Via v. Wilhelm et al

Filing 27

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 06/21/2011. (kab)

SOFFI U,. ST. URT
CE S DI K
AT RQANOKE,
VA
FI FD
LT
,
'

J 2 21
UN
01
I T H E U NI
N
TED STATES DISTR I T C O U R T
C
FO R THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI
BA RR Y LY N N V I ,#1
A
0255
21

J A C. ' - ' CLERK
ULI ' ' - j
BY;
DE
CL
ERK

CI I A C TI N N O .7: 1C V0050
V L
O
1

Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM O M N D U M OPINIO N
V S.

B. W I
G. LHELM , AL.
c
.

By: Samue G.W is
l
lon
Unied St esD i ri Judge
t
at
st ct

D ef
endant
s.

Pli ifBar Lynn Vi brngst sa tonpurua t 42 U. C.j 1 3.Vi alege i
antf ry
a i hi ci
s nt o
S.
98
a l sn

hi Co ai t tdee nt,i vi sa t Vigi aDe rme ofCore tons(d
s mpl nt ha fnda s ndi dual t he r ni pa t nt
rci C
VDOC',
'
)
t Re Oni Stt Prs ($
he d
on ae ion (
ROSP' a t Augusa Coreci l Ce er vi aed hi
' nd he
)
t
r tona nt , olt
s
c tt i
ons iutonalr g s by f l e y c r ng hi wih t di ci i r of ens of i ii t rot o
i ht
a s l ha gi
m t he s plna y f e
nc tng o i r

rotng a by f ii t pr de hi wih hallme aspa tofhi dit The c e i c r nty
i i nd
alng o ovi
m t
a at
r
s e.
as s ure l

b f r t c u to Vi' d lmoins fr p ei n r ij nci n o d rn ( )t a ROS
eo e he o r n a s ua to o r l ay nu to s r eig 1 h t
mi
P
W a de Tr y S.Ra kee cor e tonalof i r La ge a La s n s pa a e f om t pl n if
r n ac
y
p rci
fce s r nd w o e r t d r
he ai tf

andt tt VDOC ta frt pli ifoutofROSP ( .No.1 ;and ( t te oy sa
ha he
r nse he antf
Dkt
2)
2) ha mpl ee t
ROSP pr dehi wih l galc e ,not r s r c a uno tuc e a es t t lw lbr r
ovi
m t e
opi s a y e vies nd bsr t d cc s o he a i a y

( .No.22) Upon rviw oft r c d,t c tde e bot ofVi smotonsrque tng
Dkt
.
e e
he e or he our nis h
a'
i e si

itro uo yij n tv r le .
nel c tr n u cie eifl

A dititc u t ho da r p ei n r ij n tv r le s ai gya o ywhe t e
src o r s ul wad rlmi ay nu cie eif p rn l nd nl n h
pa t s eki r i ha de onsr t d a t ,i i nt ir pa a e ha m ,a wela alkelhood
ry e ng elef s m ta e c ual mm ne , re r bl r s l s i i
ofs
uccesson t m ert Rum Cr CoalSal l v.Capert a 926 F. 353, ( h Ci.
he
is.
eek
ess nc.
on
2d
360 4t r
-

1Panifi rmi e ta t sp ran o l t hi moin frij n t erle a ta pan if tlh sa
litf s e nd d h thi etis ny o s to s o nu ci eif nd h t litf si a n
v
l
o p ru i t s b t ru nst tec u tnrs o s t d fnd ns moinfrsmmayj d me trg righi
p o tnt o u miag me t o h o r i e p n e o ee a t' to o u r u g n e adn s
y
cl m si t u ryi c pl nt
ai n he nde l ng om ai .

1 91; amigv. n ,1 9F.d2 4 2 3( t Ci. 9 7 ; r xIre. d v Bra t o h
9 ) M l p Hu t 1 3 5 , 6 4h r 1 9 ) Die sa l Lt . . e khruc
Me c lGr u 9 2F.d8 2 81 (t Ci. 9 )(iai no te ) A p ei nayij n to
dia o p, 5 2 0 , 2 4h r 1 91 ctto mitd . r lmi r nu cin
t m po arl af or a extaor na y r m edy prort t i lt tc n be gr nt d pe m a nty a tr
e r iy f ds n r di r e
i o ra ha a
a e r ne l fe

til a dt ep rys e ngt ep ei n r ij n to mus d mo srt : 1 b aç la
ra, n h a t e ki h r l a y nu cin t e n tae ( ) y s e r
mi
c
s ng,'ha hei lkeyt s ce dont me isa ti ;( t thei lkeyt s f
howi 't t s i l o uc e
he rt t ral 2) ha s i l o ufer

irpaa eham i t abs eofprlmi r rle '3)t tt balneeofeq te tpsi hi
re rbl r n he enc
ei nay eif ( ha he a
,
uiis i n s

fv r a ( )t a a ij n to i i tep bi itr s. e W itrv. t r l s De. u cl
a o ; nd 4 h t n n u cin s n h u lc nee t S e ne Nau a Re . f Co n i.
l ., 555U. 7(
nc
ai i f
hat he r e a e
ac n he
S. 2008) 2 The pl ntf m ustshow t t ir par bl hann hef esi t
.

