Puckett v. WilcoHess, LLC et al

Filing 60

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 2/29/2012. (eot)

CL S OFFI U. DI .
ERK'
CE S. ST CDURT
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT
N
TED
STRI
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI I
N A
ROANOK E DI I N
V SIO

FEB 29 2 1
22
J A .
ULI

B
Y:

P

,Ct RK
x
CL
E

C i lA ct on N o.7:11cv00214
vi
i

D O N AL D PU C K E TT,
Pl ntif,
ai f

V.

M EM O M ND U M O PI O N
NI

W I
LCOH ESS LLC,e
taL
By:Sam uelG .W ison
l
U nied St
t
atesD i ri Judge
st ct

D ef
endant
s.

Thi i a pr i esla lt ac i n pur ua t t c ts di e s t -jrs ito , 8U. C.
s s em s i biiy to
s nt o he our ' v r iy u id ci n 2 S.

j 1 bypli ifDonadPuc t a ns d e nt W ic sLLC a A. W ila Oi
332, antf
l ket gai t efnda s loHes
nd T. lims 1

Co n (olci ey,s ic le s' frijzisP k t s sane a trsipigo a
mpa y c l tv l t lo- s' o nl e uc et u ti d fe l n n n
e
W
l )
r
p

I k o s b tn ea aW ic He stu k so W ic He sh smo e frsl r j dg n o
l n wn u sa c t lo s r c tp. lo s a v d o t
n
mmay u me t n
t g ot t tPuc t ca
he r md ha
ke t nnots
how wha c us d hi f l a islkey dtr to a t r f e
t a e s a l nd t i l ta i n nd he e or
ca
nnotesa i h t tW ic l s had a t lorc t c i no i ofa uns f c ton,a
t bls ha
l ol e s
c ua
onsnz tve tce n a e ondii n

es e ilelme ofaprma f c ec eofneglge e.Thec t e wih W ic l s a
s nta e nt
i a i as
i nc
our agr es t
lol e s nd

g a t ismotonfrsl r j me .
r ns t i o lmmay udg nt
1.

The r e ntf c s c t e i t lgh r tf vor bl t Puc t,a e a f l s
el va a t , ons nz d n he i t nos a a e o
ke t r s olow :

Puc t i ave e a t c drver ha ng ope a e c
ke t s t r n nz k i , vi
r t d omm e calve cessnce 1 a ha e a1
r i hi l i
981 nd ul d l
m a erofg
nn
oodst oughoutt U nie St t s Cur e l he ownsa ope a e a ta t -r ie
hr
he t d a e . r nty,
nd r t s r c or ta l r
t the us st de i ra om obie t G e gi Sou h Ca olna a Te w s e O n Augus 1
ha
e o lve ut
l s o or a, t r i , nd m s e.
t 8,

2009,Puc ttnd hi t nbr he a wokpa t r Ro l soppe a t W ic -e stu k
ket a s wi ot r nd r rne, nad) t d t he lol s r c
l
s o i W yt vil ,Vi gi a t f elPuc t' tac ort a l r
tp n
he le r ni o u
ke t s r t -r ie .Puc t ha t w a tf a p l p t
ke l d o i or
m o

CR

be m ea ia e ass a a t rtuc drve puledoutofa f ll ne, pule i Puc t
co
val bl ; oon s nohe r k i r l
ue a he l d n. ke t
t n bega hi ffee t t t mi ut r i off i t tuc and pe f mi r utne
he
n s it n- o wen y- n e outne uelng he r k
ror ng o i
i pe tons W he hewasne l done, ke ttlne t wak t d t so e hi f e we out
ns c i .
n
ary
Puc t t d o l owar he t r , s e t nt
r

fom unde hi ,az he f lha d on t pave nt Puc t i uns r wha ca ed hi t f l,
r
r m ld el r
he
me . ke t s u e
t us
m o al but
he s c a est ti w a a s i z pat h ofdi s lf lorm ot oi. W ha eve t ca e oft
pe ul t ha t s lppe y c
e e ue
or l
t r he us
he

f l W yt Co y Co m uniy Hos tllt rdignos Puc t wih abr n rghtf mur
al, he unt m
t
pia a e a ed ke t t
oke i e .

