Abed v. USA, et al

Filing 19

ORDER denying as moot 16 Motion for Reconsideration ; denying 18 Motion for Reconsideration. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/15/2016. (slt)

CLERK' OFFI U.:. eT. Ur
S
CE
Dl x
ATR> 5V ,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI

MA2 15 2 1
25
BY:

I . D
A
.

,

,

L
ERK

O BA Y DA H A N I A BED ,
FI
Petto ,
ii ner

Ca eNo.7: c 00356
s
01- v-

ts
A,

By:
R e ponde .
s
nt

H on. i
M chaelF.Ur
bans
ki
U nied St e D i t i tJudge
t
at s s r c

Oba Ha t Abe fl d apr : moton f r co i r to oft m e a um
yda nii
d ie
o q i or e nsde ai n he mor nd
-

opi o a or rdim isng hi m oto t va a e s ta i ,orc r ts nt nc pt s tt 28
nin nd de s s i s i n o c t , e sde s or ec e e e l uan o
r

U. C.j2255.Abedague i t motont tt r we edeecsi t c ltrlpr e ng,
S.
r d n he i ha hee r f t n he olaea oce di
buthe as c g t thei ae a l i e ofhi c i i lc r es t s nt nc e e dt
lo ued ha
s m ly nnoc nt
s rm na ha g , he e e e xc ede he

sauo yma mu a dt th c u t a k dj rs ito t e trteci n l u g n .Afe
ttt r xi m, n ha te o r lc e u idcin o n e h rmia j d me t tr
rc ii t en tc r q ie bywihUntd Sae v Mc e 7 3F.d3 2 4 0( t Ci. 01 )
e evng h o ie e ur d
t ie tts . Ra , 9 3 9 , 0 4h r 2 5 ,
Abe hasfl d à nme
d
e n
nded moton f rr c i r to a g ng o y t tt c ms lwho
i o e onsde ai n, r ui nl ha he ot e
r pr s edhi durngt co lt r lpr e ng r nde ed i feci a ssa by nota gui
e e ent m
i he la e a oc edi e r ne f tve s it nce
r ng
t tAbe sus ofaM ol ov c kt i di no qua iy a at tuci de c 'unde 1 U. C.
ha
d' e
ot oc al d t lf s s r tve vi e'
des
r 8 S.

9 ()4 ( a j9 4 c . nlg to Abe ' a nd dmoinf rr c n ie ain,h
21a ()C) nd 2 ()1I i h f d s me e to o e o sd rto t e
o ii a moinf rr c n ieain( No 1 )i DENI a mo t
rg n l to o e o sd rto ECF . 6 s
ED s o .

jTheCou tofAppeasr ctd t a ia ef t on die' a a :
r
l e ie he pplc bl acs
r ct ppe l
Afe s i t Co ne Str ,Ama ,Obad Raye and Chiom de de t tt y
tr coutng he r r o e
r
ya,
d,
s
ci d hq he
woul t s a M ol ov c kt lt ough t bac wi
d os
ot oc ai hr
he k ndow oft Cor r Sor i o'he
he
ne t e nt t
sèc oom. On J nual 1 1
t kr
a y 3, 995,t ca e outt rpl Chiom t tfed t tRayed
hey ni d
hei an. s esii ha
ma t M olt coc alwih awi bo te ar g,a s ga olne....Obad s r ed
de he o ov kti t
ne tl, a nd ome s i
ya e v
asal
ookouta t gontoft aly.Ate Chio br t wi
t he
he le
t r s m oke he ndow wih ar k,Ama lt
t oc
ri
t M olt coc al and Chiom t ew i i ot sor Thecons r t sme a t i c ,
he oov kti,
s hr t nt he t e.
piaor t t her ar
ckce aound t bl k,a r tr d t Chiom' a rme . The fr S mplt y bur
ld r
he oc nd eu ne o s s pa t nt
le s
co eel nt
out'heCom erSt e
't
or .
.
Unie Stt v.Abed, .98- ,98 4647,98td aes
Nos 4637 4648,984649,98- ,200 U. App.LEXI 261 a *84670 0 S.
S , t 9,

2 0 WL 1 9 , t* (t Ci.a 1 , 0 )
00
41 0 a 3 4h rJn. 0 20 0.