a e e ofr le i t ihe r mot nors c a i butacuala i i nt'Die lr el Lt ,
bs nc
e if s t t r e e
ne
pe ultve,
t nd mm ne .' r x sa . d.
952 F. a 81 W ihouta s i t tpl i tf w ils f r i m i nt ir pa a e ha m , he
2d t 2. t
how ng ha a n if l ufe m ne , r e r bl r t

c u t amo g a titro uo yij n tv r le. m Cre Co lS ls l c, 2 F.da 3 0
o r c l t rn n elc tr n u cie eif Ru e k a ae s n .9 6 2 t 6 .
M oton # 1
i

l hi frtmoi n f r a p ei n r ij ncin,Vi cams t tROSP c re to a
n s is to o
rlmi ay nu to
a li ha
o rcin l
of i e s La ge a La s have ha as e as a t d a ve ba l a e hi . V i s a est tt
fc r r nd w on
r s d, s ule nd r ly bus d m
a t t ha he
a e wilcon i untlhe dr t l w s the fl a i t W a de Ra a he r ques s t t
bus l
tnue i
ops he a ui
ied ga ns
r n y nd
e
t ha
t VD O C ta f r hi t a dif r ntprs V i a t che doc e st hi m oton s i t t
he
r ns e m o
fee
i on. a ta d um nt o s i how ng ha
he s i t a e e genc gr e nc cl i i Lar a La s n a s ule hi on M a c 21
ubm ted n m r
y i va e a m ng
ge nd w o s a t d m
rh ,

W hie Vi m a vag and c l or aleg tonst td has be n i or e he wil
l a kes ue
oncus y l a i
ha t
he
e nf m d
l

co i t be a ed untlhedr pst ca e a i tW a de Tr cy S.Ra 'a t antf f a s
ntnue o
bus
i
o he s gans r n a
y' nd s i if e r
pl

2 The c tno es t t t Fourh Cicui' pr vi l e t bls d ba a ofha ds ps t t s t o i
our t ha he
t r ts e ousy- s a ihe l nce- - r hi es e ut n

Blc wed rF riue Co.o Sae vl v.S ii Ma ua trn Co,5 0F.d 1 9 (t Ci.1 7 ) i n lng r
a k le untr
f tts il el n fcuiM . 5 2 8 4h r 9 7 ,s o o e
e
g
a l a l. Re lTrt Ab u Ob ma I .v.
ppi be a uh o t a s nc FEC,5 5F.d 3 2 (t Ci.2 09 v c td b ,rma d d b ,cr.
c
7 3 4 4h r 0 ) a ae y e n e y et

ga td 10S. . 71 16L. . d74(01)raf e i patrmad db , 07F.d3 5(t Ci. 01)
rne, 3 Ct23 , 7 Ed 2 6 2 0,efi d n r,e n e y 6 3 5 4h r2 0
nn
(ç c u eo isdfee c swi teW itrts,heBlc wed rbaa c - -ad hpts ma n lng rb a pid
i a s ft ifrn e t h ne ett a k le ln eofh rs l et y o o e e p le
Be
h
i ga tn o d n n p ei nayijncinsi teFo rhCic i . .'
n rnig r e yig rl r nu to n h ut rut . .)
mi
'

f hi lf 'he s s f t onl a sngl e s ofal ge a e,whih oc ured on M ar h 21
or s ie'
et orh y i e piode
le d bus
c c r
c ,

2011.( .1 pp2- )
Dkt 2, 3.
Thec tdieced de e nt t r s
our r t
f nda s o e pondt Vi smoton andt ha dones W a de
o a'
i
hey ve
o. r n
Ra saes i a a fda t t the does nott e at sa f ha as ment s ul,ve ba a us or
y t t n n fi vi ha
olr e t f r s
,as a t r l b e

rt iton a ns i ts a t tROSP safpos no dange t Vi. ( .23- pp.2- )
ealai gai t nmae nd ha
tf e
r o a Dkt 1,
3.
Acc di t W a de Ra o M a c 21 2011Vi f ie t f l or r by ofi e sLa ge a
or ng o r n y, n r h ,
a a ld o olow de s
fc r r nd
La s r l t d t r m ovi hi ha uf s w hi h r s t d i a di c plna y c ge a ns Vi .
w on e a e o e
ng s ndc f , c e ule n
s i i r har gai t a
W a den Ra f t r not t t of i er La ge a La s s nor alas i ne s do noti ude
r
y urhe
es ha fc s r nd w on'
m
s gm nt
ncl

