Ramey v. Astrue
Filing
19
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/12/2011. (rkc)
cLE- : oFFI u-. eT tœ r
oe s Dl .
AT R> œ ,
VA
FIED
L
02T 13 2 1
01
I THE UNI
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I T C O U R T
C
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRICT O F VIRGI A
NI
R O A N O K E D I ISIO N
V
AN TH O N Y E.R A M E Y ,
J I . DUDA cu
ULAC
e:
y:
C i lA c i N o.7:
vi t on
10cv00356
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM O R AND U M O PI I N
N O
V.
MI
CHAEL J.
ASTR UE,Com m isone
si r
ofSoci Securi y,
al
t
By:Sam ue G . is
l W l on
U nied StatesD i ri Judge
t
st ct
D ef
endant
.
Th si a a to b plitf, to yE. me , l s a tt 4 U. C. 4 5 g fr
i s n ci n y anifAnh n Rn y pz u n o 2 S. j 0 ( ) o
r
r vi w ofa de i i n by t C om m i sone of Soc a Se urt de ng Rn e s c a m f
e e
c so
he
si r
i l c iy nyi
m y' l i or
Su e tlSec iy I omeunde Til XVloft SocalSec iyAc,42U. C.jj 1 pplmena urt nc
r te
he i
urt t
S.
381
1 8 4 Th matri b f r t ec u t nco smoin frs mmmyj g n .Th c u tids
3 3 9. e te s eo e h o r o r s to s o u
ud me t e o r fn
t ts t nta e de e s
ha ubs a i l vi nc uppor st Com m i sone ' fna de i i a e e s sz m a y
t he
s i r s i l c s on nd nt r lm r
j d me ti h sfv r1
u g n n i ao.
1.
I 1 8 , me s san da ij r t h srg t a t a r s le i tea u aino h s
n 9 4 Ra y u tie n nu y o i ih h nd h t e utd n h mp tt f i
o
tu a t fn es Sic t eij r , eh swo k da as o to d rc o p c e,
h mb nd wo i g r. n e h nu y h a r e s h r-r e o k, a k r
ds wa h r a df r lf o eao .l 2 0 , u t p i a datrtsi h sij rdh n h
ih s e , n o kit p rt r n 0 4 d e o an n rh ii n i nu e a d, e
a i d f rs e e a s urt i om e. l a Oc obe 24,2005 de i i on t ta i a i n,
pple o uppl m nt l ec iy nc
n n t r
c s on
ha pplc to
a a miitaielw j d e(ALJ' fu dt a Ra ywa c p beo p ro n h sp s
n d nsrtv a u g ; ' o n h t me s a a l f ef nuig i at
( )
r l van wor and de ed t a i a i The a i a i w a t n de e a a ll ve s of
ee t k
ni he pplc ton.
pplc ton s he ni d t 1 e l
' a yha fldamoinfrsmmayj d me ti whc hecamsta teALJfie t a c r p o e
R me s i
e
to o u r u g n n ih li h th
ald o c od r p r
weihtt t opi onsofhi te i physca a t t opi o ofhi v tonale uaor andt tt ALJ
g o he ni
s r atng
iin nd o he nins
s ocai
val t ,
ha he
er e i ac ptng a r yi on t t tm on ofa voc tona e r i t ti w a i ns se wih t Di to rv
r d n ce i nd el ng he esi y
a i l xpe t n ha t s nco it nt t he c i na
ofOcc tona Til s a t Voc i nalExpe tHand k p i he by t Soci lSe ziy A d i sr to
uoa i l te nd he
ato
r
boo ubls d he
a clrt m ni ta i n.
Conssen wih t sopi o t tm oton i de ed.
it t t hi nin,ha
i s ni
f
a nitai r vi a t sc te e e a opi onon De mbe 1 2006 fndi t
dmi sr tve e ew, nd hi our nt r d n ni
ce r 4,
i ng he
Com m i i ner sdec s on t be s
so '
ii o
uppore by s t nta e de e. Ra e cl m st the be n e
td
ubs a i l vi nc
m y ai ha
cm
di a e on Oc o r25,2005s bl d
t be
-one day a t rt A LJ' de alofhi pr vi a plca i n.
fe he
S ni
s e ous p i to
Rn e es e ily c am st thi i im e ha wor e
m y s nta l l i ha s mpar nt s s ned. mey now r rst tt
Rn
epo t ha he
pan i hi rghtha hasi r s d a t ti s tmesr dit up t hi rghtebow or
i n si
nd
nc ea e nd ha t ome i
a aes o s i l
s de a r quiest the le down durng t da t r i ve i. H i pr e a i a i w a
houl r nd e r ha
i
i he y o ele t s es nt pplc ton s
t c de e a t l w erl vel ofa i s r tve r vi w a Rn e f l a m i t n r que tf a
wi e ni d t he o
e s dm nit a i e e nd m y ied
te e s or
hea i on t a i a i The he r ng washel on M a 21 2008. I a ton t he rng lve
rng
he pplc ton.
