Turner v. Digital Broadcast Corporation et al
Filing
40
MEMORANDUM OPINION & ORDER denying 32 Motion for Leave to Appeal; denying 24 Motion to Quash. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 07/08/2011. (rkc)
CL S DFFI t. . T COURT
EM
CE Js De .
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED
JUL 2s 2 1
21
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TE S DI
STRI CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E DI SI
VI ON
J C,
ULW DUDA CLERK
BY:
STEV EN T UR NE R ,
C i lActi N o.7: :vvi
on
10- 00559
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM O M N DU M O PINION & O R DER
V.
D I I L BR OA D CA ST
G TA
C O RPO R ATI N ,e aI,
O
t .
D ef
endant
s.
By:Sam uelG .W is
l on
U ni ed St es D i ri Judge
t
at
st ct
On M a 20,2011, he co tde ed def nda s Di t Br dca tng Cor a i
y
t
ur ni
e nt gial oa s i
por ton
(i ' a dZa myvao I c',t p', to t d s s f rlc o pes n l u idcin
t
DBC' n p t c m,n .s (t ' mo in o imis o a k f ro a j rs ito
)
Za )
a or r d pl i if St ve Tt wr t s
nd de e antf, e n m , o ubmi e d ede onsr tngt tDBC a Za ha
t vi enc m tai ha
nd p ve
prnc pa pl e ofbus ne s out i ofV igi a s t tt c tc d a c t n whe he di r iy
i i l ac s
i s
s de
r ni o ha he our oul s erai
t r ve st
j rs ito e it i t i c s .Nete pat d s ue ta teei dv riyJ rs ito ( mp .
u idcin x ss n h s ae i r ry ip ts h t h r s ie st ' id cin. Co l
h
u
3'Des'M e Supp. ot Dimis1. nrs et t co tsoder Tur rfld a afda t
, f. m.
M . s s )I e pons o he ur' r , ne ie n fi vi
a o ni by s ve a docl e sfo va i s ur s DBC a Zap c le d t
cc mpa ed
e r l tm nt r m rous o ce .
nd
hal nge he
a s i lt oft e doc e s t h t sild notcon es t e se e ofdi r iy
dmisbiiy hes
um nt, houg hey tl o
t t he xit nc
ve st
j rs ito .l ef c,
u idcin n fe tDBC a dZAP aeakngt ec u tornd ra o i inr g r iga
n
r s i h o r t e e n p n o e adn
hypo he i a ,a il r di put t tcon r s a i s u n w hi h t pa tesuli a el a e
t tc l nc la y s e ha
t ol n s ue po
c he r i tm t y gr e.
The c t ilnotdo s The e or t c t ilde de e nt 'm oton t quas t e bis
our w l
o.
r f e, he our w l ny f nda s
i o
h he xhi t
fl d by Tur r l
ie
ne .
DBC a Za as mov f lav l r28U. C.j 1 b t fl ali elcut y
nd p lo ed or e e mde
S. 292() o ie r ntro or
a p a o t sc u tse riro d rrg r igp ro a j rs ito
p e l f hi o r' a l r e e a dn es n lu idcin.Thec u t o sn tfn ta
e
o r d e o id h t
1Thec tsde a ofdef nt m o i t qua h i no mea t sgna isfndi t tt ei di r iy
our' nil
enda s' ton o s s t nt o i l t i ng ha her s ve st
j rs ito i ti c s .
uidcin n hs a e
'
M
isea leropi on i vestac r lng que to ofl w ast whi h t r i s t nta gr
t ri
ni nvol û ontoli
si n a
o c he e s ubsa il ound
f dif r nceofopi on'ort tta i e a ea alfom t or rmay ma e i ly ad
or fe e
ni ' ha dn mm dit ppe r he de
t ral vanc
e
t uli t tnui tonoft ltgai .' 28U. C.j 1 b) s ealo Coo - tsv. e
he tmae e nai
he ii tonll'
S. 292( ; e s
keBae Bav r
Cor , 0W L 478 38, * ( D.Va.
p.201
98 at 2 E.
Nov.16 201 (uoi Fn n v.CSX Tr p.I .
, 0) q tng nni
ans .nc,
1 W L 42583,a * ( hCi.Apr 26 1 9)(d ri c tonf i el ut ya a i a
989
t 2 4t r . 98 i tt ai or ntroc or ppe l s n
ce i
çxtaodi r rmedy'a l eo y i dxce i lst to .') Theef e t c twil
e r r nay e
vaiabl nl n e ptona iuains''. r or,he our l
de de e nt 'm o i n f la t a a t sco tsea lero de .
ny f nda s to or e ve o ppe l hi ur' ri r r
Fo t r s ns sat he e n,i i he e O RD ERED a A DJUD G ED t tde e nt '
r he ea o t ed r i t s r by
nd
ha f nda s
m otonst quas Tur ' e de e a f l ve t t l a i e l ut y a a a e D ENI .
i o
h ner s vi nc nd or ea o i e n nt r oc or ppe l r
ED
'
*
>
L
;
.
,.
.
.e
'
xve
x'
ENTER :J y 8,
ul 2011
.
ED STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?