Morris v. Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSB

Filing 13

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/18/18. (kld)

I TH E U N I D STATE S D ISTRICT COU RT
N
TE
FO R TH E W ESTE RN D ISTRI O F W RGI I
CT
N A
H ARRI N BU RG D I SION
SO
W

CL
ERK' OFFI U , DI .COURT
S
CE S. ST
AT RI NGKE,
M
VA
FI ED
L

M T H ERI E M O R RIS,
N

DE: 1S2 1
28
J
UL C. ' LPf CL
, ERK
BY: '

D PU CW

Pl ntf,
ai if

Cas N o.5: - ve
18 c 76

V.

W I I GT ON SAV I G S FU N D
LM N
N
SO CI TY ,
E

By:H on.M i
chaelF.U t
bansd
l

Cli fU . Dit tJ
ze S. sdc udge
D ef
enda .
nt

M E M O RAN D U M O PI ION
N

Pli fKahei Mori ( rs brng t sa do a nns W i ng o Sa i g
andf t rne rs Mori) i s hi c n g i t l t n v n s
mi
Fu S it ( FS , s etn i f urc un s t r eb e c ofc ta tcnmsa af rh
nd ocey WS ) a s rig,n o o t, h e r a h on r c li nd ou t
cnm f vi a i off de a lndi lws Thi m ate i be or t c ton W SFS' m odon
li or olton
e r l e ng a . s tr s f e he our
S
t dim is
o s s.
M ori ' c pl ntwa fl i t Cic tCour f t Count ofPa , ri a on
rss om ai
s led n he t ui
t or he
y
ge Vigni

ora
boutAprl16 2018 a r m oved t f r lc ton M a 1 2018.ECF N o.1 2.
i ,
nd e
o ede a our
y 7,
, The
cnm sce e on M ori' de a ton he m or ga on t pr rt l at a 133 Tr c i
li
nt r
rss f ul
r
t ge he ope y oc ed t
a ksde

La f / 21 1t t e, he ndo h, r i i (h Pr pe t)a W S ' s bs q e
ne /k a 0 sSte t S na a Vigr a t e o ry nd FSS u e u nt
l
mnl g o t ef tc ofDe a l a I t n t Ac ee ae'(r - c ee ain no ie a
in f h T ie
i
No
fut nd n e t o c lr t' p ea c lr to tc ) nd
f ecos e.
oz l ut ECF N o.1- 2.CountIalge br ac ofc t c by cnm i t W SFS f ie
2,
le s e h
ont a t
li ng hat
a ld

t gv no ea c dngt t tz oft eDe d o Tr s (
o ie dc c or i o he e ms h e f u t DOX b sndi t pr y e ng he e
a cee a i nodcevi ce t
c lt ton
a t fed m al r he t f tcl sm al asr t d by Se
i, at r han us - as i, equie
cdon 1 of
5

t D O T.CountI ,a s a bz ac ofc r c cnm ,a lge t tW SFS vi a e Sec i 22 of
he
I lo
e h
onta t li le s ha
olt d ton

t D OT by f l t pr de apr a ee a i noéc i c pla e wih Se i 22'
he
aing o ovi
i
e- cc lr ton
e n om inc t cton s

tt (g i b c u eW S s ntt eno keb c riidmal. unt 1, ri' fna b e c
e' a an e a s FS e h t y e t e i Co 1 1 Mo rss i l r a h
ms
f
)
ofc r ctc m ,algest tW SFS f a i i pos i eunde Se i 19 oft D OT f
onta hi le ha
f de t m sbl
m
r cton
he
ot

M o rs t ri tt t el n h d y pro t t sl oft Pr pe t. Fi l , untI
ri) o ensae h oa ve a s i r o he ae he o ry' nal Co V
'
y

alg svi ainsoft Tr t i Le igAc (' , a t RelEsaeS tlme t
le e olto
he uh n ndn t I TA) nd he a tt ete n
l
Pr e r sAc ( PA)a s it dwihW S ' alg d fi et pr i pa o fb ln e
oc du e t RES
socae t FSS l e al o ovde y f aa c s
e
ur
wihi a satzorl s tpe i oftm e
t n t tt iy e rod
i .
W ih r s c t Count1 W SFS cont ndsM or i' br a ofc r c cli f is
t e pe t o
,
e
rss e ch
ont a t nm a l

be us i i diec l c r ct d by t pr - c lr don notc a t c asan e bi t
ca e t s t ty ontadi e
he e a cee a
ie, ta hed
xhi t o
M or i' c pl nt ECF N o. 5.Spe ik al W SFS m ant i t pr - c e aéon notc
rss om ai .
4,
c i ly,
i ans he e ac elr
ie
s ntt M ori T i Ce tfe M al'c ttzesfr tca sm alf pur esoft D OT.1
e o
rs Y a r ii d i' onsi t is- ls
a
i or pos
he
d.
a 5. SFS m ovesf dinns ala t CountI ,cont ndi f rhe t tt noéc s ntm e
t W
or s i s s o
1
e ng u t r ha he
e e
t

alt r zr m e sofSec i 22 oft D O T.J xat6. SFSmovesf dimisla t
1 he eqtie nt
ton
he
d
W
or s sa s o
-

Countl 1on t gr
1
he oundst tVigi a1w doesnotr og zean i pled cove ntofgood
ha r ni a
ec ni
m i
na

f t a f i de lngwih r s c t t D O T.JL a 9.W SFSalge CountIIt ef e
aih nd at ai
t e pe t o he
I t
le s
I her or
-.

f l a am ate oflw . ds ty, SFS m ove f dim is lofCountI be us t
ais s
tr a L- Lasl W
s oz s s a
V ca e he
s a ut upon wlih M ori r lesa y onl t hi cos m or ga s L at10.W SFS
t t es
zc
rs ei ppl y o gh- t t ge . ds
.

c ntnd t s bjc l ni n ahg c tmo ta e l Ev n i t esa t e Mo rsr l s
o e s he u e t oa s ot ih-os tg g . d. e f h ttz s ri ei
t
e
upon a y,W SFS f t ralgesCountI s d bedinûs ed be us M ori di not
ppl
urhe le
V houl
s s
ca e
rs d
a lgeawrte r ques f ar i tt m e quot a r 't d by s a ut .1 a 11.
le
it n e
t or ensa e nt
e s eq'ie
t t e d. t
A.

