc dur nd emedy' J v. S J & Asocs,431S. 2 33 3 ( .19 )(ttngt tVigi asc ceof
. ones R.. ones s .
);
E.d , 4 ' 93 sa i ha r ni' hoi - Va
lw r l spr vi t tt co ti t a y t s t ntve1w oft f t whe e t c r c wa e e ed, t t
a u e o de ha he ur s o ppl he ubsa i a
he orz
m
r he ont a t s nt r but ha

Vigni 1w a p ist matr of r c d r a rme y .
ri a a p l o t s p o e u e nd e d )
e
e
Gi en t pa ûe 'a r nta e nton tl a i a el w, nd gu de by t Ea tm D iti tofV ig ni' a oa h i
v he r s ppa e gr eme
lc pplc bl a a
i d he s e
src
r i a s ppr c n
At. i n Su l I v. os s t cour a i sFourh Cic tlw i s t t sa r f t pr lmi r
l D vi
nc. M e , he
t pple
t r ui a n e dng he t nda d or he ei na y

i jn to a d a pisIl i lw- t ea p rnt a re -o c oc o lw p rt eI d mnt Ag e me t t t i
nu ci n n p l lnos a h p ae l g e d t h ie f a e h n e i r e n- o h s
e i
y
y
m oton.
i

10

b igs jce t amor e a t sa dadofrve 'I ( ot Co n lv S c ,9 F.
en ube td o
e x ci tn r e im 'd.qu i r wel . a hs 9
ng
ng
S p. d 6 ,7 3I D. .O OI l t i c s , , b ig mu t l cams i cu i
up 2 95 0 E. VaZ O I. n hs ae R1I rn s li e li ,n ldng
p

i u t r l f s e i pe f r nc , ndbt a h ofide t a r e ntS eCompl ECF
njnci ei , p cf to ma e a e c n mniy g e me . e
ve e
k
.
,

No 1 Thef u oft pr lnia yi u to brei ga h aigwa Ne u ' l g d
. . oc s he ei n r njncin ifn nd e rn s x s al e
l
e
br c oft I m niyAgr e entby fii t pr de a c st isr oê f z viw.
ea h he nde t
em
alng o ovi c es o t ec ds or e e
Unde Ilnoi lw, ch gove nst I
r li s a whi
r hc ndem nik ai Agr e e ,Rl1c n sa ea
f ton
e m nt , a t t

cam f rb e c ofc nta tbyd mo tai ::1 t e itnc ofavai a d e ot e b c
li o r a h o z c
e nsr t ( ) he x se e
ng (
l n nf c a l
d
c r c;()pef r n eb t epli if ()b e c o t c nta tb t ed fnd n ; nd
onta t 2 ro ma c y h antf; 3 z a h f he o rc y h e e a t a
()r s tntnjprt t plitf. Gon aze v Am. p. e i Cor , 511App. d
4 e ul i u o he an if' z lls . Ex Cr dt p.31 1
a
'
.
3

1 9 2 6 7 3 N. 2 3 5 3 (0 0 (iig Gal h rCor . Rus, 0 11Ap 3 1 2
9 , 0 , 3 E.d 4 , 51 2 0 ) ctn l e
a
v. s 3 9 1 p. d 9 ,
.
1 , 4 11De . 2 , 21N . 2d 6 5( 9 9) Thefrtee nt su ipu e i t sc s ,
99 2 2 1. c 3 6 7
E. 0 1 9 ).
ls lme i nd s td n hi a e
asbot 11, a N e a ee t tt y a ebound by t l m niyAg e e .Si ia l
h 1 1 nd xus gr ha he r
he nde t r em nt m lry,

t pa tesdo notdiput t s c
he ri
s e he e ond e e e - pe f m a by RLl a R11ha i s d
l m nt
r or nce
- s , s s ue
i nzgr i bondsa N e 'r
m i aton
t xus eques . Theonl diput sa e whet rN e ' ef a t
t3
y s e r
he
xus r us l o
pr de t or a es vi a espa a a 3 oft l m niyAgr m e a whet rR1,
ovi ec d cc s olt
r gr ph
he nde t
ee nt nd
he
l

ha be ni u e b c us ofi.
s e njr d e a e t
1.

I det r ni whe he N e hasbr ched t I m riyAgr e e ,t cour
n erni ng
t r xus
ea
he nde lt
e m nt he
t
t nsfr tt t pli l
ur ts o he an angua oft c r tpr son i diput Se I .Be ftG r .
ge he ontac ovii n s e. e ns ne i

5Onterg o J n 6 2 1 ,hed yb f et e ie é l h aigt sta a p o it b n a u , x fc a
h t ht f u e , 0 7 t a eor he vd n ay e r o e n p rpr e o d mo ntNeusi d
i
n
a
l
m oton f l a t fl acou e ca m a a e
i or e ve o ie
nt r li nd m nded a we al g'g br a h ofc r c ba e on t i ple d y of
ns r le m
ec
onta t s d
he m i d ut
good f ih a f i de l ECF No. a 1 -1 N e c e t tR'lsde a t i pe tdoc e s t
at nd a r ai
ng.
43, t 8 9. xus ont nds ha L ' m nds o ns c
um nt , he
dic r ofis d bonds a c lt r lwe e noti good f ih. c tma sno f ng a t t m oton f la
s ha ge s ue
, nd ola e a r
n
at The our ke
mdi s o he
i or e ve
t a e whih r e l c plt d bre i The c tnot st tt ei no diput be wee t pa te t tRLI
o m nd, c ec nty om e e i fng.
our e ha her s
s e t n he r is ha
pe f m e u rt co r c i i s ng t i mi a i bonds
r or d nde he nta t n s ui he m gr ton
.

I . Gu r nteTr LieI s Co.20 7I Ap (s)1 2 0 , 3 ,9 N. 3 9 0 9 ,
nc v. a a e . f n . , 1 L p 1 t 6 8 8 ! 8 1 E.d 5 , 61
a e 1 rid, 5N. 3 49 (1 2 8 (Th c r wi frtl k t t lng a eoft
a del 9 E.d 3 11 01 ) d e ou t l ls oo o he a u g he
e
.
<
l
c r ctis l t detr i t pa tes i ent a t c r ctm us be c tue a a
onta te f o e m ne he ti ' nt , nd he onta
t onsr d s

wh e fiwi e c p o ii i l hto t o h rp o ii .'(u igTho s n v.
ol,ve ng a h z v son n i f he t e z v sons' q otn
g
'
m o

Go d 2 112(4 , 1 3 911De . 36 9 N. 2 3 (0 )) t nt lng a e
r on, 41 1 1 28 44 , 4 1 c 9 , 48 E.d 9 2 11).f
.
,
Whe hc a u g
oft contac i cea a una bi
he
r t s l r nd m guous t pa tes i e m us be det rni d s ey f om
, he ri ' nt nt t
e t ne oll r

t ln a eoft c nta t tefa begv nisp an a d o dna yme ni ' aiy
he a gu g
he o r c isl nd ie t li n r i r a np'Qu l
t

Tt ns o tto Se v .I . MakTho s n Tr kn I .2 7 I App ( d 1 0 61
a rain r s nc v. r
m o uc i nc, 01 L
3) 67 ,
! 2 , 0N . 3 4 5 4 0
5 9 E.d 8 , 9 .
l r lvantpa t4t l m niy Agr e entsa es
n ee
r, he nde t
em
tt :

UntlSur t ha bee f nihe wih c l i e dence ofis
i e y s n ur s d t oncusve vi
t
dic r wihout l s fom a Bonds a untl Sur t ha
s ha ge t
os r
ny
, nd
i
ey s
bee ot wi e f l i m tiid a he e
n her s uly nde lfe s r underpr ded,Sur t
ovi
ey
s l ha t rghtofa es t t books r c dsa a count
hal ve he i
cc s o he
, e or nd c
s

o t I e t t)f t p m o eofe a lnig a c pyng
f he nd mni s or he u s
or
x n i n nd o i
t m . The I e nt rs h r b a t rz t id p ris
he
nd m io t) e e y u ho ie hr a te ,
i l ng but not lt t d t depost i of f
ncudi
inie o
iores
unds of t
he

l e nt t) t f r ih t S e y a y i or ton r q se
nd m iors, o u n s o ur t n nf mai e ue td
by Sur t i c
e y n onne i wih any t a a i
cton t
r ns cton. Sur y m a
et
y
f nih any i ot ai whih i now has or m a he ea t r
ur s
nf m ton, c t
y r fe

a q r c e nig t eI de iors,t ot e pe s ,fr o
c uie onc r n h n mn t t) o h r rons tms r
e ii f t pur e of pr urng c s et hi ot
nttes or he
pos
oc i
o-ur ys p
r i ur
ens ance or of a sng s h pe s ,fr s or entte a i
dvii uc
r ons lm ,
iis s t
m a de a oprat
y em ppr i e.

4RTIas cam e t tN e usbr a he t l m niy Agr e e ' pr ii r l tng t t dema f c l t r l Se
, lo l i d ha x
e c d he nde t
e m nts ov son ea i o he
nd or ola e a . e
l m niy Ag e m e ,
nde t r e nt ECF N o. -2 a 2. r i s ediput be we n t pa te whe he t r hasbee abr c of
1 , t The e s om s e t e he r is t r he e
n ea h
t a r e e ' co lt r l ov son. Icam st ti de a d c l e a i M a c 2 7 a Ne c am st ha
he g e m nts la e a pr i i R1. li ha t m nde ol r l n r h 01 , nd xus li o ve
at

pr i d $ 0, i c lt a a ltrofe e t pr i f t c lt a, c RLIalg yrf e t a c pt11,
ovde 20 000 n olaerl nd ae fr d o ovde urher ol erlwhih
a
le edl eus d o c e .1 1

n ie tec ut th l n 7h aigta iddn t ekad ma dfrc l trlnispei n c ijnc o moin
otid h o ra te u e ern h tt i o se e n o ol eai t rl a nu é n t ,
f
a
mi
o
b tt a i ma r t r t t ec u t fe rve i gNe u ' e o d . t ec u tf ds h tap ei na rnu c n i
u h t t y et n o h o r atr e iv n x s r c r sAs h o r t t a r l p i jn éo s
z
n
mi
m e ie ba e on t i pe i ofr c ds a RLIdoe notde a c l t r lwih t sm oto t c tdoe not
rt d s d
he ns cton e or , nd
s
m nd ola e a t hi
i n, he our
s
a e st alge br a h r ga di co lt r la t ss a oft l ia i
ddr s he l d e c e r ng la e a t hi tge he i g ton.
e
t

