Olsen v. Angelone

Filing 82

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/13/2017. (tvt)

r FRKSOF IEt.. s rnlr
a ' FC i Dlm . l
s
ATRoAs k,
ox vA
Fl Eo
L'

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DISTRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
RO ANOK E DI SI
W ON
H ENRY CH RI AN OLSEN ,
STI

OCT 13 2 1
07
JULA C.
I

. E.
CL

BY;

CASE NO .7:
01CV00310

'
D

L

Pe ii ner
tto ,
M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
R O N ALD A AN G EL O N E,

By: H on.G l n E.C onrad
e
Unied St e Di t itJudge
t
at s s rc

R espondent
.

By o ni a or re e e i J nua y 2002,t c tdimis d t spe ii f awrt
pi on nd de nt r d n a r
he our s s e hi tton or
i

öfha s c pust
bea or mder28 U. C.j2254,tld by Hemy Chrsin Olen,a Vigi a i t
S.
ie
ita s
r ni nmae

p o e dn pr K .Ole sa pe lo t a j d me twa d s se Ole ha mo e ml r u
r c e ig o
s n' p a f h t u g n s imisd. s n s v d meo s
tm e snc t n f rr c i r to oft de a ofha a r if wihouts c s Henow sl
i s i e he o e onsde ai n he nil
be s ele , t
uc es .
es

aû oint Ha eS aesP o e u a Dea lt ves d'amoin fra p it n o c u s l
& to o v tt' r c d rl fur Re re ,
M
q
' to o p on me t f o n e,
a d amoin t p o e d j f r p u ei. ( Nos 7 - . Lie Ole sma y p e iu
n
t o r c e . o ma a p rs ECF
o
q
. 9 81) k s n' n r vo s
m otons t i t ntm o i s e ng r ve s mus be de ed a wihoutm e i.
i , he nsa
ton e ki e r al t
ni s t
rt

Ole smo inf rr v ra o t h be s ud me tmus b a d e s du d rRue6 o
s n' to o e es l f he a a j g n
t e d rse n e l 0 f

t eFe e a Ru e o Ci lPr c d r . Rul 60b a t o ie r le fo acvl u g n b sd
h d r l ls f vi o e u e
e () u h rz s eif rm i ij d me t a e
on, n
mong ot r t ngs Smit ke, i dvere
he hi , G sa
na tnce, s prs , or e us bl ne e t' C wl
ur ie
xc a e gl c ' G y
ne

d so e e e i e c , G ru . . y a o p i pat, v in s o t ej d me t o t n oh r
ic v r d v d n e' l a d . b n p osng ry ' od e s f h u g n , r ç y t e
'f
'
a

ra o t a j siisr le. Rue 6 ()1 ,() ( ) ( ) & () Reifl e ti r l i a
e s n h t u tfe eif' l 0b () 2 , 3 , 4 , 6 . le md r h s ue s n
'
e ta r iay r me y a d s o l b ivo d o l whe G p rpraet a c pp ih j tc ' i
xr o dn r e d n h u d e n ke ny n s p o it o c o ls usie' n
a
G iuai nsi vi e r r na y cr lmsanc . Do lv.St t Fa m Fie Cas Aut I tr
l t to nvol ng xtao di r icl t es' wel
s
'
ae r r
. o nsl.

Co,9 3 F.d 46 4 ( t Ci.1 9 ) t u h cru tn e wilr rl o c i t e h b a
. 9 2 , 8 4h r 9 3 . G c ic msa c s l aey c ur n h a e s
s
c e . Gonzaesv. os 545U. 5 535( )
ontxt'
'
l Cr bv,
S. 24, 2005 .

A Rul 6 ( )moin ta s e s t rv staj g n ds si g a j 2 5 p tto a
e 0 b to h t e k o e ii ud me t imisn
2 4 ei n s
i
wiho m e i s d be dim is a a s c sve habe pe ii n t pr ventpe ii ne s fom
t ut rt houl
s s ed s uc es i
as tto o e
tto r r

u ig s c amoint cr l e tt er l i 2 U. C.j2 4 ( b rig s c s iep tto .
sn u h
to o icl n h ue n 8 S.
mv
2 4 1 arn uc e sv ei ns
$,
i
JZa 5 - 2 Hee Ole c le g sti c u tsfn i o p o e u a d fulu d rRue6 ()
#.t 313 . r, s n haln e l s o r' idng f r c d rl ea t n e l 0b ,
l
s t c tma a es hi c e i unde t tnze.J=a 532.
o he our y ddr s s ontntons r ha l ..t
/
Forr a onsale dy sa e i pro m e a um o ni ns howeve ,t m o i n mus be
es
r a tt d n i r mor nd
pi o ,
r he to
t
de e Ole m e e y r r s t pr dur lde a tis t tt c tha ar ady decded
nid. s n r l ea gue he oce a f ul s ue ha he our s le
i

a an thm. ( e ,eg,Opn o 2- ,ECF No 1 ;Op no 3 4 ECF No.5 ) Th c u ti
g is i S e .. ii n 3
. 3 i in - ,
6. e o r s
s ts d t t t de ii n was c r c t a y pr ed a de a tprncpls t ba r vi w of
a ife ha he c so
ore t o ppl oc ur l f ul i i e o r e e
Ole sf de a ha asc am so t m e is M o e r ast c thaspr vi l f t d,e n
s n' e r l be l i n he rt . r ove , he our
e ousy om ve
i Ole c d s w c us f hi de a tt r sa e pr e alr l s he cn
f s n oul ho a e or s f ul mde tt oc dur u e ,
nnots w a m a
ho c l

p eu ie S eCo e n v. o o 5 U. 7 2 7 0( 9 )( rig fd r l b a rve
rj dc . e lma Th mps n, 01 S. 2 , 5 1 91 barn e ea ha e s e iw
of pr edlal de a t d cli a e a s
oc tr ly f ule a m bs nt
howi of c us f r t de a t a r uli
ng
a e o he f ul nd es tng

P eu ie.
rj dc )
Fort sa e r as ,t c tmus de Olen' m o i f r co i r ton,a wil
he tt d e ons he our
t ny s s ton or e nsde a i nd l
dimi shi r m ani m otonsa m oot An a oprae o derwilis t sda
s s s e i ng
i
s
.
ppr i t r
l s ue hi y.
The ce k wil s nd a co oft s or r t pe ii r a t c
lr l e
py
hi de o ttone nd o ouns lof r co d f t
e
e r or he
r ponde .
es
nt

ENTER: Thi t * d y o t b r 201
s Z- a foco e,
7.
'

U nie St t s Di t i tJ
t d a e s rc udge

2