Bates et al v. Strawbridge Studios, Inc. et al
Filing
26
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/5/2012. (lab)
DLERK: IFFI U, QI O LRT
R :, R
J
ArR- OK;,
VA
AL O
E
I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO U RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTEM D I
STRI O F V I GI A
CT
R NI
ROA N OKE DI SI
VI ON
Mà2 25 2 1
22
JULK C. LEY C E
D
B ; i' 'zt
1Z
l
CL RK
CHA RLES M . TES, Ig
BA
# .
L,
.
Ci lActon N o.7: CV 00 6
vi
i
11
21
Pl ntf s,
ai if
M EM O M ND UM O PINIO N
STRA W BRI G E STUD I S,I C . # g ,
D
O N , 1 1,
.
By:Hon. e E.Co ad
Gln
nr
Chi U nie St t D i ti tJ
ef t d a es s rc udge
Def nda s
e nt .
ChalsM . tsa dDo naL. ts(olcieyr fre t a çhepanif' fld
re Bae n n
Bae c le t l ee rd o s l li t s' ie
v
t
f )
t sdi r iyaci f rdef ma i a br a h ofc r ta i tSta i e St os l
hi ve st ton o
a ton nd e c
ontac gans r wbrdg udi , nc.
(ûta rd e'a J l Do , nu k o e o e a do a e t fSrwb ig .Th c s i
d rwb ig ' nd om e a n n wn mply e n /r g n o ta rd e e a e s
s
)
pr e l be or t c t Sta i sm o i n t dim is Fort r as t tf l t
es nty f e he our on r wbrdge' to o s s .
he e ons ha olow, he
m oton w ilbe de e
i
l
ni d.
Background
Thef l wi f t ,tke fom t pli tfs co pli t a eac e e a t ef
olo ng acs a n r he a n if ' m a n , r c pt d s nl or
p r o e o tep n igmoi n S eErc s nv Pad s 5 U. 8 , 4( 0 7 .
u p s s f h e dn to . e ik o . r u , 51 S. 9 9 2 0 )
I Aug tof2009,hepli tfs o r ofSi hta Sot St os l ,fl a a ton
n
us
t a n if , wne s
g nd md udi , nc. ied n c i
f rb e c o c nr c i saec u t g is Srwb ig S u is I c (sr wb i g '
o r a h f o ta t n tt o r a an t ta rd e t do ,n .t ta rd e).
t
Sta i e r move t a ton t t sco to di riy g ot ,a t pa tesuli aey
r wbrdg e
d he c i o hi ur n ve st r mds nd he ri tm t l
neg i t d a s tl e ag e m en t tr ol t i di put Se Si hta Sound Sm di . nc.
ota e
e tem nt r e t ha es ved he r s e. e g nd
os l
v. ta rdg Sudo .n .No 7:9 03 8( . Va 2 0 ) Th stlme ta re n ,
Srwb i e t is Ic, . 0 CV0 3 W D. . 0 9 . e ete n g e me t
w hi w asexecut on M ay 12,2010,i udes t f l ng pr son:t-'e pari agr t
ch
ed
ncl
he olowi
ovi i û h
f
tes ee hat
neiherw ilsay,wrt publs br
t
l
ie, i h, oadcas ,ori any ot w ay partci t i negatve or
t n
her
i pa e n
i
di par ng com m ent aboutt ot '
s agi
s
he her.'
-
OnN o mbe 1 201 Sta rdger c i aphonec l fom Trna La a ,who
ve r 0, 0, r wb i e eved
al r
i
pr de
r
eque t d t orgi ne tve f he da e ' s ho phot r ph f om t pr vi ye r
s e he i nal ga i or r ught r s c ol
og a r he e ous a .
La ades
pr
poke wih Sta i sc t m e s r c r pr e ai ,
t r wbrdge' uso r e vie e es nt tve who t d he t tSta i
ol r ha r wbrdge
di no ha t phot a butt tt pli if mi ha i,snc t ywe e wor ng wih
d t ve he
ogr ph, ha he antfs ght ve t i e he r
ki
t
Sta i e dli t r e nttm e Thec t rs r ier pr s t tveadde ho ver t t
r wbrdg trng he elva i .
usome e vc e e en a i
d, we , ha
t pl ntfsE r notr putbl a c dnotbetuse 'a t tEhi gots ba weha t
he ai if t e
we
e a e nd oul
r t d,' nd ha ç ngs
t
o d
d o
g tiv le i alws i. ( mp . t 7 .
