Eubanks v. Lynchburg City Schools
Filing
3
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Norman K. Moon on July 10, 2013. (sfc)
c-
ôoF l u: DIT coU
Fce
8
r
AL c i v
To e q ï
FI
LED
I THE UNI
N
TED STATESD I
STRI COURT
CT
FoR THE W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I NI
CT
RGI A
LYNCHBURG D I SON
VI I
JACQUELI R .
NE EUBANKS,
J 1p 2 1
UL
23
JUUA .
DuD
BY;
DEP
CASEN O.6: cv13- 00040
Pl nt
ai ?
M EM ORAN DUM OPm I
ON
LYNCHBURG CI SCHOOLS,
TY
Deen .
f dant
JUDGEN ORMAN K .M OON
Pe ng beor t co ti Pli ifsmoton t pr e d i f mapau rs( ke no.
ndi f e he ur s antf
i o oc e n or
pe i doc t
1 ,whih lwilgr n . Howe r f rt f lwi r a ons lwildim isPli ifsc an ,
) c
l at
ve , o he olo ng e s , l s s antf' omplit
purua tt 28U. C.jl 5e()B)
s n o
S.
91 ()2( .
1.
A dititc tmus e l t a c an fld i f mapau rs a dimisi i i
src our
t vauae omplit ie n or
pe i nd s s t f t
deemi st tdh a tonora a ()i fi ousormai o ;(i fist saeacam o
tr ne ha s e ci
t
ppe l i s rvol
lcius i) al o tt li n
whih r ifma bega e o (i)se moneay rlefag ns a d fnda who i i ne
c ele y rntd; r ii e ks
tr ei ai t ee nt
s mmu
fom s h r if' 28U. C.j 1 5()2)B)i-ii;s ealoErlne Co.S. v Joh o 440
r uc ele.
'
S.
91 e( ( ()(i) e s ii
A. . ns n,
F.d648 6 (t Ci. )Cdse ton 1 5pe t dititc t t i e nde l a ss t
3
, 56 4h r 2006 g ci l 91 nnis src ours o nd pe nty se s he
meisofi or
rt nf mapau rsco ai s a dt e l s t t tha noag bl ba i i lw o
pe i mpl nt, n o xcude uis ha ve rua e ss n a r
fc.)(iain a itr lqu ai o te .
a t' ctto nd ntna ottons mitd)
'
A pr se ltgantspl ngsar ût be lber l consr ' Eri
o ii ' eadi
e so i aly
tued.' ckson v.Pardus,551U .
S.
89,9 ( )( iai omitd) Stl,t fc sale d m us tr s a rg t r le a e t
4 2007 ctton te . il he a t lge
t daie iht o eif bov he
s
pecultve l ,'and t com pl ntm us cont n denough f s t s at a cl m t r i t i
a i evel'
he
ai
t
ai t
act o t e
ai o elef hat s
plusbl o isfc . BelAt.Cor v.T
a i e n t a e' l l p. womby,550U. 54 555,5 ( ) Thi c r
'
l
S. 4,
70 2007. s ou t
uEau
RK
m ay not di i an ac i under Secton 1915 dunl s afer acce i a1 w el- eaded
sm ss
ton
i
s es t
ptng l
lpl
alegatons i t pl ntf scom pl ntast ue and dr i al r onabl f uali er
l i n he ai if
ai
r
aw ng l eas
e act nf ences f
rom
t e f s i t pl ntf s f
hos act n he ai if' avor,i appear cerai t t t pl ntf cannotpr any s of
t
s t n ha he ai if
ove
et
f si s
act n uppor ofhi cl m entti hi t r i .' D e' ont v.Angel
t
s ai
ilng m o elef'
f a
one,330 F. 630,633
3d
( hCi.2003 (iain omitd) l t sc s ,Pli ifsJ y 2,201 c ai fist saea
4t r
) ctto
te . n hi a e antf ul
3 ompl nt al o tt
cl m upon w hi r i can be gr ed.
ai
ch elef
ant
l
l.
l her com pl nt Pl ntf s a es t she was pr ousl empl
n
ai , ai if t t hat
evi y
oyed asa s tt e t
ubs iut eacher
h
g t
t 1 ai if l
hat he
s ged n at anuar ,
y
by t e Lynchbur Ciy Schoolsysem . Pl ntf alegest s w asdi char i l e J
201 , f her (us of r i on.' P1' Com pl 3. Pl ntf alo s at t s was di
2 or
te
elgi ' .s
. 2 ai if s t es hat he
schar
ged
be a e s wa d m e t bet
c us he s ee d o c
unqua ii ' a d nr i bl , bu c nt
lfed ' nd d ela e ' t o endst tt e ale tons
u
'
ha hos l ga i
aeSna c ae' I Plitf a t tûhe poc s f tnni ton rq r s moet n fve
r k c urt. d anif dds ha s r e s or e nai e uieg) r ha i
i
'
t
wrt ups w ihi a school year' and appear t cont t ,even i she had m or t fve
ietn
,'
so
end hat
f
e han i
Swrie- ,'t wer s
s t ups' hey e paced outovera perod exceedi one year I at4. Pl ntf has si
i
ng
. d
ai if
nce
appled f a contactt
i or
r eachi posii wih t Lynchbur Ciy Schoolsysem ,but sat t
ng
ton t he
g t
t
t es hat
s hasnotbeen abl t obt n a poston.I
he
e o ai
ii
d.
