Cecil v. Astrue
Filing
36
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Magistrate Judge B. Waugh Crigler on 12/7/11. (hnw)
@k #g@# ggU:, y ;m uq'
O
gI , pyy ( r
A :l err vlr X
Y r
l
Ac -gg k , A
u
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I I I
CT
RG N A
LYN CHBU RG D I I O N
V SI
LI V .CECIL,
SA
F1,I
k:
)
j
1 1 G/
C1
.
U$
Q? .
p 71 : RK' . CL
x
)
.
.
R
CA SE N O . 1
6: 0CV 00009
Pl ntff
ai i ,
M EM O RAN D UM O PW I
ON
V.
MI
CHAEL J A STRUE
.
Com m i s one of Soc a Sec iy,
si r
i l urt
Dee n .
f nda t
By:
B. AUGH CRI
W
GLER
U. M AGI
S.
STM TE J
UDGE
Thi a ton i be or t unde sgne i ac or nc wih a Or re e ed on
s c i s f e he
r i d n c da e t n de nt r
Ocobe 5,2011 t raut iyof28U. C.j636b)3) dieci t undesgne t r ove
t r
,mde hort
S.
( ( , r tng he
ri d o es l
t pl ntf ' Se e r30,2011moton f at ne 'f sa c t .Fort f l ng
he ai ifs pt mbe
i or tor ys ee nd oss
he olowi
r a o , nOr e wil n e OVERRULI t eCo sine ' o jcins GRANTI
e s ns a d r l e tr
NG h mmiso rs be to ,
NG
pli ifsm oto f ra t ne f esa c t a AW ARDI a tr 'f esi t a
antf
i n o tor ys' e nd oss nd
NG to neys e n he mountof
$6, 09.3 a c t i t n oun of$350.
1 5 nd oss n he m t
00.
Thepr e u hit y oft sa ton i n y s tf rh i t M a 11 2011Re r a
oc dt ul sor
hi c i s mpl e o t n he y ,
po t nd
Re o n ain(t e 0 t)e tr db M a itaeJ d eM ih e F. ba s il ( tNo 2 .
c mme d to : p r' ne e y gsrt u g c a l Ur n k . Dk . . 3)
R
'
On Aprl25,
i 2007 pli iffld a i ai f dia lt i u a be i sa s e e al
, antf ie pplc tons or s biiy ns r nce nett nd upplm nt
s urt i o be ft.( por, 4. l ade sone ee onAugus 5,2009an
ec iy nc me neis Re tp. ) n cii ntrd
t
Ad nitaieLa J d eCta J d e'f u dta pantf s fee tef l n s v r
mi srtv w u g
w u g ' o n h t li if u fr d h ol g e ee
)
owi
i im e s s olos s dior roft l ba s newiho ne v compr so a t ii,
mpa r nt : c i i, s de
he um r pi
t ut r e
es i n, rhrts
blsts alr i r i ii, a a h sa a a xeya j sme td s r e t a d e n trq ie
t ii, legc h nts he d c e nd n n it/du t n io d r h t o s o e ur
r
teament (d. TheLa J
r t .1 )
w udgec l dt tplitf rti t r sdualf tona ca ct
oncude ha anif eaned he e i unci l pa iy
(t FC' t pe f m ar ngeoflghtwor i l nglfi /ar ngupt t nt pounds
G
R. ' o ror a
)
i
k,ncudi itngc ryi
o we y
' udgeU r ns snce has be n el va e t Unie St t s D it i tJ
J
ba ki i
e e t d o t d a e s rc udge.
.
,
)
ç'
oc asonaly andt n poundsge nty,a sa ng, ki a sti e h f at a ofsx
c i l
e
que l nd tndi wal ng, nd itng ac or ot l i
hou si a e ghtho w o kda pr de t ts ha a s ts a o i t ta l she t c nge
r n n i - ur r y, ovi d ha he s i/ t nd pton ha low
r o ha
po iina wil n a o tn a ne de f rc mfr.(é4 Th La J dg f rh rc ncu e ta
sto t la d s fe s e d o o o t 1
e w u e u te o ld d h t
pli ifc donl oc sonaly pus a pul wih he l rextemii ;ci b saisand
antf oul
y ca i l
h nd l t r owe r tes lm t r
r mps soop,be knee ,c ouc orc a ;butcoul ne rclm b l r ,r sors a f ds
n ;t
nd,
l r h
r wl
d ve i adde s ope
c fol .
