Puckett v. WilcoHess, LLC et al
Filing
60
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 2/29/2012. (eot)
CL S OFFI U. DI .
ERK'
CE S. ST CDURT
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L
I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT
N
TED
STRI
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI I
N A
ROANOK E DI I N
V SIO
FEB 29 2 1
22
J A .
ULI
B
Y:
P
,Ct RK
x
CL
E
C i lA ct on N o.7:11cv00214
vi
i
D O N AL D PU C K E TT,
Pl ntif,
ai f
V.
M EM O M ND U M O PI O N
NI
W I
LCOH ESS LLC,e
taL
By:Sam uelG .W ison
l
U nied St
t
atesD i ri Judge
st ct
D ef
endant
s.
Thi i a pr i esla lt ac i n pur ua t t c ts di e s t -jrs ito , 8U. C.
s s em s i biiy to
s nt o he our ' v r iy u id ci n 2 S.
j 1 bypli ifDonadPuc t a ns d e nt W ic sLLC a A. W ila Oi
332, antf
l ket gai t efnda s loHes
nd T. lims 1
Co n (olci ey,s ic le s' frijzisP k t s sane a trsipigo a
mpa y c l tv l t lo- s' o nl e uc et u ti d fe l n n n
e
W
l )
r
p
I k o s b tn ea aW ic He stu k so W ic He sh smo e frsl r j dg n o
l n wn u sa c t lo s r c tp. lo s a v d o t
n
mmay u me t n
t g ot t tPuc t ca
he r md ha
ke t nnots
how wha c us d hi f l a islkey dtr to a t r f e
t a e s a l nd t i l ta i n nd he e or
ca
nnotesa i h t tW ic l s had a t lorc t c i no i ofa uns f c ton,a
t bls ha
l ol e s
c ua
onsnz tve tce n a e ondii n
es e ilelme ofaprma f c ec eofneglge e.Thec t e wih W ic l s a
s nta e nt
i a i as
i nc
our agr es t
lol e s nd
g a t ismotonfrsl r j me .
r ns t i o lmmay udg nt
1.
The r e ntf c s c t e i t lgh r tf vor bl t Puc t,a e a f l s
el va a t , ons nz d n he i t nos a a e o
ke t r s olow :
Puc t i ave e a t c drver ha ng ope a e c
ke t s t r n nz k i , vi
r t d omm e calve cessnce 1 a ha e a1
r i hi l i
981 nd ul d l
m a erofg
nn
oodst oughoutt U nie St t s Cur e l he ownsa ope a e a ta t -r ie
hr
he t d a e . r nty,
nd r t s r c or ta l r
t the us st de i ra om obie t G e gi Sou h Ca olna a Te w s e O n Augus 1
ha
e o lve ut
l s o or a, t r i , nd m s e.
t 8,
2009,Puc ttnd hi t nbr he a wokpa t r Ro l soppe a t W ic -e stu k
ket a s wi ot r nd r rne, nad) t d t he lol s r c
l
s o i W yt vil ,Vi gi a t f elPuc t' tac ort a l r
tp n
he le r ni o u
ke t s r t -r ie .Puc t ha t w a tf a p l p t
ke l d o i or
m o
CR
be m ea ia e ass a a t rtuc drve puledoutofa f ll ne, pule i Puc t
co
val bl ; oon s nohe r k i r l
ue a he l d n. ke t
t n bega hi ffee t t t mi ut r i off i t tuc and pe f mi r utne
he
n s it n- o wen y- n e outne uelng he r k
ror ng o i
i pe tons W he hewasne l done, ke ttlne t wak t d t so e hi f e we out
ns c i .
n
ary
Puc t t d o l owar he t r , s e t nt
r
fom unde hi ,az he f lha d on t pave nt Puc t i uns r wha ca ed hi t f l,
r
r m ld el r
he
me . ke t s u e
t us
m o al but
he s c a est ti w a a s i z pat h ofdi s lf lorm ot oi. W ha eve t ca e oft
pe ul t ha t s lppe y c
e e ue
or l
t r he us
he
f l W yt Co y Co m uniy Hos tllt rdignos Puc t wih abr n rghtf mur
al, he unt m
t
pia a e a ed ke t t
oke i e .
