Hummel v. Hall

Filing 29

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on October 18, 2012. (sfc)

r mnts oFF1 u. .DIT.
;
c; s s COURT

A LN IE R V
T Y FI D G A
CO U
L
IN THE U NI
TED STATES DI
STRI C OURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I NI
CT
RGI A
LYNCHBURG Dl s ON
vI I

221 18 2 1
,2
JU
BY;
'

C.
DUD
u

CLERK
CLERK

CAS N0.6: 1 c 0001
E
1 - v2

MI
CHAEL J.HUMM EL,

Pli tf
a nf
M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
D AVI W . ALL,TA COUNT M OTOR SALES
D H
/
RY

Dee da t
f n n.

J
UDGE N ORM AN K . OON
M

Thi m a tr i bef e t Cour on Pl ntf M ihae J Humm els moton f a
s te s
or he
t
ai if c l .
'
i or

s e ntla r ofat ne sf s( ke no.28) Fort r s t tf l lwilgrnt
upplme a wad tor y' ee doc t
.
he ea ons ha olow, l a
Pl ntf ' m oton.
ai i f s i
1 PROCEDURAL H I TORY
.
S

On M ay 2,2011 Pli iffl ac
, a ntf ied ompl i ,a s tng ava it ofc am saga ns
ant s eri
re y l i
i t
Def nd tD a d H al,a1 ofw hi r l t d t Def nt ss l ofa ve cl t Pl ntf . A f e
e an vi
l l
ch e a e o enda ' a e
hi e o ai i f t r
f ii t a
a lng o ppea , ea orot w i e de e aga ns t a ton, ef nt s de a tw a e e e
r pl d,
her s f nd i t he c i D enda ' f ul s nt r d

by t Clr oft Cour on Augus 31 2011 A c rii d c oft Cl r se r ofde a t
he e k he
t
t ,
. e tfe opy he e k' nty
f ul
wasma ld t Def nda .Subs nty,on M a c 1 201 Pl ntf fl d am oton f de a t
ie o e nt
eque l
r h 3, 2, ai if ie
i or f ul

j d me ta dmaldac p t De e d n .De e d n d dn tr s ndt t moin a h dd
u g n n ie o y o fn a t fn a t i o e po o he to , nd e i
nota
ppea a t hea i 1conduc e on Pli ifsmoto on M a 24, 2. l amemor ndum
r t he rng
td
antf
in
y 201 n
a

o i o a do d rd tdJ n 1 201 1g a tdPlitf' moi nf rd f ut u g n a d,
pnin n r e ae u e 9, 2, r ne anifs to o e a lj d me t n
aongwihij tver i ,a r Pli ifda ge i t a
l
t n unci elef waded antf ma s n he mountof$ 1 44. OnJ y2,
2,06. 1
ul

1Thi t a damage fgtr r pr s nt t combi d s ofPl ntf r cove y unde t Tr t i Lendi Ac
s otl
s i ze e e e ed he
ne um
ai ifs e r
r he uh n
ng t

(Tl ', 5U.. j1 01e sq, ndVi ni u uylw.
t LA' 1 SC. 6 t e .a r a s r a
)
gi

201 Pl i iftl amoton f a a r ofc t a r s bl at ne sf , c l
2, antf ied
i or n wa d oss nd ea ona e tor y' ees whih
g a e on J y 1 201
r nt d
ul 8, 2.

On J y 20,201 1i s a or rconsr ng alte s ntt t Cour by De enda
ul
2, s ued n de
tui
e t r e o he
t
f nt

Da i Halnh s os c p ct a amo int s t sd d f ut u g n .Afe s b s in o
v d l i irr e a a i s to o e a i e ea lj d me t tr u miso f
y
bre sby bot sdes o Se e r6, 2, de e De e ntsmoton t s tasde de a t
if
h i , n pt mbe 201 I nid f nda '
i o e i
f ul

j
udgme .OnSe t r1 201 Pli iffl amotonf as e ntlawar of
nt
pembe 4, 2, antf ied
i or upplme a
d
at ey' f ess e ng a a r off esf t a tona tm es ntdef ng a i t
tom s e e ki n wa d e or he ddii l i pe
endi gans

De e d n ' mo int sta ied fulj g n .
fn a ts to o e sd ea t ud me t
I L EGAL STANDARD
L

