Santova Logistics, Ltd. v. Castello 1935 Inc.

Filing 16

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on June 19, 2012. (sfc)

ov . , oy,ceo. si e,uer
rt.s ,j . .y
-

I THE UNI STATESDI TRI COURT ' A YFH U e0v x. '
N
TED
S CT
k TkN IB V '& ..
w
CLED

FoR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I NI
CT
RGI A

LY UR Dl so
NCHB G vllx

JUN 1! 2 2
01
1

s;
)

.

.

j.-.s ac q
' j .
; )
- .,
x

Dfpt'
c pi

. Rx

N o. 1 - v-00007
6: 2

SANTOVA LOGI CS,LTD.
STI
,

Pli t
a n?
M EMORANDUM OPI ON
NI

JUDGE N ORM AN K .M OON

CAS
TELL 1935, NC.
O
I ,
d/ / CAS
b a TELLO GROUP,

Dee d n .
fn a t

Sa t v Lo itc ,Lt (1a t v ' o i an if',a S u h Afia feg tfr r i gl
no a gsis d. û n o a' r d itf ) o t rc n r ih -o wad n
S
pl
co ny,alge t tCasel 1 I (fasel 'ori e
mpa le s ha tlo 935, nc. s tlo' û ndant),a i t a s lrof
Def
' n mporer nd ele
lne he dqua t r d Lexi on,V igi a i la e t Sa ova pur ua t Ca t l s f l e t
i ns a
re e
ngt
r ni , s i bl o nt
s nt o s elo' aiur o

pa f isr c p ofc ran i em a i ly-hi d hot lbed lne . Pli if a s rs t tt s
y or t e eit
e ti nt tona l s ppe
e
i ns antf s e t ha hi

s i i prpel wi n t Co r' a miat j rs ito pzs a t t 2 U. C.j 1 3 ( )
u t s o ry t he u t d rly u idcin l u n o 8 S.
hi
s
r
3 3 1.
De e ntmoves t dim is ar ng t tt s m a tr i a nm - -he- il l ba e c r t
f nda
o s s , gui ha hi te s
oft m l, and- s d ontac

ds ue ta d e n tfl wihn te a miat j rs ito o t e Co r. ( o ke n 4 . Th
ip t h t o s o al t i h d r l u idcin f h u t d c t o. ) e
y
pa te have r ques e a de s on on t s i s ons s 1 di pe e w ih or a gum e . l fnd
ri s
e
td
ci i
he ubm s i , o
s ns t al r
nt
i

t a t i matrfls wihn t e Co r' q a ic nr c a miat j rs ito ,a d lwi d n
h t hs t al ti h u ts u s-o ta t d r l u id ci n n
e
y
l ey
l
D ef
endant' M oton.
s
i

'ûEs e i l , afei f r r ras it as ppe i boo ng a pr rngca go f s pment
ç s ntaly r ght o wa de sss hi r n ki nd epa i
r or hi
.'
C
' Co thè
ns
o tie l e, n . . wa dI d s, n .3 9F.d9 l 9 1(t Ci. 0 2 .
nan ri s I c v Ho r n u .Ic, 0 3 0 , l 6h r2 0 )
n

1.BACKGROUND

Pli if a lges t t i ea l 2009, De e nt c r de wih a no pat Chi e
antf le
ha , n ry
f nda onta d t
n- ry
nes

c ny,Cha ho Hua ErRuiI tr tona Trde Co.Lt (i ngz ' a agee t
ompa
ngz u
nenai l a
, d. tcha hou' nd r d o
)
purha e$26,985. 2w ort ofbed lne . Compl ! 6;s eEx.1. Pl ntf s r d asafei t
c s
h
i ns
.
e
ai if eve
r gh
50
f wa de , nd ara
or r r a
r nged f t ta pora i oft lne fom Sha
or he r ns tton he i ns r
nghait LosAng esa r
o
el boa d