S eI e t Ag e me t !3() Thepate dia r ea t t me nigoff ks r c r
e nd mniy r e n , c.
ris s g e s o he a n <
boo , e o ds
a a c nt oft l e io tl'111a g st a f k , e o dsa a c unt'pli l
nd c ou s he nd mnt rs. : , r ue h t t s rc r nd c o s' any
'
boo
m ea alofN e 'books r c dsa a ount,wihoute pton. e count r t t
ns l
xus
, e or nd cc
s t
xce i N xus
e s ha

t phr s m e nsonl N e 'fna ilr cot a doesnote e t de ald pe s l
he a e a
y xus i nca e ds nd
xt nd o t ie r ona
r cor a
e ds boutbond hol r .Ba e on t st or ,couns lf N cxusa ee a t he rng
de s s d
hi he y
e or
gr d t he a i
t t1.. i e il t s e fna i lr c ds i l ng baa e s t ,pt i and l s
ha :- s ntted o om i nc a e or , ncudi
11
lnc hee s oft
os

sa e e s a t x r t ns A sofAprl27, he fr the rng on t sm oton,N e ha not
t t m nt, nd a eur .
i
t is a i
hi
i
xus d
pr de fna ilr cor t RI1des t t sa knowldgem e .N e pr ded atla t
ovi d i nca e ds o , pie hi c
e
nt xus ovi
es
s e fna i ldocum e si isM a 1 2018pt
om i nc a
nt n t y 7,
oduc i t RLI The pa tescontnuet
ton o
.
ri
i
o
dia eer ga ki t s fc e y oft spr
s gr e rlng he ufii nc
hi oduc i
ton.
N e 'adm ison t i i oblga ed a hasf ie t pr de fna ilr cor t ti
xus
s i hat t s i t nd
ald o ovi i nca e ds ha t

beive we es bjc t t l e t Ag e me i e d n eofab e c i a d of tef
le d r u e t o he nd mniy re nt s vie c
r a h n n isl.
M or
eovet t cour doesnotfnd N e 'a gum e per uasve.
, he
t
i
xus r
nt s i The pli lngua oft
an a
ge he
a r m e pl c no lt t ton on R1,' ac es t N e 'r or .
g ee nt a es inia i
1s c s o xus ec ds Them ea ng ofd
ni
'
books
,
r cor a a ount' i nots pli y l ied i t l m niyA g e e orby acom m on
e ds nd cc
s' s
o anl i t n he nde t r em nt
nl
knowl dge oft et r s Fore m pl,Blck' La D itona ydefnest s t r sbr y
e
hes e m .
xa e a s w c i r
i he e c m
oadl
be
yond fna ildoc e s <cor at books?whi i com pa a e t Tbooks'gve t t
i nca
um nt. < por e
'
5 ch s
r bl o <
' i n ha

N e usi ac po ain,sd fne a <wlitn r c r ofac r r to sa tvte a
x s or r to i e i d s ' rte e o ds
g
o po ain' ciiis nd

busne sta a t . Cor r t Boo , a ksLa Dito r (0 h e 2 4 .f i e s
i s tns ci ' po ae ks Blc ' w cina y 1 t d. 01 ) f n s
ons '
Bus
r cor 'whi a i a r a opraegve t N e i abusne s i defne asfg)
e dy' ch gan ppea s ppr it i n hat xus s
i s ,s i d fa

r po t me a um, ot e r c r ma us alj n t o di r c reof i s.
e r, mornd or h r e o d de ugl i he r nay ou s busne s'
y
'

Busne sRe or Blc sLa Dito r (0 h e 2 4 . n rv e ngaN o t r Ditit
i s c d, a k' w cina y 1 t d. 01 ) I e iwi
rhe n src

ofIlnoi a i ba e on t Fede a Tr de Com t si Ac ,t Se nt Cic t
li s cton s d
he
rl a
nison t he ve h r ui
expli
a ned,fd
tbooksofa count 'a tec ds ha r e e e t s ra,contnuous a m or
c
s nd r or ' ve ef r nc o e il
i
, nd
e

pe m a
r nentm e ora sofa c e n' busnes a afar ,c onol c ly a s t m atcal
m il
onc r s i s nd f is hr ogi al nd yse i l
y

ke a d ar ng d. Cu h Pa kn Co. Urtd S ae ,1 F.d 1 3, 3 ( t Ci.1 2 )
pt n ra e ' da
'
ci
v. t e tt s 5 2 3 1 6 7h r 9 6 .
i
Theunde sa ng oft e t m sby Blck' D i i r a t Se nt Cic text
r t ndi
hes cr
a s ctona y nd he ve h r ui end
be
yond fna i ldocum ent .
i nc a
s

N ex i a s si a e c por t entt a ha t ca ct t unde sa a
us s ophitc t d or a e iy nd d he pa iy o
r t nd nd
ne i et t r soft c r c i ent r i o wih RI,. e coul ha ba gane f
gotat he e m
he onta t t e ed nt t
I N xus
d ve t i d or
ana r e s ofdoc e sa ia et 1.. f a es ,smpl by m odiyng f
r ow r et
um nt valbl o 1 1 or cc s i y
1
fi t
books
,
r c dsa ac
e or nd count 'wih t t r <fna il' Ye N e di notdo s a dutng t
s' t he e m ti nca . t xus d
'
o, nd i hc
Aprl27 hea i bef e t scour ,sr e t s
i
rng or hi
t tuggld o ugges a basst na r t s
t ny i o r ow he copeoft
he

c r aed ume ss bjc t t rg ofa c s.
o port oc nt u e t o he iht c e s
W hie t lw and f ct pli y esa ih RI1sc r t lrghtofac es t N e '
l he a
a s anl t bls ,' ontac ua i
c s o xus
books r or a a ount,t ext i oft trghtt N e - ea ed e iisi ls
, ec ds nd cc
s he enson ha i o xusr lt ntte s e s

cea . hiet l m niyAgr m e c e t bi ng oblga i be we RLIa N e ,
l r W l he nde t
ee nt r a es ndi
i tons t en
nd xus
no m e î i m a ofafi a e e ii ,nordi Rl, pt s nte de e t s
nton s de
fl t d nttes
i
d I e e vi nc o uppot iscli
t t am
t tN ex a ist l ed e ii a eefeci l t s m e busnes f t pum os soft s
ha
us nd t eat nttes r f tvey he a
i s or he
e
hi

a r e n . t i prlni r sa e t r f r , n i u to mus bel t dt Ne us
g e me t At hs ei na y tg , hee o e a y njncin t i e o x
l
mi
a one.
l
2.

RLlsalg dbt a h o c nta tcam lsl r q r sde
' l e e c f o rc li a t e uie monstdon ofij y f r
e
y
ta
nut o
de e r ri i slke i
t r nilng t i lhood of s es on t m ett .Se G onz z e , 315 11 App.3d a 206,
ucc s
he
is e
al l s
1.
t

7 3N. 2 a 3 .t p nst t pi pr o re ofi uycusdb Ne us fi r t
3 E.d t 51 ILI oit o ' rma s u c s njr a e y x 'al e o
wo
u
al i pe i ofisr cor .Fis, 1cam st tt denilofisbagane f
low ns cton t e ds r t R1, li ha he
a
t z i d-or
c r ct lrghtt i pe tbooksa r cor r nde si i pa eofe l tngise
onta ua i o ns c
nd e ds e r t nca bl
vauai t xpos e
ur

on t t o t and outt ndi bondsa pr e tis l a i tt rs ofdef t Se
he ' hous
w
sa ng
nd ot c t ef gans he ik
aul. cond,
11, c t i r as conc n ove N e 'peror a e,ncudi a i r s i bond cli s
1 1 ies nc e ed
er
r xus f m nc i l ng n nc ea e n
am
pad byRLI i tgatonsofN ex by s a ea hortes a ot rc
i
, nvesi i
us
t t ut ii , nd he once nsove is
r
tt
fna i lcondii
i nc a
ton.

111ctsahos ofcss i ll i a oh rjrs ito , r c ursha fun
1- ie
,
t ae,n lnos nd te uidcins whee o t ve o d
i
t tt denilofi e i conta t lrght i l ng t rghtt i pe r or
ha he
a
nt rm
r c ua i s ncudi he i o ns ct ec ds a ount
m

t a i jr a t r f r mei e ktbl r l ft e o c t ec nta t a rg . e
o n nu y nd hee o e rt qz a e ei o nf r e h o r c u l ihtSe
i
e
Tr velr Ca .& Sur Co.ofAm . Des n Buid En 's& Conta t s Cor .2014 W L
a es s
.
v. i
l
r
r c or
,

7 7 0 , t+ ( . Fl. c 2 , 01 ) X1 S e il l . . Tr a , 11 CV1 8
2 48 3 a 8 M D. a De . 2 2 4 ; , ca ns Co v. ulnd No. :4 05
J J A, 01 WL 4 3 3 8 a + ( D. . g 21 2 4 9 o Ca . ns Co. L.
CC/ F 2 4
2 0 8 , t 4 E. Va Au . , 01 ) Ohi s I . v. H.
En ' Co I c,2 1 W L 1 6 3 , t* -3 ( D. lJ n. , 01 Ha v rl . . .
r . n. 04
25 9 51 a 2 C. Ca. a 2 2 $; no e ns Gr v
Sn lsRoot Co.l .2 1 WL 2 68 2 , t* 2 4( D. 1 J ne2 , 01 ) De l e s
i e
i
n
nc, 0 2
3 3 8 a 1 -1 N. 11 u 1 2 2 4 veo r
.
S r & l m. v. e . e v & Re ar I .2 09R 38 1 3 , t* (. Fl. v.1 ,
u . nde Co. Elc S r .
i nc, 0
3 4 7 a 1 SD. a No 6
2 09. n Ha ov rl . . Sn lsRoof Co.I c, 01 WL 23 8 2 ( D. 1.une
0 ) I n e ns Gr v. i e
i
n
n .2 2
6 3 8 N. 11J
21 2 2,t dititc u tf rt No t e n Ditito Il i alwe a c s t boo sa
, 01 ) he src o r o he rh r src f lno s l d c e s o k nd
i
o
r or bec us a entt a lt t i pe ,a ong ot rt quese t i , hepli ifc d
ec ds a e bs he biiy o ns ct m
he e
t d elef t
antf oul
l e i s c a m t as et as t def
os t l i o s s he enda had pr vi l f d ba upt y m uli e tm es 1 at
nt
e ousy Be
nkr c
tpl i . d.

* 5 Pe s svey t d stc c u tf t S t r DititofFl i e o n d ad fnd n
1 . rua i l,hc itit o r or he ou hen src
orda nji e e e a t
t al ac es rght t doc ent be a e ot r s t pli ifwoul K uf e ir pa a e
o low c s i s o
um s c us he wie he antf
d < f r re r bl
s

da a and l sbec us ofislkeyi biiyt be s c e i a
m ge
os
a e t i l na lt o
e ur d n dvanceag ns cai sa
ai t l m nd
l s ,a D ef ndant bel tfeet s l,ta f r dipos of le s ur orot r s
os es nd
e
s ef r o el r ns e , s e , in, ec e
he wi e

di r orc e t i as e sfom beng us d t dicha get i obl tonst e
ve t onc al he t s t r
i
e o s r het i i o xone at a
ga
r e nd

i de iyghep antfl'De l e sSu . l m. , 0 W L 3 31 7 a *
n mn f t li if. veo r r & nde Co.20 9
'
8 43 , t 2.
N exusa t m pt t ditngtih t e c s s a gti t t c s i ve onl
te s o si zs hes a e , r zng hat hc a es nvol d y
fna i lr ot ott t pli if i t e a i we e a e t s
i nc a ec ds hat he antfs n hos ctons r bl o how t de swer due
hat bt
e

a t prncpa,who had s ve y is s r us t pa t m .
nd he i i l
ol nc sue , ef ed o y he Thes ditnc i a em e e
e si tons r r
wi
ndow dr s i Fis,f t pa tye r R1, ha dogge y pur ue e t na i ofN exus
e sng. r t or he s a , 1 s
dl
s d xani ton
'
fna ilr cor . i t t flng oft slws t N e usr us d a e s Alhoug N e
' nca e ds Ptor o he ii
i
hi a ui, x ef e cc s . t
h xus

