Johnson v. Shear et al

Filing 33

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 9/1/2011. (tvt)

G ERA o'Fl u. , sm O ur
e' s sl
ATM NVI E. A
LL V
q
I ED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI T C O U R T
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I T O F VI G I I
C
R N A
RO AN O K E DIV I N
SIO

ë- 2
JU

.

B: E . L
Y/

K EV I JO H N SO N ,
N
Pl ntf
ai if,

C i lA cton N o.7: cvvi
i
10- 00381

V.

M EM O M N D U M O PINIO N

LIND A SH EAR ,etal,
.
D efendant
s.

By: H on.Jackson L .K i er
s
Seni U ni ed St es D i ri Judge
or
t
at
st ct

Ke n J
vi ohns n,a V igi a i a e pr ee ng pr y ,f l d a c vi r g s c pl i
o
r ni nm t oc di
o q ie
i l i ht om a nt
-

p rua t o4 U. C. 1 8 wi j rs ito vetdi 28U. C. 1 43 Plitf na sa
u s n t 2 S. j 9 3 t u id cin se n
h
S. j 3 . anif me s
dee nseg e pe eoft Vigi aDe rme ofCor ci (E
fnda t ihten opl he r ni pa t nt
re tons û
VDOC',mosl VDOC
'
) ty
e oye a t RedOni Stt Prs n Cçt dOni '.The i udeLi Shea,Ge
mpl es t he
on ae io le
on'
)
y ncl
nda
r ne
J
ohns n,Fr d Sc li J
o
e hilng, ohn Gar a Tr c Ra Ri ha d Row l te, am çsW a C .Sa ye s
m n, a y y, c r
et J
de,
l r,
W im ont S.C l k,A .H am it D .D alafor,O s ne,M .Boggs Rena M uli Fonni
l
,
ar
lon,
l i
bour
,
lns,
e

Ta or Ke n M ccoy a J m esLya l Pli ifal st tt def nda ss ' i a e
yl , vi
nd a
l. antf lege ha he e nt el nm t s
ve
i di e a unhe t f a Red Oni Pli ifr uessm yi c a ,a t def nda sfl
ne bl nd
alhy ood t
on. antf eq t
e us l nd he e nt ied

amo inf rs mmayj dg n .Th tmef rpanift rs nde pr d, ma i gt ematr
to o u r u me t e i o litf o epo x ie 1 kn h te
rpef diposton.Afe r viwi t r c d, de pl i ifsm o i f r us a gr nt
i or s ii
tr e e ng he e or I ny antf ' ton or ec al nd a

ted fn a t' to f rs mmayj d me t
h e e d n s moi n o u r u g n .

Pl i i fdes r best f l ng i or a i i hi c pl i t Pl i ifi di s ts i d
a ntf
c i he olowi nf m ton n s om a n . a ntf s s a i f e

1 aniffldamoinfrsncinsb cus plitf p ru n t VDOC p lc , i ar dy i e t RedOni
Plitf ie
to o a to e a e anit u sa t o
oiy s lea ndebtd o
on
f mor t $50f prorc c t a RedOni wilnol rpr defe copist hi . Pl i tf cl m st t
or e han
or i opy oss nd
on l onge ovi re
e o m a n if ai ha
heha afdavisfom Red Onin im ae buthedi notfl t m wiht co ti r pons be aus hecoul not
d fi t r
o n ts
d
ie he t he ur n es e c e
d
ha fe copi m ade Howeve ,Ifndt sa gumen doe notwa rnts nci , andlden hi r ques. Se
ve r e
es
.
r i hi r
t s
ra a tons
y se t e
UntdSae v Mou so i4 3F.d2 0 2 6(t Ci. 0 7 (ttn fd r l o rsp sesc rani id
i tts . sa u, 8 3 2 , 3 4h r2 0 ) saig e ea c u t o s s eti mpl
e
e
ih r n po r) Cr wlv v L. Be n. n .3 F 3 2 , ( s Ci. 0 4 (tt c u t d cd wh t u e a e
n e e t we s ; o e . . a l c, 61 . d 2 28 1 t r 2 0 ) sai o rs e i e a r ls r
L.
ng
d sr b ea d h w rgo o sy t e f r et e .
e ia l n o i r u l o n o c h m)
'

wiht f s r c her ce ve a Re Oni Pli ifbe ive t tt q lt off a m al
t he ood e vie e i s t d on. antf le s ha he ua iy ood c ly
s r e a Red Oni f ls bel t s anda ds s tb t V D OC asm e nst c c t . Pl i if
evd t
on a l ow he t r e y he
a o ut os s a ntf
alege t f i lr t n a s l ve n i e t c t m i t w ih pa a iesa /
l s he ood s iote nd poied, nni nf s ed, on a na ed t r s t nd or

bace ili e tons a / unrpe ec.unde c d..' (
tra nfci , ndor i , t , r ooke ..' Compl 3. Cons que l t
.)
e nty,he
V D O C' m enu pl nsale dl i ovi f r o y t m i m um da l nut ii na ne ds of
S
a
l ge y t
pr de o nl he ni
iy r to l e

s d nayt o ymo eaeya tv pes ngi)i c lre c u ta di vi mi a mieas'
e e tr o nl d rt l cie ro sc n ao is o n n n t ns nd n r l.
n
'
(d. ) Plitf camst a h e rie sxd y p rwe k a d te eo e t eme ui
1 2. anif li h t e xecs s i a s e e n ,h r f r ,h n s
i deq t f hi (d. ) Pli ifalgest tdee nt Ra Ro et ûa ot r'
na uae or m. 1 4. antf le ha fnda s y, wlte,snd he s'
punihed i aeswho br orr f e t r t n t rf taysby pl cngt m on r src e
s
nm t
oke e us d o eur hei ood r
a i he
e tit d

f e igs h d l wihDitLo é f rpeid o u t o ewe ka d o b sr igteimae '
e dn c e u e t e a o ro s f p o n e n / r y e vn h n ts
f i r rorSt of m plt a c wihoutata I 3- ) Pli ifague t tus of
ood n ubbe
yr oa aes nd ups t
ry.(d. 4. antf r s ha e
t Di tLoafi apunii m e ur am e a dbe vi con r /
he e
s
tve as e i d t s ha or tolmodii ton'a t ti i
fcai ' nd ha t s

nutiinal i de t (d.4,
rto ly na quae. I )
Pli ifal gest tvarousVDOC ofi i l ha r t la e a i thi bypr ve i
antf le ha i
tc a s ve e ait d ga ns m
e ntng
hi f om m a ng e e ge y gr e nce f rt e m on hs a t he co pl i a
m r
ki m r nc i va s o hr e
t fer
m a ned boutt f
he ood

quaiy.(d. ) Pli ifaloc anst theha no be n al dt pur es e ntl
lt I 3. antf s ompli ha
s t e lowe o chas upplme a
f ie sa t prs c m is y Cn vi ai ofVigi a Boa d ofCoreci St nda ds''
ood t m t he ion om s ar t ol ton
i
r ni
r
r tons a r .