2

Kah rneMo rs(Mo rs), zsd n ofVigni, le e s eo tePa eCou y
tei
ri f ri7 a eie t ri a alg s h wns h g
f
nt
pr ryi diput M ori e eedi o al n f $65, s cze byt Pr ryand
ope t n s e. rs ntr nt oa or 195 e trd he ope t
e ut by Cii orga l The not f t tl n i now hed by W SFS.M ori pai f l
xec ed
tM t ge, nc.
e oz ha oa s
l
rs d ul
a tm ey m orga pa ent f 8. y r .O n O ct r12,2016,l n s r rBSl
nd i l
t ge ym s or 5 ea s
obe
oa e dce

Fi nca Se dc s t pos- c e aéon notce w hi sa e t tM ori ne d t brtg
na il r es ent he tac elr
i , ch t t d ha
rs ede o il
he m orga pa ent c r ntby N ove be 16,2016 orf ceac elr i oft l n a
r
t ge ym s ur e
m r
a
c e aton
he oa nd

s eoft Pr ry. ori wassxt n m orga pa ent belnd a t tHm e whi h
al
he ope t M rs
i ee
t ge ym s li t ha
, c

a
mountd t $11, 90.M ori ne rr eved t pr -cc lr
e o
447.
rs ve ec i he ea eeaéon nodc a ci not
e nd ld
obt i a c ofi untlt da oft deti rhe rng on D e m be 8,201
an opy t i he y he a ne a i
ce r
7.
W SFS a
ppoi e Com m onwe lh Tr t s LLC a s tm t t usee t s l t
nt d
a t usee ,
s ubsi e r t o el he

Pr ry on D ec m be 1 2016.M or i r eve aN odc ofSubs i zeTm seesSa eon
ope t
e r 4,
rs ec i d
e
tt t
a
t ' l
A pzl10,201 satng a f e os e s l oft Pr r ywa s he e f M a 8,2017.
i
7 ti
oz cl ur ae he ope t s c duld or y
M or i i m e a ey r s e ar nsa e e quot fom t s equents rvc r Fa
rs m dit l eque t d ei t t m nt
er
he ubs
e ie , y
Se i on sx occ sons M or i ne
rdcng, i
a i . rs eded ar i t e e quot i atm ey m a
ensat m nt
e n i l nners s
o he

c l wihd a f sfo he 4 $)ttrme ta c ntFa S r ii p o ie t
oud t rw und r m r 01 eie n cou . y evcng r vd d he
r i t t m entquot on M a 4,201 M ori' r ie e a ountc pany coul notz l s
e nsa e
e
y
7. rss ett m nt cc
om
d
eea e
h

.

f
undsuntlM a 1 201 M or i ha t m e t pa t pr a cee a i def ul a ount
i y 0, 7.
rs d he ans o y he e- c lr ton a t m
,
butc d notac es t f
oul
c s he undsbyM a 8,2017.
y
W SFS,t ough iss tm t t us e ,s d t Pr
hr
t ubsi e r t e ol he operyby a i on M a 8 2017.
t
ucton
y ,
A fe t s l ,Fa Se dcng ofe e M ori t oppozaniy t vol a iy vac t t
t r he a e y r i
fr d
rs he
tz t o unt rl
a e he
Pr r yt ough afcas f K e A g e m e a Relas ' i M or i waved a1rght t
ope t ht
f h or ys z e nt nd e e ' f
rs i
li so

t ePr pe t. ri r f e W S n id Mo zso uy1 , 01 t ts wa t va a e
h o ry Mo rs e usd. FS odfe zi nl l 7 2 7 ha he s o c t
3

t Pr t yw ihi t n da .O n Augus 8,2017,W SFS fld a unlwf de ane a bn
he ope t t n e ys
t
ie n a ul t i t ct
a i tM ori i Pa Count G ene a D i ti Com t M or i c lenged t vai t of
ga ns
rs n ge
y
r l srct
.
rs ha l
he ldiy
W SFS' ttet t Pr r ybas d on isbr c ofm at iltz soft de i or rt s l
S il o he ope t
e
t ea h
era e m
he ed n de o el
t Pr r y The c tde e r ned M ozi' c nm swoul lkey s vi de ure butr e
he ope t .
our t rni
rss l i
d i l ut ve m r r
uld

ilc e s jc matrj idci t d cdevailyoft tteofDe e r8 2 1 . S
ta k d ube t te urs it o ei l i he il
on
ct
c mbe , 0 7 W FS
fl anot runlwf de ane a ton agans M or i i PageCount CicztColr on
ied
he
a ul t i r c i
i t
rs n
y t li zt

J nu r 2 , 01 , l h wa pe ig a t tmet sc mp an wa f e
a a y 9 2 8 wli s ndn t he i hi o lit s i d.
c
l
M oz i t fld tlsa ton i Pa Count Cic tColt on Aprl1 2018 algi
rs hen ie li c i n ge
y t ui zt
i 6,
le ng
bz ac ofc r c ast Se tons15,22,a 19 oft D O T and vi a i ofTI a
e h
onta t o c i
nd
he
oltons
LA nd
RESPA .
B.

Tos dv amoin t dinisu rFe rl l ofCiiPr e u e1 9 6,
ur e to o szs nde dea Rue vl oc d r 2 $() a
c litne d o y c ti s f in f cu lmatrwhih,fa c ptd a tu ,ftt gja
omp an e nl on an ufi e t a t a te c i c e e s r e f aes
c
s

cqm t r l ft a i p a sb eonisfc . As r f v. ba,5 6U.. 6 6 8 (0 )
li o ei h t s lu i l t a e' hc o t I l 5 S 6 2, 7 2 09
e
'
( u igBel l Co . Two ,5 0U. 5 4, 7 (0 ). c mpli i R a il
q otn lAt. r v. mbl 5 S. 4 5 0 2 07) A o ant s fcal
y
p a il'wh n t fc salg d f l wg t ec t t drw t er a o bl i ee et tt
lusb e? e he a t l e f l
e a o h ou t o a h e s na e nfr nc ha he
def ndanti labl f t nls
e
s i e or he iconduc al ge 7 I Thi f t nda d i notal t a
t le d.' d. s f a r s
s
dn o
f oba lt r qlie e ,buti as f m or t n a s e pos i lt t tadef nda ha
pr biiy e lr m nt'
t ks or
e ha
he r sbiiy ha
e nt s
a e unlw f l ' I. W he r i on am oton t dinns ,ta c utm us fa ce t w el
ct d a uly.' .
I
L
n ulng
i o s is le ot
t fc pt he l.

pl d alga i oft c pl ntast e' a f
e le tons he om ai
ru ' nd ' t' t f c sa r s bl i e e es
const he a t nd ea ona e nf r nc
ue

dei dt z fo i t l mos fvo a et t pli if'I rav. ie Stts 1 0
rve he er m n he kht t a r bl o he antf. bar Un td a e, 2
'
F. 4 2, 7 ( t Ci.1 9 )
3d 7 4 4 4 h r 9 7 .
4

W hie t cour m us a e astte alwelpld f tzlalga i ,t s m ei not
l he
t
t cc pt tz l l- e acaa le tons he a s
tue f l ga c l i .f e dba er c t l oft eem e sofaca e ofa ton,
z or e l oncusons ' a r e ias he l nt
Thr
us
ci

s
uppore byme econcl or sae
td
r
us y ttment,donots fc 'L -l 556U..a 6789s eas
s
ufie.' qba,
S' t
e lo

W a Mo eDo sLLC v. at6 0F.d35 ,3 5(t Ci. 01 )(Alh ug weae
r
Cozr, 8 3 9 6 4h t2 2 f to h r
f
cons t i d t tke t f ct i t lghtm os f voz bl t t pli f we nee notac e
tane o a he a s n he i
t a a e o he nnéf,
d
c pt
l ga concusonsc he asf c sorunwa r nt d i er nce ,unr as bl concusons or
e l
l i
ouc d
at
r a e nf e s
e ona e
l i ,

a gz nt. ( ena q ttonmak omitd)
r tme s' i r l uo ai
' nt
z s te l.
l c i rng a m oton t dim is t couz i f
n onsde i
i o s s , he
t s f z ly lm ie t ar viw oft
gene al i t d o e e
he
aie tonsoft com pli is f' G oi v. ly Cm t .Sevs Bd. 8 F. 159,165
l ga i
he
ant tel.' nes Vale
y l . , 22 3d
-66