teMN LI
h
HUE.Co l! 7 s eEx. Aslo e v i P r 11 S no ae g g d sv r lohe
mp . ; e
2.
bsr e n a t 1, a tv n a e e e a t r
e ii durng t c s of isfei f wa di dutes s h t Sa ova di notphyscal
nttes i he our e t r ght or r ng i , uc hat nt
d
i ly
s p t ca go is f The lne we e de i r a e
hi he r tel.
i ns r lve ed s xpeced i LosAngel ,a we epi d up
t n
es nd r cke
es on he
i Ma o 2 0 Co . 8 Pl ntf cl ms t tCaselo t poss si oft goodsupon
n y f 0 9. mpl! . ai if ai ha t l ook

t rarval3 Compl !9.
hei ri .
.

Des t de i rng t lnens Cha hou e d ty wasnotpa d f t
pie lve i he i , ngz
vi en l
i or hem,a i fl d s t
nd t ie ui
i t Chi s M a ii Cour a ns Sa o s d caed Chi e age ,Pa e l e nai l
n he ne e rtme
t gai t nt va' edi t
nes
nt t nt nt r tona

Lo itc ( h n ha) Co. Lt (i tn ). Co .! 1 -1 The Chne e M aii Co r
gsis S a g i , d. d e f
pa
mpl 2 3.
is
rtme u t
a r e j d me t t Ch ng h u a d te d cso wa afr d b Sh n h is S p e
wad d u g n o a z o , n h e iin s fime y a g a ' u rme
P o esCo r. Co l ! 1 ;s eEx. a 6 ( eS n h iS p e Pe pe sCo r e plie
e pl' u t mp . 3 e
3 t Th ha g a u r me o l' u t x an d

t tth c rir)h d b o e ispr mie o d lv r wih te bilofldng a d voae is
ha s e a re g a r k n t o s s f ei ey t h l a i n iltd t
t
oblga i of pr r y and c e uly t ki g
i ton
ope l
ar f l a ng ood c r of t goods I i la e t com pe a e
ae
he
. t s i bl o
ns t

( a g h uqf ri ls a dd ma e'
Ch n z o o t o s n a g .
s
).

2PanifsCo litiiil d srb sac nrc wot $ 698 .0 s eCo . !6 1 , u i g e o
litf
mpan ntal ecie o tat rh 2 , 5: , e mpl! , 0 b tt o s n
y
t a lg t a Ch n z u s u h t r c v r$ 6 9 510 i t e Chne e lws t a d Pli ifu e t e $ 6 9 51
o l e h t a g ho o g t o e o e 2 , 8 . n h i s a ui n antf s s h 2 , 8 .0
e
,
n mb rt r u h u t e d r to o t e Co an ,s e 1 l ,l , 1 2 2 - 7,3 . la s me t a t t it c n
u e h o g o t h u ai n f h mplit e 5 2 6 2 , 2, 4 2 0 su h t he h ry e t
dic e y i t r s tofa t r phi leror butIp oce d he en usi t l s ra ount snc t ti w ha
sr panc s he e ul
ypog a ca r ,
r e r i ng he es e m
, i e ha s t
Pl ntf r quessi ispr rf rr i .
ai if e t n t aye o elef

3Dee d n sae ta i a tal di n ttk (n c ul n th v tk n po ssin oftel n ,sn e
fn a t tts h t t cu l d o a e a d o d o a e a e ) seso
y
h i s ic
ne
Ca t l di note n exitasa l e iy i 2009,i t d,a or ng t Defnda ,t buye i 2009w a t sr
selo d
ve
s
egal ntt n
.nsea cc di o e nt he
rn
s t to
ca
Gr ' Def' Br 1n..D e e nta e l i e t r s t sdefns a a lt tm e.Seei
oupa
' .s . 1 f nda pparnty ntnds o aie hi e e t aer i
d

2

Purua t Pr son 1 1 of t a
s nt o ovii
0.
he genc a e m e be we n Sa ova a d Pa e ,
y gr e nt t e
nt 4 n
t nt

Sanovawa r ponsbl f rs tsyi t Chi s j
t
s es i e o aif ng he nee udgme a ns Patnt isage .Compl !
nt gai t e ,t nt
.