(d.4.
l )
Pl ntf r quessa r le uns c fe no i l c
ai if e t s ei f pe iid m na , ompe aor , a punii da a s
ns t y nd
tve m ge

j itya d sv rl a an tted fn nswi p e a po tj d me ti tr s.Plitf as
o nl n e e al g i s h ee da t t r- nd s-u g n ne et anif lo
y
h
2A r ti e fedig s dul m e nsa i aer ceve t i dal a 1 t 1 1 c oreDitLoa . The Di t
esrctd e n che e a n nm t e i s w ce iy 250 o 5 0 al i e
f
e
Loafi ahi cal i tourba edba d m i ur ofot rnutii i r dint. ( mpl Ex C.
s gh- ore,l - s
ke xt e
he rtous ng e e s Co . . )

rq e t ij n tv r le
e u ss nu cie eif
1.
I

PLAI FF FAI TO ESTABLI A BASI FOR M Y R ECUSAL.
NTI
LS
SH
S

A s a i ta m a t r pl i if fl d a m oton s ki m y r us l Tw o f de als a ut
n nii l te , a ntf ie
i ee ng
ec a .
e r t t es

g v m j dca rc a : e to 1 4a d S cin45 of te2 o t UntdS ae Co e
o e u iil e us l S cin 4 n e t
o 5 Ti 8 f he ie tts d .
l
Se i 1 r quiest pettone t f l a a fda ta a c r ii t ofc
cton 44 e r he ii r o ie n fi vi nd e tfca e
ouns lofr c d s a i
e
e or t tng
t cl i i m a i good f ih;Se i 455 i s f a tva i a doesno r qui e s h
he a m s de n
at
cton
s el- c i tng nd
t e r uc

pr e a se . Si pl ntf di no f l w t pr e alr quie e sofSe ton 1 I
oc dur l t ps nce ai if d t olo he oc dur e r m nt
c i 44,

consr hi m o i f rr c alunde Seci 455. Se Gi nsv.O' nn,No.2: v0 4,
tue s ton o e us
r ton
e ve
Oui
02c 021

2005U. Dit LEXI 31 a * 6( . Va De 7,2005 ( tr ni rc a unde j455
S. s.
S 597, t 5- W D. . c.
) deemi ng e usl r

snc panifddno tl a afd vi o c riiaer q ie b j 1 4 (ii gLi e e gv. at
i e litf i tie n fia t r e t c t e ur d y 4 ) ctn l b r He 1h
f
j
Sv s Ac usto Co p.48 U. 8 7 8 n. ( 9 8 ( h us, J, is ni )ta l.
c . q iiin r , 6 S. 4 , 71 3 1 8 ) Re nq itC..dse tng smel

A Uni d S ae j d eû h l ds u lf hi efi a ypr c e igi whihh s
t tts u g ç al iq aiy ms l n n o e dn n c i
e
s
i ril ymih ra o bl b q sin d' 2 U. C. 45 ( ) j d emu tas d s u lf
mpa t i g t e s na y e ueto e . 8 S. j 5a .A u g s lo iq aiy
at
'
hms l û eeheh sapes n l a o p eudc c n en n ap ry o pes n l no e g o
i ef s r
wh
a
ro a bis r rj ie o c r i g at , r ro a k wld e f
diputde de ir f t conc r ngt pr e ng. J j45 () 1.P ril yrq ie a
s e vi ntay acs
eni he oce di ' #
'
5b () a tai e ur s n
t
-.
.

a r ntwr ulori ppr it diposton t wa d apa t Unied Stt v. don,61F.3d
ppa e
ongf
na oprae s ii o r
ry. t
a es Gor

263,267( hCi.1 (ii. Liek v. tdStts 51 U. 5 55 (
4t r 995) ctn t y Unie ae , 0 S. 40, 2 1994:.Bi rquies
x
as e r
4af vor bl orunf vor bl diposton oropi o t ti s m e
ç a a e
a a e s ii
ni n ha s o how wr ulori ppr ra e
oncf
na op it ,

et e b c u ei i u d s r e . .e t u nk wld et tt s b e t u h no t p s e s, .
ih r e a s t s n e ev d, . r ss po no e g ha he u jc o g t t o o s s g
)
. .

( qi e s i i de ee.... Lieky,510U. a 55 ( i nale
or s xce sve n gr
' t
'
S. t 0 orgi mphass .Bisor
i) a

pa ta iy,howe r a e notG xpr sonsof i pa i nc di s ts a i a
ri lt
ve , r
s es i
e
m te e, s a i f cton, nnoya e, and even
nc

a r t ta ewihi t boundsofwha i re tm e a wom e eve a trha ngbe n
nge , ha r t n he
t mpe f c n nd
n, n fe vi
e

c nime a fd r l u g s s mei sds ly' 1 . t5 5 5 .
o fr d s e ea j d e , o tme ipa . d a 5 - 6
'
Ale i biso p eu ieo aj d esve o r l st t rs fo fcso e e t i
lgng a r rj d c f u g ' iws r ui ha a ie r m a t r v ns n
ng
cure orprorpr ee ngsi a i ufi e ba i f r c a unl st opi onsddiply a
r nt
i oc di s n ns fcint ss or e us l es he ni û s a

de p-e tdfvo iim ora a s t two dma fij men i sbl ' l a 5
e s ae a rts
ntgonim ha ul ke ar udg t mpos i e. d. t 55.
'

