Cummings v. Astrue

Filing 23

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS for 12 Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Starr Jeanette Cummings, 19 Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Michael J. Astrue. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 7/14/11. (sas)

CL S OFFI U..hî' X tR3
ERK'
CE % k iT l '
s.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

J 15 2 1
UL
01
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES D I
STR I C O U RT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
Roanoke D i son
vi i

J I c.
ULA DUp Y.CI RK
.
E

BY
;

#?
/'/
DEPU

CL
ER

STAR R JEA NETT E CU M M I G S,
N
Ci lA cton N o.7: CV vi
i
10- 00461

Pli s
ant
O RD ER A D O PTI G R EPO R T
N
AN D R EC O M M EN D A TIO N

V.

M I AEL J.ASTRUE,
CH
C O M M ISSIO N ER O F
SO CIAL SEC UR ITY ,

By:Judge Jam es C.T urk
Se or Unied St e Di t i tJudge
ni
t
at s s r c

De
fendant
.
Pli ifStr J a teCummi brngst sa tonp s ntt 42U. C.jj 41 a
antf ar e net
ngs i hi ci urua o
S.
6 nd
423 f r viw oft Com mi sone o SocalSe urt sfnalde ii n de nghe cai f r
or e e
he
s i r f i c iy' i
c so nyi
r l ms o
di a lt i u a e be i sunde t So a Se urt A c . The Cour r f r e t m a t rt
s biiy ns r nc neft
r he ci l c iy t
t e e r d he te o
Unie St t sM ag sr t J
td ae
i t a e udge B.W a Cr g e f ra Re r a Rec m e ton,pur ua t
ugh i l r o
po t nd
om nda i
s nt o

2 U.. j6 6b ()B) eM a itaeJ d es b e u nl tldarp r fn i t a te
8 SC. 3 () 1( .Th g srt u g u s q e ty ie e o t idng h th
Appea s Co i f l t pr de a a ua e e a ton f r is de i i nott r vi w ne
l unc l aied o ovi n deq t xpl na i o t c s on
o e e
w
e de e ofdi a lt t tt pl i ifs it d. The M a s r t J ge t ef e
vi nc
s biiy ha he a ntf ubm te
git a e ud , her or ,
r c m e d t tt Com m i sone ' de s on be r m a
e om nde ha he
s i r s ci i
e nded,a t tt pa te 'c os - oto
nd ha he ri s r s m i ns

frs mma yj d me tb d ne
o u r u g n e e id.
Folow i t i s nc oft Re ta Re om m e ton, he pa tesw e e e il d t
l ng he s ua e he por nd c
nda i t
ri
r ntte o

noea obe to wihi f tenda .Fed. Ci P.72( .TheCour r eve nos h
t ny jcins t n oure ys
R. v.
b)
tec i d uc
o j ci .Asars tandha ngr e dt Magsrt J
b e tons
e ul,
vi eviwe he itae udge' Re ta
s por nd
Rec
omme to a pe tne po tonsoft r c d,t Cour a r eswih t M a sr t
ndai n nd ri nt ri
he e or he
t ge
t he gita e
J
udge' r c m e ton. A c or ngl i i he e A DJUD G ED a O R D ER ED t tt
s e om nda i
c di y, t s r by
nd
ha he
M agi r e Judge' Reportand Recom m endaton i A D O PTED ,t Com m i si
stat
s
i s
he
s oner' and
s

.

Cummi 'Cr sM oi f Su r J me ( No.1 1 aeDENI a t c s
ngs os- tons or mma y udg nt ECF
2, 9) r
ED, nd he a e
i REM A ND ED .
s

The Cl r ofCour i die t d t srke t c e f om t Cour ' ac i doc t The
ek
t s r c e o ti he as r he
ts tve ke .

Cl r i f t rdie t t s nd co e oft sOr rt c elofr co d f ra 1pa te .
e k s urhe r ced o e
pis hi de o ouns
e r o 1 ris

ENTER:Thi /
s

a ofJ y, 1
y ul 201 .

am e C.Tur
s
k
Se o U nied St t D it i tJ ge
ni r t
a es s rc u