Unde t s ca ld Am e i a r e t pari t ci lltgai or na iy be rt i o
r he o- le
rc n ul, he tes o vi ii ton di rl a her wn
at
tonwy' f es a coss unl s t r i e ii sa ut y a hort t t con r r Se
s e nd
t , es he e s xplct tt or ut iy o he
ta y. e

Bu k a n n#t a d Ca eHo , n .v l P De 'o a t a d Hu n Re . 5 2 U. 5 8
c h n o f n r me I c . I W. p t fHe lh n ma s, 3 S. 9 ,
(
6 2 ( 0 ) S h a e c p in i p o d d fri te Trzh i Le dig Ac (t LA' ,whih
0 2 01. uc n x e to s r vie o n h t n n n t 1
t
TI '
) c
saest tSn t c e ofa s es f a ton t e or e t f egoi la lt 't c e t i
t t ha i he as
i
ny ucc s ul c i o nf c he or ng ibiiy,' he r dior s
labl f d he c t oft a ton,t t rw ih a r as
i e or t os s he c i oge he t e onabl a t e s f e as de er i by t
t
e tom y' e
t m ned
he

c u t' 1 U. C.j 1 4 ()3 . S mial Vig naus r lw pemisa s c sf lplitf t
o r. 5 S.
'
6 0 a () i lry, r i i u y a r t uc e su an if o
r ove co tc t a r s na eal m e sfe .Se Va.
ec r ur oss nd ea o bl to y' e s e Codej6. 3
2- 05.
1 D l l oN
11. sclssl

Ha ng pr vaied on De e
vi
e l
f ndantsM oton t Se AsdeDef ul J
'
i o t i
a t udgment Pl ntf a g s
, ai if r ue
t thei e il t r ove r a ona ea t ne sf e f t a tona tme s ntopposng
ha
s ntted o ec r e s bl tor y' e s or he ddii l i pe
i
Def nda ' moton. A numbe ofdititc t ha m a s e e a awa dsofa t ne s
e nts i
r
src ours ve de upplm nt l r
tor y'

fe frav reyo tpe o po t u g n l i to S eOd iM u i Lt v Ka h r i LLC,
e s o ait f y s f s- d me t igain. e nl sc d. . t a ss
j
t
No. V 5 0 - 5 5 2 0 W L 1 3 3 ( D. lM a 1 2 08 (d p ig ama itaej d es
Cl - 5 0 4 , 0 8
9 0 01 E. Ca. y , 0 ) a o tn
gsrt u g '

r co me ton ofa s eme a a r ofa t ne sf e i ure i e f c i a e
e m nda i
uppl nt l wa d tor y' e s nc r d n f e tng m ndme of
nt

aj d me t n o ti n ij n tv r l g; le v Pi rm 'Prd Cop.No. :5 0 6
u g n a d b anig n u cie ei Milr . l i s ie r , 50 CV0 0 4,
e
g
2008W L 68
6761, * ( . Va. a .1 2008 ( a i as e nt awadofat ne s
at 3 W D. M r 2, ) grntng upplme al r tor y'

f e frdee s a an tar n we moinf r u me t samatroflw p ru n t Fe e a
e s o fn e g is e e d to o j dg n a
te a u s a t o d r l

Rueo Cii P o e u e5 (); mi v fJ O hc so i h lN Ka 7 2F. u p. 2(
l f v l r c d r 0b ) S t . w f e fM t el
h
c
y, 6 S p 8 D.
De.1 91 ( wa dn s p lme tlat r y' fe ic re d fndn a ans amo inf ran w
l 9 ) a r ig u pe n a tone s e s n u r d ee ig g i t to o e
til.I d e i c rancr u tn e ,t je i u rdb ap e al gpa t i a e f r t
ra) n e d,n e ti ic msa c s (fe s nc re y r v ii ry n n fo to
l
n
r o rr a ona e at ne sf sa et m s l sr c r bl i r as bl .' t 762 F.Supp.
ec ve e s bl tor y' ee r he e ve e ove a e f e ona e'Smih,

a 8 ; e as Ga e v Ga rs n 81 F.d6 0 6 2( t Ci. 9 7 .W h n h n ln
t 5 s e lo n y . r io , 3 2 5 , 5 4 h r 1 8 ) e a d ig
s pplm e a m oto f f e ,a t oul m a a r s pplm e a ator y' f esi t s
u e ntl i ns or e s d ' y wa d u e nt l t ne s e n he nme
c t