e n ov d n a ut' Co la ! )
'
Afe t sc ve s ton, pr deviiedhe da e ' hi s hoola r pe t t
tr hi on r ai La a
st
r ughtr s gh c
nd e aed he
sae e smadeb Sta i e' c t rs r i r pr s n a i La a t n i r d a t
tt m nt
y r wbrdg s usome e vce e e e t tve. pr de he nquie s o
whyt s hoolwoul de wih pe e ofs h ne tvec r ce .
he c
d al t opl
uc ga i ha a tr
On M ay9, 1 t pli if fld t sd ve st a tonagans Sta i a is
201 , he antfs ie hi i riy ci
i t r wbrdge nd t
t
mknown c t
usomers r i er pr e ai as e tng cam sofde ama in a br a h ofc r c .
e v c e es nttve, s ri li
f to nd e c
onta t'
Sr wb i eha mo dt d s s tec mpan p ru n t Rul 1 ( )6 o teFe ea Rue
ta rdg s ve o imis h o lit u s a t o e 2 b ( ) f h d r l ls
ofCi lPr ed e. Them at rha bee f lybre e a i rpef r vi w.
vi oc ur
te s n u l if d nd s i or e e
St
anda ofR e e
rd
vi w
çf epupo eo aRue1 ( )6 moini t ts tes f in yo ac mp an .
d' r s f l 2 b ( ) t s o e th u fce c f o lit'
-h
o
'
Edwadsv. t ofGol boo,1 F. 231, ( hCi.1 .W he rviwi acam
r Ciy
ds r 78 3d
243 4t r 999)
n e e ng li
unde t sr e,hec tm us a c ptaloft al gai nsi t c
r hi ul t our
t c e 1 he le to n he ompl ntastuea dr w al
ai
r nd a l
#Prort flng t i t ntac i , t pl ntf sfied adef i acton agai tSt a i i
i o ii he ns a ton he ai if l
amaton i
ns r wbrdge n
sat cour,whi wasr oved t t sc ton di siy gr
te
t ch
em
o hi our
ver t ounds. On M a 1 2011 t courtp ant
y 7,
, he
ed
Sta i sm oton t dim isf f l et sa ea cl m . See Bat v.Sta i St os.l ,Cas
r wbrdge'
i o s s or aiur o tt
ai
es
r wbrdze udi nc. e
No. 11 00 ,2 1U. Dit LEXI 5 42( . Va M a 1 , 1.Du i tehe rngo t t
7: CV0 33 01 S. s. S 24 W D. . y 7 201 ) rng h ai n ha
moton,t cour advied t pari t tt pl ntf swoul be per ted t fl a a ended compl nt
i he
t s he tes ha he ai if
d
mit o ie n m
ai
ora ne acton. Thepl ntfsel ed t pur uet lte coure and Gl t i t acton on M ay 9,
w i
ai if ect o s he a tr
s
ed he nsant i
20l1. Fort r onsexpl ne bel t cour concl t t ne com pl ntcont nss fcint
he eas
ai d ow, he
t
udes hat he w
ai
ai uf i e
alegatonst s ve am oton t dim is.
l i o urvi
i o s s
r s bl i e e esi f vo oft pli if . l a 2 ûro s vveamoton t dim is a
ea ona e nf r nc n a r he antfs d. t 44. t ur i
'
i o s s,
c pl i tm us c a n s t i ntf ct lm a t r a c pt d a t u ,t ç t t a cl i t r i ft ti
om a n
t ont i ufk e a ua te , c e e s r e o sa e a m o ele ha s
p a sbeo i fc .'As co t I b l5 6U.. 6 ,1 9 S. . 9 7, 9 9( 0 9 ( u tn
lu il n t a e' h r f v.q a, 5 S 6 2 2 Ct 1 3 1 4 2 0 ) q oig
s
'
Bel l Co p. Two l 5 0U. 5 4 5 0( 0 7) 4noh rwods tefcua alg to s
lAt. r v. mby, 5 S. 4 , 7 2 0 ).; t e r ,h a t l le ain
1
(a na t e mus ç r tt co toi e mor t nt meeposi lt ofmico t''
tke s nz) t pe mi he ur t nfr e ha he r sbiiy
s nduc .'A
Soc' W ihou a N a e f rPe e wihou a H om e M il r il Fu ur - e q v. igi a 655
v t t
m . o opl t t
. le m lm t e pr s nt V r ni ,
F.d3 2 3 6(t Ci. 01 )( u tn lb l 1 9S. . t1 5 )
3 4 , 4 4 h r 2 1 q oig q a, 2 Cta 9 0 .
