Olsen v. Angelone

Filing 43

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/12/2014. (kab)

a-<f;wtD7ç el
.;jx', œ
eat
l :
Fifr
1''
.l

I THE UNI STATESDI
N
TED
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
NI
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI

HENRY CHRI AN OLSEN,
STI

Peii r
ttone ,
v.
RONALD J.
ANGELONE,
Res
ponde .
nt

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

N
0#

2#
1

J I C. '', ERK
ULA ' Y CL
BK
DO

LERx

CASE NO.7:
01CV00310
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
By: Hon.Gl E.Conr
en
ad
ChifUniedSt e Diti Judge
e
t ats srct

By opi o a o de e e ed i J nua y 2002, he c tdim is d t spe ii f rawrt
ni n nd r r nt r n a r
t our s s e hi tton o
i

o ha e sc r usu d r28 U. C.j2 5 ,fld b He r Cl sin Ole ,a Vigna i mae
f b a op n e
S.
2 4 ie y n y uita s n
r ii n t
p o e dn p o K . Ole sa p a o t a j d me twa d s se . No ct M at z v.
r c e ig r
sn' p e l f h t u g n s imis d
w, ii
ng ri
ne
Ryan, U .
S.
-

-

,

1 2 S Ct 1 0 ( 1 ) Ole h s s b te a lte t a t c u tc nsr e
3 . . 3 9 20 2 , sn a u mitd etr h t he o r o tu d

a doc t a a moton t r onsde t 200 dimi s ofhi i f ci a ssa e cli sa
nd keed s
i o ec i r he 2 s s al
s nefe tve s it nc am s

pr e la l def t Thecou tfndsno me i t Ole sm oto
oc dtr ly auled.
r i
rt o s n'
i n.
Ole wa c c e i t Cic tCour f Ne s Coun y oft c sofagg avaed
s n s onvit d n he r ui
t or lon
t
wo ount
r t
s xua a s ul and one co off ci e s
e l sa t
unt or bl odom y. He wa s nt e t lf i p ion. Ole s
s e enc d o ie n rs
s n'

c c i a s ntnc we e uphe d on a
onvitons nd e e es r
l
ppea . Ole t n fld apr K pe ii f am i of
l s n he ie
o
tton or
t
ha as c pus i t cr ui cou t ale ng cai s of i fe tve as it e. The c r ui cour
be or
n he ic t r, l gi l m
ne f c i
ssanc
ic t
t
de ed r le . Ole a tmpt t brng aha a a a t t Supr m eCour ofVigi a whi h
ni ei f s n te ed o i
be s ppe l o he
e
t
r ni, c

wa ds se a t i l fld Ole t e fldh sj2 5 p tto Th sc u t o n t a t e
s imis d s mtmey ie . sn h n ie i 2 4 ei n. i o r f u d h t h
i
Supr me Cour of Vigi a' dimis lofOle s ha as a
e
t
r ni s s s a
s n' be ppea a untm el wa a pr e lal
l s i y s
oc dtr
de a t t t ba r d f de al habe r e and t Ole ha not demonsr t d c us and
f ul ha re e r
as eviw
hat s n d
ta e a e

prj c f t tdeful.
eudie or ha a t

M oi n f rrc nsd rto l Ole s tldma yy a sa trtec alng dj dg n ,
to s o e o i eain i s n',ie n e r fe h h le e u me t
ke
ars i a al t e Rul 60 oft Fe rlRulsofCi lPr d e. Rul 60( a horze
ie, f t l, md r e
he dea e
vi oce ur
e b) ut i s

r le fo a cvi j d me tb sd o n ng oh r ti s mitk ,i d e tn e s r rs ,
eif r m i l u g n a e n, mo t e hng , sa e na v re c , u p ie
e c s ben g e t o l n oh rra o t a j tfe r l f' l 6 ( )1 & ( ) S c rle i
x u a l e lc, r % y te e s n h t usiis ei .
a
e 'Rue 0 b ( ) 6 . u h eif s
a e ta r ia yrme ya ds o db iv ke o l wh nç p rpraet a c mpihj sie'n
n xr o dn r e d n h ul e n o d ny e û p o it o c o ls u tc 'i
a
t it tonsi vi exta di r cr m sa s' Dpwelv.Stt Fn m Fie Ca .Aut l ur
t tl i nvol ng r or na y icu t nce .
s a
'
l
ae r
r s
o ns .

Co,9 3 F.d 4 48 ( t Ci.1 9 ) l u h cru tn e wilrrl o c ri t h be s
. 9 2 6, 4h r 9 3 . l c ic msa c s l aey c u n he a a
s
contxt' Gonz e v.Cr by,5 U. 524,535(
e .'
als
os 45 S.
2005)
.