ai
d
y ,
n ddii o a i i
t si onyfom Ra
e tm
r
mey a an i ri voc tona e t t ALJr vi we r or fom
nd mpa tal a i l xper, he
e e d ec ds r
Rnme ste tng physcin and hi pan mana me s ils .Ra e ste tngphyscin
y' r a i
ia
s i
ge nt peca it m y' r ai
ia
o i e t a Ra yha f n to a l tto sse n fo hi ij r b tta h wa sil b e
p n d h t me d u cin li ain tmmig r m s nu y u h t e s tla l
mi
t us hi rg ha f dal aci te a t thec dpef m aj t ta c
o e s iht nd or iy tviis nd ha oul ror ob ha c ommodae t e
td hos
lm ia i . Thi o ni w asl r l co r a e by t w rte as e s e s oft o sa e
i t tons
s pi on
a ge y r obor t d
he it n s s m nt
w tt
age y p i i nsw ho r po t d t tRmne c d bal nc soop,
nc hys c a
e r e ha
y oul
a e, t
knee ,c ouc a c a l t t
l r h, nd r w ; ha
he coul lf orc r y t e y poundsoc s ona l a t n poundsf e nty;a t the c d
d i t a r w nt
ca i ly nd e
r que l nd ha
oul
s a o w a k f sx hour d i a e g - rw or y. The a s s e s not t tR a e
t nd r l or i
s urng n i ht hou
kda
s es m nt
ed ha m y
coul pe f m unlm ie r c ng a ha i w ih hi l f ha bu t ts h ac i tesw e e
d r or
i t d ea hi nd ndlng t s e t nd t ha uc tvii
r
lmie i hi rg ha Ther or fom Ra e spai ma ge nts cils r veae t t
i t d n s i ht nd.
ec ds r
m y' n na me pe a it e ld ha
Ra yh dsif on sa d ce s dg i srn t i h srg th n , u gosl itc moo
me a tfj it nd e r a e rp te gh n i ih a d b t r sy n a t tr
s r ngt i hi a m s nor a r f e s a no m us l w as i The r or f r he i i a e t t
te h n s r , m l e l xe , nd
c e tng.
ec ds u t r nd c t d ha
Ra e w aspr c i d t o pai m edi a i a a r gi e ofhom e e r i e t t a r e l a
m y
es r be w
n
c tons nd e m n
xe c s s ha , s ec nty s
M a of2008, e ule i Rn e r por i t the wasdoi f i l w e lon hi m edi a i a
y
r s t d n m y e tng ha
ng a ry l
s
c tons nd
t athewa pe f mi hi daiy a tvii wih l sdic or. I a ton t t media
h
s ror ng s l c i tes t es s omf tz n ddii o he
cl
r or , he A LJhe r t s i ony f om a i pa ta voc tona e r . The voc tona e
ec ds t
a d e tm
r
n m ri l a i l xpe t
a i l xper
t
tsi e ta ap ro wi Rn y' lmiainsc u dh l an mb ro j b a whc Ra yh d
ett d h t es n t me s i tto o l o d u e f o s t ih me a
i
h
wor d i t pa t Thee r pr d ar pr e ai ls ofanum be ofot rc
ke n he s .
xpe t ovi ed e es nttve it
r
he omm o
n
occ pai t tRame c d pe f nn,i l ngba r c mt rs y wo ke ,ga eat nda ,
u tons ha
y oul r o
ncudi
gge , ot e uppl r r t te nt
a s c iy s vela m onior I oppostont t st tmony,Ra e s
nd e urt ur ilnce
t .n
ii o hi esi
m y ubmit a r por
ted e t
pr pa e a t r ues ofhi a t ne by a voca i
e r d t he eq t
s tor y
tonale r . Tha e r r pored t tR a e
xpe t
t xpe t e t ha m y
l c d m a ldext r t i bot ha a t t w ih a prorf ony c
a ke
nua
e iy n h nds nd ha , t
i el
onvi ton a w ihouta
c i nd t
di omaorGED,Rn
pl
mey woul ha adifcul tmefndi e oy e . Afe t c l i
d ve fi t i i ng mpl m nt tr he oncuson
oft hea i Ra e s
he rng, m y ubm it d t wrte opi on ofa s co voc tonale
te he it n ni
e nd a i
xper . The ex r
t
pe t
o ie t a s meo t ej b ie tfe b t i a t l o aina e e t o l n t p ro d
pn d h t o f h o s d n iid y he mp ri v c to l xp r c ud o be efnne
a
w ih one ha a t tRn e s f l c nvi to w oul be a ba e t e r i o m a oft
t
nd nd ha m y' e ony o c i n
d
ni r o nt y nt
ny he
ot rpostons
he
ii .
