Woods v. Federal Bureau of Prisons et al

Filing 81

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 03/22/2012. (kab)

CL S OFFI t- DI COURT
ERK'
CE JS ST.
ATROANI .
U VA
FI
LED

I TIE UM TED STATESDI CT COURT
N I
STRI

MA 212
0

V(R THE WES
)
TERN DI TRI OFVI NI
S CT
RGI A

R
OANOW DI SON
VII

ARTHUR LEE W O ODS,

BZ E'
(
)

cu
u

'

CASE NO .7: 0CV00420
1

Pl ntif
ai f ,

M EM O M N D UM O PI O N
NI
VS.

UNI
TED S
TATES OF AM ERI c K ,
CA,

By: G l n E .Conr
e
ad
ChifUnie St esDit i tJudge
e
t d at
src

Def
endant
s.

Arhur Le W oo , a f de a nmae pr ee ng pr K, tl t s cvi rgh s a ton
t
e
ds
e r li t oc di
o
led hi i l i t c i
.

purua t Bi ns v.Si Unkno Name Age sofFed.Bur a ofNa c i ,403 U. 388
s nt o ve
x
wn
d
nt
eu
r otcs
S.

( 9 )a dt Fe ea To t amsAc (TTCA'.W o d alg sta fd r l rs n of asa
1 71 n he d r l r Cli
t;
'
) o s le e h t e e a p io fkil t
t Unie Stt Pe tntay LeeCo t (< Le ' vi ae hi co tt i lrght whie
he td aes nie ir
uny 4
USP e' oltd s nsiutona i s l
)
he w as i a c r t d t r f r s r lm on hs i 2009. The c tha r vi w e t r or a
nc r e a e he e o eve a
t n
our s e e d he ec d nd

gr nt de e nt'dipostvemoto
a s f nda s s ii
i n.
1 Bac ound
.
kgr

W oods i ta s
' niil ubmison t t c ta ve i at i h,hr e rngbi r c ani
s i o he our ni d n wo-nc t e -i
nde , ont i ng
aç ompli 'a amuliu ofphot copid doc
l
c
ant' nd
tt de
o e
umen s
t .Thehe ng oft i ta c
adi
he niil ompl nt
ai

sae W oods i e i t brngacvirg saci t rBie . U. C.j 1 1 1
ttd
'ntnton o i i l iht ton mde v ns 28 S.
33 , 343,
1 , a 1 6 a t FTCA, nd lsedasE f nda s' e o i i dua USP Lee
985 nd 98 nd he
a it
ç e nt'num r us nd vi l
de

o fe r ,heFe ea Bm e u o Prs ns(BOP', n t BOP a mi itao s Th c u tie
f es t d r l a f io ( ' a d wo
: )
d nsrt r. e o r fld
t co pli co to ly,notte W oo t thi co pli tde c i i i nt , f ie t
he m a nt ndii nal
is d
ds ha s m a n s rbed nc de s but al d o
s a e wha c a m she w i he t brng, nd g an e W oo a opporuniy t f l a nm e
tt
t li
s d o i a r td
ds n
t t o ie n
nded

co ant Thec r advie W oodst t a ndedc mpli s d()sat ea hcli (
mpli .
ou t s d
hathe me
o ant houl a t e c am, b)

n met d fn a ts a ans who W o d wih dt b i t t li ()saefcs
n he ee d n t) g i t m o s s e o rng ha cam, c tt a t

c n e ngc n u te c d fn a t dtk ni v oaino hsrg t, n ( )p riulrz t
o c mi o d c a h ee d n ha a e n i lto f i ihs a d d a t aie he
c
fcsi s p o t fe c cam,n l dn d tsa de i e c o ij re .Th c u t loa vs d
a t n u p r o a h li icu ig ae n v d n e f n u is e o r as d ie
W oodst sa et s cii a tofneg i nceo whi he i e edt s t Unie Stt unde
o t t he pe fc c
lge
n ch ntnd o ue he t d a es
r

t FTCA a t s cfca tonsonwhihheba e hi camsun r42U. C.jj1 5and
he
nd he pe ii ci
c
s d s li
de
S.
98
1
986. Thec tas a s W oodst tt rBi ns hec d nots t Unie Stt s t
our lo dvied
ha mde ve , oul
ue he t d a e , he

BOP, rg o ps(i eC
o r u lk ' saf'
BOP tf )
.
W o d flda mne d d c mpan ( No . , )r iigcamsa u m io
o s ie n n e o li t ECF s 4 9 , asn li bo t s n
co tonsandexc svef c un rBi nsa amedialne i nc cli t rt FTCA.
ndii
es i or e de ve nd
c
glge e a m mde he
Li r ly co tu W oods ame d co pli al ge t f l ng g ou d c am s
be a l nsr ed,
' nde m ant le s he olowi r pe l i :
C l m 1: C r la U nus Puni hm e
ai
ue nd
ual
s
nt
1 . On Se e be 30,2009, e e an Tr es durng a r he i ofa
A
pt m r
D f nd t e , i
e arng
n
i de r por,t d W oodst thewoul ne rs e a(
nci nt e t ol
ha
d ve e t
DHO r por' a sa e tI
e t nd t t d, t
'
lf t noos on t teef ryoui s ty a t t si i n ,W o 'wie
e t he
e he r o
' horl fer hi ncde t ods f
'
r ceved20pho osby e alfo a unkno s ur ofC
e i
t
m i rm n
wn o ce û e a ga l .
noos s nd lows'
'

1 On Oc o r9,
B.
t be 2009, f nda W is t e tned W oods lf by
De e nt lon hr ae
' ie

saig i-q t al o elwy rs id n'wo kwi me y u'ea g o a
ttn ,trha j ih us a e ht o t r t - o r s o d s
g
h
de d. W oodswr e lte st Def nda sW hie La n,a O' i n a
a '
'
ot e tr o e nt
t , ppi nd Bre bouthi
s
f a t thi lf wa i da rfom saf atUSP Le
e r ha s ie s n nge r t f
e.
I On Ocobe 13 2009,De e ntW is t a1W oods'pr ry f r
C
t r ,
f nda
lon ook l
ope t o

no r s n E
ea o ;
.

1 On Oc ob 1 2009, oodsi e us d t cuf u f rW a de Te r
D.
t er 6,
W
ûf e o f p o
r
r n ry
O' in, t li O ' in t tvmi ussa fme be swe etyi t kilhi ;t e
Bre ' e lng Bre ha
'
o t f m r r r ng o l m hr e
hour ltr a as e edus o -or et n ,ld by Lt K. a tn,move W oods
s a e , n s mbl
e- ff c e m e
. M ri
d
t a t rc l whe eW oo r m ane i n bult r r tant f ove 24
o no he el, r
ds e i d n m a o y esr i s or r
hotr .
ls
1 On Oc obe 1 2009, trofk e sac us d W oo ofbr a ng a
E.
t r 9,
afe t r c e
ds
e ki
s i e he d,aus off r ta move W o ba k t t B- ngehol ng
prnklr a
e- -o ce e m
d ods c o he Ra
di
ce l whe e W oods r m a ne i r tai s f ove 3 hour .
l, r
e i d n esr nt or r 4
s
1 I Cl m s IC and 1G , W oodsc
n ai
ompl ned t ts a tng on Oct 9,2009,he had no acces t
ai ha t ri
ober
so
a phoneorvii i becauseher f ed t l hi cel. The cour s
suton,
e us o eave s l
t umm a iy dim isedt e as t
rl s s hes pec s
ofW oods'am e
nded compl nt pur uantt 28 U . .C.jl 5 b ( ) f rf iur t saeacam.(
ai , s
o
S
91 A( ) 1, o al e o tt li ECF

No.1 )
2.

1 On Oc obe 20,2009, he Re ona Die t Ki W hieviie USP
F.
t r
t n- gi l r cor m
t st d
Le andwal d t oug t s ci housnguni,i i W oods who was
e
ke hr h he pe al
i
t gnorng
,
bangi on hi c lwi
ng
s el ndow and s i t f a f my lf fom sa fi USP
houtng,t e r or
l
ie r tf n
Le Count '
e
yl'
1 On Oc o r27,2009, us off c t a plc W oodsi
G.
t be
a e- -or e e m a ed
n
a
mbult y r sr nt,a her m ane i r ta nt f r48 ho s
aor e tai s nd e i d n esr i s o
m .

1 .On Oc obe 1 2009,
H
t r 4,
Andy W olet r a e d W oods lf by usng a
f b e tne
' ie
i
ha ge t e.2
nd sur
Cl m 2: I
ai
nhum aneLi ng Co tons
vi
ndii
2A .On Oc obe 9,2009,De e ntLt M a tn l kedW oodsup i t Bt r
f nda
. ri oc
n he

r hol ngc l oft Spe i HousngUni (1 'wihouta r l ng
ange di el he cal i
t 1SHU' t
)
ny umi
wa e ort lta de i d W oo ofhygineie sa ade t f
t r oie nd prve
ds
e t m nd quae ood;
2B. o t c ndii nsi Cl i 2A,W oodsde l d a bl k fmguso
Fr m he o to n am
veope
ac t
n
hi rg t
s i ht oe.
C l m 3: Exce s veFor e
ai
si
c

3A. On Oc o r29,2009,a trofi e sr m o d W oodsfom a bult y
t be
fe tc r e ve
r m a or
r tai s unna e sa fm e be sas a t d W oods sa e hi t t foor
esr nt,
m d t f m r s ule
, l mm d m o he l ,
a plce hi bac i a bult r r ta n s whi h helt rr f e t t keof
nd a d m
k n m a o y esr i t , c
a e e us d o a
f
f f arofa he ata k.
or e
not r t c
3B.On Oc obe 30,2009,De e nt Stle a Shoema ra tc d
t r
f nda s ilr nd
ke ta ke
W oodsast tid t f c hi it awheec i;W oodsr us d t ge i a
hey re o or e m n o
lhar
ef e o t n nd

ç ed o t)t b to o t wh ec ar'
i l) nro he o tm fhe e lh i.
hg
'
3C.On Oc obe 30,2009, f nda Tr esa Ofi erTi on c m ei o
t r
De e nt e nd fc
pt a nt
W oods'c la a s ule W oods
el nd s a t d
.
Cl m 4: M e ca Ne i nc
ai
di l glge t
On A ug t9,200 a o m a e y 40 i a e a t c W oods i t
us
9, ppr xi t l
nm t s ta ked
n he
c
how hal kiki hi wih se lt d boot,be tnghi wih br m siks a
l, c ng m t t e oe
s a i m t oo tc , nd
punc ng a sa nghi ;sa fdi notdo ame c la s s e ofW oods
hi nd tbbi
m tf d
di a s esm nt
'

ij e a ga hi o ye dr .
nmis nd ve m nl ye ops

2 Thec t r vi sy dimis dCli I a ans Ard W of pu s nt oj 1 l A( ( ) f
our p e ou l s se am H g i t ty le rua t 9 5 b)l, or
f iu et saeacam.( No.1 )
alr o tt l i ECF
2.

( No 4 pp 18)Asrle i ti a t n( No 9 , o dss e se p n e n o v ro s
ECF . , . - .
eif n h s ci ECF . ) W o e k x u g me t f aiu
o
i i ntr pors r m o lofale m ii o ma i 9o hi Ce r lFie, ta f r a
ncde e t, e va
lged snf r ton m s nta l a r ns e , nd
m one a y da ag .
t r m es

Sce nigten n e c mpan u d r2 U.. j 1 5 b ( ) tec u t mmaiy
re n h me d d o li t n e 8 SC. 91 A( )1,h o r ml rl
dimi s d c ran de e
s s e e ti f ndant fo t aci whowe eno na
s r m he ton
r t medi t n nde c
n he me d ompli a
ant nd

d s se s mepo t n o tea n e c mp an , u s a t o2 U.. j 1 5 b ( ) fr
imisd o
ri s f h me d d o litp ru n t 8 SC. 91 A() 1,o
o
fiur t saeacain. ( N o.7,11 ) W oodspadt c t t ha t clr sofkemal
al e o tt l r 3 EcF
i he oss o ve he ek' t
i
.

notc ofwaverofs vieofsl
ie
i
er c
lmmonst t r ma ni de e nt a f l : Hare La n,
o he e i ng f nda s s olows
ly ppi

f me Die t oft Fe rlBur a ofPrs (%OP' ; m W hie f me Re ona Die tr
or r r cor he dea e u
ions t ' Ki
)
t, or r gi l r co
oft BOP;a cu r nta f me U SP Le ofk il Davi W is Ca a n;Te r Stle ,
he
nd r e nd or r
e t as
d lon, pti
r y ilr
Li t na ;Bran Shoe a r Core ona Ofs e ; ih M a tn,Li utnant Te Tr s
eu e nt i
m ke , r di l tc r Ket
ri e e ' d ee ,
,
Liut na ;a Te r O' in,W rde
e e nt nd ry Bre
n.
Thedef nda sha fl a mo i t dim isor i t at m a i ,moton f s m mar
e nt ve ied
ton o s s , n he le tve
i or u
y

j d me t S e i l , ee d n smo efrds s a o W o d 'F
u g n . p ct l d fn a t v o imis l f o s TCA cam f rlc o
ka y
li o a k f
j rs ito , o d s sa o o h rcamsb s do pan ifsfi r t pe ds fkin f cu l
u idcin f r imisl f t e li ae n litf' al e o la u t e t a ta
u
s p o ta frs mmayj d me ta t ter manigcams W o d ha r s nd dt
u p r, nd o u r u g n s o h e i n li . o s s epo e o
def nda s'motons
e nt
i .
l . M o i t D im i s f Lac ofJur s d i
I
t on o s s or
k
i di on

Fe ea Rueo Ci iPr c d r 1 ( )l al wsap ryt mo ef rd s sa o acam
d r l l f vl o e u e 2 b ( ) lo
a t o v o imis l f li
ba e u o ae u tslc o s be t te j rs ito Tod tr n is urs ito ûhe
s d p n o r' a k f u jc matr u id cin. eemi e t j idcin,t
t
d src c t a r ga dt pl di a m e ee de eon t is a ma c i re dt e
itit our m y e r he ea ngs s x vi nc
he s ue nd y onsde vi nc

o sdet pladi wiho c ri t pr ee ngt onef sl r j
uti he e ngs t ut onve tng he oc di o
or lmma y udgme . Vea c
nt' ls o
'
3 A compI ntf l by a i a echale ngt conductofan çof i rore pl
ai ied
n nm t
l ngi he
t fce
m oyeeofa

go r me t l ntt'ma beds se un erj l 5A( ( )i t c anti ûrv ou , ii or
ven n a e iy' y imis d d
9l b)1 f he ompli s s iol s mal ous
f
c
f l t s ae a cl m upon whih r i m a be gr nt '
ais o t t
ai
c elef y
a ed.'