Pu t b oughtane i nceaci a ns W ic s i Vigi a cr ui c t or$1, 000,
cke t r
glge
ton gai t loHe s n r ni ic t our f
000,
a W ico sr move t aci n t t sc t
nd l Hes e
d he to o hi our.
II
.
W ic le sh smo df rs
lo l s a ve o umma yj d me to teg o n t t c e t amo e tbl h
r u g n n h r u d ha Pu k t c l t sa i
s
t tW ic e sha a t lo c t c i no i ofa uns f c ton. 1 B ecause Puc t,a t
ha l oH s d c ua r ons nz tve tce n a e ondii
ke t t he
ve y l a t i una et pr e a e de eoft d a i oft al geduns e c ton a t
r e s, s bl o es nt ny vi nc
he urton he le
af ondii t he
tuc so t co tfndst tPuc t ha f ie t e t bls aprmaf i c eand gr n s
r k t p, he ur i ha
ke t s al d o sa ih i ace as
at
' i o- s , to frs mmayj dg n .
W l le s moin o u r u me t
c l
2
The r l s a i a e t s i a f l c e a e w e l s tl i V igi a Se W im - xi
u e pplc bl o lp- nd- a l as s r l- e ted n r ni . e l Di e
Str ,I v. r r 240Va.1 1 2( 990)
oes nc. Pake ,
80, 8 1 .Unde t s r e ,asor opeaormus e rie
r he e uls t e rt
t xecs
'Puc tha satd, 1 d n'k o wh t se p do . .' ( c et p. 1 , e t 8 2 1 E...
ket s t e < o t n w a I tp e n . . Pu k tDe 2 1 S p . , 01 , C F No.
I
'
51 1)W i o s ag e t a b c u eP c etsu sr wh tcu e hm t flh c n o s o t p ee c o a
-. l Hes ru s h t e a s u k ti n ue a a sd i o al e a n t h w he rsn e f n
c
uns ec ton.Butt pli ifne d notknow wha c us d hi f l a l a hi e de ei s fcin t pr
af ondii
he antf e
t a e s al, s ong s s vi nc s ufi e t o ove
tel eys lc .Fo isa c ,nF bsv We bBla. d P'hp 2 2Va 2 7(9 6,h panifso l n t a
h i l oz e rn tn e i ob . b d Lt. si, 3 . 2 1 8 )te litf ç ud o sy
k
r
c
whatc e herf 1'buti hedi t tf t s ttppe ons
aus d
al,' t
s
d esiy hat he se d
omet ng whih wasve ysi r ' I a 231.
hi
c
r lppey.' d. t
'
TheV igi aSupr eCour hed t i wass tcintt tt plitf ha s t tfed;t tiha r ce l be
r ni
em
t l hat t
ufi e ha he an if d o esii ha t d e nty en
r i ng, usngc t e st ta k wat i o t buidi , t tot rcusom e shads n wae ont foor l
ani ca i usom r o r c
er nt he l ng'
and ha he t r
ee tr he l . d.