S eBec rv. ie S ae , 5U. 2 282 ( 9 1 (e u i fd r lud efo tilfr
e r e Untd tts 25 S. 2, - 9 1 2 ) rc sng e e a j g r m ra o
sai g t emus ha eaveyj diil n ,n e d no b t (ijp eu ie a ans t
ttn ,k
on
t v
r u ca mid id e , t e o sc rj d c d g i the
Gema Ameia i t sc r
r n
rc ns n hi ounty.Therhe rsaer ki wih dil ly.) Eve rmaks
i a t z ee ng t soyat ' . n e z
'
m a i ha a e c ii alordi a ovi of ore n hos ie t co el t pa tes ort rc e ,
de û t r r tc
t
s ppr ng , ve
tl o, uns , he r i , hei as s
or na iy do no s ppor a bi orpa ta iy c le ' t y,51 U . a 555. A ddii ly,
di rl
tu
t as
ri lt ha l nge.
'Liek
0 S. t
tona l a

j g i n t e ur dt r c s hms l smpl û e a s o u u po td,rain lo hg l
ud e s o r q ie o e u e i ef i y s c u e f ns p re irto a, r ihy
b
tn o ss e uaingq'Untd S ae v. Te l,1 2 F.d2 9, 7( t Ci.1 9 )(iain
e u u p c lto .' ie tts De mpe 6 3 7 28 4h r 9 8 ctto
omit .
ted)
Pli ifsmoton f isa am at roflw a hehasnots
antf
i al s
te
a s
hown ade t bi so pa ta iy
qua e a r rilt
ts
o uppor r us l Al ofpl i if sgr
t ec a . l
antf ' oundsf rr c a sem fom c t oc edi a
o e us l t r
our pr e ngs nd

e i e e a t elw i ce r h t u iil iwp it aiigfo c u t o e dn saen t
v d nc , nd h a s la t a j d ca ve on s rsn r m o r pr c e ig r o a
s f c e bass f r us l y onl know l e ofpl i ifc esf om hi a tonst l d i t s
ufi i nt i or ec a .M
y
edg
a ntf om
r
s c i i e n hi

c t la no bi e a ns pl i if bute n i pl i ifsa lga i i tue,ha s er a o
our. m t as d gai t antf ,
ve f antf le ton s r t t ol e s n
unde l ng hi c am ofnegai diposton i no a s fce ba i f r us l Li y,51 U .
ryi s l i
tve s ii s t ufi int ss or ec a . ke
0 S,
a 550- . Abs nta r s bl bas sf quesi ng m y i pa ta iy, i i i pr rf m et
t
51
e
ea ona e i or
toni
m ri lt t s m ope or
o

rc emys f Unie Sttsv. ik,946F. 335,336- ( hCi.1 ) Ac or ngl I
e us
el. td ae Glc
2d
37 4t r 991. c di y,
deny pl i if s m oton f r c a .
a ntf
i or e us l

B.

PLAI FFFAI TO STATE CLAI SUPON W HI R ELI M AY BE GRANTED.
NTI
LS
M
CH
EF

lm us di m i s a a t o orc ai f l d by a i a e i Ide e m i t tt a ton or
t s s ny c i n
l m ie
n nm t f t r ne ha he c i

c am i fi ousorf l t sa eacl m on whih r i m a begr t d. See28 U. C.
l i s rvol
ais o t t
ai
c elef y
an e
S.

jj1 5 e( ) 1 5 b () 4 U. C. 1 9 ec .Th frtsa adi lde camsb s d
91 ()2 , 91 A( ) 1; 2 S. j 9 7 () e is tnd r ncu s li a e
upon S n i s a y m e il s l ga t ol ' t l i s ofi rnge e ofa l ga i er s whi h
' ndi put bl
a
rtes e l he y ' d a m
c
nf i m nt
e l nt e t c
c e ry doesnote s ,' cl i swhe e t t ac ualc e i a e c e ry ba e es ' N e t ke v.
lal
xi t' or a m
r he d t
f
ont ntons r l a l s l s.
' iz

W ila , U. 31 3 ( 989) Thes ondsa r i t fmiirsa r f amoi t
lims 490 S. 9, 27 1 .
ec tnda d s he a la tnda d or ton o
dimisunderFedea Rul ofCi lPr edur 1 b)6) a c ptngt pli ifsf t l
s s
rl e
vi oc e 2( ( , c e i he antf acua
aleg tonsa tue A c
l ai
s r . ompl ntnee $ s ta pli sae e oft cai s
ai
ds ( hor nd an t tm nt he l m howi t tt
a
ng ha he

pl de i e ildt rle a s fcen tgj t lalgai ...t r s arghtt r le a
ea r s ntte o eif' nd ufii t çfacua le tons o aie i o eif bove
t s cultvelvel.... BelAt.Cor v.
he pe ai e
' l l p. Twombl 550U. 544,555(
'
y,
S.
2007)(ntr l
i e na
quoai maksomit .A pli ifsbassf rle tequiesmor t lbesa
tton r
ted)
antf
i or eif d r
r
e han a l nd
co l i .... 1 The ef e apli ifmus ta lgef t s t e t sa eal t e e nt
ncusons
' d. r or , antf
'
t dle acs ufki nt o tt l he l me s

of(he cli ' Bas v. l DupontdeNe ur & Co.3 F. 761 765(t Ci.2003 .
t l am.' s E..
mo s
, 24 3d , 4h r
)
H o eve ,de e m i ng whe he a c pl i s a esa pl usbl cl m f r le i $
w r t r ni
t r om a nt t t
a i e ai or e i f s C
a

c n e ts e i ct s t a r q ie t er ve n c u tod a o isj d ca e einc a d
o tx -p ct a k h t e ur s h e iwig o r t rw n t u iil xp re e n
i
c m on s ns ' A s r f v. q l U .
om
e e.
' hc o t l ba ,
S.
-

-

,

1 9S. . 9 7, 95 ( 0 ) Th s ac u t
2 Ct 1 3 1 0 20 9 . u , o r

sr ni ac antunderRul l b)6)c ni ntf pla ng t taenote ildt a
cee ng ompli
e 2( ( a de iy e di s ha r
ntte o n
a s pton oft u h bev us t y e i tofno m or t n l be s a co
s um i
rt
a e he ons s
e ha a l nd ndus ons J Al ug l
i . . t h
Q ho
lber l cons r pr K com pl nt H ai v.K erner, 404U. 519, 20- ( 972) l nota
i aly
t ue o
ai s, nes
S. 5 21 1 , do
d

a t i
s he mnat sa
e' dvoca e s s
t , ua pont de l ng s a u or a c tt i
e ve opi t t t y nd ons iutonalcl i s t i a e
a m he nm t

fie t ce ryrieo t fc o t c mplit Se Br c v. rol 1 7F.d2 , 4 (t
ald o lal as n he a e f he o an . e o k Car l, 0 3 4l 2 3 4h
Ci.1 ( tg, ,c uri ;Bea t v. t ofHa on,77 F. 1 4,1 ( hCi.
r 997) Luti J. onc rng) udet Civ
mnt
5 2d 27 278 4t r
1 5) Se as Gor v. ke,574F. 11 1151( h Ci.1 )(e ognii t tditit
98 . e lo don Lee
2d 47,
4t r 978 r c zng ha src
cou t a e note c ed t as um e t r e ofad a e f t pr > pl ntf
rs r
xpe t o s
he ol
voc t or he o q ai ig.
.
.