ha n p o i e s f nca r c r ssnc t efrtp eilnayij ci n he rng
s ow r v d d ome i il e o d i e h is r l i t nun to ai ,
na
n
Ne ussi ha not ie RLIa c s t isQtc Bo s ha notstu at t alw R11s
x tl s gv n
l
c e s o t l k ok , s c p i o l
i
me
o ,'
f e i a ount ntt exani isbooksa r or ,a hasnotcam ed- a l s i a
or nsc cc
a o r ne t
nd ec ds nd
li
t ea t n ny
c tflngs t ha pr ded aloft fna ilr cor t te n i beive RLIi
our ii
o ve ovi
l he i nca e ds ha ve t le s
s

o i ae t tc iep rt I e t Ag e me . n e , tt J ne7 h ai , h c r
bl td o e ev e he nd mniy t e ntI de d a he u
g
e rng t e ou t
had an opporuniyt viw t s tofdoc e spr
t t o e he or
um nt oduce by N e t da e Rlls
d
xus o t . w '
f e i a ount ntt tfed a t t s r ena ur oft f w fna ilr or pr
ot nsc cc
a esiè s o he pa s t e he e i nca ec ds oduce
d.
The s tze doc e spx
anii d
um nt oduc t da e do notpz de111w hh a m e ni ulviw of
ed o t
ovi 1 .
ny a ngf e
N exus fna ilc
' i nca ondii orlLlspot nta e
ton k '
e il xpos eon t e bonds W hieN e has
ur
hes
. l xus
expr s e wilngne st m ee sisc r c ua oblga i t al i pe i ofbooks
e s d li
s o
t t onta t l i tons o low ns cton
,
r cor a a ount ,i ha notdone s t da e
e ds nd cc
s t s
o o t.
Sec
ond,11, hast i e va i c et r ga di N exus a lt t s ts y t bond
4 1
a s d ld onc ns e r ng
' biiy o a i f he

oblga i RT, pr e e e de e t ti t enty pad ove $80, i udi penali ,f
i ton. I es nt d vi nc ha t ec l i
t 000, ncl ng
tes or

eghtout t ng bond cli s 1 , sat t ti m a t spa m entbec us N e di not
i
sandi
am .U- t es ha t de hi y
1
a e xus d
pr de s fce pa tvor t RL1t ve iyt tpa m entha be s nit d t t
ovi ufi int pea k o
o rf ha y
d en ubr te o he
gove nm ent N e 'wines ,Sc i t s a e t thebeive t e eghtcam sha bee
r
. xus t s hne de , t t d ha
le s hes i
li
d n

pa d,buthe c d note an t dic epanc be us i wa nothi de rm e . n a ton
i
oul
xpli he s r
y ca e t s
s pa t nt l ddii

t bond cam spa d byl ,11, la nc t tN e ha e e cd i o ar pa m e s he e
o
li
i
tLI 1 1 e r d ha xus d nt t nt e y nt c dul

f unr ae bonds r quii Nexust pa t gove nme $30, t $35, pe da i
or eltd
, e rng
o y he
r nt 000 o
000 r y n
c r ii d f
e tfe undsf a he s et ' bonds The r pa m entpln, nc udi t r zr m e of
or not r ur ys
.
e y
a i l ng he eqtie nt
c r iid f
e tfe unds a ce ua e Rllsc
, c nt t d w' once ns Thes c
r .
e once nsa
r boutN e 's venc a e
xus ol y r
heght
i ened by t t por sofm uli e ongoi i tga i ofN e by s ac a t ne
he c t
tpl
ng nvesi tons
xus
t t tor ys

ge r a by t s t hy na-r oft fna ili or a i pr de t R1, and r viwe
ne al nd
he ke c
t e he i nca nf m ton ovi d o I
u
e e d
by Rllsf ensc a countnt The e de e pt s nt byRIIofisow n pas due bond
w ' or i c
a .
vi nc e e ed
, t
t

cam s i l ng ispa e ofcam sa pe li ,a t tr sofr ym e r lr d
li , ncudi t ym nt li nd na tes nd he e m
epa nt eqdie
f ot rs e is bonds de onsr t t tt ha m i notçe iey t e ia' asN e
or he ur te '
, m
ta es ha he r s
fntr l heor tc l'
xus
cam s I s t vr houtt a lt t exa i N e 'books RL1l e t a lt t f fl
li . n hor , i
t
he biiy o m ne xus
,
os s he biiy o ulil
isobl i a s et unde t bonds t as e st lve offnancalts i f eson t
t
i ons s ur y
gat
r he
, o s s he e l i i ik t ac
he

bondsis d t N e ,a t ke se t pr e is l a i ts h rs
s ue o xus nd a tps o ot ct t e f gans uc ik.
Ther ot ,11, hasde onsr t d t tt lw a f c scla l fvorisposton t t
ef e 1 1
m
ta e ha he a nd a t e ry a
t
ii ha

()Ne usa 111e ee i oavai c nta t()111ha pefr disobiai un r
1 x nd 1, ntr d nt l o rc,2 1, s rome t l t
d
g ons de
t c nta t ()N e usbt a he t ec t c bypt vii a c s t no d u nt ptott
he o t c, 3 x e c d h onta t
o dng c e s o
oc me s i o
t pr l nnayij to he rn depiea k wld i s h a o l to t a la ts me
he ei i r nuncin ai g s t c no e gng uc n b i i n o t e s o
n
ga

fn n il c nt, nd ()RLIha be n i u e bynot e evn t be ei of t
i a ca do ume s a 4
s e njr d
r c iig he n ft is
ba ga ned-ora ces rght.
r i f c si s

B.
H a ng f
vi ound a lkei
i lhood t tRI, wils e on iscl m f br c ofconta t
ha
1 l ucc ed
t ai or ea h
t c,

a t tt 1w and f t cea l fvorRLlsposton,t cour wile l t t r m ani
nd ha he a
ac s l ry a
'
ii he
t l vaua e he e i ng

p eilnayi u éonfcor a t t ecamsl a diont t f s W i e ee ntILI
rl i r njnc a t s s o hos li .n d t o he i t ntr lme ,I
n
i
r
m us alo rm a acla s
t s t ke e r howi t ti i lkel t beir pa a y ha m e a entpr i nay
ng ha t s i y o t e r bl r d bs
elmi t
r i . Re lTr h AboutO ba a 5 F. a 347.
elef' a ut
'
m , 75 3d t
The tke wor ...i ir pa a e. Va.
ç y
d
s r e r bl '
'

Cha tr Asocae Ge Co rco s l . I e s 4 4F. u p. 1 7, 1 2 ( . . .
e s itd n. nta t r nc v.ir , 4 S p 1 6 1 8 W D Va
1 7 ) < me ep sblt ofir pa a l h r i no e ug 'Pr - nc t LLC v Re h,
9 8 .T r osiiiy re r be a m s t no h. o co e s
A
'
. s

ot e ) Prlni r i u to aeme n t ( otc t sau q a t p e nt
nhtd . ei na y njncins r a t o i e t he tt s uo nd o tve
t
pr
ir pa a eha m durng t pendencyofalws tuli ael t pr e ve t cour ' a lt t
te r bl r
i he
a ui tm t y o es r he
ts biiy o

r nd rame ni f lud me o t meis'l ê Mir of Co . ir t t .3
e e
a ng u j g nt n he rt. n e cos t r Anttus Lii 33
'
F.d 5 7 5 (t Ci. 0 3 (iai o nte ) a o ai o ot e r ndsr c nz d i
3 1 , 25 4 h t 2 0 ) ctt
ons t itd , br t n h r ou e o ie n
on
Bet daSof vor LLC v.I e l Ent ' Cor . N o.11 60,2011W L 5
hes
t ks
a
nt r a
mt
-18
084587,a *
t2

(t Ci. t 2 , 01 ) fGl n rl f rpa a l ij yi s fr dwhe moneayd ma s
4 h r Oc. 6 2 1 .f e e al i c r be nur s ufe e
g
yr
n
tr a ge
a e cifc tt a c r an ora ei dequat ' M uli
r lfi ul o s e t i
r na
e.'
' t-cha l'' Cabl Co. Cha l t vil
nne TV
e
v. totes le

QuaiyCa eOpe aig Co.2 F.d 5 , 5 (t Ci. 9 4 , b o ae o ot r r un
l bl
t
r tn
, 2 3 46 5 1 4h r 1 9 ) a r t d n he o ds
byW i e , 5 U. 7( 0 8 .
. ntr 5 5 S 2 0 )
.
The Cotr fndst tRT. s ifest ( repa a eha nf'pr oft pr lmi r
zt i
ha
I atsi he i r r bl r
i
ong he ei na y

i inci a lsst r ug isl sofbag i d-o c r cu l iht o i pe t ks
nu t nay i h o h t os
on
r ane f r onta t a tg t ns c boo ,
r cor a a count.
e ds nd c
s TheH a
nove cour, c a i Ilnoi lw,hel t ts equent
r
t whih ppled li s a
d ha ubs
m onc a y da a a e a i
t r m ges r n nadequa e r m edy f t de a oft i e i c r t lr ghtt
t e
or he ni l he nt rm ont ac ua i o

18

a es tght t booksand t ot ,a l s whe e t t i a rs ofi ol nc Se H a
cc s i s o
ec ds t ea t t he e s ik ns ve y. e nover

I . . . i lsRoofn Co I c, 1 W L 2 6 3 8 a * 4 ( D. 1. u 21 2 2 .
ns G v S n e
i
. n .20 2
3 8 2 , t 1 N. 11J ne , 01 )
Thec u te pli d Iasa c s t t boo a dr c r sa t g a i oft nsbot
o r x ane ,' l c e s o he ks n e o d nd he r nt
g
ng i
e
h
al H a
low
nove t pr e tis l fom f ur la lt t r woul notbe a a qua er m edy
r o ot c t ef r
ut e ibiiy, he e
d
n de t e

f Ha
or nove i t e tvo pr sonswe ehed t ber m e e onl by s equentm one a y
r f hes a
ovii
r l o
e did y
ubs
tr
da a ,r t rt n s ii pe f m a e. I The rghtt a es 'r l tons p t t tght
m ges a he ha pec fc ror nc ' d.
'
i o cc s e a i hi o he i
t pr ec f om f t ela lt i ar uri t m ei ot rf r lc e t ha or ed
o ot t r
u ur ibiiy s ec rng he n he ede a as s hat ve der

a c s . eTr v lr Ca . S r Co. Am.2 1 WL 7 7 03 a * ( ndngp an if t
c e s Se a ee s s & u . of , 0 4
2 48 , t 8 i i litf me
i
blt n r ga di a ces t fna i lbooksa r or wher def nda fie t pos
zde e r ng c s o i nc a
nd ec ds
e e nt al d o
t
colatr lorpr
l ea
oduceorpr
oduc fna i ls a e e sa r quied by t i m nii a i
e i nc a t t m nt s e r
he nde fc ton

a r e nt; veo e sSu . l de Co.20 9WL 3 31 3 , t* (r rn pr du ton o
g e me ) De l r r & n m. , 0
8 4 7 a 1 o deig o ci f
r cor f i pec i ba ed on e denceofit pa a eha m fom pl i ifslkey i biiy
e ds or ns ton s
vi
r e r bl r r
antf' i l na lt

t s c ea ans iscamsi a va ea i rc g ii t t< eo i j cier l fi
o e ur g i t t li n d nc nd n e o n t ha < f nun t ei s
on
us
v e
a opra e t pr e tt sze y sc r c ua,c m on-a a eqkia erg sof
ppr it o ot c he tr t ' onta t l om
lw nd zt bl i ht

e ne ai a d q i />J) I Oh oCa . ns Co. L. En ' Co.N o.
xo r ton n ua / ' . n i s I . v. H.
' '
z
,

