Bates et al v. Strawbridge Studios, Inc. et al

Filing 26

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/5/2012. (lab)

DLERK: IFFI U, QI O LRT
R :, R
J
ArR- OK;,
VA

AL O
E

I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO U RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTEM D I
STRI O F V I GI A
CT
R NI
ROA N OKE DI SI
VI ON

Mà2 25 2 1
22
JULK C. LEY C E
D

B ; i' 'zt
1Z
l

CL RK

CHA RLES M . TES, Ig
BA
# .
L,
.

Ci lActon N o.7: CV 00 6
vi
i
11
21
Pl ntf s,
ai if
M EM O M ND UM O PINIO N

STRA W BRI G E STUD I S,I C . # g ,
D
O N , 1 1,
.

By:Hon. e E.Co ad
Gln
nr
Chi U nie St t D i ti tJ
ef t d a es s rc udge

Def nda s
e nt .

ChalsM . tsa dDo naL. ts(olcieyr fre t a çhepanif' fld
re Bae n n
Bae c le t l ee rd o s l li t s' ie
v
t
f )
t sdi r iyaci f rdef ma i a br a h ofc r ta i tSta i e St os l
hi ve st ton o
a ton nd e c
ontac gans r wbrdg udi , nc.

(ûta rd e'a J l Do , nu k o e o e a do a e t fSrwb ig .Th c s i
d rwb ig ' nd om e a n n wn mply e n /r g n o ta rd e e a e s
s
)
pr e l be or t c t Sta i sm o i n t dim is Fort r as t tf l t
es nty f e he our on r wbrdge' to o s s .
he e ons ha olow, he
m oton w ilbe de e
i
l
ni d.
Background

Thef l wi f t ,tke fom t pli tfs co pli t a eac e e a t ef
olo ng acs a n r he a n if ' m a n , r c pt d s nl or

p r o e o tep n igmoi n S eErc s nv Pad s 5 U. 8 , 4( 0 7 .
u p s s f h e dn to . e ik o . r u , 51 S. 9 9 2 0 )
I Aug tof2009,hepli tfs o r ofSi hta Sot St os l ,fl a a ton
n
us
t a n if , wne s
g nd md udi , nc. ied n c i

f rb e c o c nr c i saec u t g is Srwb ig S u is I c (sr wb i g '
o r a h f o ta t n tt o r a an t ta rd e t do ,n .t ta rd e).
t
Sta i e r move t a ton t t sco to di riy g ot ,a t pa tesuli aey
r wbrdg e
d he c i o hi ur n ve st r mds nd he ri tm t l
neg i t d a s tl e ag e m en t tr ol t i di put Se Si hta Sound Sm di . nc.
ota e
e tem nt r e t ha es ved he r s e. e g nd
os l

v. ta rdg Sudo .n .No 7:9 03 8( . Va 2 0 ) Th stlme ta re n ,
Srwb i e t is Ic, . 0 CV0 3 W D. . 0 9 . e ete n g e me t
w hi w asexecut on M ay 12,2010,i udes t f l ng pr son:t-'e pari agr t
ch
ed
ncl
he olowi
ovi i û h
f
tes ee hat
neiherw ilsay,wrt publs br
t
l
ie, i h, oadcas ,ori any ot w ay partci t i negatve or
t n
her
i pa e n
i
di par ng com m ent aboutt ot '
s agi
s
he her.'

-

OnN o mbe 1 201 Sta rdger c i aphonec l fom Trna La a ,who
ve r 0, 0, r wb i e eved
al r
i
pr de
r
eque t d t orgi ne tve f he da e ' s ho phot r ph f om t pr vi ye r
s e he i nal ga i or r ught r s c ol
og a r he e ous a .

La ades
pr
poke wih Sta i sc t m e s r c r pr e ai ,
t r wbrdge' uso r e vie e es nt tve who t d he t tSta i
ol r ha r wbrdge
di no ha t phot a butt tt pli if mi ha i,snc t ywe e wor ng wih
d t ve he
ogr ph, ha he antfs ght ve t i e he r
ki
t
Sta i e dli t r e nttm e Thec t rs r ier pr s t tveadde ho ver t t
r wbrdg trng he elva i .
usome e vc e e en a i
d, we , ha
t pl ntfsE r notr putbl a c dnotbetuse 'a t tEhi gots ba weha t
he ai if t e
we
e a e nd oul
r t d,' nd ha ç ngs
t
o d
d o

