Leschinskey v. The Rectors and Visitors of Radford University et al
Filing
26
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/24/2011. (rkc)
cl sOFFI t.s. ST O URT
ERx'
CE I DI .
AT RQANQKE,
VA
FIED
L
02T 2i 2 1
21
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STR I C O U RT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STRI O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
R O A N OK E DIVISION
JO H N P.LESC H I SK EY ,
N
JULI C.
A DUDLEK GL
ERK
BY:
C i lA c i N o.7: - v- 89
vi t on
11 c 001
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM O M ND U M O PI I N
N O
V.
TH E REC TO R S A N D V ISITO R S O F
R ADFO R D U N I ER SI
V
TY
By:Sam ue G . is
l W l on
Unied St es Di t ctJudge
t
at
s ri
D ef
endant
.
Thi i a a ton by pli if J Le c ns y,al gi t tt tde enda , heRe t r
s s n ci
antf , ohn s hi ke le ng ha ha f nt t
co s
a Vii r o Ra f r Unv riy( d o d fie t ra o a l a c mmo aeh sd sb lyi
nd st s f d o d ie st Ra f r ) ald o e s n by c o d t i ia ii n
o
t
voaino j5 4o teRe a l ainAc o 1 7 ( h b l ain Ac) 2 U. C. 7 e sq.
ilt f 0 f h h bitto t f 9 3 Re a ii to t, 9 S. j 91 t e
o
i
t
Ra or ha m ove t di m i s f f iu e t s a e a c ai .The c tfndsLe c ns y'
df d s
d o s s or a l r o t t l m
our i
s hi ke s
pl di al wih s fcinta pa tc a dea lt tRa or vi a e hi rgh sundert
ea ngs lege t ufi e nd riul r ti ha df d olt d s i t
he
Re biiai n Ac a de est def nda ' moton t dimisf f iur t sa eacli .
ha lt to
t nd ni he e nts i o s s or al e o tt
am
1.
I t lg l tf vo a e t Les hi ke t f c sa e a f l s Les hi ke bega
n he i ht nos a r bl o c ns y, he a t r s olow . c ns y
n
wo k asa i or ton t hnol s cils a Ra or i J nua y o 2005. I t s i of
r
n nf ma i ec ogy pe a it t df d n a r f
n he prng
2008,Le c ns y wa dignos d wih a be n med c lte t e f rse p i omni a
s hi ke
s a
e t nd ga
i a r am nt o l e ns
a nd
se p a
l e pnea He no ii d hi s r i orofhi s e p i om ni and c uled wih t h a
.
tf e s upe v s
s l e ns
a
ons t
t he um n
r otr esde rmen a Ra or a o t ts metme.1 Leschi ke smedialc tons
es lc
pa t t t df d r und ha a i
ns y'
c ondii
i r hi a lt t pef maorlf a tviis i l ngsa nga kewihouthih-e l
mpaied s biiy o ronn j ie ci te ,ncudi tyi wa
t
g lve
si us I t s mme of2008 her evedawrte wani f fli ase p o t ob.
tmul .n he u r
, ec i
itn r ng or alng le n hej
'Les ns y' s peviorwasalo madea r ofLes hi ke sslep a aby s
chi ke s u r s
s
wa e
c ns y' e pne
umm e of2008.
r
P
Le c ns y e aned t hi s r ior t thewass e ng ate t e f hi c ton.l
s hi ke xpli o s upe v s s ha
e ki
r am nt or s ondii n
t s m e of2009, a or s pe d Le c ns y f t o da wihoutpay f s e pi on
he um r
R df d us nde s hi ke or w
ys t
or l e ng
tej b.OnOco e 25 2 0 Le c is e ss p r io g v hm f ry eg t o r t
h o
t b r , 01 , s hn k y' u ev s r a e i o t- ih h u s o
de
monsr t why Ra or s d nott r na ehi e o e .Les ns y co e e
ta e
df d houl
e mi t s mpl ym nt
chi ke mplt d
Ame ia wi Dia iiisAc (
rc ns t s b l e t ADA)f r a drq e tdi wrtn t t d odmo b c
h
t
o ms n e u se n iig ha Ra fr ve a k
hi dal sa tng tme, a l hi t us a doze a e t a w or , bot . On Oc obe 29,201 ,
s iy tri i
t r
0
low m o e
l r2 t k or h
Ra o dt r nae hi e oy e .Ra o ddenid hi r que tf a a c moda i
df r e mi t d s mpl m nt df r
e s e s or n c om
ton
a oxi a e y one w ee l t r
ppr m t l
k ae .
ll.