S
ACV1 O 2 9C CANX, 01 W L 1 5 9 5 , t* ( D. lJ n. , 01 ) t dititc t
314 J
2 4
2 6 3 1 a 2 C. Ca. a 2 2 4 ,he stc ou t
f t Centa Diti tofCaior a ce ty expli d w hy l sofa s e ysi erm rght
or he
r l src
lf ni la l
a ne
os
ur t ' nt i i s
ca beir pa a e:
n
t e r bl
O hi Cas ly has m e is bur n of s
o
ua t
tt
de
howi t is rght t
ng hat t i
o
i pec D ef nt'booksa r cor willkey be ir pa abl
ns t enda s
nd e ds l i l
re r y

i u e wih t t r qu se r l f The p o ii of t
njr d t ou he e e td ei .
e
r v son
he
I m niy Agr em e gr ntng O hi Cas ly a ce s t
nde t
e nt a i
o
ua t c s o
D ef ndant ' books a r or i c e ry i e d t ena e
e
s
nd ec ds s l a l nt nde o
bl
O li Cas ly t f fl is oblga i
'o
z
ua t o ulil t
i tons a s et unde t
s ur y
r he
c pl ton a pa ent bonds f w hi h i t c i s cli s l
om e i nd ym
or
c t e e ve a m . f
O hi Ca uat we e r quied t w atuntlc pl i oftilt
o s ly t e r o i i om eton
ra o

a es D ef nda s books a z cor , O hi Cas ly w oul
cc s
e nt'
nd e ds
o
uat
d
ha t r pond t t cam swihouti or aton t whih i i
ve o es
o he li
t
nf m i o
c ts
conta t lyentte
r c ual
ild.
N e hasnoti ii any c s de ng as et t i e i rghtt a ce sbooks
xus
dentfed
a es nyi
ur y he ntrm i o c s
a t cor .N e t rpa t haspoi e t Fouth Cicztlw orVigi alw t ta es
nd e ds ihe ry
nt d o
t r ti a
r ni a ha ddr s

ptl n c i u t rl ft p oe ts hi ei rg s a t c mtha no f u c ss
ei a njnci ei o r tc uc ntrm iht, nd he o
mi
ve e
s t o nd ae
on poi . Howe r t stend ofc t t pr s r a s e ysi e i conta ua rght as
nts
ve , hi r
our s o e e ve ur t ' ntrm
r ct l i s lo
i consse wih t lw ofs e ys p.l Tr ve e sCas & Sur Co. O c l
s
it nt t he a
ur t hi n a l r
.
. v. kerund,N o.04 C

3 3 2 0 W L 1 9 91 ( D. 1. . , 0 4 ,hedititc r f tt eNo t r Ditit
96 , 0 4
7 4 5 N. 11Aug 6 2 0 ) t src ou t o h the n stc
ofllnoi not <unde t 1w ofs e ys p,e n i a s e y' l si m one a y a onl
li s ed, K
r he a
ur t hi ve f ur t s os s
t r nd y
t m por r ,t ti m us a s e aprm a yoblgorsobl i a ali aha m f whih t r
e
a y ha t
t s um
i r
i ' i on t l s t or c he e
gat

i noa q t rme ya lw. I . t+ (e iigt d postofc l trlt asrt
s de uae e d ta ' d a 5 rqurn he c i ol ea o u ey
'
a
pur ua t a i m niya ee e t pr e t rghtt i
s nt o n nde t gt m nt o ot ct he i o ndem nik a i f l s
f ton ot os es

i c r d a ar s l ofis ig b ds.
n ure s e ut sun on )

Thep ru sv c s lw fo sv rlfd rluidito , riual t Ha ve
es aie ae a r m e ea e ea jrs cins patc lry he no r
de ii i t N ot he n Di ti ofIlnoi,c
c son n he
t r
srct li s onvi st c tt tal sofdghtt r vi w
nce he our ha os
o e e
5l a a toni vi a i m niorsfiur t pl gec latrlpurua t a i m niia a e m e ,heditit
n n ci nvol ng n nde t ' al e o ed ol e a s nt o n nde fc éon gre ntt src
co tf t Ea t m D iti tofVigi a e e e a tm por rrr sr i ng or r Se ( L S i ly I .Co.v. u a
ur or he se
szc
r ni nt r d e
a .! e tani de . e X peca t ns
Tr l nd,

No. :4 0 8J J A, 01 WL4 3 3 8 a * (. . . g 2 , 0 4. to g tiato ddn tn ov a
11 CV1 5 CC/F 2 4
2 0 8 ,t 5 .. Va Au . 1 2 1 )Alh u h ls cin i o iv le
FD
t
s et' rghtt a c sr c ds t c tsras i i s
ur ys i o c es e or , he our' e onng n uppor ofaf ngofirpa a eham i a l us
t
mdi
re r bl r s naogo :

Pli t f a en t e evn t eb nei o t i b r an gfd fn nt g e igt
an i s r o r c iig h e ft f h s ag i o ee da a r en o
f
p e g c l trl, st e a ec e l fcn s bsa t lu c l trl e e po u e
ld e o l eaj a h y r mrnt a ig u tn i , n ol eai d x s r
a
y
a
a z
fom ove sxtr li sa i tt bonds Co lt r ls c iy i mea t pr e t
r
r i .yc am gans he
. la e a e urt s nt o ot c
a i tt sver rs Abs nte or e e oft c lac a s c iyoblga
gans hi y ik. e nf c m nt he o lt r l e urt i éon,
Pli if woul bei t s poston a a y ot vt ec e c ec t oft
antfs
d t he ame ii s n he ms ur d t l or he
a
i
D e e nt . pos mone da a esa e i de t t pr e tPli if '
f nda s Ex t
y m g r na qua e o ot c a ntf s
ex ctnc a t ve y esenc ofc l t r li t s f gu r t s e y f om l s
pe a s s he r s e ola e a s o a e a d he ur t r os es
be or i i r uie t dic r a c am s
f e t s eq r d o s ha ge ny li .

J a + ( tra ctto so te )Asp r o tetmpoayrsrii od rteculo d rda ac u t go t
és t 4 i en l iain mi d . at fh e rl etanng re,h o ' r ee n co ni fhe
n
t
t
n
def nda ' as e sbe a e wihoutt a c i ,f antfsha no i awhet a wha ex e D ef nt c n
e nts s t c us , t
he c ountngs f i if ve de
pl
hez nd
t t nt enda s a
s ts y t i i m niyoblg i orwhe he a s t de e ntpl dg d t hol i tus f t Pli if ha be n
a if her nde t
iaton
t r s e s f nda e e o d n r t or he a ntf s ve e
ta f red. 1 RLIf c sm ia unc rante he e
r ns e r ' d.
'
a es i l r e ti is r .

20

books r cor and a ount connot sir pa a e har de i ng I , oft ba ga ned-ot
, e ds
cc
s
e r e r bl m prvi UI he r i f
a lt t f fl isoblga i unde t szet bonds a s sisrs and t ke se t pr e
biiy o ulil t i tons
r he lr y
, s es t ik,
a t ps o ot ct
is l a i tf ur la lt RT,' Sus m an sa e a t Aprl27 he rng t t11, ne d t
t ef ga ns ut e ibiip Is s
t t d t he i
a i ha 1 1 ede o
r viw N e ' e dsi or t dee nanewhet ri i s f enty c lt r ied t
e e
xus r cor n der o tr i
he t s ufki l ola e alz o

p otc 111fom l b l y For n i a c u a Fa casae a t J 7 h aig t t1.1
r e t 1 , r i ii . e sc c o ntnt s i ttd t he une e rn ha 1 ,
a t
1
ha notr ceve s fce i or a i t da e f hi t r
s
e i d ufi int nf m ton o t or m o ende a opi on a
r n ni boutis
t

labiiy butexpr s d c
i lt ,
es e once nsa
r boutt va fna ili or aton pt de W hiet r
he gue i nca nf m i
ovi d. l he e
i a diput a
s s e boutwhe he N e m e isc l t r lobl tonss f t i t I m niy
t r xus t t ola e a
i i
ga
et orh n he nde t
Agr m e ,i i cea t t cour t tRLIf il i c
ee nt t s l r o he
t ha
ary s once ne a
r d boutN e 's venc Rlls
xus ol y. a'

pa e ofcam sa pe lison eghtbonds t i r asng te ofnotcesoflt
ym nt li nd nate
i
, he nc e i r nd
i
ae
pa m e s t of e ofar ym e pln sn ia t ot rs ete t r qtie us ofc rii
y nt, he f r
epa nt a ialr o he ur i s hat e lr e e tfed
chec ,a t ongoi i si tonsby a t ne ge r l lda et sc
ks nd he
ng nve tga i
tor ys ne a vai t hi once n.The ef e
r
r or ,

a mo yd ma e aonec udde rveRI1ofteprjd me rle t whc ii
s ne a g s l o l pi , h eu g nt eif o ih ts
conta ual e il RT1hasce ry de ons r t d t rs ofir pa a e ha m .
r ct ly ntted, ,
la l m
ta e he ik r e r bl r

11, as cam sl sofgoodwiland f r isr ltons p wih t Tr as ywilbe
1 - lo li os
1
l
ea s t ea i hi t hc e ur l
da a by N e 'contnue dei
m ged
xus
i d lnque esi s tsy ng t bonds R1, ct st Four h
nci n aif i he
. 1 ie o
t
Cic tc e lw s
t ui as a uppori da a sf al sofgoodwil butdoesnotct Ilnoi lw.I i
tng m ge or os
l,
ie li s a t s
uncla whet rda a f l sofgoodwile s unde Ilnoi lw . .D a Co .v.
er
he m ges or os
l xit
r li s a Cf cor

S er Pr cso ,7 3F. u 7 1 7 3 ( D. 1 1 91 (Duet t es c lt nau eof
ira e ii n 5 S pp. 3 , 3 N. 11 9 ) d
.
( o h pe u ai t r
ve
s h ada g r q e tl s of od li n c mpe a l i ac nta ta ton. Ch se
uc
ma e e u s, o s go wi s ot o ns b e n o rc ci 7
l
);
lr

Co . E. a i & S ns 5 6 F. 7 3 7 6( t Ci. 9 6 ( e i r c veyf l so
r v. Sh vz o , 3 2d 4 , 4 7h r 1 7 ) d nyng e o r or os f
pr is r ul i f om l s ofgoodwilunderPe yl ni l w ,a s atng t t Ilnoi
oft es tng r
os
l
nns va a a nd t i ha li s

21

c rswo d h d smewa ) I a ye e t 111h sno de srt da t ssa eoft e
ou t ul ol a
y. n n v n ,1 , a t mon tae t hi tg h
ltgaton t i f ce ir pa a er put tona da a W hie t c zti nnndf ofR1,'
ii i hat t a s t e r bl e a i l m ge. l he otr s i ul
Is
a gum e t l t pa m e st t gove nm enta s e ntdelnque i r por e t
r
nt hat ae y ùt o he
r
nd ubs que
i nces e t d o
t Tr s .!coul ha m isr put ton, t cam sofr put tona ha m a et s c a i at
he ea urr
d r t e a i is li
e a i l r r oo pe ultve

t ssa t s
hi t ge o uppor afndi ofir pa a eha m .
t i ng r e r bl r 6
The e it
x senceofl sofgood l da a i notnec s a y a t spr lnlna y
os
wil m ges s
e s r t hi ei i r

i uncin sa egve Rllss o ngoft eirpa a l ham ofisl ti ei tg st
nj to tg i n w' h wi
h re r b e r
t os ntrm iht o
r viw books t or a a ount . Ice l ha dem onsr t d ir r bl ha m t ough
e e
, ec ds nd cc
s Rl, laty s
t a e repa a e r ht
isi lt t s r c t bondsand pr e is fa i tt out t ng bond la lt due
t nabiiy o e vie he
ot ct tel gans he sandi
ibiiy

t N e 'f iur t pr de a ce st isr or .
o xus al e o ovi c s o t ec ds
C.