g tiv le i alws i. ( mp . t 7 .
e n ov d n a ut' Co la ! )
'
Afe t sc ve s ton, pr deviiedhe da e ' hi s hoola r pe t t
tr hi on r ai La a
st
r ughtr s gh c
nd e aed he
sae e smadeb Sta i e' c t rs r i r pr s n a i La a t n i r d a t
tt m nt
y r wbrdg s usome e vce e e e t tve. pr de he nquie s o
whyt s hoolwoul de wih pe e ofs h ne tvec r ce .
he c
d al t opl
uc ga i ha a tr
On M ay9, 1 t pli if fld t sd ve st a tonagans Sta i a is
201 , he antfs ie hi i riy ci
i t r wbrdge nd t
t
mknown c t
usomers r i er pr e ai as e tng cam sofde ama in a br a h ofc r c .
e v c e es nttve, s ri li
f to nd e c
onta t'

Sr wb i eha mo dt d s s tec mpan p ru n t Rul 1 ( )6 o teFe ea Rue
ta rdg s ve o imis h o lit u s a t o e 2 b ( ) f h d r l ls
ofCi lPr ed e. Them at rha bee f lybre e a i rpef r vi w.
vi oc ur
te s n u l if d nd s i or e e
St
anda ofR e e
rd
vi w

çf epupo eo aRue1 ( )6 moini t ts tes f in yo ac mp an .
d' r s f l 2 b ( ) t s o e th u fce c f o lit'
-h
o
'
Edwadsv. t ofGol boo,1 F. 231, ( hCi.1 .W he rviwi acam
r Ciy
ds r 78 3d
243 4t r 999)
n e e ng li
unde t sr e,hec tm us a c ptaloft al gai nsi t c
r hi ul t our
t c e 1 he le to n he ompl ntastuea dr w al
ai
r nd a l

#Prort flng t i t ntac i , t pl ntf sfied adef i acton agai tSt a i i
i o ii he ns a ton he ai if l
amaton i
ns r wbrdge n
sat cour,whi wasr oved t t sc ton di siy gr
te
t ch
em
o hi our
ver t ounds. On M a 1 2011 t courtp ant
y 7,
, he
ed
Sta i sm oton t dim isf f l et sa ea cl m . See Bat v.Sta i St os.l ,Cas
r wbrdge'
i o s s or aiur o tt
ai
es
r wbrdze udi nc. e

No. 11 00 ,2 1U. Dit LEXI 5 42( . Va M a 1 , 1.Du i tehe rngo t t
7: CV0 33 01 S. s. S 24 W D. . y 7 201 ) rng h ai n ha
moton,t cour advied t pari t tt pl ntf swoul be per ted t fl a a ended compl nt
i he
t s he tes ha he ai if
d
mit o ie n m
ai
ora ne acton. Thepl ntfsel ed t pur uet lte coure and Gl t i t acton on M ay 9,
w i
ai if ect o s he a tr
s
ed he nsant i
20l1. Fort r onsexpl ne bel t cour concl t t ne com pl ntcont nss fcint
he eas
ai d ow, he
t
udes hat he w
ai
ai uf i e
alegatonst s ve am oton t dim is.
l i o urvi
i o s s

r s bl i e e esi f vo oft pli if . l a 2 ûro s vveamoton t dim is a
ea ona e nf r nc n a r he antfs d. t 44. t ur i
'
i o s s,
c pl i tm us c a n s t i ntf ct lm a t r a c pt d a t u ,t ç t t a cl i t r i ft ti
om a n
t ont i ufk e a ua te , c e e s r e o sa e a m o ele ha s

p a sbeo i fc .'As co t I b l5 6U.. 6 ,1 9 S. . 9 7, 9 9( 0 9 ( u tn
lu il n t a e' h r f v.q a, 5 S 6 2 2 Ct 1 3 1 4 2 0 ) q oig
s
'
Bel l Co p. Two l 5 0U. 5 4 5 0( 0 7) 4noh rwods tefcua alg to s
lAt. r v. mby, 5 S. 4 , 7 2 0 ).; t e r ,h a t l le ain
1
(a na t e mus ç r tt co toi e mor t nt meeposi lt ofmico t''
tke s nz) t pe mi he ur t nfr e ha he r sbiiy
s nduc .'A
Soc' W ihou a N a e f rPe e wihou a H om e M il r il Fu ur - e q v. igi a 655
v t t
m . o opl t t
. le m lm t e pr s nt V r ni ,

F.d3 2 3 6(t Ci. 01 )( u tn lb l 1 9S. . t1 5 )
3 4 , 4 4 h r 2 1 q oig q a, 2 Cta 9 0 .
Di cuss on
s i
1.

