Ye Gon v. Holder et al
Filing
15
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 05/24/2011. (kab)
- wRrsoFFl t : nlT.w l 1
ee l : e r
A R A 6 ,A .
T os1 v ;
.
.
FiEO
L
I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TES DI RI T C O U R T
ST C
FO R TH E W E STER N DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O AN O K E DIVISIO N
ZH EN LI YE G O N ,
Pett oner,
ii
E RIC H O LD ER ,JR . etaI,
,
.
R espondent
s.
MAt 2 2 1
21
A
JULA C. !'' ,
I r
CLERK
BY:
.,
.
DEP
cbERK
C i lA cton N o.7: cvvi
i
11- 00060
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
M EM O R AN D U M O PINIO N
By:H on.
Jam e C.T ur
s
k
Seni U ni ed Stat D i ri Judge
or
t
es st ct
Zhe iYe Gon,a f r de a neepr e ng w ih c
nl
ede al t i
oc edi
t ouns ,f l d a pe ii f r aw rtof
el ie
tton o
i
ha e sc r us p ru n t 28U. C. 2 41 Pei o e c alng st ej dca d cso
b a op , us a to
S. j 2 . tt n r h l e h u iil e iin
i
e
c r iy ng hi e r dii t M e c A lhoug t s m a t ri bef e t c tf r pr lm i r
e tf i
s xt a ton o xi o. t
h hi te s or he our o e i na y
r viw ,1bot pa te fl pl di de tngt a o i t r s
e e
h ri s ied ea ngs bai he ppr prae e ponde sa t c t
nt nd he our'
s
j rs ito Fo t r a o t a f lo t c u ti st twh l i h s u idcino e t
u id cin. r he e s ns h t olw,he o r tnd ha, ie t a j rs ito v r he
m ater ve i bes pl e w ih t U nie St t D it i Cour f t Di t i tofCol bi
t , nue s t ac d t he t d a es s rct
t or he s rc
um a
a ta f r t ac i
nd r ns e s he ton.
1
.
Ree a t u ca r c r rve l h f lo n fcs l 2 0 , h UntdS ae c ag d
lv n j diil e o ds e a t e o lwi g a t. n 0 7 t e ie tts h r e
peii rwih c pii t ad and a tt m a a t eofme ha phe a i whieknowi
ttone t ons rng o i
be he nuf c ur
t m t m ne l
ng
ori e ng ofi beng i re i o t Unied St t .DEA a nt a r t d pe ii ne on J y
nt ndi
t i mpo td nt he t
aes
ge s rese tto r ul
23,2007,a t be r i oft c i i la ton,a a age oft U nie St t s M a s '
t he gim ng he r m na c i nd n nt he t d a e
r hal
s
Se vi s g d t e ut a r t d w a r nton J y 24,
r ce i ne he xec ed r es e
ra
ul
2007. The H onor bl Em m e Suli n,
a e
t lva
DititJ oft UniedSttsDititCour oft DititofCol a(' . Ditit
src udge he t ae src
t he src
umbi ' C. src
D
Cour' a
t' nunge frpeii rt beta fre fom t DititofCol aJ i,wher heha
)
d o ttone o rnserd r he src
umbi al
e
d
1 eRue 1b , o teRue Go enig j2 4Cae .
Se ls ()4 f h ls v r n 25 s s
b e sn ea trhi ar s,ot Ce ta VignaRe in lJ i (J i' i Or n e Vignaza d
e n ic fe s re tt he nrl r ii go a al 'al) n a g , r ii, n
' '
noedt t'hanksg st ( r M a s loft Ma s lSevief doi t t' Unie Sttsv.