Di cuss on
s i
1.
De am aton
f
i
Thepa tesag eet tVigni l w a isi t sdi r iya i Toesa ih a
ri r ha r i a a pple n hi ve st cton.
t bls
de a ai n ca m unde Vigi alw,t pl ntfsmus fr ts
f m to li
r r ni a he ai if
t is how t tt de e ntpubls d a
ha he f nda
ihe
f lef t lsae e t tconc r a ha mst pli if ort pl ntfs r putto Hylnd
a s acua t tm nt ha
e ns nd r he antfs he ai if ' e ai n. a
v Ra te nTe l c lS r s Co, 7 S. 2 7 6 7 0( . 0 9 .Th p an if mu tas
. yh o cmia e v . .6 0 E.d 4 , 5 Va 2 0 ) e litfs s lo
s
how t ha t de e n kne t tt sae e wa f s or beivi t tt sa e e twas
d t he f nda t w ha he t tm nt s ale , le ng ha he tt m n
t
t u l c a r as bl ba i f r s h be i f ora t d neglge l i f lng t de er i t
r e, a ked e ona e s s o uc le , c e
i nty n aii o t m ne he
fcso whi t publc tonwasbasd. L. t fmaor sae nt ma i l sae nt
a t n ch he iai
e ' ds t a t y ttme s y ncude ttme s
' u De
m a by i e e e,i i a i ori i to ' I Deamaor wo dsa e a tona eperK i
de nf r nc mplc ton, nsnuai n. d. f t y r r c i bl
'
f
t e p eu ieap ro i hi o h rta eo p oe so F t v. vesd He lh aeAs'
h y rj d c e s n n s r e rd r r fsin. use Ri rie at c r sn.
l ,575S. 2d 858,861( 2003)
nc.
E.
Va.
.
I m o ngt dimist pl i if 'de n ai cli ,Sta i a g t tt
n vi o s s he antfs f m ton am r wbrdge r ues ha he
s a e e sa l ge y m a by is c t e s r i r pr s t tve a e nota tona e,be a e t y
t t m nt le dl de t us om r e v ce e e en a i r
c i bl c us he
a e e es i ofo ni r t rt n sa e e soff c . d us sofac i n f def m a i ha
r xpr s ons pi on a he ha t t m nt
at l
ca e
to or a ton ve
terb ssi saec mmo lw b t r s be tt p icplso fe d m o s e h aiigu d r
h i a i n tt o n a u ae u jc o rn i e f r e o f pe c rsn n e
t Fi s A m e
he r t
ndm e t t U nied St t Cons iuton a A ri l 1 Se ton 1 oft
nt o he t
a es
tt i nd tc e , c i 2 he
Co si to o Vign a' Ye gev. le it Ti s 4 7S. 2 1 6 1 7( . 9 )
n tt in f r ii. a l Co lgae me , 9 E.d 3 , 3 Va 1 98 .
u
'
Co s q nl t p t ee p e so so o iiny whc d n t o ti p o a yflefcua
n e ue t t ll x rs in f pn o ' ih o o c nan r v bl as a t l
y, l r
'
c mo a i ,û a tnor ly f r t ba i ofa aci f de a a in. W J TV v. vi
ol t tons ç nno
c
ma l o m he ss n ton or f m to ' LA'
Le n,
5 4 S. 2 3 3 3 2( . 0 2 .Ho v r teUntdS ae Su r meCo r S a s e i al
6 E.d 8 , 9 Va 2 0 ) we e,h ie tts p e
u tt s p cfc l
h
y
de lne t hol t tsae e sofo ni a e c t orcal e ude a t bassf acommon
c i d o d ha t tm nt
pi on r aeg i ly xcl d s he i or
lw dea to ca eofa ton.'l (ii M iko c v. r nJ na Co.497U. 1,1821
a fmain us ci ' d. ctng l vih Loai our l ,
S. -
( 9 ) Ast eS p e Co r o sr e i M ik vc
1 90 . h u rme u t b e v d n lo ih:
I a s a s ys û n my o ni J hn J si ala , hei i a
f pe ker a , t
l
pi on o one s ir' mples
'
knowl e off c swhih l dt t co uso t tJ st dan un nzh.
