Miller v. Kelley

Filing 53

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 03/06/2012. (rkc)

CLERK' OFFI U S. ST COURT
S
CE
DI .
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT

VOR THE W ES
TERN DI TRI OFVI NI
S CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
A NN M A RIE M ILLER ,

MA2 25 2 1
22
BJL .U L C E K
K ACD DS LR
U
/, . ', =7
4 rp
>

Ci lA cton N o.7: cvvi
i
10- 00546

Pl ntf ,
ai if

V.

M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O

JEN NI
FER A N N K ELLEY ,
D ef
endant
.

By:Sam uelG .W is
l on
Unie St esD i t i tJudge
t d at
src

Pli if An M a i M ilr orgi lyfld t sa ton i t U. Diti tCour f t
antf, n re le , i nal ie hi c i n he S. src
t or he
Diti tofCo or do,ms e tng asa e lw lbe c am agans de e
src
l a
s ri
t t -a i l l i
i t f ndan ,J nnie Al Kel y,
t e f r m le

p ru n t tec u t 2 U. C. 1 3 dv riyj rs ito lTha c u trnser dt ec s t
u s a t o h o r' 8 S. j 3 2 ie st u idcin. t o r ta fre h a e o
s
t W e t r D it i tofV igi a a t sco tha snc dim i s d t ac i f M il r sf it e
he s e n s rc
r ni , nd hi ur s i e s s e he ton or le ' a ll
r

t pr e ut Them at ri c r n l be or t c ton de e
o os c e.
te s ur e ty f e he our
f ndan J nnie Ann Ke ly' m o i
t e fr
le s ton

f atr y' f spt s ntt 28U. C.j 1 27a s ncinspurua t Fe rlRul ofCi l
or tone s ee l ua o
r
S.
9 nd a to
s nt o dea e
vi
Pr e e 11.Kel y a g t tM ilrshit y o s ng Kel y,a M ilrsa s a st t
oc dur
le r ues ha le ' sor f ui
le nd le ' s ur nce ha
s wilco i t do s wa r tt i
he l ntnue o
o, ran he mposto ofa tr y' f sa s nc i . Thec t
ii n to ne s ee nd a tons
our

tndst tund rt cic tnce neihe j1 norRul 11pemi t r le Kelys ks
i ha e he rumsa s t r 927
e
r t he eif le ee .

Ne e tee s M ilrsc n u th salh idii o b df i , n t c u t le j i M i e
v rh ls , l ' o d c a 1 te n ca f a at a d he o r wil n on l r
e
h
l
fom flng a f t epr s a to i t sdititagans Keley o he f m iy.
' ii ny uur o e ci ns n hi src
r
i t l r ra l

1Kely r i i V i on, Vigi a, M ilrr sdesi Thor on,Col a Bot pa tesa ec rnty
le esdes n nt
r ni and le e i n
nt
ordo. h ri r ure l
pr ee ngpr . howe r M il ri a f merm embe oft V igi a St t Ba who ha s r e r he lc ns
oc di
oç
e;
ve , le s or
r he r ni a e r
s u r nde ed r i e e,
a K elyrt i d c eldurngt pr e ngsi Col ad
nd le eane ouns
i he oc edi n or o.

1.

A fe M il rfl d t s a ton,t U . D it i tCo ti Col ado f und t ti l c d
t r le ie hi c i he S. src ur n or
o
ha t a ke

p ro lu idcino e Kely( rsd n o Vitn Vigna a dta f re tec s t ti
es na j rs ito v r l a e ie t f no , r ii) n rnse rd h a e o h s
e
ditit Thi c t ns t d t pa te ,e t r d a dico y o de ,a s ttilt oc rs ve
src . s our co ule he ri s n e e
s ver r r nd e ra o cu e n
m ont l t r On J y 18, 1, wo w e ksbe or t s he e t i lda e M il rm oved f a
hs a e .
ul
201 t
e
f e he c dul d r a t , le
or
c tnua oft t i lda e a f pe m i s o t a arby t l phone c pl ni t ts
on i nce he ra t nd or r s i n o ppe
ee
, om ai ng ha he

c d nota f d t ta t t sdititt puruehe c s . Theco tde e M il rsm o i a
oul
for o r vel o hi src o s
r ae
ur ni d le ' ton nd
or r d he t pr de t c twih tmel no ii ai r a di whehe s plnne t be
de e r o ovi he our t i y tfc ton eg r ng
t r he n d o
pr s ntf rti on Aug t1 2011 ilri o medt c tha s di no i e t a a a
e e o ral
us ,
.M le nf r
he our t t he d t nt nd o ppe r t
t ti la s
he ra nd oughtavol a y dim is l Thec tnse d dimis d M ilrsca m f f itr
untr s s a .
our i t a s s e
le ' li or alte
t pros e.
o
ecut

