DE Technologies, Inc. v. E4X, Inc. et al

Filing 74

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 12/01/2011. (lab)

cbERrsOFFI U. . ST.
CE S DI COURT
AT R> 0e , '
%A
FIED
L

I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
FO R THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI N I
CT
RGI A
R OA N OK E DI I ON
V SI

DE2 2 12 1
21

JL'C/#E C
U E.,LMK
D ,

D E TECHN OLOG I I C.
ES, N ,

Pl n if
aitf,

Ci lAci n No. 11
vi to
7: CV001
83
M EM OM N D UM O PI O N
NI

I
SHO PU SA , N C. # g.
l , 1 1,
.

By:Hon. l n E.
Ge
Conr d
a
ChifUnie Stt DititJ
e
td a es src udge

Def nda s
e nt .

DE Te hnol e ,l (ç ' tldt spae i rng me aci algi t t
c ogis nc.tDE' ie hi tnt nfi e nt ton, le ng ha
)

d fn a t I I P A,n .( S o ' a dItr ai n l e k u ,n .tC' i lme tdt e
ee d n s SA US Ic (l h p' n nen to a Ch c o tI c (t ' mpe ne h
O
6
)
I )
t hnol came byDE i U. Pae No. 460, (the$ Pae )a U. Pae No.
ec ogy li d
n S. tnt 6, 020 t 020 tnf' nd S. tnt
t
6, 36 (t : 4Paent'.Thecourpr vi l cc tu dt cai oft smepae si
845, 4 the 36 t '
t
)
t e ousy msr e he l ms he a
tnt n
a i r nge e a ton fl by DE a i tD e l I DE Te hs.I v.D e l l , o.
n nf i m nt c i ied
ga ns l, nc.
c . nc.
l. nc. N

7:4 0 2 ( . Va) Thec s i p e e tyb f r tec u t o c n ie aino t elg l
0 CV0 6 8 W D. ..
a e s r s nl eo e h o r f r o sd r to f h e a
e f c oft co tsr i i t e le i rng nta ton.
fe t he ur ' ulngs n he arir nfi eme c i
Background

DE i a Delwa ec por tonba e i Blc bu g, r ni . Theco nytwas
s
a r or a i
s d n a ks r Vigi a
mpa t
e t bls t de l t s , nd l t r s l ... c put r s t m t c
s a ihed o ve op, e t a a e e l a om e yse o onduc i e na i l
t nt r tona
co m er alta a tons f rt s li a pur has ofgoodsove t I e t I r ne , nd
m
ci r ns c i
o he e lng nd c e
r he nt nw , nta t a

ot rc
he omputrt c
e-o-omputrs t . ( Compla 2-) Bot ofispae s t 1 Pae
e ysems' Am.
'
. t 3 . h t tnt,he 020 tnt
a t 4 Pa e ,a e< r t d t t f c ltto ofi e ai na pur ha i ofgoodsove t
nd he 364 t nt r é ece o he a iiai n ntm to l c sng
di
r he

i eme/nta t a esi a1a pe t ofs hta atons' ( ComplExs A & B)
nt ti rne , ddr sng 1 s cs uc r nsci .' Am.
. .
.

I Oco rof200 DE fldapaenti rnge n a tona i tDel,l .(i l' i
n tbe
4, ie
t nfi me t ci gans l nc ç l' n
De )
t W e t m D i ti tofV igi a, l i t tD e li r ng t : Pa e a t : 4 Pa en .
he s e
src
r ni aleg ng ha l nfi ed he 020 t nt nd he 36 t t

Thec s wa a sg e t teu e sg e d src j d ea , fe trey aso p era
a e s sin d o h nd rin d ititu g nd a tr h e e r f rtil
pr ee ngs t ca e s tl pr ort ti .
oc di , he s e ted i o ral

Be or DE a De le er it t rs tl me a ee nt t c tis d anlmbe of
f e
nd l nt ed n o hei e te nt gr me , he our s ue
l r
r lngs On Fe ua y l 2006,f l wi aM a kma hea i t co tis ac am
ui .
br r 4,
olo ng
r nl rng, he ur s ued l i
c tu ton opi o a or r c tui t dipu e tr soft 1 a ( Pa e s DE
onsr c i
ni n nd de , onsr ng he s t d e m
he 020 nd 364 t nt.

Tec .I v. l.l , 7:4CV006 2006U. Dit LEXI 5459,a *535( . Va
hs.nc. Del nc.No. 0
28,
S. s.
S
t - W D. .

