Hummel v. Hall
Filing
29
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on October 18, 2012. (sfc)
r mnts oFF1 u. .DIT.
;
c; s s COURT
A LN IE R V
T Y FI D G A
CO U
L
IN THE U NI
TED STATES DI
STRI C OURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I NI
CT
RGI A
LYNCHBURG Dl s ON
vI I
221 18 2 1
,2
JU
BY;
'
C.
DUD
u
CLERK
CLERK
CAS N0.6: 1 c 0001
E
1 - v2
MI
CHAEL J.HUMM EL,
Pli tf
a nf
M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
D AVI W . ALL,TA COUNT M OTOR SALES
D H
/
RY
Dee da t
f n n.
J
UDGE N ORM AN K . OON
M
Thi m a tr i bef e t Cour on Pl ntf M ihae J Humm els moton f a
s te s
or he
t
ai if c l .
'
i or
s e ntla r ofat ne sf s( ke no.28) Fort r s t tf l lwilgrnt
upplme a wad tor y' ee doc t
.
he ea ons ha olow, l a
Pl ntf ' m oton.
ai i f s i
1 PROCEDURAL H I TORY
.
S
On M ay 2,2011 Pli iffl ac
, a ntf ied ompl i ,a s tng ava it ofc am saga ns
ant s eri
re y l i
i t
Def nd tD a d H al,a1 ofw hi r l t d t Def nt ss l ofa ve cl t Pl ntf . A f e
e an vi
l l
ch e a e o enda ' a e
hi e o ai i f t r
f ii t a
a lng o ppea , ea orot w i e de e aga ns t a ton, ef nt s de a tw a e e e
r pl d,
her s f nd i t he c i D enda ' f ul s nt r d
by t Clr oft Cour on Augus 31 2011 A c rii d c oft Cl r se r ofde a t
he e k he
t
t ,
. e tfe opy he e k' nty
f ul
wasma ld t Def nda .Subs nty,on M a c 1 201 Pl ntf fl d am oton f de a t
ie o e nt
eque l
r h 3, 2, ai if ie
i or f ul
j d me ta dmaldac p t De e d n .De e d n d dn tr s ndt t moin a h dd
u g n n ie o y o fn a t fn a t i o e po o he to , nd e i
nota
ppea a t hea i 1conduc e on Pli ifsmoto on M a 24, 2. l amemor ndum
r t he rng
td
antf
in
y 201 n
a
o i o a do d rd tdJ n 1 201 1g a tdPlitf' moi nf rd f ut u g n a d,
pnin n r e ae u e 9, 2, r ne anifs to o e a lj d me t n
aongwihij tver i ,a r Pli ifda ge i t a
l
t n unci elef waded antf ma s n he mountof$ 1 44. OnJ y2,
2,06. 1
ul
1Thi t a damage fgtr r pr s nt t combi d s ofPl ntf r cove y unde t Tr t i Lendi Ac
s otl
s i ze e e e ed he
ne um
ai ifs e r
r he uh n
ng t
(Tl ', 5U.. j1 01e sq, ndVi ni u uylw.
t LA' 1 SC. 6 t e .a r a s r a
)
gi
201 Pl i iftl amoton f a a r ofc t a r s bl at ne sf , c l
2, antf ied
i or n wa d oss nd ea ona e tor y' ees whih
g a e on J y 1 201
r nt d
ul 8, 2.
On J y 20,201 1i s a or rconsr ng alte s ntt t Cour by De enda
ul
2, s ued n de
tui
e t r e o he
t
f nt
Da i Halnh s os c p ct a amo int s t sd d f ut u g n .Afe s b s in o
v d l i irr e a a i s to o e a i e ea lj d me t tr u miso f
y
bre sby bot sdes o Se e r6, 2, de e De e ntsmoton t s tasde de a t
if
h i , n pt mbe 201 I nid f nda '
i o e i
f ul
j
udgme .OnSe t r1 201 Pli iffl amotonf as e ntlawar of
nt
pembe 4, 2, antf ied
i or upplme a
d
at ey' f ess e ng a a r off esf t a tona tm es ntdef ng a i t
tom s e e ki n wa d e or he ddii l i pe
endi gans
De e d n ' mo int sta ied fulj g n .
