England v. Astrue

Filing 22

ORDER denying 13 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 15 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting Report and Recommendations re 19 . Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/16/11. (med)

O-R 'oF iEUs A 'c v
E KS gc .. c ou
ATRoANoc ,
vA
FI ED
L

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I T C O U RT
C
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E D I ISIO N
V

N2V l6 2 1
01
JUL
% '

,
DU

,
CLERK
E

LA UR A A.EN G LAN D ,

Ci lA c i N o.7: c 569
vi t on
10- vPl nt f ,
ai i f
FI A L O R DER
N
V.

M I AEL J.A STRU E.
CH
C om m i s oner ofSoc alSe ur t
si
i
c iy,

By:Judge Jam e C .Tur
s
k
Seni Uni ed St es D i ri Judge
or
t
at
st ct

D ef
endant
.

Pli if La a A. Englnd s
antf ur
a ought r viw of Deenda M ihae J Asr e' (he
ee
f nt c l . tu s t
icommisone' fnal de son de ng he cams f s e ntl scurt i me a
t
si r' i
)
cii
nyi
r li or upplme a e iy nco
nd
di a e w i w ' be ft und rt Soc a Se urt A c . The Cou tr f r e t m a t rt U nie
s bl d do s ne is e he i l c iy t
r e e r d he te o t d
St t s M ag s r t J e B. W a
ae
i t a e udg
ugh Crgl r f a Re r a Re om m e ton pur ua t 28
i e or
po t nd c
nda i
s nt o

U. C. 6 6 b ()B) Th M a itaeJ g s b e u nl flds c ar p r ( tNo.1 )a d
S. j 3 ( )1( . e gsrt ud e u s q e ty ie u h e o t Dk .
9 n

t P an ifo j ce ( . . 0 .
he litf be td DktNo 2 )
I a co da e w ih t ac om pa ng M e o a um O pi on, a f t r a ons s t
n e r nc
t he c
nyi
m r nd
ni
nd or he e s
e
f t t r i i i he eby
orh he e n, t s r
O RD ER ED AN D A DJUD G ED

t t Englnd' ob e tons ar OVERRULED, t M a srt J
ha
a s j ci
e
he
gitae udge' Repo t a
s
r nd
Re omme ton i ADOPTED I FULL,Defnda ' Moton f Summay J
c
ndai s
N
e nts i or
r udgme ( .
nt Dkt

No. 1 ) i GRANTED, a Pli ifs M oton fr Summay J
5 s
nd antf'
i o
r udgme ( t No. 1 i
nt Dk .
3) s
D ENIED .
The Cl k ofCourti diect t s rke t cas f t actve docketoft courtand t
er
s r ed o t i he e rom he i
he
o
s a cerii copy oft s Fi O r ,as w el ast accom panyi M em or
end
tfed
hi nal der
l he
ng
andum Opi on,t
ni o

c
ouns lofr c d f rt pari .
e
e or o he tes

E
NTER:Ths /( a o No e e, 0 1
i
y f vmbr2 1
J
a e C.Tur
m s
k
Se o U nie St t D i ti J e
ni r t d a es s rd udg

8