(t Ci. 1 ) Ho ve, h re i nc m a s tme bec nsz e :
4 h r 20 6 . we r ot e v de e y omei s o tt d
l

Fh c u t as c i r doc me t t t a e e piil
e o rl lo onsde s
u n s ha t x lct
y
i or a ed i o t c pli by r f r nce Telbs l v.M a
nc por t nt he om a nt e e e , la , nc.
kor

ls s& I ht Lt ,5 1U.. 8 3 (0 7,a tos atc e
sue U s d. 5 S 30 , 22 2 0 ) nd h e ta h d
t t c mpli a e hbis s eFe R.Ci P.1 () And ...g
o he o ant s x i t, e d. v. 0 c.
t
he
c utqma c i ra d u n s n td b t mo ntt twa
o t y onsde oc me t ub ùte y he va ha s
nota t ched t or e es l i por t i a com pl i ,s l as
ta
o
xpr sy ncor a ed n
ant o ong
t doc entwasi e a t t c pl i a t r i no ciput
he um
nt gr l o he om ant nd he e s
ls e

a u t d ume ' a he iiy ge ' ofStt f r Dee ev.
bo t he oc nts ut ntct . s c
a e o fnc )
Tzmbe F a Lt q 48 F.d g0 ) 7 5 ( 1 Ci.2 0 );Am.
i l v. d. 4 3 7 0 , 0 /t1 r 0 7j
,
Chio r tc A s ' v.Tr on H e lhc r I ,367 F. 212,234
t ac i sn
i
at a e nc.
3d

(t Ci.2 0 ) Phiisv.LCII ' l . 1 0 F. 6 9 61 (t
4h r 0 49 l
l
nt nc, 9 3d 0 , 8 4h
l
Ci. 9 9 .
r1 9)
I a 166.
d. t
C.
W SFS a gue M or i' br ac ofconta tcli due t i ufi intnotcei CountI
r s
rss e h
r c am
o ns fce
i n

f isbe a eW SFS s ntt pr - c lr ton notcevi ce t e m al The D O T sa e i
al c us
e he e a cee a i
i a ro d i.
tts n

S c on1 ,r ynoiet Bor we i c njnci wiht sSet iyl t me s lbe
ed 5 ç
An tc o ro r n o u ton t hi cz t nsnz nt hal
r
dee ed t ha be gve t Bor owe whe m al by f tcas m alorwhe a al
m
o ve en i n o
z r
n ied
rs l s i
n cm ly
5

dei r t Bor ow e ' noéceaddr s i s ntby ot rm e ns' ECF N o.1- 29.M or i
lve ed o r rs
es f e
he a .
'
2,
rs
cam sW SFS s ey us Tot rm ea ' be us t pr - cc l r i notc w a s ntvi
li
oll ed f he
ns: ca e he e a e e aton ie s e
a
ce tfed m ala c r iid m ali notf tcas m ala i e d by t D O T. SPS,on t
rii
i nd e tfe
is
us- l s i s ntnde
he
W
he
ot zha cli st tc r iid m ali f n optona f tze offt tc a sm ai,7a nota
he nd, nm ha e tfe
i sr
a
i l eaar
ts- l s
l7 nd

s pa a e tpe ofm alnplECF N o.9,2.
e rt y
ii
W hie ce tfed m ai nnghti d bea extaa ia e opton w hen at
l rii
l i ndee
n r valbl
i
temptng t
i o
s nd f tcas m al m a cour sdo t e tt tvo ass pa a em alng m e ha s sf
e us- l s i, ny
t
r a he a
e rt
ii
c nim or
pur e ofm ee i notc r quie e s Ce tfed m a la f tca sm ala e
pos s
tng i e e t m nt . rii
i nd rs- ls
i r

ds ng ih bl be a ec riid mal e lie t r cpintssg t i f d l r . on sv.
id as a e c us e tfe ir qlr s he e i e ' inau e or ei y J e
ve

Flwes 5 7U. 2 , 3 - ( 0 )W hi c zi dmalp oe t a ans l s l ey T e
o r, 4 S. 20 2 435 20 6. l ethe i r tcs g i tnidei r,'
e
v us
ofc tiidmal ag tma ea t a n els l eyi s mec s sèe a e t lte c n
eqfe in ih k c u l odc e s i l n o a e c usj he etr a not
k
bel f lke r gulrm al..>I a 235.Futhe ,i ar i e i nothom ewhe c rii d m al
e t i e a i. .7 d. t
t t f ecpi nt s
n e tfe
i
i dei z t pi e ofm ali r tzned t t pos ofie a c n t y ber tive fom
s lve ed, hat ec
i s et
r
o he t fc nd a f
onl
e re d r
t pos ofi f a s c fe pe i oftm e' 1
he t fce or pe iid zod
i .' d.

Ot rj rs ci ha hed t t whe eno ei r ql e byT i'no ies nt a
he u iditons ve l ha, r éc s e lt d f l' tc e vi
i
ma y
ce éfed m alonl c ples' t t f n lng' r qlie e upon a tzlr c i .See e..
r i
i y om i wih he f ii : e lt m nt
m
c t e ept
a
,
Aur aLoan Se vs,LLC v.Condr 181 Conn.App.
or
r .
on,
248,272-73,186 A. 708,725
3d
-26

(01 )(uig t t whe i e p ei t etr o amo ta de dr q rn n ieet r
2 8 r l ha, n ntr r t h ems f rg ge e e uiig otc ihe
n
ng
f al by fr tc a sm ai' orfa tal dei r t Bor owe ' nodc addr s i s by
f ied
m
ls l s
l: fctz l lve ed o
y
z rs
e
e s f ent
ot rm ea , ce tfed m alcons u ed ot m e ns r qlii a ua dei yi ot rt
he
ns' rii
:
i
ét t
her a , e ltng ct l lver n de o
1W SFS cam sM ori' atc d e hi t t c oft notc t s rc i d a t deqne heai s w st ti
li
rss ta he k bi, he opy he ie hat he e eve t he ti z tng, ho ha t
wa sntby ErtcasmalECF No.4,2.T
se
s-ls i.
'hough t e l i lbee f rtcl sMal' t lte i l ld fs nt
he nveope s a ld f s- as i, he e tr s abee fe
Fi
'
Vi Ce dte M a1' ECF N o.1 2 3 & 3 A sce t e m ali c i e a a on f a ur offr tc a sm alb t
a r i d i.
'
- , 3 4.
rz d i s onsder d n dd- e t e is- l s i y he
USPS,i i c i tntwih t f c sa lge i t cof antt att nodc en l wotl be m a ke wih a 'Fist s onss e
t he a t le d n he npl i h he
e ve one ld
r d t ' rt
Cl s M al' a l
a s i' l be .
X'

s ésyt t r oft de d ; riiai fom U.. ur ofA e l f Ni h Ciczt
a f he e ms he e ) Ce tfc t r
on
S Co t
as or nt r l v.
i