Les hi key a lgest tRadf r vi a e t Re biiai n Ac by de nghi
c ns
le ha
o d olt d he ha lt to
t
nyi
m
r a o bl ac omm oda i f hi diabiiy a tr i tnghi e o e s ey be us o
e s na e c
tons or s s lt nd e m nai
s mpl ym nt ol l ca e f
hi dia lt Thede e ntha m ove t dimisf f iur t sa eac am .The c r tnds
s s biiy.
f nda
s
d o s s or al e o t t l i
ou ti
Le c ns y' c pl i s a esa pl us bl c a m ,a de esRa or sm o i t dim i s
s hi ke s om a nt t t
a i e l i nd ni
df d' ton o s s .
To sa e a cl i f r i , he pl a ngsm us c t i S nough f c s t s a e a cl i t
tt
a m or elef t
e di
t on a n s
e
a t o tt
am o
r le t a i p a sbeo isfc . Bel lCo p v Two l, 5 U. 5 4, 7 (0 7
eif h t s lu il n t a e' lAt. r . . mbv 5 0 S. 4 5 0 2 0 )
'
( i to o te ) W hl tec u t t c e t h cama tsf cu l le ainsa tu , mi
ct in mitd . ie h o r mus a c p t e li n ' a t a alg to s r e He
a
Gr sLLC v. t ofN. ,130S. . 3,98 -87( 0) t stne i çnapplca et lga
p,
Ciy
Y.
Ct98 6 201 ,hi e t s ç
i i bl o e l
concusons Thr a er cial oft elme sofaca e ofa ton,s ppore by m e e
l i . e dbar e t s he e nt
us
ci u
td
r
concus r sae nt,donots fc 'As r f v.l ,1 S.Ct 1 1 (
l oy ttme s
ufie. hco t qbal 29
'
. 937, 949 2009)(iai
ctton
omitd)
te .
TheRe ltton Ac pr hi t dic i i ton a ai ta ohe wiequalted i vi l
habiia i
t o bis s rm na i g ns n t r s
ii ndi dua
wihadia lt Toesa ihaprmaf cec s ,apl nifmus s
t s biiy.
tbls
i a i a e aitf t how:û1 t theha a
t( ) ha
s
2I i t c e r fom t pl di whata E
t s m l a r he ea ngs
ç
doze a e t i .
l r' s
'
ds blt; 2 ta h i o h r s q aiidfrt e ly n .. i q sin' n ( ) h t e
ia ii ( ) h t e s t e wie u lfe o he mp o me t .n ueto , d 3 t a h
y
a
w a e ude f om t e pl ent... t di c i i ton s e y o t bas sofhi
s xcl d r he m oym
due o s r m na i ol l n he i
s
dia lt 'Doev.Uni ofM d.M e Sys Cor ,5 F. 1 ,1 - ( t Ci.1 .
s biiy.'
v.
d. . p. 0 3d 261 264-65 4h r 995)
Rad o d conc est tLe c ns y' c to qualf e a a di a lt undert AD A .
fr
ed ha s hi ke s ondii n
ii s s s biiy
he
A.
Ra f r a g st a Le c i s e wa n t( tewieq aiid'opef r h s o
d od r ue h t sh n k y s o s h r s u lfe 't ro m i j b.
o
Le c ns y i it t si a que ton off c t tc nnotpr ry be r s ve o R a or s Rul
s hi ke ns s s hi s
si
a t ha n
ope l
e ol d n df d'
e
1 ()6 mo in.Th c u t g e sta wh t e, t altrsa ti , s hn k yc u d
2b ( ) to
e o r a r e h t eh r wi ae tr tme Le c is e o l
h
p ro m tee s n il u to so h s o a dt ee yb oh nvs q aiidc n o b r s le
e fr h se ta f nci n f i j b n h rb e te ie u lfe a n t e e ov d
o Ra fr s1 ( ( )mo in.
n do d' 2b)6 to
Unde t ADA ,3ç i vi i t he wie quaii d'i he,l t orwihout
r he
t ndi dual s ot r s
lfe f
wih
t
an
r s bl ac om m oda i c n per o t es e i lf tonsoft e pl e tpos ton t
ea ona e c
ton, a
f nn he s nta unc i
he m oym n
ii hat
s hi vi lhol o de ie .'Hapei v.Aba usTec Cor ,1 F.d 1 ,1 ( h Ci.
uc ndi dua ds r srs'' l rn
c
h. p. 28 3 91 96 4t r
1 7)( i 42U. C.j1 118)(
99 quotng
S.