2S mmayjd n i a po raewh nçh pedig ,h ds o eya ddslsr maeil o fl,nd
u r u gme ts p rp it e < e la n s te ic v r n ico ue tras n i a
t
e
a yafd vt s o ta teei n g n ieis ea t a ymaeil at n ta t mo a tse ie t j d me t
n fia is h w h t h r s o e un su s o n tra fc a d h the v n i ntld o u g n
t
a amatro lw. F d R. v P. 6()2 .Th p rymo igfrs r u g n b astebzd no
s t fa ' e . Ci. 5 c() e at vn o ummayj d me t er h t e f
e
'
r
i or ngt c toft ba i f ism oto andi ntf ngt epa t oft r or whih de ons t t
nf mi he our he ss or t
in,
de iyi hos rs he ec d c m lae he
a sn eo ag n ieis eo maeilfc.Ceoe Cop v Cart, 7U. 31 , 2 (9 6 .l rviwiga
be c f e un su f tra at ltx r . . tet47 S. 7 3 3 1 8 ) n e e n
s mmayj d me t to u de Rue5 ,h c u tt tda alutta l i ee c si fv ro ten n vn
u r u g n moin n r l 6 te o r t
mus rw lj si be nfrn e n a o fh o mo ig
i
p ry' Uni d S ae v Ca o iaTr n f r rCo.9 8F.d 8 2 8 5( t Ci.1 9 ( ingAn e s nv. be t
a t . t tt s . r l
' e
n a so me , 7 2 3 , 3 4h r 9 2) ct
i
d r o Li ry
Lo b .n .4 7U.. 4 , 5( 9 6)
b v Ic, 7 S 2 2 25 1 8 ).
o di r c r t dc t r ont sor sprmies Z Or nayc r r uie t tt
r nay ae owar usomes he t e' e s .J
di r a e eq rs ha he
o e ao k e t p e s si ar a o a l s f c n iin rmo ef rino j csa ds b tn e
p rt r e p he rmie n e s n by ae o dto , e v o eg b e t n u sa c s
fom t too wihi ar s bl tm ewhe t ope a o knowso s d know oft i
r he l r t n ea ona e i
n he r t r
r houl
her
pr snc ,a wa nl
ee e nd r mknowi cuso r a t m.J
ng tmes bouthe #.
W h na iv tei ij e b af rino jc o s bsa eo t so ep e s s a
e n n ie s nurd y o eg be t r u tnc n he t r r mie ,
pli ifs e ng dmna m us s
antf e ki
ges t how t tt ope a orha acualorc tu tve notc oft
ha he r t
d t
onsr c i
i e he
c ndto Grm v Ra e l c, 46Va 23 2 2( 9 3 .W h nteei n e i e c of cu l
o i n. i . h mn .2
i
. 9, 4 1 9 ) e h r s o v d n e a t a
noie( i t c ehee ,ionsr tveknowldgeornoi ofadeeci co to ofa
tc as s he as r) ûc tuci
e
tce
f tve ndiin
pr s ...may b s
emie
e hown by ev de et tt de e twa notc a eandha e se f a
i nc ha he f c s i e bl
d xit d or
s fce lngt oftmet c r isposesorwihnoieofisdeeci c ton. l tll
uf int e h i o hage t s s t tc t f tve ondii ' d. tlf
'
t e d ef ist s
he vi enc a l o how whe ade ec occ r d ont pr m ies t pl ntf ha no ma o
n
f t ure
he e s ,he ai if s t de ut
a i a i c s . 1 ( ingW in Dii S oe , 4 Va a 1 4 .
prmaf ce a e' d. ct
'
i
n - xe tr s 2 0 . t 8 )
Ap ligt s p e e t,ti ce zt a W i od s i e tte t s mmayj g n
pyn hee rc p s i s la h t l le s s n ild o u r ud me t
c
be a ePuc t i una et pr s nte de eoft dur ton oft alege uns f cond to a
c us
ke t s bl o e e vi nc
he a i
he l d a e
ii n t
t t c sop.Notonl i Puc t uns ewha c us hi t f l he a t heha no i ahow
he nzk t
y s ket ur
t a ed m o al, dmis
s de
ln a ysip r s b tnc wa o t eg o n ( u k t De 21 , C. No 51 1- i ta i i
o g n lp ey u sa e s n h r u d P c et p. 5 E. F. . - ) f h t s n
f c wha ca ed hi t f l- a heofe sno ot re de et twoul cha ge W ico l s wih
a t t us
m o a l nd
fr
he vi nc ha
d r
l le s t
c nsnztv n tc .I i e tr l pa il ta t etu kla i j tb f r P c et ni e
o t cie o ie t s n iey lusb e h t h r c e vng us eo e u k ta v d
s le s
pild ome s t nce ort tPuc t hi s l s le f l waer oroi durng hi i pe to
ubsa , ha
ke t m e f pild ue , t ,
l i s ns ci n
r utne Se W i Di eStr , Va. t1 4 (ç- r i noe de ei t sc s t tl i
o i . e nn- xi oes 240 a 8 'lhee s vi nc n hi a e ha W nnDi e k w oft prs nceoft ( a ont foo , i t r a s ngoft lngt of
xi) ne
he e e
he be nl he l r nor s hee ny howi
he e h
tmei ma ha be nt r l i j tasl c lt a s t ti wa plce ont foora
i t y ve e hee. t s us ogia o sume ha t s a d he l n
i t tbeor g r r sr ki a ii t i e t tiha be t r l e ught tl i
nsan f e pake) tuc t s t s o nfr ha t d en hee ong no ha W nn-
Diils o l ,ntee ecs o ra o a l c r , a ek o a u i ' atrto si o iia)
x e h u d i h x r ie f e s n b e ae h v n wn bo t t'(leain n rgn l
( u tn Coo a S o e .nc v. le , 3Va 5 5 5 7( 9 2 :.