I t ej2 5moi nfldb c u s lAbe h da g dçha t c u tn a e t e
n h 25 to ie y o n es d a r ue ç the o r iv d d h
t

pr vn eo tej r byisnztn tej r ta aM o oo Co kal t d vc c n it o a
o ic f h u y n t cig h u y h t ltv c ti,a e ie o ssi f
ng
bo te, olne a ar g, i a i e a y de tuc i de c '
tl gas i , nd a ' s n nc ndir sr tve vie.'Abe v.Unie St t s No.
d
td ae ,

7: -v01c 00356,2001U. DitLEXI 1
S. s.
S 7296,a *2,2001W L 1
t
343394,a *1( . Va.Oc.
t W D.
t
1 2001 .Abe as hadague t ta laeco elsf llet riet scli ondie t
9, )
d lo
r d ha ppelt uns ' aitr o as hi am
rc

a p a s r e a c u et e c et p o e u a d fu t fta cam.Th c u t ee tdb t
p e l e v d s a s o x us he r c d r l ea l o h t li
e o r rj ce oh'
a gum e t ,fndi t cli ofc te r p oc dur l de a t dbe a eAbed f ie t
r
ns
ng he a m
our ror r e aly f ule c us
al d o

e tb iha t a p eu ieo a ta i c n e2
sa ls cu l rj d c r cu l l e c .
mo
Ab d' isa tmoi npt s n t Fe e a Rueo Cii P o e u e6 ()4 mus be
e s n tn to l ua t o d r l l f vl r c d r 0b ( ) t
r

d n e .Abe ag e i t ea n e moinf rr c n ieaint thec u e f r h j2 5
e id
d r u s n h me d d to o e o sd rto ha t o nsl o t e 2 5
moton r nde e i f c i as itnceby notar ui t tt M ol ov c kt i di notq lf as
i e r d nefe tve s sa
g ng ha he
ot oc al d
uaiy

aç e tu tv d vie' n e 1 U. C. 9 ()4 ( a dâ9 4 c.Ho v r t Sit
G sr cie e c 'u d r 8 S. j 21 a()C) n 2 () we e,he xh
d
Ame e rgh t e f c i as itnc ofco e ha no be n extnde t colae al
ndm nt i t o fe tve s sa e
uns l s t e
e d o lt r
pr e ngs a M ol t c l isc n be c nsde e çde tuci de c s. See e. .M m i z
oce di , nd
o ov ocda l a
o i r d s sr tve vi e '
' . g.
,
ne
v.Ryan,

-

U.
S.

-

,

1 2S. . 3 9 1 9 2 ( 01 ) Un td Sae v. r , 0 F.d 3 , 5
3 Ct 1 0 , 31 - 0 2 2 ; ie tt s Yo k 6 0 3 47 3 4

( t Ci. 01 ) UntdS ae v. u , 7 F. p x3 3 3 5 9 (t Ci. 0 ) Untd Sae
5h r 2 0 ; ie tts Cr z 2 0 Ap ' 9 , ' - 6 6h r 20 8 ; ie tts
9
v Si n , 3F.d68 , 7 8 ( t Ci.1 9 )(oldi c s su d r2 U. C. 2 4 , n
. mmo s 8 3 6 68 - 8 4h r 9 6 c le ng a e n e 6 S. j 8 5 a

a ao o ssau e .Ac o d n l, dfist e tb ihta tej d me ti v i u d rRu e
n lg u ttt) c r i gy Abe al o sa ls h t h u g n s od n e l
6 ( )4 , n t a n e moinf rrc nsd rto ( No 1 )i DENI
0 b ( ) a d he me d d to o e o i eain ECF . 8 s
ED.
2Thec tnotd:
our e

Oftema y ag me t t y gn ldn Ab d ma ea til te c ranl n v rag e
h n r u ns he icu ig e ) d t ra, h y eti y e e ru d
t tt y wer i en be us a M ol ov Coc al doe not q lf as an i ndir
ha he
e nnoc t ca e
ot
kti
s
uaiy
nce a y

d srcie d vieu d rj 9 4() ld e ,te c n e e a t y mu t ta a Mooo
etu t e c n e 2 c. n e d h y o c d , s he s, h t
v
lt v
Cockt l c n quaiy. No do t y a gue now t t t Mol ov Coc al wa not a
ai a
lf
r
he r
ha he
ot
kti s
n

i e dir d sr cied vc u d rj9 4 c.
ncn ay etu tv e ie n e 2 ()
I , 0 U. Dit LEXI 1 2 6 a * - , 0 W L 1 43 9 a *1
d.2 01 S. s.
S 7 9 , t 3 4 2 01
3 3 4, t .
2

I i s ORDERED .
ts o

ENTER:Thi /
s Y

da ofM a c , 201
y
rh
6.

/ /- 4 .J / % c
+ a
Unie St t Diti tJ
td aes src udge

3