Ka h n,1 W ah. d4 4 41 , 9 P. 5 5 5 8 9( s 2 0 )(uedo criidi
c ma 65 s 2 0 , 1 1 8 3d 0 , 0 -0 Wah. 0 8 q s n etfe n

Conh k rCau l I . v. c ma ,5 4F.d9 2 9 78 (t Ci. 00 )Sodig
r us e s at nsCo. Ka h n 1 3 8 , 8 -8 9h r2 8 l n
y
t c r iid m alf l i o t <a u ldei r pr ' a W a hi on sat s a ut r qtii
hat e tfe
i el nt he çct a lve y ong' of
s ngt t e t t e e zrng

notceofca el i ofi uz nc polc e t i lr d i vi l et zby m alorby acua
i
nc laton ns a e ii s o nsz e ndi duas ihe
i
t l

dei r lzOt r s , tc sntb c r idm al uaiisonya a atmpta d l r .
l y. he wie no ie e y e dfe iq l e l s n te
ve
f
t ei y
ve
Ce tfcai f om U . Cour ofA
rii ton r
S.
t

e l f N i h Cic t 1 W as 2d a 411 198 P. a
as or nt t ui, 65
h. t ,
3d t

5 -0 ;seas Fi l y& Ca . o N. v Ri y 1 Md 4 0 43 1 8A. 0 2 3 ( .
08 9 e lo dei
t
s Co. f Y. . l , 68 . 3 , 0 7 25 , 5 Md
e
1 35 (i l tv c nc lain no ie s ntb r gse e mal r a tmp sa d l r
9 ) fnci vo a elto tc s e y e itr d iwe e te t t ei y
ng
ve
be a enet rw e e a t lyr eved,a i e d by t i ur nc polc sfm Zli
c us ihe r c ual ec i
s nt nde
he ns a e iy' f '

rql e nt3Laoc uev. 1J i Rens a eAs',5 6A. 5 , 3 , 3 1 ..
e lrme l; r q R.. ont i urnc sn 3 2d 29 5 0 5 2 1
i
1 8 Sodigt tun raRh eIln sauerqligi u est ' ienoie'
98 ) l n ha de
od sa d ttt e lin nsrr o ' v tc 'of
t
g
ca elton t i ur ,acaa r ceptofs h notc i r qlied a ' a bepr um e by
nc la i o ns eds tzl e i
uc
i e s e zr nd ' y
m
es d
pr ofa or na ym alng,' notw he e a i ut r ' s ndi notcevi c r i d m al
oof n di r
ii 'but
r n ns e , ' e ng i a e dfe
by
i

i ta o r gta posa e i r a e t ers ofnon l e y'.
nse d f e z r tg ,nce s d h ik
l
dei r ' z
v lf
Cour sha ditnguihed be we c rm e m aland fz tcas m ai be us fr t
t ve si s
t en e t d i
ls- l s l ca e ls-

c a sm alca sm pl be dei t d t t a es a t a e s nee notbehom e.l Re
ls i n i y
l e o he ddr s nd he ddr s ee d
ve
n

Fz ze, 4 B. 3 9 4 ( n . D. . 0 8 . r id malncud sar c i u
a iz 39 R. 9 , 00 Ba kr E. Va 2 0 ) Ce éfe ii l e e ept pon
2The W a hi on s a tt d c ai notc t quie e sr q r d t twrte no e ofca el don ofa polc be et t
s ngt t tze i t tng ie e r m nt e uie ha itn dc
nc la
iy
ihe

T cul d l ee ' o f ie ' t te n me isrd Coz u k rCa.I s Co,5 4 F.d a 9 5 (it RCW j
T tal ei rd' r f ld' o h a d nu e . rh s e s n . . 1 3 t 8 ctz
a y v
ma
z
ig
4 .82 0. i lry teDOT s ne b Morsrq i dno c b G i db fs casmal o fc-al d l ee 't
81 .9 )Smi l,h
a
i d y ri e ur é e e mal y t t ls i' r f t l ei rd'o
g
e
e
r
' auy v
t Bor o rsnotcead e s
he r we ' i dr s .
3Agan,t polc addr s i Fi lt & Ca .Co.of Ne Yor r qu r d T rte noéc dei r t t i t d or
i he iy
esed n deiy
s
w
k e i e f i tn
w
e lve ed o he nsue
m al t i sl tadd e sa s
i o l as r s s hown by t r co dsoft co pa '16 M d. t43 17 A.a 251.
ed i
he e r
he m np' 8
a 0, 8 t
4'he c ti a r t tm a oft a
T our s wa e ha ny he bove ct d c e de l t nodc oft c nc la ofi uz nc polce ,whi h
ie as s a wih
e he a el don ns a e i is c
i om or e s i pu i pol y c i r dons Se Co nhus r Ca .I .Co. 5 F. a 98 Fi l & Cas Co.of
nc
at pechc blc i onsde a . e r ke s ns , 14 3d t 79 dei
c
.
N . ,1 M d.a 430 1 A .a 253 La oc ue,5 A. a 53 The pa all be wee t notc r qu r m e s oft
Y. 68
t , 78
t ; r
36 2d t 0.
r le s t n he ie e ie nt
he
a
bove r f r nc d sa u e a pol i s a t e of t D OT,a wel a t c pa i o m a by c t be we n
e e e e t t t nd i e nd hos
c
he
s l s he om rs ns de
our s t e
c r ii a frtcas m al si ofe gai nc i de e mi ng t e is atha
e tfed nd zs- l s i, tl f r da e n t r ni h s ue
l
nd.

dei r ,buti t z cpi i nothom e t m alc
l y
ve
f he e i ent s
, he i annotbe lf a t r i ars t m al
e t nd he e s ik he i
m a ne rbedei r d t t r i e .I Fur he ,c r iid m a lT e lt a a ft a i
y ve
l e o he ecpi nt d. t r e tfe
ve
i f qlies n flm tve
r

a t' y t r cpin . n z S fe, 40B. 1 ,1 2( n . D. . 0 ) Th r cp e
c'b he e i e t I e he fr 4 R. 21 2 Ba kr E. Va 20 9 . e e iint
m us et rsgn f 'hem alupon de i r otgo t t pos ofi t pik up t m al i i
t ihe i ol t
i
lve y
o he t fce o c
he i, f t

c ul no bedei zderir Fo t szao c u t i ma yjts ci rqzr t t
o d t l e ale. r hi es n, o rs n n uiditons e lie ha,
ve
whe a c rii d m alng goesuncni e f t za don m us bet ken t ens enotc
n e tfe
ii
l m d, uthe c
t a
o ur
ie
r r m e sa e m et Se H a i v.O c na Count Tr a ur r N o.340161,2018W L
equie nt r
. e ge
ea
y e s e,

1 81 3 a * ( c . . Apr 1 , 01 )(ul gt tno ier q ie n swe eme
8 1 7, t 3 Mih CtApp. . 9 2 8 r i ha tc e ur me t r t
n
whe t de enda ,a t rfrts ndi t notc by c rii d m al s nts ve a m or
n he f
nt fe ls e ng wo ies
e tfe
i, e e r l
e

n e t g frtca smal ndpu he n ei al a n ws pe)
oéc s l h ls-ls ia
uou
bhs d oéc n oc l e pa r.
The c tfndss r i eby c r z e m ali nots fc e unls t r i eï a t l
our i
e vc
et d i s
ufii nt e s he ecpi rt c ual
y
r cevest m al H e e W SFS ha notpt e e e de e ofr eptoft c rii d m aland
e i he i. t ,
s
es nt d vi nc
ec i
he e tfe
i
ha nots n e de e ofa a tona efor t s nd t pt - cc l r
s
how vi nc
n ddii l f t o e he e a e e aéon notc t ough
ie ht
ot rm e .M or i ha s ts id he bur n a t ssa i t pr edi by satng a
he
ans
rs s a ife r de t hi t ge n he oce ngs t i
pl i ec nm ast Count1 The m oéon t din i sCountIi D EN I D .
ausbl l i
o
.
o s ns
s
E
D.

