Protherapy Associates, LLC v. AFS of Bastian, Inc. et al
Filing
113
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on July 27, 2011. (jcf)
'
CLERK' oFFl U.
S
c:
..
1
ATL
I THE U NI
N
TED STATES D I
STRI C OURT
CT
FoR THE W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I NI
CT
RGI A
LYNCHBURG D I SI
VI ON
s, Dl counr
sm
Y
NCHBUR v
q l
;
,
,
FI
LED
J 2? 2 1
UL
91
JU I ' - tuuy '
A
'
l
$h
uEu
BY:
.
u ca
CI L N O. 1 v0001
VI
6: 0c
7
PROTHERAPY A SSOCI
ATES,LLC,
Plit f
an f
M EMORANDUM OPNI
I ON
A FS OF BAS AN, NC. etaI,
TI I , .
Dee d ns JUDGENORMAN K.M OON
f n a t.
Thi m at ri be or t coul upon co i r ton ofPl ntf ' moton s e ng
s te s f e he
'
t
nsde a i
ai ifs i e ki
co imai ofa ar tai a r a Dee
nfr ton n birton wa d, nd fndant'motont modiy s h a r ( cke
s i o
f uc wad. do t
nos 1 a 1 .Noheai ha be nr se andt motonsaerpef de ii
. 00 nd 06)
rng s e eque td, he i r i or cson.
Pl i ifas e t t tD ef nda s ha r f e t m a pa e s i ac or nc w ih t
a ntf s r s ha
e nt ve e us d o ke ym nt n c da e t he
a bir t ' de son.De e nt cai t tt a bir t re r i hol ng Am iy Fe l e ve
r taor s cii
f nda s l m ha he r ta o red n di
t lows r ,
I . // Kist He lh ae(d s i 'j itya ds v r lyla l f rt a r Aslfn ta
nc db a sio atc r t st ) on l n e e al ibe o he wad.
Ki o'
id h t
t a bir t r sdec son i c it ntwih t s tl nta ee nti t sca e, Iwilgr ntt
he r ta o '
ii s onsse
t he e teme gr me n hi s
l a he
Pli ifsm oto de t De e nt 'moton,a c im t a bir t r sawa d.
antf '
i n, ny he f nda s
i nd onfr he r ta o '
r
Pr r Asocits LLC Ct o-he a 'wa apr de ofphysc a
oTheapy s ae ,
pr r r py' s ovi r
)
ial nd
oc
cupa i lt r py a s ec lng gepa hol s r ce t ds le nur i f c lte ,' or
tona he a nd pe h/a ua
t ogy e vi s o tkil d sng a iiis '
nuri ho .TheDee nt a es ve s hf iiis(ta iii ', p1 Kist whih
sng mes
fnda s r e n uc aclte $ cltes' 1 us sio, c
F
)
l t
Alhought r a et n deenda sna
he e r e f nt med i t a nde c
n he me d ompli t abir tonpr ee d a ns t ei
ant he r tai
oc de gai t he ght
,
defndant na i t orgi lc
e
s med n he i na ompli : AFS ofBa ta ,I d/ aBl Count N ur i a Re b Ce e
ant
sin nc. b/ and
y
sng nd ha ntr
A FSofFi sl, I c/ aBra Ce e Nu sn Ca eofFi asl, AFSofLow M oor l d b aBranCe e ,
nca te nc.lb/ in ntr r ig r
nc te
, nc. / / i
ntr
N u sng CentrofAlegha Ca l l Ca eCe e ,L. ,Am iy Fel e veofHondo, I db/ Hondo
ri
e
l ny, ne sand r ntr P.
t lows r
nc. / a
z
.
,
..,
n g tae c ranTh rpySev c sAg e me t (t re n s' b t e Pr -h rp a dte
e oitd e ti ea
r ie r e n s t e me t' ewe n of ea y n h
Ag
)
Fa ltes TheFa ltest r i t d t Therpy Se vi sAgr m e si l t 2009, be n
ciii .
ciii e m na e he
a
r ce
ee nt n a e
and ga
hii Pr
rng oThe a e pl esi vi aton ofar src i c na twihi t Agr me s See
r py m oye n ol i
e titve ove n t n he ee nt .