N e ,t c tm us baa e t e zte t as es t ha m sf i 10t pa tes I
xt he our
t lnc he qtii s o s s he r acng 3 h ri . n
t sc e t c tfndst t baa e ofe te weghsi f vorofRT,. a e s d
hi as , he our i
hat he lnc
quii s i n a
1 As ddr s e

a
bove RLIha s
,
s hown t 1w a f ct ce ry fvorisposton f isbr c ofconta
he a nd a s la l a
t
ii ot t ea h
r ct
cli .Furher RI, ha de onsr ed ir pa a e ha m t ough isl sofi e i
am
t , I s m tat re r bl r hr
t os
nt rm
conta ua tg st r viw books r c dsa a ount . hiet cout f
t ct l i ht o e e
, e ot nd cc
s W l he
t ound t put tona
e ai l

ham t bet o s e ult a t i sa et c nsi eir p r bl i u y 111do sfc t e
r o o p c ai t hs tg o o tmt re a a e njr ,1- e a e h
ve
,
rs of nu yt isbu i s rlt hi wih t g ve n ntd t isd l ue p y nt
ik i jr o t sne s eai p t he o r me ue o t ei nt a me s
ons
nq
f bond cli s
or
am .
6The l sofg
os
oodwi ori usr r putton <i awelr c g z d ba i f indi ir pa a l ha ' n t Fo t
l nd t y e a i f
l
s
l- e o ni e ss or
ng r e r b e nn'i he urh

Cicl . e M ir AieS r ia I sr me sLLC v Arh e , n .7 6F. u p. ( 6 4 6 5( . . . 0 0 . we e,
rt tS e c o r u gc l n tu nt.
i
. tr x I c, 2 S p 21 0 , 3 W D Va 2 1 ) Ho v r
co t r uie s ii e de eco e n ng t a t a orpot néa l sofbusnes orgood l be or f di ir pa a e
ur s eq r pecfc vi nc nc r i he c u l
e l os
i s
wil f e m ng r e r bl

ijr S e e .S ateFl h S o t . . n o Ava nLt P' i, 0 9WL 1 1 0 ,t*-5T. VaJn.
nup e . i tr i t u r Co v La d w ido d. s 2 0
z
h
1 6 3 a 2 . .a
D.
1 a 0 9. p ryd e n h v t etbih'p cfclsey b fuf in e ie efrh Co r t f dt tts
4 2 0 )A at o s ot a e o sa l ' eii o ss' utf fi e t vd nc o te u to i ha ii
s s
' s c
n
lkeyt ts hl sshav oc ure orwil urabsntprlmi yi unci r l 'Pr co e t LLC,2 3WL
i l ha uc ose e c rd
locc
e ei nar nj tve ei
ef' o- nc s
01
5741 ,a * .To dat RLIha notm e isbu de undert ssa r
542 t 21
e,
s
tt r n
hi t nda d.

22

N e a guest tor tngi t pr vi r or a ce st 1 . c d s ve el ha m is
xus r
ha de i t o o de ec d c s o 111 oul e r y r t
busnes be us isi r gr i cint r l on N e t m ant i t i i or a i
i s ca e t m ni aton le s ey
xus o i an he r nf m ton

c i e il . rsha eb e r l tntt g a i j cier l fi t ed fnd n '
onfd ntal Cou t v e n euca o rnt nun t ei f h e e a ts
y
v e
busnes coul nots vve t t uli c t . SeeW is cook M e ,l .v. it k M ed.
i s
d
ur i he es tng os s
lond. nc W le
.

l c, . 0 2 1 ,1 91N 27 5 , t+ (t Ci. a. ,1 91 ( rc ra (firi g
n .No 9 - 9 1 9 vL 1 0 a 2 4h r M r 6 9 ) pe u im) afrrn
n
d na ofa i u to whcep ei nayr l fwo l ha aJ e t pe lyef c'o
e il n njncin r r lni r ei ud ve f ah nat fe t' n
t
e
d
d fnda ) F. C. Ve iyI ' Lt .1 4F. p 211 3 2 4 ( D. Y. 0 )( i t a
e e nt; T. v. rt nt, d, 2 Su p. ( 9 , 0 S. N. 20 0 not h t
l
ng
cour ss d be r l a <t i pos w ha naghtbea c m e ca de t s nt nc a a
t houl
e uctnt <o m
e
t i
om r i l a h e e e t n

i e l u or sa i t r i s m er a o bl atr tv 7 Ye, h c u tc cude t t
ntroc t y tge f he e s o e s na e le naie). t t e o r on l s ha
N e 'f a sofir r bl hann fom pr di i or a i pur ua t a c r c a e
xus e r
tepa a e
r
ovi ng nf m ton s nt o ont a t r
lke s s cul i l a e ,t c tca pr e a i tt dic os eofN exus
i wie pe atve. n ny vent he our n ot ct gans he s l ut
'
i or a i t ough apr e i or r N orha N e esa ihe t t c t of
nf m ton hr
ot ctve de .
s xus t bls d hat he oss
pr di 11, a es t isr or a ept bii .
ovi ng 1 1 cc s o t ec ds t ohi tve
The cour r ogni t ts ve a pa te ha m ove t i e e asdef nda si
t ec zes ha e r l r is ve
d o nt w ne
e nt n
tlsac i a ha notha an oppor uniyf a g e a is ss r
li ton nd ve
d
t t or r um nt s s ue ur ound t i lga
her e l
r pr s nt ton.To pr ec t i pot ili e cssi t sa i t cour willl tRlls
e e e ai
ot t her enta nt r t n hi cton, he
t li
ni w '
ac es t books r or a a ount t t e be rng on N e 'fna i lcondii a
c so
, ec ds nd cc
s o hos a i
xus l nca
ton nd
a lt t s ts yisoblga i unde t I m niyAg e e a ttspr lnana ys a .RT,
biiy o a if t
i tons
r he nde t r em nt t li e i i r t ge 1

ha notpr ded s f e r as t s
s
ovi
ufki nt e ons o uppor isalge nee f pe s
t t le d d or r onal nf m aton
i or i
a
boutbond hol s s h as t i c r ntl a i ,e pl m ent s a us or c i i
der - uc
he r ur e oc tons m oy
t t , r nnnal

c t
ha ges i or rt pr e a i tir pa a e ha m , nii t isl s , pr e is
n de o ot ct gans t e r bl r r tga es t os es ot ot ct t
r put i The rs ofdicos e oft ss nstvei or a i i gr a t t pa te s edng
e aton.
ik
s l ur
hi e ii nf m ton s e t o he r is e l

23

t i e v nea i c ul jo r iet i a it t r mani t Untd S ae . s don
o ntr e s t o d e pa dz her bl y o e i n he ie tt s Ba e
i
Sus m a st tm ony att Aprl27 hea i ,RLIprm a i nc a es t fna a r or
s n' esi
he
i
rng
i rl eds cc s o i ncil ec ds
y
t al a f e i cons t ntt as e swhe he 1. 1i a e t m ee isoblga i unde t
o low or nsc
ula o s s
t r 11 s bl o
.
tt
i tons
r he
l m niyAgr em e , ncl ng t pr son ofa qua c c l e a . r or at
nde t
e nt i udi he ovii
de t olatr l The ef e, lhough

t scour wilr t N ex t pr
hi
t l equie
us o oduc orpt dea es t doc e s i willn i t
e
ovi cc s o um nt, t l ilt he

s o ofno fna il u n sa s bjc al r du e o r v e d d u n st a
c pe
n-i nca doc me t nd u e t lp o c d r e iwe oc me t o
pr ec i or r
ot tve de .
Ass h,afe com pa i t l sofi e i c r c ua rght a t put tona ha m
uc t r
rng he os
ntrm onta t l i s nd e a i l r
f ed by lLlx t N e 'c t ofpr
ac
1 vih xus oss
oduc i a conc r ofconfde ilt a
ton nd
e ns
i ntaiy, nd
c i rng t ot rl ii at i e essa s a i l ng t eoft pa te s e ng t
onsde i he he eg tm e ntr t t t ke ncudi hos
he ri s e ki o

i e v ne t ec t tfnd t a t b ln eofe ute warnt a ij to
ntr e , h oz i s h t he aa c
r
q iis ra s n nuncin.
D.

Fi l ,t- mus s w t a t pu i i ee tfvo sa i u ton. p bl i
nal 111 t ho h t he bl ntr s a r n njnci Thc u i s
y ,
c
c
be ts r ed whe cour se or e pr sonsofvai c r ct.Se S ih Br edon Co.v.
s ev
n
t nf c ovii
ld onta s e nlt
a

Ha d 8 F.d7 7 79 (t C9.9 7 (rjemos e ihe e j iil l yi t 1t
di, 25 2 8 , 0 4h 1 8 ) ffh
f
t nl tn d udca poi s o e
g
c
pe em a ge t i own busnes i t i own wa unl s t gr
opl na her
i s n her
y, e s hc ound f i e f e e i
or nt rer nc s

v r ce t' S ei rPe f r r I c v. e ie No. :3 CV- 1 j 2 1 W L 1 2 3 , t
e y la. u ro ro me s n . M ak , 11 - 1 4 , 0 4
);
41 4 4 a
+ 6 ( . . . Apr 1 , 01 )(rlh pu ci tr s i sr e b e u i gt t l
1 M D N C. . 1 2 4 ç l e bh n e e t s e v d y ns rn ha vai
f
d
c nta t aee o c d.) I Ta , n . Ge a iNo. 1 - 2 6 2 4N 49 5 7 , t
o rc s r nf r e ' ; TH x l c v. r c, 2:4 CV- 3 , 01 VL 5 3 3 a
'
+ I D , . t 2 2 4 ( rl pu i i ee twi b s trdbyr qz i pate t vau
8 E. Va Oc. , 01 ) E f he bl ntt s l c eae
<
c
l
e trng ris o le
i
t s nciyofc ta t';
he a tt on r c. UBS Pan b r I . Ai e 1 7 F. u 2 4 , 4
)
iwe be . nc v. k n, 9 S pp. d 36 4 8
( . . . 20 2 (( pubi h sa i e e tn e s rngt a c nta t aee o c d.
W D N C. 0 ) <
The l a n ntr s i n u i h t o r cs r nf r e 7
c
).

