Shire LLC v. Mickle et al

Filing 161

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 8/2/2011. (eot)

I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I T C O U RT
C
FO R TH E W E STERN DI
STR I O F V I G I A
CT
R NI
R O AN O K E D I ISIO N
V
SH I E LLC ,
R

C i lA c i n N o.7: c 00434
vi t o
10- vPl ntff
ai i ,

V.

M EM O R AND U M O PI I N
N O

TR AVIS C .M ICK LE ,etaI
.
By:Sam uelG .W is
lon
U nied St es D itri Judge
t
at
s ct

Def
endant
s.

Thi i adi st a to byShieLLC (t r' , s i ar ofa i enai l
s s veriy cin
r
'Shie' a ubsdi y n ntr tona
)
phama utc lcompa a i tdee nt Ke
r ce ia
ny, gans fnda s mpham,l (û mPham') as l e ry
r nc.AKe
r ', mal al
p s bi r ac utca c pa a Tr vi M i kl K e pha m ' pr i nt alegi t t
ha e opha m e i l om ny, nd a s c e, m
r s es de , l ng ha
M i kl br c a e pl e ag e m e ,tve as i e a e m e s a a s tl m e
c e ea hed n m oym nt r e nt i
s gnm nt gr e nt , nd e te nt
a e m e be wee Shi e a M i e a t tK e pha t tous y i e f r w ih t s
gr e nt t n r nd ckl , nd ha m
nu or i l nt r e ed t he e
a e m e s Thi m a t ri c r nty be or t c r o M i kl ' a K e pha m ' m oton unde
gr e nt . s te s ur e l f e he ou t n c e s nd m
r s
i
r

F d rl l o Cii Pr c d r 1 ()f raj d me to t epla i st a t a r e n s
e ea Ru e f v l o e u e 2 c o u g n n h e dng h the g e me t
c ai i ld a une or e bl r sr c i c nan s Eve a s i t tt c l nge
ont n nva i nd nf c a e e t i tve ove t . n s um ng ha he hale d
p o s onscons iut r t i tve co
r vi i
tt e esr c i
vena s t co tfndst ti c no e ua e t r v i t
nt , he ur i ha t an t val t hei aldiy
wihou a m o e f l de ope f t lr c d. A c or ngl t c t est m oto
t t
r uly vel d ac ua e or
c di y, he our deni he
i n.
1.
I eary 2001,M i e ent
n l
ckl ered i o an em pl entagr entw ih Lot Bi
nt
oym
eem
t
us ochem i
cal

Coporton(t t ',andhebeg wor ngf Lot a as ni r eac sints. w Ri r
r ai $ us'
Lo )
an ki or us s e or es rh ce itNe ve
Phama e ial,l (t ',i as ce s i itrs t Lous a Shiei as e s i
r c utc s nc.t
NRP') s uc sor n nee t o t , nd r s ucc sor n

i e e tt xRP.lshiec am st tM ikl br a dt e pr sonsofhi e o e
nt r s o
r l i ha c e e che hr e ovii
s mpl ym nt
agreem ent.

The fr tpr s on a i s pa a a 4,i en il d (ow ne s p ofM a e i s'a
i s ovi i t s ue, r gr ph s tte ç
r hi
t ral ' nd
pr vi s i pa t
o de n r :

Al doc nt,digrms f multons rc ds cuso rlss Dicovei (s
l ume s a a , or ai , e or , tme it, s res a
d tn d i S ci n 7 hee g, e up n, a d oh r i ms p o ie b te
ei e n e to
ro q ime t n te t
e
r vd d y h
Compa and hed i t pos es i of Empl e,a ot r m a e i s i a
ny
l n he s son
oye nd he
t ral, n ny
f
onn, whi h i a wa r l t t t Compa s pas, pr e or potnta
c n ny y e ae o he
ny'
t es nt
e il
bus ne s and whi h w e e pr pa e or r ce ve by t Em pl e i t cour e of
i s
c
r e rd
e i d
he
oye n he
s
t Em pl
he
oyee' e pl en a e t e us ve p o ry oft Com pa
s m oym t r he xcl i r pe t
he
ny.