Count1 al st tW SFS br a hed t t t soft D O T by vi atng Sec
1 lege ha
ec
he e m
he
ol i
éon 22:
' e rs l gi notcet Bor owe prort ac e e a
t nde hal ve i o
r r i o c l r don f l ng Bor owe '
olowi
r rs

b ec ofa c ve nto a re nti ti Seurt l % me $utn p irt
ra h ny o na r ge me n hs c iy ns
nt
ot ro o
a c lr ton u e S ci 1 u e sAppia l ia pz vde ot r s) Theno ie
c eeai nd r e ton 8 nls
l be w o i s he wie.
c
tc
s l s ' iy ()t d fut $)t ea t r q ie t c r t dea t ()ad t,
hal pe f :a he e a l; h ci e ut d o u e he ful; c ae not
c
on
l st n 30 da f om t dat oft nodc gve t t Bor ower bywlih t
es ha
ys z
he e he
e i n o he
r
,
lc he

dea l mus b c e ; n ( )t tfi et c r t dea ton o b f r t d t
fu t t e uz d a d d ha al o u e he ful r e o e he ae
ur
s c fed i t notcem ayr s ti a e e at oft sz ss c ed by t sSec iy
pe ii n he i
e ul n cc l r bn he 'm e ur
hi
urt
l ttm e and s l oft Pr ry.'
ns tz nt
ae he ope t 7ECF N o.1- 31.
2,

8

M or i algest tW SFS f l d t pr deapr - c lr i notc i c
rs le ha
aie o ovi
e ac e e aton ie n ompla 57t3t e
ince 4 1 hes
1
.

t r sbe us M ozi ne rr eve s h anotc sTher as f t sa whet r
em
ca e
rs ve ec i d uc
ie.
e ons or hi nd
he
W SFS' eforst gvenotc m e t t z soft D OT ha bee f l addr s e i t
S f t o i
i e t he e m
he
ve n uly
e s d n he

a
bove s c i dic sngW SFS' m oton a i pe ti t Count1 The c tt r f e
e ton s us i
S i s t rans o
.
our he e or
D EN I S W SFS' m oton t din isCount1 .
E
S i o s as
l
E.

CountI 1al ge a bz ac ofSec
1 le s
e h
éon 1 oft D OT,algi t W SFS di not
9 he
le ng hat
d

tm ey pr de ar i t e e quot ,bz adng t i i c na ofgood f ih a f i
i l ovi
ensat m nt
e el
he mpled ove nt
at nd ar
de lng. SFS cont ndst tt sc
ai W
e
ha hi quntf isbe us Vigi a1w doesnotr cognie t
al ca e t ni a
e
z he

i id c ve ntou sd oft eVigni Unio m Co z ilCod ( . t
mpl o na ti e h ti a f r mme ca e UCC) To he
e
conta y,ft Unie St t Cour ofAppe l f t Four h Cic thasc i t l hed
r r fhe
t d a es
t
a s or he
t r ui
onssenty l
t tVig ni doesz cogni a i ple dut ofgood f ih a f i deai i c m on lw
ha r i a
e
ze n m id y
at nd ar lng n om
a
contac s'6St
r t . one G ln LLC v.Sout r Ba a Tr tCo. 944 F.Supp. 460,465
'
e
he n nk nd us
,
2d.

(01 ) S eW ofv. d. tMo t. sn,5 2F. p' 3 , 4 (t Ci. 1 )(u ng
2 3 . e l Fe Na. t As' 1 Ap x 36 3 5 4h t20 3 q oé
Eno ov. a eAd e t r s Lt , 2 F. u 2 4 , 5 ( D. . 0 9 ( ..jn
mot S c v n u e d.6 4 S pp. d 43 4 0 E. Va 2 0 ) f .g
<
Vigni, veyc nta tc ti a i id c ve ntofg d fih a fi d aip7) The
r i a e r o rc on nns n mpl o na
e
oo at nd ar e l l .
n
5Thepr - cc lr don nodc a t c d t t c pli c a nsale e e slse i Se
e a ee a
e ta he o he om ant onti l l m nt it d n cdon 22 oft D OT. e ECF
he
Se
N o.1 2,3
- 4-36. SFS' o y plusbl al ge vi a oft ss don i t f i et dei t nodc pr ry,a
W
S nl a i e le d ol éon hi ec
s he al o l he
ur
ver
e ope l s
dic s a .
s us ed bove
6W S r le upon a nlmberofc s si cqm i t i ple d y ofgood fih a fi de lng doesnota y t
FS eis
l
a e n li ng he m id ut
at nd ar ai
ppl o

ta fr ofra ett i Vi ii. ef s, o-sv F lo Ba k N. ,ds se ac ' ofb ec o tei l d
znses el sae n z na Th i tJ ne . utn n - A. imiss bl
g
r
m
rah f h mpi
e
c na ofgood f ih a f i de ltg i a r lesa e c r c be a e i wa pl d und t Urior Com mer ilCode
ove nt
a t nd a r ai n ea t t onta t c us t s e
z
er he lf m
ca
a asa spa aet t notbe us Vigni doe notr og z a s h i id c na o sde oft U CC.56 F.
nd
e r t or,
ca e ri a s
ec nie ny uc mple ove nt uti
he
5