1 -1 ,s e Ex 4. Ac o digy,S n o apad t e $ 6,8 .0j d me t Co l ! 1 l te
4 5 e .
.
c r n l a t v i h 2 9 55 u g n . mp . 6. n h
isa Co ant Sa tvacamst tisl bit wa c u e b t e û n a 'la u j tfe
n tnt mpli , n o li ha t i ly s a s d y h s lwf nd nusiid
a i
u
u
acinsofCasel i no pa ngf t (i ns i r eve 'a Sa ovat ase t cai f
to
tlo n t yi or he lne l t ec i d,' nd nt hus srs l ms or

i id o e utb e id mnt ( u tOn ) u j te rc me ( n Two ,a d b e c o
mpl r q ia l n e iy Co n e, nus n ih nt Cou t ) n r a h f
e
c rctast equiabl s ogeeofCha
onta
he t e ubr
ngzhou( untThre) Compl! 1 -30.
Co
e .
. 7
II.A PPLI
CABLE LAw

m zni c me t amot n frd s sa f rlc o s be t te j rs it nu d rRu e
e t o so
i o imis l o a k f u j c matr u idci n e l
o
o
1 b)1 oft Fe r RulsofCi lPr edur,
2( () he deal e
vi oc e
(l r aet c iial difrntwa i whih t pr s ntamoi t dimis
thee r wo rtc ly fee
ys n c o e e
ton o s s
. . . .

Fis,i m a be c ende t ta c
rt t y
ont d ha ompl i smpl f ist a lge f t upo
ant i y al o le ac s n

whih s b e tmatr l idcinc nbeb s d l t a e e t al h fcsalg d
c u j c te jz s ito a
r
ae . n h t v n, lte at l e
e
i t c
n he ompli ta e a s e t be tueand t pl i if i efe t i afo ded t
a n r s um d o r
he antf, n f c , s f r
he

s me p o e u a p o e to a h wo l rc ie t e a Rue 1 ( )6
a
r c d r l r tcin s e ud e ev md r
l 2b()
c nsd rto . Se o d,i ma b c n e d d ta tejlid cin lalg to so
o ie ai n c n t y e o tn e h t h t s ito a le ain f
r
t co pl ntwer nott te A t i cou tm a t n go be nd t a l ga i ns of
he m ai
e
rz . ral r y he
yo he le t o
t c pl i and i a e den i r he r ng de e m i i t r a e f c s t s
he om a nt
n n vi ta y a i
t r ne f he e r a t o uppo t
r

t j iditonalal to .
he urs ci
legains
Adams v Bai 691 F. 1 3,1 9 ( h Ci.1 . The M oi subjudi i oft frt
. n,
2d 21 21 4t r 982)
ton
ce s he is

v rey, sDee d ntsmpy a g e ta a miat j rs ito i i o ru d rt eg v r ig
a it a fn a i l z u s h t d r l uidc in s mprpe n e h o enn
y
saut,gi n t fcsalege I s h a i tnc ,tll movi pat s ul prvai onl i
tt e ve he a t l d. n uc n nsa e dthe
ng ry ho d e l y f

t emaeil u idcina fcsaen ti ds u ea t mo n pa t i e t ldt p e i a a
h tra j rs ito l a t r o n ip t nd he vig ry s ni e o rval s
t
m a trofl w.'Ri
te a ' chmon4 Fr rc s r ( Pot
ede ik bu g f omac R. v Unied St e 945 F. 765 768
R. . t ats,
2d ,
4 I t r f rnc age y a e m ent Sa ova i i ntfe a çspecrum Shi ng,LLC,'whih was
n he e ee ed nc gr e
nt
s de iid s ç t
ppi
'
c
,
Sa ova' na ebeor ac o aena e c ngeocc r d i 2007. Com pl 3n.
nt s m
f e om r t m ha
ure n
. 2.