t ha '
t
oe o M . rhal he rha r c or ng ha. td ae
'
Go No.1: cr001 ( D. J 2,
n,
07- - 81 D. C. une 2009)( ' Trn71: 25- 72:- ) Peii rs
Hrg a 23- - 1 3 . ttone'
c i i - f ns couns ls eq nty c pl i d t ts c iy pr edur s a t J lonl
rm nalde e e
e ubs ue l om a ne ha e ur t oc
e t he ai y
a l d pe ii ne onebox ofdicove y ma e i l3a atme a hewan e J e Suli nt
lowe tto r
s r t ras t i nd
t d udg
lva o
alow pe ii ne a ce st al ne es a y doc e t t pr par hi de ens
l
tto r c s o l c s r
um n s o e e s f e.W hen J
udgeSuli n
lva
a k dwh t e t J i i alc l rfd rlfclt, o n e sae ,' 'aVign aj i . . u (f )
s e eh r he al s o a o e e a a ii c u s l ttd 't
y
l s r ii al . b t is
und c r tt t m a s l ,s pe ha t r ' t hook. l a 72: 25 - 73: On Aug t
er ontac o he r ha s o r ps he es he
' d. t 231.
us
31 2 0 , u g S li nd s s e t ci n l cinwi p eu ie Go No. :7 c -01 1
, 0 9 J d e ul
va imis d he rmia a to t rj d c . n, 10 -r0 8
h
( 31 2009,dimis lor r.
Aug. ,
s s a de)
Howe r peii rr m a nsi a c r t d at h hewa ne rc ct ofa ofe e.
ve , ttone e i nc r e a e lhoug
s ve onvi ed ny f ns
Durngt pe nc oft c i na a ton,t Unie Stt ss ug t kee pe ii r
i he nde y he rmi l c i he t d a e o ht o p ttone
i a c r t d t f c lt t hi extadii t M e c whi h w ilpr e ut hi f aleg
nc r e a e o a iia e s r ton o xi o, c l os c e m or l ed
vi a i ofM e c dr g a fr ar l w s The U nie St t f l d is ' om pl i f a r s ' i
ol tons
xi an u nd ie m a .
t d a es ie t '
c
a nt or r e t' n
Se e r2008 i t D. Diti tCo ' whi h wa a sg d t M ag sr t J
pt mbe
n he C. src ul, c
t
s s i ne o
ita e udgeJ hn M .
o
Fa i a Af e m or t n t o ye r ofpr e ngs t M agit a e J
cc ol . t r
e ha w
as
oce di , he
s r t udge e e ed pe ii rs
nt r
ttone '
c
omm im e tor ra c tte hi e r dia lt t t Sec e a y ofSt t I t ma troft
t n de nd erii d s xta t biiy o he r t r
a e. n he te
he
e r iin ofZhe yYeGon, 1: mcxtadto
nl
No. 08- 00596( D. Fe 9, 1 ( riiaeof
D. C. b. 201 ) Ce tfc t
Extadiabiiya Commime Or r.Thec
r t lt nd
t nt de )
ommime o de sae t tpeiine woul
t nt r r ttd ha tto r d
2 r nge i l a ed l st n 90 m ie fom t D .C.Dit i Co t Roa
0 a
s oc t es ha
l s r he
srct ur . noke,t ct a di son whe et sm a t r
he iy nd vi i
r hi te
i pe nga whe ealf r ponde s couns lael at i neal l5 m iesfom Or nge.
s ndi nd r l our es
nt'
e r oc ed, s ry 0 l r
a
3 dic r i ve i t c i i a in i vedm or t n 25000 page ofdocum e si boh Spanih a
The s ove y nvol d n he rm nal cto nvol
e ha
s
nt n t
s nd
Engls and m a DVDS ofda a.
ih
ny
t
' em a n com m it d t t cus ody oft U nie St t s pe ng t na di pos ton oft sm a t rb
' i
r
te o he t
he t d a e ndi i l s ii
hi te y
t Se r tr ofStt and( s s rnde't M e c na hoiis (d.2.
he c eay
ae
hil ure r'o xia ut rte . I )
Afe t M agita eJ
tr he
sr t udgec rii pe ii ne ' e r dia lt pe ii rsha asco e
e tfed tto rs xta t biiy, ttone ' be
uns l
pr
omptytl t i t ntha spe ii n i t sco t na i a r s
l èed he nsa
bea tto n hi ur, m ng s e ponde sErcHol r J .