( oyme Agre nt!4. Thes c pr sona is pa a a 6,i entted
Empl nt e me
)
e ond ovii t sue, r grph s il
icont d ntalI or a i 'a pr desi par '
t ' e i nf m ton' nd ovi n t
i
.
Em pl e A g e s t t a a1 tm e whie e pl d by t Em pl
oye
r e ha t 1 i s
l m oye
he
oyer a
nd
t r fe ,Empl
he ea tr
oyeewilno us f Empl e' own pe s
l t e or
oye s
r onalbe ftorf t
ne i
or he
be ft of o he s or di c os t a ot r pe s c por to or o he e iy f
ne i
t r
s l e o ny he r on, or a i n
t r ntt or
a r s n a oft Confde i ll o maton,wihoutt prorwrte c e
ny ea o ny he
i nta nf r i
t
he i
itn ons nt
oft Boa d ofD ie t s oft Com pa (
he
r
r c or
he
ny. t i en i l onna i ' us d i
conf d tal nf
ton' as e n

t i Ag e me t wil n ld :( )ti Ag e me ta da1 r viin h r o ,()al
hs re n , l i cu e 1 h s re n n 1 p o so s ee f 2 l
i or a i ac r by Em pl e f om t Com pa is s ppler ,a r i e s
nf m ton quied
oye r
he
ny, t u i s dve ts r ,
c t e s or ot r dur ng Em pl ee' e pl e whi h r a e t t
us om r ,
he s
i
oy s m oym nt
c el t s o he
Co pa spa t pr s ntorpo e ilbusne s s h a pr n s tl ,pe s
m ny' s, e e
t nta
i s , uc s ogr m , ies r onne
l

i onnai Dic re (s defne i Se ton 7 hee t t e e not
nf ton, s oveis a i d n ci
rog o he xtnt
di c os d t t publc by t Com pa y . . . de i doc e s t hni l
s l e o he
i
he
n
s gn
um nt , ec ca
i onma i o m a e i l . . . a w e l a t Com pa s pa t pr ent o f tr
nf
ton r t r a
s l s he
ny' s , es
r utle
r s r h and de l e . ..
e ea c
ve opm nt .

(d. 6. Thefna c ese pr sonofM ikl sempl nta e nt paag a 7,s
I ! )
i l ont td ovii
c e'
oyme greme , r r ph i
e il SDi co res' pr desi pa t
ntted ' s ve i ' and ovi n r :
A l D i c r e a e t e us ve pr r y of t Com pa and Em pl
1 s ove i s r he xcl i
ope t
he
ny,
oyee w il
l
pr pty and f l di c os t m t t Com pa
om l
uly s l e he o he
ny. A s us d he e n, t t r
e
r i he e m
( i c r e ' m e a 1di cove i , i ntons i pr m e s pr es es i as
r s ove i s ' ans 1 s
res nve i , m ove nt , oc s , de
a nn es i a f
nd m n ny onn,whet r ornotpa e a e orco r ght bl ... wel a
he
t nt bl
py i a e
as l s

al l elcua Prpe t ( detne heen) whi rlt t orar us ult t
l ntle t l o ry as i d ri , ch eae o
e ef o he
Com pany' busi
s
nessw hi Em pl
ch
oyee al or w ih ot
one
t hers m ay i
nvent di
, scover
,
m ake or concei w het t Com pany' f ltes ar used or not . . . .
ve
her he
s aciii
e
Sl e l c ua Pr r y' m e ns a 1 c r nta f ur w ordw i pa e s a ot
tnt le t l ope t ' a l ur e nd ut e
l de t nt nd her
1shie plr ha e NRP i 2007.
r zc s d
n

pae rght,i ntons c i ht ,tade s r t,ta m a ks know- w,utlt
tnt i s nve i , opyrg s r
ec es r de r ,
ho
iiy
mode s a o he i a bl pr prea y rght,i l ng,wiho lm iai al
l nd t r nt ngi e o itr i s ncudi
t ut i tton, 1
a i a i a r s r tons w ih r pe tt r t Ata tm e,a t Com pa s
pplc tons nd egit a i
t es c he e o.
ny i
t he
ny'

r que ta ex ns Empl e wil wihoutfrhe compe ai ()prmpty
e s nd pe e,
oye l, t
ut r
nston i o l
r c r s c Dic v re '(i e e u ea y a sg me t a d ohe d cl n sta
e o d u h s o eis i x c t n sin n s n t r o l t h t
, )
me
t Co ny dee desrbl t pr e tis rght i t dic re 'a (i)
he mpa
ms ia e o otc t i s n he s oveis nd ii
,
a ss t Com pa i e o cng is rg s wih r pe t t t s Dic re .
s it he
ny n nf r i t i ht t es c o he e s ove i s
The e oblga i w ils v ve t r na i n ofe pl m e .
s
i tons l ur i e mi to
m oy nt