@d. TheLa J deemi t tplitf s de agei nomor t si t nr uie
)
w udge tr ned ha anif houl ng n
e witng ha eq rd
i t co s o daiy lvi a t ts m us a d e
n he ur e f l i ng, nd ha he
t voi xpos et wo kplceha r a lmg
ur o r a
za ds nd t
irtnt.(d.a p.5. Hef rhe deemi dt ts wa lmiedt t pef ma eo uns le
ria s I t )
u t r tr ne ha he s i t o he ror nc f kild
wor c itngofno c
k onssi
n- omplx, o i r peii t s i a1 sr s e r nm e t tdoes
e r utne, e ttve a ks n ow te s nvio nt ha
n tiv lewo ka ap o u to r t.(d) T La J d eddno b le plitf c udrtr
o n ov r t r d cin ae 1 he w u g i t eive an if o l eu n
t he pa t ee al wo k, utha t r weeasg iia t u e o j b i t en to a
o r s rlv t r b t thee r in fc n n mb r f o s n h ain l
t
e
conomyt ts c dpef m.(é)Uli t y,t La J ef t tpl ntf wasnot
ha he oul ror I
tmael he w udg ound ha ai if
d sbld.(d)
ia e 1 .
Pl n ifa ald t Law J e' Augus 5,2009 de ii t t Ap a sCounci,
aitf ppe e he
udg s
t
c son o he pe l
l but
t rques f rviw wa de e (2) Pli ifi tt e a a to i t sCo tonMa c 1
he e t or e e s nid. f
antf nsiutd n cin n hi ur
rh ,
201 ( . 1)
0. DktNo. .
Th pat sfld co smo in frs mmayj d me t ( t No .1 ,1 . l he moin
e ri ie r s to s o u r u g n . Dk . s 3 5) n r t
e
o
f rs mmayj dg n , litf alg dt ef lo n ;( )Th La J d ed dn t iep o e
o u r u me t pan if le e h o lwig 1 e w u g i o gv r p r
wei tt t opi on ofhe te tngphyscin,Dr Swa t ( TheLa J
gh o he ni
r rai
i a . rz;2)
w udgeerdbyfii t
re
alng o
p o el e laeh rce i ii a d( )Th La J d erle o fa dtsi n fo t e
r p ry vau t e rd blt n 3 e w u g eid n lwe e tmo y r m h
y;
v c to a e p r (VE' i fn i gt a t eeweej b i tenaina e o o t a s ec ul
o ain l x e tE ' n id n h t h r r o s n h to l c n my h t h o d
t )
per or .
f m
TheM a sr e J
gitat udge f md t tt La J e c r f l c i r d t opi onsofe e
ot ha he w udg a e uly onsde e he ni
fr d
by Dr Swa t a ga t m s
. rz nd ve he omewe g . TheM a srt J
i ht
gitae udge f rhe f undt tt de son
ut r o
ha he cii
nott gi c r lngwei t t ste tng s ur wa s
o ve ontoli
ght o hi r a i o ce s uppore by s t ntale de e He
td
ubsa i vi nc .