21 4 2006), nze o ohe gr
)over ld n t r oundsbyBar v. e 1
id Ros , 92
F. 462( hCi.19 .Le c ns yaleg t thi rquetdac ommodai wo dha
3d
4t r 99) s hi ke l es ha s e se c
ton ul ve
alow e hi t pe f m t e f tons U nde c r a n c r um s a s a l t rs a ttm e m a
l d m o r or hos unc i .
r e t i ic t nce , a e t r i
y
consiut ara ona eac ommodai 42U. C.j1 119)(ç- tr r as bl
tt e e s bl c
ton,
S. 21 ( ûl em e ona e
-he
ac ommodainma i l ... r-i ormodiidwor s he e .),a Le c ns yha
c
to y ncude pa ttme
fe
k c duls' nd s hi ke s
p a sbyalg dt t ec np ro tee sn il u cin o h s o wihaltrsa ti . e
lu i l le e ha h a e fnn h se ta f n to s f i j b t ae tr t Th
me
c u t s a c p Le c i k y' fcu lalg to sa tu a t i j n tr . nsq e ty
o r mu t c e t s hns e s a ta l ain s r e t hs u cu e Co e u nl,
e
Leshi keyhasplusbl al dhei ot r s qualfedf t j b.Acc di l t c t
c ns
a i y lege
s hewie ii or he o
or ngy,he our
3TheRe lttonA c I r ge t ADA f issa r . 2 U.. j7 4d (0 6 (t'esa ad
habiiai
t eve a s he
or t t nda ds 9 SC. 9 () 2 0 ) t h tnd rs
e
f
uscrtieemiewhhieehiscinbesb eandartdi acunderntalgigno fimaietcine lto met
sdm dtr n reh rtts ehalh he t voleappled mpatteIoft Am ercansvihtos mjlyAcnof
e o ton
t
to a en i a ni o liill nhe naf tw aD iabili t
e
r
di i nai unde t ss c i s l t s
on
ds
i
es
1 9 (2U. C.1 1 1e sq)a dtep o iin o s cin 5 tr u h5 4 a d51 ofh Ameia swih
9 0 4 S. 2 1 t e . n h r vso s f e t s 0l ho g 0 , n 0, te rc n t
o
Dia iie Ac o 1 9 ( 2 U. . 1 2 1 1 2 4 a d 1 21 ) a s c s ci n r lt t e o me t' .
s b l is t f 9 0 4 S C. 2 0 - 2 0 n 2 0 , s u h e to s eae o mply n .)
t
'
de esRa or smoton t dimiso t g ou t tLes hi keyha f ie t ade uael
ni
df d'
i o s s n he r nd ha
c ns
s al d o q t y
pl dt the i t he wie quaii d' f rt poston.
ea ha
st r s
ot
lfe ' o he ii 4
B.
R a or hasal o m oved t di m i s be a e Les hi ke w aied unt l he (11 h hou ' t
df d
s
o s s c us
c ns y t
it ç t
r' o
r que ta a omm oda i t twoul r quieRa or t r toa tvey e us m ic
e s n cc
ton ha
d e r df d o er c i l xc e s onduc ,
t
ar ng s h ar ques i i r nty unr s bl. Though Ra or i notr r d t e us
gui uc e t s nhe e l
ea ona e
df d s
equie o xc e
m ic
s onduc r t oa tvel Les hi ke scom pl i m a gi l a l est tRa or di not
t e r c i y, c ns y'
a nt r naly leg ha df d d
tnniaeh m b sdo p s c n u tb trte rj ce hi rq e t o ar a o a l
e n t i a e n a t o d c, u ah r ee td s e u s f r e s n be
ac om m oda i pr pec i l
c
ton os tve y.Cons que l t c t ni s Ra or s m oton t di m is on
e nty, he our de e df d'
i o s s
t gr undt ti dic r d Le c ns y f pa tmic
he o
ha t s ha ge s hi ke or s s onduc .
