Turner v. Digital Broadcast Corporation et al

Filing 40

MEMORANDUM OPINION & ORDER denying 32 Motion for Leave to Appeal; denying 24 Motion to Quash. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 07/08/2011. (rkc)

CL S DFFI t. . T COURT
EM
CE Js De .
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

JUL 2s 2 1
21
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TE S DI
STRI CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E DI SI
VI ON

J C,
ULW DUDA CLERK
BY:

STEV EN T UR NE R ,
C i lActi N o.7: :vvi
on
10- 00559
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM O M N DU M O PINION & O R DER

V.

D I I L BR OA D CA ST
G TA
C O RPO R ATI N ,e aI,
O
t .
D ef
endant
s.

By:Sam uelG .W is
l on
U ni ed St es D i ri Judge
t
at
st ct

On M a 20,2011, he co tde ed def nda s Di t Br dca tng Cor a i
y
t
ur ni
e nt gial oa s i
por ton

(i ' a dZa myvao I c',t p', to t d s s f rlc o pes n l u idcin
t
DBC' n p t c m,n .s (t ' mo in o imis o a k f ro a j rs ito
)
Za )
a or r d pl i if St ve Tt wr t s
nd de e antf, e n m , o ubmi e d ede onsr tngt tDBC a Za ha
t vi enc m tai ha
nd p ve
prnc pa pl e ofbus ne s out i ofV igi a s t tt c tc d a c t n whe he di r iy
i i l ac s
i s
s de
r ni o ha he our oul s erai
t r ve st

j rs ito e it i t i c s .Nete pat d s ue ta teei dv riyJ rs ito ( mp .
u idcin x ss n h s ae i r ry ip ts h t h r s ie st ' id cin. Co l
h
u
3'Des'M e Supp. ot Dimis1. nrs et t co tsoder Tur rfld a afda t
, f. m.
M . s s )I e pons o he ur' r , ne ie n fi vi
a o ni by s ve a docl e sfo va i s ur s DBC a Zap c le d t
cc mpa ed
e r l tm nt r m rous o ce .
nd
hal nge he
a s i lt oft e doc e s t h t sild notcon es t e se e ofdi r iy
dmisbiiy hes
um nt, houg hey tl o
t t he xit nc
ve st

j rs ito .l ef c,
u idcin n fe tDBC a dZAP aeakngt ec u tornd ra o i inr g r iga
n
r s i h o r t e e n p n o e adn
hypo he i a ,a il r di put t tcon r s a i s u n w hi h t pa tesuli a el a e
t tc l nc la y s e ha
t ol n s ue po
c he r i tm t y gr e.
The c t ilnotdo s The e or t c t ilde de e nt 'm oton t quas t e bis
our w l
o.
r f e, he our w l ny f nda s
i o
h he xhi t
fl d by Tur r l
ie
ne .

DBC a Za as mov f lav l r28U. C.j 1 b t fl ali elcut y
nd p lo ed or e e mde
S. 292() o ie r ntro or

a p a o t sc u tse riro d rrg r igp ro a j rs ito
p e l f hi o r' a l r e e a dn es n lu idcin.Thec u t o sn tfn ta
e
o r d e o id h t
1Thec tsde a ofdef nt m o i t qua h i no mea t sgna isfndi t tt ei di r iy
our' nil
enda s' ton o s s t nt o i l t i ng ha her s ve st

j rs ito i ti c s .
uidcin n hs a e

'
M

isea leropi on i vestac r lng que to ofl w ast whi h t r i s t nta gr
t ri
ni nvol û ontoli
si n a
o c he e s ubsa il ound
f dif r nceofopi on'ort tta i e a ea alfom t or rmay ma e i ly ad
or fe e
ni ' ha dn mm dit ppe r he de
t ral vanc
e

t uli t tnui tonoft ltgai .' 28U. C.j 1 b) s ealo Coo - tsv. e
he tmae e nai
he ii tonll'
S. 292( ; e s
keBae Bav r
Cor , 0W L 478 38, * ( D.Va.
p.201
98 at 2 E.
Nov.16 201 (uoi Fn n v.CSX Tr p.I .
, 0) q tng nni
ans .nc,
1 W L 42583,a * ( hCi.Apr 26 1 9)(d ri c tonf i el ut ya a i a
989
t 2 4t r . 98 i tt ai or ntroc or ppe l s n
ce i
çxtaodi r rmedy'a l eo y i dxce i lst to .') Theef e t c twil
e r r nay e
vaiabl nl n e ptona iuains''. r or,he our l
de de e nt 'm o i n f la t a a t sco tsea lero de .
ny f nda s to or e ve o ppe l hi ur' ri r r
Fo t r s ns sat he e n,i i he e O RD ERED a A DJUD G ED t tde e nt '
r he ea o t ed r i t s r by
nd
ha f nda s
m otonst quas Tur ' e de e a f l ve t t l a i e l ut y a a a e D ENI .
i o
h ner s vi nc nd or ea o i e n nt r oc or ppe l r
ED
'
*
>

L
;

.
,.
.

.e
'

xve

x'

ENTER :J y 8,
ul 2011
.
ED STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U