1. Pl i iff ist s a e a c a m a i tde e nt M c y,Sc li G a m a W im ont
a ntf a l o t t l i ga ns f nda s co
hilng, r n, l
,
Sayer , l Clr Hamit Da lfo o Boggs
l s Lyal, a k,
lon, la i r r
.

Tosaeacam u d rj 1 8 , plitf mus alg çh v oainof rg tsc r db
tt li n e 9 3 a an if t le e s e i lto a ih e ue y
t
t Consiuton a l wsoft Unie St t ,a m us s w t tt alege de i to was
he
tt i nd a
he t d aes nd
t ho ha he l d prva in

commitdb ape s aci unde col ofsaelw. W e tv. ki ,487U. 42, ( 988 .
te y ron tng
r or tt a ' s At ns
'
S. 48 1 )
H ow e r pl i iff l t a l ge a f c saga ns de e ant M c
ve , a ntf ais o le ny a t
i t f nd s coy,Sc li G a n,
hilng, nna
W im ont Sa ye s Lyal,Cl r Hnm it D a l f o and B oggsand,t ,f l t s a e a c ai
l
, l r,
l a k,
lon, la i r
hus ais o t t l m

ag ns t m .
ai t he
Pl i iff ist s a e a cl i a uthi a e st t Red Oni co m i s r
a ntf a l o t t
a m bo
s ec s o he
on m s a y.
Pl i i falege t the ha notbee a l
a ntf l s ha
s
n lowed t pur has s e e a f ie sa t
o c e uppl m nt l ood t m t he

Red Oni c mi s r Pl ntf alocompl nst tRe Oni empl yee us a e st t
on om s a y. ai if s
ai ha d on
o s e cc s o he
c
omm is r asûa e e i n oft dicplna y pr e e'a lm i a ce st t comm is r t
s a y tn xt nso
he s i i r oc dur ' nd i t c s o he
say o
t e i a esw ho have notc m it a d s i i r i r c i nsovera pe i oftm e.
hos nm t
om ted ny i c plna y nf a t o
r od i '
'

(
Compl4.
.)
Pl i i ff ist i ntf t l ga ba i o a c tt t o lc ai t a es t Red Oni n
a ntf a l o de i y he e l s s f ons iu i na l m o cc s he
o

c
omm is r Thi f l ei nots prsng be a ei t sdo notha a c tt i lrg t a
s a y. s aiur s
ur ii
c us nma e
ve onsiutona i ht o

c
ommis r Ga
s ay. nnonv. ye s 2009U. DitLEXI 27542( . Va.M a.30,2009)(ii
Al r,
S. s.
S
W D.
r
ctng
Cat v. as 21 F. x258,259- (t Ci.
o W ton, 2 App'
60 5h r 2006).Se Ar r v.KeeeCommis r
) e eha t
f
say

6

Nçwor Sae ,2009U. Dit LEXI 76033( . Va 2009)(W ofdea c tt i l
t k ls
S. s.
S
W D. .
û e rl onsiutona
pr sonr uiesj ist pr dei t wihac
ovii eq r al o ovi nmaes t ommis r t purha ef ie a a
say o c s ood tms t ny
prc ' (ii To v. montout 97F. 1 ,1 3( t Ci.1996
ie.' ctng kl Ar r , 3d 078 08 8h r
)
:.
M o e r t de e nt pr de a r tona bas st r s rctac es t c m i s r
r ove , he f nda s ovi
a i l i o e t i c s o om s a y

prvie sa Re Oni
i lge t d on.Se Tur rv.Salv, 2U. 78,89( 987)( di t tt rto l
e ne
fe 48 S.
1
hol ng ha he aina
basst ta ist cli ofconsiutona vi ainsi vi ac r tona fclt .Re
i es pple o ams
tt i l olto nvol ng oreci l a iiy) d
Oni W a de Ra t s i i t tR e Oni pr desa çba i qua iy oflf prvieg pl n' t t
on r n y e t fes ha d
on ovi
ç s c lt
i e i l e a ' ha

alwsi tst e ni ra i glv l o p iie e b sdo g odbe a o .( yAf.De .'
lo nmae o m. nce sn e es f rv lg s a e n o
h vir Ra f ( fs
Br Supp. ot Slmm.J ( 21 Ex.A)! 1 ) Thepur eoft spln i Sohepofendes
.
M . z
.no. )
9.
pos hi a s s l f r
t
r cog z t i r s
e nie her e ponsbiiy f goodbe vi ra i o ng c ng s lsr t rt n
i lt or
ha o nd mpr vi opi kil ahe ha

e bii be vi ss e ngi dit grtfc ton.(d. Unde t spln,i t whor ri
xhi tng ha or e ki mme ae aiiai I )
r hi a nmaes
efan
f o c m itng t m os s r ous di c plna y of e e f 1 5 ye r a w ho r r i f om
r m om ti he
t ei
s i i r f ns s or . a s nd
ef a n r
c m itng c r a n l ss r o di c plna y of e e f r 6 m ont m a r gai t ra e st
om ti e t i es e i us s i i l f ns s o
hs y e n hei cc s o

s ksfom t c
nac r he ommis r (-z
say. J .
4)
W a de R a t tfest tJ hns n ha bee c
r n y esi i ha o o s n onvi t d o 51 di c plna y of e e snce
c e f 6 s i i r f ns s i
1
991, nc udi s s rousdi c plnm' of e e a t ea e ng bodiy ha m ,a r c nty a
i l ng uch e i
s i i y f ns s s hr t ni
l r s ee l s