24

Som ecout sha vi we e or e e ofconta pr sonst ough apr lm i r
t ve e d nf c m nt
r ct ovii hr
ei na y

ij c i a ne tln r g r t t epu i i e e t S e eg, mihs.
nun t s uta i e ads o h bl ntr s. e . ..S t T Ne or Ne
on
c
t ws

S i bull He lhPln l c,1 F. u 2 6 7 6 3 2 0 WL 69 1 ( D. . 0 )
h ii
c n at a n . 48 S pp. d 3 , 5 , 0 1
45 8 E. Va 2 01.
H owe r N e adnlt isconta ua oblga i t pr deatl as s e fna ilr c ds
ve , xus
is t
r ct l i ton o ovi
e t om i nca e or ,

y hasunia e a l dc i t notg a a ces untlt cour ' i ve e .Such a fa a
et
lt r ly c ded o
r nt c s i hc
ts nvol m nt
lgr nt

r jci of t o i ton f rmo et n ay a c n tbec nsd r d n u rlo abe f t
ee t
on is bl i s o r ha e r a no
ga
o i e e e ta r nei o
t
t publc
he
i.

Ne usc ntr t tt epu t i e e ti n s r e byap eianayij t
x ou e s ha h bi ntr s s ot e v d
c
r l i r nunci
n
on
be us RT1s e detie i or aton a
ca e , e ks al d nf m i boutt bond hol r . ot ton ofc i nta
he
de s Pr ec i
onfde i l
pe s li or a i c t i yi i t publc i er s .Cf Hom e Fundi G
r ona nf m ton eranl s n he
i nt e t .
n

.LLC v.

M--c , 10 CV1 0 CC, 00 WL 6 4 9 3 a * ( D. . c 1 , 0 )(r j e
y-q No. :6 4 0J 2 6
e
8 7 5 , t 3 E. Va De . 4 2 06 tf h
publc i e es i s rv by al ng fr st pr e tta s cr sa c i il
i nt r t s e ed
lowi lm o ot c r de e et nd onfdenta

i o m ain, nd b p o i ig af u t s e tmp a yi u t r l ft e on a
nf r to a y r v dn or m o e k e orr njnci ei o nji ny
ve e
f t rbr c ordicos e, ental c usng ir par bl ha m a de toyi i ntve
urhe ea h
s l ur pot ily a i r e a e r nd s r ng ncc i s

t t v t. Howe e , h si or to i bengs r dwihac mpa yt tNe usee td
o nno a e'
).
v r t i nf main s i ha e t o n ha x lce
t e gc i busnes wih a conta ed wih t pr deisibooks r or a a count .'
o nga n i s t nd
r ct
t o ovi t < -, ec ds nd c
s'
I i dii
t s sngenuoust r l on t publci e es i notr l a i i or a i des t e e i
o ey
he
i ntr t n
e e sng nf m ton pie nt rng

i o ac ta tt d j tt t Th sc u tc n p otc t ep l ' i e e t l t t e
nt on r c o o us ha. i o r a r e t h ubi s ntr s by i i h
c
ming
a ountofi or a i dicos a i tt i apr e tve or r Thepublci nots r d
m
nf m ton s l ed nd ns iutng
ot c i
de .
i s
e ve
by ba r ng ac s t i or a
ri
ce s o nf m don ba ga ned f by c r cta pr e t by c i nta iy
r i
or
ont a nd ot c ed
onfde i lt

percour or r I l oft spr edent t c tfndst tRT, hasm etisbur n t
t de . n i
ght hi ec
, he ouz i
ha
1
t
de o

s t tap einna yi u to wo d fvo t ep bh i tr s.
how ha r l i r njncin ul a r h u c n e e t
r

111h sde nsr td al ou W i e pr g i s ppo tofaprl ana yi u to
1. a mo tae lf r ntr on s n u r
ei i r njncin
n
and t c ts l or rN e t pr de a ce st a a a1ofisbooks r cor a
he our hal de
xus o ovi c s o ny nd l t
, e ds nd

a c un sd t fo t o e ofNe us a RI1sbu i e sr lton hi o a a y20
c o t ai r m he ns t
ng
x ' nd ,' sn s eai s p nl nu r ,
2016 be rng on N e 'fna ilc
ai
xus i nc a ondii a a lt t s tsy isobl tonsunde t
ton nd biiy o ai f t
i i
ga
r he

I m niyAgr m ent N e m us as pr vi a e st t bondst m s l s aong wih
nde t
ee
. xus
t lo o de cc s o he
he eve , l
t
any a al doc e sr a i t t sa usofany 11, bonds i udi docum e sr l i
nd l um nt eltng o he t t
11
, ncl ng
nt eatng
t br ac c lton,f f iur orpe li s Gi RTIsconc r t tN e ha c nged
o e h, ancea i or et e,
nate . ven ,'
e ns ha xus s ha
orwilc ngehow t i r cor a e m anti
l ha
he r e ds r
i aned,t c tor r N e t pr de a ce st
he our de s xus o ovi c s o
t books r cor a a count a t y we em ant i on t dat offlng oft m oton
he
, e ds nd c
s s he r
i ancd
he e li
he
i

f rp einna yi u to Ap i 1 , 01 .
o r l i r njncin- rl 2 2 8
r
I
V.

Pu s nt o Fe e a Rul ofCiiPr c d r 65c, dstc c u tmus f abo
rua t d t l e
vl o e u e () a itit o r
ti
x nd

whe ve i g a t apr l ln r i jncin fn a a un t tt ec r c ie spr pe t
ne r t r n s ei ia y nu to < n mo t ha h ou t onsd r o t o
n
i

pa t c t a da g ss ti db a ypat fun t h v be nwr gfl e jie o
y he oss nd ma e usane y n ry o d o a e e on ul non d r
y
r tane ' <fhe pur e oft bond i t pr des c iy f a da a r s tng fom
esr i d.' f '
pos
he
s o ovi e urt or ny m ges e uli r

a i o i nt g a t di u to 'Ra c I us, n . Ra ko No. :7 CV- 9 20 7
n mpr vde l r n e njncin. u h nd .I c v. d , 30 - 1 7C, 0
y
'
W L 3 2 6 , t* ( . N . Oc. 5 2 0 ) < hea un oft bo t n, dnai
1 4 47 a 8 W D. C. t 2 , 0 7 .f mo t he nd,he ot i tl
x'
y

de ndso t eg a ijoft epo e il t t t ee one p ry'Hoe hs Dif i Co.
pe n h rv t h tnta ham o h nji d a t.
r
' c t aol v.
Na YaPlsisCor . 1 4 F.d 4 1 4 1n. ( h Ci. 9 9 . d src c r h s
n
a tc
, 7 3 1 , 2 3 4t r 1 9 ) The itit ou t a
di c eton i fxi t a ount f orw avi t s c iy bond.I ;s e a s Pa hb v.
s r i n i ng he m
or
i ng he e urt
d. e l o s

unde s a ed bond c d ca e it pa abl ha m on t gr
ttt
oul us r e r e r
he ound t tfhe da a s f a
ha t
m ge or n

26

er ne prl iayi u toncnno e c e tea un oft bon ' La Co .
ro ous ei n r njnci a t x ed h mo t he d.' b.
nl
'
of
Am . dn sv. a ns 8 F. u 3 4 , 6 ( . N. 2 15 ( u ig Me dJ ns n
Holi
Ke r , 4 S pp. d 47 46 M D. C. 0 ) q otn a oh o

& Co. AbbotLa .2 F.d8 3 8 8(t Ci. 0 0)Thceor, src jdg sae
v.
t bs, 01 3 8 , 8 7h r2 0 ). rf e dititu e r
ç lie byt p pos u e ligRue6 () whih i t pr vieame ha im f r
ç zd d he ur e nd ryn l 5c , c s o o d
g
c ns o

ri ri ga e j nc pat f rt h r i s ft a ar s l ofa i r v d nt is e
embu sn n noi d ry o he am t ufe s s e ut n mp o i e l su d
y
i j c in. Ho c t 1 4 F.d a 4 3n..
nun to ' e hs, 7 3 t 2 3
'
Att Aptl27 he rng,t cour a ke t pa te f a gum e a e de
he i
a i he
t s d he ti s or r
nt nd vi nce

rg r i ga a pr raea un ofbo pu s a t Fe e a Ru eofCii Pr e u e6 ()
e a d n n p op it mo t
nd r u nt o d r l l
vl oc d r 5 c.
Ne rquesedabond ofa las $29r li whi i t a
xus e t
te t
nilon, ch s he mountRLIwoul ha t pa
d ve o y

i alofisbondsdea td perSusma st tmony.kLlaguedt t$29miloni
f l t
fule
s n' esi
l r
ha
li s
unr s bl,pa tc a l gi t tt pur e ofa bond i i t cour l e fndsN e
ea ona e ri ulry ven ha he pos
s f he
t atr i
xus

di notha a c t c ua oblga i t al i pe i ofisbooks r or and a ount.
d
ve ont a t l i ton o low ns cton t
, ec ds
cc
s
W ihoute de e a ltl a gum e fom e t rpa t ,a a t rt pa te r m aned
t
vi nc nd ite r
nt r
ihe r y nd fc he r is e i
una e t r ol t i diput f l ng cour - de e m e aton,t c ts he ed a
bl o es ve he t s e olowi
tor r d di i he our c dul n

e i e ipr ai gf J ne7t stt a o ntofa a r ptaeb
v d nta he rn or u
o e he m u
n pp o it ond. u e f r11,
Co ns l o 1 1
a gue f a nor na bond bec us t I m niyAgt m e r r sN e t pr de t
r d or
ni l
a e he nde t
ee nt equie
xus o ovi he
books r or a a ount,a be a e a pr e tve or rc pr e a i tt i
, ec ds nd cc
s nd c us
ot c i
de an ot ct gans het
c i ilt c e ns N e a gued t tt bond s d be s tt t a ounti t
onfdentaiy onc r . xus r
ha he
houl
e o he m
t akest
o

r ac R1Iasas et i t e
epl e ,
ur y, n he ventt tN e ha t r pl c RLIbe us ofisde a t
ha xus s o e a e
ca e t m nd o
i pe doc e s N e t r pa t puton a e de e a t t a ount ofbond,i udi
ns ct um nt . i he r y
ny vi nc s o he m
ncl ng

t c tt N e t pr de 1 - a ce st i pe tisbooks r or a ac ount.
he os o xus o ovi 111 c s o ns c t
,
, ec ds nd c
s

The c tfndst tt cossa da a st N e a elt t d t t c t of
our i
ha he t nd m gc o xus r inie o he oss
com pl ngw ih pr
yi
t oducng orpr di a c st isbooks t c dsa a ount t Rl,.
i
ovi ng c es o t
, e ot nd cc
so 1

N e 't
xus eques f a$ l li bondi notbasd on a c denc a i e e svegi
t or 29 nilon
s
e
ny vi e nd s xc si ven
t tN e 'onl deti e i c pla ewih t c r c i e e e i o wih RLI Suc
ha xus y tm nt s om inc t he ont a t t nt r d nt t
. h

c pla e i notm one a iy c pa a et R'lsrs wih t bonds Thecour doe not
om inc s
t rl om r bl o L ' ik t he
.
t s
a ce N e 'a gum e t ti m a ne t obt i ane s e y asN exuspr e e no
c pt xus r
nt ha t y ed o an
w ur t ,
es nt d

e de e oft sposi lt a t he rngsa 111ha noti ca e t ti i e
vi nc
hi
sbiiy t he a i
nd 1 . s
ndi t d ha t nt nded t pul
o l
outoft e bonds M or ove ,al rbond a ounti a oprat gve t t 1w a
hes
.
e r owe
m
s ppt i e i n hat he a nd
f ct c e ry f vorRtlsposton.Bot pa tesr c ni t Pa a a 3 al sf a l s
a s la l a
v'
ii
h ri e og ze hat r gr ph low or t ea t

s e fnancildoc e st be pt
om i
a
um nt o
oduc D es t t sa
ed. pie hi cknowldgem e ,a aye '
e
nt nd
ars
worh ofr que t,N e s one le RT1 r zrng i t fl s t
t
e s s xus t wald ,, eqkii t o ie ui.