De am aton
f
i

Thepa tesag eet tVigni l w a isi t sdi r iya i Toesa ih a
ri r ha r i a a pple n hi ve st cton.
t bls
de a ai n ca m unde Vigi alw,t pl ntfsmus fr ts
f m to li
r r ni a he ai if
t is how t tt de e ntpubls d a
ha he f nda
ihe
f lef t lsae e t tconc r a ha mst pli if ort pl ntfs r putto Hylnd
a s acua t tm nt ha
e ns nd r he antfs he ai if ' e ai n. a

v Ra te nTe l c lS r s Co, 7 S. 2 7 6 7 0( . 0 9 .Th p an if mu tas
. yh o cmia e v . .6 0 E.d 4 , 5 Va 2 0 ) e litfs s lo
s
how t ha t de e n kne t tt sae e wa f s or beivi t tt sa e e twas
d t he f nda t w ha he t tm nt s ale , le ng ha he tt m n
t
t u l c a r as bl ba i f r s h be i f ora t d neglge l i f lng t de er i t
r e, a ked e ona e s s o uc le , c e
i nty n aii o t m ne he

fcso whi t publc tonwasbasd. L. t fmaor sae nt ma i l sae nt
a t n ch he iai
e ' ds t a t y ttme s y ncude ttme s
' u De
m a by i e e e,i i a i ori i to ' I Deamaor wo dsa e a tona eperK i
de nf r nc mplc ton, nsnuai n. d. f t y r r c i bl
'
f

t e p eu ieap ro i hi o h rta eo p oe so F t v. vesd He lh aeAs'
h y rj d c e s n n s r e rd r r fsin. use Ri rie at c r sn.
l ,575S. 2d 858,861( 2003)
nc.
E.
Va.
.
I m o ngt dimist pl i if 'de n ai cli ,Sta i a g t tt
n vi o s s he antfs f m ton am r wbrdge r ues ha he
s a e e sa l ge y m a by is c t e s r i r pr s t tve a e nota tona e,be a e t y
t t m nt le dl de t us om r e v ce e e en a i r
c i bl c us he
a e e es i ofo ni r t rt n sa e e soff c . d us sofac i n f def m a i ha
r xpr s ons pi on a he ha t t m nt
at l
ca e
to or a ton ve

terb ssi saec mmo lw b t r s be tt p icplso fe d m o s e h aiigu d r
h i a i n tt o n a u ae u jc o rn i e f r e o f pe c rsn n e
t Fi s A m e
he r t
ndm e t t U nied St t Cons iuton a A ri l 1 Se ton 1 oft
nt o he t
a es
tt i nd tc e , c i 2 he

Co si to o Vign a' Ye gev. le it Ti s 4 7S. 2 1 6 1 7( . 9 )
n tt in f r ii. a l Co lgae me , 9 E.d 3 , 3 Va 1 98 .
u
'
Co s q nl t p t ee p e so so o iiny whc d n t o ti p o a yflefcua
n e ue t t ll x rs in f pn o ' ih o o c nan r v bl as a t l
y, l r
'
c mo a i ,û a tnor ly f r t ba i ofa aci f de a a in. W J TV v. vi
ol t tons ç nno
c
ma l o m he ss n ton or f m to ' LA'
Le n,

5 4 S. 2 3 3 3 2( . 0 2 .Ho v r teUntdS ae Su r meCo r S a s e i al
6 E.d 8 , 9 Va 2 0 ) we e,h ie tts p e
u tt s p cfc l
h
y
de lne t hol t tsae e sofo ni a e c t orcal e ude a t bassf acommon
c i d o d ha t tm nt
pi on r aeg i ly xcl d s he i or

lw dea to ca eofa ton.'l (ii M iko c v. r nJ na Co.497U. 1,1821
a fmain us ci ' d. ctng l vih Loai our l ,
S. -