Ap ' 2 1 2 3 (t Ci.2 1 ) Thesc n ,Haome v U.. n Na. s ,q tsHarsn v U..Bal Na.
px 5 , 5 4. r 0 4.
h
eo d zi h . S Ba k t As' uoe rio . S r t
n
k
As' , sn isd cso o t t li . 4F. u p 3 7 1 7 1( D. . 0 5) :2 C 0 2 4 2 1 WL 2 6 1 3
sn.baig t eiin n ha hodng 9 S p . d 4 , 5 E. Va 2 1) 31 - V-0 2 , 0 2
36 6
( . . .u e2 , 0 2.ns hocn , o vr teHarsnc r mira sGre wo dAso s I c v Crsa Ba k
.D VaJ n 0 2 1 )I o ll g h wee,h rio out sed e n o sc . n . . etr n ,
E
i
i whi h t Vigni S e e Co thed t t sa t or dut ofgood f ih a f i de l wasi pplc bl t a
n c he r i a upr m
ur l hat he t tz y y
t
at nd az ai
ng
na i a e o

n nUCC c ntat2 Va 2 5 2 9 4 8SE.d3 9 4 2(9 4. rigapia no asamo yd yd e n teae
oo rc. 48 . 6 , 6 , 4 . 2 9 , O 1 9) Barn p l éo f tt r ut o s o rs
c
a i i dut ,nor wa i t Vig ni Supr m e Cour' i e
n mpl
ed y
s t he r i a
e
ts nt ndon t do s a l w e Vig n a Co tha ar ad hed
o
o- o r r i i ur d le y l
t ta i pl d c na ofgood f ih a f i de ltg a i i r ale t t co r c s wihoutdihuba .Se Stpp v.
ha n m i ove nt
e
at nd ar ail pples n e sa e nt a t y t
s nce e e

Oud o W ol Cop.Va Ci. 0 , 9 9WL 1 4 8 5 a * ( a Ci. . 9 9.
to r rd r , . r 1 6 1 8
1 3 7 ,t 4 ' . rCt1 8)
V
9

ee nt o acnm f br a h o t i id c ve n o g f ih a d fi de l a e 1 a
lme s f li or e c f he mpl o na t f ood at n ar ai r : )
e
ng
c t c u l ea ns i bewe nt pa te ; nd 2 abt a h oft i id c ve nt S o
onta t a z léo hp t e he ris a ) e c
he mpl o na . t ne
e
G ln,
e LLC,944 F.Supp. a 466.Pli if m us brng t scn m a pa tofacountf
2d. t
antfs
t i hi li s r
ot

br a ofc rctz t rt n a a i
e ch onta , ahe ha s n ndepende t tL .a 465.
nt or. da t
Fozt scni ,M ori r le on Se ton 19 oft de d w hi sa es
hi l m
ts ei s
ci
he e
ch t t :
f r r s l ha t rghtt e or m e of t s Se t i y
f owe hal ve he i
Bor
o nf ce nt hi c u t

I tu ntdic tn d a a émepro t t e ris of ()
nsr me s on iue t ny
i r o he al t : 1
e
fve da prort t s l oft Pr ry puz ua t a powe
i
ys i o he ae he ope t
s nt o ny
r
of s e c aned i t s Se urt I tum e . .
al ont i
n hi
c iy nsr nt ..
Thos
e

c diins a e t tBo r we :()pa sLe r als ms whc
on to r ha ro r a y nde l u
.
ih
t n woul be due unde t sSec iy I tum e a t N ot
he
d
r hi
urt nsr nt nd he
e

a i no a clrto ha ocur d $)c rsa ydea l ofa
s f c eeain d c re ; u e n fut ny
o he c v n n so a r e n s ()pa sale p ns si ute i
t r o e a t r g e me t; c y l x e e nc r d n
e or i t sSec iy I tnm e ,i l lng,butnotlm ie t
nf cng hi
urt nstl nt ncuci
i t d o,
r as bl at ne ' f , pz r y i pec i a vaua i
e ona e tor ys ee ope t ns ton nd l ton
f es a ot r f es i ur ed f t pur e of pr ec i
e ; nd he e nc r
or he
pos
ot tng
Le ts i e es i t Pr r y and rght unde t s Se urt
nde ' nt z t n he ope t
i s
r hi c iy

l tume ;a ()tke s h a to a Le e ma r a o bl
nsr nt nd d a s uc cin s nd r y e s na y
r quie t a s e t t Le rs i e es i t Pr t a
e t o s ur ha nde ' nt r t n he opery nd
rght undert Se iy I t e ,a Bor owe ' oblga
i s
he curt nsrum nt nd
r rs i éon
t pa t s s s c ed by tls Se urt l % m e , s l
o y he um e ur
li c iy ns
nt ha l
c i
ontnue unchanged. Le r m a r r t t Bor owe pa
nde
y equie ha
r r y
s h r i t t m e s s a e ns i one or m or of t
uc e ns a e nt um nd xpe es n
e
he

f lo n f r ,a s lce b Le r () c s ( ) mo y
ol wi g o ms s ee td y nde: a a h; b ne
o d r () criid c c , ba k c c ,te s e' c c o
r e; c etfe hek n he k taurrs he k r
c hi rs chec pr de s
as e '
k, ovi d uch c c i dr w n upon an
he k s a
i ttzi whos de is a e i ur d by a f r l a nc
ns i ton
a
e post r ns e
ede a ge y,

i sr me ai or e y o () Elct ni Fu Tr nse .
n tu ntly
t
nét; r d e to c nds a fr
Upon r i t t m e by Boz owe ,t s Se urt I tum e a
ensa e nt
r t hi c iy nsr nt nd
oblgai s tt d he e s l r m an f l efec i asi no
i tons ecze
r by hal e i uly f tve
f
a ee a i had oc r d.'
cc lz ton
cut e '
ECF N o.1- 29-30.M or i cont ndsW SFS br a
2,
rs
e
e ched t i pled cove ntofgood f ih
he m i
na
at
a f i de lng be us i wasi pos i e f M or i t r i t t t l n :veda be or
nd az ai
ca e t
m
sbl or
rs o ens a e he oa
ys f e
t s e W SFS,f ispa t a gue t t a e e a
he al.
or t r , r s hat he cc lr don oft l n upon M or i' def ul
he oa
rss a t
a t r s dng f e l ur we e not ng m or t n t e r ie ofe ii c r ctzl
nd he e ul
or c os e r
hi
e ha he xe c s
xplc t onta ta
10

rght ,a t ta cam ofbr ac oft i ple c na ofgood f ih a f i de lng
i s nd ha li
e h he m i d ove nt
at nd at a i
r quie ft tt alged br c wa dihones a i bad f il 'r t rt n m e ey a
e r s fha he le
ea h s s
t nd n
aty' a he ha
rl n
a éon t ti unf vor bl t t pli if ECF N o.4,1 Se Enom ot 624 F.Supp. at
c
ha s a a e o he antf.
0. e
o,
2d

4 0 1(i dig t tpli fspe di ofab e c o t ei l dc ve ntof od fih
5 -5 fn n ha anéf la ng
r a h f h mpi o na go at
e
a f i de lng due t def nda ' fiur t pt de hi wih as c fi and f iur t
nd az ai
o e nts al e o ovi m t pa e lght
al e o
i or hi oft hi lkei
nf m m
he gh i lhood ofm e c ldiquaii ton a t rt e or f
dia s lfcai fe hr e
out
nonr f
e unda epa m e swass fc e bec us i alged dihone t r t rt n m e ey
bl y nt
ufii nt a e t le
s
s, a he ha
rl

unfvo a e c uc)
a r bl, ond t.
Se ton 19 oft D OT gr nt t M or i t rghtt ha tf e l ut pr e ngsa
ci
he
a so
rs he i o l or c os e oce di nd
r i t e t t r sofhe l n i s c eshe def ul a pa alf esa s i t d wih t
ensat he e m
r oa f he ur
r a t nd ys l e s oc a e t he
de aul. tir tglnc t ss cton s e st c e etght f t boz owe ,z t zt n pl e
f t A - s a e, hi e i e m o r at i s or he r r a he ha ac
l
duéeson t lnde .A l c a una da e c
he e r ogial nd voi bl ondi pr ce ntt t exe cs oft s
ion e de o he r i e he e
rght ,howe ,i knowl
i s
ver s
edge ofwha condii t bor o e m us m e t dic i
t
tons he r w r
t et o s ontnue