Afe t dimis lKelys t$333148i at ne sfespurua t j 1
tr he s s a, le ough
. n tor y' e
s nt o 927,

a iin l a to pzs a t oRue 1 , n a o d re j iigM ilrfo fl f tr s is
ddto a sncins l u n t l 1 a d n r e n onn le r m ii ' u e ut
r
ng u
a an tKelya dhe h s a dwi o t ro j dca la .l s p o t he mo in Kely
g is l n r u b n t u p ir u iile ve n u p r of r to , le
e
h
hi hlghtd M ilrshit y wih he a he hus nd.Tha hit y r vea st ,i add ton t
g i e
le ' sor t r nd r ba
t sor e l hat n ii o
t c e ta f r ed he e, il rhasf l d s ti A da s Co mt Col a D i t i tCour
he as r ns e r
r M le
ie ui n
m
t y, or do sr c
t

(le igt tKelyc u e M ie t ls h rlw lc n ea dtr n t h r e n n y ; a an
algn ha le a s d l r o o e e a ie s n e miae e prg a c )2 g i
l
i Ada Count Col adoDititCour ( lgi t tKely' hus nd c us dM ilrt l e
n ms
y, or
src
tale ng ha le s ba a e le o os
he 1w lc ns a tnni t he pr na y) i De rCou y,Col a DititCour
r a ie e nd e nae r eg nc ;n nve nt
ordo src
t

(e kn t dso uino a alg dc mmo -a mara et Kely sh s a ) i U..
s e ig he is lto f n l e o n lw rig o l ' u b nd ;n S
e
e
DititCour f t DititofCol a(le ngt tKely' hus
src
tor he src
umbi algi ha le s bandc usdM ilr
a e le
2TheAda sCount cour noedt tM ilrha s tKely a herhus nd aFa book mesageo M a
m
y
t t ha le d en le nd
ba
ce
s
n y
4, 0 whihsaedt t<lhopef not ng m o et n f ryout t la nt mea ng ofg ifb l i
201
c tt ha 1
or hi
r ha o
wo o e r he ni
re y osng

e eghn y ubohh v . ( tAt' Fe sEx C, t , C. No 3 . l a dt n tec u t oe ta Milr s
v l ig o t a e' Mo. ty e . a 5 E. F. . 8) n d ii ,h o r n td h t l ha
'
o
e
t cephysc l as a td Kele t tKele a herhus
wi
ialy s ule
ly, ha
ly nd
bandha obti d apr e i or ra ns M ilr a
ve ane
otctve de gai t le , nd

ta Mie s b te afre Ite t tec ut sa e hbi.(I a 8)
h t l r u mitd og d etr o h o r a n x i t Jl t .
l
-s

itn ina e to a d sr s)3a di I.. src Co r f rteDitito W y mi ( l gng
n e to l moin l ite s, n n Js Ditit u to h src f o ng al i
e
.

t tKel ' mohe-a ft ri lw c usdM ilri e i le i ldite s. ( ot
ha ley s t r nd ahe -n-a a e le ntntona motona srsl4 M .
At' Fe sExs C-H,E. F. 38. Ther pe i cou t ha dimis da1butoneoft e
ty e .
C. No. )
es ctve rs ve s s e 1
hes

c s s a d ama itaej d eh src mme d dd s sa i teo l c s sil e i g l
ae,n
g sr t u g a e o n e imisln h ny a e tlp ndn . n
a ton, M il ha t i e fl ba u c i Col r do, a d M il ra t m pt t m a c a m s
ddii
le te ed o ke l i
ler s w c ied nkz pt y n
oa 5 n

a i tKel y i t epr e ngsf vi ai nsoft Ba
gans le n hos oce di or ol to
he nknm t Cod sa omatc sa
cy
e' ut i t y
pr sons Thr
ovii . oughout M ilrha l veedi ulsa t ea soff ur ltga i a Ke ly a
, le s e l ns t nd hr t
ut e ii ton t le nd