t
A r que tf a r ona e a om m oda i i f m a d- oo ng. I i pr pe tve. A n
e s or eas bl cc
ton s o r l ki
t s os c i
em pl e i note il t a r t oa tve a co m oda i n. The Re biia i Actdoesno
oye s
ntted o e r c i c m
to
ha lt ton
t
r uiee oye st e us mico uc .EEOC Enf c m e Gui nceon t ADA a
eq r mpl r o xc e s nd t
or e nt da
he
nd
Ps c iti Dia iiis No 91 .0 a 31( a. 5 1 9 ) Th b r ni o t e ly et
y harc s b l e , . 50 2 t M r 2 , 9 7 . e u de s n he mpo e o
t
bot i ntf t nee f a s
h de i y he d or nd ugges a a o i t ac om m o ton. yl v. i i lFi
t n ppr pr a e c
da i Ta or Prnc pa n.
Gr l .93F.d 1 1 4-65(t Ci.1 .Mic
p. nc, 3 55, 6
5h r 996) sonduc,e ni r ltdt adia lt i no
t ve f eae o sbiiy,s t
is l adia lt Mari onv. l v ShoeCop .1 4F. 683,686n. ( hCi.1 ) a i
tef sbiiy, tns Kime
, 0 3d
3 4t r 997, nd t
i no d s r m i to t hol an e pl yee r s nsbl f rt tm i c
s t i c i na i n o d
m o
e po i e o ha s onduc ,s e e. ,Lite v.FBI
t e . M. tl
,
1F. 255, 9( h Ci.1 (i ngno dic i nai unde j504f trngacoholc
3d
25 4t r 993) fndi
srmi ton
r
or ii l i
e oye f dia lt r aedi oxiai ond y)
mpl e or sbiiy-elt nt c ton ut .
4 shn kyas camst a h c np ro m tee snil u cin o hs o b u igaT o eaet'f
Lec is e lo li h t e a efr h se t fn to s f ij b y sn z z lr. I
a
d
'
Lec n k ywo l rmans sep a wokta d sieteaj sme to hi sa ti t a iwo l sila ea
shis e ud e i o le y t r h t ept h du t n f s trtme h tt ud tltk
t ealr't ke hi a a ,t c twoul lkeya e t thewoul beunqualfed.
ç
doz e t o ep m w ke he our
'
d i l gr e ha
d
ii
A r as bl ac omm oda i i onet tal wsa e oye t pe f m t e s nta
e ona e c
ton s
ha lo n mpl e o ror he s e il
f n to so tej b. y r v Ho e 5 F.d2 8 28 ( t Ci.1 9 )(Re s n b e
u ci n f h o M es . us , 0 3 7 , 3 4h r 9 5 ç a o a l
t
a co moda i i by ist r smos l c ly c tue a t twhi h pr e l ori t
c m
ton s t e m
t ogia l onsr d s ha
c es nty, n he
i daef tr , n b e t ee ly et p ro m t ee sn ilfncinso t j bi
mme it uu e e a ls h mpo e o ef r h se ta u t
o f he o n
queton. Theras blnes ofaprpos a co
si '
).
e ona e s
o ed c mmodain i odi rl aquesi off t
to s r naiy
ton ac.
Pa a i sv. . . fEd c,1 F.d 8 3 8 3( t Ci. 9 4 (ey n o Pa d zd sv. .
nd zde Va Bd o u . 3 3 2 , 3 4h r 1 9 ) rli g n n a i e Va
Bd.o Ed .946F. 345(t Ci.1 ).
f uc,
2d
4h r 991)
Be us f c splade i Le c ns y' compli tma gi ly s
ca e a t e d n s hi ke s
a n r nal uppor hi cai t t
t s l m ha
Ra or di no tr i t hi f pas m ic nd butr t be us i s w no r as t
df d d t e m na e m or t s o uct
aher ca e t a
e on o
a c m oda e hi pr pe tvel t c ur de e Ra or sm oton t di m i s
c om
t m os c i y, he o t ni s df d'
i o s s.
11
1.
The c tmus a c ptLes ns y' pl a ngsa tuea t ssa a hehassa e a
our
t ce
chi ke s e di
s r t hi t ge, nd
tt d
prmaf ci c e ofdic i i ton unde Re biiai Ac .Fort r as saed a
i a e as
s rm na i
r ha lt ton t
he e ons t t bove t
, he
cour de est Ra or smoton t dim isf f iur t sae ac am .
t ni he df d'
i o s s or al e o t t l i
Ent r:Oc obe 24,
e
t r 2011.
UW TED STATESDI TRI J
S CT UDGE
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?