Crawley v. Shuren

Filing 14

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on August 13, 2013. (sfc)

nl ri QrFl U. , ôm cotr
m
çe s Df
l

AT L BURG VA
YNO
FI
LED

IN THE UNI
TED STATESD I
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I NI
CT
RGI A
LYNCHBURGD I SI
VI ON

Ap 13 2 1
C
03
2U

BK

C.
D
DEP

EK CL
ERK
c

CASEN O.6: cv13- 00025

TRAYECRAWLEY,

Pl ntf
ai f
M EM OM NQUM OPI ON
NI
JEFFREY SHUREN
J
UDGEN ORMAN K .M OON

Deen .
f dant
1.BACKGROUND

Pli ifTrye Cr wly Cd ai if' fld t saci a ai tJ fe Shurn,heDie t r
antf a
a e pl ntf ) ie hi ton g ns efr y
e t rc o
oft Unied St t Food and Dr A dm i sr i sCent f Devi and Radi ogi
he t
a es
ug
ni taton'
er or
ces
ol cal
H ealh. Pl ntf alegest t FDA i pr l a oved cert n condom br
t
ai if l
hat he
m opery ppr
ai
andswhos
e
adverts ent do notadequat y i iy rs r at t s
i em s
el dentf iks el ed o exualy tans it dieas and
l r m ted s es
pr
egnancy. Pl ntf as t Cour t or t FDA t dunappr 't condom br
ai if ks he
t o der he
od
ove' he
ands
m entoned i t Com pl nt r lal adveri ent r at t t br ,and t r appr t
i
n he
ai , ecal 1
tsem s el ed o he ands
o e- ove he
condom si accor
n
dancew ih FDA r a i
t
egultons. The U nied St eshasfied a m oton t dim i
t
at
l
i o s ss

Pl ntf' Co antf lc o s j tmatr u idito a frfiur t saeacam u n
ai ifs mpli or a k f ubec te j rs cin nd o al e o tt li po
w hi r i can be gr ed.Fort f l i r ons lw ilgr t m oton and di m i
ch elef
ant
he olow ng eas , l ant he i
s ss

Pl ntf' Compli wiho prj c
ai ifs
ant t ut eudie.
II LEGAL STANDARD
.
Crawley v. Shuren

Doc. 14

A moint dimisf lc o s b etmalrjrs ci i go r db Fed rlRul of
to o s s or a k f u j c- te u iditon s vene y ea e
Ci lPr e r 1 b ( ) Asage r lmatr t plitf hast bu de ofde
vi oc du e 2( ) 1 .
ne a te , he an if he r n
monsr tngt t
ta i ha

s jc- te j rs ci popel lesi fdeal our.Se Eva v. F.Pe kn Co.a
ube tmatr u iditon r ry i n e r c t e ns S. r is ,
Di sono ande 1 1Cor ,1 F.d6 6 ( hCi.1 99) t he adee nt
vii fst x nt p. 66 3 42, 47 4t r 9 . û n fnda
W

Dockets.Justia.com

c le ss j c- te urs ci purua t Rul 1 b)1,(h dsrc c ti t rgad
halnge ube tmatrj iditon s nto e 2( () te itit our s o e r
t pl a ngsasm e e e d nc o t i s ,a m a c ns de e d nceout i t pl di s
he e di
r vi e e n he s ue nd y o i r vi e
s de he ea ng

wiho c ve tngtepr e di i oonef s
t ut on ri h oc e ng nt
or ummayj gme .' f (uotngRihmon4
r ud nt' #. q i c
'
Fr erc s r ( Pot cR. Co. UniedSt e ,9 F. 7 7 ( hCi.1 :.(1f
ed ik bug f oma R. v. t ats 45 2d 65, 68 4t r 991 ()
(

t maei j rs cina fcsaeno i diput a t mo ngpat i e ildt prvalasa
he traluidito l a t r t n s e nd he vi ry s ntte o e i
matroflw,'heRul 1 b)1 moto s dbegrne Rihmond,9 F. a 768 Thus
te a 't
e 2( () in houl
a td. c
45 2d t .
,

e nt ught motoni notc e tdi oonef s
ve ho he i s onv re nt
or ummayj me ,i i efci l t
r udg nt t s fetvey he
s
ummayj gme sa dadt ta is Acc di y,r s bl i ee e s oul b drwni
r ud nt tn r ha pple . or ngl eaona e nfrnc s h d e a n
t lghtm os f abl t t nonm ovi part See Reeves v.Sander Pl bi Pr .
he i
t avor e o he
ng y.
son um ng ods,

I c.530U. 1 3,1 0( 00)
n,
S. 3 5 20 .
l or t alow f t devel entofapot i l m ert i cl m ,f alcours
n der o l or he
opm
entaly
iorous ai eder
t
ha a oblgaton t consr pr sepl ngs lber l See,e. ,Boag v.M acDougal,454
ve n i i o
tue o
eadi i aly.
g.
l

U. 36 365(982 (iai o te .Ne rhees,spli i esr uii g neous
S. 4, 1 ) ctton mitd) ve t l s çl rncpl eq rng e r

c tucinofpr s c ai saen .. wihou lmis' Be detv.Ci o mptn,775
onsr to
o e ompl nt r ot . t t i t. au t
'
t fHa o
y
F. 1 4,1 78(t Ci.1 5)
2d 27 2 4h r 98 .
1 . DI
11 SCUSSI
ON

TheUniedSttsag st Cour lc j iditonove t smatrbe a et
t ae r ue he ta ks urs ci
r hi te c us he
Pl ntf l
ai if acks s a ng. St ng docti i gr
t ndi
andi
rne s ounded i t cas or contover y r r e of
n he e- - r s equiem nt