he fmiy.M ilrsae i he DititofCol i c s t çlq r i not ngi t sword
rn l
le ttd n r src
umba a e hattthee s hi n hi l
t twile rdic age( r fom g s ngKely' hus
ha l ve sour he l r purui
le s bandl'( pl Mot Dimis6,
, Re y . s s
'
E. F. 23 , nds ha i or t sc tt tKelya he hus nd, contnui i
C. No. ) a he s nf med hi our ha le nd r ba by i ng n
t i c s ofc
her oure onduc,aet ani t msl sne cvi s t,'( pl Mot At' Fee 2,
t r t r ng he eve w i l uis' Re y. . ty s
e
E. F. 40) Thec t st c or r M ilrt rs t Kely' moton, s has
C. No. .
our ha wie deed le o e pond o le s i but he
of e ed ltl m or t n r t r t a l ga i a c i ue i c i
f r ite
e ha eie a ed le tons nd ontn d nve tve.
I
I.

Kelys e satr e ' f e , d i o a s n t n , n a o d r non n M i e fo
l e k to n y s e s a dt n l a ci s a d n r e e j ii g l r' m
e
i
o
l r
fl gftles i a an tKelya dh rh s a dwih u p ir u iilla e Und rte
ii u t ut g i s le n e u b n t o t ro j d ca e v . e h
n
r s

3I t tca e,M ilrfld ar y t amo i t dimisi whih s cald Kely a' a,su dwoma
n ha s
le ie epl o
ton o s s n c he le le d t t pi
f
n
wih ba teh a ugl har' Keley' s a iob xi ,iltrt br ggaf'a he daug e at e e nwih a
t d e t nd y i'; l s on n l no ous lieae a z - nd r
htr i t e t
pr

b e g t' Mie v. slr 11 c 75 ( D. 2 1 ( pyMo . s s 4, C. No. 3 .
e r u . l r Ke se, :1v 3 D. C. 01 ) Re l tDimis E. F. 2 )
' l
4Milrcame i ta cs ta ihsp rnsi a rie ( l y' h s n )rg t'h nh wo l n t
le li d n h t ae h t f i ae t t d asd Kel s uba d ih 'te e ud o
h
e
h v e d dhsrlto s pwihMilr Mie v Kese, l 2 2 7( Wy 2 1 ( mp. , C. No 1.
a e n e i eainhi t le. l r . slr2:1v 9 D. o. 01 ) Co l3 E. F . )
l
5M ilr s l es ba upt y flng wasdoc t i Col a asNo. 1 - 8 ABC t nc. Col.Oc .
le ' at t nkr c ii
ke ed n or do
1351 2
Ba lr D. o, t
2 , 0l ) Th b n rpc c u te e tyds se tec s .Milrsoiia b n r pc tl gi d c ee i
6 2 l. e a k u ty o rr cnl imis d h ae le' rgn l a ku ty ii s o k td n
n
Colrd a No. 12 91 ABC l n r D. l ,uy1 , 01 ) Th b n rptyc u t sds se tecs , u
o a o s 1 -6 4
Ba k . Coo.Jl 8 2 1. e a k u c o rha imis d h ae b t

i i c r nty s heduld f aM ach7, 2 he rng o M ilr' motont r onsde t dimis l Be us oft
t s ure l c
e or
r
201 a i n le s i o ec i r he s s a. ca e he

a t ma i sa t a at c e p l u n t 1 U. . j3 2 dligt ep n e c o t o eb n r ptyp o e dng , h s
u o tc ty h t ta h d t s a t o 1 SC. 6 t n h e d n y f h s a k u c r c e i s t i
r
r
c tis d aN ove be 4, lm e ornd opi onandor e del ng isrui ont smotonuntlhelfig
our sue
m r 20l
m a um ni
d r ayi t lng hi
i
it itn
oft a oma i s a Tha say i notc r nty i pl c
he ut tc t y. t t s
ur e l n a e.

c r umsa spr e he e t cour maynoti
ic tnce es nt r , he
t
mpos snci l rj1 orRul 116 The
e a tons mde 927
e .

c u ti d , o v r t t h c u t h u de j i M ie fo fl f t r prps a to si t i
o r fn s h we e ,ha t e o r s o l n on l r r m ii u u e t e cin n hs
l
ng
diti ta ns Keley o he f m iy.
src gai t l r r a l

Th A1 W rt Ac, 8U.. j 1 51a ( 0 6 , uh rz sdsrc c u t t rsrc t e
e 1 is t 2 SC. 6 ( ) 2 0 ) a to ie itit o rs o e tit h
a e st f de alc t ofpa teswho r pe t dl fl fi ousltga i Cr e v. a tFo
cc s o e r our s
ri
e a e y ie r vol ii ton. om r Kr f ods