ma e a ia r e atr e sfe i tefrtnsa e' M i e , 0 8 W L 6 67 , t* (iig
nn r s t wad d to n y' e s n h s i tnc . l r 2 0
' l
8 61 a 1 ctn
Mc mb v M e r I c, 9 F.d3 6 3 - 2( t Ci. 0 :.
co s . je, n .3 5 3 4 , 61 6 6h r 20 5
Pl ntf wa t pr va lngpa t on hi unde l ng TI cai , c e il hi t
ai if s he e ii
ry
s
ryi
LA l m whih ntted m o
r c ve r as bl a t ne sf e pur uan t t s a u e. Pl ntf alo pr vaied i li
e ei e ona e tor y' e s s t o he t t t
ai if s e l n z s

o
ppostont De e
ii o f ndantsM o i n t Se AsdeDe a tJ m e . Asa r ul,lfnd t t
' to o t i
f ul udg nt
es t i ha
Pl i ifi entte t r as na e at ne sf e i ured i de endi agans De e
antf s ild o e o bl tor y' e s nc r n f ng i t f ndan ' posts t

j d me t to Th o l rmann ts i t c n ie t er a o a e e so t en t o
u g n moin. e ny e iig a k s o o sd r h e s n bln s f h momt f
f spli ifha r quese s1305 = d hi a c i f s h an a r
ee antf s e t d- , s c ountng or uc
wa d.
TheUnied St t sCour ofAppe sf t Fo t Cicui ha a e t l desa
t
ae
t
al or he urh r t s dopt d he o t r
m ehod ofdeer ni t r as bl nes ofat ne sf es Se Br zi v Run
t
t mi ng he e ona e s tor y' e . e od ak . yon,1 F.
45 3d

1 1 (t Ci.1998 .l t FourhCic tt l sa fg ei cac aedby muli yi
94, 96 4h r
) n he
t rui,he odetr iur s lult
tpl ng
t numberofr a ona ehour e nde by ar s na er t whih i de e mi i lghtof1
he
e s bl
s xpe d
ea o bl ae, c s t r ned n i
2

fco s E. O. v Sev.Ne Co. 898F. 958,965(t Ci.1 .I my e riropi on
a tr . E. C. . r ws ,
2d
4h r 990) n
ale ni

gr ntngPl i ifsorgi r ques f a t ne sf e ,1f nd t tar e of$290 pe hou wa a
a i antf ' i nal e t or tor y' e s ou ha at
r r s
r as bl a pr aii mar tr t f rPl ntf ' ator i Lync g,Vigi a Pl i if s
e ona e nd ev lng
ke ae o ai ifs t ney n
hbur
r ni . antf'
a t ne s
tor y ubmit d a a fda tsai t thes n tveho spr pa i f a r s ndi t
te n fi vi t tng ha
pe t i
ur e rng or nd e po ng o

De e
f ndantsm oton,r uli i at all t rfgur of$145 I a exe cie ofbilng
'
i es tng n ot odesa i e
, 0. n n r s
li
dic etgn,c ns r duc hi r que tby 1 t a countf a e es i trot rnons r i ou el e ed s e s
0% o c
or ny xc sve ) he

c
ompe a e a tvii ,t uli a ey as ng f a a d of$1350.
ns bl c i tes hus tm t l ki or n war
,
Iorgi l a r d Pl i ifa t ne sf esi t a oun of$9, 05 f t
i naly wa de antf tor y' e n he m t
786. or he
unde l ng TI cli . l my pr vi opi on, not d t tt f esa a de we ene ry fve
ryi
LA am n
e ous ni 1 e ha he e w r d r a l i
tmesgr a e t n t t ala ou ofda a sa r
i
e t r ha he ot m nt
m ge wa ded.I e pl ni why s h a a r wa
n x ai ng
uc n wa d s
r s bl ,ldr w a ana ogy t t c extofc tt tonalt tltgaton,whe e t Supr m e
ea ona e
e n l
o he ont
ons iu i
or ii i
r he
e