Pu t b oughtane i nceaci a ns W ic s i Vigi a cr ui c t or$1, 000,
cke t r
glge
ton gai t loHe s n r ni ic t our f
000,
a W ico sr move t aci n t t sc t
nd l Hes e
d he to o hi our.
II
.

W ic le sh smo df rs
lo l s a ve o umma yj d me to teg o n t t c e t amo e tbl h
r u g n n h r u d ha Pu k t c l t sa i
s
t tW ic e sha a t lo c t c i no i ofa uns f c ton. 1 B ecause Puc t,a t
ha l oH s d c ua r ons nz tve tce n a e ondii
ke t t he

ve y l a t i una et pr e a e de eoft d a i oft al geduns e c ton a t
r e s, s bl o es nt ny vi nc
he urton he le
af ondii t he

tuc so t co tfndst tPuc t ha f ie t e t bls aprmaf i c eand gr n s
r k t p, he ur i ha
ke t s al d o sa ih i ace as
at

' i o- s , to frs mmayj dg n .
W l le s moin o u r u me t
c l
2
The r l s a i a e t s i a f l c e a e w e l s tl i V igi a Se W im - xi
u e pplc bl o lp- nd- a l as s r l- e ted n r ni . e l Di e

Str ,I v. r r 240Va.1 1 2( 990)
oes nc. Pake ,
80, 8 1 .Unde t s r e ,asor opeaormus e rie
r he e uls t e rt
t xecs
'Puc tha satd, 1 d n'k o wh t se p do . .' ( c et p. 1 , e t 8 2 1 E...
ket s t e < o t n w a I tp e n . . Pu k tDe 2 1 S p . , 01 , C F No.
I
'

51 1)W i o s ag e t a b c u eP c etsu sr wh tcu e hm t flh c n o s o t p ee c o a
-. l Hes ru s h t e a s u k ti n ue a a sd i o al e a n t h w he rsn e f n
c
uns ec ton.Butt pli ifne d notknow wha c us d hi f l a l a hi e de ei s fcin t pr
af ondii
he antf e
t a e s al, s ong s s vi nc s ufi e t o ove

tel eys lc .Fo isa c ,nF bsv We bBla. d P'hp 2 2Va 2 7(9 6,h panifso l n t a
h i l oz e rn tn e i ob . b d Lt. si, 3 . 2 1 8 )te litf ç ud o sy
k
r
c
whatc e herf 1'buti hedi t tf t s ttppe ons
aus d
al,' t
s
d esiy hat he se d
omet ng whih wasve ysi r ' I a 231.
hi
c
r lppey.' d. t
'
TheV igi aSupr eCour hed t i wass tcintt tt plitf ha s t tfed;t tiha r ce l be
r ni
em
t l hat t
ufi e ha he an if d o esii ha t d e nty en
r i ng, usngc t e st ta k wat i o t buidi , t tot rcusom e shads n wae ont foor l
ani ca i usom r o r c
er nt he l ng'
and ha he t r
ee tr he l . d.

2S mmayjd n i a po raewh nçh pedig ,h ds o eya ddslsr maeil o fl,nd
u r u gme ts p rp it e < e la n s te ic v r n ico ue tras n i a
t
e
a yafd vt s o ta teei n g n ieis ea t a ymaeil at n ta t mo a tse ie t j d me t
n fia is h w h t h r s o e un su s o n tra fc a d h the v n i ntld o u g n
t
a amatro lw. F d R. v P. 6()2 .Th p rymo igfrs r u g n b astebzd no
s t fa ' e . Ci. 5 c() e at vn o ummayj d me t er h t e f
e
'
r
i or ngt c toft ba i f ism oto andi ntf ngt epa t oft r or whih de ons t t
nf mi he our he ss or t
in,
de iyi hos rs he ec d c m lae he

