Turner v. Digital Broadcast Corporation et al

Filing 97

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER directing the Clerk to file the billing records under seal. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 01/05/2012. (rkc)

D FM s OFFI U..DI COURT
J
CE S ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

J 25 2 1
AN
21
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E D I I O N
V SI

JULI C.
A DUD

B
K

f
W

STEVEN TUR NER ,
Ci lA cton N o.7: c 00559
vi
i
10- vPl nt f ,
ai i f

M EM O R DA N D UM O PI O N A ND
NI
O R DER

DI TAL BRO ADCAST
GI
C O R PO M TIO N ,etal,
.
D ef
endant
s.

By:Sam uelG .W is
l on
U nied St es Di t ctJudge
t
at
s ri

Thi i anaci bypli if Stve Tur r a i tdefnda s Di t lBr dc si
ss
ton
antf , e n ne , gans e nt, gia oa a tng

Co p rto (
r o ain DBC)a d Za myt c m,n . Za ) as bsd ayo DBC, le igb e c o
n p v.o Ic ( p , u iir f
algn ra h f
c n rc a du j s e rc me t n se n d caao yrle a da a c unig. Tu e i a
o ta t n nu t n ih n a d e kig e lrtr eif n n c o tn 1 m r s
f r CEO and pr sde ofDBC a Za a ale dl de l
o mer
e i nt
nd p nd lge y veopedt i e lc ua pr ry a
he nt le t l ope t t
i s i t sca ewhie wor ng f t m .Za ha m ove t diqua iy c
s ue n hi s
l
ki or he
p s
d o s lf ouns l cam i t t
e , li ng ha
t l w 51 1 e e e i Tunw r i t sc e pr vi l r pr e t d Za on m a t r t t
he a % r pr s ntng
n hi as e ousy e es n e
p
t e s ha

itrwiet es be t te o tec re ts ia a ac nsq e c c n o r p e e t r e
ne t n h u j c matr f h ur n ut nd s o e u n e a n t e rs n Tu n r
he e Tt w rhasr ponded t tw he he waspr s de ofZa he e ge hi cu r nt1 w 511
r. m
es
ha
n
e i nt
p
nga d s r e a
71
per ona l a t t i a e nt hi c r ntcl i sa e u e a e t w or t thi c r nt1 w
s ly nd ha , n ny ve , s ur e a m r nr l t d o
k ha s ur e a
f r m a ha pe f m ed f Za l ef or t r s ve t diqualf c ton m o i t c r
im y ve r or
or p. n f t o e ol he s i i a i
ton, he ou t

die t dTur rsc
rce
ne ' ouns lt s
e o ubmi hi fr ' bilng r c dsr ltngt t e rirr pr s nt to
t s im s li e or e ai o he a le e e e ai n
f ri came a r vi w. Tur rhass
o n
r e e
ne
ubmit t bilngr c ds cai st er cor a e
ted he li e or , l m hos e ds r
pr e t by t a t y- i n prvieg ha m ove t s alt m ,a t m a tr i bef r t
ot c ed he tonw cle t i l e, s
d o e he nd he te s o e he
1D BC i aD ea aecor ai t tcli t ha isprncpa pl eofbusnes i D ea e, a Za i
s
lw r por ton ha ams o ve t i i l ac
i s n lwar nd p s
a Nev c o a i t tc ai st have isprnc pa pl e ofbus ne s i D e a a e. Tur rcl m st be a r i nt
ada om r ton ha l m o
t i i l ac
i s n lw r
ne ai o
esde

o Vigna Th p riscam diest u idito o t sbai.
f rii. e a t li v ri rs cin n hi ss
e
yj