e or em e oft Sec iy I tum e .l d,Se
nf c nt he urt nsr nt ndee
céon 19 i l
ncudesal 2s ofpot il
ong t
enta
pa e sa f est borow e m a orm a notha t m ee ,a e al st ot r
ym nt nd e he r r y
y
ve o
t nd ven lude o he

pot ilpa e st a e notlse Thef lr koni ofwha abor owerm us do t hat
enta ym nt hat r
it d.
ul ec ng
t
t
t o l
f e l ur pr ee ngsi e iel wihi t contoloft lnde - he e W SFS tn ough is
or c os e oc di s ntr y t n he
r
he e r
r,
lt
t
a nt s r e ,Fa Se dcng. m ple by t gr ntng oft s rght,t t f e i t t
ppoi ed e dc r y r i l i d
he a i
he e i s he e or , s ha
W SFS a e tM or i ofw ha s ow es M ot i a l gest ts r
lr
rs
t he
.
r s le
ha he eque t d a r i t em e quot
se
e ns at nt
e

on A prl12,2017.ECF N o.1- 4. s
i
2, Es enéal M or i as whatc
ly, rs ked
ondii s woul
tons he
d

ha t m e i or rt e r ie he Se i 19 rght . SFS di notpr deM or i v'taa
ve o et n de o xe c s r cton
i sW
d
ovi
rs il

t i t em e quot untlM a 4,2017,22 da a t the t ques a f da bef e t
ensat nt
e i y
ys fe t e
t nd our ys or he
Pr rywass d a a éon.ECF N o.1 2,4.
ope t
ol t uc
-

The d y ofgood f ih a f i deai i Vigi a doe notpt ve apa t fom
ut
at nd at lng n r ni
s
e nt ry t
e r ii cont a t lrght . r ' aV e nnc ie Lt V . . G r c & Co. 156 F. 535,
xe csng
t c ua i s Vi ni r iult d. W R. a e
,
3d

5 (t Ci.1 8.tdo sho ve, zv n ap ryfo d iga ylngta wi ha te
43 4h t 99 )I e, we r p e e t at z m on n ti h t l ve h
n
l
e f c ofij o fu taig t rg toft o he pa t t r c i t f l soft
fe t nudng r r srtn he ih he t r ry o e eve he t i he
nt

c nta t t e te S eRettme (e o )ofCo tcsj2 (9 0 (eciigt
o zc bewe n h m. e sae nt S c nd
nta t 05 1 9 ) d srbn he
c nc pto T oo fil i c rcs (A c eec tlg oftpe o b d fi i
o e f ' d at n ' a t) K' omplt aao ue y s f a at s
g
f' ont
<
h
i sb e b t f lwi tpe a ea ngt s wh c h vebe nr c nie i j l il
mposil, ut he ol ng y s r mo ho e ih a e e og z d n ucca
o
i
de ii :e sop oft s rtoft ba ga n,l k ofrii nc a sa tng of,wilul
c sons va i
he pii
he t i ac
ilge e nd lcl
i
f lf
r
ende i ofi pe f ctpe f m anc ,abus ofapowe t s iy t r s a i er e e
rng m r e
r or
e
e
z o pec f e m , nd nt f z nce

wilorfi r t c o r t i t o he pat ' pe f r nc . W hi c utsi t sctu t
t al e o o pe ae n he t r rys zo ma e>
a
u
) l o t n hi ic i
e
ha f
ve ound t te r ii conta ua rght by ac e e a
ha xe c sng
r ct l i s
c l t dng al n doesnotc tt e a
oa
onsi
m
br ac oft unde li c r c ,t cour hasf
e h
he
ry ng ont a t he
t
ound no c esi wli h abor owe alged
as n nc
r r le
i biiy t hatf ecos epur ua t aconta ta rghtbe a e oft lnde ' de a
na lt o l or l uz
s nt o
r ctz l i
c us
he e rs ly.
Re i v.Cii oz a e I ,f i t nce i ve apli ifwho,afe f li
hben
tM t
nc. or ns a , nvol d
/ntf
t r alng

be nd i m or ga pa e s a id t t def ndantf al n m odii don.937 F.Supp.
hi n
t ge ym nt, pple o he e
or oa
fca

2 7 3 7 7 ( D. . 01 ) Th dee nt r ntdatmpp aymocfc to bu d n e
d 5 , 5 E. Va 2 3 . e fnda g a e e r t l iain, t e id
i
t fna m odiiadon.I Thede e nti ta e f e l ur pr e ngs t pli iffld
he i l
fc
d.
f nda niit d or cos e oc edi ; he antf le
sztt ha tt e pr ee ngs algi t t by f ii t gr ntt l n m odika i t
li o l hes oc di , le ng ha , nlng o a he oa
f ton, he

de enda ha br c d t i ple covenantofgood f ih a f i deai J. The c t
f nt d ea he he m id
at nd ar lng.I
L
out
cia r ed and r l d t not ng i t pr nis y not ott dee oft toblga ed t
ls g e
u e hat hi n he or s or
e he d rus i t he

12

de enda t gr t pli ifal n m odik a i a t tby f e l i t def nda
f nt o ant he a ntf oa
f ton, nd ha
or c osng, he e nt
ha be n e t ii a ce contacua lg .I
d e xe c sng lar
r t l i ht d.

H e e howe r i i M or i w ho ha acea c t c ualrght H e com pli a ges
r,
ve , t s
rs
d l r ont a t i . r
ant Ee
t ts wa notate ptng t a tr t tr sofhe c r t a t pli ifi Re i di
ha he s
t m i o le he e m
r ontac , s he antf n hben d,
butt f fl t t z soft c t c aswrte To do t t howe i s ne
o ulil he e m
he ont a t
it n.
ha ,
ve , he eded a

r nsa e entquot whi h s coul onl s c ewih t opposng pa t sc
ei t t m
e c he
d y e ut t he
i
ry' oope aéon.She
r
ci notr evetasr i t em e quot untli wast lt f he t e r iehe rght .
ld
ec i li ensat nt
e it
oo a e or r o xe cs r i s

O t rc esdeai wih t i ple c na a ac lt éon ofm orga sa e sr lry
he as
lng t he m i d ove nt nd cee a
t ge r inia l
ditnguiha e Cook v.Cii na il l . N o.3: c 00007,201 W L 2040070 a *6
si s bl .
tFi nca, nc,
14- v4
,t

( . Va Ma 1 , 0 4 (li fscqm o br a h oft i id c v n ntofg d f i
W D. . y 6 2 1 ) p anéf' li f e c he mpl o e a
e
oo at
h
a f i deai dinns ed bec us i w a pl d pur ua t t U CC,a a i pende t t
nd a. lng s i s
r
a et s e
s nt o he
s n nde
nt or,

a i r s ns de e a tsf t cos r a trar f slt mod f t l a ) Va z nav.
nd n e po e fnd n ' o e l u e fe e u a o iy he o n ; z a

Cii t a e I .No. :2 c 0 4 7 20 3WL 2 2 9 , t* ( D. . une4 20 3
t
Mor
nc, 71 -v- 0 9 , 1
4 30 2 a 4 W. Va J , 1 )

( snsigacam ofb e c oft i idc ve a ofg dfiha fi d aigwhe t
dirisn li
r ah he mpl o n nt oo at nd ar e l
e
n
n he
pli ifma enoa tmptt ri tt t l a atrn iewa s n )
antf d
te
o ensae he o n fe otc s e t.
M ot hass f enty pld aplusbl br a h oft i ple c na ofgood f ih
ds
ufki l e
a i e ec
he m id ove nt
at

a fidel t pa st t ehol o 1 $()W S ' moi t dinls Co nt11i
nd at ai o s he hrs d f 2q 6. FSS ton o s is u 1 s
ng
'
t z f e D EN I .
he e or
ED
E.