nt i
de , r,
U nied St t A to y G e r ;Hil r Rod m Clnt U nie St t s Se r t r ofSt t ,
t
a es t nw
ne al la y
ha
i on, t d a e c e a y
a e'
G e a d S. ol,Unie St t M ar ha f t W es e n D it i tofV igi a;a Fl Ayl ,
rl H t
t d a es
s l or he
t r s rc
r ni nd oyd or
W ar n oft J l Pettone na e W a de Ay orbe a epeii ri physc l l td
de
he ai. ii r m d r n l
c us ttone s
ialy ocae
wihnteW ad n' fcl y Peiine n me Ma s a Hot'ic h i ben h l s be t oa
t i h r e s a ii . t o r a d rh l l ' n e e s ig ed u j c t
t
t
s
fd rle ta i o wa -n 'a d 'e i si t ec td o teUn tdS ae ll ( e'sRe y
e ea xr dt n na t n ' man n h uso y f h ie tts.' P t ' pl
i
' r
' r
( . 3 6, ) Alh u hp tto e i p y ial p e e ti t W e tr Ditito Vigna
no 1 ) 7. t o g eiin r s h sc ly r sn n he sen src f r i i,
M a s H ol i o m e couns lt thi ' le i curen l i t c t oft U . M a s f
r hal t nf r d
e ha s ' i nt s r ty n he us ody he S. r hal or
c
teDitit fCo u i, o i t ec t d o t sdsrc. ( te ( o. 4-)1) Up nrc it
h src o l mb a n t n h uso y f hi itit' Letr n 1 1 . o e ep
'
oft si o m a i pe ii
hi nf r ton, ttoners a t d a duplc t ha a a ton i t D . . i t i tCo t Gon v.
t re
i a e be s c i n he C D sr c ur .
Sl ne.e a1, 1: c 00860( D. Ma 2011 .
oa t .No. 11-vD. C. y
)
l.
1
An e r dii nzi i no diecl a a a ebec us i i nota 'i or r' i t a
xta ton lng s t r ty ppe l bl
a ets
' nal de ' nse d,
f
;
one c le s a e r ton r lng by flng a pe ii n f aw r tofha asc pus Ea n v.
ha l nge n xt adii u i
ii
tto or
i
be or . i
W ikes 641F. 504,508(t Ci.1 )(ii Coli v.M ilr 252U. 364,369( 920).
l ,
2d
7h r 981 ctng lns
le,
S.
1 )
Thewrtofha sc pusi a a l er m e f rape s he d i c t y ' ro by c or
i
bea or
s n vaiabl e dy o
r on l n usod '
unde r ol
oft a hort oft UniedStts. 28U. C.j2241c () ' rt ofhabe c pusmaybe
he ut iy he t ae '
'
S.
() 1. ' is
W
as or
ga tdb . .h dsrc c u t .. wihnt i rs ciej rs ito . 1 .j2 41a .S e
rn e y . te itit o rs . t i her epe tv u idcins' d 2 () e
'
W ae v. hine 11 U. 564,574( )(' wrtofha asc pusdoe notac upont
ls W t v, 4 S.
1885 '
The i
be or
s
t
he
prs rwho s e r i ,butupon t pe s n who hol hi i wha i a l edt beunl wf
ione
e ks elef
he r o
ds m n
t s leg o
a ul
c so yr.Ac o d n l,hi c u t sj rs ito v aj2 41t c n ie t ep tto b c u e
u t d ' c r i gy t s o r ha u id cin i 2 o o sd r h eiin e a s
)
pe ii r i pr s nty i a c r t i t s dit i tpur ua t t c m im e or roft Unie
ttone s e e l nc r e a ed n hi s rc
s nt o he om t nt de
he t d
St t M a sr t J e a ca i s t wrti t sdititagans W a de Ayl r
aes gitae udg nd n s ue he i n hi src
i t r n o.