Vi spoda t tt s ofie sdono t c l ha a c a twihVi ( .23- , 2.
a'
nd ha he e fc r
t ypialy ve ny ontc t a. Dkt 1 p. )
V i f l t e t bls t the i i ac ua a i m i
a ais o s a i h ha
s n t l nd m nentda r of ha m i t c tdoe
nge
r f he our
s

no is e a itro u o y ij n to Healg so y asnge p s e io eo a u ea d e
t su n nel c t r n u cin.
l e nl i l, a t p s d f b s nd o s
e
no s t f t a s c fc i t nce ofcon i
t e or h ny pe i i ns a s
tnued a e or ha as m ent V i m e e y s c a es t
bus
r s
. a r l pe ul t o
pos i e f t e ha a s e . M o eove ,W a de Ra s a e t t ofi r La ge a La on a e
sbl u ur r s na nt
r
r
r n y t t s ha tce s r nd ws r
nota s gne t Vi s pod and do nott pi aly ha a c a tw ih hi . Be a e V i ha not
s i d o a'
y c l ve ny ont c t m
c us a s

a lged f c s s
le
a t howi he f c a t l i i nt ir pa abl ha m ,he c nnot s tsy al f
ng
a es c ua , mm ne , re r e r
a
aif 1 our

p o g o t e W itrts a d h i n te tte t a p ei n r ij n to Ac od n l,te
r n s f h n e et n e s o nild o r l ay n u cin. c r i gy h
mi
c u twild n Vi' moin f rp ei n r ij ncin o d rn t a ROSP W ad n Tr c S
o r l e y a s to o r lmiay nu t r ei g h t
o
r e ay .
Ra kee c r tonalofi e s La ge a La s s pa a e f om t pl i t f a t tt V D OC
y p or ec i
t c r r nd w on e r t d r he a n if nd ha he
tans e t pl i ifoutofRO SP.
r f r he a ntf
M oto # 2
in

Vi as fld a scond moin f aprlmi r ij ton ( .No.22 cai ng t t
a lo ie e
to or ei nay n unci Dkt
) l mi ha
em pl es atRO SP ar de ng hi l lc e ,no a y s r i s a unobsr t l w lbr r
oye
e nyi
m ega opi s t r e v ce nd
t uc ed a i a y
a es r quie t ltga e hi pe ng c tca es To e t bls a vi a i ofhi c tt i na
cc s e r d o ii t s ndi our s .
sa ih
ol ton
s onsiuto l

rg tt a c s t c u t,Vi mu t s o t cua ij r ' d fn d a t cua p eu ie wih
ih o c e s he o rs a s h w s t l nu y' ei e s û t l rj d c t
a
a
r s c t c e pl t d or e s i ltga i s h a a i lt t m ee a f lng dea i or
e pe t o ont m a e
xi tng ii ton, uc s n nabiiy o
t ii
dlne

p e e ta cam. Le s v Ca e ,51 U. 3 3 3 ( 9 6 ( i t n a d itr a qu tt n
rs n li ' wi . s y 8 S. 4 , 48 1 9 ) ct i n nen l oai s
'
ao
o
o te ;s e as Coc a v.M o s 73 F. 1 0,1 6 ( h Ci.1 (tn maki g cam
mitdl e lo hrn
ni ,
3d 31 31 4t r 996) $
l
ng a li
t t prs ofiil i rnge hi rg of a ce s t t co t a prs r ca t rl o
ha ion fcas nfi d s iht
c s o he url
ione nno ey n
c l or alegai ' ,ctngW hiev.W hie,886F. 721 723- ( hCi.1 . adoe
oncus y l tons.) ii
'
t
t
2d , 24 4t r 989) Vi s

n talg t th ha s fee a ya ta ij r , u h a misn ap riua c u t e die a a
o l e ha e s u fr d n cu ln u y s c s sig a t lr o r d a l , s
e
c
n
r s tof de e nt a lged c
e ul
f nda s' le
onduc . Atmos,he s ul t t s
t
t
pec aes o ome pos i e,non-pectc,
sbl
s ii

f tr ij r . Be a s Vi h sn te tbih dace rl l o o s c s o teme i o hs
uu e nu y c u e a a o sa ls e la i i d f uc e s n h rt f i
ke ho
s
a e scai a til he c nno s ts y a lf pr
cc s l m t ra , a t a if l our ongsoft W i e t s a he i note tte t a
he nt r e t nd s
n ild o

p ei n r ij cin. Th r fr ,t e c u twild n t e Vi' mo in f r a p ei n r
rlmi ay nun to
ee o e h o r l e y h as to o
rl ay
mi

ij n to o d rngt a e o e sa ROS p o d hm wih lg lc pe , o ay sr ie a d
n u ci n r ei h t mply e t P rvie i t e a o is n tr ev c s n
uno tu t d ac es t t 1w lbr r
bsr c e c s o he a i a y.
The Cl r w ils nd a c oft s m e o a um opi on a t ac om pa ng or rt
ek l e
opy hi m r nd
ni nd he c
nyi
de o
t pl i ifa co e ofr c d f rt de e nt .
he a ntf nd uns l e or o he f nda s

ENTER: hs
T iV

dyo Jn , 0 1
a f u e2 1 .
nie St t D i t i tJ
t d a es s rc udge