4

v Go to l o , 0F.d3 2 3 8(t Ci. 0 4 .ûl epanifha t b e o p o i
. v' f nd n.37 3 9 , 9 4h r 2 0 ) l- li tf s he md n f r vng
-h
ta s b e t te J rs ito e it. a sv B. P r isCo.aDi . fS a d xl tr .
h t u j c matr' id ci n xss' n . F. e kn s v o tn e ne n
u
'Ev
Co ,1 6F.d6 2 6 7( t Ci. 9 9 .
p. 6 3 4 , 4 4h r 1 9 )
TheFTCA pr de t excusver m e f rco mon 1 neglge cli sa i t
ovi s he l i e dy o m
aw
i nce am gans

f rle o e a ngwihi t s opeoft i e o t 28U. C.jj26 268 Asa
edea mplye s di t n he c
her mplymen .
S.
71- 0.
pr e st t flng aci la ton a i tt Unie St t s t FTCA r r pl ntf t
er quiie o ii
vi c i gans he td a e ,he
equies ai if o
pr e hi e am t t a o it f r la nc tlough a ad i sr tvet tcli .
es nt s l i o he ppr prae ede a ge y lr
n m nita i or am

j26754 Unl spl ntf hase use t sc e-pe ik,a nitai r me pr e e
*. es ai if xha td hi as s cf dmi srtve e dy oc dur

b fr tln hi cv l cint e teF
e oe iig s ii a to md r h TCA,h dsrc c u t a noj rs ito t a j d c t
te itit o r h s u idcin o du iae
hi FTCA cam a mus dimisi.Pl e v. t Stts 900F. 41s 43( h Ci.1 .
s
li nd t s s t ylr Unied ae ,
2d 42- 4t r 990)
W oodsdoe notdiput defnda s s cii evi ncet thedi notfl a
s
s e e nt' pe fc de
ha
d
ie ny
a i sr tvet tc am t t BOP r ga di hi al gai nsofme c ne i ncei Cl i 4.
dm nita i or l i o he
e r ng s le to
dial glge
n am

Be a s W o d ddn t x u ta miitaier me isa rq ie u d rj2 5 a b f r h
c u e o s i o e ha s d n sr tv e de s e u rd n e 67 () e o e e
fl dt slw s t t co tg a t de e nt 'moton t dimi sW oods'FTCA cli f l k of
ie hi a ui, he ur r n s f nda s
i o s s
am or ac
J idito
' s c i n.
ur
1 1 M oton t D i m i sf Fa l e t St e a C l m
1.
i o s s or iur o at
ai
A. St
andards ofR evi w
e

Plitf scamsc n o s ni eamo int d s s u d rRue 1 b ( ) nls çh
an if li n n t u v
to o imis n e l 2()6 u e s i e
t
pl i ifpl dsf t c en t tal w st co t o dr w t r as bl i e e t tt
antf ea acual ont t ha lo he ur t a he e ona e nf r nce ha he
de e nti la e f t m ic
f nda s ibl or he s onduc a lge ' As r tv.I l 5 1 . 662,1 S.Ct 1
t le d. hc of qba , 56 75.
'
29
. 937,

1 ( 9) I a r si t s t e yoft pli ifsc antt co tmus viw t
949 200 . n dd e sng he ufkinc he antf ompli ,he ur t e he
fcsi t lg mos fvo a et t pli if butt dno ac e t g ai ifs lgal
a t n he iht t a r bl o he antf, c
nee t c pt he pl ntf ) e
concusonsdr wn fom t fct,a .. ne d notac e a tueunwa r nt d i e e es
l i
a r he a s nd . e
c pt s r
ra e nf r nc ,

u e s na l c n l so , rag me t. Ginua ov. o n o 5 F.d2 8 3 2( t Ci.
nra o be o cu ins o r u n s' a tn J h s n, 21 3 9 , 0 4h r
'
2008)(ntr lquottonsomit ) Thec tmus dimist compl nti idoesnotalge
i ena
ai
ted .
our t s s he
ai f t
le
K nough f c st sa eacli t r le t ti nlusbl on isf c ' Bel At. o. Twombl
t
e
a t o tt
am o ei f ha s a i e t a e. l l Cor v.
'
v,

5 0U.. 4 , 4 ( 0 7 (mp a i a d d .
5 S 5 4 5 7 2 0 ) e h ss d e )
Bec us W o fld t sa i pr K ,t c tmus hol hi pl di ç o l s
a e ods ie hi cton o
he our
t d s ea ngs û es
t
srnge sa r t n f malpladi d afe by lwye s' Hanesv. m e ,40 U . 51
ti nt tnda ds ha or
e ngs r td a r .' i
Ke r 4 S. 9,

5 ( 9 2 ;Go d nv Le k , 7 F. 1 4 ,1 51( t Ci. 9 8 .F fligti o iain
20 1 7 ) r o . e e 5 4 2d 1 7 1 4h r 1 7 ) ul l h s bl to ,
n
g
t c tal d W oodst a nd t sat hi c am smor cla l nn a oprat def nda s
he our lowe
o me o t e s l i
e e ry, me ppr i e e nt,
a pm i ulrz hi alegai nsi s ppo tofe c cam . On t o he ha t co tc nnot
nd
c a i e s l to n u r
a h li
he t r nd, he ur a
i no eac e rf lzei t pl a ng t al gef c sne s a yt sae a a tona ec am .
g r l a ailr n he e di o le a t ce s r o t t n c i bl l i

W elrv De at n o So il e v .9 F.d38 ( t Ci. 9 0 .û itit u g sha en
l . p rme t f ca S r s, 01 2 7 4h r 1 9 ) o src j d e v o
e
oblgai n t a ta c ms lorpa al a t pr â ltga t . Pllrv.For 5 U. 225,231
i to o c s ot e
r eg l o o t ii n s' ie
'
d, 42 S.

(0 4 .
20)
Unde Bi ns a i vi lm a brng ac vi s tagans a i vi lf de a ofi e f
r ve , n ndi dua y i
i l ui i t n ndi dua e r l fc r or
da a sse i fom t tofk e saci i vi ai n o pl i ifseo tt i lrght .
m ge t mm ng r ha t r' tons n olto f antf
nsiutona i s4

Tr l c v.r e , 7 F.d3 1 4 2( t Ci.2 01 ( g v ns la ii i p ro a '.Th ,
uo k F e h 2 5 3 9 , 0 4h r 0 ) tBie ) ibl y s e s n p) us
l
t
po tonsofac
ri
ompli t tdono a lgea tonsbya s ii i vi lof i i vi a i of
ant ha
t le c i
pecfc ndi dua scal n olton
pli ifsc tt i rght do no s sce l plad aplusbl Bi nscli a mus be
antf ' onsiutonal i s
t uf inty e
a i e ve
am nd
t
d s i s d. Be l 550 U . a 5
im s e
l,
S. t 47.

4 Te hni l , W o 'camsaieun e Ca lo v. e n, 6U. 1 ( 9 ) whihe e e
c caly ods li rs d r rs n Gre 44 S. 4 1 80 , c xtnd d
Bi t r
vens o ecogni an i i da agesacton agai tf der prson ofk i sf vi atonsoft Ei h
ze mpled m
i
ns e al i
t al or ol i
he ght

Ame me t Se Hol v. o t4 F.d28 28 ( hCi. 6 .A Bi nscam i a lg t a
nd n . e l Sc t, 34 3 7, 9 4t r 200 )
y
ve - li s nao ous o
cam u e 4 U. C. 1 3; on e e ty, a e1w i oli j 1 8 cai i a plc bei Bi ns
li nd r 2 S. j 98 c s qu n l c s a nv vng 9 3 l ms s p ia l n ve
a to .Se , g.Fame v. e na 51 U. 8 ,8 9-0 ( 9 )(e o niig Bie a to a
cins e e. , r r Br n n, 1 S. 25 3 4 1 94 r c g zn v ns cin s
c u e p r t j 1 a to a d ctn prc d n fom b htpe o c e t d cd Eiht Ame dme t
o ntr a t o 983 ci n n iig e e e t r ot y s f as s o e ie g h
n n
camsu rBi ns .
li nde ve )
-

6

-

-

B. C l m s f om t O r gi C om pl nt
ai r
he i nal
ai
W oods om it d f om hi n e d c pl i s ve ala l ga i r s d i t or g na
te r
s m nde om a nt e r le tons ai e n he i i l

c ant i udi t f l ng:()algai t tofi asa USP Tuc onfliid
ompli ,ncl ng he olowi a le tons ha fcil t
s asfe
i or ton i W oods cls i a i pa r k t tc us hi t be s ntt U SP Le wih
nf ma i n
' a ssc ton pe wor ha a ed m o e o
e t
a t rim a eW oodsha as a t i t n c usng W oodst f a f rhi lf whiea USP Le
no he n t
d s uled, n ur a i
o e r o s ie l t
e;

()alg to t a W o d ' e ta fl icu e ia c r t sae nst a h v a v rey
b le ains h t o s c n rl ie n ld s n c u ae ttme t h t a e d es l
afce W o d 's c rt ca st to ()alg to st t aiusd si l r c n ito smu t
fe td o s e u iy lsi in;c le ain ha v ro icpi y o vcin s
ka
na
bee
xpunge bec us t e de wa i ufk into ofii l de e W oodsc ran pr e a
d a e he vi nce s ns t e r fc a s ni d
e ti oc dur l

rg s ( al ai t tofki sta fre hi fom oneprs t a heri or rt
iht; d) leg tons ha t al rnserd m r
ion o not n de o

rtlaea an thm; e alg to so t pe iidvo ainso 4 U. C. j1 8 a d 1 6;
eait g i s i () le ain f ms cfe ilto f 2 S. j 9 5 n 98

a d ( alg to o rtlao yta se fo USPHa etnt USPAle wo di Se tmb r
n 9 l ains f eaitr r n fr r m
e
zl o
o
ln o n pe e
2010.

Thec tona flngor e wa ne W o t tt ma t s a lgatonsa to bl
ondii l ii
d r r d ods ha o ke he e le i
c i na e
cli sunderBi ns W oodsne de t na ei vi lf er lofi a sasde e nt a sae
am
ve ,
e d o m ndi dua ed a tcil
f nda s nd t t
f t c e ni wha e h i vi ua de e ntdi t vi l t W oods co tmtona rght.
acs onc r ng
t ac ndi d l f nda d o o a e
' nsi i l i s

Be a s W o d h sno pe d dfcsa o ttec re td fn a t i Cli () ( ) ()( ) a d
c u e o s a t la e a t b u h urn ee d n s n ams a, b , c,d , n
() t c t a st i moi t ds s a t t ecli .
e,he our grnt her ton o imis s o hes ams
Theco ta s dimis st s c am sa t t unnnme de enda s W oodshasnot
ur lo s s e he e l i s o he
d f nt.
t ke any se t dic rt na oft eunknown d e nt,addt m t hi mne d
a n
t ps o s ove he mes hes
ef nda s
he o s
nde
cam s o a co pls s r i o t m .Be us m or t n 1 da haspas e snceW oods
li , r c m ih e vce n he
ca e e ha 20 ys
sd i

tldhi c ant Rul 4( oft Fedea Rul ofCi lPr e er uie t c rqonis
ie s ompli , e m) he
rl es
vi oc dur eq <s he ou
t

ownmoton,t dimist cli agans t edee nswiho prj c W oodsfist
i o s s he ams i t hes fnda t t ut eudie.
al o
de ons r t good c e f rhi f l e t i ntf an s r e t s i vi l w ihi t tm e
m ta e
aus o s aiur o de iy d e v he e ndi dua s t n he i

alte u d r h nze Th r fr ,h c u t ld s s wi o t rj dc W o d ' ams()
lotd n e t e l. e eo e t e o r wil imis t u p eu ie o s Cli a,
h
( ) () ( ) a d()a ans t n wnidvd as p ru n t Ru e4 m)5
b , c, d , n e g i tmk o n iiu l, u s a to l ( .
I Cli ( a a n e ( No 4 3 , o d alg st a W ad nO' in
n am 9, s me d d ECF . - ) W o s l e h t r e Bre
e
rc
e omme
nded W oods ta f rgom USP Haz lo t USP Ale
' r ns e
et n o
lnwoodi r t iton f t s
n eala i or hi

5 Wo d ' l g to snteecamsas fit i l aea (c n tuin l poetdrg ts
o s al ain i h s li lo alo mpi t n o si t al rtce ih o
e
c
to y
ast s a ean actonabl Bi nscl m .A f der prs
o tt
i
e ve ai
e al ionerhasno cons lutonalrghtt specik
tt i
i o
t
pr
ocedur pr ectonswhe prs of ii sde e mi hi c t cl ssf i ordeci on atans e
al ot i
n ion fcal t r ne s usody a ikaton
de
r f r.