Fe 1 , 0 6 ,Th e mo t sltr t ec u t rne Delsmo inf rp ril u r
b, 4 2 0 ) re n h ae ,h o r g a td l' to o ata s mmay

j d me to iv l iy c n ldngta cams1 t u h 1 a d 1 o te12 Pae tae
u g n f n ai t , o cu i h t li 3 l g 5 n 7 f h 0 0 tn r
d
uo
id fnt a amatro lw.DE Te hs.n . . l I c, 28F. p 2 5 2, 2 ( . Va
n ei ie s te f a
c .I c v Del n .4
.
Su p. d 1 5 2 W D. .
2 0 ) Th ra tr DE a dDelie a dto a moin frsl r j d me t Byo iina
0 6 . ee fe , n l fld d iin l to s o l
mmay u g n . pn o nd
o de e e e Aprl9,2007,DE' motonswe ede e a De lsm oto we egr nt d i pa t
r r nt r d
i
s i
r ni d nd l'
i ns r a e n r
a de e i pa t DE Te hs.l v. l.I , 7:
nd ni d n r.
c . nc. De l nc.No. 04CV00628 2007 U. Dit LEXI
,
S. s .
S

2 5 , t* 1 ( . Va Ap . , 0 7 .
71 7 a 1 0 W D. . r 9 2 0 )
Neihe DE norDe la ke t ha t cou tsnzi wihdr wn a pa t t r
t r
l s d o ve he r' lngs t a
s r of hei
s te
etlment Ho ver t fnalor r pr r d byt pa tes pr dedt ta1 oft pr vi
. we , he i
de , epa e
he ri , ovi ha 1 he e ous
or r i t c s ,i udi t co tscl i c t u ton nzi s a t c ur ' r lngs o
de s n he a e ncl ng he ur ' a m onsr c i
lng nd he o ts u i
n

pata s mmayj dg n,% r n tfn lweeitro uo yi n tr a dwe es b e t o
ril u r u me tç e o i a, r ne lc tr n au e n r u j c t
we
f rh rrv so b ti Co r a a ytmep irt e tyo fn l u g n .
u te e iin y h s u t t n i ro o nr f i a j d me t'
'

1M a km an v. W e t iw l tume te n . 5 F.d96 ( d. r 1 95 (n b n ) afd,51
r
sve nsr n s l c, 2 3 7 Fe Ci. 9 ) e a c , f' 7

U, 370( 9 )
S.
1 96 .
2

On Aprl23, 0, fl dt i tnta ton f rpa e i rnge nta i tI p,I
i 201 DE ie he nsa ci o t nt nfi me gans sho C,
a t ot rd e nt i t Ea tr Ditito Te sz Afe t a ton wasfl d,I
nd wo he efnda s n he se n src f xa . tr he ci
ie shop a
nd
I m o d t ta f ri t t sditit On M a c 24,201 t m o i wa g a e a t c e
C ve o r nse t o hi src .
rh
1,he ton s r ntd, nd he as

wa ta se rdt tet esg e dsrc j d e
s r n fre o h md rin d itit u g .
Att r que toft c t a i a cor nc wih t s he i or re e e on
he e s he our, nd n c da e t he c dulng de nt r d
Augus 2,2011 t pa tess m itd c os - i sr ga di t l ga efe toft c tsr i
t
, he ri ub te r sbref e r ng he e l f c he our' ulngs
i t e le pae c s The c ur hed ahe rng o t is o Nove r 1 2011.
n he arir tnt a e.
o t l
a i n he s ue n
mbe 8,
Di
scussi
on

I t i r s ci bre s DE a t de e nt f usont o ni i t pr vi
n her e pe tve if ,
nd he f nda s oc
wo pi ons n he e ous

p tn c s : 1 tec u tsr l go p ril u r j d me tha cams1 tr u h 1 a d 1
ae t a e ( ) h o r' ui n at s mmay u g n t t li 3 ho g 5 n 7
n
a
o te: 2 Pae t r iv ld a d( )tec u tsM ak nr l srg r i t p o r
f h 0 0 tn a e n ai; n 2 h o r' r ma ui e adng he rpe
ng
i e r t to ofdiput d cai fo t 1 a 6 4 Pa e s
nt p e ai n
s e l ms r m he 020 nd 36 t nt.

1
.