( 9 ) Ast eS p e Co r o sr e i M ik vc
1 90 . h u rme u t b e v d n lo ih:
I a s a s ys û n my o ni J hn J si ala , hei i a
f pe ker a , t
l
pi on o one s ir' mples
'
knowl e off c swhih l dt t co uso t tJ st dan un nzh.
edg
at
c ea o he ncl i n ha one ol
t t
Eve i t s ake s a est f c su n w hi h he bas t o ni i
n f he pe r t t he a t po
c
es he pi on, f
t ef csa eeihe i ore tori mplt ,o i hi as esm e oft m
hos a t r t r nc r c nco e e r f s s s nt he
i er
s r oneo ,t s a e e m a sili pl a f s a s r i off c . Si pl
us he t t m nt y t l m y al e s e ton a t m y
c hi s h s a e e si t r sofopi on doesnotdi pe t e
ouc ng uc t t m nt n e m
ni
s l hes
i plc tons a t sa e e ,d n m y opi o J
m i a i ; nd he t t m nt t
l
ni n onesi a la ,' n c us
s i r' ca a e
asm uch da ag t r put ton a t s a e e , tonesi a l i .
m e o e a i s he t t m nt tl
s a r'
'
l a 1 1
d. t 8- 9.

Theque to ofwhehe ade a t ysa e nti o o f toropi o pr e t alga
si n
t r f ma or tt me s ne f ac
ni n es n s e l
quesi t be d i by t c t Hvlnd,67 S. 2d a 751.ç n dee mi ngwhe he a
ton o
ecded he our. a
0 E. t
t tr ni
l
t r
s a e e ti one off c oropi on, c r m a no i ol t one pori oft s a e e a i s
ttm n s
at
ni a ou t y t s a e
ton he t t m nt t s ue

fom a t rpori oft sae nt' Ja l ta t c tmus co i rt sae nta a
r nohe ton he ttme . .. nse d,he our t nsde he ttme s
'p
w hol I
e. d.

Appl ngt s prnci es t co ti u bl t c udet tt satm e sa i s a e
yi he e i pl , he ur s na e o oncl ha he t e nt t s ue r
pur e e sonsofopi o t tca
e xpr s i
ni n ha nnotf m t ba i ofa a tona e ca m f de a ai n.
or he ss n c i bl li or f m to
Ta n a one, he s a e e t tt pl ntf sç e e notr put bl a co d notbe t ts e '
ke l t t t m nt ha he ai if s r
w
e a e nd ul
rz t dp'
4

a gua y co d bec i r d a e e so o opi on.Howeve ,gi n t c t xti whih t
r bl ul
onsde e n xpr s i n f ni
r ve he on e n c he
saeme wasm a ,a t f c t tt c t rs r ier e en a i a edt t(hi go
t t nt
de nd he a t ha he usome e vc epr s t tve dd ha ç ngs t
t

s ba ( rwbrdge ha t ge i vedi alws t't c t ncl st tt
o d Sta i l d o tnvol n a ui 'he our co ude ha he
r pr e a i s s a e e s c d be r s bl t de s ood t i pl t e s e e ofdef m a or
e es nt tve' t t m nt oul
ea ona y m r t
o m y he xit nc
a t y

f c s SeeBa l v.Compr he i Pan M gmt Cts,Ca eNo.7:
a t.
y or
e nsve i
. r. s
09CV00472,2011U. Dit
S. s .

LEXI 3 6 9 a * 4- 5( . Va Ap . , 01 )(-h ts frd tr nn wh t e fcst a
S 7 9 , t 3 3 W D. . r 6 2 1 tl e e t o ee mi ig eh r a t h t
ima beaci bl de a ton ha be n i i d i t t a r s na e lse rwoul t ke
y
tona e f ma i
ve e mple s wheher ea o bl it ne
da

(hes kelt bebasnghi t ni onknowldgeoffcsoft s tha c nbee l tdi
t pea r o
i s opi on'
e
a t he or t n a
vauae n

ad fmai ns i.'( u tn Ro e t S c S c o Den to Li e, a de, n Reae
ea to u t') q oi g b r D. a k, a k n fmain: b lSln r a d ltd
'
Pr b e j43: ( t Ed 2 0 Be a s tsttme t ce ryi li t ee itn eo fcs
o lms : 2 4h . 01 :. c u e c lae n s lal mp yng h x se c f a t
l
a ea to a ea d fmain, S nge v.TT Co .9 3F.d 1 6 ,1 71(t Ci. 9 3 ,h
r cin bl s ea to ' we lr I
'
m , 9 2 0 3 0 4h r 1 9 ) te
cour co l st tSta rdge' frta g
t ncude ha r wb i s is r umen i wihoutmert
ts t
i.
To t extntSta i at r i y a g t tt def ma i c am c it ofba e
he e r wbrdge lenatvel r ues ha he a ton l i onsss
r
l ga c l i nsa a f m ul i r c t to oft ne e s r el m e s t c t sunabl t
e l onc us o nd or a c e ia i n he c s a y e nt , he our i
eo

ag e W hie s eoft pl i if 'al ga insa ea g bl co l or t c ti oft
r e.
l om
he antfs le to r r ua y ncus y, he our s he
opi on t tt c
ni ha he ompl nt i ise iey,c anss fce f cualc entt sa eacl m f
ai , n t ntrt onti ufi int a t ont o tt
ai or
def ma i t ti pl i eon isf e I ,1 S. . t1
a ton ha s ausbl
t ac . nbal 29 Ct a 949.