fn a ts to o e sd ea t ud me t
I L EGAL STANDARD
L
Unde t s ca ld Am e i a r e t pari t ci lltgai or na iy be rt i o
r he o- le
rc n ul, he tes o vi ii ton di rl a her wn
at
tonwy' f es a coss unl s t r i e ii sa ut y a hort t t con r r Se
s e nd
t , es he e s xplct tt or ut iy o he
ta y. e
Bu k a n n#t a d Ca eHo , n .v l P De 'o a t a d Hu n Re . 5 2 U. 5 8
c h n o f n r me I c . I W. p t fHe lh n ma s, 3 S. 9 ,
(
6 2 ( 0 ) S h a e c p in i p o d d fri te Trzh i Le dig Ac (t LA' ,whih
0 2 01. uc n x e to s r vie o n h t n n n t 1
t
TI '
) c
saest tSn t c e ofa s es f a ton t e or e t f egoi la lt 't c e t i
t t ha i he as
i
ny ucc s ul c i o nf c he or ng ibiiy,' he r dior s
labl f d he c t oft a ton,t t rw ih a r as
i e or t os s he c i oge he t e onabl a t e s f e as de er i by t
t
e tom y' e
t m ned
he
c u t' 1 U. C.j 1 4 ()3 . S mial Vig naus r lw pemisa s c sf lplitf t
o r. 5 S.
'
6 0 a () i lry, r i i u y a r t uc e su an if o
r ove co tc t a r s na eal m e sfe .Se Va.
ec r ur oss nd ea o bl to y' e s e Codej6. 3
2- 05.
1 D l l oN
11. sclssl
Ha ng pr vaied on De e
vi
e l
f ndantsM oton t Se AsdeDef ul J
'
i o t i
a t udgment Pl ntf a g s
, ai if r ue
t thei e il t r ove r a ona ea t ne sf e f t a tona tme s ntopposng
ha
s ntted o ec r e s bl tor y' e s or he ddii l i pe
i
Def nda ' moton. A numbe ofdititc t ha m a s e e a awa dsofa t ne s
e nts i
r
src ours ve de upplm nt l r
tor y'
fe frav reyo tpe o po t u g n l i to S eOd iM u i Lt v Ka h r i LLC,
e s o ait f y s f s- d me t igain. e nl sc d. . t a ss
j
t
No. V 5 0 - 5 5 2 0 W L 1 3 3 ( D. lM a 1 2 08 (d p ig ama itaej d es
Cl - 5 0 4 , 0 8
9 0 01 E. Ca. y , 0 ) a o tn
gsrt u g '
r co me ton ofa s eme a a r ofa t ne sf e i ure i e f c i a e
e m nda i
uppl nt l wa d tor y' e s nc r d n f e tng m ndme of
nt
aj d me t n o ti n ij n tv r l g; le v Pi rm 'Prd Cop.No. :5 0 6
u g n a d b anig n u cie ei Milr . l i s ie r , 50 CV0 0 4,
e
g
2008W L 68
6761, * ( . Va. a .1 2008 ( a i as e nt awadofat ne s
at 3 W D. M r 2, ) grntng upplme al r tor y'
f e frdee s a an tar n we moinf r u me t samatroflw p ru n t Fe e a
e s o fn e g is e e d to o j dg n a
te a u s a t o d r l
Rueo Cii P o e u e5 (); mi v fJ O hc so i h lN Ka 7 2F. u p. 2(
l f v l r c d r 0b ) S t . w f e fM t el
h
c
y, 6 S p 8 D.
De.1 91 ( wa dn s p lme tlat r y' fe ic re d fndn a ans amo inf ran w
l 9 ) a r ig u pe n a tone s e s n u r d ee ig g i t to o e
til.I d e i c rancr u tn e ,t je i u rdb ap e al gpa t i a e f r t
ra) n e d,n e ti ic msa c s (fe s nc re y r v ii ry n n fo to
l
n
r o rr a ona e at ne sf sa et m s l sr c r bl i r as bl .' t 762 F.Supp.