TheCo tsI i t Fi ng ast Cl m s1 -5 a 17 oft ( Pat nt
ur ' nvaldiy ndi
o ai 3r nd
1
he 020 e

Asn tda o e tec u t ue o p rilsl r u g n i tep e iu c s ta
o e b v ,h o r r ld n a t l
a mmayj d me t n h r vo s a e h t
Cl m s1 t ough 1 a 1 oft 4 Patnta ei fnieasama troflw a t ,
ai 3 hr
5 nd 7 he 020 e r nde i t
te
a nd, hus
i i W hiet de e nt a k t c tt de em i wha pr cl i e f c ,i a t
nvald.
l he f nda s s he our o t r ne
t e usve fe t f ny, he

c u tsp rils mmayj d me t r e h so tec re t r c e ig ,h c u t e ln st d
o r' a t u r u g n o d r a n h u rn p o e dn s t e o r d cie o o
a
s a t stme.Ast de e nt a knowl dgei t rb i f ,i i undiputd t t i t i tnt
o t hi i
he f nda s c
e
n hei re s t s
s e ha ,n he nsa

a to , ha no a sre a yo t ecamsta weet es b e to t c u tsiv l iyr ln .
ci n DE s t se td n f h li h t r h u j c fhe o r' n ai t uig
d
Cons quen l unl s a untlDE ate p st a s r Cl i s 1 ,1 1 or 1 t c twil
e
ty, es nd i
tm t o s e t a m 3 4, 5, 7, he our l

2The ot def
her endant , E4X ,l and Fit
s
nc.
fyone,I ,wer vol a iy dim is f om t case
nc. e unt rl s s ed r he
on J
anuar 3,20ll
y
.

rfanfo r l o t elg lefc ofh c u tsp ril u r u g n od ri t e
eri rm ui n h e a fe t te o r' a t s mmayj d me t r e n h
ng
a
prviuscae.See e..J c onv. a ks 857F. 951 956n. ( h Ci.1 )(t he a
e o s
, g, a ks J c on,
2d ,
1 4t r 988 ç n
W
c r ry ha y tt a ie,bu mi ars i t f u e,hec tm a notis a opi on on
ontove s s e o rs t ght ie n he ut r t our y
s ue n ni

tepoe ta c nr v ryb c u et a c nr v ryi n ty téie f ra j dc to ' .
h tn il o to es e a s h t o to es s o e rp ' o d u iain.)
'
I.
l

The Cour ' Cl i Cons r t o R ulngs
ts a m
t uc i n
i

Ac di t t pa te 'bref,DE ha i ntfe t e patntt r sr quii
cor ng o he ri s i s
s de ii d hr e e e m e rng
c t uc i . del c i l ngua f om a m e ' çs l c i a c r y f o a m e ' a
ons r ton. s e tng a
ç
ge r
nu'' ie e tng urenc r m
,
nu'' nd
>

ii er tona s ppi i or to ' Ea h oft etr swa c tue i t c tsM a km a
tnt nai l hi ng nf mai n. c
'
hes e m
s onsr d n he our' r n
o ni i t pr vi a ton.DE Te hs,nc v. lal , 7:4CV00628,20 U. Dit
pi on n he e ous c i
c .l . De l nc.No. 0
06 S. s.

LEXI 5459,a *1 21( . Va. b.1 2006) Shorl a trt Mar nopi onwas
S
t 4- W D. Fe 4,
. ty fe he kma ni
i s d, E m o d f r c i r ton oft c ts c t uc i ofçs l c i a l ngua f om a
s ue D
ve or e ons de a i
he our ' ons r ton de e tng a
ge r
m e ' nd çs e tng a c r nc f om a m e ' DE al o a ke t c tt cl r f is
nu' a tel c i
ur e y r
nu.
'
s s d he our o a i y t

co tuci ofti e na i s p ng i onua i ' By opi o a o de en e edM a c 21
nsr ton dntr tonal hipi nf
ton.
'
ni n nd r r t r
rh ,
200 t c td e DE' m oto f r c i r ton a gr n edisr s f ca iia i
6, he our enid
s i n or e onsde a i nd a t t eque t or lrfc ton.
l s doi t co tsi l modi d isc t c i o t ph a etnt r tona s ppi
n o ng, he ur lghty
fe t onsnzton f he r s t e na i l hi ng
i
i or ton't add es t co e sr s dby DE. DE Te hs.I v. l.I ,
nf mai ' o r s he nc m aie
c . nc. De l nc.No.

