Johnson v. O'Brien, et al

Filing 254

ORDER denying 250 Prisoner Miscellaneous Motion "Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law or New Trial". Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 1/12/2012. (tvt)

CL
ERK:OFFI t. tl . 1 '
CE 2S.lsfCOtR1
ATROANQKE,V
A
FI
LED

J 12 2 1
AN
22
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROAN OK E D I I ON
V SI

J A C. L CLERK
ULI DU EX

B: oEp &J,
v u Ez
e

LA W REN CE JO H N SO N ,
C aseN o.7: :v09- 165

Pl i if
a ntf ,
FINA L O R D ER
V.

TER RY O ' I ,e a1
BR EN t .

De e nt.
fnda s

)
)
)

By: Jam e C .Tur
s
k
Seni U nied St esD i t d Judge
or
t
at
s ri

J

Thi c ehavi be n ti byaj yi t Bi St Ga Di son,a vedit ha ng
s as
ng e red
ur n he g one p vii nd r cs vi
be n r t e i f vo ofDef ntTi hy Ta ora Def nda W iln W elh,i i he e
e e um d n a r
enda
mot
yl nd e nt lim
c t s r by
A DJU D G ED AN D O RD ERED

ta Plitf sM oi nf rJ d me t saM atro La o aNe Tra ( No. 5 )i
h t an if
to o u g n a
te f w r w il ECF 2 0 s
DEN I
ED. The Pl i ifs l r c rnot ng f o a y D e e n i t sc e.
a ntf ha l e ove
hi r m n
f nda t n hi as

I a c r a ewi t j r ' v r ita dti Or e ,h Clr i DI
n c o d nc t he u y s ed c n h s d r te ek s RECTED t e tr
h
o ne
j
udgme i fvorofDee t Ti ty Ta ora Wila W ec andt srket sc e
nt n a
fndans moh yl nd lim lh, o ti hi as
fom t Cour' a tve doc t
r he
ts c i
ke .
TheClr s l s nd aco oft sOr ra a ompa ng M e or ndum Opii t
e k ha l e
py hi de nd cc
nyi
m a
n on o
t
hepr s Pl ntf and c
/ e ai if
ouns lofr or f rt Def nda s
e
ec d o he e nt .

I I SO ORDERED.
T S

ENTER:Thi /k
s

a ofJ nua y,201
y a r
2.

A J
i Unied St esD i ' Judge
or t
at
s ct