q oi g lnil t rs I . Puly 20 . 3 , 3 1 6 )
Pu t a gue a lng h t tt c ts d c r e W ic s wih c tu tvenotc
cke t r s t e t ha he our houl ha g
l oHe s t onsr c i
ie
be a et tuc sop wasabus l aton whos ve ybusnes wa t dipe e si r lqui .
c us he r k t
y oc i
e r
i s s o s ns lppe y i ds
Thi e de e,ho e r i i ufi intpr fofc tu tvenotc underV igi alw. See
s vi nc
w ve , s ns fce
oo
onsr c i
ie
r ni a
Ho g v W a- r Str s I c, 6 F.d4 6 4 3(t Ci. 0 4 (p yn Vigni lw)
d e . lMa t o e s n .3 0 3 4 , 5 4h r 2 0 ) a plig r i a a .
Rah r s c e ie c t o so l t wh t e teu s f c n iint t r d c d ( e ij r wa
te , u h v d n e d e ny o eh r h n ae o dto ha p o u e t ) nu y s
g
h
f esea ei g r ,notwhehe ghede e nt ha a t lo c tuci notc oft
or e bl n eneal
t r t f nda l d cua r onsr tve ie he
s c u aec n iinta ij rd ( eplitfj, j .
pe 6c nsf o dto h tn u e t an if.3 t
h
, j
W ha e rt ca eofPuc t' f l Vigi a1w i cea ont poi t twhe t r i
t ve he us
kets al, r ni a s l r he nt ha
n he e s
no e de eoft dur ton ofa uns f c ndii t pl i ifha notesa ihed aprmaf i
vi nc
he a i
n a e o ton,he antf s
t bls
i ace
ca e Be a e t r i no s h e de he e t c twilgr tW ic es 'm oton f r
s . c us he e s
uc vi nce r , he our l an
l oH s
i o
4
s mmayj d me t
u r u g n.
3Pucketde edvarousW icoles e o sr ga di W ic l s i pe ton a s l ce u
t pos
i
l - s mplyee e r ng loles ' ns c i nd pil lan-p
l
p o e ue, ndatmpst c nueag n n iseo maeilatrg rigW ic He s is e t nrgme
r c d r sa te t o o j r e uie su f tra fc e adn lo s'n p ci e i .
o
( eRep. tS mm. . 3 2 , C. No 5 )Bu a tee do ted y Pu k t si d e n t n w wh t a s d
Se s Mo. u J 2 - 4 E. F. . 6. t th n fh a , c ettl o s o k o a c u e
l
hi t fl orwhe t algeduns f c to a os Unde t cic m sa s t a
m o al
n he le
a e ondiin r e.
