RLI Insurance Company v. Nexus Services, Inc.
Filing
80
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 8/25/2018. (jv)
CLERK' OFFI U.S. SX COURT
S
CE
DI
AT O ANOKE,VA
FIED
L
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES D I
STM CT CO U RT
FO R TH E W E STE RN D I RI O F W RGI I
ST CT
N A
At 2 7 2 1
s , 22
H ARRI N BU RG D W ISI N
SO
O
B JUL c, DtEy
.
Y;
1 1I SURAN CE COM PAN Y,
V N
Pl nt f y
ai i f
Ci lActon N o.5:8- 00066
vi
i
1 CV-
N EX' SE RW CE S,I C.
US
N ,
By:
D ef
endant
,
Mi
chaelF.U r
bansd
l
Chi fUnie St t sDiti tJ
e t d a e src udge
J
UAN VALOY,e a .
t 1,
I er enor .
nt v
s
M EM O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O
'
.
sgu
.)
Tlsmk' i$Sb fr tec p'o d fn a t x s evcsIc'r x s) t n
l ,.t. strteoe h olt n ee d n Neu S rie,n . Weu ' moi
i vr,,sTi
t
s
' o
.
.
.
f l vet Sl a c âe c m a a e
or ea o e oui'r bi nd m nded ans r ECF N o. Them ate ha be n 6ll
we .
43.
tr s e l
y
bre ed.Thecour dipe e wi. or la px e bec us t lga c enéonsa e a qua ey
if
t s ns s t a r m nt a e he e l ont
h
r de t l
pr s nt d i t m a e i l be ot t c tand a gum e w oul notad t decsona
e e e n he t ras f e he our
t
nt
d
i he ii l
pr s .Fort f l ng r s , e 'm oéon f l ve t fl count r hi a
oce s
he olowi ea ons N xus
or ea o ie
e c m nd
a e d a we i GR AN TED .
m nde ns r s
RTIl sua eCo ny(f ,) a d Ne use e e i o a i e iya r e nton
, n t nc mpa < I n x ntr d nt n nd mnt g e me
RT '
J n a y20 2 1 rl mni Ag e me ' a c i r éo f RTIsa r e ntt is e
a u r , 0 6 fnde t r e nt' s onsdea n or ,' g e me o su
y
)
i m ir ton bonds A sde al d i t cout' opi on on t e e i l M gat d pr i i r
m g ai
.
t ie n he
ts ni
he xt nsvey
e el na y
m
i u do ILIalg st tNe usbra he t I e iyAg e me fravait of
njnc n,I l e ha x e c d he nd mnt t e nt o
e
rey
r as , ncl lng f iur t pr de a ce st N e 'books z or a ac ount .
e ons i uci al e o ovi c s o xus
, ec ds nd c
s The
c ur ga e RIlap i nayi unc nt trq rdNe ust gv a c s t aslcin
o t rntd , ml r nj do ha e uie x o ie c es o eeto
mi
ofisbooks r or a a ount .
t
, ec ds nd cc
s ECF N o.60.
Dut t c ureo bifnga agu ntf tep ei nayi do Ne us
i he o s f rei nd t me or h rl r t
ng
mi junc n, x
m oved t a e isans ra add a c m tr l m .ECF N o.43.The c
o m nd t
we nd
ot e c/i
ount r bi ,
ec m
br
oughtunde 10t Vigi aa Ilnoi lw,aie ILIbr a d t l m niyAgt e e
r 7 h t ni nd li s a
ges L
e che he nde t
e m nt
unde t i pled dut ofgood f ih a fi deni g t ough isde and t a es N e '
r he m i
y
at nd ar lt hr
n
t m
o cc s xus
books r cor a ac
, e ds nd count a isr que tt N e dic t albondsi s d or izt
s nd t e s hat xus s ha ge l
s ue , t he
a tr éve f nih RI, wih cola e a s ltt s ice t s ur a i ta i t l s
le na , ur s
1 t
lt r l ecniy uf i nt o ec e gans nécpa ed os
and e
xposue unde t bonds
t
r he
.
N e a gue t tFede a Rul ofCi lPr e e 15 s
xus r s ha
rl e
vi oc dur
uppot sa e
' m ndm e bec us
t
nt a e
Thec ur s ldfel gvela whe j dc s rq ie. ECFNo 4 a 2 Ac o dn t
f o t hoz rey i eve n us e o e u s'
t
l
'
. 4, t . c r ig o
Ne usnon oft fco st ts ppo td nilofla et a nd prjdiet t o sn
x , e he a tr ha u r e a ev o me - eu c o he ppoig
pa t ,ba f ih,orf tlt - a y,a t la s d begr nt d. ili s f M a 20,
ry d at
u iiy ppl nd hus e ve houl
a e Tta s et or y
2 9 dso r ha no c mme e $utfrtedicosrsno or rdb t p ei nay
01 , ic vey s t o ncd
o h sl u e w dee y he r l r
mi
i nc n , ndNe uscnmsRTIc nn b s r e bytec untrli salg do a
t éo ) a
ju
x li
, a ot e updsd h o ecnm' l a ns s
e
t y 0. F fom t s m e ta a éon a oc ur e e Addi
he
e r he a r ns c
nd c r nc .
donal t count r bi i m ade
ly, he
éc m s
i good f ih a s pa a eldga
n
at nd e t t i don oft scli w oul bea wa t oftm e a r s ce .
hi l m
d
s e i nd e our s
RII f rispa t o e t t t ea n nta atr tv l mo st dimist
, o t r, bjc s o h me dme nd lenaiey ve o s s he
,
c u ecnm und rFe ea Rul ofCi l oc d r 1 $()ECFNo. 3 RTIag e t t
o ntrli
e d rl e viPr e u e 29 6 .
5 . , t u s ha
N exusf ist alge lLIbr c a dut esa ihed by t l m niyAg e e ort ta
al o le t
ea hed
y t bls
he nde t r em nt ha n
2
i tr zs td I RIIsviw,heI e t Age me doe no c nfrr supo Ne us
t zy eul . n , e t nd mniy re nt s t o e kht n x
j
e
'
nori pos oblgadonsupon RT,,a t t r i no i ple dut t ac wih good f ih
m e i
I nd hus he e s m id y o t t
at
unde t e cr lm s a es RT, f t he a gue t tN e hasno gr
r hes icl t nc . I ' t r r s ha xus
u
oundsf da a s as
or m ge ,
t I m niyAgr e entdoe notpr de f a t ne sf e t N e orc e arg t
he nde t
em
s
ovi or tor y' e s o xus onf r i ht o
ciputbo cnmst Ne usa teei n p o maecus bewenNe usi e a d
l t nd li o x , nd h z s o z vi t a e t e x 't s n
s
jM
RT-' a lge br a
1s le d e ch.
II
.
Fe rlRu eofCiiPr e t 1 ()p o i st tfg)pa t ma a ndisp e cig
dea l
vl oc due 5 a r vde ha f ry y me t laln
a
onc a am a tzofc s wihi 21 da afe s rdng i....I alot tc e ,apa t m a
e s
te
our e t n
ys t r e
t
n l he as s
ry y
a e isplaci onl wih t opposng pa t ' wrte c entort c utsla ' Rul
m nd t e lng y t he
.
i
rys it n ons
he ot ' e ve.
' e
1 alwsc urst fe l g a la t a nd aplal g f n j tc s r q ie . l ; e
5 lo o t o r ey r nt e ve o me
e cn f
i whe usie o e ur s' d.s e
'
as J hns nv. owe t dsCo.7 5F. 5 3 5 1(t Ci.1 6.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?