de e ne t tt Law J
t nni d ha he
udgeha ca e u l c i r t medi le de ea ha a co e
d r f ly onsde ed he
ca vi nc nd d c unt d
f he pan and i im e swhe hec l dt ts waslmiedt lg wo k.The
or r i
mpar nt
n
oncude ha he
i t o i ht r
M agita eJ e c ude t tt La J
sr t udg oncl d ha he w udge' c edi lt fnd ng wa s ppore by
s r biiy i i
s u
td
antf i l r
nt o he our, he
itae udge
s tnta e denc I a s sngpl i ifsfna a gume t t c tt M ag sr t J
ubsa il vi e. n s es i
f
ound:
Thec r tsa eoft a i sr tver c d l ve s m equesi ast whatt VE wa
uren t t
he dm nitai e or ea s o
ton o
he
s
syngi r s o s t t eco se miainb (litf s c u s l Be a eo telc
a i n e p n e o h r s-xa n to y p an if q o n e. c us f h a k
ofc mi y i t VE' t tm o andt f tt tt Comm iso rbe r t bur n a
l t n he
s esi ny
he ac ha he
s i ne a s he de t
se fve oft s que i e l ton pr es , he t der i d bele st tt s c e
tp i
he e ntal va ua i
oc s t m s gne
i ve ha hi as
ne t ber m a d f acomplt t r t ng oft voc tonale de epr de
eds o e nde or
e e mde sandi
he a i
vi nc ovi d
by t VE .
he
( p r, .1 .
Re o tp 3)
Th p rise c fldtmeyo j cin t teM a itaeJ g ' Re o t ( tNo . 4,
e a t a h ie i l b e to s o h g srt ud e s p r. Dk . s 2
e
Up nd n v rv e t eprsdngDititJ d ef t ta tep ris o j cinswee
o e o o e iw,h e ii src u g omd h t h a t ' be to
e
r
wihoutm e i.Headopt t Re te iel a r m a d t c et t Comm iso r
t
rt
ed he por ntr y nd e nde he as o he
s i ne
p ls a tt S ne eFo ro 4 U.. j4 5 g .
tru n o e tnc u f 2 SC. 0 ()
O n Se e be 30, 1 pl ntf ' co e t l d t i t ntm o i n f a t eys f es
pt m r 201 , ai i f s uns l i e he nsa
t o or tom
'e
a dc ssp ts a t ot Eq l c s t J tc Ac (t A', 8U. C.j2 2 a, e kn
n o t t u n t he ua Ac e s o usie t t
r
EAJ ' 2 S.
)
41 () s e ig
$ ,0 5 i fe a d$ 0i c ss ( tNo. 0. l teb iftldi s p r o h rmo infr
6 1 9.3 n e s n 35 n o t . Dk . 3 ) n h re ie n u po t f e to o
a t ne 'f es pl i ifa gue t ts i e ild t r c
tor ys e , antf r s ha he s ntte o e overat r ys f esbec us t
to ne ' e
a e he
Co s in rspo i o wa n ts bsa tal usi e .( an ifsS p e e 3 , 01 mo in
mmiso e ' st n s o u tnil tt d Plitf e tmb r 0 2 1 to
i
yj i
f ra tr e ' e s heen fe G ' mo in'p. 2 Fu te , h c ne st t h fe s ud
o t n ys fe , ri a tr Tls to , 3. rh r s e o tnd ha t e e s ho l
o
' )
b a r e a art o $1 33 pe h u , rt h g e t a t sa d r $1 5p rh t .(d)
e wad d t ae f 7 .2 r o r a ae ih r h n he tn a d 2 e ol 1
r
Fi ly, antf a guest tconsse wih t a sg e s fld wiht c lt a pur ua
nal pl i if r
ha
it nt t he s i nm nt he ie t he otr, nd s nt
t Asr ev Ra l f 1 0S. . 5 ( 01 ) tefea r s o db ma ed rcl p ya l t he
o tu . tf i 3 Ct 2 21 2 0 ,h e wad h ul e d ie ty a be o r
c u s la tri i d tr ne ta s ed e n t a ea yFe ea d b whih i s b e t o
o n e, fe t s ee mi d h t h o s o h v n d r l e t c s u j c t
c le to (J)
olcin. f
I hi Op ii n, he Comm iso ra gue t tpli tf f e a ia i s d be
n s posto t
s i ne r s ha a n ifs e pplc ton houl
d ne b c u eteGo r me tsp sto wa s b tn ilyj siido teb ssta ih da
e id e a s h ve n n ' o iin s u sa tal u tfe n h a i h t t a
r s na ebassi 1w a fc.(
ea o bl i n a nd a t Commiso rsOpposto pp.3- ) TheCo si r
sine'
iin,
7.