Ga t v. ylr 9 F.d34 3 ( h Ci.1 1 (idi t a imaeha n l ry itr s i c ng s
son Ta o , 46 2 0, 43 4t r 99 ) fn ng h t n t s o i t ne e t n ha e
be
t hi lc tons rainso d i r u ie c nge i c ndiinsofc nfn me t(ncu nga mi srtve
o s o ai va ito f al o tn , ha s n o to
y
o ie n i ldi d nitai
s grg to ,a dde a o prv lg , c us s h c a e aec n e ae wihi t s o of
e e a in) n nil f iie es be a e uc h ng s r o tmpltd t n he c pe
imae' orgna s ne c t p io ) l t as d no h vea y c nsiu in lrg tt b i ac rtd
n t s ii l e tn e o rs n . nmaes lo o t a n o tt to a ih o e nc r e ae
i a yp riua pio j i, rc nfne ntfclyo a ypatc lrsc iylve.Me c v. no
n n atc lr rsn,alo o i me a it f n riua eurt e l ahum Fa ,
i
4 U. 21 , 3- ( 97 .t sl ga tec ndton o d g e o c fn me tt whihteprs ne
27 S. 5 22 24 1 6) W on s h o ii s r e r e f on ie n o c h io r
i s j ce i wihi t s n e ei os du nhi a d i no o h r s vi ai o t Co tt ton
s ube td s t n he e tnc mp e po m n s t t e wie oltve f he nsiui ,
teDu Prc s Clus d sn ti islsbe t nimae'te t nt prsna hoiist u ca
h e o e s a e oe o n tef u jc a n t s rame by io ut rte ojdiil
o r ih . Mon a ev. yme , 7U. 23 2 ( 97 .
ve sg t'
' tny Ha s 42 S. 6, 42 1 6)
Unde t eprnci es,W oods'alegatonsofwr ulactonsorus ofi ur t i or aton
r hes i pl
l i
ongf
i
e nacc ae nf m i

i tec luaino hs u td lv lhsta se t apio o tiehs%e in'o hsta se t te
n h ac lt f ic so y e e, i rn fro rs n usd i s jo , r i rn fr o h
o
r
'
SHU w ih f
t ewerpr ry iem sa prviegessmpl ar no consiutonalls t t courtmay
ope t t
nd i l
i y e t
tt i
s ues hat he

aj c t u e Bie .Woo 'c cusr asrinso c ns rc a rtlainrltdt t s
dudiae nd r v ns
ds on l oy seto f o pia y nd eaito eae o hee
cl msar nots tci t brng hi cl st aton pr emsundert umbr l ofcons iutonal
ai
e
ufi ent o i s as ik i
obl
he
ela
tt i

p o e tonst tc nbevi iae tr ug aBi nscam.Se Ada v. c ,40F. 72 7 (t Ci.
r t ci ha a
ndc td h o h ve li
e ms Rie
3d , 4 4 h r
1 4)(i ngi t mus p e e tmor t n c n us r alg ton ofrt lai n) Br wnv. lne
99 fndi nmae t r s n e ha o cl o y le a i s eaito ; o
Angeo ,
9 F. pp. 40 3 ( . Va 1 )(i i t twh r alg tonsofc ns rc aemeey
38 Su 3 , 46 W D. . 996 fndng ha ee le ai
o piay r rl
c ncuor wi tfcss wi c mmo p r s t ij r pli ilc an ma b s
o ls y, t a t ho ng o n upoe o nue antfl omplit y e ummaiy
hou
rl
ds se )
imis d .
Exp nge n ofdicp i r c nvitons a W oo salg d i Cli ( )a i hi p a e fr
u me t s ilnay o ci , s d le e n am c nd n s r y r o
r i: i no a is ec nz bl u e Bie .Pr ie v. d iu z 41 U. 47 48 - ( 97
el s t n su og ia e nd r v ns esr Ro rg e , l S. 5, 7 88 1 3)
e
(idi ta p io e swh wa tt c le et i ds i i c n cins s ne e , a mi s tv
fn ng h t rs n r o n o halng her icpl
nmy o vito , e tnc s or d nikaie
a i whi r vokegood-i cr t mus pur s cl m by petton f a wrtofhabeascop us,
ctons ch e
tme edis t sue uch ai
ii or
i

r t rt a acvirg sa to ( v rue onohe g o dsbyHe kv. mph e 51 U. 47 48
ahe h n i l iht cin) o e r ld t r r un
c Hu r y, 2 S. 7, 2
( 9 4) l tec al ng ddicpl r c vito r s td i al so ean d g odtme W o sma s e
1 9 . f h h l e s i i y on cin e ul n os f r e o i , od y e k
e
na
e
t o rul t a c n cint r ug flngapeiinf rawrtofha e sc r usu e 2 U. C. 2 i
o ve t ' h t o vito h o h ii
n
tto o
i
b a o p nd r 8 S. j 241 n
t uidito wheeh i c nfne .Se Wiki o v. sn, 4U. 7 788 ( 05;l r Jne ,
hej rs cin r e s o i d e l nsn Doto 54 S. 4, -3 20 ) n e o s
22 F. 3 33 ( t Ci. 0 .A dicpi r c vci t tr s td i ape lyote t a l sof
6 3d 28, 2 4h r 20 0)
s ilnay on iton ha e ul n nat h r h n os
e
good tm eor narl doesnotgi rs t consiutonalpr ectonsa al,and i nota i
i
di iy
ve ie o
tt i
ot i t l
s
ctonabl i habeas
en

o Bi ns Olv rv.
r ve . ie Powel25 F. p 2d59 6 ( D. . 0 ( ii Sa di v. nn r 51
l, 0 Su p.
3, 05 E. Va 20 2) ctng n n Co e , 5
U. 47 ( 9 ) (ttngt a c sod a s c rt sau a g dtmee r n r ts b c us t ya e
S. 2 1 95 ) sai h t u t y nd e u iy tt s nd oo i anig ae , e a e he r
s j c t c a e d no i iaef d r l ep o e s .Smial W oo h snoa to bl
ub e t o h ng , o t mplc t e e a du r c s) i lry, ds a
cina e
consiutonalcl m bas on hi alegatonsofdf l e'di ci i y convi i
tt i
ai
ed
s l i
ta s ' s plnar
ctons. See,e. ,Fr
g. eeman v.
-

Ri o t 808F. 9 ,96 - 3( Ci.1 6 (G- a to tlngfledicpln r c r e do sno is l
de u ,
2d 49 2 6 2d r 98 ) tl c f ii a s s i iay ha g s e t tef
-he
volt aprs n rsc nsiu in lrg t.) Mc avv. wles No.10 CVl 0( TCB) 2 08W L
i ae io e ' o ttto a ih s'; clr Fo k ,
'
:7 08 LO/ , 0
3 26 ,* ( D. . 08 (idigi t h sn c nsiuina rg ta ans b i f ley a c s d o
99 37 4 E. Va 20 ) fn n nmae a o o tt to l ih g i t eng as l c u e f
c nd tt tma r s l i de iain o pr tce lb ry itr s)
o uc ha y e ut n prv to f oe td ie t ne e t.
8

l ws t whi h nn
a ui, c med O' i n a ade e nt6 W oodss
Bre s f nda .
ubmisac ofar ues f ta f r
t opy
eq t or r nse ,
sgne by O ' in on Augus 1 201 whih satd a pa toft ç tonae f Re e r l'
i d
Bre
t 7, 0, c t e s r he l i l or f r a '
Ra
:
Ac or ngt ame or ndum da e Aug t1 201 i t W oodsha c r nt
c di o
m a
td
us 7, 0, nma e
s ure
ltgai pe ng a i ta Exe utve sa fme be a USP Haz lon. Ba e on
ii ton ndi gans n c i tf m r t
et
sd

t fcsp e e td geern t lse sc rt c d sa sg e t W o d l imae
he a t r sn e rfrig o itd e u i o e sin d o o ssn t
y
W oo i no l nge a o i t f t ge r lpo ai a t si tt i Hi
ds s o r ppr prae or he ne a pulton t hi nsiuton. s
tanse i r se t e ur hecn
r f r s eque td o ns e
nnotma al ga i ofr t lai by t
ke le tons e a iton he
Exec tvesa fduet t pe ngltg ton.I i r c
ui tf
o he ndi ii a i t s e omm e
nded i t W oodsbe
nma e
ta f redt a a opraeHI s c iy lve i tt ton....
r nse r o ny ppr i t GH e urt e l nsiu i

( 4- pp.2- ) W oodsa srst tt slws tagans O' ini t r as O' inas d
ECF 4,
3.
se t ha hi a ui i t Bre s he e on Bre ke
f W oodst be s ntt USP Ale
or
o
e o
lnwood, hi rlvels urt f iiy, r W oodsha
a ghe e ec iy aclt whe e
d
ongoi toubl wih s a f
ng r e t t f.

Imae 'camso r tlainaeg neal te tdwihs piim b c u ete v r a t
n ts li f eaito r e rly rae t ke tcs e a s t q ey c
l
ofdicplneby prs ofii l i by de i ton ûeala or i t s ns t ti r s
si i
ion fc a s s
fnii r t it y' n he e e ha t e pondst
o

p io e mic n u t' Co i a v. o s 7 F.d 1 0 1 7(t Ci. 9 6 .To s c e do
rs n r so d c . cl n M ni, 3 3 31 , 31 4 h r 1 9 )
'
r
uce n
hi cai , i emus aleg f c ss fcen t de
s l m an nmat
t l e a t ufi i t o monsr et tt al ge r t la o y a t
tat ha he le d e a it r c
t st ke i r s et t exe c s ofa c nsiutonal pr ecedrgh ort tt a tis l
t a n n e pons o he r ie
wa
o tt i ly ot t i t ha he c te f

viltds c arg t' Ad msv Rie 40F.d7 7 (t Ci.1 9 .Th r a r p an ifmus
oae u h i h . a . c , 3 2, 5 4 h r 9 4) ee ûe , litf t
'

d mo srt ta h s fee s mea v rei a to a ta ij r ACLU o M d.n . .
e n tae h t e u frd o d e s mp c r cu lnu y.
f .lc v
W iomioCount M d.999F. 78 785(t Ci.1 ) Addii ly,a i t mus c
c c
v. ,
2d 0, 4h r 993 .
tonal n nmae t ome
f wadwih s ci e de t sa ihlng)t tb frt rt it ymotve,hec aned
or r t pe t vi nce d tbls i ha ut o he ealaor
k
e
i t ompli

o i ie t. . udn t v o c re . W o d v. mi 6 F.d 1 61 1 6 ( t Ci.1 9 )
f ncd n . wo l o ha e c u r d' o s S t 0 3 1 , 1 6 5h r 9 5 .
'
h,
The f c sW oo pr s nt do no s
at
ds e e s
t uppor ar a i ton c ai . Fis ,W oodsdi no fl
t et la i l m
rt
d t ie

t sl ui un i Se e r22, 0,a t O' in wr et tanse r omm e ton, td t
hi aws t tl pt mbe
201 fer Bre ot he r f r ec
nda i al he
de e nt r c i d t com pl nt a t e r i t i M a c 2011. M o e r t tans e r que t
f nda s e e ve he
ai , t he a les , n r h
r ove , he r f r e s
6 O ' in wasw a de ofU SP Le whe W oods'cli si t sacton ar e. W oodsl tUSP
Bre
r n
e
n
am n hi i
os
ef
Leef USP Hazelon on November3,2009,and s ve almont lt r O ' i be ewar a USP
or
t
e r
hs a e , Bren cam
den t
Hazelon.
t

e es e no i e t pu s W oodsf t lws theha ar a fl d,butr t rsa e a
xpr s d nt nt o nih
or he a ui
d le dy ie
a he t t d
desr t a d gi ng W oodsa r as t fl a tona lga cam s Ther que tdoe not
ie o voi vi
ny e on o ie ddii l e l li .
e s
s
de o taet tO' in ha a pe s nalmotveori e t r t laeagans W oodso r
m nsr t ha Bre d ny r o
i
ntnt o e ait
i t
ve
ltga i i Augus 201 Se ond,i ad ton t t me i n oft n- ndi ltga in,t
ii ton n
t 0. c
n dii o he nto
he pe ng ii to he
tanse r que tlse s r ls ci s ctrt c
r f r e s it d eve a pe fc e liy oncensasba e f W oods ta f rt ahi r
r
s s or
' r ns e o ghe
s urt f ciiy,i l ng anot t thi s c iy d i naton hadbee i
ec iy a lt ncudi
e ha s e urt esg i
nû
updatd t r tec a
e o el t

mio hit r o v oe c ( ti t els fv y a s, u t imaeW o d b igs n to e f r
n r so y f i ln e wi n h a t i e e rl d e o n t o s en a cin d o ,
h

a la tf t icd n rp rsf rAsa lwi o tS ro sij r whl a US Le i 2 0 .
t e s, oz n ie t e o t o s ut t u ei u n u y ie t P e n 0 95
r
h
'
( 4- p 2 3) T id teta frr q s idc tsta O' inhms l ddn tefcuae
ECF 4, p. - . h r ,h rnse e uet n iae h t Bre i ef i o fe t t
t ta f rordee m i t f c lt t whi h W oodswoul bedesgna e
he r nse
t r ne he a iiy o c
d
i t d.Be us W oodsf l
ca e
ais
t plad f cua c e fom whih t c tc n d a a r a o bl i e e et tr t la i f r
o e a t l ont nt r
c he our a r w e s na e nf r nc ha e a iton o

e r ieofa c tt i rghtwa t i f r'c us ofW oods ta f rt U SP Ale
xe c s
onsiutonal i
s he l o ' a e
but
' r ns e o
lnwood,
t s a lga i saeno a tona er t lai ca m .I l 1 S.Ct a 1
he e le tons t t
c i bl e a iton li gba, 29
. t 949. Acc di y,
or ngl
t c tg a t O ' i n' m o i n t d s i sast t sr t la i cl i .
he our r n s Br e s t o o i m s
o hi e a i ton a m
C. Unnam e D e e
d f ndant i t Am e d Com pl nt
s n he
nde
ai

l Cli 1 1 a 3A oft a nde c pli ,W oodsal ge t tunknown
n a ms E, G, nd
he me d om a nt
le s ha

o t r a US Le s be tdhm t a uao yr srit f rln p ro of i a du e
fke s t P e u j ce i o mb ltr e tan s o o g eids tme n s d
f c agans hi . Thecou te e sy wa ned W oodst thewoul ne d t unde t efors
or e i t m
r xpr s l r
ha
d e o
rake f t
i
mmedit l t dicove t namesofa a tona de enda sa a t m t hi ca msi t
a ey o s r he
ny ddii l f nt nd dd he o s li n he

ame co ai , t yc dnotbesr eda woul notbepatoft lws t ( No.
nded mpl ntor he oul
e v nd
d
r he a ui. ECF
7, 2- , No.11 p. 4.
p. 3.ECF
, 3- )Thee talowane W o t tt tmefra co ihi
our s r d ods ha he i o c mpts ng
s r c o hi de e nt w a lm ied.
e vi e n s f nda s s i t