A Ru e 6 1)moi n t a se st rvii aj d me tds sig a j 2 4 peiin a
l 0
to h t e k o e st u g n imisn
25 tto s
wihoutmerts d be dimis d a a s ce sve ha as pe iin t pr ve pe ii r fo
t
i houl
s s e s uc s i
be
tto o e nt ttone s r m

usn s c amo int cru e tter l i 28U. C.j2 4 (9,b rig s c si peiins
ig u h
to o ic mv n h ue n
S.
2 4 1 arn uc e sve t o .
t
L. a 53132. El l n a Rul 60( moton atc ,nott s t e oft f dea c ts
ds t - tW he
u
e b) i ta ks
he ubsanc
he e rl our'
r s uto of a cai on t m e is but s
e ol i n
lm
he rt ,
ome def c i t i e iy of t f r l ha a
e t n he nt grt
he ede a be s

pr e di ,'howe r t moton i no a s e sve ha as J at532. Bec us Ole s
oc e ngs'
ve, he i s t ucc si be . #.
a e s n'
cure moton doe notat kt diposton ofhi j2254 cai ont meisorprs ntne
rnt i
s
tac he s ii
s
l ms he rt
ee w

ha ascli ,heague t ti i pr ry c i r a aRul 60( moin f rc i rton
be ams r s ha t s opel onsdeed s
e b) to or e onsdeai
oft c tsdimi s lofhi def ule c am s
he our' s s a
s a t d l i .Eve as umi wihoutfndi ass h,Ole i
n s ng t
i ng uc
sn s
no e ild t r i .
t ntte o elef
W he asae c t sr i d on asa epr edt a t l t dim isaha sc am t tti l
n t t our ha ele
tt oc l l ' e o s s
r u
bea l i ha ra

c ms lwasi fe i f de alha sr vi i bar d a e as
ot e
ne f ctve, e r bea e ew s re bs nt howi ofca e f t de a t
ng
us or he f ul

a d r s lig p eu ie Coe n v Th mps n, 5 1 U. 7 2 7 0 ( 9 ) Ge eal,
n e utn rj dc . lma . o o 0 S. 2 , 5 1 91. n r l
y
ûl egi nce on t pa tofa prs rsposc ci at ne doesnotquaiy a taus ''
Gnl lge
he r
ione ' tonviton tor y
lf s c e.'
M apl v.Thom as,565 U .
es
S.

-

,
-

,

1 S.Ct 91 922( 2) nM a tne t Supr meCour
32
. 2, 201 .I ri z,he
e
t

2

r c ze t f l ng lmie e e i t t s ge r r l û na uae a ssnnc of
e ogni d he olowi i t d xc pton o hi ne al u e: G deq t s it e
l

c e ( l k ofco ela i ta-eviw c lt a pr ee ngsmay etbls c us f a
ouns l or ac
uns l t niilr e olaerl oc di
sa ih a e or
prs rs pr dur lde a tofa cai ofi f c i a ssa e a til' 1 S.Ct a 1 5.
ione ' oce a f ul
lm
nefe tve s it nc t ra . 32
'
. t 31
Ole sst to doe no f l wihi t s ope oft M ari z e pton,howe r He r s d
s n' iuai n
s t a l t n he c
he
tne xce i
ve .
aie
i feci a ssa e cl m si hi sa e ha aspe ii
ne f tve s it nc ai n s tt be
tton.Hi pr e u de a toft e cai
s oc dt ul f ul hos l ms
oc ured notdtrng t ei ta c l tr lr viw pr e ngsi t c r ui c t butdurng hi
c r
li hos niil olae a e e
oc edi n he ic t our,
i
s
a tmpt d ha a a
te e be s ppea t t Supr me Cour ofVigi a The e or t M a tne e pto t
l o he
e
t
r ni .
r f e, he ri z xce i n o
pr e zalde a tdoe notpr de a gr
oc dlr f ul s
ovi ny ound on whi h Ole may ove c
c sn
r ome t de a tofhi
he f ul
s
i f ec i a s s a c a m s I a 1 6- 7.
ne f tve s i t nce l i . d. t 31 1
For t s a ed r s ns t c t m us de Ol e s m oton f r r cons de a i
he t t ea o , he our
t ny s n'
i o e
i r ton. A n

a opra eor rwilis t sday. The cer wils nd a c oft sor rt pe ii ra t
ppr it de l s ue hi
l k l e
opy hi de o ttone nd o
couns ofr cor f t r ponden .
el e d or he es
t

ENTER:Th s 'A d y o No e e , 01
i J a f v mb r 2 4.

Chi fUnied St t Diti tJ
e
t
aes src udge

3