Novembe 201 (#. 20. Duet t spatr ofbe vir Re Onin ofi asrmove
r 0. J=! )
o hi ten
ha o , d o fcil e
d
pli ifsprviege t t co m is r Ac or ng y, hedef nt ha ar tonaeba i
a ntf' i l s o he m s a y. e di l t
enda s d ai l ss
r a ona y r l t d t a l gii at pe ogi a i t r tt r m ove pl i if s a e st t
e s bl e a e o e tm e nol c l n e es o e
a ntf cc s o he
c m m i s r but r ga dl s , a ntf doe no ha a c tt i lrghtt a com m i s r .
o
s a y, , e r e s pl i i f s t ve onsiutona i o
s ay
Pl i iff is t s a e a cl i a
a ntf a l o t t
a m bouta ce st g i va pr dur s.
c s o r e nce oce e
Pl i ifcl i s t pr s ofk i l pr ve e hi f om f lng m or em er nc gre nc s
a ntf a m hat i on t a s e nt d m r
ii
e
ge y i va e

afe hefld m a e e ge y g ivanc sa
tr ie
ny m r nc re
e boutt aleg ypoorf
he l edl
ood.Howe r pl i ifdoe
ve , antf
s
notha a due pr e s orot r c tt i lr g t Red Oni s ort V D O C' g i va e
ve
oc s
he ons iutona i ht o
on'
he
s r e nc

pr e es l i wel s tl d t tt Consiuto c e t sno e il m e ofaprs rt
oc dur . t s l e te ha he
tt i n r a e
ntte nt
ione o
g iva epr edur sora e st a s h pr dur vol nt rl e t ihe bya sae.Ada s
re nc oc e
cc s o ny uc oce e u a iy sabls d
tt
m

v.Rie,40F. 72,75( h Ci.1 .Acc di y,pl niff ist saeacam upo whih
c
3d
4t r 994)
or ngl aitf al o tt li
n c
r le m ay be gr nt d.
e if
a e

Pli iff l t sa ea cai a
a ntf ais o tt l m boutSt of m a r rut is pl t war ,orta .
yr oa nd ubbe ensl , a e e r ys
Pli tf ale st tde enda spu s d i aeswho br orr us d t r ur t rf
a n if l ge ha f nt nihe nm t
oke ef e o et n hei ood
taysby gi ngt m Di tLoa f up t onewe k ml orby s r ng i a e 'f wih nz ror
r
vi he
e
f or o
e d/
e vi nm t s ood t bbe
St of m ut nsl , a e r o ta .Howe r pl i ifpr s nty l c sa ngt s on
yr oa e is plt wa e, r r ys
ve , antf e e l a ks tndi o ue

be l ofot ri ts SeeLuinv. fnde sofW idlf 5 U. 555,560- 4992)
haf he nmae .
a Dee r
l ie, 04 S.
61 1

( odngt a sa dngr q ie ij r , a sto a r d e s blt) Ev ni pli t f e ev d
h li h t tn i e ur s nu y c u ain, nd e r sa ii . e f ani r c ie
y
f
St r f m orr re tng ie s pl ntf d notha a c tt i lrghtt sl r r o t
y o oa
ubbe a i t m , ai if oes
ve onsiutona i o ive wa e r o
no r ce ve St r on orr
te i
y of m
ubbe ut ns l ,pl t w a e,o t a . A cc di y, a ntf f l t s a e
r e is a e r r r ys
or ngl pl i if ais o t t

ac am u whih r i fm a begr nt
l i pon c ele y
a ed.
C. THE D EF NDANTSA RE ENTI ED TO SUMMARY J
E
TL
UDGM E F PLAI F ' M E AND
NT OR
NTI F S NU
DI LOAF CLAI S.
ET
M

A p ryi e t ldt sz r j d me tSft pla ig ,h ds o e ya ds ls r
a t s n i e o lmma y u g n d he e dn s te ic v r nd ico u e
t
i
ma e i l on fl a a a fda t s
t ras ie, nd ny fi vis how t tt r i no ge neis ast a ma e i lf d a
ha he e s
nui s ue o ny t ra a nd

t themo n i e ildt j d me ta amatro lw. Fe . . v. 5 ()3 M aeil a t
ha t
va t s nt e o u g n s te f a ' d R Ci P. 6 c . tra fcs
t
'
3Thepa te r ceve r onabl a e i tnotcet tte cour m a c
ris e i d eas
e nd xplci i ha h
t y onver am oton t dim i st tr e e es
t
i o s s ha ef r nc

matr o tiet pla n sit amoinfrs mmayj d metwh nt eClr is e atmeyRo e oonoie
tes usd he e dig no to o u r u g n e h ek su d i l sb r tc .
S eFe R. v P.1 d ; sb r v. rion 5 F.d3 9 31 ( t Ci. 9 )
e d. Ci. 2() Ro e o o Gars , 28 2 0 , 0 4h r 1 75.

a et ene s a yt esa ih t elm e sofapa t sc us ofa on.Ande s v. be t
r hos ce s r o tbls he e nt
ry' a e di
r on Li ry

Lobbv.l .477U. 242,248( 98 .A ge neis ofmaeilf te ssi,i viwi t
nc,
S.
1 6)
nui sue
tra ac xit f n e ng he
r or a a1 r as bl i e e esdr t r fom i alghtm os f vor bl t t non- o ng
ec d nd l e ona e nf r nc
awn he e r n i
t a a e o he
m vi

pary,aras bl f tfnde coul rt naveditf t nont e ona e ac-i r d eur
r c or he mova .Jl Themovi pa t
nt .a
t
ng ry
hast bur n ofs
he de
howi - dha i,poi i outt t dititc t- t t r i an a e eof
ng s t s ntng
t
o he src our hat he e s bs nc
evi nce t s
de
o uppor t nonm ovi pa t s c e. Cel ex Cor v. t e t 477 U . 31 325
t he
ng ry' as '
' ot
p. Ca r t,
S. 7,

(1 ) l t mova s tsi t sbur n,t nt non- va mus s tfrh s cii f t
986 . f he
nt aifes hi de he he mo nt t e o t pe fc acs
ad i s bl a e de e t tde ons r t t exi t nce ofa ge ne i s off d f t i l Fe R.
m s i e s vi nc ha m t a e he s e
nui s ue a or r a . d.