( t Ci.1 91 (iig T e t o t v Fr n irPa .Aic a tI du . 8 3 F.d l 5 ,1 5 (t
4h r 9 ) ctn r nac sa . o te c r rj n s, 1 2 5 3 5 8 9h
Ci.1
r 987:.
1 1 D I CUS I
1 . S S ON

The gove ni J idi tona saut pr vi t tt ç src c t s l ha orgi l
r ng ' s ci l tt e o des ha he s tit ours hal ve i na
ur
di

ju s ito ...o gj y cv lc s o a miat o ma imeJ rs ito ...
tidcin
f an ii a e f d r l r rt ' id ci n
y
i u

28 U..
SC.

j 1 (1.Ast Su e Cour oft Unie St esha ex ane f adititco tt ha
333 )
he pr me
t he td at s pli d, or src ur o ve

p o e s be tmatrj rs ito o e a c nr cu lds u e u e j 1 3 ( ) t e c nrc a
r p r u j c te u id ci n v r o ta ta ip t nd r 3 3 1, h o ta t t

is emus b aS rtme' n .S e cg.Nof l S R
su
t e l ii 'o e e , . , ro k . y.Co v Kib 5 U. 1 23( 0 4 .
ma
. . r y, 43 S. 4, 2 0 )
Andt mlrtmej rs ito wh n f u d d u o c nr c d p nd u o t enau e a d s b e t
t aii u idcin e o n e p n o ta t e e s p n h tr n u j c
g
matro t c tac. Sande lnv Ol Domi onStv dorng Cor ,385 F. 79,81( hCi.
te f he onr t'
'
ri . d
ni e e i
p.
2d
4t r
1 ( tngN Pac S. Co.v.Hal Br .MarneRy.drShi l n Co. 249 U. 11 1
967) cii
. S.
l os
i
pbuidig ,
S. 9, 25
( 91 ) Whie no cea lne hasbe n drwn bewe ma ii and non- rtme c rcs
1 9).
l
lri
e a
t en rtme
maii onta t,

Ko sc v Un td Fr i Co , 5U. 7 , 3 ( 9 ) a b to çhetu c i ro i wh t r
sik . ie ut . 36 S. 31 7 5 1 61, t o tm, t r e rt in s ehe
t
e
(hec r t hasrfr et ma ii s r i o maii ta a tons' Kib 543U. a 2
t ontacl eeenc o rtme e vce r rtme r ns ci . ry,
'
S. t 4
(iainsa i enalquottonmakso te .
ctto nd ntr
ai
r mitd)
Se r di f r nt c r c s c e i o bei durng t c s of t tne s pm e i
ve al f e e ont a t am nt
ng i he our e
he i ns hi nt n

2009. Thr s h c r c sa e r f r nc i Pl i ifsCompl nt The tr tc r c i t one
ee uc onta t r e e e ed n antf
ai .
is onta t s he
be we n Ca t l a Cha hou, c e tbls d t plr hasng a ee ta s taprc f
t e selo nd
ngz
whi h sa ihe he zc i gr men nd e
i e or

t lne . Se Co .Ex.1(onfr t y i c )
he i ns e mpl
c imaor nvoie .Thes c tc r c'i abilo ldi
e ond çonta t' s l f a ng
t t lss tEtr sa Fr ght Se vie I ' on is hea r lss t s ppe a (Als r c , a
ha it d la i ei
r c ne.
'
t
de , it he hi r s t le vies' nd
'
i ca e t tt goods a e cons gne t tCCB l er tonalCusom s Br r' See Com pl Ex.
ndi t s ha he
r
i d ot
nt na i
t
oke . '
.

2. Th tidc nrc i a Ag n y Ag e me tb t e S no a (o me l Sp cr m S p n
5 e h r o ta t s n e c r e n ewe n a t v fr ry e tu hipig
Lt )a dPae t p r o whc f r dt eba i o S n o aha i t p y t Ch n s j d me t
d. n tn , a t f ih o me h ss f a t v vng o a he i e e u g n
onbe l ofPaen . Compl Ex.
haf
t t See
. 4.

