Johnson v. O'Brien, et al
Filing
205
Memorandum Opinion and ORDER: denying 186 ; granting 187 ; denying 190 Prisoner Miscellaneous Motion; granting in part and denying in part 192 Motion for Reconsideration ; denying 199 Motion for Sanctions. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/04/2011. (kab)
CL S OFFG U,
BRK'
ATR
S, S; COUR7
DI
'
OANOKE,V
A
FI ED
L
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROA N OK E D I I O N
V SI
N0V 2j 2 1
21
1J L>C.
j 'l D
4 /
.
?
, ERj
CL
'
-,
-
.
U
E 'J-,>
I x
k
LAW R EN CE JO H N SO N ,
C as N o.7: : 00165
e
09- vPl i if
a ntf ,
M EM O M N D UM O PI I N
N O
AN D O R D ER
TERR Y O ' EN ,e al
BRI
t .
By: Jam e C .Tur
s
k
Se or Unied St e Di t c Judgc
ni
t
at s s ri t
De e nt.
f nda s
Trali t smal ri s tf rNove
i n hi te s e o
mber1 and 1 2011 i t Bi St Ga Di son.
7
8,
, n he g one p vii
Beor t Co taePlitf La enc J on' tk quetf Entyon La '( No.1 )
f e he ur r anif wr e ohns s t e s or r
l
nd' ECF
86 ,
Plitf sRe u s f rPe uiso t W e rPr p rAtiea Tra ( No. 8 ) Plitf s
an if q et o n sin o a o e tr t il ECF 1 7 , an if
M oinf Ate nc a De ii ( No.1 ,Pl ntf M oton frRe onsdeai a t
to or tnda e t poston ECF
90) ai ifs i o c i rton s o
t Cour' e ri grntoft Dee nt'M otoni Li ne( No.1 ,a Pl ntf'
he
ts a ler a
he fnda s i n mi ECF
92) nd ai ifs
M oinf rS nci n ( No. 9 ) Plitf' Re u s f rPemiso t W e rP o e Atiea
to o a to s ECF 1 9 . an ifs q e t o r si n o a r p r tr t
Tra ( No. 8 )i GRANTED.Plit fsMo infrRe o sd rto ( No 1 2 i
il ECF 1 7 s
ani ' to o c n ieain ECF . 9 ) s
f
GRANTED i par and DENI i pa t Pli ifsot rm oto a eDENI
n t
ED n r. antf
he
i ns r
ED.
1
.
Pl ntf stR eques forE nt on L and'
ai if' t
t
ry
'
Plitf akst Coltoal w tej r t vsth s e eo tealg to s ta i, S.
anif s he t t lo h u y o iite c n f h le ain ,h t s U.
r
Penie ir Lee Thi woul bea e r or na y se i af r lci lc e,a notonet t
tnta y . s
d
n xta di r tp n ede a vi as nd
hat he
Co ti i lne t t ke lghty. I t pr e c s ,s c iy a l si lc e nsco e
ur s nc i d o a i l n he es nt a e e urt nd ogitca onc r
uns l
a i tt sco s of a ton. Pl i t f i a hi h s c iy i a e Tr a i s tf r onl t o da .
ga ns hi ur e
ci
a n if s g e urt nm t . i l s e o
yw
ys
The c t e i Bi St G a i m or t n 20 m ie f om U . Penientar Le
ourhous n g one p s e ha
ls r
S.
t i y e.
Tr n p ri gsve jzo s c u t tf tepanifh ssc rt d ti, n d f n a t a dter
a s o tn e n t r, o r saf h litf, i e u iy eala d ee d ns n h i
r
a t ne t t prs w o d notbean e s t s TheCour i notconvi edt tt sc ei s
tor ys o he ion ul
a y a k.
ts
nc ha hi as s o
e e i last w a r n s h a t e e ouse ndiur ofpu i r o c s Thus t sm oton
xc ptona
o r a t uc r m nd
xpe t e
blc es ur e .
, hi
i
i DENI Th Pli t f yp o eh sc s t t ej r tr u ht eu eo tsa naya d
s
ED. e ani ma r v i ae o h u y h o g h s f etme tr n
f
doc e a y e de .
um ntr vi nce
II
.
Pl i i f sR eque tt W e Prope A t i e atT r al
a nt f '
s o ar
r tr
i
Pli ifm o t Cour t al hi t a a a ti i ci la cl hi Thi moto
antf ves he
t o low m o ppe r t ral n viin ot ng. s i n
i GRANTED.S b e tt t s c rt r srci n i s db t U. M as asS r ie te
s
u j c o he e u i e tito s mpo e y he S. rh l e vc ,h
y
Pl nifwilbeal
aitf l lowedt we rone( )stofcviinclt sdurngtil Howe r Pl nif
o a
1 e i la ohe i ra.
ve , aitf
a
ppea st bei vei woul bebes f rhi f m iy t s nd t cl hi t hi c r tpl eof
r o le t
d
t o s a l o e he ot ng o s uren ac
i a c r ton.Afe cons tton wih t U. M a s sSe v c ,t Cour hasde e ne i
nc r e a i
tr
ula i
t he S. rhal r i e he
t
t nni d t
woul bem o tefi intf t Pl i ifsf miyt s nd t c ohi die tyt t U .
d
s fc e or he antf ' n l o e he l t ng r cl o he S.