10

Be us W oodsdoe no a lget ta oft c r tde e ant wasperonaly
ca e
s t le ha ny he uren f nd s
s l
i ve i t i i nt des rbe i Cl m s 1 1 a 3AsW oodsf l t saeany cai
nvol d n he ncde s c i d n ai E, G, nd
ais o t t
lm

unde Bs nsa i tt m . l ,1 S. .a 1
r vç - gans he gbal 29 Ct t 949. The e or t co tg a sde e nt'
r f e,he ur r nt f nda s
m o i t dim isa t t s c am s
ton o s s s o he e l i .
W oodshasnott ke a se t dic rt na soft eunknown defnda s a
a n ny tps o s ove he me
hes
e nt, dd
t m t hi a nded ca ms ora c
he o s me
li , c ompls s r c on t m ,a f ist de
ih e vie he nd al o monsr t g ca e
tae ood us

f hi fitr t do s wihi t tmeal tdunde Rul 4( . eor,t c t ldimis
or s alle o o t n he i lote
r e m) Therf e he our wil s s

wi o t rj d c W o ds camsa an t h s u k o id vd as( ams1 1 a d3 ,
t u p eu ie o ' li g i s t e e n n wn n i iu l Cli E, G, n A)
h
p rua t oRul 4 m)7
us n t e ( .
l . M oton f r Sum m ar Judgm e
V
i o
y
nt
A . St
andard ofR evi w
e

An a r o sz r u g n i a prp it wh nEh p e dn ,h ds o eya
wa d f t
mmayj d me t s p o rae e t e la igs te ic v r nd
t
dicl ur m ae il on fl,a a af viss t t r i no ge ne is a t a
s os e tra s ie nd ny sda t how hat he e s
nui s ue s o ny

maeil a ta dta temo a t se tte t j d me ta amatro lm ' Fe R. v.
tra fc n h th v n i n ild o u g n s te f a ' d. Ci P.
56() Fo apa t se de et r ieage neis ofmatra fcts f e t a d
c . r ry' vi nc o as
nui sue
eil a ufkint o voi

s mmayj d me ti mu t eç u ht t r ao a l j r c udr t av r itfrt en n
u r u g n,t s b t c ha a e s n b e u y o l el
s
ma e dc o h o movi pa t ' Andes v. bet Lobby.l ,477U. 242,248( 986) l ma ngt s
ng ry.
'
ron Li ry
nc.
S.
1 . n ki hi
dee mi ton,çhe c t sr uie t viw t f c sa dr w r as bl i e e esi alg
tr na i t our i eq r d o e he a t nd a e ona e nf r nc n i ht
t

mos fvorbl t t no
t a a e o he nmovi pat ' Sha v.Sto 1 F. 791 798(t Ci.1 .
ng ry. w
'
rud, 3 3d , 4h r 994)

7 Furher e, asdi cus ed i r def
t mor
s s nfa, endant uncont t e dencem akesi cl t tW oods
s'
esed vi
t ear ha
hasno cons iutonalcl m c
tt i
ai oncer ngt i de sa i s i Cl m s 1 1G,and 3A . W oods ow n
ni he nci nt t s ue n ai E,
'
behavi cr t ane f ofi al t usef ce, he f c a i w aspr tonalt t t eatofi r
or eaed
ed or fci s o
or t or e ppled
opori
o he hr
fce s

r s n bl p r ev dhi be virt po e a temi ma ij isW o ss f rdr te tt to fc r
ea o a y e c ie s ha o o s , nd h ni l nure od ufe e el c ha fies
appr it y t
opra el empe ed t f ce a i i agood f t efor t r t e or rand di notwant y us
r he or ppled n
aih f t o esor de
d
onl e

f c f rt p r s o h r ngW o .Se Hud onv. c ila 5 U. 1 8( 9 )
ore o he u po e f a mi
ods e s M M lin, 03 S. , 1 92 ,
11

A p rys e ig st r j d me t ast eiiil l d no s o n t a e c o a
a t e kn t
mmay u g n be r h nta b z e f h wig he bsn e f
r
ge neis o maera fc.Cel e Cor v. tet477U. 31 323( 98 .The t
nui sue f t il a t otx p. Cart,
S. 7,
1 6) n,he
btr n s fst t non ovi pa t t s t ts h a is does i f t e s .Se
lde hit o he m ng ry o how ha uc n s ue
, n ac , xit e

M as hiaElc.ndus Co. Ze t Ra oCor ,475U. 57 58 8 ( ) Deald
tus t e l . v. nih di p.
S. 4, 6-7 1986 . tie
f c ua a l ga i i a ve ii d, o > co ant ba ed o pe s lknowl dge, a be
a t l le tons n
rt e pr x mpli , s n r ona
e
m y
.
.

s f in t wi tndamo in frs mmayj d me t t s p o t afd vi c n ann a
u fce t o t a
hs
to o u r u g n wi u p ri fia t o tiig
h
ng
s
c nlcigv rin o t efcs W i imsv. it 9 2F.d8 0 8 3(t Ci. 9 ) Da sv
o titn e so f h a t. l a
l
Grf n, 5 2 2 , 2 4h r 1 91 ; vi .
i
Za rd ik 6 0F.d45 (t Ci.1 7 ) W h r ten n v n fist r s ndt d fnd ns
h a n c , 0 2 8 4h r 9 9 . e e h o mo a t al o epo o ee a t'
s ci e de c r c i c l or a lga i i t c
pe t vi nce ontaditng oncus y le tons n he ompli t s
k
ant o how age ne is
nui s ue

o maeil a to whc ar a o a l j r c ul fn i h sfv r h we e , ee d n sae
f tra f c n ih e s n be u y o d id n i a o , o v r d fn a t r
e tte t s mmayj d me t S ot Hars 5 0U. 3 2 38 ( 0 7 (ç h no p sn
n ild o u r u g n . c t v. ri, 5 S. 7 , 0 2 0 ) t e p o ig
W
pa te t lt dif r ntsore , ofwhih i blt nty c ta ced byt r or s t tno
ris el wo fe e t i s one
c s aa l on r di t
he ec d, o ha

ra o a l j r c ul b le ei ac u t h udn ta o t h t ri no t ef csf r r o e o
e s n be u y o d eiv t o r s o l o d p t a veso f h a t o pu p s s f
,
r l o amoin frs mmayj d me t'
ui n
ng
to o u r u g n .
).

De e d n smo frsl r j d me to W o d ' e ii camsu d rBi n .
fn a t ve o t
mmay u g n f o s rmanng li n e ve s
The as e t ha W oodsf l t e us a i sr tver me e a t a oft s c am s a
y sr t t
aied o xha t dm nitai e dis s o ny he e l i , nd
i t ale na i t thef ist pr en a ge neis ofma e i lf c i diput on whih
n he tr tve, ha
a l o es t ny nui s ue
t ra a t n s e
c
he c d s t tdef nda svi aedhi co tt tonalrgh sort tde e n sa e e ttedt
oul how ha e nt olt
s nsiu i
i t
ha f nda t r n il o
qualfe i t t
ii d mm miy.

12

B. Exhaus i ofA dm i s ra i Rem e e
ton
ni t tve
di s

An i m a emus e us d uc ad i sr tver m e esasa e a ia e't hi wih
n t
t xha t t h m nitai e di
s
r va lbl 'o m t

rs e tt tec n iin o whc h c mpan .4 U. C. 1 9 ea .Thse h usi n
e p c o h o dto s f ih e o lis 2 S. j 9 7 () i x a to
r quie e a i st t li aes t , t rt y i l ge r lc r um sa esorpa tculr
e r m nt pple o ç nm t uis whehe he nvo ve ne a ic t nc
al
ri a
e s ,.. whehe t y a lgee s i f r eors eot rwr 'a whe he ornott
piodes . t r he le xce sve o c
om he ongs' nd
t r
he
f r ofr le t i e s e i a ia e t oug e usi ofa i sr tver m e es
om
ei f he nmat e ks s va lbl hr h xha ton dm nita i e di .

Nusl v. tr 5 U. 51 5 (
se Pore , 34 S. 6, 24 2002)
.Morove ,j1 ( r r t ope e usi '
e r 997ea) equies t r xha ton.'
pr

W o d o dv Nc ,5 U. 8 , 4( 0 6 .Th t s : p io e mus c mp eet ea miitai
o f r . o 48 S. 1 9 2 0 ) a i,t rs n r t o lt h d n srtve
a
r viw pr es i ac or nc wih t a ia epr e a nze ,i l ng de i s asa
e e oc s n c da e t he pplc bl oc dur l ls nc udi
adlne ,
pr ondii t brngi s ti f de alc t' I at88.
ec ton o i ng ui n e r our. d.
'
A f de ali ae' fr tse t r pr rex usi i t pur uea i or a g i va
e r nm t s is tp owa d ope ha ton s o s n nf m l re nce
pr edtr ,a trwhi h hem us fl awrte f malc
oc le fe
c
t ie
itn or
ompl i on t pr pe f m a t
ant he o r or t he

i tt i llvelwihi 20da oft i i nt Se 28C. R.j 54 1 542.4.Hemus
nsiutona e
tn
ys he ncde . e
F. j 2.0, 1
t
t n a alwihi 20da ofa ad s dec son t t r gi llvel a t wihi 30 da
he ppe
tn
ys ny vere ii o he e ona e , nd hen t n
ys

oft r onalrs e,t t BurauofPrs 'OfkeofGe r Couns l(( '.Se 28
he egi e pons o he e
ions t
neal
e û
OGC' e
)
C. R.j542.5. Onl whe a i t ha fldhi cai a allvel oft sBOPgre nce
F.
1
y n n nmae s ie s l m t l e s hi
iva
pr ed eha he< xha td'a ia ermedi .L. Ani t sfimet e us i a
oc ur s d use ' valbl e es d
e
.
a nmae' al o xha t s n
a fr ai de e e,a t btr n i on t de e ntt pr t f itr t e us . Se J
fim tve f ns nd he lde s he f nda o ove he a lle o xha t e ones

v Bo k 5 9U..1 9 21 ( 0 7 .
. c, 4 S 9 , 6 2 0)
De e nt pr s ntev de et tW oodsf ie t e
f nda s e e
i nc ha
al d o xhaus a nita i r m e esast
t dmi sr tve e di
o
t p io c tonsa e es i f e dam sher ie i hi dam sunde Bi ns.A r viw
he rs n ondii nd xe sve or e i
as s n s i
r ve
e e
ofW oods a i sr tve r m e flng hit y i SEN TRY,t B OP' el c r c r c ds
' dm ni ta i e dy ii
s or n
he
s e t oni e or
s t m , ete t t tW oodshasfl d 1 ad i sr tve r m e r ques sw hie i BO P cus ody.
ys e r l c s ha
ie 01 m ni ta i e dy e
t
l n
t

13

( a 1 c .Ata h. ) Fr m M ac tr u hOco e 1 , 0 9 wh l a US Le , o d fld
W h De l tc D. o
,
rh h o g tb r 6 2 0 , ie t P e W o s ie
r m e r ue t abo dicplna y heai and s nc i , ope t hi c t cls ik ai n
e dy eq ss ut s i i r
rngs
a tons pr ry, s usody a st to
s or ,a t applcai n ofa ma ge e va i bl o hi c t y c a sfcai n. TheBOP
c e nd he
i to
na m nt ra e n s usod l s ii to
r or donoti cae, we ,ha W oodspr ry fld a i sr tver m e e abou t
ec ds
ndi t ho ver t t
ope l ie dm nita i e di s
t he
celc tons ve ba ha as me a t e t ,a s cii i t nc ofe s i f c t the
l ondii , r l r s nt nd hr a s nd pe fc nsa es xce sve or e ha
m s rsasc am si t a e d co ant
se t
l i n he m nde mpl i .
W oodsas e t i r s et t co tsc tona flng or rt the ha e
s red n e pons o he ur' ondii l ii
de ha
d xhause
td
ad i sr i r me e . I s
m nitatve e dis n uppor oft sas e to W o fl d doz nsofphot pid
t hi s ri n, ods ie
e
oco e
doc e s i udi dici i r hea i r pors muli eco e ofa nita i r dy
um nt, ncl ng s plna y rng e t, tpl pis dmi sr tve eme

f r o a p as( fe u n mb rda di o sbet mac wi ofcas rs o s s, n
o ms r p e l o tn n u ee n mp s il o th t fiil' e p n e) a d
h
nume o l tr t prs n ofi i san ot rf de ala hort tgur s s h asErcHol r
r us ete s o io fcal d he e r ut iy i e , uc
i
de ,