edg
at
c ea o he ncl i n ha one ol
t t
Eve i t s ake s a est f c su n w hi h he bas t o ni i
n f he pe r t t he a t po
c
es he pi on, f
t ef csa eeihe i ore tori mplt ,o i hi as esm e oft m
hos a t r t r nc r c nco e e r f s s s nt he
i er
s r oneo ,t s a e e m a sili pl a f s a s r i off c . Si pl
us he t t m nt y t l m y al e s e ton a t m y
c hi s h s a e e si t r sofopi on doesnotdi pe t e
ouc ng uc t t m nt n e m
ni
s l hes
i plc tons a t sa e e ,d n m y opi o J
m i a i ; nd he t t m nt t
l
ni n onesi a la ,' n c us
s i r' ca a e
asm uch da ag t r put ton a t s a e e , tonesi a l i .
m e o e a i s he t t m nt tl
s a r'
'
l a 1 1
d. t 8- 9.
Theque to ofwhehe ade a t ysa e nti o o f toropi o pr e t alga
si n
t r f ma or tt me s ne f ac
ni n es n s e l
quesi t be d i by t c t Hvlnd,67 S. 2d a 751.ç n dee mi ngwhe he a
ton o
ecded he our. a
0 E. t
t tr ni
l
t r
s a e e ti one off c oropi on, c r m a no i ol t one pori oft s a e e a i s
ttm n s
at
ni a ou t y t s a e
ton he t t m nt t s ue
fom a t rpori oft sae nt' Ja l ta t c tmus co i rt sae nta a
r nohe ton he ttme . .. nse d,he our t nsde he ttme s
'p
w hol I
e. d.
Appl ngt s prnci es t co ti u bl t c udet tt satm e sa i s a e
yi he e i pl , he ur s na e o oncl ha he t e nt t s ue r
pur e e sonsofopi o t tca
e xpr s i
ni n ha nnotf m t ba i ofa a tona e ca m f de a ai n.
or he ss n c i bl li or f m to
Ta n a one, he s a e e t tt pl ntf sç e e notr put bl a co d notbe t ts e '
ke l t t t m nt ha he ai if s r
w
e a e nd ul
rz t dp'
4
a gua y co d bec i r d a e e so o opi on.Howeve ,gi n t c t xti whih t
r bl ul
onsde e n xpr s i n f ni
r ve he on e n c he
saeme wasm a ,a t f c t tt c t rs r ier e en a i a edt t(hi go
t t nt
de nd he a t ha he usome e vc epr s t tve dd ha ç ngs t
t
s ba ( rwbrdge ha t ge i vedi alws t't c t ncl st tt
o d Sta i l d o tnvol n a ui 'he our co ude ha he
r pr e a i s s a e e s c d be r s bl t de s ood t i pl t e s e e ofdef m a or
e es nt tve' t t m nt oul
ea ona y m r t
o m y he xit nc
a t y
f c s SeeBa l v.Compr he i Pan M gmt Cts,Ca eNo.7:
a t.
y or
e nsve i
. r. s
09CV00472,2011U. Dit
S. s .
LEXI 3 6 9 a * 4- 5( . Va Ap . , 01 )(-h ts frd tr nn wh t e fcst a
S 7 9 , t 3 3 W D. . r 6 2 1 tl e e t o ee mi ig eh r a t h t
ima beaci bl de a ton ha be n i i d i t t a r s na e lse rwoul t ke
y
tona e f ma i
ve e mple s wheher ea o bl it ne
da
(hes kelt bebasnghi t ni onknowldgeoffcsoft s tha c nbee l tdi
t pea r o
i s opi on'
e
a t he or t n a
vauae n
ad fmai ns i.'( u tn Ro e t S c S c o Den to Li e, a de, n Reae
ea to u t') q oi g b r D. a k, a k n fmain: b lSln r a d ltd
'
Pr b e j43: ( t Ed 2 0 Be a s tsttme t ce ryi li t ee itn eo fcs
o lms : 2 4h . 01 :. c u e c lae n s lal mp yng h x se c f a t
l
a ea to a ea d fmain, S nge v.TT Co .9 3F.d 1 6 ,1 71(t Ci. 9 3 ,h
r cin bl s ea to ' we lr I
'
m , 9 2 0 3 0 4h r 1 9 ) te
cour co l st tSta rdge' frta g
t ncude ha r wb i s is r umen i wihoutmert
ts t
i.