M a s l Ser c a t f l i a e s 1
r ha s vi e t he olow ng ddr s :
Unie St t M a s l Se vie
t d aes r ha s r c
Atn:Tom Slm p,Su r s y De y U. M arha
t
e
pe vior put S. s l
1 U . Pos O fi e
29 S. t fc
M ai St e t
n re
Abi n, 2421
ngdo VA
0
1
11.
Pl ntf sM oton f At endance atD epos ton
ai ir
i or t
ii
Pl i ifa kst Cour t r c i rispr o or ralow i hi t be pr s nt
a ntf s he
t o e ons de t i r de l ng m o
ee
te
el phoni ly dtrng t de ii n ofhi w ie, ls J
ca l li he pos to
s f A i on ohns n. Se O r r Oc .24,201 ECF
o
e de , t
1,
No.1 9.ThePl ntf ha no a ol erghtt bepr e a hi wie' de ii Hei
7
ai if s
bs ut i o
es nt t s f s poston.
s
i a ce a e a hi r g t pe s ly pl d hi ci lca e m us ne s a iy be ba a d w ih
nc r r t d, nd s i ht o r ona l ea s vi s
t ce s r l
l nce t
lPlitf s dha t peron who i s ng hi t cot nglbelhepac gew ih Pl ntf' namean c e
an if houl ve he s
s endi m he l hi a t
ka
t ai ifs
d as
nu be .Addiinaly,i Pli ifwihest havet cl hi rt nedale ti ,t s nders d i ud ar t n
m r
to l f antf s o
he ot ng eur
r ral he e
houl ncl e eur
maln lb lp saepead. aln t icu eape adrtr lb l yla t t dsrcino tecohs
i ! ae,otg rp i F i g o n ld rpi eun ae ma ed o he etuto fh lte
i
i
afe t .
tr nal
lgt t p n o ia c n ens Prc v J h so , 3 U. 26 , 5 6( 9 ) Th Co r,
e ii e e olgc l o c r . ie . p n tn 3 4 S. 6 28 -8 1 48 . e u t
ma
havi c i r d a n
ng onsde e
umbero f cor ,i l ng t c ta s c iy conc r as oca e wih
f a t s nc udi he os nd e urt
e ns s it d t
t a por i t Pl ntf a t ne es iy ofhi pr s nc a t de ii ha f und t t
r ns tng he ai i f nd he c st
s e e e t he pos ton, s o
ha
Pl i ifsat nda by t lpho r as bl ba a e t Pl ntf si e esswiht eofhi
antf te nce ee ne e ona y l nc s he ai if nt r t t hos
s
c td a s Se I r Co l , 3F.d61 61 ( t Ci. 9 5 ( rczim)(u l n an mb r
uso in . e n e li 7 3 4, 5 6h r 1 9 ) pe l a o ti g u e
ns
r
ni
ofr e ntf cor t be c i r bydititc t i dee m i ng whehe t pe m i a i t
elva a t s o
onsde ed
src ours n t r ni
t r o r t n nma e
t at prti de ii ) TheCour sesnora ont atrispr vi r i Thus
o tend eral postons.
te
e s o le t e ous ulng.
,
Pli ifsmoton t a tnd t de iin i DENI
antf
i o te he posto s
ED.
IV.
Pl nt f ' M oton f R econs derat on
ai i f s
i or
i
i
On Oc o r27,2011 t Co tgr nt D e e nt sM oton i Li i t e l
t be
, he ur a ed f nda '
i n m ne o xc ude
e de er a i t cli t tha be dim is fom t sc s The Pli tf now movesf r
vi nc eltng o a ms ha ve en s s ed r hi a e.
a n if
o
r co i e ai n oft Cour' Or r a g ngt thepl nst i r
e nsd r to
he
ts de , r ui ha
a o ntoducee de er a i t hi
vi nc eltng o s
pr vi l dim is cai st s
e ousy s s ed l m o how p o ofde e
r of
f ndan Ta or sm o i o
t yl ' tve, pporuniy, n e ,
t t i t nt
pr pa ai pl n,knowldg i ntt ora e e ofm it keora i t Upon r c i r ton,
e r ton, a
e e, de iy, bs nc
sa
ccden .
e onsde ai
t Cou tfndst tispr vi Or rm a ha be n ove l br d. ThePl i ifmaynot
he r i ha t e ous de y ve e
ry oa
antf
i r uc e denc f t pur eofs
ntod e vi e or he pos
howi t hi p e ousy dimi s d cli a etu
ng hat s r vi l s s e a ms r r e.