7:4CV00628,2006U. Dit LEXI 11 a *6- ( . Va.Ma . 2006)
0
S. s.
S 603, t 7 W D.
r 21,
.
The de e nt c e t tt c r' m i rM a kma r lngss ul be gve
f nda s ontnd ha he ou ts o
r n ui
ho d
i n
pr cusvee f c ,a t tt docrneofc l tr e t ppe ba sDE fo r ltga i t t r
e l i fe t nd ha he ti
olae al so l r
r m eii tng he e ms'
appr pra ec tu ton. I r pons ,DE ar est tt cli c tuci n or wa nota
o it onsr c i n es e
gu ha he am onsr to der s

tfna j me 't whiho ltrle t lo da ya t ,ha t c tspror
di l udg nt'o c olaea soppe oul ppl nd,hus t t he our' i

M a kma r lngsa enote il d t pr cl i e f c . Se K1 h v. ir of Cop .355 F.
r n ui
r
ntte o e usve fe t e 0t M c os t
,
3d

322,326(t Ci.
4h r 2004)(t a ycolaea esoppe o is prcl i t a is orfc,he
( ppl ltrl t l r sue e uson o n sue a tt
To
pr
opone mus de taet t()t is orfc i i ntc lt t oneprvi l ltgae
nt t monsrt ha 1 he sue a t s de ia o he
e ousy ii td;

( )teis eo fc wa a tal rs ve i tep irp o e dn ; 3 teis eo fc wa ciia
2 h su r a t s cu l eol d n h ro r c e ig ( ) h su r a t s rtc l
y
a dn c sayt t j d me ti tep irp o e dn ; 4 t ej d me ti tepro p o e dngi
n e e sr o he u g n n h ro r c e ig ( ) h u g n n h ir r c e i s
fnala vai a ( )t pat t bef e l e byt prorrs uton o t is orfc hada
i nd ld; nd 5 he ry o orcosd he i e ol i f he s ue a t

f l a dfi o p ru iyt l iaeteis eo fc i t ep irp o e d n .
ul n ar p o tnt o i g t h su r a tn h ro r c e i g'
t
).
Asbo h sde r c ni i t rr s tvebre s dhe ei a ongoi de east t
t i s e og ze n hei e peci
if ,t r s n
t
ng bat
o he
pr c usve e f c sofa M a km an l i ' Po e v p. nc. St tc ContolCom pone s l , o.
e l i fe t
r
' ng.' w r i l v. a i
ul
r
nt . nc. N

108 0 8 , 01 U. DitLEXI 7 28 a * ( . M ih J y6 2 1 .ç i l t
: CV0 3 2 2 1 S. s.
S 23 , t 9 W D. c . ul , 01 ) d t i l
W h te
g da e fom t Fe r lCic tont is dititc rsha s i on whehe aM a km a
ui nc r he de a r ui
he sue, src ou t ve plt
t r
r n
c ai c t c i r lng ha pr cl i e f c si s e n lt g ton i vi t s m e
l m ons nz ton u i
s e us ve f e t n ubs que t ii a i nvol ng he a

p tn , s cal wheetep i rl iain stldb f r afna j g n wa e trd,her l g
ae t epe il
y r h ro i g to et eo e i lud me t s nee t ui
t
e
n
h so h r s y tt b a pidi afn l u g n rg r igifig me t rv l iy o wh r
a t ewie e o e p le n ia j d me t e adn n rn e n o ai t , r ee
d
t er ln ha no u d r o F d rl ru t e iw. l . itr a ctto o t d ; e as
h uig s t n eg ne e ea Cic i rv e ' d (nen l iains mit l s e lo
'
e
Pake-- r fnCop . Badwi Fitr .nc,724F.Supp. 81 81 ( D.Ohi 201 )
r rll mii
a
v. l n le s I .
2d 0, 5 N.
o 0

( o igt a %h r i as i i cru t o t i is e'(n e l i to so te ) W h l s me
n tn h tt e e s pl n ic is n hs su ' itma ct in mi d . ie o
t
t
)
a
t
dititcou t ha he dt tpro M a kma r lngswe eis t i nty Ei l t me i a ia i
src
rs ve l ha ir r n u i
r tufk e l fna ' o rt pplc ton
ofc lt r le t pe - e nt
ola e a sop l ve hought ma trt whih t y we ene s a y wa ne rr duc d
he te o c he
r ce s r s ve e e

t afn l u g n atrv r it'TM Pae t. P. l tl s M a h . r , 2F. u p. d
o i a j d me t fe ed c,
'
tn s L. v.n 'Bu . c s Coo.7 S p 2
370,377( D. Y.l , he s i l nga t rj i t sdsrc,ha rac dt
S. N. 999) ot r,ncudi nohe udge n hi itit ve e he he

oppost c l i on smia f c s eKolm or e Cor v. s waElc.Co . 1 F.
ie oncuson
i lr a t .Se
l gn
p. Ya ka
e
p , 47