Gi n t tt c tt pr de a e st docum e sf pr
ve ha he os o ovi cc s o
nt or oducton i notlkey t be
i s
i l o
g e t ora las no e de e ofs h acos ha be n pr s nt and N e i hi y unlkey
r a, t e t
vi nc
uc
t s e e e ed,
xus s ghl
i l
t f c ha m gi t ti i conta t al oblga e t pr de s ac s ,t cour s l s
o a e r ven ha t s
r c u ly i t d o ovi uch ce s he
t hal et
anot na a ountf t bond.
ni l m
or he
TheFoath Cic tand c t i t s diti tha
t r ui
our s n hi stc ve

r ognied t ta nor na bond s fce whe e t rs ofha m i r m ot .SeeH oe hs ,174
ec z ha
ni l
ufi s
r he ik
r se e
c t

F.d a 4 n. (ppr v n dsrc c u tsfxn bon a nta z r i t a e eo
3 t 21 3 a o i g itit o r' iig d mou t e o n he bs nc f
e i nc rg r i l ei oo ofham) s eas Ca dl Fa t I c v Tr d Aso s G .
vde e e a dng i l d
k h
r ; e lo n e co n . . a e s c .

Lt , F. x 1 4 1 9 (t Ci. 0 )( r l ditit o r' de ii n t f abo i
d.23 App' 3 , 3 4. r 2 01 < f he src c u ts cso o i
h
f
x nd n
t s of$5 w a a a opra e e r ie ofisdic e i a isfndi t TAG
he um
00 s n ppr it xe cs
t s r ton, nd t i ng hat

woud s frltl h r i e one fom f rh rs ln isi rn i gs a hels pe c nde
l ufe i e a m f nji d r u t e el g t nfig n e s l ha d a ls
t
i
i no ce rye r e us' S. C. Do l No. V. 301
s t lal ron o . E. v. wdel
);
, CI A. : CV00 1 , 0 2V'
1620 L

28

3 3 7 5 , t 4( D. . t 1 , 0 )(W heetec r deemie t tt ts of
1 5 0 9 a * W. Va Oc. 1 2 02 T t h out tr n s ha he ik
f
ha m i r m ot or t t c r s ance ot r s w a r nti,t cour m a s ta nor na
r s e e, hat he icum t s he wi e r a t he
t y e
ni l

bond. cor ngl t Rec i rs l pos abondass urt i t a
Ac di y,he eve hal t
ec iy n he mountof$100. 1
00.
'

( ena ctto onit dl CaDit 1 Unie Mi W o k r o Am. A & M Tr l
i r l iain nte l;. s. 7 td ne r e s f v.
nt
f
ucdn
l .9 F.d 1 8 1 1(t Ci. 9 3 ( i c r' d sr to t s tabon a ntof
nc, 91 2 0 , 1 4 h r 1 9 ) not ou ts ic ein o e
ng
d mou
z r ) Sr i ry c ursi t i d src h ves tbo co e t ap antf pr pos d a unt
e o . inl l, o t n h s itit a e nds ls r o li ips o e mo
a
whe ea def nda hasnotpr ent s c fce de e ofda a a pr
r
e nt
es ed pe ii vi nc
m ges nd opos sabond
e

a untn b s d o ispo e il ma sfo t ij c in. e Mer Re lI o. y .
mo ot a e n t tnta da ge r m he nun to S e to. g' nf S s,
I . Am.HomeRe lyNea or l .9 4F. u p. d 5 0 5 6 7 ( M d. 01 ) a fd,
nc v.
at t k, nc, 0 S p 2 3 , 3 -3 1
' v
3. 2 2 , f
7 2F. 5 1( h Ci. 01 )(et bo a un cos t pan if p op a wh r
2 3d 9 4t r 2 3 s ti nd mo t l e o li tf' r os l e e
ng
s

d fnd ntsT ac ai a p o e sc rt a un aeno bae one ji n
ee a ' f lultons nd r posd e uiy mo t r t sd nonig
c
ge e a ')us ofg an ifs c py ih e ph o rphs'dee a tsat dt c l b
d fnd nts e plitf' o rg t d ot g a ' fnd n tte o ompy y
l
,
r m ovi phot ,a def nda di inotpr s nt d a s cik e de e ofda a
e
ng
os nd e nt d f
e e e ny pe f vi nc
m ges

s ti d d t t t mo l Ac or i l, sNe usi o yr q ie t c ywihis
usane ue o he e va' c dngy a x s nl e u rd o ompl t t
).
c r tzloblga i t al i pec i ofisr or a hass tf t no e dence oft
ontac ta
i ton o low ns ton t ec ds nd
e orh
vi
he

c t ofcompla e t c tfndst ta$1 000bondi afi and a opraes urt
oss
inc , he our i ha
0,
s at
ppr it ec iy
a ountgi n t i s pr s nt d i t sc e a t pot nta c t ofdoc ent
m
ve he s ues e e e n hi as nd he e il os s
um

pr du t S eHo c t 1 4F.d a 4 (x anngt a as c iys l c ve t
o ci e e hs, 7 3 t 21 e plii h t e urt houd o r he
on.
pot nta i i a a cons que ilc t a et rt l s fom t def nda beng
e il nc dentl nd
e nta os s nd ihe he os es r
he e nt i

r sti d ott a e s t ben u j tye rc d .
e tane
he dv r a' ig nusl n ihe l7
y
?Ath e dofh Apr 2 a dJ n 7h a g, x su h asa o t ijn t nt alw fta itro uoy
te n te i 7 n u e edn sNeus o g t ty fhenu ci o l o n nelc tr
l
o
o
a
ppea t t Fourh Cic t N et rpa t s bsa i l a gue orpr e ed e de e i s ppo tofa sa a t
l o he
t r ui. ihe r y u t ntvey r d
es nt vi nc n u r
t y t he
he rngs Ass h,t c ti unwi i t e e as a att i tm e l N e de ie as a t c ur wi r viw moto
a i . uc he our s
l ng o nt r ty h s i . f xus sr s ty, he o t l e e
l
l
i ns
s
ubmit d pur ua t t Fe r lRul sofCii Pr e e a isl a m l .
te
s nt o he de a e
v l oc dur nd t oc l es

V.

Durn t J ne7he rn ,hec r notf d t pat ofisc i rton of
ig he u
ai g t ou t ii he ry t onsdeai
e
a ntng a s ilm a t r a pr de t m t opporuniy t c entt a s ca
ppoi i
peca s e , nd ovi d he he
t t o ons o pe il

ma t t Thepate fld no e ofc ns ntt as ca ma tro J e 1 .
se .
ris i
e dc s o e o pe il se n un 1 ECF No . 8 49
s4- .
N exuscons nt t a a count ntr viwi isbooks r cor a a count e r ot r
e ed o n c
a e e ng t
, e ds nd c
s ve y he
We
dnes y,a ag e t f iia er vi w ofdoc e sfom ot rN e -e aed e ii
da nd r ed o aclt t e e
um nt r
he
xus r l t nttes
s h a Li e by N e .
uc s br
xus Thenotces
i oughtr ton ofat ne a ot rlga i or ai
edaci
tor y nd he e l nf m ton,

r qtied s a es t be bound by c i ntaiy a r quie RLInott us s h
e lr uch cc s o
onfde ilt , nd e r d
o e uc

i or aton t a r t de t c us t a r s ,orc us t de t ton ofany bonde
nf m i o r es, por , a e he r e t
a e he por a i
d

i ii ua. No. 8 a 2 4. w r s ond d t Ne u ' tc a d o e t dt t
ndv d lECF 4 , t - RlI e p e o x s no ie n bjce o he
r da ton offna i lt a a i wih a t ne a lw fr sa N e 'd t m pt t
e ci
i nc a r ns ctons t tor ys nd a lm nd xus f e s o
at

r d eisbr a c nta t l k ai . ECF No. , t3 De pi t s o e to ,
e uc t o d o rcua obl t '
ons '
49 a . s t he e bjcins RLl
e
c ns ntd t as ca ma trs bjc t t f lwigc ndton :()t a i m e ofa
o e e o pe il se u e t o he ol n o ii s 1 he ppont nt
o
s calm ase wih e r iei f e i a ountng a e re ei s e y bondsa
pe i
t r t xpe ts n or nsc cc
i nd xpe i nc n ur t
nd

cams ()t es ca ma ttsa it t pt e d dl e tya ha ea t rz t t e a nne
li ; 2 h pe il se ' bl y o oc e ig n l nd v u ho iai o x ni
i
i
on
N e 'doc e s i l ng a horz i t i si e de e r ne,a of e
xus
um nt, ncudi ut i aton o nve tgat, t rni nd f r

rc
e omme to a utt es op ofNe us bo sc
ndains bo h c e
x ' ok ompa e t isr ltd e ie ;()t
r d o t eae nt is 3 he
t
s calm ase ' pe nls i t ha e pa t c
pe i
t rs r ison o ve x re onununi tonsvzt t cour a s i
ca i
ih he
t nd ubnlt

wc kyr po t t bo h t c u ta t pate ;a d ()Ne usc mpe ai t es e il
e l e rs o t he o r nd he ris n 4 x o ns t h p ca
ng
m ase .ECF N o.49,a 1
tr
t -2.
The c thoped t ta s c a m ase c d be a nt d i le oft e r ofa
our
ha pe i l t r oul
ppoi e n iu he nty

pr l an r i u ton butt mae il e msoft p ris c nsnt re s fce ty
ei i a y njnci , he tra t r
n
he a t ' o e vaid ufiin l
e

s ii ly RI1sc ts fi pt son a t ni um t t m e sf t s il
pec fcal ,' os- hitng ovii nd ni m
equie nt ot he peca
m ase - t t c tcoul notvi w t notc asm ee i Fe r lRul ofCi l
t r hat he our
d
e he ics
tng de a
e
vi