mmisone
as e t t ti t sCour de e m i t tpl ntf i e il t af a r t numbe ofho s
s rs ha f hi
t t r nes ha ai if s ntted o ee wa d, he
r
ur
s u h s o db r d c d (# a p 79. Fial t Co si n rc n e d ta plitf i
o g t h ul e e u e . f . t p. - ) n l he mmiso e o tn s h t an if s
y,
i c re ti a s ri gt a a yf ea r s o l b p i dr cl t h rc u s l (#. tp 2)
n o rc n s e t h t n e wad h ud e ad ie ty o e o n e. f a . .
n
A cutsoa r atre'fe a de ssoapeal gp r i crancvl cin
o rit wad t nys es n ott rvin at n eti iiat s
o
i /
o
agans t Unied St t unde t EAJ unl si fndst tt gove n e ' poston wa
i t he t
aes
r he
A es t i ha he
r m nts ii
s
s b tn ilyj siido t a s e il ic msa c sma ea a r u j t 2 U. C.
u sa tal u tfe r h t p ca cr u tn e k n wad nus. 8 S. j
2 2 d( )A) Th dititc u t ha ed sr to t d tr n ara o bl fea r a d
41 ( )1( . e src o rs v ic ein o eemie e s na e e wa d n
whehe t awar s d bem a i e s oft saut y c p.Pir e v Unde
t r he
d houl
de n xce s he t t or a
ec .
rwoo4 487
U. 5 2 (98 ) l a v Sulv n 9 6F.d 1 6 1 7(t ci.9 )
S. 5 1 8 ; i y . lia , 3 2 7 , 7 4h r1 91 .
H a ng r vi w e t r or be or t c ta t pa te 'm e or nda, he t de sgne
vi e e d he ec d f e he our nd he ri s m a
t m ri d
c n ld sta t ep iinof h Co sin rwa n ts bsa tal j siid.Al ug
o cu e h t h osto t e mmiso e s o u tnil u t e t h
y f
ho
z antf d d notas i pa numbe st t bre fl d i s ppo tofhe m oton f a tr ys
pl i if i
sgn ge
r o he i f ie n u r
r i or to ne '
f es Forea e ofr e e e t unde s g d ha as i ned pa num be st t doc l e .
e .
s
ef r nc , he
r i ne s s g
ge
r o he tm nt
3A pary who w i a r m and pur ua t Sen e Fotroft Soc a Se trt A c ,4 U .S. j
t
ns e
s nt o t nce t he i l c liy t 2
C.
4 5 g ,sap e al pa t f rEAJ p r o e . eS aa av S h #r 5 9U. 2 2 3 0 3 2
0 ( ) i rv ii ry o
ng
A u p s s Se h ll . c ae , 0 S. 9 , 0 - 0
( 993) Ther ndi t sca ewa madepuruantt Se e eFotr
1 .
ema n hi s s
s
o ntnc l.
neihe M ag srt J e Ur ns nort pr sdi Diti tJ
t r
itae udg ba ki
he e i ng src udges cii ly f md t Law
pe fca l ot he
J d e sd cso t a t e eaeoh r o si ten to a e o o ta pan ifc udp ro m n t
u g ' e ii n h t h r r te j b n h ain l c n my h t litf o l e fr o
t bes
o uppo td by s bsa ile de e, heunde sgned c l st tt ado edfndi of
re
u t nta vi nc t
ri
oncude ha he pt i ngs
J
udgeUr ns w e et nt mountt s h afndi Atbo t ,i wasde e m i d t tt
ba ki r a n
o uc i ng.
tom t
t r ne ha he
Comm isone f ie t dic r hi bur n a t fna l ve i t s que ile l to W he
s i r a ld o s ha ge s de t he i l e l n he e nta va uai n.