Fial,h c u t s as rj c t eapl n t a ted fmaincam i ba 'db t e
n l te o r mu t lo ee t h r me t h th ea to li s ne y h
y
s tl nta e m e tt tt pa tesr a he i t fr taci
e teme gr e n ha he ri e c d n he is ton.Ha ng r vi we t t r of
vi e e d he e ms
t a e m e ,hec ti una et c ude a ama troflw,t tt ag e me woul
he gr e nt t our s bl o oncl , s
te
a ha he r e nt
d
pr ude t partes f pur ui a cl m t ar e s alm ont aft t agr entwas
ecl he
i rom
s ng ai hat os ever
hs er he eem
execut Fort e r
ed.
hes easons,Staw brdge' m oton m us be deni w ih r pectt t pl ntff
r
i s i
t
ed t es
o he ai i s'

c a m f de a aton.
l i or f m i

I.
I

Br ach ofC ont t
e
rac

Sta i a s a g t tt co antf ist sa eac am f rbr c ofc r c .
r wbrdge lo r ues ha he mpli al o tt l i o ea h onta t

Und rVignalw,ith e sn il lme t o ac us o a to f rb e c o c nrc ae( )a
e r ii a ç l e se ta ee n s f a e f cin o ra h f o ta t r 1
l
lg l bi aino ad fn a t oapanif ( )avoaino b e c o ta o lg to a ()a
e a o lg to f ee d n t litf, 2 ilto r ra h f h t b iain, nd 3
c n e u n ilij r o d ma et t epanif' Ha e v. y s 6 SE.d 1 5 1 8( .
o s q e ta nu y r a g o h litf. mlt Ha e , 41 . 2 1 , 1 Va
'
2007)
.
Upon r viw oft c
e e
he ompli , hec t sc ta ne t c udet tt pl i if ha
ant t our i onsr i d o oncl ha he antfs ve
s fcinty saed acai f br ac o co r c .Assl rz d abo ,t pl i if aleget t
ufi e l t t
l m or e h f nta t
lmma ie
ve he antfs l ha
t y e e e i o as tl me a e men wih Sta i , s ntt whi h t pa tes
he ntr d nt e te nt gr e t t r wbrdge pur ua o c he ri
e e syag e d t r r n fom s yi a yt ngne tveordipa a nga utt ot r The
xpr s l r e o efai r a ng n hi
ga i
s r gi bo he he .
pli if a s a lget tt sae e t ma by Sta i e' a ntwe e i die tc lc wih
antfs lo le ha he t tm n s de
r wbrdg s ge
r n r c ontit t
t s t r oft s tl m e ag e e .l or a i t a l ga i c a ne i pa a a 1
hi e m
he e te nt r em nt nc por tng he le tons ont i d n r gr phs

t oug 1 oft c
hr h 2 he ompli , hepl ntfsf t rale t tt vi ai oft s tlm e
ant t ai if urhe lge ha he olton he e te nt
ag e me r s t d i dn a t t pli if 'busne sr put to Ba ed o t f e ng,t
r e nt e ule n m ge o he antfs
i s e ai n. s n he or goi he
c tc ude t tt pl ntfs a lgai a es fc e t sa eacli f b e c ofc r c
our oncl s ha he ai if ' le tons r ufii nt o tt
am or r a h onta t
a t , ha t moton mus alo bede e wih r s c t t scai .
nd, hus t t he i
t s
nid t e pe t o hi l m
Concl i
us on

Fort r as nssa e Sta i e' motont dimiswilbe d e TheClr i
he e o t t d, r wbrdg s i o s s l
enid.
ek s
diec e t s nd c riid c esoft sme o a lm o ni a t a c
r t d o e e tfe opi
hi m r nd l pi on nd he c ompanyi o d rt al
ng r e o l
c
ouns ofr c d.
el e or

c
sNTER: i G M day ofM ar h, 20 2.
Th s
1

t
Chi U nie St t D i ti J
ef t d a es s rct udge

6