I Br d nv. 0hJ dii lCicui Courq410U S. 8 ( 9 3 ,heS p e Co r
n a e 3 t u ca r t
4 4 1 7 ) t u r me u t
.
rc g ie t t r t no efd r l ititc u t ye riej rs ito o e aj2 41
e o n z d ha mo e ha n e e a d src o r ma xecs u id cin v r 2
pe ii Br de w a i a ce a e i A l ba a a K e uc of i i s l ed a de a nera i t
tton. a n s nc r r t d n a m , nd nt ky f c al odg
ti
ga ns
hi . Br de w a ed K e uc ofi a st brng hi f o A l ba a t K e uck s he co d
m
a n nt
nt ky tci l o i
m r m a m o nt y o
ul
ha as e tili Ke uc t dipos o t Kenuc c r s Brde fl hi j22
ve pe dy ra n nt ky o s e f he t ky hage . a n ied s 41
pe ii wih t f der lditi tcour i Ke uc whi h or r Kent ky ofi i st brng
tton t he e a src
t n nt ky, c de ed
uc
fcal o i
hi fom Alba at sa ti li Ken uc
m r
a m o t nd ra n
t ky. Howeve ,t Fit Cic tCour ofAppe s
r he fh r ui
t
al
r re sai t tt j2241peii co dbeis donl wihi t dititc tsrs ci
eves d, ttng ha he
tton ul sue y t n he src our' e pe tve
j rs ito a dt a ted src c u t o l n tis et ewrt c us Br d nsc t da wa i
u idcin n h t h itit o r c ud o su h ibe a e a e ' uso in s n
Alb ma b y n isl tdj rs ito i Ke t c y
a a , e o d t i e u idcin n nu k .
mi
On a a ,t Supr m e Cour de er i d t tf r ldit i tco t l t i dif r nt
ppe l he
e
t t m ne ha ede a s rc ur s oca ed n f e e
sae c udh ve' o c re t b a j rs ito ' v raj2 41peiin.Th Co r n tdt t
tts o l a ' n u rn ha e s u idcin'o e
c
2
to
t
e u t oe ha,
alhough Br de wasi a c r t d i Alba a Ke uc wa t ' ia ef um f r
t
a n
nc r e a e n a m , nt ky s he ' r bl or o
des
a j c ton'bec us i wa wheet mae ile nt t plc t r c dsa wine s s
d udiai ' a e t s r he tra ve s ook a e,he e or nd t s e
pe tne t t cai we el ae a wasmo ec nintf t rs
ri nt o he l m r oc td, nd
r onve e or he e ponde s J-at493nt. #s
94.
I s h a c s t St e hol ng t pr s ri i m e at contne e a t a a nt
n uc
a e, he at
di he i one n m di e
i m nt c s s ge
f rt de a ng St t and t c t a Stt i pr um a y i fe e t t
o he m ndi
a e,
he usodin a e s es bl ndif r nt o he
r s uton ofprs rsata k on t de a ne . H e e,f rexa pl t pe ii
e ol i
i one ' t c
he t i r
r o
m e, he ttoneri
s
c i i A l ba a buthi di put i w ih t Com m onw e t ofKen uc not
ontned n a m ,
s s e s t he
a1h
t ky,
t St e ofA l m a. U nde t s cic sa s i woul s ve no us ulpur e
he at
aba
r he e r um t nce t
d er
ef
pos
t a pyteAh e s v Clr , 3 U. l 8( 9 ) r l a dr q iet a tea to
o p l h r n l . ak 3 5 S. 8 1 481 ue n e ur h t h cin
b brug ti Alb ma I fc , sa iha piaino ter l wo djrwihte
e o h n a a . n a t a lv s p lc to f h ue ul a t h
ve y pur e underyi t addii oft phr e,' ihi t i r pe tve
r
pos
l ng he
ton he as ' t n he r es c i
w
j rs ito . W ec n o a s meta Co g e sitn e t rq r t
u idcins'
'
a n t su h t n r s n e d d o e uie he
Co monwe t ofKen uck t de e isa ton i a dit ntSt t a t pr cl
m
a1h
t y o f nd t ci n sa
a e nd o e ude
t er s lto o t ed s t b afd rl u g fmiirwi t elwsa dp a tc so
h e ou in f h ipue y e ea j d e a la t h a n rcie f
h
Ke uc
nt ky.
Jla 498I, t 99.