Th frtc nr c (hea r e n o s l)i n tama i mec n r c;i me ey rp e e t
e ss o ta t t g e me t f ae s o
rt o ta t t r l e r sn s
i
a a e ntbet en abuyera as le ,a i i ve no s ii aly m a ii eas ct. The
n gr eme
we
nd e lr nd t nvol s
pectc l rtm
pe s

tid c nrc (h a e y a re n) i as no a maii o . Se Piri T r n l
hr o ta t te g nc g e me t s lo t
rtme ne
e esde e mia
Opeat s I .v M/ Fl i an,423 F.Sup 96 969 (ii Bl kSeaSt eS. Li v
r or, nc . V ordi
p. 2, -70 ctng ac
at S. ne .

As ' o 1 t1Tr d Dit 1 I c,95F.u p.1 0 ( D. Y.95 ) (t c nr c o id mni ,
sn f n ' a e s. , n .
s p 8 S. N. 1 1) $ o ta t f n e t
A
y
eve whe e i bef de a ti t pe f ma e ofa ma ii e s r c i note s ntaly ma ii
n
r t or f ul n he ror nc
rtm e vie, s
s e i l rtme

i c rce snc i c mo ,bydetnii çeaet as p i isus ass h.') Bu be a eis
n haa tr i e t al t
i ton, r lt o hi n t e uc ''. t c us t

t rmay o j cie i t a c mpih te ta s o tto o g o sb sa'fo S a ha t Lo
d i r be tv s o c o ls h rn p rain f o d y e ' r m h ng i o s
p
Angels t s c c rctme i d a
e ,he e ond onta
ntone bove(hebilofldi i ama ii co rct Kib
t l a ng) s
rtme nta . ry,
543 U. 24. The ot bil ofl ng a e alo ma ii e c r c s a Pl ntf cai t be a
S.
her ls adi r s
rtm onta t , nd ai if l ms o
pa t t a l a tone s h c r t l i tue t tnone oft bil ofl ng r pr e a c r c
ry o t e s
uc ontac . t s r ha
he ls adi e es nt onta t

b t e ti Plit a d ti De n a t s ltusc n o fn t a a y o t ebi so ldng
e we n hs an ? n hs # d n , o h a n t id h t n f h l f a i ,
l
sa dn ao e g v s rs t t i Co r' a miat j rs ito Un ie mo tc s si whc
tn ig ln , i e ie o h s u ts d r ly u idcin. lk
s a e n ih

5 Ac or ng t Pli if Exhi t2 contr t f tt tPl ntf ar nge f t ta po tton oft
c di o antf,
bi
ims he ac ha ai if ra d or he rns rai
he

l e sfo S a g i oLo An ee .S eCo . 7 Ha n is etdt bi o ldn h we e, cn o tn
i n rm h n ha t s g ls e mpl! . vig n p ce he l f a ig, o v r l a n ti d
n
l

t ti co i s h a ar ngem e . l t d,asImen i
ha t nfnus uc n ra
nt nsea
toned a
bove i lss ç a a Fr ghtSe vie I ' on is
, t it é si ei
Eur
r c nc.' t
hea r i lss t le vies'a t s ppe ;i de c i t s pme bei consgne t CCCB l t r tona
de ; t it ç s r c ' s he hi r t s rbes he hi nt ng
Al
i d o K
n enai l