(d !7.Th e ly n a re n e p e syp o i e t t ikl' o lg to su d r
I . ) e mpo me t g e me t x rsl r v d s ha M c es bi ai n n e
paa a 4,6,a 7s vvet tr nainofM ikl se oyme .(d. 1 g))
rgrphs
nd ur i he emi to
c e' mpl nt I ! 4( .
W hie a N RP,M i kl a s a i d f s ve a pa e st tr ule f om hi w or f t
l t
c e l o pple or e r l t nt ha es t d r
s k or he
com pa I c
ny. n onne ton w ih t s pa e a i a i , i kl e c ed fve as i e
ci
t he e t nt pplc tons M c e xe ut i
sgnm nt
a e m e s a s gni hi i e es s i t e pa e st N RP. Thos a s gnm en ag ee e s
gr e nt s i ng s nt r t n hos t nt o
e si
t r m nt
pr de i pa t
ovi , n r :

g j doherbys l,a sgna tanse unt s i ASSI
W e
e el s i nd r fr o ad
GNEE ... e ierghttte
our ntr i ,il
a i e es i a t oug utt Unie St t ofAm e i ...a a1 coun resf e g
nd nt r t n nd hr ho he t d aes
rca
nd 1
ti or i n
t r o a t s d i pr m e s s d Unie St t sa i to a ot Unie St t s
he et nd o ai m ove nt , ai
t d a e pplca i n, ny her t d a e
a ia i ,i l ng pr sona,di so ,r ne l s tt e, tnuai n,
pplc tons nc udi
ovii l vii nal e wa , ubsiut con i to
r e mi to a r is a ia i ,ba e i whol ori pm'on s i Unie St t
e xa nai n nd e s ue pplc tons s d n
e n t a d t d aes
a i a i ori w hol ori pa ' on s d i pr m e s a f ei a i a i ,
pplc ton n
e n l
t ai m ove nt , ny or gn pplc tons
i udi i e a i la r gi la i tons ba ed i w hol or i pa ton a oft
ncl ng nt m tona nd e ona pplca i , s n
e n r
ny he
af es d Unied St t sa i tonsori w hol ori pa ton s i i pr m e s a i
or ai
t
a e pplca i
n
e n r
a d m ove nt , nd n
a t a a a ll ter pat nt i l ng e e i t r , a c m t y whi h ha
nd o ny nd 1 e t s e , nc udi xt ns ons he eof of ny ot r
c ve
be n orm a be g a t o a oft af r ai a i a i oron s d i pr ve e sor
e
y
r n ed n ny he o es d pplc tons
ai m o m nt
a pa t t r of..
ny r s he e

( . Mo .o J o t Pla i g , 2 6(ç sg me t re n sl. S iecamsM ike L
P1' tf r . n he e d n s Ex. - d in n Ag e me t' ) h r li
s
As
cl
@

br a he t e pr vi i by de l ng ne i elec ua pr r y ba e on t as i d pa e t E
e c d hes o s ons
ve opi
w nt l t l ope t s d
he s gne t n s
g
!

a t he l t RP,a as i ni hi i e e t i t e ne pa e st hi ne c pa
fer ef N
nd s g ng s nt r s s n hos w t nt o s w om ny,
K e phar ,i ead ofN RP.
m
m nst
l 2005,M i e l tN lp and ent ed i o a s tem entagr entw ih t com pany.
n
ckl ef t
er nt etl
eem
t he

Tha ag ee e r ie a e t tM i kl s oblga i unde ce t n pr s ons oft e pl e t
t r m nt e t r t s ha c e' i tons
r rai ovi i
he m oym n
a e m e t i udi pa a a 4,6,a 7, ur ve hi t r i ton. Shie alege t tM i kl s :
gr e n , ncl ng r gr phs
nd s vi s e m na i
r l s ha c e'

br a hesofpa ag a 4,6,a 7 oft empl e a ee nta s c tt ebr a so t
ec
r r phs
nd
he
oym nt gr me lo onsiut e che f he
s tem entagreem ent
etl
.
II.