Unied St t Atom ey Ge r l M a oft greva esa a
t
aes t
ne a . ny he i nc nd ppeasi l d i t s e bis
l nc ude n he e xhi t
a es W oods'c e nsa
ddr s
onc r boutdicplna yr pors M a oft g iva ora
s i i r e t. ny he re nce ppea r pons
l es es
i c t t tt r m e ora alwa r t ne bec us W oodsf iedt f l pr dur he
ndi a e ha he e dy ppe
s e ur d a e
a l o olow oce e;
di nota tc aco o t i tt to lr med andr pons ;hetld t r m e outi t
d
ta h
py f he nsiu i na e y
es e
ie he e dy sde he
pr s rbedtm elm i; a tmpt d t r iem or t n oneis a a tm e; hes ntt r m e
e c i i i t he te e o a s
e ha
s ue t i or e he e dy
die ty t t r gi na ofk eort OGC wiho pr ry c
r c l o he e o l t
he
t ut ope l ompltngt r m e pr edtr a
ei he e dy oc te t
t i tt i No r s
he nsiuton.
ea onabl f c fnde co d fnd fo t smount i ofpa t tW oods
e a t i r ul i r m hi
an
per ha
ptr ue t pr s rbe r med pr edur ast ea h ofhi cai si t a e d c pli
ls d he e c i d e y oc es o c
s l m n he m nde om a nt
t oug ea h se oft r m e s hemei atm ey mn ra r quie f e usi
hr h c tp he e dy c
n i l nne s e r d or xha ton.
W oods' e po et t moton t dimism a no r f r nc t def nda s e usi n
r s ns o he i o s s kes e e e e o e nt ' xha to
de e e. l t f ce ofde e nt 's c fc e de e t tW oo f ie t m a pr rus of
f ns n he a
f nda s pe i vi nc ha
ds a l d o ke ope e
e ch l veloft r m ed m oce m e t pr s n hi Bi ns c a m st m i on of i i t be o e flng
a e
he e y
d s o e e t s ve l i o s
f c a s f r ii

14

t sa ton, oodscamo r l on hi prorc us y a s ri ofe usi a hi
hi c i W
r t ey
s i oncl or s e ton xha ton nd s
i oncl i e bi eole ton.The c tc l st tt r or t n asawhol c d not
nc usve xhi t lc i
our onc ude ha he ec d ake
e oul

pes deaf tfndert tW oodsc idwihj 1 97 () Sc t 550U. a 380.Thec t
rua ac i ha
omple t 9 ea . ot,
S. t
our

g a t d fn a t' t nf rs mmayj d me t n e j1 9 ea a t a1o t eBie cams
' ns ee d ns moi o u r u g n u d r 9 7 () s o 1 f h v ns li
r
o
i t n nde c
n he me d ompl nt
ai .
C . Ei ht Am e
g h
ndm e Cl m s
nt ai

Eve i W oodsc d de
nf
oul monsr t t thepr ry e use a i sr i r m e esas
tae ha
ope l xha td dm nitatve e di

t s meo al fhscamsu d rBie s d fn a t aee t ldt s mmayj dg n be a e
o o r 1 o i li n e v n , ee d n s r ni e o u r u me t c us
t
W oodsf l t esa ih a Ei ht Ame m e cli a i tt .
ais o t bls ny g h
nd nt am gans hem
Ve
rbalT hre s
at

Alegai t tofk i sve ba l a e ha a s d,ort e t ned a i t wih ha m d
l tons ha t al r ly bus d, r s e
hr a e
n nma e t r o
not wihoutmor ,sae a c tmtona cli . He l v.Le s 1 Fe App' 1 1
, t
e t t ny onsi i l am
nsee
wi, 53 d.
x 79, 79

(t Ci. 0 )(iigColn v. n y 6 3F.d 8 , 2 ( 0hCi. 9 9 .Pli tf sfa fr
4 h r 2 05 ctn lis Cu d , 0 2 25 8 7 1 t r 1 7 ) anif e r o
hi lf ,ca e by a ofk ilsve ba t e t çi no a a t li rnge e tofaconsiutona
s ie us d
n t a ' r l hr a ,ts t n c ua nfi m n
tt i l

rg t' Emmo sv. c u hi 8 4F.d3 , 5 - 4(t Ci. 9 9 .Tot ee tn p an if
ih .
'
n M La a l 7 2 51 3 35 6h r 1 8 )
n,
h x e t litf
a lge t tany d e ntt e t ne hi , f l t sa ef c sa tse t tde e an t k
le s ha
ef nda hr a e d m but ais o tt a t bou t ps ha f nd t oo

t c r outt t e t pli iff ist saea cai ofc tt i ldi nso .
o ary
he hr a , antf a l o t t l m
onsiutona me i ns'
Cl i I
am A

l Cli 1 W oodsale t De e ntTr sma a t e e ngcomm e t W oods
n am A,
lges hat f nda
ee de hr atni
nt o
a
boutçla ng t noos out' nd t tW oods wiet r fe r c v e a l c ur sofnoos ,
de vi he
e 'a ha
' f he ea tr e eied m i pit e
es
whih s r re t t CFBI' Tr essa est thes
c he epo td o he t .' e tt ha
pokewih W oodso Se e r30,2009,
t
n pt mbe
8 S

e , ..W ison v Mc l r2 4F d Ag ' 9 0 9 1(t Ci. 0 7 (e c ra
e eg, l
Kel , 5 e . px 6 , 6 4h r2 0 ) p r uim)
a
,

( pu ih d)(i ngalg tonta o l ru e r ca su whiea s utngpantf,wih tmo e
un bls e fndi le ai h t fke s d a ll lr l s a li li if tou r ,
f ie t saec gnz bl j1 3cam) Ca trv. o rs l 4F. 21 ,2l n. ( t Ci.1 9
ald o tt o ia e 98 li ; re M ri, 6 3d 5 9 3 4h r 9 9)
(çAltou Ca tralge t ti i d l tc r i ul dhe wihr cal pih t,s c u e a l
l lh gh re le s ha ndviua ofi es ns t r t a i e t es u h nd niby
l
e
depl abl and unpr es i behavi doesnotby is frs t t lvelofacons iutonalvi a i '
or e
of sonal
or
t el ie o he e
tt i
olton ).
.

1
5

i t pr s nc ofW oods ca ema e ,a
n he e e e
' s nag r bouta i i ntr po tW oodsr ceve a a he
n ncde e r
e i d t not r
i tt i Afe ar hea i Tr esuphe dt pr vi usy i
nsiuton. tr e rng, e
l he e o l mpos s ton. Tr esde es
ed anci
e
ni
maki a c me t W oodsa
ng ny om nt o
boutS
ç e 'ors nd ng a e lpi t est W oods wie
noos s' e i ny mai cur o
' f.
Taki t e de e i t lghtmos fvor et W oods Tr si entted t sl r
ng he vi nc n he i
t a abl o
, ee s il o lmma y

j d me t W o dsd e n t tt a yfcsc l ci Tr e t ten os e is n rd e W o d
u g n . o o s o sae n a t ome t
ng e s o h o e mal, o o s o s
sa ea co uc Tr st t r c nyi outt al ge t ea .Thus e n i W o c d
tt ny nd t ee ook owa d a ng
he le d hr t
, ve f ods oul
pr t Tr sm ad t co me sa t tt ca e W oodst f a f hi lf ,ne t rt
ove hat ee
e he m nt nd ha hey us d
o e r or s ie ihe he
co me nort f rde i W oodsofa c tmto l pr t c e rg . Tr si e ttedt
m nt
he ea prved
ny onsi i naly o e t d i ht ee s n il o

s mmayj d me ta t Cli 1
u r u g n s o am A.
( l l 11
T ain 1

W oodsal ge i Cl m I t tDef nda W is t e t d W oods lf by s yi
le s n ai B ha
e nt lon hr aene
' ie
a ng,

<h t al o s lwy rs i d n'wokwi me o 'ea g o a d a . W o d as cams
t a j ih u e a e ht o t r t -y u r s o d s e d' o s lo li
t
h
'
ta h t l oh r ( ht, p i , n O' in t a W is n st ra ma ehi f a f rhslf.
h t e od t e s W ie La p n a d Bre ) h t lo ' h e t d m e r o i ie
W is t n Ca an ofUSP Lee de est themad t sa e ntW oodsal gesort the
lon, he pt i
, ni ha
e he t t me
le
ha

oh r s t rae e t ham W o d .W is nsae ta a c p ano tefcly, sj bwa t
te wie h e tn d o r
o s lo tts h t s a ti f h a ii hi o s o
t
pr ec i a es
ot t nm t .

Eve i W oodsco dpr vet tW is ma t a lge ve balt ea ,W is i en ild
n f
ul o ha lon de he le d r hr t lon s tte

t sl r u me t etra ao e r g r ls o W o d ' e ru ra to t i, i n t
ol
mmayj dg n .Th h e t ln ,e ade s f o s fa f l e cin o t dd o
vi ae W oods c nsiutona rg s a W oodsf ist al get tW is n t a se t r
ol t
' o tt i l i ht , nd
a l o le ha lo ook ny tps owa d
a tng outt t ea . W oodsa s f ist de ons r t t tW hie,O ' i n,orLa n vi a e
ci
he hr t
l o a l o m ta e ha
t
Br e
ppi ol t d

hi e tt to lrght by f ii t r pond t r porsofW is n' al ge veba t e t See
s onsiu i na i s a lng o es
o e t
l o s le d r l br a .

Sha 1 F.d a 799(ors r io yla lt r rnge d nc s r iorkne s di ts
w, 3 3 t f upe vs r ibiiy,equii vie e upe vs
w ubor nae
weet ng di co tt tpos apeva i a l e ona ers ofc tt i lij f'
r û age n nduc ha ed r sve nd mras bl ik onsiutona nur
e
16

t whihtes p r io r s o d du r ao a l) Dee d n sa ee tte t s mmayj d me t
o c h u e vs r ep n e n e s n b y . fn a t r n i d o u r u g n
l
a t Cl m 1 .
s o ai B
2. A m bul or R e t ai sI i nt
at y s r nt nc de s

tgq lnne esaya wa oni lcinofpai ...c tttscue andunus l
t- he l c s r nd nt nfito
f
n
onsiue r l
ua

p n s me tf r id nb teEihhAme d n . Hu s nv. c l a , 0 U. 1 5( 9 2
u ih n o bd e y h g t
n me t' d o M Mil n 5 3 S. , 1 9 )
'
i
( u tngW hi e v Al r, 7 U. 31 31 ( 9 6 tl tee tn ta g rs nl n l
q oi
t v . bes 4 5 S. 2, 9 1 8 $. t- h xe t h t p io i g
l
'o
vi
c tonsa er srci a e n harh,t ar pa t t pe ly t tc i i lofe r pa
ondii
r e ti tve nd ve
s hey e r of he na t ha rm na f nde s y

f r h i o fn e a ans s cey' o e v Cha ma 4 2U. 3 7, 4 ( 9 ) Animae
o t er fe s s g i t o it.
'Rh d s . p n. 5 S. 3 3 7 1 81 . n t
p e e sa Ei t Ame e c am by s
r s nt n gh h
ndm nt l i
howi t tt de e ntprs ofk i lace wih
ng ha he f nda
ion t a td t
dei r t i fe e et as bsa i rs ofham -t thek w f t fom whi hhedr w a
lbe ae ndif r nc o u t ntal ik
r ha
ne ac s r
c
e n

i e e et ta s t nta rs ofha m exit d, tf l t tke û e ona em e s e 't
nf r nc ha ubsa il ik
r
se ye aied o a i as bl a ur s' o
r

alvaet rs F r rv. e n n 51 U. 8 5 8 5 3 ( 9 4 .Th imaep an ifmu t
le it he ik. ame Brn a , 1 S. 2 , 3 - 7 1 9 ) e n t litf s
a s sa ef c sde
lo tt a t monsr tngt tt c lng d c tonsc us d hi a s ro orsg fc nt
ta i ha he hale e ondii
a e m e i us i nii a

p sc l re to a iju 'S a k v S t, F.d 1 2 1 6( t Ci.1 9 )(mit
hy ia o moi n ln ly' h k a . mi 71 3 6 , 6 4h r 9 5 o ti
h
ng
i e na quottons.
ntr l ai )
I r pons t W oods c am sc
n es e o
' l i once i t us ofa
m ng he e mbul t y r tant andt aleg
aor esr i s
he l ed
us ofe e svef c de e nt pr s ntc pisofUSP Le i de r po t f Oc obe 16,19,
e xc s i or e, f nda s e e o e
e nci nt e rs or t r
27, 30, 09.Ambult y r sr i sc nss o ha uf sc me t d t lg s c esby a
and 20
aor e tant o it f ndc f ol c e o e ha kl

wa s c i wih a blc bo ov t c f . BOP r a i dei ambult y r sr i sa
it han, t
a k x er he ufs
egultons fne
a or e ta nt s
a ove s ta ha d r sr i e pm e tt tal wst i aet e t drnk,a t keca eof
ppr d of nd r e tant qui n ha lo he nm t o a , i nd a
r
ba i hum a ne dsw ihouts a fi e v nton. w oods a l t o a e c i t ntw ih t
sc
n e
t
t f nt r e i g
' lega i ns r ons s e
t he

9 seeBoP pr am st e ent5566.06,Us ofFor e and Applcaton ofRes nt ,p.l1,
ogr
atm
e
c
i i
kai s
avaia e a w wm bop.
lbl t
gov.