Ci . 5 ( ) i a 3 2- .A p ryi e tte t s mmayj d me t f h r c r a awh l
v P. 6 c 'd. t 2 23
,
a t s n i d o u r u g n i t e e o d s oe
l
c d notl a ar tona ti roff c t fnd i f voroft nonoul
e d ai l re
ato i n a
he
mova .W ila sv.Grfi 952
nt
lim
ifn,

F. 820,823( hCi.1 )
2d
4t r 991 .

Co ves l, u r j g n i ia p o raei t ee ie ei s fi in f ra
n rey s mmay ud me t s n p r p it f h vd nc s u tce t o
r as bl f c - i rt r ur a ve di ti f vo oft non- o ng pa t A nder on, 7 U .
e ona e a t fnde o et n
r c n a r he
m vi
r y.
s 47 S.

a 2 .Eve i t r i n d s u ea t t e i e tayf cs s
t 48
n f hee s o ip t s o he v d nir a t, ummayj dg n i as n t
r u me t s lo o
a o i t whe et uli a ef c ua c l i nst bedr wn a e i diput Ove sr tv.
ppr pra e
r he tm t a t l oncuso o
a
r n s e.
r tee Kv.

Ce . f I Co.950F. 931 937(t Ci.1 ) A c tma net rrs veds e
nt Lie ns. ,
2d , 4h r 991 . our y ihe e ol iputd
fdsorweih t e denc Ruselv. ir vneCo p.65F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) nor
a
g he vi e, s l M cod
r , 3d 229, 239 4t r 995 ,
ma deer nai ofcrdi lt Sos be v. uphv,797F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 .
ke t mi tons e biiy, e e M
2d 79, 82 4t r 986)
Rahe , hepa t opposng t moton i en ild t ha hi orhe ve son oft f dsa ce e
t rt
ry
i he i s tte o ve s
r ri
he a c ptd
ast ue a m or ove , o ha a li t r c lc sr ol i hi orherf vor Cha bo ge de
r nd, e r t ve l n e nal onf i t es ved n s
a .
r nna s

Frnc v.Smih,597F. 406,41 ( h Ci.1 .Howe r ûy he o i pa te tl t
a e
t
2d
4 4t r 979)
ve,twl n pposng ris elwo
dif r ts ores one ofw hi h i bl t nty c r di t by t r or , s t tnoras
f e en t i ,
c s a a l onta c ed
he ec d o ha
e onabl j y
e ur

c d be i ve i,a c ts d nota
oul le t our houl
doptt tve s on oft f c sf pur e ofr i on a
ha r i
he a t or pos s ulng

moi f s
ton or ummayj me .'Sc tv. ri,550U. 37 380(
r udg nt' ot Hars
S. 2, 2007) Furhemor,apa t
. t r e ry
Sn
t nnotc e e a genui i s ofm a era f c t oug m e e s ul i n ort buidi ofo
c
r at
ne s ue
t i l a t hr h r pec ato
he l ng
ne

i ee upona t r' al v.Ha d 769F. 21 21 (t Ci.1 .Theeor Cg ee
nfrnce
nohe .
'Be e
r y,
2d 3, 4 4h r 985)
rf e,imjr

u s p o tds e ulto . .sn t no g t d fa as mmayj d me t to ' En sv.
n u p re p c ain . i o e u h o ee t u r u g n moi n. ni
'
Na 'As ' ofBus & Educ.Ra o.l ,53F. 55, ( h Ci.1 ) M oeove,apli if
tl sn
.
di nc.
3d 62 4t r 995 . r r antf

c n o rl o ar s ns t amo inf rs mma yj d me t oa t sa a n me tt c re t
a n t ey n epo e o
to o u r u g n t c a n me d n o o r c
d t e de i ac mplitc le g db ad fn a tsmo inf rs mma yj dg n .S e
ekin s n o an haln e y ee d n ' to o u r u me t e
Gimourv. ts M c l & Co.38 F. 1 2,1 5( t Ci.2004)(( pli ifma not
l
Gae , Donad
, 2 3d 31 31 11h r
:A antf y

a n h rc mplitt o g ag me t nab ifo po ig s mmayj dg n .) Baca W ht
me d e o an hr u h r u n i re p sn u l u me t'; r ly ie
'
Ska ka.nc. BatleM e 'l t, F. x556,563& n.6( h Ci.
ns I v. tel m l ns.262 App'
1 4t r 2008)@ o.
071 ,a lbl a 2008W L 23856 a * 2008U. App.
084) vaia e t
2, t 6,
S.
LEXI 1 6, t*1820 ( i t t
S 91 a - notng ha
ot rc r uiss m ia l pr bi a pl ntf f om r i i ne c a m s i o
he ic t i l ry ohi t ai i f r
a sng w l i n ppos ton t s m a y
ii o um r

j
udgme a noi t tdititc t wihi t Fourh Cic tha a e Gimour.
nt nd tng ha src ours t n he
t rui ve doptd l )
To s ce d on an Ei t Amendme d r e a unus lpunihm e ' ca m , prs ne
uc e
gh h
nt t u l nd
c
ua
s nt' li a i o r

mu tp o et f lo ngee n s ( ) h d p iaino ab sch ma n e wa o j ciey
s r v he ol wi lme t: 1 t e e rv to f a i u n e d s b e tv l
C u tce tys ro s' n ()t ep io ofca s j cieya dwi d lb rt i ifrn e
t fi inl ei u 'a d 2 h rs n fiil ube tv l de t eie ae ndfee c .
s
h
W is v.Setr 5 U. 294,298,303( 991.Ale tonsofi de t f frhuma
lon
ie , 01 S.
1 ) lgai
na quae ood o
n
nutii lne oruns nia y f s r i ef ciii m a bes t i ntt sa e ac za e
rtona eds
a t r ood e v c a ltes y ufk e o tt ogni bl
c tt i lcai i t de i ton i s rousa t de e nti dei r t l i fe e t
onsiutona l m f he prvai s e i
nd he f nda s lbe a ey ndif r nt o

t ne Se Bol nRv. s usr 575F. 461( hCi.1 )
he ed. e dî Holho e ,
2d
4t r 978 .
Thi courtr s t once agai whet t V DO C ' D i Loafcons iut crueland
s
evi is
n
her he
S et
tt es

m ni
unus puni hm enti vi a i oft Ei h A m e
ual
s
n ol ton he ght
ndm e . Se e. ,H e r on v.Vi i a,
nt e, :. nde s
.