N. ,l ,390F. 81 81 ( h Ci.200 Ct
Am. nc.
3d 2, 7 4t r 4) undou e y,heA1W rt Ac ... a s
btdl t l is t grnt
f e a c t t a ho iy t lm i a e st t c t by ve tousandr pe ii
ed r l ours he ut rt o i t cc s o he ours
xai
e ttve

ltg n s. ,' .Pr-iig ij n to ss o l b i s dE p rngy' u a ewarn e u d r
i a t . .) efl nu cin h ud e mpo e d ai l'b t r ra td n e
i
'
n
s

û xg n cru tn e , u ha ali a tsc niu u a u eof h j iil r c s b tln
t ie t ic msa c s s c s i g n ' o t o s b s t e udca p o e s y ii g
e
t
n
meils a rpeii a tons' l a 81 8( tngBr v. rel 994F. 1 27,1
rte s nd e ttve ci . d. t 7-1 quoi ow Farly,
'
2d 0 038
( Ci.1 .TheFourh Cic tdie t dititc t t e uaet f l ngfcor i
3d r 993)
t rui rcs src ours o val t he olowi a t s n

d tr n n wh te ap e fl ij n to i wa rn e ( )tepat shso yo ltg to ,n
eemii g eh r r -ii nu cin s ra td: 1 h ry' itr f iiain i
ng
6Kele s eksa t ne sfesunde 28U .S. j12 T t o epo so sae i p r:
ly e
tor y' e
r
C. 9 7. ha c d rviin tts n at
Any at neyorot rpe s ad itdt c
tor
he r on m te o onduc ca e i a c t t Unie Stt
t s s n ny our of he t d aes

o ayTertr tee f os mut istepoedn si aycs u rao a yad
r n ri y h ro wh o li e h rce ig n n ae nesnbl n
o
pl

ve tousy ma ber uiedby t c r t stsypes ly t e es coss expe es
xal l y eq r
he ou t o a if ronal he xc s t, ns ,
a at ne 'fesr as
nd tor ys e e onabl i ure be us ofs h c
y nc r d ca e uc onduc.
t

A l e a c n tu to o j 1 2 l t i a pl aint atr e sa dn t opr s lt a t l e
i rl o sr ci n f 9 7 i s t p i t o to n y n o t o e ii n s i
t
mi s c o
g
k
M ilr W hienet rt Supr meCour nort Fou t Cic tha s ctcal a e s t squesi
le . l ihe he
e
t he rh r ui ve pe ii ly ddrs ed hi
ton,

tep e aln o iina n tedsrc c u ti ti crutst tj12 d e n t p yt os
h rv i g pno mo g h itit o rs n hs ic ii ha 9 7 o s o a pl opr e
i
ltga s Se e..Shapv.
ii nt. e. g , r Town ofK it HawkN . ,No. 1 CV-I BR , lW L 5520432,a #1
tv
C.
2: I3- 20l
t

( D. . No .l , 01 )Pati v Re s, . :9 2 5 MBS 2 0WL 3 5 9 0 a * n. ( SC.
E. N C. v 4 2 1; ran . ee No 30 - 41 - , 01
2 7 7 , t 2 4 D..
J l 1 , 01 )(e ot n rc mme d to )a o td 2 1 WL 3 7 91( S. Aug 1 2 0, b t
uy 3 2 0 rp ra d e o n ain , d ne , 0 0
25 9 D. C. . 6, 01 )Ab ot
.
v S nrs Mo t .n .No. : c 6 5 2 0 WL 9 2 7 a *-8( D. . r 8 2 0 ) Bacrv. l
. u tut rg.lc , 308 v 6 , 0 9
71 6 , t 7 E. Va Ap . , 0 9 ; la Bel
& Aso s.
s c.LLC, 9 F. u p 2 6 , 9( D. . . 0 3, f d 8 Fe Ap x 51 (t Ci. 0 3,
2 5 S p . d 35 63 N. W Va 2 0 )af , 3 d. p'. 9 4h r 2 0 )
.
seas Me d wb irHo frChi rn l . . mn 81F.d5 , 3 (t Ci.9 6 ; a swe v
e lo a o ra me o l e .nc v Gt , 3 21 5 5 5h r1 9 ) S so r .
d
Fil, 7 F 2 75 8 (dCi.1 9 .Thi c ut ge swi teoh rc u t i ti dsrc a dfn sta
ed 9 3 . d , 0 2 r 9 2) s o ra re t h te o rs n hs itit n id h t
h
j 1 27i i p l a l h r .
9 s na p i b e e e
c
Ast KelysRue1 moin tetsf h ro ' r vso o ( l 1 ) rcu etesr n
o le ' l 1 to ,h t ae ab r p o iins f Rue 1 p e ld h evig
t
a tlng ofan Rul l1m o i a t c usonoft ca e. Huntrv.Ea t ansCo.Ba r 281F.
nd ii
y e
ton fer oncl i
he s '
'
e
rhgr i
ke y,
3d