17

i i ntr pors a hedoe notc e tt r porsort def nt 'a sda t co e ni t
ne de e t, nd
s
ont s he e t he enda s f vis nc r ng he
i de s
nci nt .
Oct r 1 2009
obe 6,
On Oc obe 1 2009,a 1 5 p. .ofi e sr pe t dl or r W oodst c
t r 6,
t 2:2 m , fc r e a e y de ed
o ompl wih
y t
c fngpr duz sa ane s a ys e t
uf
oce e s ce s r tp owar m ovi W oodst a he c l. W ood r f e t
d
ng
o not r el
s e us d o
c pl a sa e t thewoul notc eou oft c lf a r s Una et gan W oods
om y nd tt d ha
d
om
t he el or ny ea on.
bl o i
'

volmt r c
t a y oope a i an ofk e or r t tW oo bepl e i n bult y r sr i t i t
r ton,
t r de ed ha
ds
ac d n m a or e ta n s n he
s embl t m oveW oods
ed o
ne c lbec us ofhi dir ptve be vi .0 A us o -or e tnm a s
w el a e
s su i
ha or1
e- f f c e
,
butwhe t st m a rve W oodss it vol a iy t t ha r tant a t beng
n hi ea ri d,
ubm ted unt rl o he nd esr i s nd o i

es ore t ane cela plce i n
c td o
w l nd a d n mbul t y r tait ,whe eher m aned f s ve a hour .
aor esr n s
r
e i or e r l
s11

Afe ofc r rla e W o d fo rsrit, dc l tf a s se h m a dn tdn ij re
tr fies ee s d o s r m etan s me ia saf s e sd i n o e o n u is
ori i ntt cr ul ton.
mpanne o ic ai
O c obe 1 2009
t r 9,

Ofk er r pore t tW oodsha br ke t s i e hea i hi cel Bec us oft s
t s e td ha
d o n he prnklr d n s l. a e hi
dir ptvebe or ofi r de de nmbult r r tai swer a opra e. W he aus - su i
havi , fce s ci d
a o y esr nt
e ppr it
n
e of
f r ta a rve W oodss itdt ha r sr i sa t beng es ore t t ne celand
o ce e m ri d,
ubm te o nd e tant nd o i
c td o he w l
pl c d i a
a e n mbul t y r tai s f r a pledt r sr n sa l1: 0a. . nd r ea ed W oods
aor esr nt .Ofke s p i he e tait t 1 m a el s

1 BOP po1cy gener l r quiesconf ont ton avoi
0
i
aly e r
r ai
dance asapr
ecurs t a us off c . The
or o ny e or e
r ng ofi on t s
anki
fcer he cene,aferconf rng wih am e alhealh pr es onaland ot rsa
t
eri
t
nt
t of si
he boutt
he
i at a t siuaton,a tmpt t avoi conf ont i by r oni w ih t i a e i a atemptt
nm e nd he t i te s o
d
r aton
eas ng t he nm t n n t
o
gai t i a e' vol ar cooper ton;i t al
n he nm t s unt y
a i f he temptf l,ofi rst n det mi i us off ce i
ais tce he
er ne f e or s

ne e s r 2 C. R.j5 2.
c s ay. 8 F.
5 23.
1 W oodsaleged i hi amended compl ntt def
1
l
n s
ai hat endant kepthi i r tai sf 24 hour
s
m n esr nt or
s
afert Oc ober l6,2009 i de .The i dentr tde endant oferi s
t he t
nci nt
nci
epor f
s f n uppor oft rm oton f
t hei
i or

s mma yj gme t ho v r i c tst a o fc r rla e W o dsfo a ult y r srit a 8:
u r ud n , we e ,ndiae h t fies ee s d o r m mb aor etan s t 00
p. .on Oct
m
ober l 2009,afers n hour i r tai s
6,
t eve
s n esr nt .

18

fom t r sr i so Oc obe 20,2009 a 1 0 p. .M e ca sa fas e s W oodsa not
r he e tant n t r
t 0:0 m
di l t f s s ed
nd ed

n ij re a dn c mplit fo W o d a a ytmedzigt er sr it ro .
o nu is n o o an s r m o s t n i l n h e tan peid
r
O ct
ober 27,2009

W oodsr f s d hi ni h c ns c i m e lo Oc o r27,20 ti rng ar quie nt
e u e s nt o e utve a n t be
09,rgge i
e r me
unde BOP r gultonsf He t Se vce t e l t hi t de e mi whehe f ce f ed ng
r
e a i or a1h r i s o vauae m o tr ne t r or d-e i
woul bene s a yt s t i hi . W he ofie sca et es or W oodst He lh Se vc ,
d
ce s r o usan m
n fc r m o c t
o at r ies he
rf e t c
e us d o ome o ofhi c l. W oodsf l t c
ut
s el
aied o ompl wih r peaed o de st s i t
y t e t r r o ubm t o
r s nt s he c d bem ove fo t cela evaua e by me c lsa f Duet t s
e kai s o
oul
d r m he l nd l t d
di a t f
o hi
dinz i be vi r a ofi e or e e t tW oodsbepl c d i n bult y r tai sa
s ptve ha o , n tc r d r d ha
a e n m a or esr nt nd
a s mbl d aus - -or et n . W oodst n c m ple wih ofi e s or r a ne s a yt be
se e
e off c e m
he o i d t fc r ' de s s ce s r o
e c td t ahol ng c l,media l a s s d,a pl e i a bult r r sr i s W oods
s ore o
di e l
c ly s es e nd ac d n m a o y e tant .
r m ane i t er tai sfom 1 5 p. . i 8: p. . Ocobe 29, 9,at alof55
e i d n hes esr nt r
2:2 m untl 30 m on t r 200
ot
hour .Durng t splc nt m e ca sa fnotd t tW oodsha mi a asonson bot
s
i hi a eme , di l tf e ha
d nor br i
h
wrssa 1 00 am . Oc obe 29. Slf cea d t a r sonsa a i d ba ge . W oods
it t 0: . on t r
f l ne he b a i
nd pple nda s

d e no me to t s a rso so a ohe ij e i hssae n o t scam.
o s t n in he e b a in r ny t r nmis n i ttme t f hi li
A m bul t y Re t ai s Anal i
a or
s r nt
ys s

W o a r nty bele st tal ngt pe i i a
ods ppa e l ive ha e hy rod n mbult y r sr nt a om a ia l
a or e tai s ut tc ly
co tt e cr la ut s pt ihm e . Be us t pr s e r e i a da r one
ns iut s ue nd m ual m s nt ca e he i on nvionm nt s
nge ous

f c r di na ofk e s ho ve ,c rsm us a co d prs a nita o st dtr ngng
or ore o l t r , we r ou t
t c r ion dmi sr t r ç -a i
wi

de e enc 't de i a i e e polcesa r taitmea ur t tt y be ivea e
f r e' o sgn nd mplm nt i i nd esr n
s es ha he le r

n c say frt p e e v to o o d ra ds c rt b sdo terp o e so a j d me ta d
e e sr o he rs r ain f r e n e u i a e n h i r f sin lu g n n
y,
e re e.W hil y,475U . a 3 - Thi c t she dt tt us ofa
xpe inc
te
S. t 21 22. s our ha l ha he e mbult y
a or
r sr i s e n f r l ngt pe i sm ia t wha W oodse re d,doe notco tt e c u
e t a nt , ve o e hy r ods i l r o
t
xpe i nce
s
ns iut r el

19

a dt s l o iinswh nt eimaes fe sn sg i n p ysc lo e to a ij r a a
n mu ua c ndt
o
e h n t u fr o in t t h ia r moin l nu y s
ka
r s t Hole v.J on,Ca eNo.7:
e ul. lv ohns
s
08CV00629,201 W L 2640328,*1 ( . Va. une30,
0
3 W D. J

201 .
0)
On Ocobe 1 1 a 27, 9, oo 'o dir tve a r s sa be vi c e t d a
t r 6, 9, nd 200 W ds wn sup i nd e itnt ha or r a e
ne d f ofk e st tkes m ea ton t r t r o de a dici i W oods uli t
e or t r o a o
c i o eso e r r nd s plne.
' tma e
compla e wih r sr ntpr e esf esale t n d f of r t a y a f ceot r
inc t e tai oc dur or t ld he ee or fce s o ppl ny or he
t nt a
ha he mbul t y r tant t m s ve . Thel h pe i i r sr i sma havec us
aor esr i s he el s
engty rods n e tant y
a ed
W oodss edic or,a a tmes r s t i mi a asons N e rhees ,t
om
s omf t nd t i , e uled n nor br i . ve t l s he

t o e t e de esmpl doe nots
mc nt sed vi nc i y s
uppor ar as bl i e e et ta oft defnd s
t e ona e nf r nc ha ny he e ant
i ve i a yi orm ant ni W oods a
nvol d n ppl ng
i ai ng
' mbult y r sr i skne t tt e de ce pos
a or e tant
w ha hes vi s ed
a sgnii ntrs ofhn m t W oods asr quiedt s
i tca ik
r o
, e r o how dei r t i fe e eunde Fa me ,
lbe ae ndif r nc
r r r
511U. a 8 37. W oodsa s doe no al get tt a bult r r sr i pe i he s r e
S. t 35lo s t le ha he m a o y e tant rods e v d

a US Le c u e hm as ro so sg i n p y ia o e to a ij r ' S n k , F.da
t P e a s d i eiu r in t t h sc l r moin ln uy. h k a 71 3 t
ka
'
1 Be us W oodst f ist esabls t e e t o a Ei h Amendme c tons
66. ca e
hus al o t ih he l men s f n ght
nt ondii
2
a
cam, t ed fnd n saee t ldt sl r j dg n ast Cli sID ,IE, nd 2A
li 1 h ee a t r ni e o l
t
mmay u me t o am

.

D ee
f ndantW hi e
t

l Cl i 1 W oodsa lge t ton Oc obe 20,
n am F,
le s ha
t r 2009, l W oodswasi a
whie
n mbult r
ao y
r sr i safe t s i e i i nt Def n W hiec m et ough t s c i oft prs n.
e tant tr he prnklr ncde , enda t t a hr
hat e ton he io

W oodsa s rst thes edt he ,C f a f my lf fo s fi USP Co y, bu
s e t ha
hout o r 4 e r or
I
ie r m uf n
unt ' t
'
c pli ,ç hiei e my pl af hep.
om a ns tW t gnor d
e or l '
'

1 W oodsdoesnoti udet e a
2
ncl hes mbult y r tai scl m sundert tExces i For '
a or esr nt ai
he û
sve ce'
s
ubhea ng i hi am e
di n s nded c pl nt Even i he i ended t alege t us ofam bult y r tai si
om ai .
f nt
o l hat e
a or esr nt n

t e ei tn e wa u o ttto a,e e svef r e d fnd n saee tte t s
h s nsa c s s nc nsiu in l xc si o c , e e a t r nild o umma yj me a t
r udg nt s o
a ys hcams Se Holy,2 0W L 26 03 a *1 (idi t tus o a ultr r sr it wi
n uc li . e le 01
4 28 t 4 fn ng ha e f mb ao y e tan s t
h
o ymi rr s tngij re f t d ysSsn taus o f reta o fndsc tmp a ysa dadso
nl no e uli n u is or wo a t o e f o c h t fe one orr tn r f
i
d c n ys a t stsyt obetv c mp ne tofa e c si frecai '.
e e c o s o aif he jcie o o n n x esve oc l m'
)
20

W oodsa z nty bei vesW hies dha known f o s i W oodsi r sr i s
ppa e l le
t houl ve
r m eeng
n e tant
a he ng hi sa e f a st tUSP ofi e swe evi ai W oodsc tm to lrg s ye ,a
nd mi
s t t d e r ha
fc r r oltng
onsi i na i ht ; t s
as r ior ofi il W hief ie t pr ve f rhe vi a i . Gi nt e tsfndi t t
upe v s y fca , t al d o e nt u t r oltons ve he our' i ng ha
m ant i ng W oodsi ambult yr sr i son Ocobe 20,2009 di no ,n f c , olt hi
i ani
n
a or e tant
t r
d t i a t vi a e s
c tmtonalrght,W oodsf ist de
onsi i
i s
a l o monsr t a Ei h Ame m e c am a ns W hiei
ta e ny ght
nd nt l i gai t t n
he s r ior r ef rf ii t or rhi r mova fom r sr i s Se Sha 1 F. a 799
r upe v s y ol o alng o de s e
l r e tant . e w, 3 3d t

Dee d n W ht i e tte t s mmayj d me ta t Cli 1
fn a t ie s n i d o u r u g n s o am F.
l
3. I
nhum ane C e lC o tons
l ndi i

I Cli 2A, oodscompli t ton Oco r9,2009, f nda M a tn pl c d W oods
n am
W
ans ha
t be
De e nt ri a e
i acelwih not l tornmni wae ;am ates we wih trnet tofs e sr pl c d wihi a
n
l t
oie
ng tr
tr s t t li ha fc r e a e t n
f w ho s o y bo rs rs s ksa at es r t we r t mpert ess c d a ni W oods
e
ur ; nl xe ho t, oc nd e hit o a ; e
aur o ol t ght
woul c y;a f s
d r nd or ome da ,no t hbr h ort hpase, no s p.W oodsus t one
ys
oot us
oot t and
oa
ed he

s e t r v d dt E o e fc s' ( nd Co . . W o d as alg st a Estf tmp r d
h e p o i e o t v r e e . Ame . mpl2) o s lo l e h ti qaf a ee
c
'
e
l
wihmyme l (pit gi myf o a dgv n meh l p rin .. (d. t ) Cli 2 a srs
t
as s ti n o d n ii g
n
af o t sl' I a 3. am B se t
o '
t tlvi i t eco to c usdW oo t de o ( bl kfmguson g s rgh t 'fom
ha i ng n hes ndiins a e
ds o velp : ac t
a
hij i t oe' r
ha ngnos sdurngt spei (#a
vi
hoe i hi rod. J )
Ac or ngt BOP celas i
c di o
l sgnme r e dsdef nda ss
nt e or
e nt ubmi,o Oc obe 9,2009,
t n t r
ofi e splce W oodsi t B- ng hol ng c l whe ehesa duntlm ove t a t rc l
fc r a d
n he Ra e di el, r
t ye
i
d o no he el
on Ocobe 1 2009.Thi d yceldoesnotha at ltorr mi waer bu durngt bref
t r 6,
s r l
ve oie
ur ng t , t i he i
pe i whe ofk e splcea i t i s h acel t i aeca a k f wae o atrnalo
rods n t r a n nma e n uc
l, he nm t n s or t r r zi r
be n asnee d.De e
dpa
de
f ndan M a tn doe no r calt i i n W oodsdes rbe , de e
t ri
s t e l he nc de t
c i s but ni s

t thewoul ha wlhhel cot ng,f od,
ha
d ve t d l hi o beddnp orhygi neie a W o aleg .
i
e t ms s ods l es