2008U. Dit LEXI 5230,*1 15( . Va. a 23, ) Bl v.Ge r 2007U.
S. s.
S
4- W D. J n. 2008 , ount
.
ntv,
S.

DitLEXI 3 0 2 * 6 1 ( . Va M a 3 2 0 ) afd2 3F. p' 2 9( t Ci. 0 7 ;
s.
S 3 9 , 1 - 7 W D. . y , 0 7 , f' 5 Ap x 9 4h r 2 0 )
Bl v.W ila ,
ount
lims 2007U. Dit LEXI 21 5,*1 20( . Va. ar 26,2007) Thoma v.
S. s.
S 21 9- W D. M .
,
'
s
Vi ni,2005U. Dit LEXI 1 ,* 11( . Va J y28,2005 .Pli ifatc sa
mi a
S. s.
S 5517 8- W D. . ul
) antf ta he

d c me t nildt srce Fe dn DitLo fRe ie'h tsae ,i z c ditla c n ans
o u n e tt t titd e ig e a cp 't a tts dEq h e o f o ti
e Re
la
1 0caore ,f at alof25 caore pe da ' (
25 l is or ot
00 l is r y.' ComplEx.C. anifalge t tt
.
)Plitf le s ha he
VDOC r m ovedt m e tco e fom t DitLoa i 2006 a di notr pl e i wih a he
e
he a nt nt r he e
fn
nd d
e a e t t not r
pr t i s ce
o e n our .
Li Shea ,a nur e a t V D OC D i tc a pr de t f l ng a nne st
nda
r
s nd he
e i i n, ovi d he olowi ve nt o

s p o th d fn a t'mo inf rs mmayj d me t Th VDOC' r g lrme up o i e a
u p r t e e e d n s to o u r u g n . e
S e ua n rvd s
daiyc orci akeof2700- c ores ( a Af.!6. TheVDOC rc ntytse t Dit
l al i nt
2800 al i . She r f )
e e l etd he e
Loafa f
nd ound t tt daiy c orci a fom Di Loaf exc ed t r quie nt ofVDOC
ha he l al i nt ke r
et
s e he e r me s

Fo dS r ie Ma ua b ofeig30 c lre pe d y td !7. TheDitLo fc nans
o e vc s n l y frn 20 ao is r a . L= )
e a o ti
t m pl pr t n' f om ki
s e o ei ' r
a
dney bea ,dr m ik,a e ,a m e tw asr m oved f om t Di t
ns y l nd ggs nd a
e
r he e

Loa t a co
f o c mmodaeve t a .(d AsofFe ay2011 J o wa 5' 't land
t gemi ns L=)
bnlr
, ohns n s 9' al
weghe 1 pounds ç ch i aheat we g f hi heghtba e on t Na i l tt eof
i d 80
,s
whi s
lhy i ht or s i
sd
he tonal nsiut

He lhb d ma side c a t'(d. 8)
at o y s n x h r. l ! .
'
Re O ni sD iec orofN ur i a s a r t tpl ntf w e g d 1 pounds i Fe ua y
d
on' r t
sng l o ve s ha ai i f i he 80
n br r
20 ll a he ' e e ofhi m e v r v d be w e n A prl%,201 a Am i 1 20l1, d not
nd tr vi w
s di al e or t e
i
0, nd
l 2,
di
r ve lû ny c pl n s a uthunge ,f po s ni oro he f r l t i s s i t pa t
e a 6
a om ai t bo
r ood i o ng
t r ood e a ed s ue n he s

ye . ( ppsAf. 4- )NurePhi smial rporst tpli ifûsnotundeweghtor
ar' Phi
'
f!! 5.
s pps i lry e t ha antf û
i
r i

mano ihed. (d. 5. Fi ly,J me W a t Re Oni FoodOpe ai Diet , ve s
l urs ' l ! ) nal a s de,he d on
'
rtons r cor a r
t tal f a Red O ni i l ng t Di tLoaf i pr pa e i a or nc w ih t V D OC
ha l ood t
on, nc udi he e
, s e r d n cc da e t he
m a t rm e e ua e quare l pr ec ed f om c a i ton, i pec ed f
se
nu, val t d
tr y, ot t r
ont m na i and ns t or
w hol s e s al i edi nts tt i a e a o d i ac or nc w ih t Fo Se v c
e om nes ; l ngr e ubs iutons r ppr ve n c da e t he od r i e

M a .( a Af. !4- 2.
nual W de f ! 1 )
Pl i if s c a m t tt m e i i qua e t hi ne l cksm e i,bot a m a t rof
a ntf ' l i ha he nu s nade t o s eds a
r t h s te

1w a i lghtoft r l va f c si t sca e. Pli ifshe t we g de onsr t t the
a nd n i
he e e nt a t n hi s
antf
alhy i ht m taes ha

i no i a wa undeno ihe SeeHe ron,s a,a *15( i t tt pli iffie t
s t n ny y
r urs d.
ndes upr t notng ha he antf ald o

p o i eS n me ia e i e c t s b tn it acam ta h e ein e a ysg i c n ij l
r v d ç y d c l v d n e o u sa tae li h t e xp re c d n int a t nuy
a
i
ort thel tweght') TheDitLoa i a a e abl core tve, nol c r pons t
ha os i . .
'
e f s n cc pt e rci pe ogial es e o
t r a st i ae dicplneori tt i s c iy.W a ave st ti a e de toye bewe
h e t o nm t s i i
nsiutonal e urt
de r ha nm t s sr d t en