Thos c a m sha b n di m i s d f o t ss ta a e t notr e
e li
ve ee s s e r m hi ui nd r hus
el vantt t m a t r t b
o he te s o e
de de a t i l H ow e ,t Pl ntf m a i r
ci d t r a .
ver he ai i f y ntoduc e de e a t t na ur ofhi
e vi nc s o he t e
s
r ltons p wih t Def nda si or rt s
ea i hi t he e nt n de o how t De e
he f ndan s sae ofmi du i t
t' tt
nd rng he
i i nti quesi Aspa toft se de e, ma t tf a t t f c t theha pr ousy
nc de n
ton.
r hi vi nc he y esiy s o he a t ha
s evi l
fl a n be ofc
ied um r ompli sa i to orm or oft De e nt .Hem a alot siy ast
a nt ga ns ne
e he f nda s
y s e tf
o
t di c plna y c pl nt t tt D e e nt ha pr vi l m a aga ns hi ,a t t f c
he s i i r om ai s ha he f nda s ve e ousy de i t m nd o he a t
t he diput t e alegatons Butt Courtwilnotalow t Pl ntf t us t sti asa
hat
s es hos l i .
he
l
l he ai i f o e hi r al
ve cl t con i t pr e i n ofhi pr vi l dimis d c am s and i e t e l e
hi e o tnue he os cuto
s e ousy s s e l i ,
nt nds o xcud
e ie ea t etmeo til fifnd ta i i irlv n o o e l p eu iil Th Plitf s
v d nc t h i f ra i t i s h t t s ree a t r v ry rj dca. e anif
m oton i t G R AN TED i pa ta D EN I i pa t
i s hus
n r nd
ED n r .
Pl ntf sM oton f Sanc i
ai ir
i or
t ons
Pl i ifa s m ovesf di cove y s nctons a i tt D e e nt ,c ai i t y ha
a ntf l o
or s
r a i
ga ns he f nda s l m ng he ve
' lf l diobe d't Cour' Oc obe 26 Or rco pelng dic r a wel ast Co ts
t luly s ye ' he
wi
ts t r
de m li s ove y s l he ur'
s he i Or rr r ngdi c r Def nda sr s nd by a gui t y ha f l c
c dulng de ega di
s ove y. e nt e po
r ng he ve uly omple
id
w ih t Cour ' or r , ovi ng t Pl ntf w ih m o et n 1 000 page ofdi c r The
t he
ts de s pr di he ai i f t
r ha ,
s
s ove y.
Co tc t e Pl i ifsM o i asoneunde Rul 37oft Fede alRul ofCi lPr e e
ur onsnz s antf
ton
r e
he
r
es
vi oc dur .
Re ol ng Pli ifsmoton i at se i uiy.Fis,t Co tmus de e newhehert
s vi
antf'
i s wo tp nq r
r t he ur
t t nni
t he
Def nda svi a e is or r . Onl i i a w e st tq ton i t a fr a i ne i m ove
e nt ol t d t de s
y f t ns r ha uesi n he f im tve ed t
on t a de e m i ton ofw he he s tonsa e wa r n e ora opr a e. H e e t Pl i if s
o
t r na i
t r anc i
r ra td
ppr i t
r , he a ntf
moto i s
i n s upporedby no hi m or t n co us r sa e nt .TheCour fndsno e de e
t
t ng
e ha ncl o y t t me s
ti
vi nc
t tt De e nt vi a e iso de s Thus t Pl ntf' moton i DENI
ha he f nda s olt d t r r .
,he ai ifs i s
ED.
V I.
C oncl on
usi
Fort af e i dras , antf s( ques frEntyonLand'( No.18
he ormentone e ons Pli if t
Re t o r
' ECF
6)
i DENI Pli ifsRe tf Pemisont W ea Pr Atiea Tral( No.1 i
s
ED. antf
ques or r si o r oper tr t i ECF
87) s
GRANTED.Pli ifst oto frAte nc a De ii '( No.1 i DENI
antf รป in o tnda e t poston' ECF
M
90) s
ED.
Pli ifsMotonf Rec i rton( No.1 i GRANTED i pa4a DENI i
antf' i or onsdeai ECF
92) s
n 1 nd
ED n
pa t Pl ntf sM otonf Sa to ( No.1 i DENI
r. ai if
i or ncins ECF
99) s
ED.
The Cl r oft Co ti die t d t s nd a co oft s Or rt t Pl i if c
e k he ur s r c e o e
py hi de o he a ntf , ouns f
el or
t D e e nt ,a t Unie St t s M ar ha f t W ese n D i ti tofVi gi a.
he f nda s nd he t d a e
s l or he
t r sr c
r ni
I I SO O R DE RED .
T S
'
F >d yo xo mb r
z a f ve e,
ExrsR: i +
r Ths
2 1
01 .
J
ni Unied St t Dl rc J
or t
aes
it udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?