n
t toc uz ,t diti tcour c t nl coul r ve s t Comm iso rsde i i a e e
ha c s he src
t erai y
d e r e he
s ine ' c son nd nt r
j d me to b hafo t cama tb c us t r wa i u tce t vie c o frdt rb t
u g n n e l f he li n e a e hee s ns f in e d n e fe e o e u
i
p an ifs i a i c s o d s bl y.Al r tv l,h c u t o l rma dt c s f r
litf prmaf ce a e f ia ii
t t naiey te o r c u d e n he a e o
e
f rhe pr e ngs t a f di t Comm isone as c cha t deveop evi ncet t
u t r oce di ,hus for ng he
s i r e ond nce o
l
de
ha
h dn t u c ud s b tn il j siyad na o ,h tfiig fc tep o p c o h vigt
a o b t o l u sa tal u tf e il r t a aln , a e h r s e t f a n o
y
gr ntbe t .Eihe wa t unde sgne c nnotfndt Com misone ' poston
a
neks t r y, he
ri d a
i he
s i r s ii
s sa tal j tfe et e a miitai eyo j iil wh r , sh r ,h c u t a
ub tn il usiid, ih r d n sr tv l r udcal ee a ee t e o r h s
y
y,
de e mi t the f ie t dicha gehi bur n a t fna lve oft s nta e l ton
t r ned ha
a ld o s r
s de t he i l e l he eque il vaua i
Pr S.
OCCS
Pl i ifsc e s ksa houry r t of$1 32 pe hourf wor pero me bef e
antf ouns l ee n
l ae
73. r
or k f r d or
ti Co r.( ' mo in, 3. Plitf sc t e d tr n dt eh u l rt o $1 3.2b
h s u t P1s to p. ) an if oms l eemie h o ry ae f 7 3 y
notng t tt c toflvi a r fec ed i t Co lm e Pr c I x f t So h ur
i ha he os
i ng, s e l t n he nsl r i e nde or he ut ban
r gi hasi r a e fom 1 40 i M ac 1
e on,
nc e s d r
52. n rh 996, hee f ci da eoft EAJ t 211308 i
t f e tve t
he
A, o . n
Au u t2 0 temo t t a amao iyo wok i t ec s wa p ro me .1 . Th sic e s t
g s 01 ,h nh h t j rt f r n h ae s e f r d (d) i n r a e o
t $1 pe hourlmi on EAJ f e r s t i an houry r t of$1 32 pe hour The
he 25 r
i t
A e s e uls n
l ae
73. r
.
Co s in rh sn t b e tdt panif c ku ain o t eh t l rt , n t u d rin d
mmiso e a o o j ce o li tf s a lto f h ol y ae a d he n esg e
r
fndst tt si ar s bl hotryr t i t sc e
i ha hi s em ona e ll ae n hi as .
Pli ifsc
antf ouns ls ist tt y e nde at a of35. hotr r pr s i t
e ubm t ha he xpe d ot l
25 ls e e entng he
pl i ifbef r t sCo t W hiet Co misone a guesf ar duc i i t numbe of
antf o e hi ur.
l he m s i r r
or e ton n he
r
hotr cl i e t unde s g d fndst m i m i l r s bl The C om m i sone s
zs a m d, he
r i ne i
he m nenty ea ona e.
s i r'
o j cini t i rg r wil eo er ld.
be t n h s e a d l b v rue
o
Fi ly, heCom mi sone oppos sdie tpa ntofa EAJ a r t pli ifs
nal t
si r
e r c yme
ny
A wa d o antf '
c t e i se do t plitf, es l.Hei tr rt Asr ev Ratf t s p o t i o jcin.
oms l n ta f o anif h ref
nep es tu . l f o u p r hs be to
The e t amoun duet cai
r , he
t
he l mantwa ofs tby s t pl ntf owe t t gove n e t a
s fe
ums he ai if d o he
r m n , nd
t Supr me Cour hel t t und t ec r lmsa s t EAJ r quie a tr ys f e be
he
e
t d ha , er hos icl tnce , he
A e r s to ne ' e s
a r die ty t t ltga t Spe t a l t Cour hed t tt pl n t xtoft EAJ
wa ded r c l o he ii n . cik ly, he
t l ha he ai e
he
A
rq ie atme s f e bea r e t t l ia t tu s b e tn EAJ f e t ofe o a y
e ur s to y ' e s wa d d o he i g n ,h s u j cig A e s o fs t f n
t
pr e si Fede alde s
e xitng
r bt .