5 a 1 f ta awe k,c tngRe Oni $3. pe ta W adeAf.a ! 1 ) I i
0 nd 00 ood rys e osi d on 00 r r y.(
f t 5. t s
c ra nl r as bl t s l i eswho i e i naly de toy t rta wih ta madeof
e ti y e ona e o e' mnat
ve
nt nto l sr hei r ys t r ys

mo ersle t b rp ae r o c a e Sy o o m.F rhemo e j g e , lsi p e e fo
r e iin nlbe ltwa e r he p r tr f a u t r r ,a g d p atc ic s r m
br ke t a a e a c e rt ea t i tt i ls c i' be a e ofi a es pr pe iy t m a
o n r ys r l a hr t o ns iutona e urt c us
y
nm t ' o ns t o ke

s nksfom s r o pl tc.Furhe m o e, antf r eved ar ti t d f di s he e
ha
r ha ds f asi
t r r pli if ec i
esrc e ee ng c dul
s ty a t rhe r c ved t ee s pa a e d s plna y vi a i nsf t e t ni t s a a
hor l fe
e ei
hr e r t i ci i r ol t o or hr a e ng o t b

co r ona ofie wih a pi eofsee t the ca medwass crt d i hi ce la r f i t
redi l fc r t
ee
t l ha
li
e e e n s l nd e usng o

rt r hsta a dc pt VDOC p ro n l fe b igdr dl o d rdt d s ( yAf. ! 1 eu n i ry n u o
e s n e a tr en ie y r ee o o o. Ra f ! 4
1 ) Gi nt s cic tnce ,pl ntf splc ntonr srde f di wiht DitLoaf
6. ve he e rumsa s ai if a eme
eti d ee ng t he e
w asr onabl and r i l r at t l tm at penol cali eres s.
eas
e
atonaly el ed o egii e
ogi nt t
A1 V D OC f ltesf l t M as erM enu and adher t t portonsi cat on t
1
aciii olow he
t
e o he
i
ndi ed
he

me u.( he rAf. 4. Th pln n a dp e a ain o alme l tk sit c n ieainf o
n S a f ! ) e a nig n rp rto f l as a e n o o sd rto o d
ta , e ur ,t m pe a ur a
l vor t xt e e r t e, ppea a ,a pal t biiy,a t s m e f s r d t of e r
r nce nd a a lt nd he a
ood e ve o f nde s

i as s r dt saf.(d. Pori aesr edi t equantte asi caedont M ase
s lo eve o t f l ) tons r e v n hos
iis ndi t
he tr
M e (d Pori c r i us di me plnni pr paai a s r c i o de t prve
nu. L=) ton ontol s e n al n ng, e rton, nd evie n r r o e nt

e esi plt wasea lfovesa i e oce f bohsaf a ofe r.(d The
xc sve ae t nd e t r nd s nf r d or t t f nd fndes L=)
VDOC me a ea l d a c rii t me ore e t Rec
nus r nayze nd e tfed o et xce d he omm e
nded Di tr
ea y
Alowa esasde i d by t Foodand Nutii Boa d oft Natona Aca my ofSce e .
l nc
fne
he
rton
r
he i l de
inc s

td !6. Thea a daiycaorec mtf t e me sfo t M atrM e a r es2700t
L. )
.
a
verge l l i ot or hre al r m he se nu veag
o
28 caores (d.
00 l i . I )
Pl ntf ge r l cl m s t tt m e pl ns de i d by D e e ntShea a
ai i f ne aly ai ha he nu a
s gne
f nda
r nd

i plm e e by t VDOC t ovi f onl t mi mum dal nutii ne ofs de a y
m e nt d he
s
pr de or y he ni
iy rtonal eds e nt r

t o l mo eaeya tv p ro (iji c lrec u ta di vi mi a d mi rl. ( mpl
o ny d rtl ci e e s n sc n ao i o n n n t ns n neas' Co .
a
'
2. Notbl pli iff ist algeo pr fra fc t s
) a y, antf al o le r ofe ny a t o uppor hi ale tont tt f d
t s lgai ha he oo

pr desi de t nutii
ovi na quae rton.See e. ,Ve yv.W yc 293F. 726,730( h Ci.200
, g. ne
he,
3d
4t r 2)
(e gni ngt tc t a enotr quiedt a ce a tuealgai t ta emeeyc us y,
rco zi ha ours r
e r o c pt s r le tons ha r rl oncl or
unwa r ed de tonsoff t unr s bl i e e e ,oral ga i t tcon r ditm at r
rant
duc i
ac , ea ona e nf r nc s
le tons ha
ta c te s

p o e l s b e tt j dca n tc o b e hii. P an ifcamst tteme ui mi mal
r p ry u j c o u iil oie r y x bt' litf li ha h n s ni ly
).
ade ua ef t i ae populton, tt i i wholy i de t Furher e, antf saes
q t or he nm t
a i no hat t s
l na qua e. t mor pl i if t t
t tt dal c l realo m e ti m i ma l i ufii n f hi bec us hee r iessx tm es
ha he iy a o i l t n s ni ly ns fc e t or m
a e
xe cs i i
pe we k.Howe r pl ntf se r es hed ei hi snglr e
ve , ai if xe ds c ul n s i e bunk ce li i am a mtm l nsde
xi l
s urt f c tt i w ihi hi pow e t c nt ol Pl i i fr c ni es1 m e 'a qua y f
ec iy a iiy s t n s
r o o r . a ntf e og z he nus de c or
pe e who exe ci e l s ofe
opl
r s e s t n.Pl ntf c n sm pl c ng hi e r i e r gi e t pe m i t
ai i f a i y ha e s xe c s e m n o r t he

menust pr det ne s a y lvelofs t na e.SeeOwe v. nse 635 F. 950,955
o ovi he ce s r e
use nc
ns Hi l y,
3d

(t Ci. 1 ( di t tapli ifsvol ayde sont no e doesnotsaea Ei t
7h r 201 ) hol ng ha antf' untr cii o t at
tt n ghh
Ame me cai .Ac or ngl pl ntf fist etbls t tt f s r iec tt es
nd nt l m) c di y, ai if al o sa ih ha he ood e vc onsiut
c ue and unus lpuni hm e .
r l
ua
s nt
11.
1

Fort f e ng r as ,t de e nt a e e il d t qua ii i m uniy. See Sa i r
he or goi e ons he f nda s r ntte o lfed m
t
uc e

v.Kaz,53 U. 1 ( )(ttngdee nt aee ildt quaii i
t 3 S. 94 2001 sai fnda s r ntte o lfed mmuniy iplitf
t f anif
f ist esa ih ac tttona deprvai .Ac or ngl Ide plitf smoi f rc a
al o tbls onsiui l i ton) c di y, ny anif
tons or e us l

ands nci a grntt dee nt'motonf s
a tons nd a he fnda s i or ummayj me .
r udg nt
The Cl r i di e t d t s nd c e oft s M em or ndum O pi on a t a om pa ng
e k s r c e o e opi s hi
a
ni nd he cc
nyi
Or rt pl i if a c
de o a ntf nd ouns lofr or f t def nda s
e
ec d or he e nt .

E E Ti
NT R:hs
l

dyo Spe e,0 1
a f etmbr2 1.
Se o U nied St t l t i tJ
n r t
a es sr c udge