Via v. Ray et al

Filing 18

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS for 14 Report and Recommendations; OVERRULING plantiff's objections 17 ; DENYING 5 Motion for TRO, Motion for Preliminary Injunction filed by Barry Lynn Via. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 06/02/2011. (kab)

'

r FRKS OFFI U s DI O ur o
a
CE
:X
j

A R A r ,l ,..
T o sxkv :
Flso
t
.

JUN 22 2 1
21
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I CO UR T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N DI
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI
BAR RY LY NN V I ,
A

JULA :
BY i t.

,

;

DEP

CL
ERK

ERK

C i lA c i N o. 7:11-cv-00138
vi ton
0138

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

V.

O R D ER A D O PTI G REPO R T AN D
N
R EC O M M EN D A TI N
O

TM CY R AY ,etaI,
.
D ef
endant .
s

By:Sam ue G .W is
l
l on
Unied St es D i ri Judge
t
at
st ct

Thi m a t ri bef e t cour on pl i i fBar y Lynn V i sm oton f r i eroc o y
s te s or he
t
a ntf
r
a'
i o nt l ut r

ij n tv r l f( c e No. )drci t ed fn a tp io o fcast r so eteg o
nu cie ei Do k t 5 ie tng h ee d n rs n fiil o e t r h o d
e
c
onduc tmehef f t byrf sngarquiedt rul i ( t tf rlgi ras ,a
ti
oreied e u i e r ubec oss TB) es or ei ous e ons nd
diec i ofi a st pr de hi w ih a a t na i TB t s . The c t e e r t m a t rt
r tng tci l o ovi
m t n ler tve
et
our r f r ed he te o

Unie Stt M a sr eJ M ihae Ur ns ,purua t 28U. C.j636( ( )B) fra
td aes gitat udge c l ba ki s nt o
S.
b)1( , o
Re t nd Rec
por a
omm e i
ndaton.The M agita eJ e s e
sr t udg ubs quen l fld ar po t fndi no bass
ty ie e r, i ng
i

t ga tVi' mo ina rc mme igta tec u t e yi.Vi fldo j cinswi nt e
o rn as to nd e o ndn h t h o r d n t a ie be to t h
hi
f t nda al tdunde j636( ( ) lr l rieai t agtme sma i hi pladi .
ouree ys lote
r
b)1,a gey etrtng he r l nt de n s e ngs

Ha i gr ve dt Re r a dRe o nd to t o j ci n t rt , n p ri n p rin
v n e iwe he po t n c mme ain,he b e to s heeo a d e t t o t s
ne
o
oft rco ddenov i a cor nc wih j636( () t c ta e wiht Magitae'
he e r
o n c da e t
b) 1,he our gres t he
srt s
J
udge' r com m e ton. A c or ngl i i he e O RD ER ED a AD JU D G ED t tVi s
se
nda i
c di y, t s r by
nd
ha a'

obe tonst t M a sr t J e' Re ta Rec
jci o he gitae udg s por nd omme tonaeOVERRULED,a t t
ndai r
nd ha

Vi' moin fratmp rr rsr iigo d ra prl n r ij n t r l f sDENI
as to o e o ay etann r e nd ei ay nu ci ei i
mi
ve e
ED.
The co tnot ,how e ,t tnot ng i t c ts opi o s d be r d t i ca e t tV i s
ur es
ver ha
hi n he our ' ni n houl
ea o ndi t ha a'

c pl i tha f ie t r i e a pl i e Fi s A m endm e cl m r r ng t TB t tng
om a n s a l d o a s
aus bl r t
nt ai ega di he
esi
m e hods e pl d by t de e nt .
t
m oye
he f nda s l
The c e k wils a co oft sor rt pl i ifa c
l r l end
py hi de o a ntf nd ouns lofr c d f t
e
e or or he
def
endant
s.

ENTER : June 2,2011

A

O I STATESDI CT J
TED
STRI UDGE

1SeeCa dav. Ra , 01 WL 5 5 1 a * ( . Va F b. 20 1 (i igta whl ap io rma h v sae
na
v2 1
6 61 , t 4 W D. . e 9, 1 ) t n h t ie rsne y a e ttd
nd
aplusbl cl m t tt TB t tng m ehod s lc e byprs ofk il vi aedhi rg sunde RLUI a t
a i e ai ha he
esi
t
ee t d
ion f as olt s iht
r
PA nd he

Fis Ame d n, rs not asween v rh ls e tte t s mmayj d me tb c us tep io e h dn t
rt n me tp io f l r e etees nild o u r u g n e a e h rsn r a o
ki
d mo srtdta teTB ts a tal c nan dac h l ra yoh rsb tn e b n dbyhsr l in .
e n tae h th
et cu l o tie lo o o n te u sa c s a ne
y
i ei o )
g