1 4 1 2(t Ci. 0 2 . e as j s 1 Cû ad cso rn ee p ir otetaeh r o ' me d n i
4 , 5 4h r2 0 ) se lo . n.2 l e iin e d rd ro t h sf ab r a n met n
,
é
n
1
993,weo er t tno a ol etm elm i gove ne Rul l1motons and c i atonsoftm ei s
bs ved ha
bs ut i i t
r d e
i ,
onsder i
i lne s

çr e utbl, n musber sle o ac s b c s a ay i.'( u tn I r Ku slr 91 F.d5 5
ae q i e a d t eov d n ae y ae n lss') q oig n e nte, 4 2 0 ,
a
'
5l (t Ci. 9 0 ) Th isa t to wa tldo Au ut5 2 l , fe tec u t imisdtec s
3 4h r 1 9 ). e ntn moin sie n g s , 0 l atr h o r ds se h ae
wi peu iea dsrc ifo teatv d c e.Th stec u t yn ti o esn to su d rRue
t rj dc n tu k tr m h cie o k t u ,h o r ma o mp s a cin n e l
h
11
.

patculrwhehe s hasfl ve tous haasi o d iai lws t ( whehe t
ri a
t r he ied xai , r sng, r uplc tve a uis;2) t r he
pa t flshe c s sonagood f t bassoronl t haa s ( t e e oft bur n o t
ry ie r a e
aih i
y o rs ; 3) he xtnt he de n he

c u t a doh rp risr s tn fo t epa t sfln s a d( )t a e ua yo atr aie
o rs n te a t e ul g r m h ry' i g ; n 4 he d q c f len tv
e
i
i
s n to .I . t8 8 l ap efln ij n to i warn e ,ts o l b n ro yti rdt ft
a cins d a 1 . f r -iig nu cin s ra td i h u d e ar wl al e o i
o
t cr u sa sa is l
he i c m t nce t s ue. d.

M i e' c n u t stv l meisanar wl d a p etln ij n to FrtM i e
l rs o d c po iiey rt ro y rwn r -iig n u cin. is, l r
l
l
ha a hit y offlng vexa i , r s i a duplc tve l w s t . She hasus d he
s s or
ii
tous ha a sng, nd
i a i a uis
e r
know l dge oft l ls t m t brng num e ous l w s t a i tK e l y and herf m iy i a
e
he ega ys e o i
r
a uis ga ns le
n l n
m uliude off r s a r st co r N otone o t e l ws t ha s ce de on t m e is
tt
o um c os he unt y.
f hos a uis s uc e d
he rt .
Se ond,t r i no i c ton t tM il r spur e i t lng t e l w s t i a hi
c
he e s ndi a i ha le ' pos n i i hes a uis s nyt ng
ot rt n t ha as K e l y a he f m iy. R a he t n usng he f lng t m a l ga
he ha o r s le nd r a l
t r ha i
r ii s o ke e l
a g e s s us s t
r um nt , he e hem t hea s n a rdi ul on Kele a he f m iy. Se e g. M il r
o p cor nd i c e
l y nd r n l
e. . , le

v. slr 1: 1 v753( D. 2011 (ttngi arpl t amoto t dimist tKele wa a
Kese , 1 c
D. C. ) sai n e y o
in o s s ha ly s
S a ,supi wom a wih bad t e h a ugl ha r' t tKele s s n w asa d
çt t d
f
n t
e t nd y i ' ha
;
l y' o
nç
obnoxi ,ilt r t
ous lie a e