ec ve e s bl tor y' ee r he e ve e ove a e f e ona e'Smih,
a 8 ; e as Ga e v Ga rs n 81 F.d6 0 6 2( t Ci. 9 7 .W h n h n ln
t 5 s e lo n y . r io , 3 2 5 , 5 4 h r 1 8 ) e a d ig
s pplm e a m oto f f e ,a t oul m a a r s pplm e a ator y' f esi t s
u e ntl i ns or e s d ' y wa d u e nt l t ne s e n he nme
c t
ma e a ia r e atr e sfe i tefrtnsa e' M i e , 0 8 W L 6 67 , t* (iig
nn r s t wad d to n y' e s n h s i tnc . l r 2 0
' l
8 61 a 1 ctn
Mc mb v M e r I c, 9 F.d3 6 3 - 2( t Ci. 0 :.
co s . je, n .3 5 3 4 , 61 6 6h r 20 5
Pl ntf wa t pr va lngpa t on hi unde l ng TI cai , c e il hi t
ai if s he e ii
ry
s
ryi
LA l m whih ntted m o
r c ve r as bl a t ne sf e pur uan t t s a u e. Pl ntf alo pr vaied i li
e ei e ona e tor y' e s s t o he t t t
ai if s e l n z s
o
ppostont De e
ii o f ndantsM o i n t Se AsdeDe a tJ m e . Asa r ul,lfnd t t
' to o t i
f ul udg nt
es t i ha
Pl i ifi entte t r as na e at ne sf e i ured i de endi agans De e
antf s ild o e o bl tor y' e s nc r n f ng i t f ndan ' posts t
j d me t to Th o l rmann ts i t c n ie t er a o a e e so t en t o
u g n moin. e ny e iig a k s o o sd r h e s n bln s f h momt f
f spli ifha r quese s1305 = d hi a c i f s h an a r
ee antf s e t d- , s c ountng or uc
wa d.
TheUnied St t sCour ofAppe sf t Fo t Cicui ha a e t l desa
t
ae
t
al or he urh r t s dopt d he o t r
m ehod ofdeer ni t r as bl nes ofat ne sf es Se Br zi v Run
t
t mi ng he e ona e s tor y' e . e od ak . yon,1 F.
45 3d
1 1 (t Ci.1998 .l t FourhCic tt l sa fg ei cac aedby muli yi
94, 96 4h r
) n he
t rui,he odetr iur s lult
tpl ng
t numberofr a ona ehour e nde by ar s na er t whih i de e mi i lghtof1
he
e s bl
s xpe d
ea o bl ae, c s t r ned n i
2
fco s E. O. v Sev.Ne Co. 898F. 958,965(t Ci.1 .I my e riropi on
a tr . E. C. . r ws ,
2d
4h r 990) n
ale ni
gr ntngPl i ifsorgi r ques f a t ne sf e ,1f nd t tar e of$290 pe hou wa a
a i antf ' i nal e t or tor y' e s ou ha at
r r s
r as bl a pr aii mar tr t f rPl ntf ' ator i Lync g,Vigi a Pl i if s
e ona e nd ev lng
ke ae o ai ifs t ney n
hbur
r ni . antf'
a t ne s
tor y ubmit d a a fda tsai t thes n tveho spr pa i f a r s ndi t
te n fi vi t tng ha
pe t i
ur e rng or nd e po ng o
De e
f ndantsm oton,r uli i at all t rfgur of$145 I a exe cie ofbilng
'
i es tng n ot odesa i e
, 0. n n r s
li
dic etgn,c ns r duc hi r que tby 1 t a countf a e es i trot rnons r i ou el e ed s e s
0% o c
or ny xc sve ) he
c
ompe a e a tvii ,t uli a ey as ng f a a d of$1350.
ns bl c i tes hus tm t l ki or n war
,
Iorgi l a r d Pl i ifa t ne sf esi t a oun of$9, 05 f t
i naly wa de antf tor y' e n he m t
786. or he
unde l ng TI cli . l my pr vi opi on, not d t tt f esa a de we ene ry fve
ryi
LA am n
e ous ni 1 e ha he e w r d r a l i
tmesgr a e t n t t ala ou ofda a sa r
i
e t r ha he ot m nt
m ge wa ded.I e pl ni why s h a a r wa
n x ai ng
uc n wa d s
r s bl ,ldr w a ana ogy t t c extofc tt tonalt tltgaton,whe e t Supr m e
ea ona e
e n l
o he ont
ons iu i
or ii i
r he
e
Co r çee te )t p o o i o ta fea r su d rj 1 8 s o dn c s aiyb
u té j cgd he r p st n h t e wa d n e 9 8 h ul e e s rl e
r
i
p o o t n t t t ea u t d ma e acvirg t p an ifa tal r c v r. Ci o
r p ri ae o h mo n of a g s i l ih s litf cu ly e o e s' t f
o
' y
Rie sdev Rier 477U. 561 574( 986) I c ume ce tca e ,a i ci lrght c es
v r i . v a,
S. ,
1 . n ons r rdi s s s n vi i s as ,
t l w mone a y val ofcl msc n ç s otr vi ouse or m e ofc ume pr t c i
he o
tr
ue
ai a t c tage gor
di
nf ce nt ons r o e ton
s a ut . Cr y v E.H al tr s s,P. . . , o.5: cv- O7,2007 W L 67
t t es ' o .