Brd n'j rs ito a is eb t e t s v rin i a ao o st p t in rsi tn
a e s u idci n l su ewe n wo o eeg s s n lg u o ei o e ' nsa t
t
ha m peii n. Br de sde a ne l d by t r quesi sa eupon hi d san c t a i
be s tto
a n' t i r odge
he e tng t t
s i t t usodi n s
f cualy smia t t M e ca de
a t l i lr o he xi n mandt t Unie St t st hol pe ii rf e r dii
o he t d a e o d ttone or xta ton.
The J i,lke A l ba a i Br den,i t l le iy r pons bl f f e ng,c o hi and
al i
a m n a
s he oca ntt es
i e or e di l t ng,
ho i pe ii runde a c r c be w e i a t M a s l Se vi e. The M a s l Se v ce
us ng ttone
r ont a t t en t nd he r ha s r c
r ha s r i ,
lke Ke uc i Br n,guar nt s pe ii rs c tnued c i m e unde t a hort oft
i
nt ky n ade
a ee ttone ' on i
onfne nt
r he ut iy he
f de alc tand t M e ea exta ton r ques . Furhe
e r our
he xi n r dii e
t
t nnor ,t J i,whi h i r pr s n e by
e he a l
c s e e e td
prvaeco el i undoubt dl i fer ntt t out ome oft sm a tr For i t J i, ch
i t uns , s
e y ndif e o he c
hi te . cng he al whi
t da e had a ol e y no i ve e w ih pe ii rs c i i ore r dii pr e ngs t
o t
bs ut l
nvol m nt t ttone ' rm nal xt a ton oc edi , o
a we pe ii rsc
ns r ttone ' ompl pe ii doesnots l t publcsi e es t t r ug y a
ex tton
ewe he
i' nt r t o ho o hl nd
e dii l r s ve t sm a t r
xpe tous y e ol hi te .
M or ove , he pa te r ce l r c ze t tpe ii ' t ue c t a i t U nie
e rt
ri s e nty e ogni d ha ttoners r us odi n s he t d
Stt M a s lf t DititofCol bi i whos ca epe ii rhasbe n comm it d snc
aes r ha or he src
um a, n
e r ttone
e
te i e
hi ars i 2007.See28C. R.j0. l1k)(ttngU. Marhal Ser i r ponsbl f
s re tn
F.
1 ( sai S. s s vce es i e or
'suse i ofc t ofFe r prs r fom t tmeoft i are tbyamas lort r
' l tnton usody
r
deal ione s r he i
her r s
rha hei
r ma t amarha by t c u untlt prs ri co mit by o de oft c tt t
e nd o
s l he ot t i he ione s m ted
r r he our o he
c t oft Ato ne Gene alf t s r ceofs nt nce ot r s r l s d fom c t y by
usody he t r y
r or he e vi
e e , he wie eea e r
usod
t ec u to r tr e t t ec t d o t eU. PaoeCo sino t eBu e uo P io .)
h o r, r eu n d o h uso y f h S. r l mmiso r h r a f rs ns'
'
Se as 28CFR j0.1l (ut i ngt Ma s sSewie'ota por,s r r rc vea
e lo
1 a a horzi he rhal l c ' rns t urende ,e ei nd
t
m ai t n c t ofpr s r wines est m por r l t a f r e f om ort t U nie St t s
n ai us ody
i one - t s e
a iy r ns e r d r
o he t d a e
purua t ate t e utvea e me ,o ohe l la hort '.Thee oe,W a de Ayl
s nto ray, xec i gre nt r t r ega ut iy'
)
rf r
r n or
a t a a a ntf M a s lSl nevi bot c r c a Br n,a t D . Cic tCo t s
c s s n ge or rha oa
a h onta t nd ade nd he C. r ui ur ha
c n u rn h b a j rs ito o e p tto e' j2 4 peiinwh nM a s a Sla i j i da
o c re t a e s u idcin v r eiin r 2 1 tto e rh l o ne s one s
s
ap ry S eFe R. v P. (' moi no o iso ,h c u t ya a ytme o u t
at. e d. Ci . 21 '
On to r n t wn t e o r ma t n i , nj s
tr , ddordr apa t '.
ems a
op ry.)