b a i'a t tKely' da e wasat ee nwihabee gut' .And, ve muli e
r gga ; nd ha le s ughtr
t te t
pr
r .)
'
gi n tpl
o ru te i muli ef ms M ilrhasr peae y f ld t s es f l pr e ut e n one
ppo tnii s n tpl onl , le
e tdl aie o ucc s uly os c e ve
ofhe c am s Thr
r l i . oughout he lng eha bee s tf l i c nt a t eae ng.
, r a uag s n pie u , nde e , nd hr tni
Thid, he e i noque ton t tM ilrsflngsha b de d t c t a ot rpa tes
r t r s
si ha le ' ii
ve ur ne he ours nd he ri .
The c t i w hi h M il rha ap a e ha e nde unt d r our es a e s ng he flngs
our s n
c
le s pe r d ve xpe d ol es c ddr s i
r ii .
Li w i e Kele a he f m iy ha be n f ce t de e t m s l s ag ns m erte sc a m s
ke s , l y nd r n l ve e or d o f nd he e ve ai t il s l i
i c t a r st c
n ours c os he ount y.
r
Fourh, t r tve s nc i a e i de t i t s c s
t ale na i a tons r na qua e n hi a e.The c t s e a ne
our ha xpl i d

ele r i t sopi ont tRul 11a j1 aei pplc bl hee.W hiet c tc d
swhee n hi ni ha e nd 927 r na ia e r
l he our oul

us isi r ntpo rt mone a iy s nc i M il ,s e Chnmbe sv.
e t nhe e
we o
t rl a ton ler e
r NASCO.l . 501U .
nc,
S.

3 45 46( 991, rrce ba uptyflngsc td onhe a lt t pa s has ncin.
2, - 1 )he e nt nkr c ii as oubt
r biiy o y uc a to
I add ton,M ilrha i or e t sco t ha Kel y a he hus nd,by c i ng i t r
n ii
le s nf m d hi ur t t le nd r ba
ontnui n hei

c u s o c n u t aet a nn te ev sn w cv l ut. ( pl. o. t Fe s2 E. F.
o re f o d c, r û r ig h ms le e ii s is' Re y M t At' e , C.
e
'
y
No. ) AndM ilrsae i he DititofCol ac s t tCll r i not ngi t sword
40.
le ttd n r src
umbi a e ha lthee s hi n hi l
t twile rdic ag g r fom ( s ngKely' hus ndl' ( pl M ot Dimis6,
ha l ve sour e hej r purui
le s ba . Re y . s s
'

E. F. 2 . Th c u th r fr fn si u l eyt a a ys n to s r o ap e fl
C. No. 3) e o r t eeo e d t ni l h t n a cin ho t f r -ii
k
ng
ij cinwi d trMilr
nun to l ee l .
l
e
Laty a ij n to p o i t gM i e fo fl gf tr os a to a an t l y
sl, n n u cin r hbin l r rm ii uu epr e cins g is Kel
i
l
n
e
a he f m iy i t sditi ti na r y t ior d t ftt s c fccic sa esa is By
nd r a l n hi src s rowl al e o i he pe ii r um t nc t s ue.
flngm uli epr s a tons M il rha us d t lga s t m t ha a sKele a he f miy
ii
tpl o e c i , le s e he e l yse o r s
ly nd r n l
w ihouti uni t ex ns ofa a t y. A sa r ul, lc ns a t ne ve sM il r s
t
nc ng he pe e n tonw
es t no i e ed tor y t le '
c pl i s be or s f l t . By r quii M il rt fl t ough c
om a nt f e he ies hem
e rng le o ie hr
ouns lbef e s ng Kele
e
or ui
ly
orhe f m iy, he co ts e t e ur a s r s c t
ra l t
ur e ks o ns e obe e ond houghtbef r tlng,r s rc M il r s
o e i i e ti t le '
a ce st t c t t t l s e e ne s a y,pr e tKele and he f m iy f om ve to
c s o he ours o he ea t xt nt ce s r ot c
ly
ra l r
xa i us

l iaini h rh medsrc, n ti rteij n to t tep riulrcr u tn e o t i
i g to n e o itit a d al h nu cin o h a t a ic msa c s f hs
t
o
c
Case.

1
11.

F rt era o ssae ,h c u t le tra ij n to p o iii M ilrfo fln
o h e s n ttd t e o r wil n e n nu cin r hbtng le r m iig
f t epr s a tons a ns K e l y orhe f m iy i t sdit i t
u ur / e c i
gai t le
r n l n hi src .
-

C

ENTER : hi 6t da ofM a c 201
t s h y
r h, 2.
'
A,
. .
.
'
z
.

A

.

.'

A

y

I
TED STA TES D I
STRI JUD GE
CT