CutmsBrk r'a dii sa da t b to b Fa Ch n ltr ain lTrns rainSevc Co, t .tsn
so
o e'; n ts tmpe the o tm y n e g nen to a a po tto r ie .L d (t'
la
Ch n '.No eo t s e tte,o c u s, r p rist teisa t ui Th o yme to ted cl n ma e o
e g' n fhee niis f o re ae at o h ntn s t e nl nin h o t t k s f
)
e
.
me
eihe pa t t t sc ei t selo'bei lsedi t box i c i t ar a N um be s'
t r ry o hi as s t t l ' ng it n he
ca
ndiatng t ks nd
M
r .'
Pli ifsExhi t3 s dss m elghto t s ppi a rnge e t Exhi t3,quoed onpage2,s pr i a
antf
bi he o i n he hi ng ra m n .
bi
t
u a, s
ta lt co oft o ni fom t Shangha Supr m e Peopl s Cour,w hih afim e t lw e co ts
rnsaed py
he pi on r
he
i
e
e'
t
c fr d he o r ur'

j d me ta an t tn.Frm ta o iin ia p asta sv rl il o ldn e s (re se ) a dt t no a
u g n g is Pae t o h t pno ,t p e r h t e ea bls f a ig xit o xitd , n ha Sa tv
e ed Patnt whih i tun e
ngag
e , c n t' ngage Fa Cha t s pt lnens Se Co plEx.3,a 2 Exhi t2, t n,i
d n
ng, o hi he i . e m .
t -3.
bi he s
a r nty t Gna bilofldi r pr s ntngt e r ul oft tpr s .
ppa e l he l l a ng, e e e i he nd es t ha oce s

5

c u' ds u ste p o rey o e ecsn a miat j rs ci n o e a c nr c ds u e u d r
o ls ic s h r p it f x r iig d r l u idito v r o ta t ip t n e
t
y
j1 1,Sa o a Cat l a eno t t patest t conr tatis 6
333( ) ntva nd selo r t he wo ri o he tac sue.

ld a c p , o v r Pli t psa g me t h ta atr ai eba i f rt eCo r' s b e t
o c e t h we e , ani r u n t a n l n tv ss o h u ts u j c
f
e

matrj rs ito e it u d rt lw o q a ic nr c,a i a pl st a miat Th ti,
te u id ci n xss n e he a f u s- o ta t s t p i o d rly. a s
e
S ad r l c u t h v j rs ito o e q a ic nr cu lcamst taie o to maii
t l miat o rs a e u idcin v r u s-o ta ta li ha rs u f rtme
l
y
conta t orot r i r nty m a ii ta aci ns' Bar Cons ppi S. .v J 000 M erc
rcs
he nhe e l
rtme r ns to .
'
na
hi ng, L . ,
ti

T n ,M o e o Le s o a d n d S e l 41 F.Ap ' 71 4 2 (t Ci.201 )( e c ra
o s r r s, fAb n o e te, 0
p x 6, 2 4 h r 1 p r u im)
(iai a i ena q ttonmaksomitd) h q s-onta tcl msar ma b pa te
cttons nd ntr l uoai
r
te .Suc ua ic rc ai e de y ris
S f va i ras ,c dnotpr valonac rc cli ' 1 ( tngM at e ev.Moor
û
who,or rous e ons oul
e i
onta t am.' d. cii
ar s
eM c mac Li s,158F. 631, ( Ci.1 46)
cor k ne
2d
634 2d r 9 ).
O ne r s a pary c d no pr vai on a co r c c a m i t pa t i nota pa t t ora
ea on
t oul t e l
nt a t l i s he ry s
r y o,

t r pa t be fcir of t r l ntconta . The ef e,e n i Pl ntf a De enda ta e
hid- ry ne i a y , he eeva
r ct
r or ve f ai if nd f n r
notbot pari st one oft e rirbil ofldi a 1have a s e Pli tf ' Co antca
h te o
he a le ls a ng, s
s um d, a n if s mpli n
s ilbe br ug bef e t s Cour unde a quas- on r c t or s nce t aleged da a s quie
tl
o ht or hi
t
r
i c t a t he y, i
he l
m ge
t
cl a l a os asa r s toft br ac ofa l as o oft s m artm e c r c s 1 See ArchJwlk
e ry r e
e ul he e h
t e t ne he e
ii
ont a t .
i

v.Hani i 35 U. 532,535 ( 95 (tS) l ast cl m ase t ars soutofamaii
ot, 0 S.
1 6) tg o ong he ai s red ie
rtme