'
' r h c n e in eo p risa dwi e s s i t ei tr s o j tc , d src c u t
' t e o v n e c f a t n t se ,n h ne et f usie a itit o r
Fo
e
n
m a ta f ran ci la ton t an ot rdi ti to di s on w he e i m i ha bee br ug .
y r ns e y vi c i o y he sr c r vi i
r t ght ve n o ht'
'
2 U. C. 1 0 ( ) l a dto t c n u rn h b a j rs ito peiine c u dh v fld
8 S. j 4 4 a . n d iin o o c re t a e s u idcin, t o r o l a e ie ,
t
a s eq nty di fl a pe ii wih t D. DititCo tbe us Unie Stt sM a s l
nd ubs ue l d ie, tton t he C. src ur ca e t d a e
r ha
So n i lc tdwihnt a c u t j rs ito M as a S o ermanst eo fc rr s o sbe
la e s o ae t i h t o r' u id cin. rh l l n e i h fie e p n i l
s
f pe ii rsc t asor e by t D. Diti tCour.Furhe
or ttone ' usody
der d he C. src
t
t nnor ,pe ii rsc
e ttone ' ouns l
e
pr tc slw i t DititofCol bi ,wa co e ofr c d f nea l ayea ofpe ii '
aci e a n he src
um a s uns l e or or ry
r
ttoners
e r ton pr e ngs a t D . . i ti tCour ,a a
xtadii
oce di
t he C D sr c
t nd ppea sbef e t s c tpr ha vi e.
r
or hi our o c c
The U nie St t ' ouns lwho w o ke on t e r dii f om bot t U . De rm e of
t d a es c
e
r d
he xt a ton, r
h he S. pa t nt
J tc a t U . Ator y' Of i e f D . . a e l a e i t D i ti tofCol bi
us i e nd he S. t ne s f c or C , r oc t d n he s r c
um a.
M o eove ,c ms lf ra1pa teshavei o m e t c toft e r or na y a o of
r r ot e o l ri
nf r d he our he xta di r m unt
doc e snota l e on a publc doc t e t rbe a e t docu e s a e s al d o bec us
um nt
vaiabl
i
ke , ihe c us he
m nt r e e r a e
t y w e e s vol i
he
r o um noust tt y w e e notdi tz d. The e docu e spr s m a y r m a n i
ha he
r
gii e
s
m nt e u bl e i n
t cus ody oft D . Cicui Cour Cl r s O f i e. The e or t s m ate i bes r s ve by
he t
he C. r t
t e k' fc
r f e, hi
t r s t e ol d
6
t D . . i ti tCour f is e y a e st t r l van r co ds t pr tc le di ton of
he C D sr c
t or t as cc s o he e e t e r , he ac i a oor na i
D . . tor ysale know l dg bl i t s f r ye rol ltga i and is a lt t bot
C a t ne
r ady
e ea e n hi ou - a d ii ton,
t biiy o h
c mp l t ine'atn a ea g a t i r le.Ac o dn l,nt eitr sso j siea d
o e pei o rs te d nc nd r n h s eif c r igy i h n e et f u tc n
t
j dca e o o ,hec u t xecs sisd srto a do d r t sa to ta serdt t eD.
u iil c n my t o r e rie t icein n r e s hi cin rn fre o h C.
D i t i tCour f a lf t rpr e ngs
s rc
t or 1 urhe oce di .
11
1.
F rt f rg i ra o s t c u ton Ed nD. l a e t eUntd S ae M as a f r
o he o e ong e s n ,he o rj is wi S o n ,h ie tts rh l o
t Diti tofCol
he src
umbi ,asa r s
a
e ponde a ta f r t a ton t t Unie St t Ditit
nt nd r nse s he c i o he t d aes src
Cour f t D i t i tofCol bi
t or he s rc
um a.
TheClr i die e t s nd c e oft sm e a
e k s r ctd o e opi s hi mor ndum opi on a t a ompa ng
ni nd he cc
nyi
or rt al c
de o l ouns lofr or
e
ec d.
ENTER: hsVYZ a o Ma, 0 1
Ti
y f y2 1.
Sen rUnie Stt Diti
t d a es src
dg
e
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?