a sn eo ag n ieis eo maeilfc.Ceoe Cop v Cart, 7U. 31 , 2 (9 6 .l rviwiga
be c f e un su f tra at ltx r . . tet47 S. 7 3 3 1 8 ) n e e n
s mmayj d me t to u de Rue5 ,h c u tt tda alutta l i ee c si fv ro ten n vn
u r u g n moin n r l 6 te o r t
mus rw lj si be nfrn e n a o fh o mo ig
i
p ry' Uni d S ae v Ca o iaTr n f r rCo.9 8F.d 8 2 8 5( t Ci.1 9 ( ingAn e s nv. be t
a t . t tt s . r l
' e
n a so me , 7 2 3 , 3 4h r 9 2) ct
i
d r o Li ry
Lo b .n .4 7U.. 4 , 5( 9 6)
b v Ic, 7 S 2 2 25 1 8 ).

o di r c r t dc t r ont sor sprmies Z Or nayc r r uie t tt
r nay ae owar usomes he t e' e s .J
di r a e eq rs ha he

o e ao k e t p e s si ar a o a l s f c n iin rmo ef rino j csa ds b tn e
p rt r e p he rmie n e s n by ae o dto , e v o eg b e t n u sa c s
fom t too wihi ar s bl tm ewhe t ope a o knowso s d know oft i
r he l r t n ea ona e i
n he r t r
r houl
her

pr snc ,a wa nl
ee e nd r mknowi cuso r a t m.J
ng tmes bouthe #.

W h na iv tei ij e b af rino jc o s bsa eo t so ep e s s a
e n n ie s nurd y o eg be t r u tnc n he t r r mie ,
pli ifs e ng dmna m us s
antf e ki
ges t how t tt ope a orha acualorc tu tve notc oft
ha he r t
d t
onsr c i
i e he

c ndto Grm v Ra e l c, 46Va 23 2 2( 9 3 .W h nteei n e i e c of cu l
o i n. i . h mn .2
i
. 9, 4 1 9 ) e h r s o v d n e a t a
noie( i t c ehee ,ionsr tveknowldgeornoi ofadeeci co to ofa
tc as s he as r) ûc tuci
e
tce
f tve ndiin
pr s ...may b s
emie
e hown by ev de et tt de e twa notc a eandha e se f a
i nc ha he f c s i e bl
d xit d or

s fce lngt oftmet c r isposesorwihnoieofisdeeci c ton. l tll
uf int e h i o hage t s s t tc t f tve ondii ' d. tlf
'
t e d ef ist s
he vi enc a l o how whe ade ec occ r d ont pr m ies t pl ntf ha no ma o
n
f t ure
he e s ,he ai if s t de ut

a i a i c s . 1 ( ingW in Dii S oe , 4 Va a 1 4 .
prmaf ce a e' d. ct
'
i
n - xe tr s 2 0 . t 8 )

Ap ligt s p e e t,ti ce zt a W i od s i e tte t s mmayj g n
pyn hee rc p s i s la h t l le s s n ild o u r ud me t
c
be a ePuc t i una et pr s nte de eoft dur ton oft alege uns f cond to a
c us
ke t s bl o e e vi nc
he a i
he l d a e
ii n t
t t c sop.Notonl i Puc t uns ewha c us hi t f l he a t heha no i ahow
he nzk t
y s ket ur
t a ed m o al, dmis
s de

ln a ysip r s b tnc wa o t eg o n ( u k t De 21 , C. No 51 1- i ta i i
o g n lp ey u sa e s n h r u d P c et p. 5 E. F. . - ) f h t s n
f c wha ca ed hi t f l- a heofe sno ot re de et twoul cha ge W ico l s wih
a t t us
m o a l nd
fr
he vi nc ha
d r
l le s t

c nsnztv n tc .I i e tr l pa il ta t etu kla i j tb f r P c et ni e
o t cie o ie t s n iey lusb e h t h r c e vng us eo e u k ta v d
s le s
pild ome s t nce ort tPuc t hi s l s le f l waer oroi durng hi i pe to
ubsa , ha
ke t m e f pild ue , t ,
l i s ns ci n