M ik ea dKe am h v mo df r u g n o t pe dn p ru n t Rue
c l n mph r a e ve o j d me t n he la igs u s a t o l
1 c , r ui t tt r e tc rc pr viinsc ttt f ilyt nf c a ersrci
2() a g ng ha he elvan onta t o so onsiue acal me or e bl e titve
c nan sund Vi gi a l w . A s um i a guen t tt e pr s ons a e pr r y
ove t
er r ni a
s ng, r
do, ha hes ovi i
r ope l
c i r d t be r s r c i c
ons de e o
e ti tve ovena s t c tfndst td t r i ng w he he t y a e
nt , he our i ha e e m ni
t r he r
l e s na e r s rc i a t r or u nf r e bl r quiesa m o e f ly de ope f c ua
mr a o bl e t i tons nd he ef e ne o c a e e r
r u l vel d a t l
r c d. Cons que l t c t ni M i kl sm o i
e or
e nty, he our de es c e' ton.

ç amoin fr u g nt ntepla igsma epzs a tt Ru e1 () o l t e
t
on
to o j d me o h e dn
d l u n o l 2 c , ny h
r
pl a ngsa e c i r ' A . A be lCo. Ba t Tv r c U ni N o.1 338 F. 1
e di
r ons de ed,' S. l
v. l. pog aphi al on
2,
2d 90,

1 ( hCi.1 ,a t c tmus daw a1ras bl fcua i ee si fvo oft
93 4t r 964) nd he our t r 1 e ona e a t lnfrnce n a r he
nonmo ngpat Se Edwadsv.CiyofGol boo,1 F. 231 243- (t Ci.1
vi ry. e
r
t
ds r 78 3d , 44 4h r 999)
(ppl ngt smesandadi r viwi aRul 1 c motona iwoul aRul 1 b)6
a yi he a t r n e e ng
e 2() i s t d
e 2( ( )
moto .Unde Vigi al ilqnon-ompeii a e me tbewee a e oye a a
in)
r r ni aw,da
c tton gre n t n n mpl r nd n
empl ewilbeenf c i t ontac i na r y d a opr e tt e oye ' l tmat
oye l
or ed f hec r t s rowl r wnt otc he mpl rs egii e
'

bus ne s i e e t i notundul b de om e on t e pl e' abiiy t ea n a lvi a i not j
i s nt r s , s
y ur ns
he m oye s lt o r i ng, nd s
!
!

aga ns publcpolc ' O m ni e W ord Se v . p v.U . I ve tca i Se vs.I ,270 Va.
i t
i
i y.'
pl x
l r s Cor .
S. n s i tons r . nc.
I
(
i

246,249( ) Howe ,whet rac twilenfr ori ldaeaçr titvec na ' i
2005 .
ver
he our l oce nvai t lesrci ove nt' 1
.

i eq t i ofe afc-ade i r Fot v.Coo 220Va 800,805( 980)( i t t
n uiy s tn a tl n nquiy. i
k,
.
1
notng ha

i

!
i
!

û t rr titveco na si a e oyme c ta twilbeenf c i e t de nds
s he esrc i
whe
ve nt n n mpl
nt on r c l
or ed n quiy pe

uPOnt fcsi t patc arc e',s ealoDe iinI i s l c. Seni Gr .I ,311
he a t n he riul as '' e s cso nsght,- v. ta p. nc.
)
n
.

Fed. x58 598( h Ci.
App' 6,
4t r 2009)(e ri hetilc tsdeenni to t tano c mpeei
r vesngt ra our' t nain ha
n-o t
p
;

i
i

pr s on wasune o c abl and i t u tng t ti lco t o w e gh t S m pe i i e e t o
ovii
nf r e e
ns r c i he r a ur t
i he l
co tng nt r s s f

t e oye a t e o ' .
he mpl r nd he mplyee'
)
Thec tfndst tt pl a ngsf i o pr des fc e co e f t cour t ma
our i ha he e di a lt ovi ufi i nt nt xt or he
t o ke
t f c -a n i r r quie t dee m i t r as blne soft ontac pr sonsi
he a tlde nquiy e r d o tr ne he e ona e s
hec r t ovii n
ques i W hie c t ha f
ton.
l our s ve ound br dl or d nonc pe e ag ee ent w ihoutexpr s
oa yw de
om t r m s t
es
ge a c ort m por llm ia i nsf i ly i ld,s .e. ,Ca ol l v. c a el 2006 W L
ogr phi
e
a i t to ac a l nva i ee c. nt . nc. M D ni ,