Fi al, ri alg svolto oft Trz i Le i Ac (T1 ' 1 U. C.
n l Mo zs l e i ains he th n ndng t ç LA' 5 S. j
y
e
t
<
)

1 3 ()2 a tz RelEsaeS tlme Pr e rsAc (RESP )1 C. R.
6 9t() nd le a tt ete nt ocdu e t T
< A' 2 F. j
2 63 c()i) Thesa eM orsrle o (5U.. j1 39t(), ndisi e nt
2 .6()1(i.
i
tmt ri eis n 1 SC. 6 ( 2)a t mplme i
)
ng
13

r gz ton (2 C. R. 2 .6c ()ii , ppl o yt hih c s morg g s S e1 U.. j
e tai 1 F. j 263 ()1 ( ) a y nl o g - o t t a e . e 5 SC.
l
i)

1 3 () ()1( (pa of teo sa ngbaa eonahih-o tmorg g ' 7 hih-o t
6 9a,t()A) T y f h uttndi lnc
T
g c s ta e). A g c s
m or ga i ata a ton wih ar t t t l e e bym oz t n 6. pe c nt gepoi s. .
t ge s r ns c i
t a e hat T l xc ed
.
wi
e ha 5 r e a
nt .

tea ea epi o frrt. 1 U.. j1 0 )1( (() Thea zgeprmeofe r t
h v rg rme fe ae' 5 SC. 6 2>b ()A)i I.
'
)
vea i fr ae
fm e t a z pzm e ofe z e f a c pa a e ta ac i asoft dat on wl h
f ans he ve age i
f t at oz om z bl t ns ton
he e
ùc

t ei ee tr t f rt ta a t i s t a p ls d b t But a ' 1 U.. j
h ntr s a e o he z ns ci s e, s ub ihe y he e u. 5 SC.
on
'

1 39 $)2( .
6 c ()B)
H e e t l n w a a30- rfxe r t m orga w1. a 11. i e e tr t e e ed
r , he oa
s
yea l d a e
t ge :4 n 5% nt t s a e nt r
1

i oon Ocobe 26 2 0 D OT I F. c r ig t t Fe z Fi nca I tt é
nt
t z , 0 7.
J Ac o dn o he de z na il nsiu ons

Exa n t Co i(FFEI ) tea ea eprmeofe rt onOcob r26 2 0 fra30
miai
on unclT
K C' h v zg i ft ae
t e ,07 o
yea fxe l was6. / . The sa tt y tne hol 6. 4,pl t a r geprm eofe r e,
r i d oan
45008
ttzor lr s d, 50 us he ve a
i
f r at

64 00e as1 9 0 S e1 U. C. 1 0 $b ()A)i()Thi t a,1 95 e c e
.5/, qu l 2.54. e 5 S. j 6 2 )1( ( l. s otl 2. % x e ds
)
M or i' r t of11. 4. r or ,M or i' l n i nota d gh- t?m orga wili t
rss a e
150 The ef e
rss oa s
f
hi cos '
t ge tnn he

me nngoft Tr t i Le ngAc (TI ) 1 U. C. 1 3 t()o t Re l tt
ai
he u h n ndi t T LAA 5 S. j 6 9( 2 z he a Esa e
)
S tlme Pr c d e Ac (< PA' 1 C. R. 2 6.6()1 (i. s sa t e a e
ete nt o e ur s t C
RES ) 2 F. j 2 3 c()i) The e ttz s r
i
t
i
napplc e t M ori ' D OT,t r or t m oton t dir s CountI i GRA N TE D .
iabl o
rss
he ef e, he
i o sni s
V s
F.

7Co rsrc g iet p o iin o 1 U.. j1 3 weea a nd nt d e t TI, f yHOEP whc rq ie
ut eo nz he rvso s f 5 SC. 6 9 r n me me a d d o TA T
b
A, ih e urs
lnder t m a a ldona dic os e t bor o r ofT gh- os ' f ih- a e l ns' Cunni ha v. a c e t
e s o ke dci l s l ur s o r we s hi c t or h g z t ' oa .
'
n m N dons r di

Fn S rsCo .49 F.d7 4 7 7(t Ci. 0 7; e as Se h n v Ba ko Am. meLo n I c, . :6c i. ev .
7 3 1 , 1 7h r 2 0 )se lo t e s . n f Ho
a s n .No 51 -v
6 OF, 0 7WL 3 4 1 , t 4( D. C.a 2 , 0 7. s b c ue1 U.. j1 3 i tei lme é ga to y
6- 2 1
8 3 5 a * E. N. Jn. 5 2 1 )Alo, ea s 5 SC. 6 9 s h mpe n n uh dt
fr1 C.. j2 63 ()1(i, 2C. R. 2 63 ()1(ii as sei t hih-o t rg g sS eTt t i Le ig
o 2 FR. 2 .6c()i) 1 F. j 2 .6c()i)s lo p chc o g c s motae. e 'h n ndn
i
i
u
Ac 7 FR 4 22- ,4
t 3
455 01 4526 t u 4 7.
hr 452
8S ft r ePrm eOfe Rae 'Ta e ,
ee r ve a
z
i
fr ts' bls FEDERALFI
NANCI I TI ONSEXAMI ON COUNCI
AL NS TUTI
NATI
L

h s/ - . cg v/aepe d a za ls % (ac lt t Av rg Pr eOfe Raea dp bihn weky
up :/ f .o rts ra /potbe. cluai he ea e i fr t n u l ig e l
he
h
ng
m
s
u d ts.
p ae)
14

A c or ngl a f t r s s tf t he e n,t cour G RAN TS t m oéon t
c di y, nd or he ea ons e orh r i he
t
he
o
dinls Count 1 I ,and 1 1 a D EN I S t m oton t dir s CountI
s is
s ,1
1 , nd
E he
i o snis
V.

An a opzat or rwilbe e e ed.
ppr i e de l
nt r

Ent r
e ed:

/ - /// .
7 J û.
/
'

4 /- 4
u

f K &,, '
2-

M iha lF.Ur sd
c e
ba l

ChifUn td Sae Ditit ud e
e ie tts stc l g

15