r utne Se W i Di eStr , Va. t1 4 (ç- r i noe de ei t sc s t tl i
o i . e nn- xi oes 240 a 8 'lhee s vi nc n hi a e ha W nnDi e k w oft prs nceoft ( a ont foo , i t r a s ngoft lngt of
xi) ne
he e e
he be nl he l r nor s hee ny howi
he e h

tmei ma ha be nt r l i j tasl c lt a s t ti wa plce ont foora
i t y ve e hee. t s us ogia o sume ha t s a d he l n
i t tbeor g r r sr ki a ii t i e t tiha be t r l e ught tl i
nsan f e pake) tuc t s t s o nfr ha t d en hee ong no ha W nn-

Diils o l ,ntee ecs o ra o a l c r , a ek o a u i ' atrto si o iia)
x e h u d i h x r ie f e s n b e ae h v n wn bo t t'(leain n rgn l
( u tn Coo a S o e .nc v. le , 3Va 5 5 5 7( 9 2 :.
q oi g lnil t rs I . Puly 20 . 3 , 3 1 6 )
Pu t a gue a lng h t tt c ts d c r e W ic s wih c tu tvenotc
cke t r s t e t ha he our houl ha g
l oHe s t onsr c i
ie
be a et tuc sop wasabus l aton whos ve ybusnes wa t dipe e si r lqui .
c us he r k t
y oc i
e r
i s s o s ns lppe y i ds
Thi e de e,ho e r i i ufi intpr fofc tu tvenotc underV igi alw. See
s vi nc
w ve , s ns fce
oo
onsr c i
ie
r ni a

Ho g v W a- r Str s I c, 6 F.d4 6 4 3(t Ci. 0 4 (p yn Vigni lw)
d e . lMa t o e s n .3 0 3 4 , 5 4h r 2 0 ) a plig r i a a .

Rah r s c e ie c t o so l t wh t e teu s f c n iint t r d c d ( e ij r wa
te , u h v d n e d e ny o eh r h n ae o dto ha p o u e t ) nu y s
g
h
f esea ei g r ,notwhehe ghede e nt ha a t lo c tuci notc oft
or e bl n eneal
t r t f nda l d cua r onsr tve ie he

s c u aec n iinta ij rd ( eplitfj, j .
pe 6c nsf o dto h tn u e t an if.3 t
h
, j
W ha e rt ca eofPuc t' f l Vigi a1w i cea ont poi t twhe t r i
t ve he us
kets al, r ni a s l r he nt ha
n he e s
no e de eoft dur ton ofa uns f c ndii t pl i ifha notesa ihed aprmaf i
vi nc
he a i
n a e o ton,he antf s
t bls
i ace
ca e Be a e t r i no s h e de he e t c twilgr tW ic es 'm oton f r
s . c us he e s
uc vi nce r , he our l an
l oH s
i o
4

s mmayj d me t
u r u g n.

3Pucketde edvarousW icoles e o sr ga di W ic l s i pe ton a s l ce u
t pos
i
l - s mplyee e r ng loles ' ns c i nd pil lan-p
l

p o e ue, ndatmpst c nueag n n iseo maeilatrg rigW ic He s is e t nrgme
r c d r sa te t o o j r e uie su f tra fc e adn lo s'n p ci e i .
o
( eRep. tS mm. . 3 2 , C. No 5 )Bu a tee do ted y Pu k t si d e n t n w wh t a s d
Se s Mo. u J 2 - 4 E. F. . 6. t th n fh a , c ettl o s o k o a c u e
l
hi t fl orwhe t algeduns f c to a os Unde t cic m sa s t a
m o al
n he le
a e ondiin r e.
r he r u tnce , he dequac ofW ico e s
y
l H s'