21

Eve i W oodsco dpr ve a1t c tonshe al ge ,hec tfndsno Ei h
nf
ul o 1 he ondii
le s t our i
ght
Ame m e vi a i he e. W oo doe no sae f css
nd nt olton r
ds s t t t a t howi t tlvi unde t s
ng ha i ng
r he e

c n iin framm i l o s v nd y c u e hm a ysg iia t h ia o e to a ij r
o dto s o
xmt f e e a s a s d i n infc n p ysc l r moin l nu y
m
a r q rdt me tteo j ci eee n o t cam.S a k , F.da 1 6.W o d c s
s e uie o e h b e tv lme t fhe li h k a 71 3 t 6
o s ho e
no t us t s tf hi own wa mt a doe no al gel i weghtfom eai l s whie
t o e he hee or s
r h nd s t le osng i r
tng e s l
i t ho di c l Fi ly,W oodso fr not ng mor t n s c a i i s ppor ofhi cli
n he l ng el. na l
f e s hi
e ha pe ulton n u
t
s am
t thavi no s sf rawee c us d t fm g a saesno f t s wi t sc ton t
ha
ng
hoe o
k a e oe t us nd t t
acs ho ng hi ondii o

b asg i n me ia p o lm. Co rsh v rj ce EihhAme d n camsf rlc o
e int t dc l r b e 1 u t a e ee td g t
ka
3
n me t li o a k f
sg i c n ij r fo l n c n i o sfrh rh rt nt s W o d alg ss f rn f ra
i nt a t n u y r m i g o dt n a a s e ha ho e o s le e ufeig o
i
vi
i

we ka USPLe . Th d fn a t aee t ldt s mmayj d me ta t Cli 2 a d2
e t
e1 e ee d n s r ni e o u r u g n s o ams A n B.
4
t
4. Exce sve For
si
ce

TheEi ht Am e
g h
ndme doe notpr hi tal a i a i off c ori lc i o pan
nt s
o bi l pplc ton or e ntiton f i

a ans p io r .UntdS ae v. r , 9 F.d4 9 49 (t Ci. 01 ) Co rcin l
g i t rs nes i tts Goe 5 2 3 8 , 4 4 h r 2 0 . re to a
e
o fcasmu td iyma t n pj d me t r g ri gt eteyr a tr asg t u r s p e e t
fiil s al ke t a u g n s e a dn h v r e lh e t t q n e t r sn s
s
ha
t i aesa prs ofi a salke,n addii n t t pos i ehn mst i t sa i twhom
o nm t nd ion fcil i i
to o he sbl r o nma e ga ns
1 w oodspr desa pi ur oft t f
3
ovi
ct e he oe ungusa amedi lr
nd
ca eques fl atUSP Haz t on
t ied
elon
Aprl8,201 aboutt t f
i
0
he oe ungusand abouthi ri f cr m pi durng exe cieshe lar i
s ght oot a ng i
rs
e ned n

t rpy.( No. 2, p.12.
he a ECF 4- p - )
1 Se , . , ver t v. Smi 1 F. 50 5 n. ( hCi. 99 ( t t tnmae '
4 e eg.Be a i
t 20 3d 0, 05 5 4t r 1 7) no i ha i t s
h,
ng
aleged confnementf sx m ont i hotcels i ese w ih ver n and s e ed wih urne and f ,
l
i
or i
hs n
l, nf t d t
mi
m ar
t i
eces
wih onl col f i s l pori ,a i r ntc ngesoflne di notsat Ei h Am e ent
t y d ood n maler tons nd nfeque ha
i n d
t e ght
ndm

cam wihnos wi t tc diins%eule i srou p ial e ina ij i '; riv.
li t ho ng ha on to ç s td n ei s hysc or moto lnures' Hars
r
)
Flmi ,8 9F. 1 2,1 33 3 ( t Ci.1 )( ovilto wh r i t n tgv n s p,oohp seor
e ng 3 2d 23 2 - 6 7h r 988 n oain e e nmae o ie oa t t a t
t t r h f tn d ysa n t ie p p rfrfved ys ; ha fe v.S ha No. - 51 20 W L
oohb us or e a nd o olt a e o i a ) Sc e fr c mp, 06 1 6, 08
25 47 a *56( . Pa J e25 20 )( li t a imaewa pa e i t r c l'f rtn d yswih
53 4, t - W D. . un , 08 cam h t n t s lc d n ' d el' o e a t
ha
no matr s no pil s no s p,no t ltpa ,a no nmni wat di notconsiut cr land
tes ,
low , oa
oie per nd
ng er d
tt e ue

u u lp ih nt; n v. p No. - 6 2 7W L 9 41 , t* ( . Pa. a . , 07
nus a un s me ) La e Cul, 05 57 , 00
5 01 a 5 W D. M r 28 20 )
( lg to t timaewa de e r n ngwae f rapeid o d y a f r e t se pont foo
ale ain ha n t s nid u ni tr o ro f a s nd o c d o le
he l r
wih tcohi o b ddngf rs ve d y f ie t saeac nsi to l am) Co pe v.S w,
t ou lt ng r e i o e n a s ald o tt o tt ina cli ; o r ha No.
u
5:0- 0 58 RH- ,201 W L 55 367 a * - ( D. a. c. 2 0)( o i t a c urs
1 CV- 01 - GRJ 0
5 6, t 2 3 N. Fl De 7, 01 n tng h t o t
addr i t is off l et pr de hygi iems i udi matr s and bl
essng he s ue aiur o ovi
ene t , ncl ng tes es
anket,f a
s or

t mpo aype idoftmeha ef ndnoco siuina vi ai )
e r r ro i
v ou
n tt to l olton .
22

f r emi htbeus ds' a physc lco a tbewe n ofk e sandprs ne si a i e pa tof
oc g
e '' nd
i a nt c t e t r
i o r s n nher nt r

t snz et mai ai or ra pr des ft L-a 493( otngW hilyv.Al r,475
he t ggl o nt n de nd ovi aey. da t
qu i
te
bes
U. 31 320( 986).tl nl t unne esaya wa oni lci ofpan'rs st t lvel
S. 2,
1 ) iol y he c s r nd nt nfiton
i ' ie o he e
ofa c tt tonalvi aton. W hil v, U. a 31 W he a i ae cai sofi r us
onsiu i
ol i
te 475 S. t 9.
n n nm t l m fce s ed
e es i f cea ns hi , hec ta kst quesi :whehe theofk il a t d wih a
xc sve or gai t m t our s wo
tons
t rû
t
t as ce t

s fkin l c pa l saeo mida d( eh r tealg dwr ng on wa o j ciey
u t e ty ul be tt f n n wh t e) h l e o d ig s be tv l
e
hamf le ught etbls ac tt ona vi ai ' Huds 503U. a 8( ti i ena
r u no o sa ih onsimi l olton.'
on,
S. t omit ntr l
ng
quotto )
ains.

I a p yn tefrt s b e tv c mp n n u d rHu s n t ec u t s swh te
n p l ig h is, u j cie o o e t n e d o ,h o r a k eh r
ofi i sa pled f r em ai i l a s ditcal f t ve ypur eofca i ha m, ahe
fcal p i o c
lcousy nd a si ly or he r
pos
usng r r t r

t na patofagood-at efo tomai an o r t edici i J a 7.Theco tmus
ha s r
fih fr t nti r esor s plne. . t
Z
ur t
tf uson whehe t e de es
ioc
t r he vi nc upporst i e e t tt gua dswa t y punihe 'he
t he nf r nce ha he r
n onl
s d't
i t ,a noto whehe t i a tonswe et es a y'i t c tse .W hil y,475 U.
nma e nd
n
t r her ci
r s
nec s r ' n he our' yes
te
S.
a 31 322. I W hily,t Supr m eCour r c ni e t tr l ntf t st de e m i t s
t 9,
n
te he
e
t e og z d ha eeva acor o t r ne hi

i r ae:()t ne d fra i tonoff c ( t rltons pbewee t ne d a t
nquiy r 1 he e o pplcai
ore,2) he eai hi t n he e nd he

n u to f ret t su e , 3 t ee tn o teij r , 4 t etr a r a o byp r eve b
mo n f o c ha wa s d ( ) h xe t f h nu y ( ) h h e t e s na l e c i d y
t r s i eofkil basdont fcsknownt t m, nd ()a ef t ma t tmpe
he eponsbl t as e
he a t
o he a 5 ny fors de o e r
t s ve iy ofa f r e u r pons l a 3
he e rt
o c f l es e. d. t 21.C om s h e i r tonsi e e e m a be
é
Fr uc onsde a i nf r nc s y
dr wn a t whehe t us off r ec dpl usbl ha bee t
a
so
t r he e o c oul a i y ve n houghtnec s a y,o i tad
e s r r nse

e ic ds c wa t n e swihrs e t ot eu j siidifito of z a i tnn u toa
vn e u h no n s t ep c t h nu t e n lcin ham s s a tmo n t
f
kn i w ilngnes t ti occ .' l
ow ng li
s ha t ur' d.
l r c nii t tt pr s n e r e i a da r one f r c r c i l
n e og ton ha he i o nvionm nt s
nge ous
o or e tona
of i e s pr s ad i sr t sm us be a c de û de r ngi def r nce ' o
fc r , i on m ni ta or
t c or d E - a ng e e ' t
wi

de i a i e ntpolce a pr cie t ti t ij
sgn nd mplme
iis nd a tc s ha n her udgme aene esay
nt r c sr
f t pr e va i n o or a s curt W hil v, U . at321 22,1 S. .
or he es r to f der nd e iy.
te 475 S.
06 Ct
23

a1
t 085.
Thus whe prs s c iym e lr sa et ke i r pons t a uprsng
, n ion e urt asze r a n n es e o n ii
orprs dit ba e, hec t c
ion sur nc t ours nnno awa e c ape fctym e ur d
t l ys xpe t re l as e
r s e. tl i lci ofpa ni t c s ofaprs s c iy me ur
e pons t- nti ton
-he
i n he our e
ion e urt as e
m t o r l nd unus lpt i hm e sm pl be us i m a
ua m s nt i y ca e t y
. . . doesnota oun t c ue a
a
ppea i r tos c t tt de e off c a horz o a pled f rs urt
r n e r pe t ha he gr e or e ut ied r p i o ec iy

pu pos swasunras bl,a he elnne e s yi t src s ns ' L aa 31
r e
e ona e nd nc l c sar n he tit e e. l t 9.
'

Stnlvv.Heii ,1 F. 62 634(t Ci.1 )
a e
irka 34 3d 9, 4h r 998 .

l a d e sn teo j ciec mpo e tu d rHu o ,h c u t s swh t rt f re
n d rs ig h b e tv o n n n e ds n te o r a k ehe he o c
a idwa t rvil' W iki v.Ga
pple s û i a. l ns
nont
'
ddv,

U.
S.

,1 S. .11 1 9 ( 0) The
30 Ct 75, 77 201 .

o j ci eiq iyi ç epo i t c ne r r sa d r so d c n y, a di t e e sv
be tv n ur s i s nsve o o tmpo ay tn ad f e e c ' n n he xc si e
r
'
f rec ne t dwl e p io o fcasmaiiu l a ds dsial u ef r et c u eh r
o c o tx ,: h n rs n fiil lco sy n a it ly s o c o a s am,
l
c
c n e o aysa dad o d c n yawa sa ev oae . . eh ro n t in fc n ij r i
o tmp rr tn r s f e e c l y r i ltd . wh t e r o sg i a t nu y s
e ie t' Hu s n, 03U. a 9.Ne etee s tee tn o t eimae sij r i n t
vd n . d o 5
'
S. t
v rh ls,h xe t f h n t' n u y s o
tre e nt'o t Ei h Am e
i r l va 't he ght
i
ndme i res asi t y s s t t rt us off ce
nt nquii , t t
ma ugge t whehe he e or

c d pl usbl ha be n t
oul a i y ve e houghtne s a y'i apa tc a st to 'orma C o des
ce s r n
ri ulr iuai n'
y t vi ome
pr

i cain oft n untoffr ea id.'W iki ,1 S. .a 1 ( tngHuds 503
ndi to he mo
o c pple ' l ns 30 Ct t 778 quoi
on,

U.. t7 .Asars l Canimaewh c mpan o a( r)Eu ho s o e t a c u e n
Sa )
e ut ç l n t o o lis f mee p s r h v ' h t a s s o
g
dic r il ij r amos c ranl fist saeav l e c si fr ecam . W i i ,l 0 S
s enb e n u y l t eti y al o tt ai x e sve oc li ' l ns 3 .
d
' k
Ct a 1 78( u t Hu s n, 0 U. a 9 .
. t 1 q oi
ng d o 5 3 S. t )
O ct
ober 30,
2009: W he l hai I i
e c r nc dent

De e nt S ilra Shuma rde c i t cr um sa esi whih W oods Cl ms38
f nda s tle nd
ke s rbe he ic t nc n
c
' ai
a 3C a os c i t ntw ih W oods'a l ga i . On Oc obe 30,2009,a
nd
r es ons se
t
le tons
t r
bout 1 27 a.m
0:

.a
,

us off cet m as e e t r move W oodsfom n bult r r tant a e c thi t
e- -or ea s mbl d o e
r m a o y esr i s nd s or m o
m e ca f f rhe e l ton a m o t i i t m e c luni. D e e ntStle , a a e of
di l o< u t r va ua i nd niorng n he di a t
f nda
il r w r

W oods dir ptvebe ori t SHU i t l ts ve alda ,i tuced t t n t ti
' su i
havi n he
n he as e r ys nsr t he e m ha f
W oodsr f s d t wa kt med c l t y woul plc hi i awheec rf ta por t
eue o l o
i a , he
d ae m n
lhai or r ns t o
24

m e c l W oodsso i hi celi r sr i s s tng t thef a e f hi lf . W he sa f
di a .
t od n s l n e tant , hou i ha
e r d or s ie
n tf
m e be sope d t c l door W oodsb cke a y,sils i W he ofi e sr ac d f
m r
ne he e l
,
a d wa tl houtng.
n fc r e he or
hi a m st e co thi , oodss to f lt t foor wr ppe hi l gsa ound De e an
s r o s r m W
a r el o he l , a d s e r
f nd t
Shoe ke ' l f l g,a gr bbedont t whe l i.W he ofk e sti t fe Shoe a r s
ma rs e t e nd a
o he
echar
n t r red o r e
m ke '
l fom W oods g a p and f r W oodsi o t whe c i,W oodsbega ki ng,silhol ng
eg r
' rs
o ce
nt he
elha r
n cki tl di
ont t wheec i.Fa ed wih W oods a s uli be vi r Stle or r d t t m t l ve
o he
lhar c
t
' s a tve ha o , il r de e he ea o ea
t cel
he l.