Pr e r 5 a ()A)sal n eofa i me twheet es ca ma trf e f m gj
oc du e 3()1( ' l
owa c
ppont n
r h pe il se d ror s
p
dute cons nt d t by t pa te . Howe r t c tfndsi pr ntt a nta s c a
is
e e o
he r is'
'
ve , he our i t ude o ppoi
pe i l

ma trf c mpin ewih t pr l ana ij ncin. epate lr l a r e o t
se or o l c t he ei i prn u to Th ris agcy g e d n hc
a
n
ne f a s c a m ase ,a gi t s ver dia r em e sbe we n t pa te t da e t
ed or pe i l t r nd ven he e e s g e nt t e he ri s o t , he

c r i t tFe rlRueofCiiPt c d r 5 ()1( i me be a s as ca m at r
ou t ' ha dea l
i
nds
vl o e u e 3 a()C) s t c u e pe il se
c df
oul < es pr ra a pos tilm a t st tc nnotbe efe i l a tm ey a es ed
addr s eti l nd
tra ter ha a
f ctvey nd i l ddr s

bya a albedititjdg o ma itaej g of hedsrc 'Th c r e e t
n v ia l src u e r gstt ud e t itic' e ou t xp cs
sgniiantdiput r ga di RT1srghtt i pc docume sfom Ne a
i fc
s es e r ng ,' i o ns ct
nt r
xus nd/oris
t
r l ed enttes whi a s ca m ase ,who r gulry woul bei ve i t sdiput ,
eat
ii , ch pe il t r
e al
d nvol d n hi s e

woul be i t be tposton t addr se dii l
d n he s
ii o
es xpe tousy.
The e or pur uantt Fede a Rul ofCi lPr dur 53,t c ta nt
r f e, s
o
rl e
vi oce e
he our ppoi s
G r gor T.St O tr ,Es ofW ha t Al z r& W e ve ,PLC a as ilm a tri t s
e y
. zs q.
ron dhi e
a r
s peca se n hi

c e t ad s a m a r c m e tonst t c ta t pa test e ur c
as o vie nd ke e om nda i
o he our nd he t i o ns e ompla e
inc

wih t ep eiana yi u t r l fo d r d b t ec r a d me aediputswihn t
t h r l i r njnci ei r e e y h ou t n dit s e t i he
n
ve e
s o oft pr l anayij n t o d r8Th s e il se ' du iss lno e o s
c pe he ei i r n u ci r e . e p ca ma trs te hal t nc mpa s
n
on
m a ng fndi off c orc l i oflw,norr or enda
ki i ngs a t oncusons a
ec nm
éonson m otonsi t s
i n hi
m a tr unl st cour m odii s h dutesf l ng c ula i wih t pa tes
te , es he
t
fes uc
i olowi ons tton t he r i .

8111r comm e d t a i m e ofFTICons éng orThe Ve tx Co pa est s r e a s ca m a t r The
1. e
nde he ppo nt nt
'
ul
re m ni o e v s pe il se .
diput a
s e bouta c st N e us books r cor a a c ss
c es o x '
, e ds nd c ount oundsi dic r . r S .Out ha e e i e re e
n s ove y M . t
s s xt nsve xpe i nc
i cvi ltgai i t sditi ,i udi cic r diput si oli f nc a doc nt i M r St O ur i mor
n i l ii ton n hi srct ncl ng ls ove y s e t v ng ma i l ume aton. . . s s e
w
tun quaii d t s r e a s i lm a t ra i ba e l al t e dii l r ol t sdiput
l
lfe o e v s peca se nd s s d oc l o xpe tousy es ve hi s e.
y

To f iia em atng t c s fl a ia c t t s ilm a t ,t Cour a horz
aclt t li he a e ie va lbl o he peca ser he
t ut i es
t thebepr de wihoutc r a ce st ough t PublcAc s t Cour El c r c
ha
ovi d, t
ha ge, c s hr
he
i ce s o
t e toni

Rc o dsS se (
c r y tm PACER) ThePACER Se vc Ce tri dr ce t p o i t s ca
.
r ie n e s ie td o r vde he pe il
m ase wih t r quiieac ounta pa s d wihoutc r .Suc a ces i gr nt d f
t r t he e st c
nd s wor t
ha ge
h c s s a c or

t s c a m ase ' us s eyi ttsc e.
he pe i l t rs e oll n li as The s ca m a tr s l becom pens t d a hi
pe il se hal
ae t s
sa r houry r t ,pl r a ona ee ns .The s ilm ase ' f esa t ona e
t nda d
l a e us e s bl xpe es
peca
trs e nd eas bl
expens r l i t hi dutesass c a m a t rs l beal at e nl bet en 1 w a
es eatng o s i
pe i l s e hal loc ed ve y we U I nd
N exusg
.

VI
.

H a i g ce ryme alt r q r me t f rap ei n r i u t o s mepo ton
v n la l t l he e uie n s o r l a y njnci n o
mi
on
ri

ofiscamsf r l f RlIsmo i f rp ei nayi u t n, No 4 i G
t li or ei , ,' ton o r l r njnci ECF . , s
e
mi
o

TED

i par a D EN I D i pat .A ss tf t i t a com pa i Or ,N e i
n
t nd
E n
t
e orh n he c
ny ng der xus s

PRELI I
M NARI ENJ N ED d rngt pe e c oft i c s , ndi h r by
LY
OI
u i he nd n y h s a e a s e e
O RD ERED a f l :
s olows

Ne us wihi t e y(0 da fo t daeR1Iposss fiintbo ,s l
x , t n a nt 2 ) ys r m he t , t u f e nd hal
v
c
p od et RLIa d/ p o i RI1wih f l ndunftee a c s t t
r uc o
n or r vde , t ula
etr d c e s o he
f l ng books r cor a a c
olowi
, e ds nd c ount ofN e Se dc ,I .ast yw e e
s
xus r es nc he r
m anti d on Aprl1 2018:
i ane
i 2,

9I isl t rc e i t t s c a mase ,I , a gu t tN e usa o s d be rt c toft s ca m a t rs
n t ete ons nt o he pe i l t r U- r es ha x l ne houl a he os he pe il se '
ng
I
s r i spur ua t t I m niyAg e m e . t ssa oft ltga i t co tde lne t de e m i who s l
e vce
s nt o he nde t r e nt At hi t ge he ii ton, he ur c i s o t r ne
hal
bea t c t pe t a e m e .
r he oss r he gr e nt

32

a. A ny a a1books r cor a a c
nd l
, e ds nd c ount ofN e Se vce ,I .f t
s
xus r i s nc or he

pei of a a y2 , 1 t t pr s n , a gonisf nca c diin
rod l nu r 0 20 6 o he e e t be dn
t i il on to
na

a a ii t stsyisob kainsu e t I e t Ag e me t
nd bl y o aif t l to nd r he nd mniy r e n ;
t
TheBond t e eve (rc ist r of,ncudngBon n e s
s h msl s o ope he e ) i l i
d umb r
l M1
M
00001 tuough 1 511
l
51 02497;
Any a a1doc e sr l tng t t sa usofanyR11bonds i l ng
nd l
um nt e ai o he t t
.
, ncudi
docum ent r a i t br a ca lton,f fiur orpenate .
s eltng o e ch, ncea i ore t e,
li s
2. To t e enta oft a
he xt
ny he bove doc e si l i or aton ofi vi l ot r
um nt ncude nf m i
ndi duas he

t n t bonded prncpa,s i or a i m us ber da t d.
ha he
i i l uch nf m ton
t e ce
3. O nl RI,,isa nt,oriscons t ss l r viw t doc e spr
y I t ge s
t
ulant hal e e he um nt oduce
d

pu s ntt t sp ei nayi jnci or e . , s lnots a et s d c me t
rua o hi r l r nu ton d r R1I hal h r he e o u n s
mi
ott i or a i l a ned fom t e doc e st any ot rpari ,i l ng
he nf m ton e r
r
hes
um nt o
he
tes ncudi

govenme a
r nt gencisori it toncours wihoutpet si ofXexusort s
e mnlg ai
t, t
rnison
hi
Cour .
t

RIIs l notus t doc ent ort i or a i la ned fom t e doc e s
, hal
e he um s he nf m ton e r
r
hes
um nt
t a r torca e t a r s ofa bond hol r orpe s i ntfed i t
o r es
us he r e t ny
de s
r ons de ii n he
doc ent .
um s

Thsp einna yi u to do snota pl t ot rNe usr ltd e tte .
i r l i r njncin e
r
p y o he x -eae n iis
6 11, s lpos abo i t a u oftn t ousnddolr ( 1 ,0 )pu s a t
. 1 1 hal t nd n he mo nt e h a
la s $ 00 0 ru nt o
Fe rlRueofCiiPr e r 6 c.
dea l
vl oc du e 5()

Thi prl nna yi u to s alsu a tkce fc i daeyup RII
s ei i r njncin h l is e nd a fe t mme itl on =
r
pos i a s f i ntbond w ih t Cl r ofCour .
tng ufk e
t he e k
t

33

G t gor T.St O ut ,Es ofW ha t A l ze & W ea r PLC i a
e y
. s q.
r on dhi r
ve ,
s ppoi e asa
nt d
s ilm a tri tascas pur ua t Rul 53 oft Fede a RulsofCi l
peca se n li e s nt o e
he
rl e
vi

Pr edur ,t advieand m a r om m enda i t t cour a t pa te t
oc
e o
s
ke ec
tons o he
t nd he ri s o

e ur c inc v'ht p ei n r i u t rl fo d rdb t c r a
ns e ompl e i he rl ay njnci ei r ee y he out nd
a
t
mi
ve e
me aedip e wihnt so o t prlni r i uncinot t
dit s uts ti he c pe f he ei nay nj to de.
t
9. M r St Ours dutess l note om pas m a ng fndi off c orc usonsof
. .
' i hal
nc
s ki i ngs a t oncl i
lw,norr or e tonson m otonsi t sm a t r unl st cour m odii
a
ec nm nda i
i n hi te , es he
t
fes

s dutesf l ng c ulaton wih t pa te .
uch i olowi ons t i
t he r is
10.M r St Ourss l fl bi el yr
. .
hal ie we t eporson t doc tde alng hi fndi a a
l
t
he ke t ii
s i ngs nd ny
e or m e r om m e i r ga di com pla evr h t pr lm i r
nf ce nt ec
ndatons e r ng
inc i hc ei na y
t

i uncin. pa t sma fl obe to t t s fn i g a r c mme dains
nj to The ri y ie jcins o he e i d n s nd e o n to
e
wihi sve ()da s wh c wi bes bjc t deno r ve
t n e n 7 y , ih l u e t o
l
vo e iw.
11. f c l at m adng t ca e fl a ia et M t St O ut ,t cour aut i st t
To a ii e l
t
he s ie valbl o . . s he
t horze ha

hebepr de wihoutc r ,a ce st oug t PublcAc s t Cour
ovi d, t
ha ge c s hr h he
i ce s o
t

Elcr n cRe or S se (
e to i c ds y tm PACER) Th PACER S r ieCe e i dr ce t
. e
e vc ntr s ie td o
pr de t s ilm a trwih t r quiie a counta pas wor wihoutcha ge.
ovi he peca se t he e st c
nd s d t
r
Suc a es i gr e f M r St Our 'us s eyi t sc e.
h cc s s ant d or . . s e oll n hi as

1 M r St Our s l becom pe aed a hi sa r houryr t ,pl r as bl
2. . . s hal
ns t t s t nda d
l a e us e ona e
C IS .
XPCA CS
13.M r.St O urs f and reas
.
' ees
onabl expens rel i t hi dutes asspeci m ast
e
es atng o s i
al
er

s lbeal t d e y bea n 11- a N e .
hal
loca e venl tvee 4 1 nd xus

34

A n a opra e O r rwilbeent r d t sda
ppr i t de l
e e hi y.

Entr
e ed:

f
wf

D T - <)c - J.& ?F
'
k

' '/ .
' N
V

M i ha F.
c el

V -C '
X-

a ki
ns

ChifUnie S ae Ditit u g
e td tts src l d e

35