Co r çee te )t p o o i o ta fea r su d rj 1 8 s o dn c s aiyb
u té j cgd he r p st n h t e wa d n e 9 8 h ul e e s rl e
r
i

p o o t n t t t ea u t d ma e acvirg t p an ifa tal r c v r. Ci o
r p ri ae o h mo n of a g s i l ih s litf cu ly e o e s' t f
o
' y
Rie sdev Rier 477U. 561 574( 986) I c ume ce tca e ,a i ci lrght c es
v r i . v a,
S. ,
1 . n ons r rdi s s s n vi i s as ,
t l w mone a y val ofcl msc n ç s otr vi ouse or m e ofc ume pr t c i
he o
tr
ue
ai a t c tage gor
di
nf ce nt ons r o e ton
s a ut . Cr y v E.H al tr s s,P. . . , o.5: cv- O7,2007 W L 67
t t es ' o .
'
l f As oc . L L C. N
06- 001
6698, t*3
a

( . Va M a . , 0 7 .Tha ben s i , we e ,h S p e Co r d dr c g iei Ci o
W D. . r 2 2 0 ) t ig ad ho v rt e u rme u t i e o n z n t f
y
Rier i t tt hea ountofda
v sde ha s m
t
mage apl ntf r c r i c ti y r e ntt t a
s ai if e ove s s era nl elva o he mountof
a t ne sf st beawa de ' sE ofm a f c or t tac ts ul eonsde .' 477 U . a
tor y' ee o
r d'a t
one
ny a t s ha our ho d
i r'
S. t

I t sca e 1fnd t tt a ountoft pr vi usa r c
n hi s , i ha he m
he e o wa d ombi wih t dipa iy
ned t he s rt
bt e t a
e we n he mountofda
mage a t a omtofa tm e sf e a a de we ghsi f vorof
s nd he m t
to y' e s w r d i n a
r uci Pl i if s l t fgur , a dIfn ta ara o befefrtepo tj d me t
ed ng a ntf ' odesar i e n id h t e s na l e o h s-u g n

pr e di i $5 Unlket unde l ng c us ofaci , t l w r gar ng whet rt s t
oc e ngs s 00. i he
ryi a e
ton he a e di
he o e

a iead fulj d me ti ce ra sr ih fr r I a di o , n d tre tefc o ft r
sd ea t u g n s la nd tag towad. n d t n a y ee rn fe t n uu e
i
vi a i nsby t sD e enda orot r hasale dy bee a hi ved by t orgi la d off e .
ol to
hi f
nt
he s
ra
n c e
he i na war
es

Si ia l gi n t tc
m lry, ve ha ouns i t sc ehasar ad r c ve a s t nta a r off st t
el n hi as
le y e ei d ubsa i l wa d ee ha

mac e h so i ia rq e t g a tn tef lld sa a u t o t p t u g n wo kwo l
th d i rgn l e u s, r ni g h ul o e tr mo n f r he os- d me t r ud
j
ha ltl addii efe ton t wilngne sofat ne t t ke on s h ca e . The 1w doe
ve ite
tonal f c
he li s
tor ys o a
uc s s
a
s

p o iet a c u e s udr c i ra o a ec mp n ainf rh sp t u g n wo k a dl
r vd h t o ns l ho l e eve e s n bl o e s to o i os- d me t r , n
j
t r f r fnd t t$500 pr de r as bl c pe ai n wihoutbeng e es i .
he e o e i ha
ovi s e ona e om ns to t
i xc sve
I . ONCLUS ON
V C
I
For t f egoi r a ons Pl ntf s m oton f r a t y' f es a c t s l be
he or ng e s , ai i f
i o tonw s e
nd os s ha l

g a e An or rwilis a z ng Pli tf a t ne sf si t a oun of$500.
r ntd.
de l s ue wa di a n if tor y' ee n he m t
00.
The Clr oft Cour i her by dieced t s nd a c rii co oft sm e o a
ek
he
ts e
r t o e
e tfed py
hi m r ndum
opi on a t ac mpa ng or rt a1c
ni nd he co nyi
de o l ouns lofr cor a t De e nt
e
e d nd o f nda .
I i s O RD ERED .
ts o

E trdti 1 +- a o- tbr
nee hs î- d y t o e 2012.
oc
,

-

>

NO
AN K.M O
UN I
TED STATES D I TRI J
S CT UDO E