is eto rgmei i tra.S eGrm, 46Va a 2 2 4 (< n e n td cd wh t rteo -a p ro
n p cin e i s mmaeil e i 2
. t 4 - 3 < e d o e ie ehe h ned y eid
We
s g etdb teIlitf wo dj si ghagn ted fn a t t c ntu tv n tc qb cu e a tetil o r
u g se y h panit ul utf c rig h ee d n wih o sr cie oie e a s , s h ra c ut
l
y
puti,the ei a olt y no e de a t whe t txt ewasbr n,
t t r s bs uel
vi nce s o
n he i ur
oke how i wasbr n,noevi nc t tt
t
oke
de e ha he

o e k e a o tt I c ul ha eb e b o e fv miue a oo so e.'.
wn r n w b u i. t o d v e n r k n ie n ts g r o n r')
'
4I r s et RonadPuc tsde iin tsi onyt thi br he m i ha si d o a(ier t'
n e pons o
l
ket' posto e tm
ha s ot r ght ve lppe n tr u'
t
ca e byt c tntweghtoftacortaie smo ng ov t tuc sop pa men ,W ic
us d he onsa
i
r t r lr vi
er he r k-t
ve t loHes a gue t ta
s r s ha ny
ale szf c def miy ne t f elilnd woul havebee ope a obvi .Puc t doe no a rt ba e
lged lra e or t ar he u sa
d
n n nd
ous
ke t s t ppea o s

hsc s o t she r (e Co l3 5 E. F No. -) a dhsrsone t temoinfrsmmayj d me t
i a e n hit oy se mp. - , C.. 12 , n i ep ss o h t o u r u g n
o
o l me to i i o e( nfn s e )p r g a h ( s M o . u . . 4 E. F. 5 )(Ast ( r ts ef c o
n y n in tn n u i ih d a a r p . Re p. t S mm J 2 , C. No. 6. f o a u ') fe t n
é
teflo teplitf ic nbec n iee ac nrb tn fco b tej r whc d e n t e ur c ne tr o
h al f h anif t a
o sd rd o tiuig a tr y h uy ih o s o rq ie oj cue r
u bild'sc)
n rde 'Iil.
Theea enum eousVigi ac e fndi sm iars fcedef test beo n a obvi a am atr
r r
r
r ni as s i ng i l ura
onnii o
pe nd
ous s
te
oflw andt r f eno grs frapr m ie la lt lws t See e. , kv M t Shoppi Ct.As oc v.
a
he eor t it o
e s s ibiiy a ui. . a.Roc
.
na r s s.

S e z l, 35Va 6 6 6 7( 9 8 . Towh tv re tn P c e t g t n e dt rs o s c at e l Vigni c s ta al2
. 3 , 3 18)
ae e x e t u k t mi h i tn o e t n u h h o y, r i a a e
Iw,c e wih t fct pr s nti t sc e,rnde t t or s c a i a unwor e.
a oupld t he a s e e n hi as e r he he y pe ultve nd
kabl

4

1
11.

Puc t f l t esabls aprm af c ec s ofpr m ie labiiy. Ac or ngl an
ket has aied o t ih i a i a e
e s s i lt
c di y, d

f rter ao sae ,h c u t lg a tW i o s ' to f rs mma yj d me t
o h e s ns ttd te o r wil rn l He s mo in o u r u g n.
c
s
ENTER : Thi 29t da ofFe ua y,201
s h y
br r
2.

A'

..

'

I IE S E oll c'J
T D TAT S s w r UDGE

5Thec tclrntyha unde a s m e W icoHe s m oto f Rul 37 s nctons. W ic
our tre l s
r dvie nt l s ' in or e
a i
l oHes a l ge
s le s
t tPucketsco elhasbe uncoope ai d i dic r ont is ofda age andm ovest srkepo tons
ha
t' uns
en
r tve urng s ovey he sue
m s
o ti
ri

o Pu k t'pla ig .I lg t ftejdg n h ri tec u t ld n W i o-s ' to frsn t n .
f c ets e dn s n ih o h u me t een,h o r wil e y l le s moin o a ci s
c l
o