Afe rv e n t ee ie c ,heALJf u dta Rn y' ij r q ai e a a
tr e iwi g h vd n e t
o n h t me s n u y u li d s n
t
i ime ,butt thew a no dia edwihi t m e ni oft SocalSe urt Ac .The
mpar nt
ha
s t s bl
t n he a ng he i c iy t
A LJ c l d t tR a e ha e r e d s e c nge i hi i pa r e butt the c ul
onc ude ha m y d xpe i nce om ha s n s m i m nt
ha
o d
pe f m a r nge ofw or t the ha pe f
r or
a
k ha
d r onne i t pa tor i t a t r tve t the c d
d n he s , n he le na i , ha
oul
p ro m an mb ro ohe lg t u s i e j b e it i t en to a e o my Ra y t g s
ef r u e f t r ih, n kl d o s x si n h ain l c no . me l e
l
ng
r
t c tt tt ALJf l d t ac or s fc e weghtt t opi onsofhi te tng physca
he our ha he
aie o c d ufi i nt i o he ni
s rai
iin
(ot exe t tt eopi onsfvordhi andt t opi onsofhi o vocaina e r.
t he tnt ha hos ni a e m) o he ni
s wn
to l xpe t
2Ra e sphysca notdt hi paten t w a hadaf ry hih demandf rpanm edi ton'andt t
m y'
iin e hat s i t t ys
al
ail g
o i
cai '
ha
h tnd dt ha eû 1t fds o o th t(o d n t l y b e pan do jciey.
e e e o v < o o ic mfr ta c ul) o awa s e x lie betv l '
a
'
Ra y f t rc am st tt ALJe r d i a ce tng a r yi on t opi on oft i pa ta
me urhe l i ha he
re n c p i nd el ng he ni
he m ri l
voc tona e pe tw ho t s ii d a hi he rng.
ai l x r
e t te t s a i
lI
.
Thi c tsr vi w i lm ie t a d t r nai n ofwhehert r i s t nta e de e
s our' e e s i t d o e e mi to
t he e s ubsa i l vi nc
t s
o uppor t Comm isone ' c uson t tRn y f ie t m e tt c tonsf
t he
s i r s oncl i ha me a ld o e he ondii or
e ilme .42U. C.j405() Rihads nv. rls 402U. 389,401( 971.Thec t
ntte nt
S.
g ; c r o Peae ,
S.
1 )
our
m a notc
y
onduc a de novo r vi w orr w ei t e de e. Bl l k v.Ri ha ds 483 F.
t
e e
e gh he vi nc
a oc
c r on,
2d
7 3 7 5( t Ci 1 7 ) S sa ta e d n ei s c rlva t vie c , o i eigter c r
7 , 7 4h r 9 2 . ub tnil vie c s u h ee n e d n e c nsd rn h e o d
asawhol asm i bef
e,
ght ound a
dequ et s
at o uppor a c l i by ar a ona emi
t oncuson
e s bl nd.
Rihads v. r es 402U. a 401( tngCons . s Co. NLRB,3 U. 1 229
c r on Peal ,
S. t cii
olEdion v.
05 S. 97,
( 938) l s tnile de ee ss t c tmus afi t fna de ii oft
1 ). f ubsa ta vi nc xit,he our t fnn he i l cson he
Co sin r Ha v. ulv n 9 7F.d 1 5 ,1 5 ( t Ci.1 9 ) Fu te , n ce iii
mmiso e . vs S l a , 0 2 4 3 4 6 4h r 9 0 . rh r a y rdb ly
i
t
de e mi tonsmadeby t ALJa ee il d t gr a wei t Shi v v.Hec e ,739 F. 98
t r na i
he
r ntte o e t gh . vel
kl r
2d 7,
9 9( t Ci.1 8 )
8 4h r 9 4 .