, ERK
CL

c to t tmoton.Howe r e h bilpur rst bef rg r lr pr s nt ton ofZa a
our n ha
i
ve , ac l po t o o ene a e e e a i
p nd
doesnota
ppea t i de any a t ne c i ntprvie t tTur rm i ha .2 I de ,i t
r o nva
tor y- le
i l ge ha
ne ght ve n ed f he
bil di c os prvieg c m uni atons t y w o d s m t be Za sprvie
ls s l e i l ed om
c i , he
ul ee o
p' i l ged

co muni tons Unde t cr um sa s t c twildie tClr t fl t bilngr or
m
cai .
r he ic t nce ,he our l r c e k o ie he li ec ds
unde s alwhe et y m a beviwe by t pari t t sltgai n a t uns alt bilng
re
r he
y
e d he tes o hi ii to nd o e he li
r or a e f r he ar e by Tur rora c a m o prvie by Za
ec ds bs nt u t r gum nt
ne
l i f i l ge
p.
Fo t r as s a e a ve t Cl r oft sco ti O R DER ED t fl t bilng
r he e ons t t d bo , he e k hi ur s
o ie he li
r o dsunde s al I t r a e no f t rprvie c a m s by t pa tesw ihi s ve days t
ec r
r e . f he e r
ur he i l ge l i
he r i
t n e n
, he

c twildiec t Clr t uns a t rco ds
our l r t he e k o e l he e r .

)
f

EN TER : a r 5, 2.
J nua y 201

- ...
<
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

2Thea t ne cle prvie mus benar y c tue be us i i e f r wihthetuh s e ng
tor y- int i lge t
rowl onsr d ca e t ntr ees t t r t e ki

miso o telga p o e s'I r Grn J l S b e a 41 F.d3 8(t Ci. 0 5 (u tn o UntdSae v
sin f h e l r c s. n e a d u' u po n , 5 3 3 4h r2 0 ) q oig n i tts .
'
y
e
Te dr 8 F.d 1 3 ,1 41(t Ci. 9 6) lwil erc r ie ûnl t tev r lmi de tn t t. .
d e, 01 2 4 7 4 4h r 1 8 ). t lb e o z d t y o h ey i t xe tha .
o
e
e udi r lva e de hasapublcgoodta c ndi t no m al pr
xcl ng ee nt vi nce
i
r ns e ng he r ly edom i prnci eofutlzng a1
nant i pl
iii l

rto a me n fracrann tetuh'l .rl n o Trmme v. ie Sae , 4 U. 40 5 (98 ).I
ain l a s o setiig h rt. d (eyig n a l Untd tts 4 5 S. , 0 1 0) n
'
ke pi wih t epr nc pl s t a t ne c i ntprvie doe no no m a l e e t ato ne bilng r or .
e ng t hes i i e , he tor y- le i l ge s t r ly xt nd o t r y li ec ds

UntdSae v ( d rS a) 3 F.d3 2 3 4(t Ci. 9 4 (iigUntdSae v ( d rS a)7 4F2 6 4,
i tts .Un e e l, 3 3 4 , 5 4h r 1 9 ) ct
e
n i tts .Un e e l, 7 .d 2
e
6 8(t Ci.1 8 )c r. e id 4 5U..1 0 ( 9 6 )seas RMLCop. Asta c Co. fAm.No. 2
2 4h r 9 5 , etd ne , 7 S 1 8 1 8 ), e lo
.
r v. st n e o
r
, CH0 1 7 2 0 WL 3 0 5 3 a * ( Ci. . t2 2 0 )(eyn o P tl . lsn, . . 7 1 9 , 0 0WL
2 ,0 2
2 7 21 , t 7 Va. r CtOc. 5, 0 2 rlig n ae v Alio No C19 -3 8 2 0
3 6 0 2 ( . rCtOc. 0, 0 0).Bil grc r srv aigted t a da u t fp y nt n t ie tt
3 5 0 2 Va Ci. . t3 2 0 ) li e od e eln h ae n mo n o a me a d he d ni
n
y
oft pes maki t pa e saenotprvie be us t s fct donotr vea a hi a
he rons
ng he ym nt r
i lged ca e he e a s
e l nyt ng boutt ad ce
he vi

s u h o gv n. tdSae v I r GrndJuvMatr 7 9F. u p 6 3 6 5( Md 1 9 )
o g t r ie Uni tts .n e a t' t , 8 S p . 9 , 9 D. . 9 2 .
e
e