Supp. 46 466470( . Va 2001 ( k,J)( di t tt docrneofc ltrl
2d 4, - W D. . ) Tur . hol ng ha he ti
olaea
e t ldi nota y, ndt tapatnt ewasnotbound b a cam c t u ton or ris i
soppe d
ppl a ha
e e
y li onsr ci
de s ued n
apr vi ca e a i ta dif r ntdefndanti whih t pa tess tld a trt M a kma
e ous s gans
fe e
e
n c he ri e te fe he r n

r l g b t e o etej r rtm e av r ito t eut t is eo ifi g me t.
ui , u b fr h u y eu d edc n h lmae su f n rn e n )
n
i
H a ng c i r d t pa tes a gum e s t ap i a e c e l w ,a t pa tc a
vi ons de e he ri ' r
nt , he plc bl as a nd he r i ul r
c r um s a soft s c s ,t co t c i t a y t do rne o cola e a e t ppe t t
ic t nce
hi a e he ur de lnes o ppl he cti f l t r l s o l o he

co tsprorM a kma r lngs I t a t c t ds a ha ot dititc t f c d wih
ur ' i
r n ui . nse d, he our hol , s ve her src ours a e t
t sis , ha whienoten ild t pr cl i e f c , hep i M a km a r lngswilbegi n
hi s ue t t l
tte o e usve fe t t ror r n ui
l
ve
çde e e i lt e t e unl s cl a l e r ous ' Pa ke --a f n Co p. 7 F.
t f r nta r a m nt e s e r y r one . r rl nnii r , 24 Supp.2 a 81
'
l
d t 6;

s ealo Sea sPe r e & Tr ns Cor v. c rDa esM i a Co,N o.5:
e s
r tolum
a p. p. Ar he ni l dlnd ,
03CV011
20,

2007U. DitLEXI 53576, *24( D. Y. ul 24,2007)(mpha ii t tS onsdea e
S. s.
S
at N. N. J y
e
szng ha d i rbl
c
de e e e's dbe gi n t a c tspro cli c tu ton r lngsç e sove r l or
f r nc ' houl
ve o our' i r am onsr c i ui ç s
unl
r ued

undemi bys e tl a de l
r ned ubsquen eg l veopmens i l ngi e v ni c elw'.Thus a en a
t,ncudi ntr e ng as a '
)
, bs t
s
howi b DE t tt c r ' o i na co tu ton ofadiput d tr wasi r e tasam at r
ng y
ha he ou ts rgi l nsr c i
s e em
nco r c
te
ofl w, hec t l a y ispro M a kma r lngsi t i t nta to
a t our wil ppl t i r r n u i n he nsa ci n.
Thecou ti c nc t tt ssa r a pr i tl ba a est i
r s onvi ed ha hi t nda d p opraey l nc wo mpora i e e t tnt nt r s s
f ine st al ltga t ,a c it nc i t co tu ton ofpae cai s The sa r
ar s o l ii n s nd onsse y n he nsr c i
t nt l m .
t nda d
r co zest Si pora e ofunionniy i t tea m e ofa gi n pa en . M a km a 51
e gni he 'm tnc
f t n he r t nt
ve t t'
' r n, 7

U . a 390.Afe al onc c am c tu ton r i aer nde e f l nga dea ld a
S. t
tr l, e l i onsr c i ulngs r e r d, olowi
t ie nd
st ed anal i i i onl reasonabl t expectt tt rulngsw ilcar y som e pr
udi
ys s, t s y
eo
ha he i
l r
ecedental
i

val On t ot rha t cou ts d notbe s i r ns ge ta t i nor pe s i
ue.
he he nd, he r houl
o nt a i n s o g e r uasve

a gume se t bls ngt e se eofcla e i a e rirc am c tuc in. Thus unl s
r
nt sa ihi he xit nc
e r nor n n a le l i onsr to
, es
pl i ifs t nst s difc tbur n ofpe s i n, he c tw ilde e t is e ri rr i .
a ntf us ai hi f i ul de
r uas o t our l f r o t a le ulngs

The Clr i die t d t s nd c rii c piso t sm e a
e k s r c e o e e tfed o e f hi mor ndum o ni t alco ms l
pi on o 1 t e
ofr co d.
e r
fN #

EN TER : Thi
s

da ofD e e be ,2011
y
cm r
.

4

(
)

Chi fU nie St t D it i tJ e
e
t d a es s rc udg