l t sc e,s t i levi nc s
n hi as ubsanta de e upporsafndi t tRame i no dia e wihi t
t i ng ha
y s t s bl d t n he
m ea ng oft Soc a Sec iy A c . Conta y t Ram e s c ai t tt A LJ di notac or
ni
he i l urt t
rr o
y' l m ha he
d
c d
pr rw e ghtt t o ni ofR a e ste i phys c a t A LJ not t the di i f t
ope i o he pi on
m y' r atng
i i n, he
ed ha
d, n ac ,
a o d w e g t t phys ci n' opi o c e t tRa e sr ghthand i paim e was
cc r
i ht o he
i a s ni n, onc ded ha m y' i
m r nt
wel- um e ed,a i por t d t doc e ed lmiai i o hi fna dec son.Furhe ,
ldoc nt nd ncor a e he um nt i t tons nt s i l ii
t r
t A LJ not d t tt r po tby Ra e sow n voc to le ua orwas i ons s e tw ih t r t
he
e ha he e r
m y'
a i na val t
nc i t n t he es
oft e de i t r or i udi Ram e s do um e ed a lt t do lg hous hol
he vi nce n he ec d, ncl ng
y' c nt biiy o
i ht
e d
c e s h a c ng, lundr andr a ng hi c l e f s hool3 I t a ,t ALJr le
hor s uc s ooki a y,
e id
e dyi
s hidr n or c . nse d he
on t o ni ofa i pa ta a hi hl q ii d voc tona e r i de enni ng t tRa e
he pi on
n m r i l nd g y ualf e
a i l xpe t n t ni ha m y
silha t a lt t wor des t hi i r nt I addii n, heALJc i r d t r po t
tl s he biiy o
k pie s mpaime . n
to t
onsde e he e rs
oft o o he m e c e rs w ho o ne t tRa e c d pe f m w or t tw oul
w t r di al xpe t
pi d ha m y oul r or
k ha
d
a co m oda e hi lm ia i ,i l ng w or t the ha done i t pas ,s h a pa ki
c m
t s i t tons nc udi
k ha
d
n he t uc s c ng,
s ri a wor ng a a s t o derc
o tng, nd
ki s hor - r
ook. The i pa talvoc tona e r t tf e t t s m e
m ri
a i l xpe t es ii d o he a
e f c ,a e de ewaspr en e t tRa e c i dt us hi rghtha a t thi pan
fe t nd vi nc
es t d ha m y ontnue o e s i
nd nd ha s i
waswel- ntole by media i n.Fi l t ALJno e t the f
lco r l d
c to
naly, he
t d ha
ound Ra e t bet
m yo f
not
cr di e ' Be us t ALJ ha t opporuniy t obs r e Ra e s de ea a de e m i
e bl .
' ca e he
d he
t t o e v m y' m nor nd t r ne
hi c edi lt fr t nd,dheALJ Sobs r a i c e ni t s que to a et be gi n gr a
s r biiy isha t
t
'
e v tons onc r ng he e si ns r o
ve e t
w e g . Shi l 739 F. a 98 Ra e i e s nta l a ki t c t o r w e g t
i ht'
' ve y,
2d t 9. m y s s e i ly s ng he our t e i h he
e de e pr e e t t ALJ, nd t s t co tc r otdo.
vi nc es nt d o he
a hi he ur a m
Thee de pr e e wa a uaet s
vi nce es nt d s deq t o uppor ac uson by ar as bl mi t t
t oncl i
e ona e nd ha
Rn e ha e re ed s m ec nge i hi i nne snc hi l s a ia i butt the sil
m y s xpe inc o
ha s n s mpai nt i e s a t pplc ton
ha
tl
h st a i t t wo ka j bswieya albei ten to a e o o .I f lo ta teei
a he bl y o r t o d l v ia l n h ain l c n my t ol ws h t h r s
i
s t nta e de et s
ubsa i l vi nc o uppor t ALJSde so Thec the e or a fnnst de son of
t he
' ciin.
our t r f e fi
he cii
j5
s'
teCo sin ra e tr s mmayj d me ti hsfv r
h mmiso e nd ne s u r u g n n i a o .
-'
A'
ENTER :Thi 1 h da ofOcobe , 1.
s 2t y
t r 201
A
.
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J GE
CT UD
3I hi diabiiy a ia i , Ra e rpore t hee u e t thi c l e go up i tm ef s ol
n s s lt pplc ton m y e td hat ns r d ha s hidr n t n i or cho ,
go ont bus anddi t i homewor ,t theprpaedhi own m e l e r da t thew a he hi owncl he
t he ,
d her
k' ha
e r s
as vey y;ha
s d s
ot s
wihs eas itnce;ha hew e outi dal wake andt k publcta porai andt thes ilze wih
t om ssa t t
nt sde iy, l d,
oo
i r ns tton;
ha
ocai d t
fi , sc l e andhi m ot r
rends hi hidr n,
s he .
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?