Ari elloft Consiuto Se Frend o heEarh I .v fai aw EnvlK NJ ( ,
tcl l he
tt in. e i s ft
t, nc . dl
t.V . TOC)
I 5 U. 1 1 ( ) TostsyAril 11srquie ns
nc, 28 S. 67, 80 2000 . aif tce 1' e rme t;
apli ifmus s ()( )ha s fee aninur i fc't ti ()co rt
antf t how 1 he s ufrd t j y n a t'ha s a ncee
i
a patculrze a ( a t o i n t no c j curlo hypoh tc l (
nd ri ai d nd b) cual r mmien, t one t a r teia; 2)
t ij yi fil ta a et t c le da to o tedee a 'a 3)i i
he nur s ary rce bl o he halnge cin f h fnd nt nd t s
,
lkey,asop e t me ey s c ai t tt ij y wilbe r dr s e by a
i l
pos d o r l pe ultve, ha he n ur l
e e sd
f abl deci on.
avor e
si

1 . tl 0 8l( in fua v Dee d r o Wi le 5 4U.. 5 , 6 - 1( 9 2 df ep ry
d a 8 - ct g j n . f n es f l f , 0 S 5 5 5 0 6 1 9 :. d' at
i
d
-h
i ki fd aj idito be r t bure ofetbls ngt eelme s' Luan,5 U. a
nvo ng e erlurs cin as he d n sa ihi hes e nt. j 04 S. t
'
561.

lfnd t tPl ntf has f l t es a ih t fr tel entofs andi t hehas
i ha ai if
aied o t bls he is em
t ng- hat

s fr da ij yi fc.Fo Plitf t ha sa ng, hi efmus ha s fee a ij y,
ufe e n nur n a t r anif o ve tndi he msl t ve ufrd n nur

whc mu tb moeta d o jcu a o h p t eia. Fre d o h Ea t, 2 U.. t1 0
ih s e r h n s ne trl r y oh tc l' in s fte rh 5 8 S a 8 ;
c
'
s ealoLu 5 U. a 563(û-j Gnuyi fc'etrquie mor t na ij r t a
e s jan, 04 S. t Eg-he ij r n at ts e rs e ha n nuy o
l
c z bl i er t I r uiest tt pat se ngrviw behi efa
ognia e nt es. t eq r ha he ry e ki e e
msl mongt ij e ';
he nurd'
)
Warhv Sedi 4 U. 490, (975 (kW le t a sre ham i a( neaie
t . l n, 22 S. 499 1 ) sg h n he se td r s ge rlz d
gri
evance's ed i s t i l equalm eas e by a1 ora l ge cl ofcii
har n ubs antaly
ur
l
ar
ass
tzens,t har
hat m

alnenor lydo sno warnte r s of u iditon.) Alhoug Plitf sae i t
o
mal e t ra xecie j rs ci '. t h anif tts n he
'
Compl ntt cert n condom adveri em ent l w ar ngsr di t r s ofpr
ai hat ai
ts
s ack ni egar ng he i k
egnancy and
s
exualy t ans it di eases,he doesnotaleget thehascont ac ed a dieas or s f ed fom
l r m ted s
l ha
r t
s e ufer r

a yot rtpeo ij yorha 1 A c r ngl , 1fndta Pli iflc sa ngt bi t s
n he y f nur
nn. codi y i h t antf a ks tndi o rng hi
c s be au eheha f ldt alget thes frda ij y.Be a ePl ntf lc sa ng,
ae c s
s aie o le ha ufee ny nur
c us ai if a ks tndi

t i Co r lc s u idcint h a tes i, n is al eds se .
hs u ta k j rs ito o e r h uta d t h lb imisd2
lV.C ONCLUSI
ON

For t f egoi r ons I wilgr def
he or ng eas ,
l ant endant s m oton t dim i s. A n a oprat
'
i o s s
ppr i e
or accom pani t sm em or
der
es hi
andum opi on.
ni
The Cl k oft Cour i he eby diect t s a cerii copy oft sm em or
er
he
ts r
r ed o end
tfed
hi
andum

opi on and t accom panyi or t Pl ntf and al couns ofr d.
ni
he
ng der o ai if
l
el ecor
1pl ntf e n sa e i hi r pons t De e ntsmoton t th fl hi Compl i ttf t s e y ofot r .''
ai if ve t t d n s es e o f nda '
i ha e ied s
a n Gor he af t
he s

2si e Pl i tf ha s ed a of i al a f de ala nc i hi ofk i c pa t ,hi s ti one a i tt Unie
nc a n if s u n fci of e r ge y n s t al a ciy s ui s
gans he t d

S ae , n t eCo r lc s u id cino e s c s isu e st eUnt dS ae h swav d i s veeg i nt .
tt s a d h u t a k j rs it v r u h ut nls h ie tts a ie t o ri n mmu i
o
s
y
S eg n r l F. IC. . e e , 0U. 4 ( 9 4 .P an if a n tie t id a dt eed e n ta p a t e s,
e e e a l D.. v M y r 51 S. 71 1 9 ) litf h s o d n i e , n h r o s o p e r o xi
y
f
t
a ysv rini nt wav ra pia l h r.T u ,h Co rlc ssbetmatr uidcinfrhs es na
n o eeg mmu i ie p l be ee h ste utak uj c te jrs ito o tirao s
y
c
w el
l.

E trdti / dyoAuut2 1.
nee hs 3 a f gs,03

NO
K.M O
UNI
TED STA TES DI CT JUDGE
STRI