r he r u tnce , he dequac ofW ico e s
y
l H s'
is eto rgmei i tra.S eGrm, 46Va a 2 2 4 (< n e n td cd wh t rteo -a p ro
n p cin e i s mmaeil e i 2
. t 4 - 3 < e d o e ie ehe h ned y eid
We
s g etdb teIlitf wo dj si ghagn ted fn a t t c ntu tv n tc qb cu e a tetil o r
u g se y h panit ul utf c rig h ee d n wih o sr cie oie e a s , s h ra c ut
l
y
puti,the ei a olt y no e de a t whe t txt ewasbr n,
t t r s bs uel
vi nce s o
n he i ur
oke how i wasbr n,noevi nc t tt
t
oke
de e ha he
o e k e a o tt I c ul ha eb e b o e fv miue a oo so e.'.
wn r n w b u i. t o d v e n r k n ie n ts g r o n r')
'
4I r s et RonadPuc tsde iin tsi onyt thi br he m i ha si d o a(ier t'
n e pons o
l
ket' posto e tm
ha s ot r ght ve lppe n tr u'
t
ca e byt c tntweghtoftacortaie smo ng ov t tuc sop pa men ,W ic
us d he onsa
i
r t r lr vi
er he r k-t
ve t loHes a gue t ta
s r s ha ny
ale szf c def miy ne t f elilnd woul havebee ope a obvi .Puc t doe no a rt ba e
lged lra e or t ar he u sa
d
n n nd
ous
ke t s t ppea o s
hsc s o t she r (e Co l3 5 E. F No. -) a dhsrsone t temoinfrsmmayj d me t
i a e n hit oy se mp. - , C.. 12 , n i ep ss o h t o u r u g n
o
o l me to i i o e( nfn s e )p r g a h ( s M o . u . . 4 E. F. 5 )(Ast ( r ts ef c o
n y n in tn n u i ih d a a r p . Re p. t S mm J 2 , C. No. 6. f o a u ') fe t n
é
teflo teplitf ic nbec n iee ac nrb tn fco b tej r whc d e n t e ur c ne tr o
h al f h anif t a
o sd rd o tiuig a tr y h uy ih o s o rq ie oj cue r
u bild'sc)
n rde 'Iil.
Theea enum eousVigi ac e fndi sm iars fcedef test beo n a obvi a am atr
r r
r
r ni as s i ng i l ura
onnii o
pe nd
ous s
te
oflw andt r f eno grs frapr m ie la lt lws t See e. , kv M t Shoppi Ct.As oc v.
a
he eor t it o
e s s ibiiy a ui. . a.Roc
.
na r s s.
S e z l, 35Va 6 6 6 7( 9 8 . Towh tv re tn P c e t g t n e dt rs o s c at e l Vigni c s ta al2
. 3 , 3 18)
ae e x e t u k t mi h i tn o e t n u h h o y, r i a a e
Iw,c e wih t fct pr s nti t sc e,rnde t t or s c a i a unwor e.
a oupld t he a s e e n hi as e r he he y pe ultve nd
kabl
4
1
11.
Puc t f l t esabls aprm af c ec s ofpr m ie labiiy. Ac or ngl an
ket has aied o t ih i a i a e
e s s i lt
c di y, d
f rter ao sae ,h c u t lg a tW i o s ' to f rs mma yj d me t
o h e s ns ttd te o r wil rn l He s mo in o u r u g n.
c
s
ENTER : Thi 29t da ofFe ua y,201
s h y
br r
2.
A'
..
'
I IE S E oll c'J
T D TAT S s w r UDGE
5Thec tclrntyha unde a s m e W icoHe s m oto f Rul 37 s nctons. W ic
our tre l s
r dvie nt l s ' in or e
a i
l oHes a l ge
s le s
t tPucketsco elhasbe uncoope ai d i dic r ont is ofda age andm ovest srkepo tons
ha
t' uns
en
r tve urng s ovey he sue
m s
o ti
ri
o Pu k t'pla ig .I lg t ftejdg n h ri tec u t ld n W i o-s ' to frsn t n .
f c ets e dn s n ih o h u me t een,h o r wil e y l le s moin o a ci s
c l
o
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?