c nr c,h a miat c u th sjlid cin o ri.) Ame id Shp n Cop.v J r a 1 t1
o ta t te d rly o r a t s ito ve t'' rn ipig r . o d n n '
r
',
Co. 31 F.Su 1 1 ( D.La.1 . I Ame n Shipi ac e q t smia t t
, 4
pp. 324, 326 E.
970) n rid p ng, as uie i lr o he
one a t ba ,a a nt f oc n c r ir a lge t ti ha e a s pmen of se f a
t he r n ge or ea a re s le d ha t ndld hi
t
t el or n
i
mpore ,a pa dt wha f gecha get tt i
tr nd i he
ra
r ha he mpore r f e t r pa . The c tr t ne t
tr e us d o e y
our eai d he
6Idonotf ecl eon t pos i lt t ta exp es c r texit bewee Pli ifa Defndant Bu
or os
he sbiiy ha n r s ontac sed t n antf nd e
. t

bea s lf ta ti Co r h ss be t te j rs ito o q a ic nrc go n s l on t e iet is e
c ue md h t hs u t a u jc matr u idcin n u s-o ta t ru d , d o d cd he su

.

1Thi muc s ms cl r fom t f tt Cha hou o i nal s d Pae i t & hi e M artm e
s h ee
ea r he ac hat ngz
rgi ly ue tnt n he f nes
ii
Coul 'a t onl c r tbet ent et e ii wasoneoft bil ofldi .
t' nd he y ontac we hos wo nttes
he ls a ng

6

c s i a miat ,saig i r lva tp rs t ti ha J rs ito sn eéheu j te rc me t
a e n d rly ttn , n ee n a t,ha t d ' id ci n ic i nus n ih n
u
t
(ot i relaos asar s toft br c ofamaii c r t' 1 ( tngAr haws ,
t he mpo tr r e
e ul he ea h
rtme ontac. d. quoi c ki
'
350U. a 5
S. t 36:.
Sa ova' la lt t Cha hou u ubt dl S r e'be us isage ,Paen ,br c d
nt s i biiy o
ngz
ndo e y û os ' ca e t
a
nt t t ea he
isoblga i undera bilofl di whih Ifnd t be a m a ii c r c unde t de i ton
t i tons
l
a ng, c i o
rtme onta t
r he fnii
de o by o he c t . Sa ova' c a m s a ns C a t lo,t n,lke i e a os as a r s t of
vel ped
t r our s
nt s l i gai t s e l he i w s r e
e ul

t br c oft tcon r t I fnd De e
he ea h
ha
tac . i
f ndan ' efors t ditnguih Bar Cons ppi a
ts f t o si s
na
hi ng nd
Ar hawsk una lng,a lw ilde D e enda ' M o i
c
i vaii
nd
l ny f
nt s ton.
IV .C ONCLUSI
ON

De e ntdoe notdi put t tvarous bil of l di c im t f tPl i ifanunge
f nda
s
s e ha
i
ls a ng onf r he ac a ntf
d

f rt martm e c r ige ofce t n lne fom Shangha t LosAnge e
o he
ii a ra
rai i ns r
io
l s.Thos bil ofl di
e ls a ng
a e m a ii c r t unde a ialy lw ;a alhough i does nota
r
rtme ontac s
r dm r t a nd t
t
ppea t t Pl ntf a
r ha ai if nd
Def nda a ebot pa test a s c r c ,lwilde De e ntsM o i a e r iet
e nt r h ri o ny uch onta t
l ny f nda '
ton nd xe c s he

Co r' j rs ito o aq s-o ta t l a i.
u ts u idcin n uaic nr cua b ss
The Cl r oft Cour i diec e t s nd a c rii c oft sM e or ndum Opi on
e k he
t s r td o e
e tfed opy hi
m a
ni
a t a om pan ng o r rt a 1c
nd he cc
yi
de o l ouns lofr or
e
ec d.

Eteti qY/dayotJune 21.
nedhs j
r
02
.
.e

,

NO
K.M OO
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE

7