Pl i irsc
antt ouns lhasar d t tpli ife c e a a sgn e off est he moto
e
gue ha antf xe ut d n s i m nt e o r i n,
t e e ilng c
her by ntti ouns lt die tpa
e o r c ymen oft EAJ f esa coss Thi c e s ms
t he
A e nd t . s as ee
d si g s bl o isfcsfo Ral i ta t eei n a s ri nta tepanifo ste
itn uiha e n t a t r m tf n h t h r s o se t h t h litf we h
o
Co sine a yo ep y ns o t elk .M o e v r Ral fd e no p o i t sin n so
mmiso r n v r a me t, r h ie ro e , tl o s t r hbia sg me t f
f
EA J f esa c t t t i a t neysby t s c s ulpl i ifa i tw hom no of s tc n
A e nd os s o he r tor
he uc es f a ntf ga ns
fe a
o ti.Atla t woc u t i t i Ditit a eefcu tdfea sg me t a trRalf S e
ban
e s t o rs n h s src h v fe t ae e sin n s fe tf e
Hi l v Asr ,201 W L 390991 ( . Va Se e r30,201 9
nke . tue 0
6 W D. . ptmbe
0) Powe sv Asr 201 WL
r . tue, 0
2 7 6 0( . Va J n 2 , 01 ) rh r r ,ts o l b p ne o tha t Co sin r
7 2 6 W D. . u e 2 2 0 .Fu temo e i h ud e oitd u t the mmiso e
hit ialy hashonor s h as i e si ot rc s sbe or t t r i ne
sorc l
ed uc sgnm nt n he a e f e he mde sg d.
I t sc s howe ,t unde sgne c
n hi a e,
ver he
r i d annotl ca ea as i e e c e by t
o t ny sgnm nt xe ut d he
pli ifi t pladi be o et c t Abs nta a sg e ,hea t
antf n he e ngs f r he our.
e n s i nm nt t tonwys f sa c t
' ee nd oss
awar d he e n s d be pai di e ty t pl i i f N ot t t ndi i i w e e pl i i f s
de r i houl
d r c l o a ntf .
wihs a ng, f t r a ntf '
i e i n t a sgn r c r ofEAJ f a c t t he couns l s s d b gi n t
nt nto o s i e ove y
A ees nd os s o r
e, he houl e ve he
opporuniy t s m i t t cou ta t Com m i sone , wr te a s gne a s gnm e o f s
t t o ub t o he r nd he
s i r a i t n nd i d s i
nt f ee
a cosswihi ar s na etm e.l t teve ,t Commi so i t m a payme a
nd t t n ea o bl i
n ha
nt he
s i ner s o ke
nt s
diecedby s h a sgnme 4
r t
uc s i
nt.
Foral t s r as ns a O r rw ile e GR AN TI pl ntf sm oton f r a t r
1 he e e o , n de l nt r
NG ai if
i o to neys
'
fe i t a
e s n he mountof$ 1 53 a cossi t a ou of$350 t be pad i a cor nc
6, 09. nd t n he m nt
o
i n c da e
he e t
r wih.
The Cl r oft Cour i diec ed t ta m i a c oft s M e or
e k he
t s r t o r ns t opy hi
m andum O pi on t al
ni o l
c uns ofr c d.
o el e or
EN TERED :
G. M a itaeJ d e
s. gsrt u g
Q
D at
e:
4I i beyo t t r i d t t a en afna i li e e tt beofs ta i ti t sl s
ts
nd he mde sgne ha , bs t i nc a nt r s o
f e ga ns n he tm
awar
ded,t Com m i s onerha a bas st c le t pr i t orva i t ofa as i e of
he
si
s
i o ha l nge he opre y
ldiy
n s gnm nt
a EAJ a r I al os goe wihouts yi t tac am a ' a sgnm e off sa c t t
n
A wa d. t m t s t
a ng ha l i nts s i
nt ee nd oss o
co ele s ntaly as ur cot s lt y a m a l w ilr e vet f e whi h t y ea e i
uns s e i l s es m e he c ly l ec i he e s c he m d n
r pr s i t c i nt
e e entng he le .
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?