Pr he a As oc .LLC v AFSo tan,I ,--F.Su 2d-- 2011W L 17071 0 ( .
ol rpy s s,
.
fBasi nc. pp. -,
9 W D.
Va. l .Pr
201 ) oTherpyalocame t tDee nsfie t pa f sr c r ndeed.
a s li d ha fnda t ald o y or evies e r
Thepa tesentr i o e- i neg itonst r s vet rdiput s.The r s twasa
ri
e ed nt ma l ota i o e ol hei s e
e ul
s tlme t g e me t e i n e b ap i o emal d tdNo e e 6 2 0 (h
ete n a r e n , vde c d y ar f - is ae v mb r , 0 9 te
t et me f'.S ePr h rpyAsoc . . o sin I c, 6:0 c - 7 201 W L
t tl n ) e oT e a s s v AFS fBa t , n .No. 1 -v 1 , 0
s e
a
e mi ha he teme e r he
2696638, * ( . Va. ul 7,201 .1det r ned t tt Setl ntr quied t payment
at 2 W D. J y
0)
ds uet beab tae b tt t hsc u t dj rs ito o rt r srciec v n n cam.
ip t o r irtd, u ha t i o r ha u idcin ve he e titv o e a t li
1 llt rde e nedt tt Fa iii we ela ef br ac ngt r srci co na ,
d. a e t nni ha he cltes r ibl or e hi he e titve ve nt but
t tPr
ha oThe a ha nots
r py d
hown goodr as t pi r t cor a evei a hol Kist labl
e on o e ce he por t l nd d s io i e
f rt br a 2011<
o he e ch.
1 071 a * 3* eeSt ee r .Cont1Ditli Sal sCo.v
7 90, t 2- ,
s
at x el
s ilng e
.
V c l ,2 S 2 7 , 2 ( a 1 46 ; o n o Ene s o a kwnvle I c v F#f Gr , n .
o el 7 o.d 28 7 9 Fl. 9 )J h s n tr. fl c
e
il, n . .
#.I c,
1 2F.d 1 9 ,1 2 ( 1h Ci.9 ) l c nr s,heab tao d tr n dt a Kist s ud
6 3 2 0 3 0 1 t r1 98 . n o ta tt r irt r eemie h t sio ho l
b j it a ds v r l l bef rd ma e aii o to tepa me t ipue
e onl n e eal i l o a g s rsng u f h y n d s t.
y
y a
J c a r ew ofa bir ton de sonsi S m ong t narowe tknown t l '
udii l evi
r ta i
cii s t
a
he r s
o aw.'
Po t Se v v Am. t Wor e sUni 204F. 523,527( h Ci. )( i Uni
sal r . . Posal k r on,
3d
4t r2000 quotng on
Pa . R. . h e a 43 U. 8 , ( 9 ).Be a s ire iw o a abi ao ' a r i
c R. v S e h n, 9 S. 9 91 1 78) c u e t lve f n r t trs wad s
l
r
s ve ey cr um s rbe ' ac ts ul notdit b a a bir t ' a r e e k
e r l ic c i d,' our ho d
sur n r ta ors wa d xc pt t
upon a s
howi
ng
ofo oft g o
ne he r undslsed i t Fe r lAr tai Ac ,ori t a bir t a t d i m a f t
it n he de a bir ton t f he r taor c e n nies
dirgadoft l ' Ape Pl ngSu yv US. ppl Co. 1 F. 1 1 (t
se r he aw.
' x umbi ppl . Su y , 42 3d 88, 93 4h
He t r a Re biia i AFS ofLe
alhca e nd ha ltton,
banon,l d// M a eGr Reha ltton a Heat Ca eCe er
nc. ba pl ove
biiai nd lh r nt ,
AFS ofYu a,l d baPal Viw Re ltton a Ca eCentr a A m iy Felows rv l d/ / Kist
m nc. / / m e
habiiai nd r
e , nd
t
l e e, nc. ba s io
Heat a e Asus d he en,t tr tDefnda s' eer t t ei tdefndant named i t orgi c
lhc r .
e r i he e m : e nt'r f s o he gh e
s
n he i nal ompli .
ant
2
Ci 9 8 (iai n o te ) Th F d rlAr irto Ac (
nl 9 ) ctto s mitd . e e ea btain t k
TAA' , U. C. j9 1 , lo a
' 9 S. j - 1 al ws
)
c toc im,va t ormodiyabirtona r .(
our t ontr
cae,
f r tai wads û
undert tr ofj9,acoul i t
he ems
' mus'
t
c i a abirtona r t es i i va td, fed,orc r td $ pr s rbed'i jj
onfnn n r tai wa d unl s't s cae modii
orece as e ci n
1 a 11. Hal Ste As oc . v M ate,I ,552U. 576( )
0 nd ' l r et s s, . tl nc.
'
S. 2008 .
Hee, f nt sekmodii tonoft a birt ' a r purua t j11oft
r Deenda s e
fcai
he r taors wa d s nt o
he
FAA ,whi h a i t t f l i c es
c pples o he olow ng as :
()W her t r wasa e de maei mic c ai offgursorane de mae il
a
e hee
n vi nt tral salulton i e
vi nt tra
mit ke i t de c i i ofa pe s t ng,orpr t r e r t i t a r
sa n he s rpton ny r on, hi
opery ef red o n he wa d.