'
l f As oc . L L C. N
06- 001
6698, t*3
a
( . Va M a . , 0 7 .Tha ben s i , we e ,h S p e Co r d dr c g iei Ci o
W D. . r 2 2 0 ) t ig ad ho v rt e u rme u t i e o n z n t f
y
Rier i t tt hea ountofda
v sde ha s m
t
mage apl ntf r c r i c ti y r e ntt t a
s ai if e ove s s era nl elva o he mountof
a t ne sf st beawa de ' sE ofm a f c or t tac ts ul eonsde .' 477 U . a
tor y' ee o
r d'a t
one
ny a t s ha our ho d
i r'
S. t
I t sca e 1fnd t tt a ountoft pr vi usa r c
n hi s , i ha he m
he e o wa d ombi wih t dipa iy
ned t he s rt
bt e t a
e we n he mountofda
mage a t a omtofa tm e sf e a a de we ghsi f vorof
s nd he m t
to y' e s w r d i n a
r uci Pl i if s l t fgur , a dIfn ta ara o befefrtepo tj d me t
ed ng a ntf ' odesar i e n id h t e s na l e o h s-u g n
pr e di i $5 Unlket unde l ng c us ofaci , t l w r gar ng whet rt s t
oc e ngs s 00. i he
ryi a e
ton he a e di
he o e
a iead fulj d me ti ce ra sr ih fr r I a di o , n d tre tefc o ft r
sd ea t u g n s la nd tag towad. n d t n a y ee rn fe t n uu e
i
vi a i nsby t sD e enda orot r hasale dy bee a hi ved by t orgi la d off e .
ol to
hi f
nt
he s
ra
n c e
he i na war
es
Si ia l gi n t tc
m lry, ve ha ouns i t sc ehasar ad r c ve a s t nta a r off st t
el n hi as
le y e ei d ubsa i l wa d ee ha
mac e h so i ia rq e t g a tn tef lld sa a u t o t p t u g n wo kwo l
th d i rgn l e u s, r ni g h ul o e tr mo n f r he os- d me t r ud
j
ha ltl addii efe ton t wilngne sofat ne t t ke on s h ca e . The 1w doe
ve ite
tonal f c
he li s
tor ys o a
uc s s
a
s
p o iet a c u e s udr c i ra o a ec mp n ainf rh sp t u g n wo k a dl
r vd h t o ns l ho l e eve e s n bl o e s to o i os- d me t r , n
j
t r f r fnd t t$500 pr de r as bl c pe ai n wihoutbeng e es i .
he e o e i ha
ovi s e ona e om ns to t
i xc sve
I . ONCLUS ON
V C
I
For t f egoi r a ons Pl ntf s m oton f r a t y' f es a c t s l be
he or ng e s , ai i f
i o tonw s e
nd os s ha l
g a e An or rwilis a z ng Pli tf a t ne sf si t a oun of$500.
r ntd.
de l s ue wa di a n if tor y' ee n he m t
00.
The Clr oft Cour i her by dieced t s nd a c rii co oft sm e o a
ek
he
ts e
r t o e
e tfed py
hi m r ndum
opi on a t ac mpa ng or rt a1c
ni nd he co nyi
de o l ouns lofr cor a t De e nt
e
e d nd o f nda .
I i s O RD ERED .
ts o
E trdti 1 +- a o- tbr
nee hs î- d y t o e 2012.
oc
,
-
>
NO
AN K.M O
UN I
TED STATES D I TRI J
S CT UDO E
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?