To t extntSta i at r i y a g t tt def ma i c am c it ofba e
he e r wbrdge lenatvel r ues ha he a ton l i onsss
r
l ga c l i nsa a f m ul i r c t to oft ne e s r el m e s t c t sunabl t
e l onc us o nd or a c e ia i n he c s a y e nt , he our i
eo
ag e W hie s eoft pl i if 'al ga insa ea g bl co l or t c ti oft
r e.
l om
he antfs le to r r ua y ncus y, he our s he
opi on t tt c
ni ha he ompl nt i ise iey,c anss fce f cualc entt sa eacl m f
ai , n t ntrt onti ufi int a t ont o tt
ai or
def ma i t ti pl i eon isf e I ,1 S. . t1
a ton ha s ausbl
t ac . nbal 29 Ct a 949.
Fial,h c u t s as rj c t eapl n t a ted fmaincam i ba 'db t e
n l te o r mu t lo ee t h r me t h th ea to li s ne y h
y
s tl nta e m e tt tt pa tesr a he i t fr taci
e teme gr e n ha he ri e c d n he is ton.Ha ng r vi we t t r of
vi e e d he e ms
t a e m e ,hec ti una et c ude a ama troflw,t tt ag e me woul
he gr e nt t our s bl o oncl , s
te
a ha he r e nt
d
pr ude t partes f pur ui a cl m t ar e s alm ont aft t agr entwas
ecl he
i rom
s ng ai hat os ever
hs er he eem
execut Fort e r
ed.
hes easons,Staw brdge' m oton m us be deni w ih r pectt t pl ntff
r
i s i
t
ed t es
o he ai i s'
c a m f de a aton.
l i or f m i
I.
I
Br ach ofC ont t
e
rac
Sta i a s a g t tt co antf ist sa eac am f rbr c ofc r c .
r wbrdge lo r ues ha he mpli al o tt l i o ea h onta t
Und rVignalw,ith e sn il lme t o ac us o a to f rb e c o c nrc ae( )a
e r ii a ç l e se ta ee n s f a e f cin o ra h f o ta t r 1
l
lg l bi aino ad fn a t oapanif ( )avoaino b e c o ta o lg to a ()a
e a o lg to f ee d n t litf, 2 ilto r ra h f h t b iain, nd 3
c n e u n ilij r o d ma et t epanif' Ha e v. y s 6 SE.d 1 5 1 8( .
o s q e ta nu y r a g o h litf. mlt Ha e , 41 . 2 1 , 1 Va
'
2007)
.
Upon r viw oft c
e e
he ompli , hec t sc ta ne t c udet tt pl i if ha
ant t our i onsr i d o oncl ha he antfs ve
s fcinty saed acai f br ac o co r c .Assl rz d abo ,t pl i if aleget t
ufi e l t t
l m or e h f nta t
lmma ie
ve he antfs l ha
t y e e e i o as tl me a e men wih Sta i , s ntt whi h t pa tes
he ntr d nt e te nt gr e t t r wbrdge pur ua o c he ri
e e syag e d t r r n fom s yi a yt ngne tveordipa a nga utt ot r The
xpr s l r e o efai r a ng n hi
ga i
s r gi bo he he .
pli if a s a lget tt sae e t ma by Sta i e' a ntwe e i die tc lc wih
antfs lo le ha he t tm n s de
r wbrdg s ge
r n r c ontit t
t s t r oft s tl m e ag e e .l or a i t a l ga i c a ne i pa a a 1
hi e m
he e te nt r em nt nc por tng he le tons ont i d n r gr phs
t oug 1 oft c
hr h 2 he ompli , hepl ntfsf t rale t tt vi ai oft s tlm e
ant t ai if urhe lge ha he olton he e te nt
ag e me r s t d i dn a t t pli if 'busne sr put to Ba ed o t f e ng,t
r e nt e ule n m ge o he antfs
i s e ai n. s n he or goi he
c tc ude t tt pl ntfs a lgai a es fc e t sa eacli f b e c ofc r c
our oncl s ha he ai if ' le tons r ufii nt o tt
am or r a h onta t
a t , ha t moton mus alo bede e wih r s c t t scai .
nd, hus t t he i
t s
nid t e pe t o hi l m
Concl i
us on
Fort r as nssa e Sta i e' motont dimiswilbe d e TheClr i
he e o t t d, r wbrdg s i o s s l
enid.
ek s
diec e t s nd c riid c esoft sme o a lm o ni a t a c
r t d o e e tfe opi
hi m r nd l pi on nd he c ompanyi o d rt al
ng r e o l
c
ouns ofr c d.
el e or
c
sNTER: i G M day ofM ar h, 20 2.
Th s
1
t
Chi U nie St t D i ti J
ef t d a es s rct udge
6
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?