( W her t abir or ha a r u n amatrnots te t t unl sii a
b)
e he r tat s ve waded po
te
ubmitd o hem, es t s
ma t notafe tngt m e isoft decson upon t m at rs it d.
ter
f c i he rt
he ii
he te ubm te
()W heet awadi i rec i matroffr notafe tngt meisoft
c
r he r s mpe f t n te om
fci he rt he
cont
rover y.
s
9U. C.j11a -c .l s h c e ,t c tS ymodiyandc r tt awad,s a t ef t
S.
()() n uc ass he our t
ma
f
orec he r o s o fec
teitn t ee fa dp o t j sieb t e t ep ris' I De e da t' li d e n t
h n e t h r o n r moe u tc ewe n h ate . d fn ns cam o s o
'
a a t ttw ihi a oft s a ut y ca egore
ppe r o i t n ny he t t or t i s.
Nordoesi a
t ppea t tt ar taoracedwih ç a f s dir r oft l ' Ape
r ha he bir t t
t s nie t sega d he aw.
m
' x
Pl n 1 F. a 1 l i wel esa ihedt tt cor a ef mus ber s ctd. A nd
umbig, 42 3d t 93. t s l t bls
ha he por t onn
t e pe e
De enda sa e lkey co r c t tt Agr e e sdo not by t m s l , pr vi a r as t
f nt r i l r e t ha he e m nt
, he eves o de ny e on o
hol K i s t la e f t def ul oft Fac lte . Howe r t a bir t ' de son co r d
d s io i bl or he a t he iii s
ve , he r ta ors cii
nce ne
noto y t A gr em e s buta s t Se te e . The Se te e pr des
nl he
e nt ,
l o he t l m nt
t l m nt ovi :
Thi e- i c imsourag e me .AlhoughPr r p ase t t tge ti
s mal onfr
r e nt t
oThe a y srs ha c ran
doc
ument)aenotr r t bepr vi dt Kist andisaflae (t sio' i wil
s r
equied o
o de o sio
t fiits t st ),t l
Ki
do s unde t a ee entr c
o
r he gr m
ea hed:
( )Fort a
1
he mount owe f sr c srnde e t oughOcobe 31 Kist wilpa
s d or evie e r d hr
t r , s io l y;
a. $1 000 on orbef eNo mbe 23,2009
04,
or ve r
b. $1 000 on orbe or Novembe 30,
04,
f e
r 2009
c. OneFourh oft Oc obe i c on orbef e Dec m be 4, 2009
t
he t r nvoies
or
e r
d. OneFourh oft Oc obe i c on orbef eDe m be 11 2009
t
he t r nvoies
or ce r ,
OneFourh oft Oc obe i ce o orbe or Dec m be 18,
t
he t r nvoi s n
f e
e r 2009
One Fourh oft Ocoberi ce on o be or De ember28,2009
t
he t
nvoi s
r f e c
(mpha i adde .l a r fom t f eg ngt tt pate ,byagee nt deer nedt t
e
ss d) t ppeas r he or oi ha hc ris
r me , t mi ha
Kist s d bela ef t s
s io houl
i bl or he umspr de
ovi d.
Bec us Kist wa notapa t t a oft Agr ment,t a bir t wa onl hal
a e s io s
ry o ny he ee
s he r ta or s y f
o r c t c udet tEKist i cea l bound by t t r soft Sete e Ag ee nta
ore t o oncl ha t s io s l ry
he e m
he tlm nt r me nd
t A g e m en s ' K i s t wasno bound by t A gr e e s See 2011 W L 1
he r e t .' s io
t
he
e m nt .
7071 0, * 3.
9 at 2-
Butsnc Kist wasclary boundby t Sete e , t a bir t ' a r dr die ty
i e s io
e l
he tlm nt and he r ta ors wa d ew r c l
fom ispr sons an e r i a ysswasi ma e i l a t a r s d bec ime
r t ovii , y ror n nal i
m t ra, nd he wa d houl
onfr d.
Il.
Fort f egoi r ons Iwilg a Pl i ifsm o i deny De enda s mo i a
he or ng eas , l r nt antf
ton,
f nt ' ton, nd
c i m t a bir t ' awar
onf r he r t a or s
d.
The Cl r oft Cour i diec ed t s nd a ce tfe cop oft s opi on t al co e of
e k he
ts r t o e
rii d y hi ni o l uns l
r
ecord.
E
nee ti279*a o Jl, 0 1
trd hs dy fuy 2 1.
>
AN K .M OO
NO
U NI
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D GE
CT U
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?