W oodss Stle a Shuma rf tl a ng)anat ka physc l a sullngl'
ues ilr nd
ke or tegdi
tac nd
ialy sa ti '
hi ( nd.
m. Ame Compl3. W oodsal est tdurngt sr l,Stle sn
. )
leg ha i he tugge ilr lmmedhi t t
m o he
g ound a k e hi i t ba k,whie Shuma ral dl kiked a pule on W oods t i
r
nd ne d m n he c
l
ke lege y c
nd l d
, mtl

W o d g a be hi 1ga dt e tewh ec ar W o d d e n t nina yij r h s fe e
o s rb d s e n h n h e lh i. o s o s o me to n nu y e u f rd
d i t sat r to .1
urng hi le cai n 5
O c obe 30,2009:
t r

l Cl i 3C, oodsale t f lowi s ue eofe nt . Def nda Tr esgr bbe
n am
W
lges he o l ng eq nc
ve s
e nt e
a d
a si k a a s ed on hi wa t t A-a ehol ng c l,whe eW oodswa i n
tc nd hi l
s y o he r ng
di e l
r
s n mbult r
ao y
r tai s W oodssa tdt yel t f a f my lf fom sa f'an m ove t sa i fontoft
esr nt .
t re o l,i e r or
I
ie r tf,' d
d o ty n r
he
wi
ndow i viw oft c m e a.Tr ssa td movi W oods'ha ufs a whe Of r
n e
he n r
ee tre
ng
ndc f , nd
n fce

1 A ar ofhi s isons
5
s t s ubm s i , Wo d h sicu e c lrg oo rp sd pcigs lpn ,
p
o s a n ld d oo h tga h e it mal ik
n
horzonu lsc sacr st ba ofW oods'ankl a f i r s srpesar
i
ar os he cks
es nd ant eddlh t i
ound t i i ofhi
he nsde
s

wrss ( No.1 Exh. .W oo saest tsafa USPHa et tokt s pitr si mi
it . ECF
, P)
ds tt ha t f t
z lon o he e cu e n dDece ber2009,si w e aferW oodsl tU SP Lee.
m
x eks t
ef

25

Ti on r a d f hi a m , W oodsm ove a y fo hi g as t wrd t wi
pt e che or s r
d wa r m s r p o
he ndow a f l.6
nd e l1

Tr estsa t choki 'W oods butsoppe afe Ti onputtrthi kne a t n hi pam ,
e tt red
ng'
,
t d tr pt
is s e, nd he s l on

W o d ' e d, oligh sfc t tefo r W o d s o td G s tf i a tc i mewhl'Ia
o s h a h dn i a e o h l o . o s h u e ,t laf s ta kng
l
ie' m
i r s r nt . The of i e s are c ng W o a i a pr s i dow n hi f c t t foor
n e tai s
f c r t t d hoki
ods ga n nd e sng
s a e o he l

wih hi pal s whieat r ofi e hed W o 'l . Of e st n ca red W oodst C-a e
t s m , l hid fc r l
ods egs fc r he ri
o r ng
a sr ppedhi down t ace ntbt W oodsr f s t c eoutofr tai suntlhi
nd ta
m
o
me mk.
e u ed o om
esr nt i s
tans e f om U SP Le t U SP Haz lon o N ove be 3,
r fr r
eo
et n
m r 2009.

I tt i lr c dsfo t sda ea Tr es de a a i r ve a tonali or to
nsiutona e or r m hi t nd e ' clr ton e al ddii
nf ma in

c nsse twi W o ds alg to s M o . mm. . h 1 Ata h. Tr e De l Tre wa
o itn t o ' le ain .( t Su J Ex . , tc H; e s c. e s s
h
)
t SHU Liut na i c r eofc
he
e e nt n ha g
onductng r s ntc ckson W oodson Ocobe 30,2009.
i e kai he
t r
Tr essa e t ta hea oa d W oods t i ae s t d a c r d i t Tr s srki
e tt s ha s ppr che
, he nm t hou e nd ha ge n o ee , ti ng
hi u rbody. Tr esand Ti o ti d t gan c ntoloft r it ntW oodsand snz e
s ppe
e
pt n re o i o r
he essa
t ggld
brefywih hi . W oodsg a d Tr es tnge s t si hi rghtm i efnge a hi lf
il t m
r bbe e ' i r , witng s i
ddl i r nd s e t
mi ea i x fnge s s h t tt y we es r a s nstve a tr r . W oods s tng
ddl nd nde
r , uc ha he
r o e nd e ii fe wa ds
' hou i

a
boutbei a tc c us d ot ri t so t A-a o t SHU t begi kiki t rc l
ng ta ked a e he nma e n he r nge f he
o
n c ng hei el
door a t e t ni t a s ul sa fa i ta eot rd s u i a tvii .Bec us ofW oods
s nd hr a e ng o s a t t f nd niit he ir ptve c i tes
a e
'
a s uli be vi ,s r s r pe s
s a tve ha or upe vi o y r onne gave a hort t pl ce hi i t ogr s ve f l - n
l
ut iy o a
m nû
pr es i otr poi t

gofjr sri s'onabe
s t etant'
d.

1 w hen s r ng t amended com pl nt t cour i
6
c eeni he
ai , he
t nadve t l ove l
renty rooked Ti on' nam e i
pt s
n

cam 3 a dimisdalcamsa anshi un rj1 5 b)1.Wood di n toj c t ti
li C nd s se l li g i t m de 91A( ()
s d o beto hs

ds sa a dh sn t v dt a n t risaeti d fn a t r c o l hsrieo go e so
imis l n a o mo e o me d o en tt hs ee d n o a c mp i evc f rc s n
s

hi Se Rue4( .Morov r f rra on sae hee W o sdi no s fe a yde rv tonof
m. e l m)
e e , o e s s ttd r , od d t u fr n p ial

consiu i rght durng t Ocober30,2009 i dent The ef e,t cour s marl dim is
tt tonal i s i he t
nci . r or he
t um
iy s s es

wiho tp eudc a ycam a i tTi o pu s ntt 28U. C. 1 5 b)1 f rfiu et saea
t u rj ie n li gans ptn, rua o
S. j 91 A( () o alr o tt
cl m .
ai

26

M edia sa fa s s e W oodsa trt si de andnot d t f l ng: 14 c
c l tf s e sd
fe hi nci nt
e he olowi
/ m
s r t he t t r g w rs a e w' h no b e ng o di c o to a o1 band a d t t l f
c a c s o he i ht i t r a, i
t
l edi r s ol m i n; n d
i o he e t
wr s , ao1 s r t t t l f a e ar ,a no di tes no e
i t al d c a ch o he e t nkl ea nd
sr s t d.
Excessi Force A nal i
ve
ys s

Afe c r ulr vi oft e de e t c tc l st tW oodshasf l d t
tr a ef e ew
he vi nc , he our onc ude ha
aie o

f rc s e ie c b whihh c udpes d af c fn e u d rt es j ciefc to Hu s n,
o e a t vd n e y c e o l rua e a t id r n e h ube tv a e f d o
a de i d by t W hil v f c or ,t tt def nda tof i er w a o y a i d f c f t
s tne
he
t e a t s ha he e n fc s nt nl pple or e or he
pur e ofha m i hi . The t c e t d e de e i t tW oods'o n cotr e ofr s s a ,
pos
r ng m
m ont s e vi nc s ha
w
ls
e i t nt
a s uli be vi dur ng t l s wee ofOc obe 2009 a U SP Lee c e ed t nee f
s a tve ha or i he a t k
t r
t
r at he d or

ofk e st e pl f ceon Oc obe 30,2009. Conta yt W oods a r ntbe if ani t s
t r o m oy or
t r
rr o
' ppa e
le , nma e'
pe s nalf a sdo notexc ehi nonc
ro er
us s
ompla ewih ofk e s or r .
i nc t t r ' de s
l t m om i t prs ofi i l m e e y a tm pt d t f l pr e lest r m o
n he
ng, he i on tc a s r l t e e o olow oc dtr o e ve

W oods ambult y r sr i t a ha hi a s s d bym e ca sa fi t m n rt t
'
a or e ta n s nd ve m s es e
di l tf n he nne ha
r gultonsr quie I t a tm oo Tr e a Ti on al mpt dt pe f m r utner sr i
e a i e r d. n he fe n, e s nd pt te e o ror o i e tant
c c .W oods'a tver ssa et t of e s e f rson bot o a i c eaedt nee f
he ks
c i e it nc o he fc r ' fo t
h cc sons r t he d or

o fc r t e o itn i e p y ia me s r st a c mp iht ero j cie ,nk e igwi
f es o mply n e st d h sc l au e o c o ls h i b e tv s i e pn t
i
h
t fr t s ond a f t W hilv f c or .
he is, ec
nd ourh
te a t s

W o d h sn t sa ls e ta h s fee a ysg i c n ij r a ar s l o hs
o s a o e tbih d h t e u frd n int a tn u y s e ut f i
i
at r a i wih ofi e so Oc o r30,2009.Att mos,W oodspoi st t s r o hi
le c tons t tc r n t be
he
t
nt o he ca s n s
a e , s bl i t pi t est n a U SP H a elon s m e m ont l t r a s
nkl s vi i e n he c ur ake t
z t o
hs a e , nd ugges st tt
t ha he

ofie s a tons rt rt nhi o a tver itnce s how i lce t s wo .(
fc r ' ci , ahe ha s wn ci essa , ome
nfitd he e unds ECF

No. 1 pp.1 1 ) TheX mi mi natr oft ij isa t i l ai i c t t tt
4- , 4- 5.
ni s tle he nure nd her oc ton ndiaes ha he

ofie sus d onl t tm e ur off c nec s a y t c r t i ae,l ng t t t r a
fc r e
y ha as e or e e s r o ontol he nm t ooki o he hid nd
ffh W hil y f c or .
it
te a t s
Undera lf c o sofW hil v, U . a 320- , he c t i no g nui i s of
l a tr
te 475 S. t
21 t our f nds
e ne s ue

ma e i f c i diput on whi h W oodscoul s
t ral a t n s e
c
d uppor ar a o bl i e e et ta oft
t e s na e nf r nc ha ny he
de e nt wa onl a id f c o Oc obe 30,2009, t a i e t pt s W oods a
f nda s nt y pple or e n t r
wih n ntnt o mih
,s

rquie t pr t s j ci f e ofhi Ei hAme me cli unde Huds 503U.
e rd o ove he ub e tve ac t s ght
nd nt am
r
on.
S.
a 8.Ra he ,t e denc esabls st tt ofier a id t t a n mtoff r et y
t
t r he vi e t ihe ha he fc s pple he ype nd mot
o c he
be i ve w a ne es a y t r s or or ri t f c ofW oods'l c
le d s c s r o e t e de n he a e
m oope a i a be lg r n
r tve nd li e e t

a to s Thed fnd nsaet se tte t s mmayj g n o Cli 3 a d3 wi u
cin .
ee a t r hu nild o u r ud me t n ams 8 n C t t
ho
f rh rds usi no t eo j ciefc tu d rHu s n, n tec u t rn st er to 1
u te ic so f h b e tv a e n e d o a d h o r g a t h i moin.7
V . C oncl i
us on

Fort satd r as ,t cour g a sde e
he t e e ons he
t r nt f ndan s m oton t dim is o i t
t ' i o s s , r n he

atmaie moi nf rs mmayj d me t a dds se wih u p eudc W o d 'cams
l t , to o u r u g n, n imiss t o t rj ie o s li
e v
a ans u n me a dt e v didiiu l p rua tt Ru e4m)a d j1 5 b ( ) An
g i t n n d n msr e n vd as u s n o l ( n 91 A( )1.
a opr a e or rw ili s t s da
ppr i t de l s ue hi y.

TheCl r i diece t s nd c pisoft sme o and opi on and a c
e k s r td o e o t
hi m r um
ni
c ompa ng
nyi
or rt pli ifa t c
de o antf nd o ouns lofr co d f de enda s
e
e r or f nt.

ENTER:Ths X
i

d yo Mac 2 2.
a f rh, 01
Chi fU nied St t D i ti tJ
e
t
a es sr c udge

1 Be a etec ur c ncud sta ted fnd n saee ildt s mmayj gme tont
7 c us h o t o l e h t h e e a t r ntte o u r ud n he
mert ofW oods'e svef ce cli s t courtwilnotaddr sdef
is
xces i or am , he
l
es endant addii def e of
s' tonal ens
qualfed i muniy.
ii m
t

28