Pl ntf ' alega i a
ai if s l tons ppear t s
o ugges t t t Lynchbur Ciy School s t t
t ha he
g t
ysem ook
acton agai the due t herdus ofr i on' i t cl r . How e such r i ousconduc
i
ns r
o
d e elgi ' n he ass oom
ver,
elgi
t
i no pr t c e by eihe Til V l,s e e g. Gr s man v S.Shor Pub Sc D it,5 F. d
s t o e td
t r te 1 e , . , o s
.
e
. h. s . 07 3
1 7 ( t Ci. ) ort Fis Ame
09 7 h r 2007 , he rt ndme t s e eg.Edwar sv Aguil d,48 U. 578 58
n, e , . ,
d . lar 2 S. , 4
( 987 (i mii e r tpublcshool wiht e ai oft i c l e b c ndiin tei
1 ) ç les ntus
Fa
i c s t he duc ton her hidrn, ut o to h r
lPli ifsaest ts fld he i ta c aitwih te Equ Empl
antf tt ha he ie r niil ompl n t h
al oymen Opporu t Commiso (
t
tniy
s in EEOC)
o o ab J ne20,2 2.Plitf sn ieofhe s trghsfo t EEOC wa m aldonM a 8,2 3.
n r out u
01
an if otc
r ui i t r m he
s ie
y 01
2 Plitf al s t tJ n W oma a p i pa f Lync r Ciy Sc s t d he t the ç a ot h e
anif lege ha oh
ck rnci l or
hbu g t hool, ol r ha
û nn av
c
( anilu igayfr o rl in. . ti tesh o. 1l
Plitf sn n om f ei o . wi n h c o l' 6
t
g
h
'
t us on t under t ng t t cl r
r t
he
sandi hat he ass oom w ilnotpur el be us t advance r i ous
l
pos y
ed o
elgi
viwst a ma c lc wih t prvaebeif oft sude a hi orhe f miy.)
e h t y onfit t he i t le s he t nt nd s
r a l '.
'
Even i Pl ntf i atem ptng t alege t t s was unl f l di crm i ed agai t
f ai if s t i o l
ha he
aw uly s i nat
ns
based on her r i ous belef
elgi
i s,bot when s w as t m i ed fom her s tt e t
h
he
er nat r
ubs iut eachi
ng
postona whe s wa ltrrjce frc nta tta hi postons he c antsilmus
ii nd n he s ae ee td o o rc e c ng ii , r ompli tl t
be dim ised. A pl ntf aleges a prm a f e cas of dicrm i i unde Til V1 i s
s s
ai if l
i aci
e
s i naton
r te 1 f he
pla t t ()s e i ame rofaprtce grup;(i he j pef ma ewa stsat y
e ds ha: i h s
mbe
oe td o i) r ob ror nc s aifcor
( s wasqu iid fra ope postonf whih s a id) (i)s wa sb etdt a
or he
alfe o n n ii or c he pple ; ii he s u j ce o n
a ves e oyme a to ,a (v)smial st td e oye s o sde he cas rc v
d re mpl nt cin' nd i i lry iuae mpl e uti r l s e eied
mor fvorbl te t nt( s wa rjce f teope postonunde cic tnc sgi ng
e a a e rame or he s ee td or h n ii
r rumsa e vi
rs t a i ee eofu a uldic i nain) Se Colmanv Md.Cou to
ie o n nfrnc nlwf srmi to . e e
.
r fAppe s 6 F.
al, 26 3d
1 l (t Ci.201 ) Br wn v.Mc e 1 F.d 898 9 ( h Ci.1 ) Co tui
87, 90 4h r 0 ; o
L an, 59 3
, 02 4t r 998. nsr ng
Pl ntf ' cl i s lbe a l Pl i tf ha f ie t ale f t t s por t l s of t e f
ai if s a m i r ly, a n if s a l d o l ge ac s o up t he a t hes our
r r el ent .
equied em s
1 .
11
Fort f egoi r ons Pl ntf has f l t s at a cl m upon whi r i m ay be
he or ng eas , ai if
aied o t e ai
ch elef
grntd.Theeor, ru ntt 28U. C. 1 5()2)B) Pl ntf' c anti dimisd.
ae
rf e pus a o
S. j 91 e( ( , ai ifs ompli s s se
The Cl k i diect t s certfed copi of t s m e or
er s r ed o end
ii
es
hi m andum opi on and t
ni
he
accom panyi or t t Superi e
ng der o he
nt ndent of Lynchbur Ciy School, t Lynchbur Ciy
g t
s he
g t
Ator
t ney,and t t Pl ntf .
o he ai if
Enee ti /0 # a oJl,03
trdhs . y fuy2 l.
-d
NO AN K.M OO
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?