1 399 a * ( D. Apr 28,2006) t Vigi aSu e Cour hasnothedt tt
21 2, t 6 E. Va. .
,he r ni prme
t
l ha he
a e e oft e e e s lm ia i r
bs nc
hos xpr s i t tons ende sco i ntalt c a esoras i e ag ee e s
r nf de i iy l us
s gnm nt r m nt ,

s h a t e a is i t sca e,i i rs 2 A c or ngl , t cour fndst tt r c d
uc s hos t s ue n hi s nvaldre e. c di y he
t i ha he e or
r quiesf rhe f c ua deve opm e t a s s t r as bl ne soft c le d pr sons
e r ' t r at l
u
l
nt o s e s he e ona e s
he ha l nge ovi i ,

a dd ne ted fn n s mo inf r u g n o t epe dn s
n e is h ee da t' to o j d me t n h la ig .
111.

Fo ter a o ssae a o e t c u t e ist ed fn a t'mo inf r u g n o
r h e s n ttd b v ,he o r d n e h ee d ns to o j d me t n
pla i g p ru n t Rue 1 ()
e d n s u s a t o l 2 c.

P
''
..

M

f
.'

.'
.

EN TER :August2,2011.

UNI STATESDITRI J
TED
S CT UDGj!
I
I
i

;
i
E
2M ikl ciest Vigi aCicui Cour ca e t ta idt e ts meanaysst contde i iy pr vii a !
c e t wo r ni r t
t s s ha pple he xac a
l i o i ntalt o sons s i

WO l n r l a pyt c v n nsn t oc mp t.Se BB&Tl . ev . Th ma Ruh ro r.nc, 01 Va l
ud o mal p l o o e a t o t o ee e
y
ns S r sv. o s t ef od l .2 0 .

Ag.1XS5aFlde (aCrCiFb921)Leeoivt awo,t0st andd87,t8eo.urC. j
CrL2,I09).t1-ralcourt.tge.,00,auph s. 1tn2exiWL7880a*sVrCggeti$
i E202,t#12V.iit. i diersiy.l rn tWa asi09s 3onotsurmi(asi s t
.
1 sstn n v t lusspae s
.t
u
ç e
'
e pa so 'Bu rsCh m.lc v. X Cop.1 F.d2 3 2 7(t Ci.1 9 ) a dtec u tsu wiigt p e it
x n in, ri e .n . US r , 0 3 4 , 4 4h r 9 3, n h o r i n ln o rdc 1
'
l
t tt Vigi aSupr Cour woul a t postonoft s c t i lghtofot rpr ce ts si t t f
ha he r ni
eme
t
d dopt he ii
he e om' n i
s
he e den ugge tng ha
co i i iyclus sne t bea yze unde s
nfdentalt a e ed o
nal d
r omewha dif rntsanda ds Se Roo- ev.Le s r 899F. I
t fee t r . e t Di
se,
I

Su p. 51 ,l 2 ( . Va 1 9 )(oigta tet ifrn ei p mo e' ewe nan n s l uep o iina da
p 1 5 5 3 W D. . 9 5 n tn h th t fee c n u s 'b t e o dicosr r vso n i
d
I
n n o eep o ii i d c t st et e e st f rd fe e t r ame f)( i n Ed nHa n n & Co v S mi mo q
o c mp t r v son n ia e h t c s i o ifr n te t n ' ct g e n o
n
y
i
..u t
o
Tr s & Baz n Co.91 F.d5 (t Ci. 9 0 ) e as Wo e Elc . m. Ad a c Gp.lc,1 91W L j
ut l a > 4 2 56 4h r 1 9 ) se lo v n e sCo v. v n e .n . 9
ki
5 l 8 a * (t Ci. r 1 ,1 91 (oig,na pyigS uhCaol alw i te a sn eo e piig ia c !
4 1 , t 4 4h r Ap . 5 9 ) n t i p l n o t r i a n h b e c f x l t ud n e l
n
n
c
fom t sae' s prm ec tt tano s os ea ee ntma bevald e n t
r he tt s u e our, ha
ndicl ur gr me
v
i ve hough i c ai notmeorplc
t ont ns i
aq

rsrcin )
etito s.

!